Bingkuan Xu1, Jing Chen1, Yinghui Liu1. 1. Jiangsu Key Laboratory for Molecular and Medical Biotechnology, College of Life Sciences, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing 210023, China.
Abstract
The amyloid aggregation of α-synuclein (α-Syn) is highly associated with Parkinson's disease (PD). Discovering α-Syn amyloid inhibitors is one of the strategies for PD therapies. Recent studies suggested that α-Syn undergoes phase separation to accelerate amyloid aggregation. Molecules modulating α-Syn phase separation or transition have the potential to regulate amyloid aggregation. Here, we discovered that curcumin, a small natural molecule, interacts with α-Syn during phase separation. Our study showed that curcumin neither affects the formation of α-Syn condensates nor influences the initial morphology of α-Syn condensates. However, curcumin decreases the fluidity of α-Syn inside the condensates and efficiently inhibits α-Syn from turning into an amyloid. It also inhibits the amyloid aggregations of PD disease-related α-Syn E46K and H50Q mutants under phase separation. Furthermore, curcumin can destabilize preformed α-Syn amyloid aggregates in the condensates. Together, our findings demonstrate that curcumin regulates α-Syn amyloid formation during protein phase separation and reveal that α-Syn amyloid aggregation under phase separation can be modulated by small molecules.
The amyloid aggregation of α-synuclein (α-Syn) is highly associated with Parkinson's disease (PD). Discovering α-Syn amyloid inhibitors is one of the strategies for PD therapies. Recent studies suggested that α-Syn undergoes phase separation to accelerate amyloid aggregation. Molecules modulating α-Syn phase separation or transition have the potential to regulate amyloid aggregation. Here, we discovered that curcumin, a small natural molecule, interacts with α-Syn during phase separation. Our study showed that curcumin neither affects the formation of α-Syn condensates nor influences the initial morphology of α-Syn condensates. However, curcumin decreases the fluidity of α-Syn inside the condensates and efficiently inhibits α-Syn from turning into an amyloid. It also inhibits the amyloid aggregations of PD disease-related α-Syn E46K and H50Q mutants under phase separation. Furthermore, curcumin can destabilize preformed α-Syn amyloid aggregates in the condensates. Together, our findings demonstrate that curcumin regulates α-Syn amyloid formation during protein phase separation and reveal that α-Syn amyloid aggregation under phase separation can be modulated by small molecules.
The deposition of Lewy bodies and Lewy
neurites in the cytoplasm
of neurons is a key pathological hallmark of Parkinson’s disease
(PD).[1,2] α-Synuclein (α-Syn), a small
soluble protein mainly localized at the presynaptic nerve terminal,
is the major component of Lewy bodies and Lewy neurites.[3−6] α-Syn is composed of 140 amino acids which are divided into
three domains, including the amphipathic N-terminal domain (residues
1–60), a highly hydrophobic NAC domain (residues 60–95),
and a proline-rich C-terminal region (residues 95–140).[7,8] It has been accepted that α-Syn is involved in PD pathology
by forming toxic amyloid aggregates, although its physiological function
has not been fully understood.[9]Depending
on the local environment, the monomeric α-Syn is
either disordered or in physiological α-helical conformation.[10−14] α-Syn forms oligomers through intermolecular assemblies and
further accumulates to mature amyloid fibrils, which is considered
the pathogenic mechanism in PD.[15−17] Previous studies suggested that
the hydrophobic NAC domain is the core domain for α-Syn aggregation.[18,19] Recent SSNMR and Cryo-EM studies showed two kinds of polymorphs
in α-Syn fibrils: rod and twister polymorphs. The core of rod
polymorph fibrils is composed of residues 37–99, while the
core of twister polymorph fibrils is composed of residues 43–83.[20,21] Another recent study suggested that α-Syn segment 44–47
is required for the amyloid fibril elongation.[22] Hence, in addition to the NAC domain, residues 37–59
are also critical in forming amyloid aggregates. Furthermore, multiple
familial PD disease-related mutants of α-Syn have been identified,
including E46K and H50Q. Most of the α-Syn mutants accelerate
α-Syn fibrillar formation, confirming the central roles of α-Syn
in PD pathology.[23−25] Therefore, the amyloid aggregation has become a critical
target for PD therapy.[26−30]Proteins can condensate into liquid droplets through protein–protein
weak multivalent interactions, called liquid–liquid phase separation
(LLPS). The protein is highly concentrated in the phase-separated
droplets, dozens or hundreds of times higher than that in the dilute
phase. Under physiological conditions, the phase-separated droplets
are highly regulated and reversible.[31] However,
the formation of droplets may be disturbed in some pathological conditions
such as gene mutation, abnormal post-translational modification, or
cellular stress.[32] Many amyloid aggregation-prone
proteins, including α-Syn, undergo LLPS.[33−40] Recent studies suggested that α-Syn initiates the conformation
change and amyloid formation from LLPS.[36−42] The phase-separated α-Syn facilitates the liquid-to-solid
transition to form mature amyloid fibrils.[39]A number of small natural molecules, including polyphenols,
have
been discovered to inhibit the aggregation of amyloid proteins and
alleviate the cellular toxicity caused by amyloid proteins.[43−49] For example, the green tea polyphenol epigallocatechin-3-gallate
(EGCG) prevents the tau protein from forming toxic oligomers.[50] Another polyphenol resveratrol could convert
soluble oligomers and fibrils of amyloid Aβ into non-toxic aggregated
species.[51] Multiple polyphenols have been
discovered to inhibit α-Syn aggregation, including curcumin,
myricetin, EGCG, hydroxycinnamic acids, rosmarinic acid, and ferulic
acid.[47,52−59] Furthermore, some small natural polyphenols can destabilize the
preformed α-Syn aggregates in vitro.[47]Curcumin (1,7-bis(4-hydroxy-3-methoxyphenyl)-1,6,-heptadiene-3,5-dione)
is a non-flavonoid biphenolic compound extracted from the root of
the Curcuma longa plant. It has anti-inflammatory,
anticarcinogenic, and anti-oxidant abilities.[60] In addition, curcumin is able to slow down the progression of neurodegenerative
diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease, Huntington’s disease,
and PD.[61−63] In the past decades, the effects of curcumin on α-Syn
aggregation have been widely studied. Previous biochemical studies
found that curcumin efficiently blocked α-Syn aggregation in
vitro.[54,64] Several modified analogues of curcumin with
improved stability have also been proven effective in inhibiting α-Syn
amyloid aggregation and depolymerizing α-Syn fibrils.[65] Moreover, the combination of curcumin and β-cyclodextrin
could inhibit α-Syn aggregation and break up the preformed aggregates
almost completely at appreciably low concentrations.[66,67] Interestingly, other studies reported that curcumin may bind to
oligomers and fibrils that accelerate α-Syn fibrillation, producing
less-toxic α-Syn aggregates.[68,69] Cellular studies
showed that curcumin could reduce the toxicity of SH-SY5Y cells treated
with α-Syn oligomers.[70] It was reported
that curcumin could prevent HKI release and ROS enhancement triggered
by α-Syn fibrils in mitochondria.[71]In this work, we examined whether curcumin plays a role in
the
phase separation and amyloid formation during α-Syn LLPS. We
discovered that curcumin binds to α-Syn condensates directly
and reduces protein fluidity inside the condensates. However, it does
not affect the formation and initial morphology of α-Syn condensates.
While the phase-separated α-Syn gradually turned into an amyloid
with the extension of incubation time, curcumin efficiently inhibited
the formation of amyloid aggregates in a dose-dependent manner. Interestingly,
curcumin could also impede the amyloid aggregation of α-Syn
E46K and H50Q mutants during phase separation. Moreover, we found
that curcumin dose-dependently disassembles the preformed amyloid
aggregates in condensates. Altogether, our findings demonstrate that
curcumin can target α-Syn during phase separation and prevent
the phase transition of α-Syn to form amyloid aggregates.
Results
Curcumin Interacts with α-Syn Condensates but Does Not
Affect the Morphology
α-Syn undergoes LLPS in vitro
in the presence of a crowding agent, which mimics the cellular physiological
conditions.[39,40] We labeled α-Syn with the
fluorescence dye rhodamine (Rhod) and mixed it with the unlabeled
α-Syn at a molar ratio of 1:9. Using a confocal microscope,
we observed α-Syn formed liquid droplets in the presence of
20% PEG-10000 as we previously observed (Figure A).[40] To test
whether curcumin regulates α-Syn LLPS, we mixed curcumin with
α-Syn in the presence of PEG, and no noticeable morphology change
was observed (Figure A). We further analyzed the condensates by quantifying the size and
numbers. Curcumin affected neither the size nor the numbers of α-Syn
condensates (Figure S1).
Figure 1
Curcumin interacts with
α-Syn in the condensates. (A) Fluorescence
and differential interference contrast (DIC) images showing the formation
of Rhod-labeled α-Syn phase-separated condensates in the absence
or presence of 25 μM curcumin. The total α-Syn concentration
is 200 μM. Scale bar, 5 μm. (B) Fluorescence emission
spectra of curcumin with or without α-Syn. α-Syn formed
condensates in the presence of PEG. Curcumin fluorescence was increased
with a blue shift in the presence of α-Syn condensates. The
final concentrations of α-Syn and curcumin are 200 and 25 μM,
respectively.
Curcumin interacts with
α-Syn in the condensates. (A) Fluorescence
and differential interference contrast (DIC) images showing the formation
of Rhod-labeled α-Syn phase-separated condensates in the absence
or presence of 25 μM curcumin. The total α-Syn concentration
is 200 μM. Scale bar, 5 μm. (B) Fluorescence emission
spectra of curcumin with or without α-Syn. α-Syn formed
condensates in the presence of PEG. Curcumin fluorescence was increased
with a blue shift in the presence of α-Syn condensates. The
final concentrations of α-Syn and curcumin are 200 and 25 μM,
respectively.We performed fluorescence measurements to examine
whether curcumin
directly interacts with α-Syn condensates. Curcumin was excited
at 426 nm, and it showed a weak fluorescence at approximately 540
nm. When we mixed curcumin with α-Syn condensates, a dramatic
increase in fluorescence intensity with a blue shift to 510 nm was
observed (Figure B).
In contrast, α-Syn, mostly in monomers, does not induce noticeable
fluorescence change in the solution without PEG (Figure B). These data suggested that
curcumin efficiently interacts with the hydrophobic regions of the
α-Syn protein in the condensates.[68] However, whether curcumin directs α-Syn in monomers or oligomers
needs to be further examined.
Curcumin Reduces α-Syn Protein Fluidity inside the Condensates
We then examined how curcumin affects the formation of α-Syn
condensates. We employed sedimentation and turbidity assays to quantify
the phase-separated α-Syn protein.[72,73] In a sedimentation-based assay, the fraction of phase-separated
α-Syn, indicated by protein recovered from the condensed phase
in pellets, was not affected by curcumin (Figure A). Protein phase separation leads to the
increase in turbidity, which can be monitored by measuring the absorbance
at 600 nm.[72] We found that α-Syn
liquid droplets caused high turbidity in the presence of PEG and curcumin
has less effect, confirming that the total amounts of phase-separated
α-Syn were not affected. (Figure B).[40,72] These studies demonstrated that
curcumin affects neither the initial morphology of α-Syn condensates
nor the total amounts of phase-separated α-Syn.
Figure 2
Curcumin decreases the
fluidity of the α-Syn protein inside
the condensates. (A) Sedimentation-based assays showing the distributions
of α-Syn in the supernatant (S) and pellet (P) in the absence
or presence of curcumin. (B) Turbidity assays showing the effect of
curcumin on the formation of phase-separated α-Syn. Turbidity
was evaluated by monitoring the absorbance at 600 nm. Data are presented
as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates). P values were calculated using Student’s t test. n.s., P > 0.05. (C) Representative
FRAP images of α-Syn condensates in the absence (top) or presence
(bottom) of curcumin. The fluorescence images of prebleached, bleached
(0 s), and bleached after 120 s recovery are shown. Scale bar, 2 μm.
(D) The normalized FRAP curves of α-Syn condensates in the absence
(black) or presence (red) of curcumin shown in (C). Data are presented
as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates).
The concentrations of α-Syn and curcumin are 200 and 25 μM,
respectively. All the experiments were carried out in the presence
of 20% PEG-10,000.
Curcumin decreases the
fluidity of the α-Syn protein inside
the condensates. (A) Sedimentation-based assays showing the distributions
of α-Syn in the supernatant (S) and pellet (P) in the absence
or presence of curcumin. (B) Turbidity assays showing the effect of
curcumin on the formation of phase-separated α-Syn. Turbidity
was evaluated by monitoring the absorbance at 600 nm. Data are presented
as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates). P values were calculated using Student’s t test. n.s., P > 0.05. (C) Representative
FRAP images of α-Syn condensates in the absence (top) or presence
(bottom) of curcumin. The fluorescence images of prebleached, bleached
(0 s), and bleached after 120 s recovery are shown. Scale bar, 2 μm.
(D) The normalized FRAP curves of α-Syn condensates in the absence
(black) or presence (red) of curcumin shown in (C). Data are presented
as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates).
The concentrations of α-Syn and curcumin are 200 and 25 μM,
respectively. All the experiments were carried out in the presence
of 20% PEG-10,000.The protein inside the liquid droplets has high
fluidity, which
can be measured by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP)
experiments.[40] In our conditions, the fluorescence
intensity of α-Syn droplets could fully reach the prebleaching
state at 120 s after fluorescence bleaching, confirming the phase
state of liquid droplets (Figure C,D). Unexpectedly, an apparent decrease in FRAP was
observed in the α-Syn condensates with curcumin, primarily caused
by α-Syn–curcumin interactions (Figure C,D). Our data suggested that curcumin interacts
with α-Syn and hinders the protein fluidity inside the condensates,
although it does not influence the initial formation of α-Syn
condensates.
Curcumin Inhibits the Amyloid Formation of Phase-Separated α-Syn
Protein phase separation can promote α-Syn amyloid aggregation
by facilitating the rate-limiting protein nucleation. Next, we studied
how curcumin regulates α-Syn amyloid aggregation through phase
separation. We used Thioflavin T (ThT), an amyloid-specific dye, to
monitor α-Syn amyloid formation during phase separation.[74] While curcumin slightly affected ThT fluorescence
in the absence of α-Syn, the wholly matured α-Syn fibrils
dramatically increased the ThT fluorescence intensity, which was decreased
by adding the compound (Figure S2). A time-dependent
increase in ThT fluorescence was observed after the incubation of
α-Syn condensates at 37 °C, indicating that α-Syn
gradually turned into an amyloid in the condensates (Figure A). We did not observe the
apparent lag phase in the ThT fluorescence experiments during incubation.
We speculate that LLPS gives an extremely high protein concentration
of α-Syn in the condensates, leading to rapid protein self-assembly
and a high aggregation rate. Interestingly, curcumin reduced the ThT
fluorescence in a concentration-dependent manner (Figure A). Furthermore, it slightly
decreased the initial aggregation rates of α-Syn. The corresponding
time-dependent fluorescence images showed that curcumin had less effect
on the morphology of α-Syn condensates (Figure S3). Based on the ThT fluorescence intensity of the
wholly matured α-Syn fibrils, we estimated that nearly 50% of
α-Syn formed complete fibrillization in the condensates after
incubation at 48 h. The uncomplete fibrillization of α-Syn in
the reactions may be due to the incubation conditions without shaking.
The solidified α-Syn condensates could not further recruit free
α-Syn monomers in the solution.
Figure 3
Curcumin inhibits α-Syn amyloid
aggregation in the condensates.
(A) Kinetics of α-Syn amyloid aggregation in the absence (black)
or presence of the indicated molar ratio of curcumin. The enhanced
ThT fluorescence indicates the formation of α-Syn amyloid aggregates
at 485 nm. Data were normalized with the ThT fluorescence intensity
of completed matured fibrils and presented as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates). The total α-Syn concentration
is 200 μM. Curcumin concentrations are 10 μM (red), 25
μM (blue), and 50 μM (green), respectively. (B) Transmission
electron micrographs showing the fibrillar formation of α-Syn
condensates in the absence or presence of 50 μM curcumin after
incubation at 37 °C for 48 h. The α-Syn concentration is
200 μM. All the experiments were carried out in the presence
of 20% PEG-10,000.
Curcumin inhibits α-Syn amyloid
aggregation in the condensates.
(A) Kinetics of α-Syn amyloid aggregation in the absence (black)
or presence of the indicated molar ratio of curcumin. The enhanced
ThT fluorescence indicates the formation of α-Syn amyloid aggregates
at 485 nm. Data were normalized with the ThT fluorescence intensity
of completed matured fibrils and presented as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates). The total α-Syn concentration
is 200 μM. Curcumin concentrations are 10 μM (red), 25
μM (blue), and 50 μM (green), respectively. (B) Transmission
electron micrographs showing the fibrillar formation of α-Syn
condensates in the absence or presence of 50 μM curcumin after
incubation at 37 °C for 48 h. The α-Syn concentration is
200 μM. All the experiments were carried out in the presence
of 20% PEG-10,000.Then, we used transmission electron microscopy
(TEM) to observe
the detailed morphology of α-Syn condensates. We found that
α-Syn formed amyloid fibrils matured from the condensates after
48 h incubation (Figure B). However, the fibrils were largely reduced by curcumin, demonstrating
that curcumin blocks α-Syn amyloid aggregation in the condensates
(Figure B). Interestingly,
FRAP experiments showed that the fluorescence intensity of α-Syn
condensates could not be recovered after 48 h incubation, confirming
that α-Syn aggregated into a solid-like state after incubation
(Figure A–C).
An increased FRAP was observed with α-Syn condensates in the
presence of curcumin, indicating that the α-Syn/curcumin condensates
are partially solid (Figure A–C). However, we were not able to verify the formation
of amyloid aggregation by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy (Chapter S1). Therefore, the exact secondary structure
of the α-Syn condensates in the presence of curcumin needs to
be further studied.
Figure 4
The morphology of α-Syn condensates is not altered
by curcumin
after incubation. (A) Fluorescence and DIC images showing the morphology
of α-Syn condensates in the absence or presence of 25 μM
curcumin after incubation at 37 °C for 48 h. Scale bar, 5 μm.
(B) Representative FRAP images of α-Syn condensates in the absence
(top) or presence (bottom) of curcumin after incubation for 48 h.
The fluorescence images of prebleached, bleached (0 s), and bleached
after 120 s recovery are shown. Scale bar, 2 μm. (C) The normalized
FRAP curves of α-Syn condensates in the absence (black) or presence
(red) of curcumin shown in (B). Data are presented as mean ±
SD (n = 3 independent replicates). The total α-Syn
concentration is 200 μM. All the experiments were carried out
in the presence of 20% PEG-10,000.
The morphology of α-Syn condensates is not altered
by curcumin
after incubation. (A) Fluorescence and DIC images showing the morphology
of α-Syn condensates in the absence or presence of 25 μM
curcumin after incubation at 37 °C for 48 h. Scale bar, 5 μm.
(B) Representative FRAP images of α-Syn condensates in the absence
(top) or presence (bottom) of curcumin after incubation for 48 h.
The fluorescence images of prebleached, bleached (0 s), and bleached
after 120 s recovery are shown. Scale bar, 2 μm. (C) The normalized
FRAP curves of α-Syn condensates in the absence (black) or presence
(red) of curcumin shown in (B). Data are presented as mean ±
SD (n = 3 independent replicates). The total α-Syn
concentration is 200 μM. All the experiments were carried out
in the presence of 20% PEG-10,000.
Amyloid Aggregations of α-Syn E46K and H50Q Mutant Condensates
Were Inhibited by Curcumin
Multiple familial PD disease-related
mutants have been identified. Most of the mutations accelerate the
amyloid aggregation and increase cytotoxicity, supporting the importance
of α-Syn aggregation in PD pathogenesis. A recent study suggested
that E46K, A53T, or phosphomimetic S129E mutation could promote α-Syn
LLPS, accelerating amyloid aggregation of α-Syn in condensates.[39] We chose the E46K mutant, which underwent LLPS
dramatically in the previous study, to examine curcumin’s effect.
Moreover, we tested a new mutant H50Q which has not been examined
in the phase separation. Confocal microscopy studies showed that α-Syn
E46K and H50Q mutants underwent LLPS, and curcumin did not change
the morphology of the condensates (Figure A,B). We then examined if curcumin inhibits
the aggregation of E46K and H50Q mutants during phase separation.
As shown in Figure C,D, α-Syn E46K and H50Q mutants form α-Syn amyloid aggregation
in the condensates. Curcumin inhibited the amyloid aggregation of
E46K and H50Q mutants efficiently (Figure C,D). Together, these data suggested that
curcumin could block both wide-type and PD disease-related α-Syn
aggregation during α-Syn phase transition.
Figure 5
Curcumin inhibits the
amyloid aggregation of α-Syn E46K and
H50Q mutants in the condensates. Fluorescence and DIC images showing
the formation of Rhod-labeled α-Syn E46K (A) and H50Q (B) phase-separated
condensates in the absence or presence of curcumin. The kinetics of
amyloid aggregation for α-Syn E46K (C) and H50Q (D) mutants
in the absence (black) or presence of curcumin (red) were indicated
by the enhanced ThT fluorescence. Data were normalized with the ThT
fluorescence intensity of completed matured fibrils and presented
as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates).
The concentrations of α-Syn and curcumin are 200 and 25 μM,
respectively. All the experiments were carried out in the presence
of 20% PEG-10,000.
Curcumin inhibits the
amyloid aggregation of α-Syn E46K and
H50Q mutants in the condensates. Fluorescence and DIC images showing
the formation of Rhod-labeled α-Syn E46K (A) and H50Q (B) phase-separated
condensates in the absence or presence of curcumin. The kinetics of
amyloid aggregation for α-Syn E46K (C) and H50Q (D) mutants
in the absence (black) or presence of curcumin (red) were indicated
by the enhanced ThT fluorescence. Data were normalized with the ThT
fluorescence intensity of completed matured fibrils and presented
as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent replicates).
The concentrations of α-Syn and curcumin are 200 and 25 μM,
respectively. All the experiments were carried out in the presence
of 20% PEG-10,000.
Curcumin Destabilizes the Amyloid Aggregates Matured from α-Syn
Phase Separation
Then we tested whether curcumin could disassemble
preformed α-Syn amyloid aggregates in the condensates. We prepared
the phase-separated α-Syn aggregates by continuously incubating
α-Syn condensates at 37 °C. Curcumin was then added to
these preformed α-Syn aggregates in a different concentration.
We found that curcumin reduced the ThT fluorescence intensity of α-Syn
aggregates in a dose-dependent manner (Figure A). TEM images showed that the number of
visible fibrils decreased in the presence of curcumin. However, it
does not allow precisely quantifying the amount of the aggregated
protein in the whole sample (Figure B). Curcumin is active at concentrations lower than
one molecule per α-Syn molecule. Therefore, it is unlikely that
the fibrils were dissociated into monomers. Due to the lack of curcumin-α-Syn
structural information, the mechanism of aggregation destabilization
by curcumin also needs further investigation. Together, our findings
reveal that curcumin not only inhibits the formation of α-Syn
amyloid aggregates but also disassembles the preformed amyloid aggregates
during the phase separation process.
Figure 6
Curcumin destabilizes the preformed α-Syn
amyloid aggregates
matured from phase transition. (A) The preformed α-Syn amyloid
aggregates (200 μM) were mixed with 10, 25, and 50 μM
curcumin, respectively. ThT fluorescence was measured to indicate
the destabilization of α-Syn amyloid aggregates by curcumin.
Data are presented as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent
replicates). P values were calculated using Student’s t test. **P < 0.01. ***P < 0.001. ****P < 0.0001. The preformed α-Syn
amyloid aggregates were prepared by incubation of α-Syn condensates
at 37 °C for 48 h. (B) Transmission electron micrographs showing
the preformed α-Syn amyloid aggregates (200 μM) were reduced
after incubation with 50 μM curcumin for 12 h. All the experiments
were carried out in the presence of 20% PEG-10,000.
Curcumin destabilizes the preformed α-Syn
amyloid aggregates
matured from phase transition. (A) The preformed α-Syn amyloid
aggregates (200 μM) were mixed with 10, 25, and 50 μM
curcumin, respectively. ThT fluorescence was measured to indicate
the destabilization of α-Syn amyloid aggregates by curcumin.
Data are presented as mean ± SD (n = 3 independent
replicates). P values were calculated using Student’s t test. **P < 0.01. ***P < 0.001. ****P < 0.0001. The preformed α-Syn
amyloid aggregates were prepared by incubation of α-Syn condensates
at 37 °C for 48 h. (B) Transmission electron micrographs showing
the preformed α-Syn amyloid aggregates (200 μM) were reduced
after incubation with 50 μM curcumin for 12 h. All the experiments
were carried out in the presence of 20% PEG-10,000.
Discussion
The aggregation of α-Syn is a critical
target for PD treatment.
In the past decades, many efforts have been performed on the screen
or rational design of reagents targeting α-Syn aggregations.[28,29,75] Multiple studies demonstrated
that α-Syn aggregation was accelerated by protein phase separation,
making phase-separated α-Syn a new drug target for PD treatment.[39] Recent studies reported that small molecules
could modulate protein LLPS by promoting or preventing the formation
of liquid droplets.[76,77] It is a promising strategy to
target α-Syn aggregation by interruption of phase separation
or transition, both of which affect α-Syn turning into an amyloid.Multiple recent studies suggested that α-Syn might take two
pathways to form amyloid aggregates.[38,39] In the traditional
deposition pathway, α-Syn forms oligomers and grows into matured
fibrils. In the condensation pathway, α-Syn undergoes LLPS,
facilitating the amyloid aggregation in the condensates. Some studies
showed that curcumin inhibits α-Syn fibrillization and destabilizes
preformed aggregates in solution.[54,64−67,71] However, other reports suggested
that curcumin binds to oligomers and fibrils that accelerate α-Syn
fibrillation to produce morphologically different amyloid fibrils.[68,69] The observation of distinct roles might be due to the different
experimental conditions, such as the protein purification method and
the pH conditions.[69] Molecules bound to
α-Syn may regulate its phase separation or transition.[39] For example, we recently reported that Mn2+ induces α-Syn to form irregular solid-like condensates.[40] Curcumin is a vital lead compound that regulates
α-Syn amyloid aggregation in the deposition pathway and releases
cellular toxicity. However, how curcumin regulates α-Syn amyloid
aggregation in the condensation pathway remains unknown. Here, we
studied the roles of curcumin on α-Syn amyloid aggregation under
LLPS conditions. Interestingly, our findings demonstrate that curcumin
inhibits α-Syn amyloid aggregation and destabilizes the preformed
aggregates in the condensates (Figure ).[54,64−67,71]
Figure 7
Schematic
illustration showing that curcumin inhibits α-synuclein
amyloid aggregation under phase separation.
Schematic
illustration showing that curcumin inhibits α-synuclein
amyloid aggregation under phase separation.Different from the recent studies showing that
small molecules
modulate liquid droplet formation, curcumin has less effect on the
initial morphology and total amounts of α-Syn condensates.[76,77] However, curcumin interacts with α-Syn condensates directly
and decreases the molecular diffusion of the α-Syn protein inside
the condensates, as indicated by fluorescence and FRAP experiments.
Previous studies suggested that curcumin binds to the hydrophobic
surfaces of α-Syn oligomers and fibrils.[68] The concentrated α-Syn forms liquid droplets with
the requirement of the central hydrophobic region, which might be
more exposed during LLPS.[39] Our study indicated
that phase separation facilitates the hydrophobic interactions between
curcumin and α-Syn, hindering protein diffusion. Since the hydrophobic
region is the primary domain for α-Syn intermolecular assembly,
the curcumin−α-Syn interactions could further inhibit
α-Syn amyloid aggregation in the condensates.[78] It should be noted that the condensates are apparently
different from the oligomers. α-Syn oligomers are solidified
substances, but the condensates are typical spherical droplets with
liquid properties, although they are both formed by the intermolecular
assembly. Furthermore, the size of the prepared α-Syn oligomers
is usually at the level of nanometers, but the diameters of condensates
can reach micrometers. Indeed, recent studies reported that α-Syn
could further form oligomers and fibrils in the condensates by a liquid-to-solid
transition.[38,39] Interestingly, we discovered
that curcumin also inhibited the amyloid aggregations of two PD disease-related
E46K and H50Q mutants in the condensates. Besides the inhibition of
amyloid aggregation, curcumin can destabilize the preformed amyloid
aggregates matured in the condensates, confirming our conclusion that
curcumin interacts with α-Syn through the hydrophobic interaction.Together, we discovered that curcumin interacts with α-Syn
in the condensates during phase separation. Curcumin disturbs the
α-Syn protein fluidity in the condensates and inhibits the α-Syn
protein from turning into an amyloid, although it has less effect
on the initial formation of α-Syn condensates. These findings
demonstrate that curcumin efficiently inhibits α-Syn amyloid
aggregation and destabilizes preformed amyloid aggregation during
phase separation. Our study reveals that α-Syn amyloid aggregation
under the condition of phase separation can be targeted by small molecules
like curcumin.
Materials and Methods
Protein Expression and Purification
Recombinant α-synuclein
(α-Syn) was expressed in E. coli as previously described.[40,79−82] Briefly, the cDNA encoded human α-Syn gene was cloned into
a pETSUMO vector. The recombinant plasmid was transformed into a BL21
(DE3) Competent Cell. The protein expression was induced by adding
1 mM isopropyl β-d-galactopyranoside (IPTG) when the
OD of bacteria reached 0.6–0.8. The culture continued to grow
for 2 h at 37 °C, and the pellets were collected by centrifugation.
After lysis, the His6-SUMO-α-Syn fusion protein was purified
by nickel affinity chromatography. The extra His6 tags were removed
by digestion with SUMO protease. The purified untagged protein was
subsequently dialyzed overnight against a protein storage buffer (25
mM Tris–HCl [pH 7.4], 50 mM NaCl).[40]
Preparation of Curcumin Stock Solution
The stock solution
(10 mM) of curcumin was prepared in DMSO. For each experiment, curcumin
was diluted by protein storage buffer to the required concentration.
Chemical Labeling
The α-Syn protein was labeled
by a Rhod labeling kit following the manufacturer’s instructions
(ThermoFisher Scientific, USA) as we previously described. The protein
was dialyzed against a labeling buffer (50 mM sodium borate, pH 8.5)
and then mixed with 15-fold molar excess of fluorescence dye. After
incubation at room temperature for 1 h, the free dye in the solution
was removed by overnight dialysis against the protein storage buffer.[40]
Confocal Imaging of α-Syn Condensates
The α-Syn
condensates were prepared in the presence of PEG-10,000. Unlabeled
and Rhod-labeled α-Syn were mixed at a molar ratio of 9:1. The
α-Syn mixture was incubated with or without curcumin in the
presence of 20% PEG-10,000 (w/v) to form condensates. The α-Syn
condensates were visualized with a 100× oil immersion objective
under a Nikon A1 microscope (Nikon Corporation, Japan).[40]
Fluorescence Measurement
The fluorescence measurements
were carried out on BioTek Synergy HT microplate reader. The curcumin
fluorescence was monitored with an excitation wavelength of 426 nm
and an emission wavelength of 450–650 nm.
FRAP Analysis
The FRAP analysis was carried out as
we previously described.[40] The Rhod-labeled
α-Syn condensates were loaded onto a glass slide. The sample
was then covered with a coverslip, sealed, and dried with nitrogen.
FRAP experiments were performed using a Nikon A1 microscope, and the
measurements involved 2 prebleaching frames, 1 flash of bleaching
(100% of laser power), and 12 postbleaching frames. Fluorescence photobleaching
and recovery were conducted using a 561 nm laser. Data were normalized
to the maximal prebleach and minimal postbleach fluorescence intensities.
Sedimentation-Based Assay
Sedimentation and electrophoresis
assays were performed as we previously described.[40] The 50 μL samples of α-Syn condensates were
separated from free protein by centrifugation at 16,000g for 10 min. The supernatant and pellet were collected individually,
and the pellet was washed and resuspended with 50 μL of the
same buffer. The same volume of samples from the supernatant and pellet
was analyzed by SDS-PAGE.
Turbidity Assay
In the turbidity assay, the samples
were added to a transparent 96-well plate. The absorbance at 600 nm
was measured using a BioTek Synergy HT microplate reader.[80] Full accounting of statistical significance
was included for each data based on at least three independent experiments.
ThT Fluorescence
The amyloid aggregation of α-Syn
was indicated by ThT fluorescence intensity. The ThT fluorescence
assay was carried out as we previously described.[40,74] 200 μM WT α-Syn and the indicated concentrations of
curcumin were incubated at 37 °C for 48 h without shaking. The
samples were diluted by 40-fold, and the final concentration of ThT
is 40 μM. Fluorescence was measured every 12 h on a BioTek Synergy
HT microplate reader with an excitation wavelength of 440 nm and an
emission wavelength of 485 nm. In the control experiment, the wholly
matured α-Syn fibrils were prepared by shaking the α-Syn
protein (200 μM) at 37 °C for 7 days without PEG. Curcumin
and α-Syn fibrils were diluted to equal concentrations as we
used in the kinetic assays. The ThT fluorescence was monitored with
excitation at 440 nm and an emission range of 468–600 nm using
a BioTek Synergy HT microplate reader.We prepared the preformed
amyloid aggregates by incubating the phase-separated α-Syn at
37 °C for 48 h for the destabilization of preformed aggregates.
The α-Syn amyloid aggregates were incubated with the indicated
concentration of curcumin. The ThT fluorescence was measured on a
BioTek Synergy HT microplate reader after incubation at 37 °C.
Data are presented as the percentage of the fluorescence change without
curcumin.
Transmission Electronic Microscopy
α-Syn condensate
samples were prepared in the absence or presence of curcumin with
incubation at 37 °C for 48 h. The samples were loaded onto the
carbon-coated copper grids for 1 min and subsequently stained with
2% uranyl acetate for 1 min. The TEM images were obtained on an H-7650
TEM (HITACHI) at an acceleration voltage of 80 kV.[40]
Authors: Bruno Fauvet; Martial K Mbefo; Mohamed-Bilal Fares; Carole Desobry; Sarah Michael; Mustafa T Ardah; Elpida Tsika; Philippe Coune; Michel Prudent; Niels Lion; David Eliezer; Darren J Moore; Bernard Schneider; Patrick Aebischer; Omar M El-Agnaf; Eliezer Masliah; Hilal A Lashuel Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2012-02-07 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Beate Winner; Roberto Jappelli; Samir K Maji; Paula A Desplats; Leah Boyer; Stefan Aigner; Claudia Hetzer; Thomas Loher; Marçal Vilar; Silvia Campioni; Christos Tzitzilonis; Alice Soragni; Sebastian Jessberger; Helena Mira; Antonella Consiglio; Emiley Pham; Eliezer Masliah; Fred H Gage; Roland Riek Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2011-02-15 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Ali Reza A Ladiwala; Jason C Lin; Shyam Sundhar Bale; Anna Marie Marcelino-Cruz; Moumita Bhattacharya; Jonathan S Dordick; Peter M Tessier Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2010-05-28 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Pilong Li; Sudeep Banjade; Hui-Chun Cheng; Soyeon Kim; Baoyu Chen; Liang Guo; Marc Llaguno; Javoris V Hollingsworth; David S King; Salman F Banani; Paul S Russo; Qiu-Xing Jiang; B Tracy Nixon; Michael K Rosen Journal: Nature Date: 2012-03-07 Impact factor: 49.962