| Literature DB >> 36071530 |
Catherine Kansiime1, Laura Hytti2, Kate Andrews Nelson2, Belen Torondel3, Suzanna C Francis2, Clare Tanton2, Giulia Greco2, Sophie Belfield4, Shamirah Nakalema4, Fred Matovu5, Andrew Sentoogo Ssemata6, Connie Alezuyo7, Stella Neema8, John Jerrim9, Chris Bonell2, Janet Seeley2,10, Helen A Weiss2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Menstrual health is an increasingly recognised public health issue, defined as complete physical, mental, and social well-being in relation to the menstrual cycle. The MENISCUS trial aims to assess whether a multi-component intervention addressing physical and emotional aspects of menstrual health improves educational attainment, mental health problems, menstrual management, self-efficacy, and quality of life among girls in secondary school in Uganda.Entities:
Keywords: Adolescent health; Education; Menstrual health; Mental health; School-based intervention
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 36071530 PMCID: PMC9449307 DOI: 10.1186/s13063-022-06672-4
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Trials ISSN: 1745-6215 Impact factor: 2.728
MENISCUS intervention reported according to the TIDieR framework
| 1. Menstrual Health (MH) Action Group | |
| 2. Puberty education | |
| 3. Drama skit | |
| 4. Menstrual health kit and training | |
| 5. Pain management | |
| 6. Water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) improvements | |
| 1. To facilitate school-ownership of the MENISCUS intervention and hence that it is implemented well in the school | |
| 2. To strengthen schools’ capacity to deliver knowledge of puberty and menstruation | |
| 3. To enable a supportive school environment and reduce stigma and teasing | |
| 4. To improve menstrual management and provide product choice | |
| 5. To improve ability to manage menstrual pain | |
| 6. To improve menstrual hygiene management | |
| 1. The WoMena staff training the Action Group will receive a manual and training to deliver the training. The MH Action Group members will receive in-person training in puberty and menstruation and on running an MH Action Group. The MH Action Group members will receive a T-shirt with the MENISCUS logo, the budget for running the Group, an MH kit and an MH Action Group Charter, guide and action plan to complete. The MH Action Group will receive support by WoMena Uganda after the initial training in follow-up sessions. | |
| 2. The schools’ staff delivering puberty education will receive in-person training on how to deliver the Ministry of Education and Sports’ (MoES) training on menstrual health management and a copy of the MoES Training Manual for teachers and other stakeholders on Menstrual Health Management. | |
| 3. The drama group members (facilitators and students) will receive two facilitation sessions on menstruation and the drama skit. They will receive an outline of a MH-related drama to be developed into a drama skit and performed at an existing school meeting. A small budget, managed by the MH Action Group, will be available to buy props and supporting materials for the performance and the students taking part. The students taking part will receive a T-shirt with a MENISCUS logo. | |
4. i) Trained school members (“MENISCUS trainers”) including student leaders and prefects to provide peer support to girls will receive in-person training on how to deliver menstruation education sessions (a joint session of menstruation for boys and girls and separate girls’ and boys’ sessions), alongside receiving specially developed materials to deliver these sessions, flipcharts and a training manual. The trainers will receive a certificate, a T-shirt, and an MH kit. ii) S2 students will receive in-person education sessions delivered by the MENISCUS trainers. The students will receive a MENISCUS booklet developed by WoMena to accompany the education sessions. The girls’ session includes puberty, how to use the MH kit components, and tracking and managing their periods, including managing menstrual pain. Students will receive a MH kit consisting of the AFRIpads “schoolgirl kit” of 5 reusable pads, a towel, soap, two pairs of underwear, and MH booklet with a menstrual tracker, plus a menstrual cup and container for girls who consented to the cup. The boys’ session will include male puberty, genital hygiene, male circumcision, and attitudes towards girls who are menstruating. iii) Female caregivers will receive in-person education around menstruation and the use and care of reusable menstrual products (menstrual cup and reusable pads). Caregivers will receive a MH kit of the AFRIpads “standard kit” of 6 reusable pads, a towel, soap, and underwear plus a menstrual cup and container to those who consent and are willing to receive the cup. | |
| 5. S2 female students will receive (i) an information sheet about safe use of paracetamol and ibuprofen, plus information on pain management methods more broadly in the MENISCUS MH booklet, and (ii) vouchers to be redeemed for a maximum of 6 tablets per month from the school nurse or designated senior teacher who will be trained in administering these by the MENISCUS clinical officer. | |
| 6. Basic improvements to school WASH facilities (installation of locks, repair of broken doors, provision of bins and toilet paper holders fixed to the wall, liquid hand washing soap, and water drums). | |
1. The MH Action Group will consist of 6–8 people selected by school management and will be responsible for implementing and maintaining the intervention. They will be MH champions within the school. The MH Action Group members will include a minimum of at least one representative of school management, a senior woman teacher, a student, and a parent. The group will receive: • 1-day training on menstruation and being a member of the MH Action Group by WoMena Uganda • Follow-up and support from WoMena Uganda facilitators at 3 MH Action Group meetings | |
| 2. Up to 5 male and female teachers per school who usually deliver puberty education to secondary students will attend a 2-day training, followed by 1-day training by WoMena Uganda. | |
| 3. The drama skit component will involve the drama group in the school, including the drama teacher and students who attend. If there is no active drama club or group in the school, the MH Action Group will be encouraged to support the creation of a group. Drama groups, including a drama teacher/facilitator and around 30 students in the school, will be invited to 2 facilitation sessions which contain training on menstruation and puberty and introductions to the concept of the drama skit and the script. The group will also have rehearsals observed and supported by WoMena. | |
| 4. Approximately 7 school staff and students will be selected as MENISCUS trainers, responsible for training S2 students in MH and using the MH kit. Selected prefects and student leaders will support the trained staff in training activities and act as peer support in their schools. Training participants will be selected by school management according to specified selection criteria (for example, motivation and agreement to attend trainings and train young people of puberty, menstruation and using reusable menstrual products, as well as having the trust and respect from students). Approximately 8 female caregivers associated with the schools will be selected by school management according to a specified criterion (willing to try products, respected in the community, has a child who attends the school). | |
| 5. The school nurse or other designated senior teacher will be trained on safe use and management of paracetamol and ibuprofen by the MENISCUS clinical officer, including how the voucher scheme works. | |
| 6. WASH improvements will be made by a contractor employed by MRC/UVRI and LSHTM Uganda Research Unit. The MH Action Group members will be responsible for maintaining the improved WASH facilities. | |
| 1. WoMena Uganda will provide face-to-face group training around the MH Action Group and will have in-person follow-up visits for each school to observe and support. | |
| 2. WoMena Uganda will provide face-to-face group training in puberty education to teachers. | |
| 3. WoMena Uganda will introduce the drama skit and provide a brief training on menstruation in person and will attend a rehearsal to give feedback and support in each school. | |
| 4. WoMena Uganda will provide face-to-face group training of MENISCUS Trainers, with follow-up in each school to provide support. WoMena Uganda will provide face-to-face group trainings of female caregivers. | |
| 5. The MENISCUS clinical officer will provide training of school nurses or other designated staff on appropriate analgesic use, and WoMena will provide training on alternative pain management strategies to MENISCUS Trainers. | |
| 6. WASH improvements will be made at each school by the contractor. | |
| All intervention elements will take place at the school or at an event space in the community for the trainings. | |
| All elements will be delivered over the course of a year, following randomisation. | |
| 1. The training of the MH Action Groups will take place once, in clusters of about 5 intervention schools based on their location. The training will be for 1 day per cluster of schools. The MH Action Groups following this will run for 8–11 months (depending on when they receive their training). They will have 3 meetings, with one attended by the WoMena Uganda team over this period. | |
| 2. The training of the puberty educators will be two sessions in each district. The first training will take place approximately 4 weeks ahead of the second training. The first training will last 2 days and the second training will last 1 day. Those trained will then deliver the puberty education to students they teach over the following 8 months. | |
| 3. Two drama skit facilitation sessions will take place in each school followed by an attendance at one rehearsal. The drama skit facilitation sessions, rehearsals, and performance will take place over a period of 3 months. | |
| 4. The training of MENISCUS trainers will take place once with two separate sessions firstly, a 2-day session and a 1-day follow-up session, approximately 1 month after the initial training session. The MENISCUS trainers will then deliver this training to students at the school over the following 3 months. The training of female caregivers will take place once in a 1-day session. | |
| There are plans for adaptations and tailoring based on attendance at the initial trainings and the delivery of the training by the MENISCUS trainers to the S2 students. If there is no attendance at the initial trainings, schools will be offered these trainings at their schools individually unless there are enough schools who did not attend and then another training will be held in a central location. If schools do not deliver the training to S2 students, they will be supported to do so by WoMena Uganda by either delivering the sessions or being present when the school delivers all the sessions. | |
| This will be evaluated in the process evaluation (please see details in Table |
Primary and secondary impact outcome measures
| Outcome | Measure | Tool | Study population |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1) Educational attainment in girls (primary outcome) | Mean total score on examination of curricula material in English, Mathematics, and Biology taught during the intervention year (adjusted for baseline score) | Examination set by UNEB | All girls in the endline survey |
| 2) Mental health problems (primary outcome) | Mean Total Difficulties score from the Strengths and Difficulties questionnaire (adjusted for baseline SDQ score) | Strengths and Difficulties 25-item questionnaire | |
| i) Knowledge of puberty and menstruation; attitudes towards menstruation | Proportion answering all knowledge questions correctly Proportion answering all questions on myths correctly Proportion with “good” responses on attitudes | Endline survey | All girls and a random sample of boys in the endline survey |
| ii) Menstrual practices at last menstrual period (LMP) | Proportion using manufactured methods only at LMP Proportion correctly washing and drying reusable pads and/or menstrual cups at LMP Proportion with ‘adequate MHM at school’ at LMPa Mean score on the Menstrual Practice Needs Scale | Endline survey | All girls in the endline survey |
| iii) Knowledge and practices of pain management at LMP | Proportion knowing 4 or more effective pain management methodsb Proportion of those with pain at LMP who used an effective pain management method | ||
| iv) Self-efficacy of MH | Mean score on Self-efficacy in Addressing Menstrual Needs Scale [ | ||
| v) Quality of life and happiness | Mean CHU9D score (9-dimension questionnaire) Self-reported measure of happiness | ||
| vi) Prevalence of urogenital infections | Prevalence of bacterial vaginosis (Nugent score >7) Prevalence of vaginal yeast (Gram stain) Prevalence of UTI (symptoms ± leucocyte esterase and/or nitrates with urine dipstick) | 2 vaginal swabsc Urine Multistix 8 dipstick if symptomatic for UTI | Post-menarchal girls only (~95%) at endline |
| vii) School and class absence during menses | Proportion of full school days missed by girls during their period (adjusted for absence on non-period days) Proportion of school days with classes missed by girls during their period (adjusted for absence on non-period days) | Daily diary on school attendance and menstrual cycle, administered for 12 weeks at endline | Random subsample of ~1500 post-menarchal girls at endline |
| viii) School and class attendance overall | Proportion of full school days missed Proportion of school days with classes missed | ||
| ix) Self-confidence in Mathematics and science abilities | Mean score on the Students Confident in Mathematics scaled Mean score on the Students Confident in Science scaled | Endline survey | All girls in the endline survey |
aSelf-reported use of clean materials to absorb/collect blood, changed privately, safely, hygienically, and as often as needed
bUse of painkiller, drinking water, using water bottle, exercise, stretching, and foods with lots of water
cThe second swab will be stored in RNAlaterTM Stabilization Solution for future testing to characterise the vaginal microbiome by 16S rRNA sequencing (funds not included)
dStandardised scales from the IEA’s Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study – TIMSS 2011 Copyright © 2012 International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement (IEA). Publisher: TIMSS & PIRLS International Study Center, Lynch School of Education, Boston College
Fig. 1Time schedule of enrolment, interventions, and assessments
Overview of qualitative data collection activities
| Tool | Participants | When |
|---|---|---|
| Semi-structured phone interviews with senior school staff | 60 senior staff members (one per school, | Baseline and endline |
| Semi-structured interviews with MH Action Group members | 30 members of the school’s MHM leadership group member (one per intervention school | After initial intervention delivery and endline |
| Semi-structured interviews with intervention providers | 8 WoMena Uganda staff | After initial intervention delivery and endline |
| Focus groups | 4 FGs with 4 female students ( 4 FGs with 4 school staff ( 4 FGs with 4 male students ( | After initial intervention delivery and endline |
| Semi-structured interviews with school staff and female students | 12 staff members and female students (menstrual cup recipients and non-recipients) | After initial intervention delivery and endline |
| Semi-structured interviews with female caregivers | 8 female caregiver MH kit recipients | Endline |
Process evaluation research questions and data collection methods and sources
| Research domain | Research questions | Data sources | |
|---|---|---|---|
Was training and school components implemented as planned? What adaptations were made? How did fidelity vary between schools? What were the barriers and facilitators to implementation fidelity? | Log books Structured observations Endline surveys with male and female students IDIs and/or FGDs with students, staff, MH Action Group members, intervention deliverers WASH checklist | ||
What proportion of students received and accessed various components of the intervention? How acceptable was the intervention to students? How did reach and acceptability vary by student characteristics? What contextual factors affected reach and acceptability? | |||
What is usual provision of puberty lessons and MH activities in control schools? What puberty and MH activities are happening within schools and in the wider community? What WASH provision exists in control schools? | Baseline/endline surveys with male and female students Rapid assessment data Structured interview with senior staff member at endline WASH checklist | ||
How did intervention providers and school staff and students describe how they used the intervention resources to enact the intervention, including any adaptations? What mechanisms did participants say were triggered by enactment of intervention activities and what impacts and other consequences did these have on students and the school? | IDIs and/or FGDs with students, staff, MH Action Group members, intervention deliverers Structured interview with senior staff member at endline | ||
How did participants describe enactment and mechanisms as affected by school context? What were contextual reasons for adaptations to the intervention and its delivery? | IDIs and/or FGDs with students, staff, MH Action Group members, intervention deliverers Rapid assessment data Structured interview with senior staff member at endline Log books | ||
| Title {1} | Menstrual health interventions, schooling and mental health problems among Ugandan students (MENISCUS): Study protocol for a school-based cluster-randomised trial. |
| Trial registration {2a and 2b}. | International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number (ISRCTN): 45461276, registered on 16th September 2021. |
| Protocol version {3} | Version 3.0: January 2022 |
| Funding {4} | Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) through the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR), Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO), the Medical Research Council (MRC) and the Wellcome Trust through the Joint Global Health Trials scheme. |
| Author details {5a} | 1. Dr Catherine Kansiime, MRC/UVRI and LSHTM Uganda Research Unit, Uganda Research Unit 2. Ms Laura Hytti, Independent Researcher, LSHTM, UK. 3. Ms Kate Andrews Nelson, MRC International Statistics and Epidemiology Group, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine (LSHTM), UK. 4. Dr Belen Torondel, Faculty of Infectious and Tropical Diseases, LSHTM, UK. 5. Dr Suzanna C Francis, MRC International Statistics and Epidemiology Group, LSHTM, UK 6. Dr Clare Tanton, Faculty of Public Health and Policy, LSHTM, UK. 7. Dr Giulia Greco, Faculty of Public Health and Policy, LSHTM, UK. 8. Ms Sophie Belfield Research and Innovations Project Manager, WoMena Uganda, Email: sophie.belfield@womena.dk 9. Ms Shamirah Nakalema, Head of Programs, WoMena Uganda 10. Dr Fred Matovu, Makerere University, Uganda 11. Dr Andrew Sentoogo Ssemata, MRC/UVRI and LSHTM Uganda Research Unit, Plot 51-59 Nakiwogo Road Entebbe, Uganda, 12. Ms Connie Alezuyo, Coordinator, Education Response Plan Secretariat, Ministry of Education and Sports, Uganda 13. Dr Stella Neema, Makerere University, Uganda 14. Prof John Jerrim, UCL Institute of Education, University College London, UK 15. Prof Chris Bonell, Faculty of Public Health and Policy, LSHTM, UK. 16. Prof Janet Seeley, Faculty of Public Health and Policy, LSHTM, UK and MRC/UVRI and LSHTM Uganda Research Unit 17. Prof Helen A Weiss, MRC International Statistics and Epidemiology Group, LSHTM, UK On behalf of the MENISCUS Trial Group |
| Name and contact information for the trial sponsor {5b} | Research Governance and Integrity Office London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine Keppel Street London WC1E 7HT Tel: +44 207 927 2626 Email: rgio@lshtm.ac.uk |
| Role of sponsor {5c} | The sponsor and funder have no role nor authority in the study process or dissemination of the project |