| Literature DB >> 36157302 |
Alexander J Adams1, Asif M Ilyas1,2.
Abstract
The United States' opioid epidemic has taken an immense toll over the past 2 decades when assessed by morbidities, mortalities, and economic costs. Prescription opioids are a substantial contribution to this public health emergency, and it is critical for health care providers to practice good analgesic stewardship. Interventions have effectively curtailed opioid overuse, including prescription drug monitoring programs, educational initiatives, and multimodal analgesia strategies. Surgeons, particularly hand surgeons or those who perform musculoskeletal procedures, have been implicated as high-volume opioid prescribers. Guidelines for appropriate opioid dosing and analgesic management strategies after common hand and upper-extremity surgeries are sparse and offer an area for meaningful improvement. We sought to generate comprehensive, evidence-based recommendations for postoperative analgesia regimens for common hand and upper-extremity procedures.Entities:
Keywords: Evidence-based; Opioids; Postoperative analgesia; Recommendations; Upper extremity
Year: 2022 PMID: 36157302 PMCID: PMC9492791 DOI: 10.1016/j.jhsg.2022.06.006
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Hand Surg Glob Online ISSN: 2589-5141
Hand/Wrist Soft Tissue Procedure Opioid Requirements
| Author | Journal | Level of Evidence | Y | Procedure (N Patients) | Opioid Requirement | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rodgers et al | J Hand Surg Am | I | 2012 | CTR, ganglion & mass excision, TFR, tendon/nerve repair (156) | 9 | — |
| Stepan et al | J Hand Surg Am | II | 2018 | CTR, TFR, DQR (123) | 4–10 pills/25 MME (range 0–330) | — |
| Adalbert and Ilyas | Hand (N Y) | II | 2021 | 1. Soft tissue | 1. 4.2 pills | Soft tissue procedures used no opioids in 44% of cases. |
| Chapman et al | Hand (N Y) | II | 2017 | CTR (277) | 4.3 pills (median 3.2) | Fewer pills required with age and male sex |
| Peters et al | J Hand Surg Am | IV | 2018 | CTR (56) | >50% used <2 tablets over 2 d (range 0–7 d) | — |
| Miller et al | Hand | II | 2017 | 1. TFR (78) or CTR (103) with WALANT 2. TFR (50) or CTR (185) with MAC | 1. WALANT: 3.85 pills (range 0–32, SD 6.7) | No difference in opioid use by procedure or anesthesia type. |
| Miller et al | Hand | II | 2017 | CTR with postoperative | 1. Tramadol: 3.3 pills for 1.8 d | Reduced overall opioid use with tramadol. |
| Kim et al | J Bone Joint Surg Am | II | 2016 | 1. Soft tissue (904) | 1. 7.4 pills in 2.9 d | Authors recommended |
| Dwyer et al | J Hand Surg Am | II | 2018 | CTR (121) | 3 pills (range 0–20) + 11 OTC pills (range 0–20) | Authors recommended 5–10 opioid pills after CTR. |
| Gaspar et al | J Bone Joint Surg Am | II | 2018 | 1. CTR | 1. 112.7 MME (95% CI 101.3–124.1) | Results based on survey of surgeons not actual patient use. |
| Ilyas et al | Orthopedics | II | 2019 | CTR (112)/TFR (76) | <5–10 pills | Pain scores equivalent for oxycodone, ibuprofen, Tylenol |
CTR, carpal tunnel release; DQR, de Quervain release; MAC, monitored anesthesia care; OTC, over-the-counter; TFR, trigger finger release; WALANT, Wide awake, local anesthesia, no tourniquet.
Elbow/Forearm Soft Tissue Procedure Opioid Requirements
| Author | Journal | Level of Evidence | Y | Procedure (N Patients) | Opioid Requirement | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kim et al | J Bone Joint Surg Am | II | 2016 | 1. Soft tissue (904) | 1. 7.4 pills in 2.9 d | Recommend |
| Hozack et al | Hand (N y) | II | 2019 | 1. Cubital tunnel procedures (100) | 1. 50 MME (range 0–300) | Medicare < private insured & worker’s compensation. Older patients consumed less. |
CuTR, cubital tunnel release; MME, morphine milligram equivalents; UNT, ulnar nerve transposition.
Hand/Wrist Bony Procedure Opioid Requirements
| Author | Journal | Level of Evidence | Y | Procedure (N Patients) | Opioid Requirement | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rodgers et al | J Hand Surg Am | I | 2012 | Hand/wrist ORIF or arthroplasty (46) | 14 | — |
| Kim et al | J Bone Joint Surg Am | II | 2016 | 1. Unspecified fracture (260) 2. Joint procedure (252) | 1. 13 pills in 4.5 d | Authors recommended |
| Dwyer et al | J Hand Surg Am | II | 2018 | DRF ORIF(24) | 16 pills (range 0–30) + 20 OTC pills (range 0–65) | Authors recommended 30–45 MME after DRF ORIF. |
| O’Neil et al | Am J Orthop | II | 2017 | DRF ORIF (98) | 58.6 MME (range 0–280) in 4.8 d (range 0–16 d), 14.6 pills | No difference by anesthesia/fracture type. Increased with younger patients, self-pay, Medicaid. |
| Adalbert and Ilyas | Hand (N Y) | II | 2021 | 1. Fracture ORIF (53) 2. Arthroplasty (26) | 1. 6.7 pills | Rx use differed by location for hand (63%), wrist (76%), and elbow (80%). |
| Cunningham et al | Injury | III | 2021 | DRF ORIF (174,091) | Mean 45 pills filled | Results based on prescriptions filled not actual use. |
| Gaspar et al | J Bone Joint Surg Am | II | 2018 | 1. Thumb BJA | 1. 254.9 MME (95% CI 242.0–267.8) | Results based on survey of surgeons not actual patient use. |
| Bhashyam et al | J Orthop Trauma | III | 2019 | DRF ORIF (1,445) | 204 MME | Results are author recommendations, not actual patient use. |
BJA, basal joint arthroplasty; CRPP, closed reduction percutaneous pinning; DRF, distal radius fracture; ORIF, open reduction internal fixation.
Elbow/Forearm Bony Procedure Opioid Requirements
| Author | Journal | Level of Evidence | Y | Procedure (N Patients) | Opioid Requirement | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cunningham et al | Injury | III | 2021 | 1. Forearm ORIF (18,276) 2. Olecranon ORIF (24,415) 3. Radial head ORIF (9663) | 1. 54.8 pills 2. 43 pills | Results based on large database study on prescription filling patterns, not patient-reported use. |
| Bhashyam et al | J Orthop Trauma | III | 2019 | 1. Proximal radius & ulna ORIF (619) | 1. 218 MME 2. 254 MME | Results are author recommendations, not actual patient use. |
ORIF, open reduction internal fixation.
Summary Of Multimodal Analgesia Types
| Medication | Recommended Dosage | Maximum Daily Dosage | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Acetaminophen | 3,000 mg daily (500 mg every 4 h standing) for up to 10 d after surgery | 4,000 mg (2,000 mg if history of liver disease) | Consider medical consultation if existing liver disease history. |
| Naproxen | 440–500 mg twice a d standing for up to 10 d after surgery | 1,100 mg | -Only 1 NSAID should be used. |
| Ibuprofen | 800 mg every 8 h for up to 10 d after surgery | 2,400 mg | -Only 1 NSAID should be used. |
| Anticonvulsant class ie, gabapentin and pregabalin | N/A | Gabapentin: 3,600 mg (after up-titration) | Evidence is inconclusive for the effective and safe use of these medications for postoperative analgesia in hand and upper-extremity surgery, thus it is not recommended here. |
| Peripheral nerve block/catheter | Case-by-case basis | N/A | Dependent on patient, surgeon, and anesthesiologist preference. |
N/A, not available; PPI, proton-pump inhibitor.
Summary Of Oral Analgesia Recommendations
| Surgery Type | Representative Procedures | Recommended Postoperative Prescription |
|---|---|---|
| Soft tissue surgeries of the hand and wrist | CTR | Naproxen 500 mg twice a d, dispense #20 |
| Soft tissue surgeries of the forearm and elbow | CuTR | Naproxen 500 mg twice a d, dispense #20 |
| Bony surgeries of the hand, wrist, and elbow | Thumb basal arthroplasty | Naproxen 500 mg twice a d, dispense #20 |
CTR, carpal tunnel release; CuTR, cubital tunnel release; DQR, de Quervain release; TFR, trigger finger release.