Danhua Xie1, Yulong Jiang1, Kangling Li1, Xinyue Yang1, Yunjin Zhang1. 1. Fujian Provincial Key Laboratory of Featured Biochemical and Chemical Materials, College of Chemistry and Materials, Ningde Normal University, Ningde, Fujian 352100, China.
Abstract
The morphology of nanoparticles plays a significant role in the properties and applications of Pickering emulsions. Oil-in-water (O/W) Pickering emulsions were prepared using spherical, rod-like, and thread-like mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNPs) in combination with the cationic surfactant dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide (DTAB) as a stabilizer. The effects of nanoparticle morphology on the stability and stimuli-responsive properties of Pickering emulsions were investigated. For spherical and rod-like MSNP systems, stable Pickering emulsions were obtained at DTAB concentrations above 0.2 mmol·L-1. Stable Pickering emulsions containing thread-like MSNPs were produced at lower DTAB concentrations of approximately 0.1 mmol·L-1. The droplets with thread-like MSNPs were extremely large with an average diameter around 700 μm at DTAB concentrations of 0.1-0.3 mmol·L-1, which were approximately 20 times larger than those of conventional droplets. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images showed that all three types of MSNPs were located at the O/W interfaces. Irrespective of the morphology of the MSNPs, all the stable Pickering emulsions retained their original appearance for more than 6 months. By adding NaOH and HCl alternatively, the Pickering emulsions containing spherical and rod-like MSNPs could be switched between unstable and stable states more than 60 times. The Pickering emulsions containing thread-like MSNPs, by contrast, could have their droplet size switched between large and small more than 10 times without any obvious phase separation. The high anisotropy of thread-like MSNPs contributed to the low interface curvature of the droplets. This study revealed the relationship between the morphology of MSNPs and the characteristics of Pickering emulsions. These results enrich our knowledge about the formulation of Pickering emulsions and expand their applications.
The morphology of nanoparticles plays a significant role in the properties and applications of Pickering emulsions. Oil-in-water (O/W) Pickering emulsions were prepared using spherical, rod-like, and thread-like mesoporous silica nanoparticles (MSNPs) in combination with the cationic surfactant dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide (DTAB) as a stabilizer. The effects of nanoparticle morphology on the stability and stimuli-responsive properties of Pickering emulsions were investigated. For spherical and rod-like MSNP systems, stable Pickering emulsions were obtained at DTAB concentrations above 0.2 mmol·L-1. Stable Pickering emulsions containing thread-like MSNPs were produced at lower DTAB concentrations of approximately 0.1 mmol·L-1. The droplets with thread-like MSNPs were extremely large with an average diameter around 700 μm at DTAB concentrations of 0.1-0.3 mmol·L-1, which were approximately 20 times larger than those of conventional droplets. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images showed that all three types of MSNPs were located at the O/W interfaces. Irrespective of the morphology of the MSNPs, all the stable Pickering emulsions retained their original appearance for more than 6 months. By adding NaOH and HCl alternatively, the Pickering emulsions containing spherical and rod-like MSNPs could be switched between unstable and stable states more than 60 times. The Pickering emulsions containing thread-like MSNPs, by contrast, could have their droplet size switched between large and small more than 10 times without any obvious phase separation. The high anisotropy of thread-like MSNPs contributed to the low interface curvature of the droplets. This study revealed the relationship between the morphology of MSNPs and the characteristics of Pickering emulsions. These results enrich our knowledge about the formulation of Pickering emulsions and expand their applications.
An emulsion is a thermodynamically
unstable system consisting of
two immiscible liquids, one of which is dispersed in the other. Besides
surfactants, amphiphilic solid nanoparticles can also be adsorbed
at liquid–liquid interfaces to lower the interfacial surface
energy and prevent the coalescence of emulsion droplets. Emulsions
stabilized by nanoparticles are known as Pickering emulsions.[1] These emulsions are widely used in many fields
including food science, biomedicine, and catalysis and in the manufacture
of cosmetics and functional materials.[2−9] Compared with traditional emulsions stabilized by surfactants or
polymers, Pickering emulsions possess various advantages, such as
increased stability, lower toxicity, and additional characteristics
derived from the properties of the particles themselves.[1,4,10,11]The morphological properties of nanoparticles, such as size,
shape,
anisotropy, surface roughness, and specific surface area, play a critical
role in the properties and behavior of Pickering emulsions.[4,12−17] Binks compared the average droplet diameters of oil-in-water (O/W)
emulsions stabilized by hydrophilic silica nanoparticles.[18] With increasing nanoparticle size, the droplet
diameters also increased. The droplets also evolved from being spherically
shaped to being nonspherical. O/W Pickering emulsions stabilized by
cylindrical polystyrene nanoparticles were stable for up to 1 year
over a wide pH range. In contrast, obvious coalescence occurred after
several days in Pickering emulsions prepared using spherical polystyrene
nanoparticles.[19] Anisotropic (rod-shaped
or disc-like) nanoparticles had a higher detachment energy than that
of spherical nanoparticles, indicating that the former can be adsorbed
at liquid interfaces more strongly.[20,21] Huang et al.
investigated O/W Pickering emulsions stabilized by silica microrods
with various aspect ratios (ARs) from 1 to 16.[22] The results showed that the properties of Pickering emulsions
were highly dependent on the ARs of the nanoparticles. The larger
the AR, the more stable the emulsion. The enhanced stability was the
result of a higher steric hindrance, greater interfacial adsorption
energy, and stronger capillary forces. Bose and co-workers reported
O/W Pickering emulsions stabilized by fractal fumed silica nanoparticles
and spherical silica nanoparticles with similar hydrodynamic sizes.[23] Emulsions stabilized by fumed silica were more
stable than those stabilized by spherical silica. The improved stability
was due to the closely packed multiple layers of fractal fumed silica
nanoparticles at the O/W interfaces and a network structure formed
between the emulsion droplets. These kinds of network and bridge structures
were also reported in Pickering emulsions stabilized by cellulose
nanorods or nanofibers, which always enhanced the viscosity of emulsions
and restricted droplet coalescence.[24−28] The morphology of nanoparticles affects their adsorption
energy, their manners of packing at the O/W interface, and the interparticle
interactions and viscosities of emulsions, all of which can give rise
to varied behaviors and applications.Inorganic mesoporous nanoparticles
have been widely applied in
catalysis,[29] energy storage,[30,31] medicine,[32,33] absorption, and separation[34] due to their high specific surface areas, large
pore volume, tunable morphologies, and higher reactivities of their
functional groups on their inner pore surfaces. In our previous work,
Pickering emulsions stabilized by spherical mesoporous silica nanoparticles
and the pH-insensitive cationic surfactant cetyltrimethylammonium
bromide (CTAB) showed novel responsiveness to the addition of bases
and acids.[14] The rich pore structure of
MSNPs plays a critical role in their novel stimuli-response behavior.
However, the effects of MSNP morphology are still unclear. In this
study, therefore, mesoporous silica nanoparticles of different shapes
(spherical, rod-like, thread-like) were synthesized and used as emulsion
stabilizers, together with a conventional cationic surfactant, dodecyltrimethylammonium
bromide (DTAB). The effects of the morphology of the mesoporous nanoparticle
on the stability and stimuli-responsive properties of Pickering emulsions
were then investigated. The results were expected to enrich the knowledge
of Pickering emulsions stabilized by mesoporous nanoparticles and
their application.
Experimental Section
Materials
Dodecyltrimethylammonium
bromide (DTAB, ≥99.0%), was purchased from Aladdin Bio-Chem
Technology Co. (Shanghai, China). Tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS,
AR), cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB, ≥99.0%), aqueous
ammonia (NH3·H2O, AR, 25–28%), ethanol
(AR), n-octane (≥98.0%), hydrochloric acid
(HCl, 36–38% in water), sodium hydroxide (NaOH, 99%), styrene
(AR), and 2,2′-azobis(2-methylpropionitrile) (AIBN, 98%) were
purchased from Sinopharm Chemical Reagent Co. (Shanghai, China). All
materials were used as received. Aqueous solutions were prepared using
ultrapure water (18.2 MΩ·cm).
Method
Synthesis of MSNPs
MSNPs with various morphologies
were synthesized using surfactant micelles as the soft template in
basic conditions.[35,36] A CTAB aqueous solution and a
volume of aqueous ammonia were mixed and stirred at room temperature
for 1 h. TEOS was added to the mixture at a rate of 5 mL·min–1. The reaction was continued for 4 h with constant
stirring. The morphologies of the MSNPs were controlled by varying
the compositions of the reactants (CTAB, H2O, NH4OH, and TEOS) and the stirring rate, as listed in Table . The resulting suspension was
then incubated in a Teflon-lined autoclave at 100 °C for 24 h.
The solid products were then separated, purified, and dried. MSNPs
were obtained after removal of the soft template (CTAB) by calcining
the solid at 550 °C for 5 h.
Table 1
Characteristics of MSNPs
Morphology
Reactant
ratio (CTAB:H2O:NH4OH:TEOS)
Stirring
rate (rpm)
Size (d × l) (nm)
Aspect ratio
(AR)
Surface area SBET (m2·g–1)
Pore volume V (cm3·g–1)
Pore size Dp (nm)
Spherical
0.1:1000:7:0.7
350
∼150
1
1055
0.92
3.08
Rod-like
0.4:1000:10:1.4
400
∼250 × 1000
4
1100
0.88
2.97
Thread-like
0.4:1000:5:1.4
350
∼80 × (∼5000)
∼60
896
0.95
3.74
Characterization of MSNPs
The morphologies of the MSNPs
were characterized by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) (JEOL
JEM-2100, Tokyo, Japan) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) (SU-8010
instrument, Hitachi, Tokyo, Japan). The mesoporous structures of the
MSNPs were investigated by X-ray diffraction (XRD) (D8 Advance, Bruker,
Karlsruhe, Germany) and N2 adsorption–desorption
isotherms (ASAP 2020 MP, Micromeritics, Norcross, GA, USA).
Preparation of Pickering Emulsions
MSNPs (0.021 g,
0.3 wt %) were dispersed in 7 mL DTAB aqueous solutions at various
concentrations by sonication at 50 W for 1 min (FS-250N, Shanghai,
China). A 7 mL volume of n-octane was then added.
The mixtures were homogenized at 12 000 rpm for 2 min (T18
basic, S18N-10G head, IKA, Staufen im Breisgau, Germany) and afterward
stored in an incubator at 25 °C. The concentrations of MSNPs
and DTAB were calculated relative to the volume of the water phase.
The volume ratio between the oil and water phases was 1:1.
Characterization of Pickering Emulsions
A drop of Pickering
emulsion was added to the water and oil phases in order to test for
the style of emulsion formed.[37] If the
droplets dispersed into the water quickly, the emulsion type was O/W;
otherwise, it was water-in-oil (W/O). Photos of the Pickering emulsions
were taken with a digital camera. The droplet images of the Pickering
emulsions were obtained using an optical microscopy system (VHX-100,
Keyence Co., Itasca, IL, USA). The size distribution of droplets was
determined by image analysis, for which 200 droplets were analyzed
and measured for each sample.[22,38] The number-average
diameter (DN), volume-average diameter
(DV), and the polydispersity index (PDI)
were calculated according to the following equationswhere ni is the
number of droplets with the diameter of Di.
SEM Images of Droplets in Pickering Emulsions
Styrene-in-water
Pickering emulsions were prepared with identical volumes (7 mL) of
a styrene–AIBN mixture (100:2, w/w) and aqueous dispersions
containing 0.3 wt % MSNPs of various morphologies and 0.6 mmol·L–1 DTAB. Following homogenization, the Pickering emulsions
were polymerized at 40 °C for 24 h without stirring.[24] The resulting polystyrene microspheres were
washed, separated, and observed by SEM operated at 5.0 kV.
Reversible Cycling of Switchable Pickering Emulsions
A volume of concentrated NaOH solution (n = n) was added to the stable Pickering emulsions to observe the
demulsification phenomenon. A volume of concentrated HCl solution
(n = n) was subsequently added to the NaOH-containing
samples. The mixtures were homogenized once again to observe the re-emulsification
phenomenon.
Surface Tension Measurements
DTAB solutions in combination
with MSNPs of various morphologies were prepared in either the presence
or absence of NaOH (n = n). All the solutions
were aged for 24 h to attain equilibrium. The surface tension measurements
were obtained using a DCAT-21 type tensiometer (DataPhysics, Santa
Clara, CA, USA) with a Pt–Ir Du Noüy ring at 25 °C.
Results and Discussion
MSNPs with Various Morphologies
MSNPs
with different morphologies were synthesized in our lab according
to the reported method.[35,36] These MSNPs had large
specific surface areas in the range of 896–1100 m2·g–1, similar to the typical mesoporous silica
particles previously reported.[39−41] The morphology of the nanoparticles
was controlled by the composition of reactants (CTAB, H2O, NH4OH, and TEOS) and the stirring rate. Figure shows SEM images of the prepared
spherical, rod-like, and thread-like MSNPs. The spherical MSNPs had
an average diameter of approximately 150 nm (Figure A). The rod-like MSNPs had an average diameter
of approximately 250 nm, and a length of approximately 1 μm
(Figure B). The thread-like
MSNPs had an average diameter of approximately 80 nm, and a length
of approximately 5 μm (Figure C). The characteristics of MSNPs are listed in Table . These MSNPs had
narrow pore size distributions and regular mesopore structures. The
TEM, XRD, and N2 adsorption–desorption isotherm
data are available in the Supporting Information (Figures S1–S5).
Figure 1
SEM images of (A) spherical, (B) rod-like, and
(C) thread-like
MSNPs.
SEM images of (A) spherical, (B) rod-like, and
(C) thread-like
MSNPs.
Pickering Emulsions Stabilized by MSNPs in
Combination with DTAB
The MSNPs (0.3 wt %) with various morphologies
were dispersed in DTAB solutions of different concentrations, following
which, an equal volume of n-octane was added to each.
The mixtures were first homogenized and then stored in an incubator
at 25 °C. Images of the resulting solutions are shown in Figure . As reported,[37,42,43] bare silica nanoparticles were
too hydrophilic to stabilize the emulsions and so were bare MSNPs
(see Figure at CDTAB = 0 mmol·L–1). In
the presence of a cationic surfactant, these MSNPs can be hydrophobized
in situ and act as effective emulsifiers to stabilize the emulsions.[1,14,42,43] For spherical MSNP systems, as shown in Figure A, the Pickering emulsions were unstable
at DTAB concentrations below 0.2 mmol·L–1.
Phase separations occurred within 2 days. For DTAB concentrations
above 0.2 mmol·L–1, stable Pickering emulsions
lasting more than 6 months were obtained. Similar phenomena were observed
for the Pickering emulsions stabilized by rod-like MSNPs and DTAB
(Figure B). The synergistic
behavior of thread-like MSNPs and cationic surfactants seems to be
more effective for stabilizing the emulsions. Stable Pickering emulsions
can be produced at lower DTAB concentrations of approximately 0.1
mmol·L–1 (Figure C).
Figure 2
Digital photos of mixtures of n-octane and suspensions,
containing 0.3 wt % MSNPs and DTAB at various concentrations (mmol·L–1, labels in A), taken 6 months after they were homogenized.
The MSNPs were (A) spherical, (B) rod-like, and (C) thread-like.
Digital photos of mixtures of n-octane and suspensions,
containing 0.3 wt % MSNPs and DTAB at various concentrations (mmol·L–1, labels in A), taken 6 months after they were homogenized.
The MSNPs were (A) spherical, (B) rod-like, and (C) thread-like.Figure shows optical
micrographs of the prepared Pickering emulsions. The average diameter
of the droplets in these emulsions stabilized by spherical and rod-like
MSNPs was 30 ± 5 μm at DTAB concentrations of 0.3–0.6
mmol·L–1 (Figure A,B). The average diameters of droplets in
Pickering emulsions stabilized by thread-like MSNPs were 43.4 μm
at 0.4 mmol·L–1 DTAB and 26.8 μm at 0.6
mmol·L–1 DTAB (Figure C). Similar variations in droplet sizes with
surfactant concentrations were also reported for conventional Pickering
emulsions.[37,42−44] With increasing
DTAB concentrations, the droplet sizes of all Pickering emulsions
became more uniform. In the reported nanosilica Pickering emulsions,
the average diameters of droplets were typically between 10 and 100
μm.[14,18,23,45,46]
Figure 3
Optical micrographs of
Pickering emulsions stabilized by 0.3 wt
%: (A) spherical, (B) rod-like, and (C) thread-like MSNPs in situ
with different concentrations of DTAB (mmol·L–1) as indicated, with a bar scale of 50 μm if without a special
mark.
Optical micrographs of
Pickering emulsions stabilized by 0.3 wt
%: (A) spherical, (B) rod-like, and (C) thread-like MSNPs in situ
with different concentrations of DTAB (mmol·L–1) as indicated, with a bar scale of 50 μm if without a special
mark.The droplets in Pickering emulsions stabilized
by thread-like MSNPs
and 0.1–0.3 mmol·L–1 DTAB were extremely
large, however (Figures and S6). The average diameter of these
droplets was approximately 700 μm, which was about 20 times
larger than those of conventional droplets. This was an intriguing
phenomenon, considering that these large droplets were able to resist
coalescence over a period of 6 months or even remain dispersed after
heating in an oven at 50 °C for 48 h (Figure S7). The morphology of the thread-like MSNPs is likely to be
responsible for this unique behavior. Huang et al.[47] prepared O/W Pickering emulsions using two-dimensional
(2D) graphite oxide (GO) sheets as stabilizers. The oil droplets thus
obtained were also very large, ranging between 0.267 and 1.347 mm
in diameter as the GO concentration varied from 0.95 down to 0.0095
mg·mL–1. These abnormal phenomena indicated
the tremendous effect of nanoparticle morphology on the microstructure
and stability of Pickering emulsions. In our study, the thread-like
MSNPs had a high AR (ratio of long to short axis), as did the GO (ratio
of lateral size to thickness). When absorbed at the O/W interfaces,
these nanoparticles had limited freedom due to restricted rotation.
Their orientations were thus kinetically trapped at the interface,
with the long axis parallel to the interface. The alignment of the
nanoparticles in this way resulted in interfaces with low curvatures.
Moreover, the long thread-like MSNPs might have been entangled with
each other at the O/W interfaces and even in the continuous phase
and thus formed a network-like structure, which reduced the coalescence
of droplets and enhanced the stability of the emulsions.[15,24,48]SEM is expected to provide
direct evidence of the location and
orientation of MSNPs at the O/W interfaces. However, the in situ observation
of an emulsion droplet using SEM is impossible due to solvent evaporation
under vacuum. To achieve this, Pickering emulsions stabilized by 0.6
mmol·L–1 DTAB together with 0.3 wt % MSNPs
were prepared using styrene as the oil phase instead of n-octane. Polymerization of styrene was induced in order to solidify
the emulsion droplets for observation.[24] The results are shown in Figure . All three MSNPs were located at the surfaces of the
droplets. This indicated that although the MSNPs used had diameters
of hundreds of nanometers to several micrometers, they did adsorb
at the O/W interface and serve as stabilizers. The sizes of traditional
nanosilica particles used in preparing Pickering emulsions have usually
been in the range of 20–200 nm.[18,23,45,49] Larger particles failed
to remain at the interfaces due to the effect of gravity. However,
MSNPs are characterized by their low bulk densities, which lead to
a decreased gravity effect. In this study, the MSNPs used were much
larger in size, which could be adsorbed at the interface.
Figure 4
SEM images
of polymerized styrene-in-water emulsions stabilized
by 0.6 mmol·L–1 DTAB in combination with 0.3
wt % MSNPs of various morphologies: (A,B) spherical, (C,D) rod-like,
and (E,F) thread-like.
SEM images
of polymerized styrene-in-water emulsions stabilized
by 0.6 mmol·L–1 DTAB in combination with 0.3
wt % MSNPs of various morphologies: (A,B) spherical, (C,D) rod-like,
and (E,F) thread-like.The spherical MSNPs distributed at the surface
of the oil droplets
were similar to those formed in conventional Pickering emulsions.
The rod-like and thread-like MSNPs located at the O/W interface were
oriented with some of their long axes parallel to each other. The
packing of nanoparticles at the interface was denser in the case of
both spherical and rod-like MSNPs but was looser for the thread-like
MSNPs (Figure A,C,E).
Obviously, the ARs of nanoparticles directly affect surface coverage.
Capron et al. reported the surface architecture of Pickering emulsions
stabilized by cellulosic nanorods with various ARs, in which short
nanocrystals were densely organized, while longer nanocrystals had
low coverage, with most of the nanocrystals involved in the network
of the material.[24] Similar effects of ARs
on the surface coverage and the stability of Pickering emulsions were
also observed in O/W Pickering emulsions stabilized by silica microrods
with various ARs from 1 to 16.[22] In general,
particles with a higher AR showed flexibility to some extent in a
multiphase system, which is proportional to the AR.[16,24,27,50,51] These particles could behave like flexible threads
in the Pickering emulsions systems. This might also have been the
situation in the current study. As shown in Figure E (indicated by arrows), some of the thread-like
MSNPs were inserted vertically into the droplets and resulted in the
fuzzy edges of the solidified spheres. With this alignment, the thread-like
MSNPs were possibly intertwined and formed a three-dimensional (3D)
network. The detailed structure shown in the SEM image taken directly
following drying of the emulsion containing thread-like MSNPs implied
the formation of a 3D network structure (Figure S8).
Switchable Behaviors of Pickering Emulsions
Irrespective of the morphology of the MSNPs, all of the prepared
stable Pickering emulsions remained their original appearances for
more than 6 months. Following addition of a certain quantity of NaOH
(n:n = 1:1), rapid demulsification was
observed in the Pickering emulsions stabilized by spherical and rod-like
MSNPs in combination with DTAB (Figures and S9) within
10 min. The emulsions were separated into two phases, with a clear
oil phase on the top and a turbid water phase containing nanoparticles
at the bottom. Following addition of HCl (n:n = 1:1), stable Pickering emulsions were reformed following homogenization.
The average droplet size of the reformed emulsions was 30 μm
(Figures S10 and S11), which was close
to those of the original emulsions. By alternately adding HCl and
NaOH, the Pickering emulsions could be switched between stable and
unstable states. The emulsification/demulsification cycle could be
repeated more than 60 times. Similar phenomena have also been reported
previously,[14] showing the novel behavior
of mesoporous nanoparticles when preparing switchable Pickering emulsions.
The concentrations of NaOH and HCl required to induce the demulsification/emulsification
were very low (<1 mmol·L–1), which have
no effect on the morphology of the MSNPs (see SEM images in Figures S12–S14). Thus, the switchable
behavior was attributed to the varied interactions between MSNPs and
the surfactants. The inner channels and outer surfaces of the MSNPs
contained numerous silica hydroxyl groups, which have high reactivity.[40,52] In the presence of NaOH, silica hydroxyl groups were transformed
into anionic forms, which strongly absorb DTAB molecules by means
of electrostatic interactions. Compared with the outer surface, there
were more silica hydroxyl groups in the inner surface of MSNPs.[39,40,52] Due to the large specific surface
areas of MSNPs, most of the DTAB molecules were adsorbed into the
inner channels[14] (see the schematic illustration
in Figure ). As a
result, the MSNPs became hydrophilic and were thus unable to stabilize
the emulsions. With further addition of HCl to neutralize the NaOH,
the silica hydroxyl groups were regenerated. The DTAB molecules were
released from the inner channels, and the MSNPs were hydrophobized
again, enabling them to stabilize the emulsions.
Figure 5
Digital photographs of
Pickering emulsions first stabilized by
0.3 wt % rod-like MSNPs and 0.6 mmol·L–1 DTAB
and then switched between unstable and stable states by alternately
adding NaOH (causing the emulsion to be unstable) and followed by
an equimolar amount of HCl (restoring stability). A schematic illustration
is shown at the top of the figure. The photographs were taken 20 min
following addition of the NaOH and 24 h following addition of the
HCl, respectively.
Figure 6
Schematic illustration of the adsorption of DTAB molecules
on the
MSNPs following addition of NaOH and followed by HCl.
Digital photographs of
Pickering emulsions first stabilized by
0.3 wt % rod-like MSNPs and 0.6 mmol·L–1 DTAB
and then switched between unstable and stable states by alternately
adding NaOH (causing the emulsion to be unstable) and followed by
an equimolar amount of HCl (restoring stability). A schematic illustration
is shown at the top of the figure. The photographs were taken 20 min
following addition of the NaOH and 24 h following addition of the
HCl, respectively.Schematic illustration of the adsorption of DTAB molecules
on the
MSNPs following addition of NaOH and followed by HCl.In contrast, the Pickering emulsions stabilized
by thread-like
MSNPs and DTAB behaved totally differently. As shown in Figure , following addition of NaOH,
the volume of the water phase at the bottom increased, but no obvious
phase separation was observed. The microscopy images showed large
droplets with submicrometer diameters in the emulsions, similar to
those shown in Figure C. The Pickering emulsions in this state were stable even after heating
at 50 °C for 48 h or after stirring for several hours or adding
excess NaOH (n:n = 10:1). Following addition
of equimolar quantities of HCl to the NaOH and homogenization, stable
Pickering emulsions with small droplet sizes (∼30 μm)
were reformed. The transformation from small-sized droplets to large
droplets could also be repeated for at least 10 times by alternately
adding HCl and NaOH repeatedly.
Figure 7
Images of Pickering emulsions stabilized
by 0.3 wt % thread-like
MSNPs and 0.6 mmol·L–1 DTAB, and micrographs
of droplets following repeated addition of NaOH and HCl, with a bar
scale of (A,B) 50 μm and (C,D) 200 μm. A schematic illustration
of the changes in the emulsion droplets following addition of NaOH
is shown on the right.
Images of Pickering emulsions stabilized
by 0.3 wt % thread-like
MSNPs and 0.6 mmol·L–1 DTAB, and micrographs
of droplets following repeated addition of NaOH and HCl, with a bar
scale of (A,B) 50 μm and (C,D) 200 μm. A schematic illustration
of the changes in the emulsion droplets following addition of NaOH
is shown on the right.The surface tension results for DTAB solutions
in the presence
of various MSNPs are shown in Figure . Following addition of NaOH (n = n), the surface tensions of these solutions increased with values
close to that of water (72 mN·m–1), even at
a relatively high DTAB concentration of 5 mmol·L–1. This showed that there were few free DTAB molecules in the solution.
Most of the DTAB molecules were absorbed into the inner mesopores
of the MSNPs. These results proved that the previous proposed mechanism[14] worked, regardless of the morphology of the
MSNPs. Thus, the unique responsive behavior of Pickering emulsions
stabilized by thread-like MSNPs and DTAB following addition of NaOH
should be attributed to the difference in morphology. As shown in Figure , when the surface
of the MSNPs became hydrophilic following addition of NaOH, small
droplets merged together, leading to the formation of larger droplets.
However, further coalescence of these larger droplets was prevented
by the thread-like MSNPs located at the O/W interfaces. With low bulk
density and limited freedom, these MSNPs prefer to locate at the interface,
even with very weak hydrophobicity. The 3D network structure formed
by the elongated thread-like MSNPs also inhibited further coalescence
of the droplets. For the stimuli-responsive properties of Pickering
emulsions, systems containing spherical and rod-like MSNPs showed
similar behavior, that is, demulsification together with phase separation
was observed after the addition of NaOH. These results indicated that,
for both spherical and rod-like MSNPs, the interactions between nanoparticles
were similar when adsorbed at the O/W interface. However, for thread-like
MSNPs, they could be entangled at the interfaces with each other,
forming a cross-link and 3D network structure and resulting in long-range
interactions that affect the whole interfacial film. Therefore, after
the MSNPs were converted from amphiphilic to hydrophilic, the strong
cross-linking between the thread-like MSNPs restricted the further
coalescence of droplets and made the dispersion of droplets with large
size possible. In general, the morphology of nanoparticles had no
effect on their in situ hydrophobilization process but affected the
interactions between nanoparticles and their orientations and arrangements
at the interfaces.
Figure 8
Surface tensions of DTAB in combination with various MSNPs
in the
presence or absence of NaOH, where S, R, and T represent spherical,
rod-like, and thread-like MSNPs, respectively.
Surface tensions of DTAB in combination with various MSNPs
in the
presence or absence of NaOH, where S, R, and T represent spherical,
rod-like, and thread-like MSNPs, respectively.
Conclusions
Irrespective of the morphology
of the MSNPs (spherical, rod-like,
or thread-like), stable oil-in-water (O/W) Pickering emulsions can
be prepared using MSNPs in situ hydrophobized by a cationic surfactant
DTAB as stabilizers. Although the sizes of the MSNPs were in the range
of hundreds of nanometers to several micrometers, all three MSNPs
were adsorbed at the O/W interface. The low bulk densities of the
MSNPs led to a decreased gravity effect, which allowed them to remain
at the interface. These Pickering emulsions were thus characterized
by adsorption layers composed of MSNPs with high specific surface
areas and multiple adsorption sites. They are especially useful for
heterogeneous catalysis, organic synthesis, and controlled drug release.
The properties of Pickering emulsions were also significantly affected
by the morphologies of the nanoparticles. With increasing nanoparticle
anisotropy, adsorption of nanoparticles with high anisotropies at
the O/W interface was less dependent on their surface hydrophobicity.
For thread-like MSNPs (aspect ratio (AR) ≈ 60), extremely large
droplets with submicrometer diameters were observed at a suitable
concentration of cationic surfactant. The orientations of these nanoparticles
were kinetically trapped at the O/W interface, with their long axes
oriented parallel to the interface, resulting in interfaces with low
curvatures. Our results demonstrate that the microstructures and characteristics
of Pickering emulsions can be modulated effectively by altering the
morphology of the nanoparticles. The present system also provides
a new approach for synthesis of functional materials using the Pickering
emulsions as templates. Our study has, for the first time, revealed
the relationship between the morphology of mesoporous nanoparticles
and the characteristics of Pickering emulsions. These results enrich
our knowledge of the formulation of Pickering emulsions and expand
their application.
Authors: Lauriane Alison; Patrick A Rühs; Elena Tervoort; Alexandra Teleki; Michele Zanini; Lucio Isa; André R Studart Journal: Langmuir Date: 2016-12-09 Impact factor: 3.882