| Literature DB >> 35968163 |
Amritha James1, Lekshmy Jayan1, Ramya Ramadoss2, Preethi Arunachalam1.
Abstract
Introduction: Understanding the molecular pathogenesis of an entity helps in devising the mode of progression as well as mode of therapy. Even with years of research to claim the understanding of the molecular pathogenesis of oral submucous fibrosis (OSMF) is limited. More deeper knowledge of the genes responsible for this will help in understanding and managing this disease better. Materials andEntities:
Keywords: Oral cancer; SMAD; oral submucous fibrosis; profibrotic genes; transforming growth factor-beta
Year: 2022 PMID: 35968163 PMCID: PMC9364652 DOI: 10.4103/jomfp.jomfp_102_21
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Oral Maxillofac Pathol ISSN: 0973-029X
Figure 1Diagrammatic representation of selection of articles for the systematic review using PRISMA checklist
Overview of the studies included in the review
| Author and year of study | Profibrotic gene studied | Research objective | Evidence level of study | Sample size | Analytic method followed | Inference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Srinivasan | TGF-alpha | Evaluate the expression of PCNA, c-myc, EGFR, TGF-alpha in OSMF | Level IV (Cohort) | OSMF: 15 | IHC evaluation | Increased expression of TGF-alpha is evident in the basal and parabasal or the proliferative layers of epithelium |
| Tu | MMP-3 | Aim was to clarify whether the functional | Level IV | Control-98 | Polymerase chain reaction based genotyping | The 5A promoter group was more frequent in OSMF, but no association was found between 5A genotype in MMP3 promoter and site or lymph node metastasis as well as stage of OSCC |
| Bishen | FGF | Evaluation of the expression of FGF in both fibroblasts and endothelial cells in OSMF and comparison of the level of the expression in various grades of OSMF | Level IV | Control-5 | IHC evaluation | Increased expression of FGF in fibroblasts and endothelial cells with strong positivity in the early stages of the disease and reduced in advanced stages may be an immunomodulator in the initial stages of the disease. At the same time, it also contributes to the reduced vasculature and hypoxia with the progression of the disease |
| Tilakaratne | HIF-1alpha | Evaluation of role of hypoxia in progression and malignant transformation of OSMF | Level IV | Control-10 | Real-time polymerase chain reaction | The levels of HIF-1 alpha were elevated at both protein and mRNA levels, and the resulting hypoxia contributes to the fibrosis and progression of OSMF and eventually lead to malignant transformation |
| Mishra and Ranganathan (2010)[ | MMP-1 | To evaluate the role of MMP-1 in OSMF | Level IV | Control-10 | IHC evaluation | The level of MMP-1 is elevated in OSMF, but there was no correlation between the levels of MMP-1 and the grade of the disease |
| Rajendran | TGF-beta | Evaluation of polymorphisms in TGF-beta associated with OSMF | Level IV | Control-50 | Quantification of DNA was performed with spectrophotometer and the analysis of polymorphism by Genotyping | The polymorphism in 5′UTR C-T in TGF beta 1 gene has a significant association |
| Khan | TGF-beta | Identification of differentially regulated genes in tissue microarray and analyze the role of TGF-beta and arecoline in regulating other genes present in keratinocytes and fibroblasts | Level IV | Control-11 (microarray) | Microarray and real-time polymerase chain reaction to identify the genes in the specimen | The SMAD2 positivity has shown that TGF-beta activation is an important mediator in OSMF. On treating keratinocytes and fibroblasts with TGF-beta, there was upregulation of CTGF, TGM2, THBS1 at the same time downregulation of BMP7. This indicates that in OSMF, there is activation of TGF-beta and at the same time, there is downregulation of BMP-7 |
| Khan | TGF-beta | Comparison of the gene expression profile in epithelial cells (HaCat) following treatment with areca nut extracts and the TGF-beta-induced gene expression profile | Level IV | 16 gingival tissues | Real-time polymerase chain reaction, microarray | Polyphenol and alkaloid fractions in areca nut induces TGF-beta signaling and its downstream targets in epithelial cells but not in fibroblasts. This indicates that the arecoline-induced activation of SMAD2 upregulates and activates TGF-beta in OSMF and contributes to its progression |
| Kale | TGF-beta | Correlation of the role of TGF-beta in the loss of adipose tissue in OSMF | Level IV | 84 OSMF | IHC evaluation | Early stages showed more intense TGF-beta staining than in advanced stages with loss of adipose tissue increasing as the grade progresses. The findings suggest that TGF-beta plays a key role in causing lipodystrophy in OSMF |
| Shrestha and Carnelio (2013)[ | MMP-2 | Evaluation of expression and distribution of MMP-2 and TIMP-2 in various grades of OSMF | Level IV | Control-10 | IHC evaluation | Both MMP-2 and TIMP-2 were elevated with progression of the disease and may indicate their role as important mediators in the development and progression of the disease |
| Sodhi | TNF-alpha | Evaluation of the levels of TNF-alpha in OSMF and to correlate the levels of TNF-alpha with disease severity | Level IV | Control-25 | Sandwich enzyme immunosorbent assay | The levels of TNF-alpha were increased in OSMF, and there was positive correlation with the levels of TNF alpha and the severity of OSMF |
| Kamath | TGF-beta | Assessment of correlation between levels of TGF-beta with stages and grades of OSMF | Level IV | Control- 10 | IHC analysis | The expression of TGF-beta in moderate grade of OSMF was comparable to that of scar or keloid tissue. Thus, fibrosis in both these conditions may be linked through the TGF-beta pathway |
| Patil | CTGF | Estimate the levels of CTGF in OSMF and to correlate the value with progression of the disease (stage and grade) | Level IV | Control-40 | Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay | CTGF is elevated in OSMF group in comparison to the control group and at the same time should statistically significant elevation with the progression of stage or grade of the disease |
| Kamath | TGF-beta 1,2 | Correlate the levels of TGF-beta 1,2 with various stages of OSMF | Level IV | Control- 10 | IHC evaluation | The level of TGF-beta 1 was higher than TGF-beta 2 in OSMF. TGF-beta 1 is the promoter of the fibrosis in OSMF whereas TGF-beta 2 plays a contributory role |
| Maria | TGF-beta 1 | Areca nut and pan masala extracts where used to induce OSMF and then the expression of TGF-beta 1 is assessed | Level IV | Control-10 | Real-time polymerase chain reaction | Significant upregulation of TGF-beta 1 was reported, and a statistically significant elevation was noticed with the progression of the disease |
| Pant | TGF-beta | Assessment of regulation of TGF-beta signaling by areca nut in epithelial cells and the evaluation of the mechanism by which it is induced in the epithelial cells in OSMF | Level VI | HeLa cell lines are used | Immunoblotting technique | TGF-beta signaling can be induced by areca nut extract which leads to fibrosis in OSMF |
| Iyengar | TGF-beta | Evaluation of the presence of COX-2 and TGF-beta in different stages and grades of OSMF | Level IV | 35 subjects with OSMF | IHC evaluation | Progressive increase in the levels of TGF-beta and COX-2 with advancement of the disease both stage and grade. Both the molecules play an important role in the progression of the disease |
| Katarkar | MMP-9 | To investigate whether SNPs in | Level IV | Control-196 | RT-PCR, Western blotting technique | Genotypic and functional study revealed definitive role of MMP-9 |
| Rai | TGF-beta | Evaluation of role of TGF-beta in pathogenesis of OSMF | Level IV | Control-10 | Real-time polymerase chain reaction | The mRNA expression of all isotypes of TGF-beta and receptors were increased in OSMF. This indicates that the molecule plays a very important role in the molecular pathogenesis of OSMF |
| Hu | SMAD-7 | Evaluation of the role of SMAD-7 in the progression of OSMF and OSCC | Level IV | Control-12 | IHC evaluation and cancer genome atlas analysis | SMAD-7 expression is higher in OSCC and OSMF. It is a promoter for the progression of OSMF and development of OSMF |
| Zagabathina | SMAD-2 | Compare the expression of SMAD-2 in OSMF and reactive lesions | Level IV | Control-20 | Quantitative | There was a statistically significant elevation in the levels of SMAD2 in OSMF in comparison with control group. However, the levels of this molecule were not statistically significant. This indicates that SMAD plays a role in accentuating fibrosis in OSMF |
TGF: Transforming growth factor, CTGF: Connective tissue growth factor, EGFR: Estimated glomerular filtration rate, OSMF: Oral submucous fibrosis, OSCC: Oral squamous cell carcinoma, MMP: Matrix metalloproteinases, OSF: Oral submucous fibrosis, FGF: Fibroblast growth factor, HIF: Hypoxia inducible factor, mRNA: Messenger RNA, IHC: Immunohistochemical, TIMP: Tissue inhibitors of matrix metalloproteinases, TNF: Tumor necrosis factor, SNP: single nucleotide polymorphism, PCNA:proliferating cell nuclear antigen
Figure 2Profibrotic genes included in this systematic review