| Literature DB >> 35980413 |
Cameron J Gettel1,2, Arjun K Venkatesh1,2, Hollie Dowd3, Ula Hwang1, Rockman F Ferrigno4, Eleanor A Reid1, Mary E Tinetti5,6.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: The "4Ms" model - What Matters, Medication, Mentation, and Mobility - is increasingly gaining attention in age-friendly health systems, yet a feasible approach to identifying what matters to older adults in the emergency department (ED) is lacking. Adapting the "What Matters" questions to the ED setting, we sought to describe the concerns and desired outcomes of both older adult patients seeking ED care and their treating clinicians.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35980413 PMCID: PMC9391017 DOI: 10.5811/westjem.2022.4.56115
Source DB: PubMed Journal: West J Emerg Med ISSN: 1936-900X
”‘What Matters” semi-structured interview guide for older adult patients and their treating clinicians.
| Questions for older adult patients
One question to ascertain fears or concerns about healthcare in ED What concerns you most when you think about your health and about being in the ED today/tonight? or What fears and worries do you have about your health as you think about what brought you to the ED today/tonight? One question about outcome patients most want from their ED visit What outcome are you most hoping for from this ED visit? or What are you most hoping for or looking for from your ED visit? |
| Questions for treating clinicians
What do you think the patient/family is concerned about today? What outcomes do you think the patient is most hoping for? |
ED, emergency department.
Sample characteristics.
| Variable | N = 46 |
|---|---|
| Age, mean (SD) | 87 (7) |
| Female, n (%) | 27 (57) |
| Race, n (%) | |
| White | 37 (80) |
| Black | 7 (16) |
| Other | 2 (4) |
| Ethnicity, n (%) | |
| Hispanic or Latino | 2 (4) |
| Non-Hispanic | 44 (96) |
| Marital Status, n (%) | |
| Single | 4 (9) |
| Married | 22 (48) |
| Divorced | 3 (6) |
| Widowed | 15 (33) |
| Other | 2 (4) |
| Chief Complaint Category, n (%) | |
| Fall, musculoskeletal | 16 (35) |
| Weakness, fatigue, dizziness | 11 (24) |
| Cardiopulmonary | 10 (22) |
| Other | 9 (19) |
| ED Evaluation, n (%) | |
| Labs | 43 (93) |
| Radiograph | 32 (70) |
| Ultrasound | 4 (9) |
| CT imaging | 16 (35) |
| Final ED Disposition, n (%) | |
| Admit | 26 (57) |
| Discharge | 20 (43) |
| ED Diagnosis Category, n (%) | |
| Musculoskeletal | 12 (26) |
| Infection | 7 (15) |
| Cardiopulmonary | 8 (18) |
| Metabolic, electrolyte disturbance | 7 (15) |
| Other | 12 (26) |
| Interview time of day, n (%) | |
| 9 AM–4 PM | 16 (35) |
| 4 PM–11 PM | 30 (65) |
| Clinician type, n (%) | |
| Physician | 34 (74) |
| Non-physician practitioner | 12 (26) |
| Average patient interview length, min (range) | 3 (1–8) |
SD, standard deviation; ED, emergency department, CT, computed tomography.
Fears and concerns related to emergency care of older adults and their treating clinicians.
| Question #1 – Fears and concerns about healthcare in the ED? | |
|---|---|
|
| |
| Theme | Exemplar quotes |
|
| |
| | One of my doctors did not like the result of a blood test that I had taken last Friday and he did not like the result of my blood pressure today. (Participant) |
| I really did not want to come, but my kids made me come. (Participant) | |
| Well, I haven’t paid a great deal of attention to my health. My wife has been at me to be more concerned about how I feel, what’s happening, and what I need to feel better. (Participant) | |
| | When I came into the emergency department tonight, I was treated with respect, and I love being here because at least I get some progress. (Participant) |
| I don’t know if I have any concerns, because I have total confidence that they are going to take care of the problem. (Participant) | |
| Nothing really, because I’m in good hands. They know what they’re doing. I have no worries about it. (Participant) | |
| | I would say what concerns me the most is finding out what is my problem. (Participant) |
| What concerns me most is that I just want to find out what’s going on with my health and my body. (Participant) | |
| Finding out what is really wrong with me. (Participant) | |
| Finding out what is wrong with me. (Participant) | |
| | I have pain in my left hip, which is totally unexplainable. (Participant) |
| Being able to feel better and poop, because I have been eating, but nothing’s been coming out and it’s very uncomfortable. (Participant) | |
| Getting rid of the pain that I got. (Participant) | |
| To get better…I felt like I was going to faint and my legs gave way. (Participant) | |
| I feel awful, I feel so nauseous. So that is concerning to me be because I really do not want to mess myself or anything you know. (Participant) | |
| | Mobility – I have a heart condition, an artificial knee – mobility is the big issue. (Participant) |
| I am just concerned that I will not get back to normal. (Participant) | |
| I fell, and if my knee gets hurt I don’t know if I will ever walk again. (Participant) | |
| I want to be by myself, and I want to take care of myself. I don’t move much at home because I have a hard time getting up and moving. (Participant) | |
|
| |
| | I think he is most concerned about the source of his pain. (Clinician) |
| He is definitely concerned about his left knee pain. He thinks he has another infection, because he has a history of similar. (Clinician) | |
| I think one of the main things that he is concerned about is the dizziness that he does not know where it is coming from. (Clinician) | |
| | I think he is concerned that he has an infection that has not been improving on antibiotics. (Clinician) |
| Persistent shortness of breath that has not been treated. (Clinician) | |
| The pain in her back. (Clinician) | |
| He was concerned that he was not urinating. (Clinician) | |
| The patient’s main concern was the discomfort in her right shoulder and left knee after falling today. (Clinician) | |
Desired outcomes related to emergency care of older adults and their treating clinicians.
| Question #2 – Outcome most hoping for from this ED visit? | |
|---|---|
|
| |
| Theme | Exemplar quotes |
|
| |
| | The doctors will find whatever is causing the pain and we will just move on. (Participant) |
| To actually just learn what is wrong. (Participant) | |
| Find out what is causing this. (Participant) | |
| | That I do not have to have any operations and I can go home soon. (Participant) |
| To go home. (Participant) | |
| Nothing really, because I’m in good hands. They know what they’re doing. I have no worries about it. (Participant) | |
| That I can be bandaged up and go home. (Participant) | |
| Recovery back home. (Participant) | |
| To be able to go back to the facility where I reside. (Participant) | |
| | No recurring symptoms. (Participan) |
| Get rid of the pain. I can tolerate discomfort, but pain management today. (Participant) | |
| I am hoping that my stomach will go down and I will [be] able to poop and feel better. (Participant) | |
| To get rid of the pain. (Participant) | |
| | I want to get back to where I can be myself because I used to love to exercise. I used to love to walk and it seems like I can’t even do none of that now, and I am an independent person and I like doing for myself and I hate when I have to have other people to do for me. (Participant) |
| That I know what to do to better take care of myself. (Participant) | |
| | Something that doesn’t incur surgery. (Participant) |
| Everything is normal. (Participant) | |
| I hope there is nothing wrong. (Participant) | |
|
| She wants to go home. (Clinician) |
| | Could be able to be discharged home. I think it is what she is hoping for. (Clinician) |
| Ability to go back to Assisted Living. (Clinician) | |
| I think he hoped that he could go home. (Clinician) | |
| | He is hoping that I tell him that that is not the case [an infected knee] and he gets to go home. (Clinician) |
| I think that she is hoping that everything is negative and she gets to go home. (Clinician) | |
| To be discharged from the emergency department today, and to have reassurance that he does not have a fracture or new blood clot. (Clinician) | |
| I think she was hoping that she would be cleared with basic emergency department evaluation and be able to go home. (Clinician) | |
| I think ultimately she would like to be discharged home and be told everything is looking good. (Clinician) | |
| | The bleeding to stop. (Clinician) |
| Probably pain control and her arm healing. (Clinician) | |
| To feel better and not be short of breath. (Clinician) | |
ED, emergency department.