Muhammad Usman Akbar1,2, Muhammad Badar1, Muhammad Zaheer2. 1. Gomal Center of Biochemistry and Biotechnology, Gomal University, Dera Ismail Khan, KPK 29050, Pakistan. 2. Department of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Syed Babar Ali School of Science and Engineering, Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), Lahore 54792, Pakistan.
Abstract
Along with the increasing incidence of cancer and drawbacks of traditional drug delivery systems (DDSs), developing novel nanocarriers for sustained targeted-drug release has become urgent. In this regard, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have emerged as potential candidates due to their structural flexibility, defined porosity, lower toxicity, and biodegradability. Herein, a FeMn-based ferromagnetic MOF was synthesized from a preassembled Fe2Mn(μ3-O) cluster. The introduction of the Mn provided the ferromagnetic character to FeMn-MIL-88B. 5-Fluoruracil (5-FU) was encapsulated as a model drug in the MOFs, and its pH and H2S dual-stimuli responsive controlled release was realized. FeMn-MIL-88B presented a higher 5-FU loading capacity of 43.8 wt % and rapid drug release behavior in a tumor microenvironment (TME) simulated medium. The carriers can rapidly release loaded drug of 70% and 26% in PBS solution (pH = 5.4) and NaHS solution (500 μM) within 24 h. The application of mathematical release models indicated 5-FU release from carriers can be precisely fitted to the first-order, second-order, and Higuchi models of release. Moreover, the cytotoxicity profile of the carrier against human embryonic kidney cells (HEK293T) suggests no adverse effects up to 100 μg/mL. The lesser toxic effect on cell viability can be attributed to the low toxicity values [LD50 (Fe) = 30 g·kg-1, (Mn) = 1.5 g·kg-1, and (terephthalic acid) = 5 g·kg-1] of the MOFs structural components. Together with dual-stimuli responsiveness, ferromagnetic nature, and low toxicity, FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs can emerge as promising carriers for drug delivery applications.
Along with the increasing incidence of cancer and drawbacks of traditional drug delivery systems (DDSs), developing novel nanocarriers for sustained targeted-drug release has become urgent. In this regard, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have emerged as potential candidates due to their structural flexibility, defined porosity, lower toxicity, and biodegradability. Herein, a FeMn-based ferromagnetic MOF was synthesized from a preassembled Fe2Mn(μ3-O) cluster. The introduction of the Mn provided the ferromagnetic character to FeMn-MIL-88B. 5-Fluoruracil (5-FU) was encapsulated as a model drug in the MOFs, and its pH and H2S dual-stimuli responsive controlled release was realized. FeMn-MIL-88B presented a higher 5-FU loading capacity of 43.8 wt % and rapid drug release behavior in a tumor microenvironment (TME) simulated medium. The carriers can rapidly release loaded drug of 70% and 26% in PBS solution (pH = 5.4) and NaHS solution (500 μM) within 24 h. The application of mathematical release models indicated 5-FU release from carriers can be precisely fitted to the first-order, second-order, and Higuchi models of release. Moreover, the cytotoxicity profile of the carrier against human embryonic kidney cells (HEK293T) suggests no adverse effects up to 100 μg/mL. The lesser toxic effect on cell viability can be attributed to the low toxicity values [LD50 (Fe) = 30 g·kg-1, (Mn) = 1.5 g·kg-1, and (terephthalic acid) = 5 g·kg-1] of the MOFs structural components. Together with dual-stimuli responsiveness, ferromagnetic nature, and low toxicity, FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs can emerge as promising carriers for drug delivery applications.
Cancer has remained one
of the major human diseases with an ever-increasing
mortality rate every year.[1] Although the
quality of knowledge about cancer has improved, its management and
eradication still require novel therapeutic approaches.[2] Among different influences on therapeutic efficacy,
the tumor microenvironment (TME) is considered a crucial aspect. The
TME is the location where, apart from tumor cells, blood vessels,
extracellular matrix (ECM), and signaling molecules exist.[3,4] As compared to normal tissues, the TME consists of a hypoxic environment,[5] lower pH[6] due to metabolic
alterations, and excessive reactive oxygen species.[7,8] The
major chunk of cancer treatments are still comprised of traditional
chemotherapy, surgical resection, and radiotherapy,[9] the efficacy of which is hampered due to the nonspecific
toxicity, emergence of drug resistance, and cancer metastasis.[10]To overcome these challenges, drug delivery
systems (DDS), such
as quantum dots,[11] mesoporous silica,[12] nanoparticles,[13] dendrimers,[14] and liposomes,[15] have
extensively been studied. Still, their applications are hindered by
the limitations of premature degradability, undue toxicity, and lower
drug loading capacities.[1,16] Among all the available
DDS, metal–organic frameworks (MOFs), endowed with excellent
porosity, tunable character, higher surface areas, and better biocompatibility,
exhibit encouraging potential as nanocarriers for anti-cancer drug
delivery.[17] Since their first use in the
sustained release of ibuprofen in 2006,[18] MOFs have been extensively modified to be used in advanced drug
delivery applications.[19]Recently,
stimuli-responsive MOFs have gained much attention that
in response to internal (e.g., ATP, redox reaction, pH, and H2S) or external stimuli (temperature, pressure, irradiation,
and magnetic field) triggered drug delivery.[20−24] Among others, magnetically active MOFs can be effectively
deployed for target-specific drug delivery, as they can be dragged
to a specific location through an external magnetic field.[16,25,26] However, magnetically responsive
MOF-based nanocarriers usually achieve their magnetic properties through
the encapsulation of magnetically active nanostructures (Fe3O4) at the expense of reduced porosity and lowered drug
encapsulation efficiency,[27,28] whereas introduction
of the second metals into the structural nodes of the MOFs is another
way to induce magnetic properties without losing porosity.[29−32] Among various methods, the secondary building unit (SBU) approach
is the most favored one. In this method, presynthesized mixed metal
clusters are used to fabricate bimetallic MOFs with a precise ratio
of both metals inside the structure.[33,34] Keeping in
view the lower pH of the TME (pH 5.2–6)[35] and higher (H2S) concentration in some cancer
types (colon and ovarian),[36−39] the pH/H2S-responsive magnetic MOFs could
serve as potential DDS for improved therapeutic effects, but they
have rarely been studied.5-Fluorouracil (5-FU) is an anti-cancer
drug (pyrimidine analog)
that has been clinically approved to treat various tumors. It is incorporated
into the DNA or RNA and alters their structure, causing cytotoxicity
and, ultimately, the death of cancerous cells.[40,41] However, because of the rapid degradation rate of 5–10 min,[42] its clinical efficacy is still hampered due
to the lack of suitable carriers in chemotherapeutics.[43,44]In this study, a magnetic bimetallic iron–manganese
MOF
(FeMn-MIL88B) was synthesized for encapsulation and stimuli-responsive
delivery of 5-FU. Through the characterization of powder X-ray diffraction
(PXRD), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), UV–vis,
and mathematical release models, the drug release behavior of FeMn-MIL-88B
was discussed. Moreover, the cytotoxicity profile of the carriers
was evaluated in human embryonic kidney 293T (HEK293T) cells.
Results and Discussion
Synthetic Scheme
The synthesis of
bimetallic (FeMn) MIL-88B MOFs followed a two-step approach (Scheme ). At first, a bimetallic
cluster compound was synthesized following a previously published
procedure.[45] During synthesis, mixed-metal
ions were bridged to a central oxygen (μ3-O) triangularly.
In their terminal positions, these metal ions were bonded to solvent
molecules (H2O) and also coordinated with acetate ligands
and gave a cluster compound with a trinuclear geometry
[Fe2Mn(μ3-O)(CH3COO)6(H2O)3].[46]
Scheme 1
Illustration of the Synthetic Route for the Synthesis of FeMn-MIL-88B
In the second step, the bimetallic cluster was
reacted with the
organic linker (terephthalic acid), which displaced the acetate ligands
attached to the metal center. This substitution reaction followed
a dissociative pathway, resulting in the formation of bimetallic MOFs
with MIL-88B type topology.[34]
Characterization of Materials
The
morphology, crystal size, and elemental composition of the cluster
compound and corresponding MOF were investigated by scanning electron
microscopy (SEM) and energy dispersive X-ray analysis (EDX). SEM analysis
of the clusters shows a polycrystalline sample with no defined morphology
(Figure A), whereas
the corresponding FeMn-MIL-88B nanocrystals exhibited a hexagonal
rod-shaped morphology (Figure B) with an average aspect ratio of 500 ± 116 nm and 140
± 30 nm diameter (Figure D). The size distribution was also analyzed through the dynamic
light scattering (DLS) method, and the average size of the particles
was found to be 504 nm (Figure S2).
Figure 1
SEM images
(A, B) and EDX spectra (C, D) of the FeMn cluster and
FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs.
Figure 2
PXRD patterns of the FeMn cluster (A) and FeMn-MIL-88B
(B). FT-IR
spectra (C), aspect ratio (D), N2 adsorption–desorption
isotherm (E), and pore size distribution (F) of FeMn-MIL-88B.
SEM images
(A, B) and EDX spectra (C, D) of the FeMn cluster and
FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs.PXRD patterns of the FeMn cluster (A) and FeMn-MIL-88B
(B). FT-IR
spectra (C), aspect ratio (D), N2 adsorption–desorption
isotherm (E), and pore size distribution (F) of FeMn-MIL-88B.The EDX elemental maps confirmed the homogeneous
distribution of
Fe and Mn elements in a 2:1 ratio in both the cluster (Figure C) and FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs (Figure D). The elemental
composition was further confirmed through inductively coupled plasma-optical
emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES) analysis of the solubilized samples
(Figure S1C). The Fe to Mn ratio in the
cluster and FeMn-MIL-88B MOF was found to be 2:1, as also confirmed
by the EDX spectra. These results indicated that clusters retained
their structural features during the reaction and are present as the
metal nodes in the framework.The structural characteristics
in terms of the crystallinity and
phase purity of the FeMn cluster and FeMn-MIL-88B were analyzed through
PXRD measurements. The PXRD pattern of the FeMn cluster (Figure A) exhibited a polycrystalline
material with characteristic peaks matching well with the reported
Fe3O cluster.[47] The PXRD pattern
of the synthesized MOF crystals reveals a highly crystalline material
with prominent reflection peaks and matches well with the simulated
pattern of the pure phase MIL-88B MOFs.[48] As evident from Figure B, FeMn-MIL-88B exhibited three characteristic peaks at 9.1°,
10.5°, and 11.8° corresponding to the 002, 100, and 101
planes.[49] A shift from 10.9° for as-synthesized
MOFs to 11.8° in the thermally activated MOF was also observed.
A shift in the 2θ value to a higher angle represents the cage
shrinkage based on Bragg’s law.[50] The decrease in cage volume of FeMn-MIL-88B is due to the evacuation
of trapped solvent molecules.The formation of the mixed-metal
cluster and the corresponding
MOFs was further confirmed by FT-IR spectroscopy. The monometallic
Fe3O cluster shows a D3h symmetry which breaks
to C2v upon the incorporation of one Mn and the formation
of a bimetallic cluster (Fe2MnO). In the FT-IR spectra,
the characteristic peaks for the Fe3O cluster (at ∼600
cm–1) were absent, and two new metal–oxygen
stretchings appeared at 726 and 524 cm–1 corresponding
to the FeMn–O linkage in the cluster (Figure S3) and the MOFs (Figure C).[51] The absorption bands
around 1577 and 1409 cm–1 in the FeMn(μ3-O) cluster were attributed to the asymmetric and symmetric
stretching vibrations of the -COO bonds of the acetate ligand.[52−54] A similar trend was also observed in the IR spectra of the corresponding
MOF, and the strong absorption stretching vibrations found around
1373 and 1606 cm–1 were assigned to the asymmetric
and symmetric stretchings of the coordinated terephthalic acid.[53]Nitrogen physisorption studies at 77 K
were carried out to determine
the porosity and Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET)-specific
surface area of the bimetallic MOF. FeMn-MIL-88B represented a type-I
isotherm with a BET surface area of 46 m2·g–1 (Figure E). The
lower surface area is due to the reversible swelling behavior of the
MIL-88B structure, as it tends to shrink into a highly dense and closed
form upon thermal activation by subsequent removal of coordinated
solvent molecules.[55] The FeMn-MIL-88B samples
showed characteristics of a microporous structure with an average
pore diameter of 1.4 nm and a 0.155 cc·g–1 pore
volume (Figure F).The magnetic behavior of Fe-MIL-88B and FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs was characterized
through vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM) analysis. From the VSM
plots of the MOFs (Figure A), it can be observed that the saturation magnetization values
for Fe-MIL-88B MOFs and FeMn-MIL-88B are 1.6 emu·g–1 and 12.7 emu·g–1, respectively. From the
magnetic hysteresis loop, the coercivity and remanence values were
calculated to be zero. The results revealed that the FeMn-MIL-88B
MOF shows a superparamagnetic nature compared to Fe-MIL-88B, which
renders our bimetallic MOFs susceptible to the magnetic field and
easily separable from the reaction mixture by magnetic attraction
(Figure B).
Figure 3
Magnetic hysteresis
loop of the VSM studies (A) and magnetic properties
of the Fe-MIL-88B (B) checked physically with an external magnet.
Magnetic hysteresis
loop of the VSM studies (A) and magnetic properties
of the Fe-MIL-88B (B) checked physically with an external magnet.
Fabrication of FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU
SEM analysis was performed to assess the morphological changes in
the crystals after 5-FU impregnation. As seen in Figure A, the MOF crystals retain
their overall morphological features after encapsulating the drug
except for an expansion in the crystal structure leading to swollen
crystallites. The drug incorporation into FeMn-MIL-88B was further
confirmed by FT-IR, XRD, UV–vis spectroscopy, and TGA analysis.
The characteristic peaks in the IR spectra of 5-FU at 1731 and 1240
cm–1 were attributed to the C–O and C–N
stretching vibrations of the drug molecule, while the additional characteristic
peaks found around 800 cm–1 to 540 cm–1 were ascribed to the C–F deformations of 5-FU.[56] These vibrational stretchings were also evident
in the IR spectra of FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU samples (Figure B), confirming the loading of 5-FU into the
materials.
Figure 4
SEM image (A, inset: at 500 nm scale), FT-IR spectra (B), PXRD
patterns (C), and TGA curves (D) of MOF crystals after contact with
5-FU.
SEM image (A, inset: at 500 nm scale), FT-IR spectra (B), PXRD
patterns (C), and TGA curves (D) of MOF crystals after contact with
5-FU.PXRD patterns of the samples were collected to
check the effect
of drug encapsulation on the carriers. No significant change was observed
in the PXRD patterns of the 5-FU encapsulated carriers, and most of
the characteristic peaks were retained by the carriers. An extra peak
around 28.2 (2θ) found in the PXRD pattern of FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU
was attributed to 5-FU,[57−59] confirming its presence in the
structure (Figure C). Moreover, loading of 5-FU resulted in FeMn-MIL-88B’s pore
volume expansion, reflected by the decrease in the diffraction angle
of the 101 peak from 11.8 to 11.2 (2θ). These findings further
confirm the structural flexibility of FeMn-MIL-88B through the “breathing
effect” that enables the carriers to entrap drug molecules
with a shrinkable architecture (consistent with the previous literature).[46,60−62]Finally, thermogravimetric analysis was carried
out to rectify
the loading of 5-FU by calculating the decrease in mass of FeMn-MIL-88B
and FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU heated under nitrogen. The samples without 5-FU
molecules presented two major weight loss regions. The weight loss
below 275 °C corresponded to the removal of any coordinated water/solvent
molecules present in the structure, while the major weight loss that
occurred from ∼275 to 475 °C was attributed to the decomposition
of the terephthalic acid and structural collapse.[63] The TGA curve of FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU lacked most of the initial
weight loss pattern for solvent molecules found in FeMn-MIL-88B and
indicated the presence of 5-FU molecules inside the pores.[7,64−66] However, a 10% weight loss related to solvent molecules
can be seen from 150 to 240 °C. The initial weight loss up to
300 °C in FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU was attributed to the loss of incorporated
5-FU molecules. The second phase of weight loss from 310 to 520 °C
was due to the degradation of linker and collapse of the structure
(Figure D).By analyzing the IR, PXRD, and TGA results of FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU,
we concluded the successful incorporation of 5-FU into our carriers.
To further quantify the amount of drug loaded on the carriers, UV–vis
spectroscopy was utilized to determine the concentration of 5-FU at
265 nm (λmax). The loading capacity of the MOFs was
found to be ∼438 mg·g–1 correlated with
the calibration curve of different 5-FU concentrations in ethanol
(Figure S4).
Release Kinetics
The pH-triggered
release of 5-FU from the MOFs was first investigated in PBS solutions
(pH 5.4 and pH 7.4), mimicking the pH of the tumor microenvironment
and physiological fluid system. The drug release quantity was calculated
through the calibration curve drawn in PBS (Figure S6). The drug release can be distinguished into two stages:
the first stage involves the rapid release of 5-FU molecules, whereas,
in the second stage, drug release occurs in a sustained manner. The
initial rapid release of 5-FU from the carriers can be attributed
to the loosely bound drug molecules on the surface of the carriers.
Under the simulated physiological pH (7.4), a slow and controlled
release of 5-FU from the carriers amounted to a cumulative 38% even
after 24 h (Figure A). The slower drug release at physiological pH is due to the reasonable
stability of MIL-88B MOFs at physiological pH and aqueous solutions.[67] It is also beneficial to prevent unwanted and
untargeted drug releases that may cause toxicity to healthy cells.[25] However, a rapid release of 70% from the carriers
was observed at a slightly acidic pH (5.4).
Figure 5
5-FU release from FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU
(A), FT-IR spectra of terephthalic
acid and of FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs before and after being contacted with
PBS (pH 5.4) and NaHS (500 μM) (B), and PXRD patterns of samples
immersed in PBS (pH = 5.4 and 7.4), water, and NaHS solutions (C).
5-FU release from FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU
(A), FT-IR spectra of terephthalic
acid and of FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs before and after being contacted with
PBS (pH 5.4) and NaHS (500 μM) (B), and PXRD patterns of samples
immersed in PBS (pH = 5.4 and 7.4), water, and NaHS solutions (C).The rapid release under weakly acidic pH could
result from MOFs’
structural decomposition due to linker protonation.[68,69] To confirm this, the FT-IR spectra of FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs (before
and after) immersed in pH 5.4 solution for 24 h and free linker were
compared. As shown in Figure B, a shift in the antisymmetric and symmetric bands of the
coordinated linker from 1597 and 1365 cm–1 to 1627
and 1277 cm–1 in the acid-exposed MOFs hints at
the protonation of the linker.[51] Consequently,
the disintegration of the MOF releases the encapsulated drug molecules.
To gain further insights into the MOFs’ behavior under different
pH conditions, we performed PXRD analysis of MOFs immersed in PBS
(pH = 7.4 and 5.4) for 24 h. These MOFs were able to retain their
crystallinity under pH 7.4 (Figure C), which corroborates well with previous literature.[70,71] However, at pH 5.4, our carriers lost their crystallinity and disintegrated,
as shown by the PXRD pattern that appeared featureless.Furthermore,
considering the higher concentration of H2S found in breast
and colon cancers, 5-FU release from the nanocarriers
was also investigated under a H2S simulating environment.
Drug release contents were calculated through the calibration curve
of 5-FU drawn from the different concentrations of the drug dissolved
in water (Figure S5). Compared to the drug
release of 11% in deionized water, rapid release of 5-FU was observed
in NaHS solutions. The material showed NaHS concentration-dependent
release of the payload. By increasing the NaHS concentration from
200 to 500 μM, a release of 5-FU from 19% to 26% was observed.
Such behavior of MOFs upon contacting NaHS solution is due the strong
affinity of the S atom toward Fe ions in the nanocarriers and their
competitive binding against the linker.[72] According to the previously published reports, Fe3+ in
the MOFs is rapidly seized by H2S due to ultrahigh affinity
between S2– and Fe3+ resulting in the
formation of Fe2S3. The intermediate product
(Fe2S3) is unstable and rapidly converts into
FeS and S. The strong coordination between Fe and S results in the
breakage of other metal bonds (e.g., of metal–linker) and ultimately
results in the release of the linker and MOFs’ decomposition.
The emergence of extra peaks at 28°, 32°, and 45–47°
(2θ) in the PXRD pattern (Figure C) of the NaHS-immersed samples indicates the presence
of a metal–sulfide linkage[73−75] and correlates to the
decomposition phenomenon. We also compared the FT-IR analysis of the
NaHS immersed samples with non-NaHS-exposed samples and a free linker.
As shown in Figure B, the emergence of the antisymmetric and symmetric vibrational stretchings
of -COO at 1638 and 1271 cm–1 in the NaHS-exposed
samples indicates the presence of an uncoordinated linker.[51] Furthermore, by comparing the recently reported
MOFs for anti-cancer drug delivery (Table S1), FeMn-MIL-88B exhibits a higher loading capacity of 5-FU. Our MOFs
also bypass the laborious step of loading superparamagnetic oxides
or making MOF-based composites to achieve the magnetic character and
dual-stimuli responsiveness.We applied several mathematical
kinetic release models to better
understand the factors behind the drug release behavior of FeMn-MIL-88B
(Figure S7). The summary of the drug delivery
mechanisms by their correlating fitting models is presented in Scheme and Table . The drug release kinetics
from a carrier depends on different factors such as drug movement,
the carrier’s swelling nature, interaction with the guest molecules,
and degradation.[76,77] The zero-order release model
relies on Fick’s law of diffusion and evaluates the drug release
kinetics from diffusion-controlled carriers.[76] Similarly, the Higuchi model is based on the principle of drug release
from insoluble carriers.[78] The first-order
and Hixson–Crowell models describe the drug release by complete
decomposition or block erosion of the material.[79,77]
Scheme 2
Illustrative Scheme of 5-FU Release from FeMn-MIL-88B
Table 1
Drug Release Kinetic Parameters and
Mathematical Models
Drug
release medium
Parameters
Zero-order
model
First-order
model
Higuchi
model
Hixon-Crowell
model
PBS (7.4)
R2
0.984
0.9983
0.994
0.9356
PBS (5.4)
R2
0.9452
0.9673
0.9979
0.8801
NaHS (500 μM)
R2
0.9199
0.9875
0.9974
0.9014
The regression coefficient (R2) of each
model was evaluated
to fit the accuracy of the statistical models (Table ). In our case, the higher R2 (>0.96)
values of the zero-order, first-order, and Higuchi models for release
kinetics suggest the release of 5-FU from the carriers in a complex
manner. The drug release occurs through diffusion, dissolution, and
structural decomposition of the carriers.
Cytotoxicity Studies
The HEK293T
cells belong to a class of human embryonic kidney cell lines widely
utilized to assess the toxicity of materials.[80] The optical images of the HEK293T cells treated with FeMn-MIL-88B
nanocarriers exhibited dose-dependent cytotoxicity.The non-MOF-exposed
(control group) cells appear in a spindle-shaped morphology, which
is typical of the untreated version of HEK293T cells.[81,82] However, when these cells were treated with MOFs, a morphology and
cell density change was observed (Figure ). Upon a gradual increase in the MOFs’
concentration (50 μg·mL–1 to 1000 μg·mL–1), cells started to lose their defined morphological
characteristics and number. The chemical composition of FeMn-MIL-88B
might be the reason behind their improved biocompatibility as compared
to other nanomaterials (e.g., nanoparticles).[83] The lower LD50 values of Fe, Mn, and terephthalic acid
(BDC) (Fe = 30 g·kg–1, Mn = 1.5 g·kg–1, and BDC = 5 g·kg –1) constituting
FeMn-MIL-88B make it less toxic to HEK293T cells.[84] For further confirmation, an MTT assay was performed to
assess the cell viability (Figure ). Compared to the control group, HEK293T cells treated
with different concentrations of nanocarriers exhibited a reduction
in the cell viability by an increase in the concentration of the MOFs.
An obvious decrease in the cell viability (51.2%) was observed upon
reaching the nanocarrier concentration of 250 μg·mL–1 with an IC50 = 180 μg·mL–1.
Figure 6
Images of HEK293T cells after being exposed to varying
concentrations
of FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs for 72 h using an inverted microscope: 50 μg/mL
(A), 100 μg/mL (B), 250 μg/mL (C), 500 μg/mL (D),
1000 μg/mL (E), and control group (F).
Figure 7
Effect of FeMn-MIL-88B on HEK293T cells by the MTT assay.
Cell
viability was tested by measuring the OD570 of the HEK293T
cells treated with varying concentrations (1–1000 μg/mL
with ctrl = control) of FeMn-MIL-88B.
Images of HEK293T cells after being exposed to varying
concentrations
of FeMn-MIL-88B MOFs for 72 h using an inverted microscope: 50 μg/mL
(A), 100 μg/mL (B), 250 μg/mL (C), 500 μg/mL (D),
1000 μg/mL (E), and control group (F).Effect of FeMn-MIL-88B on HEK293T cells by the MTT assay.
Cell
viability was tested by measuring the OD570 of the HEK293T
cells treated with varying concentrations (1–1000 μg/mL
with ctrl = control) of FeMn-MIL-88B.
Conclusions
In this study, ferromagnetic
FeMn-MIL-88B nanocarriers were synthesized
by a two-step approach. They were utilized as pH/H2S sensitive
DDS for the encapsulation and delivery of an anti-cancer drug (5-FU).
The cumulative release of 5-FU from the vehicles arrived at ∼70%
and ∼38% in the PBS solutions (pH = 5.4 and 7.4) after 24 h.
The mechanism behind the rapid release of the drug molecules in a
simulated cancer environment (PBS, pH = 5.4) was analyzed through
PXRD, ICP-OES, FT-IR, and release kinetic models. The strong binding
affinity between the Fe ions in the carrier and the S atoms of the
NaHS in the H2S simulated microenvironment also influenced
the 5-FU release in the NaHS solutions as compared to water. The cumulative
release percent in NaHS solutions (200 μM and 500 μM)
arrived at ∼19% and 26%, while, for water, it only stood at
12% after 24 h. By studying the PXRD patterns, FT-IR spectra, and
release kinetic models, the 5-FU release can be attributed to the
disintegration and decomposition of FeMn-MIL-88B’s structure.
The release behavior in PBS and NaHS solutions can be fitted well
with the zero-order, first-order, and Higuchi models of drug release.
The low toxicity against HEK293T cells and its ferromagnetic and dual-stimulus
(pH and H2S) sensitive nature makes FeMn-MIL-88B an excellent
candidate for anti-cancer drug delivery.
Experimental Section
Materials
Iron(III) nitrate nonahydrate
(Fe(NO3)3·9H2O), manganese(II)
nitrate tetrahydrate (Mn(NO3)2·4H2O), 1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid (BDC/terephthalic acid), sodium
acetate trihydrate (CH3COONa·3H2O), 5-fluorouracil
(5-FU), and N,N-dimethylformamide
(DMF) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. Methanol (CH3OH)
and water (H2O) used were of HPLC grade. All of the chemicals
were used as received.
Synthesis of the Mixed-Metal Cluster
Mixed metal clusters (FeMn) were synthesized following a previous
method.[45] In a typical synthesis, CH3COONa·3H2O (12 g, 0.088 mol) was dissolved
in 20 mL deionized (D.I) water in a 50 mL beaker and called solution-1.
A mixed solution of Fe(NO3)3·9H2O (2.284 g, 0.0056 mol) and Mn(NO3)2·4H2O (8.308 g, 0.028 mol) in 20 mL D.I. water in another beaker
(solution-2) was prepared, filtered, and kept on stirring. After that,
solution-1 was added dropwise into a stirred solution-2. The reaction
mixture was kept on stirring for 24 h at room temperature. After 24
h, dark brown precipitates were filtered off and washed once with
a small amount of absolute ethanol. Finally, the product was left
to air-dry.
Synthesis of MOFs (FeMn-MIL-88B)
For the synthesis of FeMn-MIL-88B, equimasses of the corresponding
bimetallic cluster (100 mg) and BDC (100 mg) were dissolved in 7.5
mL of N,N-dimethylformamide. Sample
vials were sonicated until the clusters and linker were dissolved.
Later, the dissolved cluster was added dropwise to a stirred linker
solution along with 0.5 mL of glacial acetic acid. The mother solution
was kept on stirring for 1 h until a homogeneous solution was obtained.
Finally, all reactants were transferred to 25 mL Pyrex vials and incubated
at 120 °C for 24 h. After that, precipitates were obtained with
centrifugation and washed thrice with DMF and ethanol. Further, samples
were vacuum-dried for 24 h at 120 °C before characterization.
Characterization
The X-ray diffraction
(XRD) pattern of the samples was obtained on a BRUKUER (D2 Phaser)
diffractometer over a 2θ range from 5 to 80° using Ni-filtered
Cu Kα irradiation (λ = 1.5406 Å). The surface morphology
of the MOFs was characterized through an FEI NOVA Nano SEM 450 scanning
electron microscope (SEM) equipped with an energy dispersive X-ray
spectroscope (EDX). The nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherm
was calculated using Quantachrome Nova 2200e. The FT-IR spectra of
the samples were assessed in the range of 400–4000 cm–1 using a Bruker Alpha Platinum ATR instrument. Thermogravimetric
analysis (TGA) was performed under an N2 atmosphere in
the temperature range of 10 to 600 °C (10°/min ramp) using
the TA Instruments (SDT Q600). The particle size of the MOFs was determined
on a Malvern Zetasizer (Nano ZS, Malvern) using dynamic light scattering
(DLS) at room temperature. The magnetic properties of MIL-88B (Fe)
and FeMn-MIL-88B were analyzed by a physical magnetic system and vibrating-sample
magnetometer (Cryogenic Ltd.). The high-performance liquid chromatography
(HPLC) system used was manufactured by The Waters Alliance (Model
e2695) and equipped with a (Waters 2998) photodiode array detector
and fitted with a C18 column. UV–vis spectroscopy was performed
to determine the drug content in the liquid samples using a spectrophotometer
(Shimadzu UV-1800).
Preparation of FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU
60 mg of MOF samples was immersed in 30 mL of ethanolic solution
with a 6000 ppm concentration of 5-FU. The immersed samples were put
on an orbital shaker for 48 h. After the adsorption process, the filtrate
was obtained through centrifugation and further used to calculate
the adsorbed 5-FU in the samples through the UV–vis spectrophotometer.
The drug loading capacity of the MOFs was measured by the following
equation:[85]In this equation, C0 and C correspond to
the initial and final concentrations of 5-FU in the ethanolic solution,
whereas V is the solution’s volume and m indicates the mass of the final MOFs (dried at 50 °C
for 24 h).
In Vitro Drug Release
The detailed
5-FU release from the samples was carried out by exposing the 5-FU-loaded
MOFs to 80 mL of PBS (pH 5.4 and 7.4), NaHS (220 and 500 μM)
solutions, and D.I. water. Briefly, a dialysis bag (3500 MWCO) containing
a concentrated solution of FeMn-MIL-88B/5-FU was put into 80 mL of
PBS, NaHS, or water-containing beaker, and dialysis was carried out
under magnetic stirring at 37 °C constant temperature. After
predetermined intervals, 2 mL of the solution was withdrawn and the
same amount of the fresh solution was added to maintain the total
volume at a constant concentration. The withdrawn mixture was used
to calculate the drug release using HPLC with mobile phase 5% methanol
and 95% water at a flow rate of 1.0 mL/min. The 5-FU content was detected
at 265 nm wavelength. The experiments were performed in triplicate,
and final results were realized through averaging. The equation used
to determine the cumulative release percentages of 5-FU is as follows:where R is the concentration of 5-FU released from the MOFs at time t and R is
the amount of total 5-FU concentration present in the carriers.
Cell Culture
Human embryonic kidney
293 cells (HEK293T cells) were obtained from the NIBGE Cell Culture
Collection (NCCC) and were cultured in DMEM (Dulbecco’s modified
Eagle’s medium) supplemented with 10% Hi-FBS, 1% Pen-strep
(100 IU/mL penicillin and 100 μg/mL streptomycin), 2 mM l-glutamine, and 1% nonessential amino acids (NEAAs). The cells
were grown in cell culture flasks (tissue culture treated) and incubated
at 37 °C in a humidified atmosphere with 5% CO2. Every
3–5 days, the cells were treated with 1–2 mL of 0.25%
trypsin–EDTA solution and were subcultured at a 1:3 split ratio.
Cell Viability Test
MTT (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium
bromide) assay was used for cytotoxicity studies and calculation of
cell viability. For this purpose, 100 μL of HEK293T cells with
a 0.1 × 106 cells/mL density was seeded in a 96 well
plate. The cell culture medium was removed after overnight incubation,
and FeMn-MIL-88B was dissolved appropriately in the cell culture medium
and was added immediately into the cells after sonication. The cells
were treated with FeMn-MIL-88B (1–1000 μg/mL). After
72 h of treatment, 10 μL of MTT (12 mM) reagent was added to
each well. Before the addition of the MTT reagent, the morphological
changes in cells were observed with an inverted phase-contrast microscope
(IMT-2; Olympus, Tokyo, Japan). The cells were incubated for 4 h;
after the removal of medium from the wells, 100 μL of DMSO was
added to dissolve formazan, i.e. the end product. A Synergy H1 hybrid
multimode microplate reader (BioTek Instruments Inc., Winooski, VT,
USA) was used to check the absorbance of samples at 570 nm. The percentage
of viable cells was calculated by the following formula: % = [100
× (sample abs/control abs)]. The IC50 of FeMn-MIL-88B
treated cells was calculated by Prism (GraphPad Software, Inc., San
Diego, CA).
Authors: Patricia Horcajada; Christian Serre; María Vallet-Regí; Muriel Sebban; Francis Taulelle; Gérard Férey Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2006-09-11 Impact factor: 15.336