Kamila Maciejewska1, Lukasz Marciniak1. 1. Institute of Low Temperature and Structure Research, Polish Academy of Sciences, Okólna 2, 50-422 Wroclaw, Poland.
Abstract
An increase in the accuracy of remote temperature readout using luminescent thermometry is determined, among other things, by the relative sensitivity of the thermometer. Therefore, to increase the sensitivity, intensive work is carried out to optimize the host material composition and select the luminescent ions accordingly. However, the role of nanocrystal morphology in thermometric performance is often neglected. This paper presents a systematic study determining the role of synthesis parameters of the solvothermal method on the morphology of YPO4:Yb3+,Nd3+ nanocrystals and their effect on the lifetime of Yb3+ ion-based luminescent thermometer performance. It was shown that by changing the RE3+:(PO4)3- ratio and the concentration of Nd3+ ions, the size, shape, and aggregation level of the nanocrystals can be modified changing the thermometric parameters of the luminescent thermometer. The highest relative sensitivity was obtained for the low RE3+:(PO4)3- ratio and 1% Nd3+ ion concentration.
An increase in the accuracy of remote temperature readout using luminescent thermometry is determined, among other things, by the relative sensitivity of the thermometer. Therefore, to increase the sensitivity, intensive work is carried out to optimize the host material composition and select the luminescent ions accordingly. However, the role of nanocrystal morphology in thermometric performance is often neglected. This paper presents a systematic study determining the role of synthesis parameters of the solvothermal method on the morphology of YPO4:Yb3+,Nd3+ nanocrystals and their effect on the lifetime of Yb3+ ion-based luminescent thermometer performance. It was shown that by changing the RE3+:(PO4)3- ratio and the concentration of Nd3+ ions, the size, shape, and aggregation level of the nanocrystals can be modified changing the thermometric parameters of the luminescent thermometer. The highest relative sensitivity was obtained for the low RE3+:(PO4)3- ratio and 1% Nd3+ ion concentration.
Materials that exhibit
emission of electromagnetic radiation under
nonthermal stimuli called phosphors are commonly used primarily in
the lighting industry.[1−4] However, in recent years, they have been increasingly used in many,
much more demanding applications. One of the most interesting is the
exploitation of luminescence for remote sensing of physical or chemical
quantities of the medium in which they are located, including luminescence
thermometers, manometers, pH meters, etc.[5−10] Among these techniques, luminescence thermometry is undoubtedly
the most strongly developed.[11−19] It enables remote readout of temperature by analyzing spectroscopic
properties of phosphor. Although the ratiometric approach is the most
popular noncontact temperature sensing technique described in the
literature, the reliability and accuracy of the temperature readout
are significantly limited by the fact that the ratio of the intensity
of the two bands can be modified by the medium in which the phosphor
is located.[17,20]Therefore, an important
alternative to the ratiometric technique
is the lifetime-based approach.[17,20−24] In the case of luminescence kinetics, the absorption of the emitted
radiation by the medium does not significantly affect the lifetimes
of excited states and thus does not modify the calibration curve of
the thermometer. To increase the sensitivity of a thermometer based
on luminescence kinetics, physical processes are sought that will
significantly affect the thermal dynamics of the emission level depopulation
in a predictable way. In the case of lanthanide ions, the main process
responsible for the thermal depopulation of the excited level is the
multiphonon depopulation process. However, the probability of this
process increases when the number of phonons required to energetically
bridge the emitting level with the next lower-lying level decreases.
Unfortunately, this leads to the reduction of the luminescence intensity.
Therefore, recently there has been increasing interest in the exploitation
of alternative processes, among which phonon-assisted energy transfer
provides very promising results.[25−27] In this case, a luminescent
ion characterized by high luminescence intensity provided by a high
energy separation between the excited and the ground levels and a
codoped ion with a configuration of energy levels that serve as an
energy acceptor are desirable.[28] An ideal
pair of ions fulfilling these requirements is Yb3+, Nd3+ ions, where the distance between the ground 2F7/2 and excited 2F5/2 levels of
about 10,000 cm–1 limits the probability of multiphonon
processes and the 4F3/2 level of Nd3+ ions located about 1500 cm–1 above 2F5/2 can be populated after the absorption of one to two
host phonons.[29,30] The probability of this process
strongly depends on the temperature. A luminescent thermometer could
be developed on the basis of this finding.[25−27] An additional
advantage of using this ion pair is the fact that they operate in
the near-infrared spectral range, which can be important for many
applications, e.g., biomedicine.[31−33] To develop thermometers
with the desired properties and thermometric parameters, it is important
to understand what material parameters and how they affect the thermometric
performance of the phosphor. As our previous studies have shown, the
chemical composition of the host material significantly affects the
thermometric parameters in APO4:Nd3+,Yb3+ (A = Y, Lu, La, Gd).[25]In this work, the effect of the synthesis parameters on the morphology
of YPO4:Nd3+,Yb3+ nanocrystals and
their consequences on the thermometric parameters of the phosphor
are analyzed. For this purpose, the solvothermal synthesis method
in a mixture of ethanol and oleic acid was used.[34,35] It was observed that with the increase in the molar concentration
of (PO4)3– ions relative to RE3+ cations, the cubic nanoparticles (for (PO4)3–:RE3+ = 0.5) change their shape to spherical ((PO4)3–:RE3+ = 1). Further decrease
in the (PO4)3– concentration causes the
lowering of the particle size and facilitates their aggregation. On
the other hand, with the increasing concentration of Nd3+ ions, the morphology of nanocrystals also undergoes a significant
modification from spherical nanoparticles, with the shape of nanoparticles
changing to cubic and then elongating along one axis to form elongated
cuboids (Figure ).
Figure 1
Schematic representation of the influence of
the synthesis condition
on the morphology of the YPO4:Nd3+,Yb3+ nanocrystals.
Schematic representation of the influence of
the synthesis condition
on the morphology of the YPO4:Nd3+,Yb3+ nanocrystals.
Experimental Section
Ytterbium(III)
oxide Yb2O3 (99.99%, Alfa
Aesar), europium(III) oxide Eu2O3 (99.99%, Alfa
Aesar), neodymium(III) oxide Nd2O3 (99.9%, Alfa
Aesar), yttrium(III) oxide Y2O3 (99.99%, Alfa
Aesar), sodium phosphate Na3PO4 (98.0%, Alfa
Aesar), oleic acid (90%, Sigma Aldrich), sodium hydroxide (99.8%,
POCH S.A., Poland), ethanol (96% pure p.a. POCH S.A. Poland), methanol
(POCH S.A., Poland), n-hexane (POCH S.A., Poland),
and chloroform (POCH, Poland) were used without further purification.In a typical synthesis in a 50 mL autoclave, 0.6 g of NaOH was
dissolved into 5 mL of deionized water under stirring. The rare-earth
(RE) oxides were dissolved in hydrochloric acid to obtain chloride
salts. The resulting rare-earth salts were adjusted to neutral pH
by recrystallizing three times with distilled water. Then, the rare-earth
chlorides (0.2 M) were added. Thereafter, 10 mL of ethanol and 10
mL of oleic acid were added under vigorous stirring. After 1 h, 5
mL of NaH2PO4 aqueous solution (x = 0.1, 0.2, 0.5, and 1 M) and 10 mL of ethanol were added to the
autoclave after stirring for another 30 min. Then, the autoclave was
sealed and heated at 180 °C for 8 h. The solution was cooled
to room temperature and the nanoparticles were washed with hexane/ethanol
by centrifugation. The final product was redispersed in 5 mL of chloroform.
Methods
Powder diffraction data were
obtained using a PANalytical X’Pert Pro diffractometer equipped
with an Anton Paar TCU 1000 N temperature control unit using Ni-filtered
Cu Kα radiation (V = 40 kV, I = 30 mA). Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images were performed
with a Philips CM-20 SuperTwin transmission electron microscope operating
at 160 kV. A drop of the suspension was put on a copper microscope
grid covered with carbon. Before the measurement, the sample was dried
and purified in an H2/O2 plasma cleaner for
1 min. The hydrodynamic size of nanoparticles was determined by dynamic
light scattering (DLS) using Malvern ZetaSizer at room temperature
in a quartz cuvette using hexane as a dispersant. Measurements were
made using histograms representing the number of particles per their
average size. The emission spectra and luminescence decay profiles
were measured using an FLS1000 fluorescence spectrometer from Edinburgh
Instruments equipped with a 450 W Xenon lamp and 808 nm line laser
as excitation sources and an R928P side window photomultiplier tube
from Hamamatsu as a detector. The temperature of the sample was controlled
using a THMS 600 heating–cooling stage from Linkam.
Results and Discussion
Structural and Morphological Characterization
Depending on the synthesis condition, the YPO4 crystallizes
in the tetragonal or hexagonal structures.[36−38] However, a
tetragonal structure is usually observed when higher annealing temperatures
are applied, whereas in the case of the as-prepared nanocrystals,
a typical hexagonal structure of the P6222 space group can be found (Figure a). In this host
material, the Y3+ ions are coordinated by eight O2– ions, and this dodecahedral site can be successfully substituted
by lanthanide dopant ions (Figure b).[36−38] Despite many factors such as pH, reaction time, and
solvent volume ratio, the (PO4)3–:RE3+ ratio can most significantly influence the nanocrystal growth
process. Therefore, the first aspect in the optimization of the synthesis
conditions of YPO4:Nd3+,Yb3+ nanocrystals
is to find a proper ratio between phosphate ions (PO4)3– and rare-earth ions (RE). It is found that even for
the nonstoichiometric ratio between ions, pure phased nanocrystals
can be obtained (Figure c). However, the comparison of the X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns
of the nanocrystals synthesized using different ionic ratios does
not reveal any phase impurities. One can observe that for samples
with different Nd3+ concentrations exhibit a slight shift
in the reflections toward lower 2θ angles (e.g., from 20.48
to 20.17° for the most intense reflection). This is due to the
expansion of the crystallographic cell unit associated with the ionic
difference between Nd3+ and Y3+ ions, which
may also be associated with the preferred orientation of the particles
or the preferred growth direction of the nanoparticles. The average
particle size determined using the DLS technique indicates that when
the (PO4)3–:RE3+ ratio is
below 1, the nanoparticles of average size around 26 nm are obtained
(Figure d). When the
stoichiometric amount of (PO4)3– ions
is applied, an increase in the particle size to 107 nm is found. A
further decrease in the molar amount of the phosphate ions results
in an increase in size to 250 nm and 270 nm for the ratios 2 and 5,
respectively. However, as is well known, the results obtained from
the DLS technique for nonspherical and highly aggregated particles
can be misleading. This is particularly important when a PDI close
to 1 is obtained. However, in the case of the examined materials with
nonaggregated particle form, the PDI values range from 0.002 to 0.310;
therefore, the quality of the measurements is satisfactory. The analysis
of the TEM images (Figure S1) reveals that
for a low (PO4)3–:RE3+ ratio
of 0.5, the cubic nanoparticles can be obtained. An increase in the
stoichiometric ratio causes the crystallization of relatively large
spherical particles. Further increase in the (PO4)3–:RE3+ ratio reduces the size of the particles
and facilitates their aggregation. Since the small particle size and
nonaggregation are optimized for (PO4)3–:RE3+ = 0.5, this molar ratio is applied in further syntheses.
In the second step of the analysis, the influence of the Nd3+ concentration on the structural and morphological properties of
the YPO4:Nd3+,Yb3+ nanocrystals is
investigated. It is found that even for 75% Nd3+, the hexagonal
structure remains (Figure e). However, the morphology differs significantly when the
Nd3+ concentration is increased. In the case of as low
as 1% Nd3+, the spherical particles are achieved with a
diameter of around 14 nm, and an increase in Nd3+ to 25%
results in the enlargement of their size to around 60 nm. Surprisingly,
a further increase in the Nd3+ concentration enables us
to achieve a cube with a size of 40 nm (50% Nd3+) and even
rodlike particles with a length of 120 nm and a width of 15 nm (75%
Nd3+). As can be clearly seen, the results obtained using
the DLS technique are not reliable in this case (Figure f).
Figure 2
Visualization of the
hexagonal structure of YPO4 (a)
and the polyhedra of Y3+ ions (b). (c) XRD patterns of
YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ synthesized
with different RE3+:(PO4)3– ratios and (d) the corresponding particle size distribution obtained
from DLS measurements. (e) XRD patterns for YPO4:10% Yb3+ and different concentrations of Nd3+ ions and
(f) the corresponding particle size distribution obtained from DLS
measurements.
Visualization of the
hexagonal structure of YPO4 (a)
and the polyhedra of Y3+ ions (b). (c) XRD patterns of
YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ synthesized
with different RE3+:(PO4)3– ratios and (d) the corresponding particle size distribution obtained
from DLS measurements. (e) XRD patterns for YPO4:10% Yb3+ and different concentrations of Nd3+ ions and
(f) the corresponding particle size distribution obtained from DLS
measurements.The luminescent properties of the Nd3+ and Yb3+ ions are very well known.[39−41] Therefore,
only a brief description
is given here. Upon 808 nm excitation, the excited state 4F5/2 of the Nd3+ ions can be populated, followed
by the fast nonradiative processes causing the population of the emitting 4F3/2 state of the Nd3+. Radiative depopulation
of the 4F3/2 state leads to the occurrence of
the three emission bands at around 880, 1060, and 1350 nm that can
be assigned to the 4F3/2 → 4I9/2, 4F3/2 → 4I11/2, and 4F3/2 → 4I13/2 transitions, respectively. In the presence of the
Yb3+ codopant, the 4F3/2 state of
the Nd3+ ions can be also depopulated by the energy transfer
with the emission of the phonon to the 2F5/2 state of the Yb3+ ions. The high energy separation between
the 2F5/2 state and the 2F7/2 ground state (around 10,000 cm–1) prevents efficient
depopulation of the excited state of Yb3+ by multiphonon
relaxation. However, an increase in temperature results in the growing
probability of the back energy transfer to the Nd3+ with
the absorption of phonons, thus shortening its lifetime. This preserves
high thermal variability of the lifetime of the Yb3+ ions
and thus is beneficial from the thermometric perspective. However,
in the case of the nanocrystals also, the surface effect significantly
affects the luminescent properties of the dopant ions.[42−45] In the case of the small particles, the energy diffusion among excited
states of Yb3+ ions to the surface defects becomes a very
efficient channel for the quenching of the luminescence. Thus, the
smaller the particle, the shorter the lifetime that is expected in
this case. As can be seen, the applied different RE3+:(PO4)3– ratios affect the morphology of the
YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ significantly
(Figure a–d). Hence, changes in the spectroscopic properties
of these particles are expected. The comparison of the low-temperature
emission spectra of the YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ reveals that some changes can be found in the shape of the 4F3/2 → 4I9/2 emission
band when the RE3+:(PO4)3– is changed (Figure e). The smaller the particle size, the higher intensity of R1 → Z1 and R2 → Z1 electronic transitions between particular Stark components of excited
and ground states. This effect can be explained in terms of the energy
reabsorption between Nd3+ ions.[46] When the concentration of Nd3+ is high, the light emitted
by one of the ions can be absorbed by the other before being emitted
from the nanoparticle. The probability of energy reabsorption is the
highest for the resonant lines since the population of the Z1 Stark sublevel of the 4I9/2 state is the highest.
The larger the size of the particle, the higher the probability of
this process because the longer distance photon needs to travel before
it leaves the nanoparticle. Therefore, for smaller nanoparticles,
more intense R1 → Z1 and R2 → Z1 emission lines can be found by comparing
larger counterparts.
Figure 3
Representative TEM images of the YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ nanoparticles synthesized using different
(PO4)3–:RE3+ ratios of 0.5
(a), 1
(b), 2.5 (c), and 5 (d). (e) Comparison of the normalized emission
spectra of YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ nanoparticles measured at 77 K upon λexc = 808
nm, (f) emission intensity ratio of Nd3+ to Yb3+ ions, (g) luminescence decay profile of Yb3+ ions, and
(h) the corresponding τavr of the 2F5/2 state of Yb3+ ions as a function of (PO4)3–:RE3+ ratio.
Representative TEM images of the YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ nanoparticles synthesized using different
(PO4)3–:RE3+ ratios of 0.5
(a), 1
(b), 2.5 (c), and 5 (d). (e) Comparison of the normalized emission
spectra of YPO4:10% Yb3+, 50% Nd3+ nanoparticles measured at 77 K upon λexc = 808
nm, (f) emission intensity ratio of Nd3+ to Yb3+ ions, (g) luminescence decay profile of Yb3+ ions, and
(h) the corresponding τavr of the 2F5/2 state of Yb3+ ions as a function of (PO4)3–:RE3+ ratio.Also, the emission intensity ratio of Nd3+ to Yb3+ ions is modified by the size of the particles
(Figure f). The reduction
of the particle size leads to a monotonic increase in the Nd3+-to-Yb3+ ratio. This effect can be caused by either the
reduction of the Yb3+ emission intensity or a growing emission
intensity of Nd3+. Since the spectral position of the emission
bands is independent of the RE3+:(PO4)3– ratio, the energy-level configuration of Yb3+ and Nd3+ remains unchanged. Hence, the probability of the interionic
energy transfer is expected to be independent of the particle size
in this case. Therefore, the observed phenomenon can be explained
in terms of two effects. First of them is the light-induced heating
of the particles and associated with this more promoted transfer of
the electrons from Yb3+ to Nd3+. The efficiency
of heat dissipation in strongly dimensionally constrained objects
like nanoparticles is strongly limited. Hence, light-induced heating
is more efficient for smaller objects. On the other hand, the reduction
of the particle size causes an enhancement of the probability of the
quenching of the excited state of Yb3+ ions via surface-related
quenching processes. Undoubtedly, the change in Yb3+ emission
intensity affects the ratio of luminescence intensity of Nd3+ to Yb3+ ions, which is confirmed by the analysis of luminescence
kinetics of Yb3+ ions (Figure g). It is clearly seen that with the increasing
RE3+:(PO4)3– concentration,
the average lifetime (τavr, eqs S1 and S2) of the 2F7/2 level is monotonically
shortened from τavr = 250 μs for RE = 0.5 to
τavr = 48 μs for RE = 5.To verify the
influence of the particle size on the luminescence
thermometer parameters based on the lifetime of the 2F7/2 level of Yb3+ ions, the luminescence kinetics
was measured as a function of temperature and the average lifetimes
were determined (Figures S2 and 4a). As shown in the presented
analysis for RE3+:(PO4)3– =
0.5, τavr shortens significantly above 200 K up to
about 350 K, above which the rate of observed changes slows down.
An increase in the RE3+:(PO4)3– ratio, as shown earlier, reduces the value of τavr and an increase in temperature causes an additional shortening of
its value but at a much lower rate than is the case for larger nanoparticles.
This effect can be explained by the increased role of surface processes.
As it is well known, in the case of materials doped with Yb3+ ions, the energy diffusion across excited 2F5/2 states is very efficient.[32,47,48] For nanomaterials, such a process due to the relatively short ion–surface
distance very often leads to energy quenching at the nanocrystal surface
through interactions with ligands and functional groups on the surface
or on surface structural defects.[42−45] The energy diffusion is a resonant
process and its probability should not depend on the temperature,
so it effectively shortens the lifetime of Yb3+ ions when
it becomes more efficient by reducing the nanoparticle. From a thermometric
perspective, this process can be seen as competing with the energy
transfer process between Yb3+ and Nd3+; whereas
the latter favors increasing the sensitivity of the thermometer, the
former suppresses the thermal dynamics of the lifetime changes. For
small nanoparticles, it is so efficient that further temperature-induced
shortening of τavr values is less evident. The rate
of temperature-induced shortening of the Yb3+ ion lifetime
can be quantified by the absolute sensitivity (SA) of the luminescence thermometer determined by the following
formula[14]where Δτavr represents
the change in τavr corresponding to the change in
temperature by ΔT. As expected, the highest SA values were obtained for the largest nanoparticles
because the longest τavr values were found for these
nanoparticles. The maximum value of SA = 1.36 μs/K was obtained at 275 K. Decreasing the size of
nanoparticles resulted in a successive decrease in the SA value. For the smallest nanoparticles (RE3+:(PO4)3– ratio = 5), the maximum SA = 0.06 μs/K at 220 K. For a further
quantitative comparative analysis, the relative sensitivity was also
determined according to the equation[14]In this case, the highest value of SR = 0.9%/K was obtained at 300 K for YPO4:10% Yb3+,50% Nd3+ synthesized using
RE3+:(PO4)3– = 0.5 (Figure c). It was worth noting that the temperature at which the
maximum sensitivity was obtained for individual samples depended on
the size of the nanoparticles and a general trend could be observed
that it decreased with the reduction of the size of the luminescent
thermometer. The maximum values of SR decreased
monotonically with the RE3+:(PO4)3– (Figure d). The
analysis carried out allowed us to conclude that to increase the sensitivity
of the luminescence thermometer based on luminescence lifetimes, it
was advantageous to use nanoparticles of a larger size. It should
be noted here that the hexagonal structure of the YPO4 was
stabilized by the crystallographic OH groups that could affect the
population of the excited state of the 2F5/2 state of Yb3+ ions. Hence, the removal of the OH groups
at higher temperatures may influence the τavr. However, according
to the TG-DSC analysis shown by Li et al. in the hexagonal YPO4, this removal was observed around 470 K.[49] This temperature exceeded the analyzed temperature range
in this study.
Figure 4
(a) Thermal dependence of the τavr of
Yb3+ ions obtained for different RE3+:(PO4)3– ratios. The corresponding SA (b) and SR (c). (d) Influence
of the RE3+:(PO4)3– on the
maximal SR (d).
Figure 5
Representative TEM images for YPO4:10% Yb3+, % Nd3+ nanoparticles with different Nd3+ concentrations:
1% Nd3+ (a), 25% Nd3+ (b), 50% Nd3+ (c), and 75% Nd3+ (d). (e) Comparison of the low-temperature
emission spectra upon λexc = 808 nm for different
Nd3+ concentrations. (f) Nd3+ to Yb3+ emission intensity ratio as a function of Nd3+ concentration.
(g) Influence of the Nd3+ on the τavr of 2F5/2 state of Yb3+ ions.
(a) Thermal dependence of the τavr of
Yb3+ ions obtained for different RE3+:(PO4)3– ratios. The corresponding SA (b) and SR (c). (d) Influence
of the RE3+:(PO4)3– on the
maximal SR (d).Representative TEM images for YPO4:10% Yb3+, % Nd3+ nanoparticles with different Nd3+ concentrations:
1% Nd3+ (a), 25% Nd3+ (b), 50% Nd3+ (c), and 75% Nd3+ (d). (e) Comparison of the low-temperature
emission spectra upon λexc = 808 nm for different
Nd3+ concentrations. (f) Nd3+ to Yb3+ emission intensity ratio as a function of Nd3+ concentration.
(g) Influence of the Nd3+ on the τavr of 2F5/2 state of Yb3+ ions.As indicated by the above studies, the nanocrystal
morphology had
a significant effect on the thermometric performance of a luminescent
thermometer based on the luminescence decay times from the 2F5/2 level. Taking into account that the phonon-assisted
energy transfer to the neighboring Nd3+ ion was responsible
for the thermal lifetime shortening of this level, one could expect
that increasing the Nd3+ ion concentration would facilitate
this energy transfer by shortening the average Nd3+–Yb3+ distance. Therefore, the thermometric properties of such
a thermometer were expected to depend significantly on the concentration
of Nd3+ ions. On the other hand, it was known that REPO4 phosphates with large RE ionic radii (such as Nd3+) preferentially crystallized in the monoclinic structure and revealed
an increased tendency to form elongated rodlike structures.[50] Therefore, it was important to verify how the
concentration of Nd3+ ions affected the morphology and
spectroscopic properties of the obtained phosphors. As mentioned above
and illustrated by representative TEM images, the increase in the
concentration of Nd3+ ions significantly modified the morphology
of the sample. For a concentration of 1% Nd3+, small, spherical,
and nonaggregated nanoparticles were observed (Figure a). An increase in the Nd3+ concentration
to 25% enlarged the size of the nanoparticles while maintaining their
shape (Figure b).
However, the increase in the Nd3+ ion concentration to
50% caused a slight decrease in the size of the nanoparticles. Additionally,
apart from spherical particles, cubic ones could also be observed
(Figure c). Further
increase in the concentration of Nd3+ ions resulted in
the elongation of the nanoparticles’ shape by their growth
along the c-axis (Figure d).[50] Importantly, even for such
high concentrations of Nd3+ ions, the hexagonal structure
was maintained (Figure ). A comparison of the luminescence spectra of YPO4:10%
Yb3+,% Nd3+ with different concentrations of
Nd3+ ions revealed that this change in concentration caused
the reduction of the luminescence intensity of the 4F3/2 → 4I9/2 band of Nd3+ ions relative to the 2F5/2 → 2F7/2 band of Yb3+ ions. This was mainly due
to an increase in the quenching of the excited level of 4F3/2 through the {4F3/2, 4I9/2} ↔ {4I15/2, 4I15/2} cross-relaxation process. Additionally, the shape
of the emission bands changed slightly, revealing a larger number
of Stark components for both Nd3+ and Yb3+ bands.
This effect suggested a decrease in the local symmetry of the lanthanide
ions as the concentration of Nd3+ ions increased associated
with the transition to the monoclinic NdPO4 structure.
Considering the fact that XRD patterns confirmed the presence of only
hexagonal structure, the change in the shape of the emission spectrum
might indicate the local character of the mentioned changes. Assuming
that the observed symmetry changes occurred only in the inner part
of the nanocrystal and the hexagonal phase was stabilized mainly in
the surface part of the nanocrystal, one could expect that the luminescence
spectra would be dominated by the contribution from ions localized
in the reduced symmetry. However, this was a speculative hypothesis
and required more in-depth investigation in the future. The ratio
of the luminescence intensity of Nd3+ ions to Yb3+ ions decreased almost linearly with increasing Nd3+ ion
concentration (Figure f). As expected, the lifetime of the 2F5/2 level
shortened with the increasing Nd3+ concentration, and the
monotonic nature of this shortening with no deviation around between
25% Nd3+ and 75% Nd3+ where significant changes
in nanoparticle shape were observed indicated that the dominant factor
causing the shortening was the effect of shortening the average distance
between interacting ions.As can be seen, regardless of the
Nd3+ ion concentration,
τavr shortens above 190 K. However, the rate of this
shortening clearly depends on the dopant concentration (Figures a and S3). As indicated above,
the high efficiency of the phonon energy transfer process associated
with an increase in dopant ion concentration results in a shortening
of τavr. Therefore, the additional lifetime shortening
associated with phonon absorption is less efficient (Figure a). Hence, the highest absolute
sensitivities and the relative sensitivities are observed for low
dopant concentrations. Importantly, a linear decrease in the maximum
relative sensitivity is observed with increasing concentration. This
directly demonstrates that although increasing the Nd3+ concentration causes a change in sample morphology (which should
result in improved thermometric performance as the nanoparticle size
increases), the increased probability of phonon-assisted energy transfer
plays a dominant role in this case. The high repeatability of the
τavr within several heating–cooling cycles
(Figure S5) and low-temperature determination
uncertainty (δT < 0.1 K) confirms the high
applicative potential of the presented luminescence thermometers.
Figure 6
Thermal
dependence of the τavr of 2F5/2 state of Yb3+ ions in YPO4:10%
Yb3+, Nd3+ for different concentrations of Nd3+ ions (a); SA (b) and SR (c); and influence of the Nd3+ concentration
on the maximal achieved SR (d).
Thermal
dependence of the τavr of 2F5/2 state of Yb3+ ions in YPO4:10%
Yb3+, Nd3+ for different concentrations of Nd3+ ions (a); SA (b) and SR (c); and influence of the Nd3+ concentration
on the maximal achieved SR (d).
Conclusions
The solvothermal synthesis
parameters of YPO4:Nd3+,Yb3+ nanocrystals
significantly affect the morphology
of the final product. It has been shown that using low RE3+:(PO4)3– concentrations can deliver
cubic and well-separated nanocrystals while increasing the RE3+:(PO4 )3– ratio results in a
decrease in the size of nanoparticles, changing their shape to spherical
and increasing the degree of aggregation. This significantly affects
not only the spectroscopic properties of YPO4:Yb3+,Nd3+ but also the thermometric performance of the thermometer
based on the luminescence kinetics of the 2F5/2 level of Yb3+ ions. The decrease in nanoparticle size
increases the role of surface quenching processes in the luminescence
of Yb3+ ions manifested in the shortening of the lifetime
of the 2F5/2 level and decrease in the emission
intensity of the 2F5/2 → 2F7/2 band with respect to the 4F3/2 → 4I9/2 band of Nd3+ ions.
The surface luminescence quenching processes competing with the energy
transfer process involving Yb3+ → Nd3+ phonons decrease the absolute and relative sensitivity of the luminescence
thermometer. An increase in the concentration of Nd3+ ions
changes the shape of nanoparticles from spherical to cubic (50% Nd3+) or even rodlike (75% Nd3+). Cross-relaxation-activated
processes decrease the luminescence intensity of the Nd3+ band relative to the Yb3+ band with the increasing Nd3+ concentration. Interestingly, the shape of the luminescence
spectra recorded for Nd3+ concentrations above 50% suggests
that a monoclinic structural phase is present in the samples despite
the fact that the XRD falls indicate the presence of only hexagonal
structure. Considering the linear decrease in the maximum relative
sensitivity of the luminescent thermometer with increasing Nd3+ ion concentration, it can be concluded that the concentration
of Nd3+ ions has a dominant influence on the thermometric
parameters of this type of thermometer. The presented studies indicate
the important role of nanocrystal morphology on thermometric performance,
which is often not considered, or not analyzed.
Authors: Fiorenzo Vetrone; Rafik Naccache; Alicia Zamarrón; Angeles Juarranz de la Fuente; Francisco Sanz-Rodríguez; Laura Martinez Maestro; Emma Martín Rodriguez; Daniel Jaque; José García Solé; John A Capobianco Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2010-06-22 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Erving Clayton Ximendes; Weslley Queiroz Santos; Uéslen Rocha; Upendra Kumar Kagola; Francisco Sanz-Rodríguez; Nuria Fernández; Artur da Silva Gouveia-Neto; David Bravo; Agustín Martín Domingo; Blanca del Rosal; Carlos D S Brites; Luís Dias Carlos; Daniel Jaque; Carlos Jacinto Journal: Nano Lett Date: 2016-02-11 Impact factor: 11.189
Authors: Jossana A Damasco; Tymish Y Ohulchanskyy; Supriya Mahajan; Guanying Chen; Ajay Singh; Hilliard L Kutscher; Haoyuan Huang; Steven G Turowski; Joseph A Spernyak; Anurag K Singh; Jonathan F Lovell; Mukund Seshadri; Paras N Prasad Journal: Cancer Nanotechnol Date: 2021-02-05