| Literature DB >> 36089938 |
Faith A P Zeng1, Anna Wilson1,2, Tabrez Sheriff1,2, Dedee F Murrell1,2,3.
Abstract
Background: Systemic glucocorticoids are first-line treatment options for autoimmune blistering diseases; however, their long-term use is associated with significant toxicities. Objective: To evaluate the side effects of steroid-sparing agents and compare them with those of steroids.Entities:
Keywords: AE, adverse event; AIBD, autoimmune blistering disease; AZA, azathioprine; BP, bullous pemphigoid; CTCAE; CTCAE, Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events; CsA, cyclosporin; GC, glucocorticoid; GTI; RCS, retrospective case series; RCT, randomized controlled trial; TPMT, thiopurine methyltransferase; autoimmune blistering diseases; bullous pemphigoid; glucocorticoids; immunosuppressants; pemphigus; side effects; steroid-sparing; treatment
Year: 2022 PMID: 36089938 PMCID: PMC9450124 DOI: 10.1016/j.jdin.2022.07.005
Source DB: PubMed Journal: JAAD Int ISSN: 2666-3287
Fig 1Flowchart illustrating the results of the search strategy. AIBD, Autoimmune blistering disease; BP, bullous pemphigoid.
Summary of randomized controlled trials and retrospective case studies evaluating adjuvant therapy in bullous pemphigoids
| Author; year; country | Type | Steroid (GC); adjuvant | Study arms | Study population and indication | CTCAE grading of AEs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Burton et al | RCT, nonblinded | Prednisone; AZA | GC only; GC, AZA | 25 patients with newly diagnosed BP | Grade 2: 2/12 patients (17%) |
| Beissert et al | RCT, multicenter, nonblinded | Methylprednisolone; AZA/MMF | GC, AZA; GC, MMF | 73 patients with newly diagnosed mild-to-severe BP | |
| Grade 3: 8/36 patients (22%) | |||||
| Grade 4: 3/36 patients (8%) | |||||
| Grade 3: 11/34 patients (32%) | |||||
| Grade 4: 2/34 patients (6%) | |||||
| Sticherling et al | RCT, multicenter, nonblinded | Methylprednisolone; AZA/dapsone | GC, AZA; GC, dapsone | 54 patients with newly diagnosed BP | |
| >Grade 1: 18/27 patients (67%) | |||||
| >Grade 1: 13/27 patients (48%) | |||||
| Gual et al | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; CTX | GC, CTX | 20 patients with moderate-to-severe BP, initially treated with STS or systemic GCs and with CsA as first-, second-, or third-line adjuvant | Grade 2: 3/20 patients (15%) |
| Schmidt et al | Retrospective case series | Methylprednisolone; dapsone | GC, dapsone | 62 patients with untreated or refractory BP | Grade 1: 10/62 patients (16%) |
| Grade 2: 9/62 patients (15%) | |||||
| Grade 5: 5/62 patients (8%) | |||||
| Amagai et al | RCT, multicenter, double-blinded | Prednisone; IVIg | GC only; GC, IVIg | 56 patients with BP were on a stable regimen, which included GCs | AEs were recorded as the number of events per AE and not all AEs experienced per patient |
| Kjellman et al | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; MTX | GC, MTX; MTX only | 98 patients with newly diagnosed mild-to-severe BP | Grade 2: 5/98 patients (5%) |
| Du-Thanh et al | Retrospective case series | STS, bethamethasone propionate, or clobetasol proprionate; MTX | GC, MTX | 70 patients initially treated with short-term STS and low-dose MTX, followed by long-term, low-dose MTX | Grade 1: 2/70 patients (3%) |
| Grade 2: 3/70 patients (4%) | |||||
| Grade 3: 2/70 patients (3%) | |||||
| Grade 4: 8/70 patients (11%) | |||||
| Grade 5: 1/70 patients (3%) | |||||
| Delaumenie et al | Retrospective case series | TPC; MTX | GC, MTX | 51 patients with moderate-to-severe BP, initially treated with TPC as first line | Grade 1 and 2: NA (48%) |
| Grade 3: NA (22%) | |||||
| Polansky et al | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; RTX | GC, RTX | 20 patients with untreated severe or refractory BP | AEs could not be graded because of inadequate information |
| Williams et al | RCT, multicenter | Prednisone; tetracycline | GC only; tetracycline only | 234 patients with newly diagnosed BP | Grade 0/1/2: 99/121 patients (81%) |
| Grade 3: 14/121 patients (12%) | |||||
| Grade 4: 5/121 patients (4%) | |||||
| Grade 5: 3/121 patients (3%) | |||||
| Fivenson et al | Randomized, open-label trial | Prednisone; TCN | GC only; TCN only | 18 patients with BP with no systemic GC therapy within 2 wk of enrollment | Grade 2: 2/12 patients (17%) |
| Grade 3 or 4: 1/12 (possibly treatment related) (8%) |
AE, Adverse event; AZA, azathioprine; BP, bullous pemphigoid; CsA, Cyclosporin; CTCAE, Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events; CTX, cyclophosphamide; GC, glucocorticoid; IVIg, intravenous immunoglobulin; MMF, mycophenolate mofetil; MTX, methotrexate; NA, not available; RCT, randomized control trial; RTX, rituximab; STS, superpotent topical steroid; TCN, tetracycline and nicotinamide; UK, United Kingdom; US, United States.
The corresponding studies for each drug are arranged in chronologic order, ie, most recent to least recent.
The drugs are presented in alphabetical order by steroid-sparing adjuvant agent.
Summary of randomized controlled trials and retrospective case studies evaluating adjuvant therapy in patients with pemphigus
| Author; year; country | Type | Steroid; adjuvant | Study arms | Study population and indication | CTCAE grading of AEs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rose et al | RCT, multicenter, nonblinded | Methylprednisolone/dexamethasone; AZA/CTX | Methylprednisolone, AZA; dexamethasone, CTX | 22 patients with newly diagnosed PV/PF | AEs were recorded as the number of events per AE and not all AEs experienced per patient |
| Kakuta et al | Retrospective case series | None; AZA | AZA only | 8 patients with newly diagnosed PV/PF | Grade 2: 2/8 patients (25%) |
| Dastgheib et al | RCT | Prednisone; AZA/tacrolimus | GC, AZA; GC, tacrolimus | 41 patients with PV | |
| Grade 2: 3/21 patients (14%) | |||||
| Grade 3: 1/21 patients (5%) | |||||
| Grade 1: 1/20 patients (5%) | |||||
| Grade 2: 1/20 patients (5%) | |||||
| Chams-Davatchi et al | RCT, nonblinded | Prednisone; AZA/MMF/CsA | GC only; GC, AZA; GC, MMF; GC, CTX | 90 patients with newly diagnosed PV | AEs were not described for each treatment arm; it was noted just that there was no significant difference in AE profiles across the 4 groups |
| Olszewska et al | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; AZA/CTX/CsA | GC only; GC, AZA; GC, CTX; GC, CsA | 101 patients with moderate-to-severe PV | AEs were recorded as the number of events per AE and not all AEs experienced per patient |
| Cummins et al | RCT, nonblinded | Prednisone; CTX | GC, CTX | A total of 23 with refractory PV/PF | Grade 2: 11/23 patients (47%) |
| Grade 3: 3/23 patients (13%) | |||||
| Sharma and Khandpur | RCT, nonblinded | Prednisone; CTX IV pulse therapy | GC only; GC, CTX | 60 patients with mild-to-moderate PV | AEs were recorded as the percentage difference compared with control arm |
| Khandpur et al | Cross-sectional, prospective, clinical, laboratory investigational | Dexamethasone; CTX IV pulse therapy | GC, CTX | 44 patients with PV/PF who have been on CsA for at least 1 y | Grade 2: 23/44 patients (52%) |
| Ioannides et al | RCT | Prednisone; CsA | GC only; GC, CsA | 33 patients with newly diagnosed PV/PF | AEs were recorded as the number of events per AE and not all AEs experienced per patient |
| Baum et al | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; dapsone | GC, dapsone | 125 patients who received dapsone between 1984 and 2013; for the purpose of this review, excluded patients will be evaluated as they experienced early AEs and, thus, were not included in the study | Grade 2: 99/125 patients (79%) |
| Werth et al | RCT, multicenter, double-blind | Prednisone; dapsone | GC only; GC, dapsone | 19 patients with chronic PV in the maintenance phase | Grade 1: 1/9 patients (11%) |
| Grade 2: 1/9 patients (11%) | |||||
| Svecova; 2016 | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; IVIg | GC, IVIg | 10 patients with PV with at least 3 consecutive courses of IVIg | Grade 2: 8/10 patients (80%) |
| Beissert et al | RCT, nonblinded | Prednisone; MMF | GC only; GC, MMF | A total of 94 with existing mild-to-moderate PV | Grade 3: 3/58 patients (5%) |
| Ioannides et al | RCT, nonblinded | Methylprednisolone; MMF | GC only, GC, MMF | 47 patients with newly diagnosed PV/PF | Grade 1: 11/24 patients (46%) |
| Baum et al | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; MTX | GC, MTX | 30 patients with untreated or refractory PV | Grade 2: 4/30 patients (13%) |
| Tran et al | Retrospective case series | Prednisone; MTX | GC, MTX | 23 patients with PV with refractory PV and subsequently on MTX for at least 3 consecutive mo | Grade 2: 2/23 patients (9%) |
| Chen et al | RCT, phase 3 open-label | Prednisone; RTX | GC only; GC, RTX | A total of 74 patients with newly diagnosed PV | Grade 1/2: 22/38 patients (58%) all attributed to Infusion-Related Reaction |
| Grade 3: 10/38 patients (29%) from drug itself; 1/38 patients (3%) from IRR | |||||
| Grade 4: 2/38 patients (5%) | |||||
| Kurihara et al | Multicenter, phase 1/2 open-label | Prednisolone; RTX | GC, RTX | 9 patients with refractory PV/PF | Grade 3/4: 9/9 patients had at least one AE in this grade |
| McCarty and Fivenson | Retrospective case series | Not specified; TCN | GC, TCN | A total of 51 with/without initial GC therapy and at least 3 mo of TCN | Grade 2: 3/51 patients (6%) |
AE, Adverse event; AZA, azathioprine; BP, bullous pemphigoid; CTCAE, Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events; CsA, cyclosporin; CTX, cyclophosphamide; GC, glucocorticoid; IV, intravenous; IVIg, intravenous immunoglobulin; MMF, mycophenolate mofetil; MTX, methotrexate; PF, pemphigus foliaceous; PV, pemphigus vulgaris; RTX, rituximab; RCT, randomized control trial; STS, superpotent topical steroids; TCN, tetracycline and nicotinamide; UK, United Kingdom; US, United States.
Drugs are presented in alphabetical order of steroid-sparing adjuvant agent and the corresponding studies for each drug is arranged in chronological order, ie, most recent to least recent.
The maintenance phase is defined as disease controlled with steroids and/or stable dosages for at least 2 months on cytotoxic agents, including AZA, MMF, or MTX.
Common steroid-induced side effects are classified by organ system in alphabetical order49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61
| Organ system | Side effects |
|---|---|
| Cardiovascular | Coronary heart disease, heart failure, hypertension, ischemic heart disease |
| Dermatologic | Acne, delayed wound healing, easy bruising, ecchymosis, erosion, hair loss, hirsutism, purpura, skin atrophy, striae |
| Endocrine and Metabolic | Adrenal suppression, Cushingoid features, diabetes mellitus, dyslipidemia, hyperglycemia, weight gain |
| Gastrointestinal | Gastritis, gastrointestinal bleeding, hepatic steatosis, pancreatitis, peptic ulcer disease, visceral perforation |
| Immunologic | Predisposition to infections, reactivation of latent infections |
| Musculoskeletal | Myopathy, osteonecrosis, osteoporosis |
| Neuropsychiatric | Akathisia, anxiety, cognitive impairment, depression, euphoria, mood changes, mood lability |
| Ophthalmologic | Cataract, glaucoma |
Classification of adverse events recorded in the reviewed randomized control trials and randomized case series according to how likely they are due to glucocorticosteroids or steroid-sparing adjuvant therapy for pemphigoid and pemphigus
| Adverse event | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Drug | Likely to be true GCAE | Likely to be true AEs of adjuvant therapy for pemphigoid and pemphigus | Unable to be distinguished |
| AZA | Amenorrhea, cataract, cerebrovascular accident, Cushingoid features, depression, diabetes mellitus, duodenal ulcer, GI bleeding, GI ulcer, GI discomfort, glaucoma, hot flushes, hyperglycemia, hypertension, hypertrichosis, lumbar stenosis, mood changes, myopathy, edema, osteoporosis, pancreatitis, temporary psychosis, tendonitis, redistribution of fat, weight gain | Diarrhea, liver function test abnormalities, myelosuppression (leukopenia, pancytopenia, thrombocytopenia), pharyngitis, vomiting | Arthralgia/myalgia, dizziness, deep venous thrombosis, drug-related exanthema, effluvium, infection |
| CTX | Acute myeloid leukemia, bladder symptoms (enuresis, frequency/urgency of urination, hematuria, incontinence, nocturia), myelosuppression (anemia, leukopenia, thrombocytopenia), nausea, vomiting | Acute heart failure, dizziness, infection, headache | |
| CsA | Elevated transaminase, gingival hyperplasia, hyperbilirubinemia, nephrotoxicity (decreased creatinine clearance, increased urea/serum creatinine) | N/A | |
| Dapsone | Anemia, cyanosis, fever, liver function abnormalities, methemoglobinemia, paresthesia | Arthralgia/myalgia, dizziness, drug-related exanthema, infection, renal failure | |
| IVIg | Chest pain, decreased blood alkaline phosphatase, depressed platelet count, elevated blood lactate dehydrogenase, fever, injection site erythema/pain, liver function test abnormalities, malaise | N/A | |
| MMF | Fatigue, hypokalemia, liver function test abnormalities, myelosuppression (lymphopenia, neutropenia) | Arthralgia/myalgia, eye disease, infection | |
| MTX | Alopecia, anemia, interstitial pneumopathy, liver function test abnormalities, myelosuppression (leukopenia, pancytopenia, thrombocytopenia) | Alveolitis, asthenia, GI bleeding, GI ulcer, pulmonary embolism | |
| RTX | Arthralgia/myalgia, hypogammaglobulinemia, hypergamma glutamyltransferase | Cerebrovascular accident, dental carries, headache, infection, nasal septum perforation, peripheral neuropathy, phlebitis, psoriatic arthropathy, pulmonary embolism, venous thrombosis | |
| TCN | Diarrhea, nausea, vomiting | Decubitus ulcers, deep venous thrombosis, erosive gastritis | |
AE, Adverse event; AZA, azathioprine; CsA, cyclosporin; CTX, cyclophosphamide; GC, glucocorticosteroid; GCAE, glucocorticoid-induced adverse events; IVIg, intravenous immunoglobulin; GI, gastrointestinal; MMF, mycophenolate mofetil; MTX, methotrexate; N/A, not available; RTX, rituximab; RCT, randomized control trial; TCN, tetracycline and nicotinamide.
The AEs are listed in alphabetical order.