| Literature DB >> 36071725 |
Nancy Cross1, Cécile van Steen2, Yasmina Zegaoui1, Andrew Satherley1, Luigi Angelillo2.
Abstract
Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP) is a group of inherited retinal dystrophies (IRDs) characterised by progressive vision loss. Patients with RP experience a significant impact on daily activities, social interactions, and employment, reducing their quality of life. Frequent delays in referrals and no standard treatment for most patients also contribute to the high unmet need for RP. This paper aims to describe the evolving therapeutic landscape for RP including the rationale for advanced therapy medicinal products (ATMPs). A review of available data was conducted in three stages: (1) a search of publicly available literature; (2) qualitative research with physicians treating RP patients in France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the UK; and (3) a review of leading candidates in the RP pipeline. Globally, there are currently over 100 drugs in development for RP; 50% of which are ATMPs. Amongst the 15 cell and gene therapies in late-stage development, 5 leading candidates have been selected to profile based on the development stage, drug target and geography: gene therapies AGN-151597, GS-030 and VMCO-1 and human stem cell therapies jCell and ReN-003. Hereditary retinal diseases are suitable for treatment with cell and gene therapies due to the accessibility of the retina and its immune privilege and compartmentalisation. Therapeutic approaches that aim to rescue photoreceptors (eg gene therapies) require that non-functional target cells are still present, whereas other therapies (eg cell therapies) are not reliant on the presence of viable photoreceptors. Gene therapies may be attractive as their fundamental goal is to restore vision; however, cell therapies will likely have a broader application and do not rely on genetic testing, which can delay treatment. Ensuring effective therapeutic options for RP patients across disease stages requires the continued diversification and advancement of the development pipeline, and sustained efforts to promote early patient identification and timely diagnosis.Entities:
Keywords: cell therapy; gene therapy; retinal dystrophy; retinitis pigmentosa; therapeutic landscape; treatment
Year: 2022 PMID: 36071725 PMCID: PMC9441588 DOI: 10.2147/OPTH.S370032
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Ophthalmol ISSN: 1177-5467
Figure 1Identification of leading candidates in RP. Created using the official PRISMA 2020 flow diagram for new systematic reviews.
Exclusion of Candidates in the RP pipeline8
| Drug Name | Sponsor | Reason for Exclusion |
|---|---|---|
| 4D-125 | 4D Molecular Therapeutics Inc. | Undisclosed mechanism of action |
| Botaretigene sparoparvovec | MeiraGTx Holdings Plc. | Targets a specific gene: RPGR |
| BS-01 | Applied Genetic Technologies Corp. | Targets a specific gene: RPGR |
| Cotoretigene toliparvovec | Biogen Inc. | Targets a specific gene: RPGR |
| CPK-850 | Novartis AG | Targets a specific gene: RLBP1 |
| CTxPDE-6b | Coave Therapeutics | Targets a specific gene: PDE6B |
| CTxPDE-6b | Thea Open Innovation S.A.S.U. | Targets a specific gene: PDE6B |
| Gene Therapy to Activate PDE6A for Retinitis Pigmentosa | University of Tubingen | Targets a specific gene: PDE6A; Limited clinical capacity of a university sponsor |
| Laruparetigene zovaparvovec | Applied Genetic Technologies Corp | Targets a specific gene: RPGR |
| QR-1123 | ProQR Therapeutics NV | Targets a specific gene: RHO |
| QRX-421a | ProQR Therapeutics NV | Targets a specific gene: USH2A |
Leading Cell and Gene Therapy Candidates in the Development for RP8,22–26
| Drug Name | Indication | Formulation | Mechanism | Mechanism of Action | Phase of Development | Sponsor | Geographic Scope |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AGN-151597 | RP | Intravitreal | ChR2 functions as light-gated cation-selective channels in retinal neurons, facilitating the depolarisation of these neurons in response to the absorption of specific wavelengths of light. | Phase II | AbbVie Inc. | US | |
| GS-030 | RP | Intravitreal | The ChrimsonR-tdTomato gene is embedded into the nucleus of photoreceptor cells, using optogenetics technology, which can then produce a critical protein which makes cone cells light-sensitive. | Phase II | GenSight Biologics S.A. | US, EU, UK | |
| jCell | RP | Intravitreal | Retinal progenitor cells are developed by human retinal progenital cell (hRPC) technology. They act as photoreceptors and stabilise the retina by directly replacing the dying cells. These progenitor cells secrete neuroprotective factors and have the ability to phagocyte damaging materials that build up in disease. | Phase II | jCyte Inc. | US | |
| ReN-003 | RP | Intraocular | ReN-003 hRPCs differentiate along the photoreceptor lineage and are capable of self-renewal and multipotent and retina-specific differentiation. They integrate with the host retinal tissue, differentiating to express the protein rhodopsin. | Phase II | ReNeuron Group | Spain, UK, US | |
| VMCO-1 | RP | Intravitreal | VMCO-1 acts by delivering white opsin to the target cells. | Phase II | Nanoscope Therapeutics Inc. | US |
Figure 2(A) RP pipeline by development phase. (B) Drug types across each stage of the clinical development pipeline for RP.
Figure 3The most common targets for RP drug candidates (excludes those targeted by a single product in the pipeline).
Figure 4Potential treatment for photoreceptor degeneration based on stage of disease and degree of photoreceptor loss.
The Advantages and Potential Limitations Associated with Cell Therapies
| A cell therapy could stop the progression of disease through delaying the death of photoreceptors |
| Stem cells are self-renewing, and due to their capacity of unlimited expansion and their plasticity, stem cell-based therapies may reduce or eliminate the necessity for repeated administrations of the therapeutic cells. |
| Cell therapies will likely have a broad application as they are mutation-independent. |
| Treatment can be initiated earlier as genetic testing is not required for cell therapies. |
| In principle, culture techniques allow the generation of unlimited transplantable cells. |
| Challenges include integration of transplanted cells into the host retina and reconstruction of the synaptic connections and functionality. |
| Evidence for successful integration of transplanted photoreceptors into the host retina is still preliminary. |
| Risk of rejection due to immunopriviledge being compromised in surgery. |
| Risk of tumorigenesis due to the persistence of undifferentiated stem cells at the end of a reprogramming and differentiation protocol. |
| Several clinical and preclinical studies have reported transplantation-related adverse effects including retinal detachment and inflammation and further research into the optimal delivery route is required. |
The Advantages and Potential Limitations Associated with Gene Therapies
| The fundamental goal is to treat the disease and restore vision, by introducing corrective, healthy genetic material into cells to either produce a functional protein or compensate for a specific diseased gene. Therefore, gene therapy offers the possibility to cure diseases such as RP. |
| Gene therapies are likely to be specific for a particular genetic mutation, increasing the likely effectiveness and allowing for “personalised” treatment. |
| Optogenetics have been developed as an acceptable gene therapy approach to combat limitations associated with traditional gene therapy. This includes the fact it is a gene-independent approach, and its application in late-stage disease where there is significant photoreceptor loss. |
| In advanced disease, target photoreceptors will have largely degenerated and conventional gene therapy (to silence or mutate a gene) will no longer be effective. |
| With any delays in referral, diagnosis and genetic testing for RP, it is possible that patients will miss the limited time window for successful gene therapy. |
| Although intended as one-time treatments, the durability of response to gene therapies will only be established with time. |
| Genetic testing must be undertaken to identify patients eligible for gene therapy at a stage of disease where the patient has sufficient remaining retinal cells. |
| The effect of a gene therapy is difficult to halt following treatment delivery, and long-term safety is yet to be established. |
| Inconsistent clinical outcomes may be associated with insufficient transgene expression mediated by adeno-associated virus (AAV) in target cells and/or immune response. |
| Retinal blood flow and oxygen uptake is reduced in patients with RP, therefore even if there are photoreceptors remaining, there may not be sufficient oxygen supply for photoreceptors to survive. |
| Risk of rejection, despite immunopriviledge |
| Current gene therapies are not able to address large genes (eg USH2A) that so far cannot be delivered by a viral vector. |