Muhammad Ikram1, Ayesha Khalid2, Anum Shahzadi3, Ali Haider4, Sadia Naz5, Misbah Naz6, Iram Shahzadi7, Anwar Ul-Hamid8, Junaid Haider5, Walid Nabgan9, Alvina Rafiq Butt2. 1. Solar Cell Applications Research Lab, Department of Physics, Government College University Lahore, Lahore, Punjab 54000, Pakistan. 2. Physics Department, Lahore Garrison University Lahore, Lahore, Punjab 54000, Pakistan. 3. Faculty of Pharmacy, The University of Lahore, Lahore, Punjab 54000, Pakistan. 4. Faculty of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, Muhammad Nawaz Shareef University Agriculture, Multan, Punjab 60000, Pakistan. 5. Tianjin Institute of Industrial Biotechnology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Tianjin 300308, China. 6. Department of Chemistry, Division of Science and Technology, University of Education, Lahore, Punjab 54000, Pakistan. 7. Punjab University College of Pharmacy, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Punjab 54000, Pakistan. 8. Core Research Facilities, King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals, Dhahran 31261, Saudi Arabia. 9. Departament d'Enginyeria Química, Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Av Països Catalans 26, 43007 Tarragona, Spain.
Abstract
This research work intends to evaluate the photoactivity of calcium oxide (CaO) nanorods (NRs) doped with cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) and cerium (Ce). CNC-doped CaO and Ce/CNC codoped CaO were synthesized via the sol-gel technique. Structural, optical, morphological, physiochemical, phase constitution, and functional group evaluations were performed. The photodegradation of the prepared nanostructures was analyzed by observing photodegradation of a mixture of methylene blue and ciprofloxacin dye under light irradiation. The photocatalytic activity of the dye was drastically enhanced upon codoping in CaO. For both Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus, statistically significant inhibitory zones (p < 0.05) were achieved in the case of CNCs and pristine and codoped CaO. Furthermore, in silico molecular docking studies (MDS) were accomplished against DNA gyrase from nucleic acid biosynthesis and enoyl-[acyl-carrier-protein] reductase (FabI) from the fatty acid biosynthetic pathway to rationalize the possible mechanism behind these antibacterial activities.
This research work intends to evaluate the photoactivity of calcium oxide (CaO) nanorods (NRs) doped with cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) and cerium (Ce). CNC-doped CaO and Ce/CNC codoped CaO were synthesized via the sol-gel technique. Structural, optical, morphological, physiochemical, phase constitution, and functional group evaluations were performed. The photodegradation of the prepared nanostructures was analyzed by observing photodegradation of a mixture of methylene blue and ciprofloxacin dye under light irradiation. The photocatalytic activity of the dye was drastically enhanced upon codoping in CaO. For both Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus, statistically significant inhibitory zones (p < 0.05) were achieved in the case of CNCs and pristine and codoped CaO. Furthermore, in silico molecular docking studies (MDS) were accomplished against DNA gyrase from nucleic acid biosynthesis and enoyl-[acyl-carrier-protein] reductase (FabI) from the fatty acid biosynthetic pathway to rationalize the possible mechanism behind these antibacterial activities.
Recently, the remarkable
increase in water pollution caused by
dye emission from various industries such as paper and fabric manufacturing
and processing as well as paint and makeup manufacturing has been
identified as a significant concern. The emergence of this menace
will have negative effects on freshwater ecosystems. The current worldwide
research of the colorant industry for 2021 predicts that the market
will grow from its present value of 32 billion USD to 42 billion USD.
Every year, 700,000 tons of synthetic dyes are generated, with 15%
of colors released into water being hazardous or xenobiotic in nature.[1,2] Photosynthesis is inhibited by the presence of dyes in water, which
also restricts the microbiological activity of aquatic plants.[3] Coagulation, membrane separation, adsorption,
microbial degradation, photochemical, and filtration techniques have
all been employed to remove dye effluents from wastewater.[4,5] The major source of worry is the development of harmful byproducts
as a result of the design to adopt these approaches for wastewater
cleanup.[6,7] Hence, the main concern is generating eco-friendly
byproducts in photocatalysis. Photogenerated electrons (CB) and holes
(VB) in the photocatalyst initiate redox reactions. These compounds
are desorbed from the surface and are re-introduced into the fluid
phase.[8,9]Advanced oxidation processes have
increased the curiosity for complete
degradation of dyes, which include processes like photocatalysis,
photo-Fenton, and photo-ozonation.[10,11] The medium
for the reaction and atmospheric conditions, catalyst properties,
band gap (Eg), surface charge, nature
of the reaction medium, and environmental conditions affect the efficiency
of advanced oxidation processes.[12,13] Extensively,
for the degradation of dyes, a variety of photocatalysts such as metals,
metal oxides, semiconductors, and so forth are under study in wastewater
treatments.[14,15] Recently, researchers have concentrated
on combining inorganic materials with conductive polymers to realize
interactive and compatible behaviors for increasing the pollutant’s
degradation rate.[16,17] For this purpose, metal oxide
nanoparticles (NPs) have been widely applicable to degrade nonbiodegradable
dyes using the photocatalytic process.In this document, for
effective dye degradation, codoped calcium
oxide (CaO) NPs have been used as photocatalysts.[18] In general, CaO white, caustic, alkaline, and crystalline
powder are used. CaO has the highest Eg ∼ 4.17 eV and a dielectric constant of 11.8 among light alkaline
earth oxides.[19] CaO is applied in many
fields, which includes its use as additives in refractory, bactericides
in the biomedical field, and adsorbents especially in catalysis.[20] For photocatalytic dye degradation, however,
developing high-performance CaO that provides more active sites and
a large specific surface area is still a challenge. Nano-photocatalysts
containing rich surface states, large surface area, and characteristic
morphology are novel materials.[21] However,
lower efficiency and formation of secondary pollutants result when
nano-photocatalysts agglomerate during the reaction, which limit their
development and usage.[22] Therefore, to
overcome these challenges, semiconductor NPs coupled by a matrix produce
a semiconductor/matrix composite.[23] CaO
was doped with cellulose to enrich the photocatalytic activity. Cellulose
is an ideal matrix with high hydrophilic character, transparency,
physiochemical resistance, permeability, flexibility, and thermal
stability.[24] Cellulose, which is a natural
polymer, is commonly employed in polymer nanocomposites synthesis
because of its abundance and biodegradability.[25] Good environmental stability cellulose is highly favored
as it is preferred for synthesizing composites, providing an interface
for charge transfer and also decreases leakage of ions.[26,27] Cellulosic materials have superior mechanical capabilities, are
cost-beneficial, have a lower density, and have tunable surface features.[28,29] Generally, CNCs are produced with concentrated H2SO4 through the acid hydrolysis method.[30,31] Cellulosic nanostructures are acknowledged as unique nanomaterials
that can create new high-performance materials.[32,33] Cellulose is a polymer as one unit of cellulose has three hydroxyl
groups, and the polymer is connected by β-1-4 glucosidic bonds.[34,35] Hydrogen connections established between the hydroxyl groups in
the cellulose molecules allow the molecules to create a highly organized
crystal structure. As a result, cellulose possesses a high degree
of crystallinity.[36] The hydroxyl group
of cellulose has a strong electron providing effect and a low electron
loss tendency because of the lone electron pair of oxygen atoms.[37,38] In this perspective, CNCs may be the most viable alternative for
fabricating cellulosic materials for new uses.[39,40] Lanthanide ions have been considered as innovative dopants to affect
the structural and optoelectronic characteristics of CaO.[41] By forming complexes with various Lewis bases,
it is possible to increase the absorbability of organic contaminants
on metal surfaces. Among these, cerium doping attracted more interest;
in redox conditions, cerium oxide shifts between CeO2 and
Ce2O3 because of the redox couple Ce+3/Ce+4. Different optical and catalytic properties result
from different electronic structures between Ce3+ (4f1 5d0) and Ce4+ (4f0 5d0).[42] Ce doping on CaO plays a key
role as it increases defects in surface layers in photocatalytic activity.
Thus, this research attempts to enhance the photocatalytic activity
of codoped CaO in degradation of MBCF under visible light. As far
as we know, the production of CNC/Ce-doped CaO and its utilization
in organic pollutant degradation and antibacterial activities have
been unfamiliar.Therefore, binary dopants (CNC and Ce) doped
into CaO synthesized
with sol–gel and examine the effect of dopants for dye degradation
and antibacterial activity. Furthermore, antibacterial properties
of the produced nanocomposites have been investigated using in silico
MDS on enzymes from the nucleic acid and fatty acid biosynthesis pathways.
Experimental Details
Materials
Calcium chloride dihydrate
(99.9%), sodium hydroxide (99%), cerium nitrate hexahydrate (99%),
methylene blue, and avicel (C6H10O5) were procured from Sigma Aldrich.
The experiments involve bacterial growth media to perform bactericidal
activities.
Preparation of CNC
Sulfuric acid
hydrolysis of microcrystalline cellulose (Avicel) provided CNC (Figure a). First, avicel
was hydrolyzed in H2SO4 (64% w/w) at 45 °C
for half an hour. After that, DI water was added to suppress the reaction.
The obtained cellulose pallet in the solution was centrifuged at 6000
rpm for 10 min. The Buchner flask and funnel were used to wash it,
and sodium hydroxide 0.25 mol/L was added to the suspension for neutralization.
Finally, the remaining suspension was sonicated for 5 min with a vibrance
sonicator.[43]
Figure 1
(a) Cellulose nanocrystal
synthesis; (b) schematic of the synthesis
of Ce/CNC-doped CaO nanostructures.
(a) Cellulose nanocrystal
synthesis; (b) schematic of the synthesis
of Ce/CNC-doped CaO nanostructures.
Preparation of (CNC-Doped CaO) and (Ce/CNC-Doped
CaO)
Chemical precipitation was adopted to prepare metal
oxide (CaO) nanoparticles. Supersaturated solution of CaO nanoparticles
was obtained by adding NaOH in CaCl2 under continuous stirring
at 100 °C for 40 min. To obtain uniformly sized nanoparticles,
the solution was kept static. Ca(OH)2 was washed several
times with DI water and centrifuged at 7100 rpm for 9 min. The achieved
pallet was dried at 70 °C for 24 h, and the powder was obtained.
The same method was reprised by methodically adding 2% Ce and 2.5
mL of CNC to obtain CNC-doped CaO and Ce/CNC-doped CaO nanostructures,
as illustrated in Figure b.
Absorption and Photocatalytic Activity Process
Photocatalytic reduction of MBCF (10 mg/L) was observed in accordance
to the photocatalysis of Ce-doped and Ce/CNC-doped CaO nanorods. To
gain equilibrium between dye and Ce/CNC-doped CaO, 10 mg photocatalyst
suspension in 60 mL MBCF was prepared. In the absorption method/procedure,
the prepared solution was vigorously stirred at 50 rpm in dark conditions
for 5 min before illumination. During photocatalysis, a Hg lamp (400
W, λ ∼ 400–700 nm) was employed as a source of
visible light. A suspension (5 mL) was obtained for UV–Vis
absorption to determine the concentration of MBCF under visible light
for specific time intervals. During the photocatalytic activity, decolorization
was represented by a function of absorption peak intensity (665 nm)
with irradiation time. The percentage age deterioration was calculated
using eq :where C0 and C are the starting and final MBCF solution
concentrations following a set irradiation duration at 665 nm.
Results and Discussion
The crystalline
material structures of CNC, CaO, CNC-doped CaO,
and Ce/CNC-doped CaO were inspected via X-ray diffraction (XRD) (Figure a). The diffractogram
of CNC perceived peaks at 12°, 19.5°, 22.4°, and 33.9°
that are attributed to (101), (002), and (112) crystal planes, which
confirmed the monoclinic structure well harmonized with JCPDS card
No. 46-090.[39] Peaks located at ∼28.53°,
32.2°, 37.3°, and 47.306° corresponding to (210), (111),
(200), and (112) planes for undoped (CaO) and codoped CaO. In accordance
with JCPDS card No. 00-004-0777, it demonstrated a cubic structure
without impurities.[20,27,44,45] In the XRD pattern of CaO, a few low-intensity
calcite peaks (CaCO3) illustrate rapid carbonation of CaO
by atmospheric CO2.[46] Upon codoping,
the slightly shifted layer spacing to higher values is attributed
to the homogeneous distribution of Ce and CNC between interlayers
of pure CaO, which is consistent with the peak shift observed in XRD
spectra. With Ce and CNC addition, no obvious peak and crystal phase
of dopants was noticed in XRD spectra, implying that dopants are homogenously
distributed in the CaO matrix and their concentrations are too low
for detection. Ce-related compounds are not developed during the growth,
but the atoms of Ce are incorporated in CaO lattice sites. Crystallite
sizes of CNC, CaO, CNC-doped CaO, and Ce/CNC-doped CaO were determined
as ∼10.11, 11, 12.3, and 13.1 nm, respectively, using the Debye–Scherer
equation. To analyze attached functional and molecular vibration modes
in samples, the Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) technique was utilized
(Figure b, c zoom).
The observed spectra for CNC exhibited a transmittance band at 1082
cm–1ascribed to C–O vibrations. In contrast,
the peaks detected around 1635 and 1435 cm–1 are
related to C=O stretching vibrations and C–H stretching
vibrations, respectively.[47] It was revealed
that the CaO band at 3647 cm–1, which was attributed
to the O–H bonds, was expressed by the presence of −OH
and H2O on the samples’ external surface when handling
the samples to record their spectra.[46] Carbonation
of CaO nanoparticles indicated broad bands around 1400–1500
cm–1 endorsed to the C–O bond. The asymmetric
stretching vibration of C=O from carbonate groups is shown
by band widening with weak intensity at 1388.42 cm–1.[48] The sharp peaks found that ∼874
and 712 cm–1 are ascribed to Ca–O–Ca
and Ca–O bonding, respectively, identified the presence of
CaO.[49] Because of constant active phase
amounts, no notable change in intensity was observed. A slight shift
toward a higher wavenumber was also observed upon Ce/CNC doping in
the CaO lattice.
Figure 2
(a) XRD spectra, (b) FTIR profiles of codoped CaO, (c)
zoom FTIR
profile of products, (d–g) SAED profiles of CNC, CaO, CNC-doped
CaO, and Ce/CNC-doped CaO, respectively.
(a) XRD spectra, (b) FTIR profiles of codoped CaO, (c)
zoom FTIR
profile of products, (d–g) SAED profiles of CNC, CaO, CNC-doped
CaO, and Ce/CNC-doped CaO, respectively.The selected area electron diffraction (SAED) analysis
of the pristine
and Ce- and CNC-doped materials revealed distinct rings that correspond
to the hkl values (planes) of NPs, as illustrated
in Figure d–g.
These results are attributed to well-crystallized specimens, and ring
indexing is supported by previous with XRD results.The obtained
absorption spectra of pristine and doped CaO with
a UV–vis spectrophotometer are depicted in Figure a. The absorption band for
CNC has been measured at 340–390 nm, depicting 3.15 eV band
gap.[50] The absorbance of CaO was observed
between 290 and 340 nm. Upon doping of Ce and CNC, the absorption
increased and introduced red shift. Eg of samples decreased from 4.17 eV (CaO) to 3.41 eV (Ce/CNC-doped
CaO), as shown in the tauc plot (Figure b–e). Calculated Eg values for pure CaO (4.17 eV) and CNC (3.15 eV) were
in good agreement with the reported results.[20,51] The redshift in absorption edges for nanorods arises from the quantum
size effect and is considered mandatory for enhancement in photocatalytic
behavior.[52]
Figure 3
(a) Absorption spectra
and (b) PL spectra; (c–f) Tauc plot
for the band gap.
(a) Absorption spectra
and (b) PL spectra; (c–f) Tauc plot
for the band gap.To analyze the trapping efficiency, electron–hole
recombination,
and charge carrier transportation of the synthesized product, PL was
employed. The significance of Ce/CNC in promoting electron transfer
and PL emission spectra of pristine and codoped CaO was measured from
400 to 700 nm (Figure f). Because PL emission is associated with the surface states, oxygen
sites and defects are produced on the sample surface. CNC is characterized
by the emission band located in the 325–700 nm region under
excitation at 300 nm.[26] In the red region
with the exception of photoluminescent CaO bands shifted to the infrared
(IR) region to a lesser range of the band in the red region, Ca(OH)2 is denser than cubic CaO and has a lower energy interface
defect.[53] Band to band transition raised
spontaneous emission at the PL emission peak (400 nm). The catalytic
activity of CaO was enhanced by unsaturated surface sites, and photoluminescence
spectra are formed by unsaturated sites on the CaO surface.[54] Surface unsaturated sites with the coordination
number <5 was exhibited by the lower energy region.[55] In low coordination states, surface absorption
bands connected with electronic transitions in surface oxygen ions
display low PL energy excitation. Surface absorption bands are linked
with the electronic transitions in surface oxygen ions in the low
coordination state, which causes lower excitation energy of PL.[56] PL intensity decreased as excited electrons
jumped from VB to the new state introduced by doping.The various
electronic states of CaO have been investigated by
XPS, as clarified in Figure a, b. The signal at 532.5 and 530.6 eV, corresponding to O2– and O1– in Ca–O interactions,
was equally detected in O 1s spectra; Figure (a). Two specific heights at 346.5 and 351.2
eV found were ascribed to Ca 2p3/2 and Ca 2p1/2 in CaO, as shown in Figure b.[57]
Figure 4
XPS spectra of CaO (a)
O 1s and (b) Ca 2p.
XPS spectra of CaO (a)
O 1s and (b) Ca 2p.These thermogravimetric analysis curves for CaO
and CNC-doped CaO
have been recorded in air and are depicted in Figure a, b. Using a 10 °C min–1 ramp rate, the sample was heated from ambient temperature to 800
°C. It is believed that the oxidation of CaO results in an increase
in mass up to 420 °C, a process known as an exothermic reaction.
This initial mass loss is caused by the breakdown of Ca(OH)2 in the CaO sample; in turn, this decomposition of Ca(OH)2 results from the interaction of CaO with water, which produces Ca(OH)2. It has been discovered that dehydration occurs first and
results in the elimination of water from crystallization about 100
°C, but a hump detected around 200 °C indicates that the
transition is endothermic in nature. When the temperature is increased
to 420 °C, an endothermic peak is detected, indicating that CaO
melts without any associated mass loss.[58,59]
Figure 5
TGA curves
of (a) CaO and (b) CNC-doped CaO.
TGA curves
of (a) CaO and (b) CNC-doped CaO.The morphology and crystal structure at single
grain’s edges
of nanoparticles and individual atomic plane periodic arrangement
in samples was observed by high-resolution transmission electron spectroscopy
(HR-TEM). Figure a′–d′
exhibits HR-TEM images of CNC, CaO, CNC-doped CaO, and Ce/CNC-doped
CaO, respectively, along with the corresponding TEM images (Figure a–d) with
marked lattice fringes. The HR-TEM micrograph revealed that CaO has
agglomerated a nanocrystalline structure with an inhomogeneous spherical
shape (Figure b′).
Nanoparticles slightly scattered with slight transparency with agglomeration
and random rationing when doped with CNC and Ce (Figure c′,d′).The clearer
image of CNC is shown in Figure S6, which
indicates the nanocrystalline nature of cellulose. Ce/CNC-doped CaO
depicted the formation of nanorods with agglomeration (Figure d′). These rod-like
structures manifested increased photocatalytic activity by contributing
a large surface area and a greater number of active sites. Furthermore,
HR-TEM micrographs up to 10 nm resolution were recorded to acquire
details about the interplanar distance and morphology of samples,
as represented in Figure a–d. The calculated interplanar d-spacing
values came out to be ∼0.327, 0.326, 0.240, and 0.250 nm for
CNC, CaO, CNC-doped CaO, Ce/CNC-doped CaO, respectively, computed
using Gatan Digital Micrograph (GDM) software and ascribed to a hkl planes set (210), (112), and (202), well harmonized
with corresponding diffraction patterns attained from XRD results
consistent with (JCPDS card No. 46-090 for CNC &JCPDS card No.
00-004-0777 for CaO).
Figure 6
(a–d) d-Spacing calculated using
HR-TEM
images of CNC (a′), CaO (b′), CNC-doped CaO (c′),
and Ce/CNC-doped CaO (d′). HR-TEM scale bar is 100 nm.
(a–d) d-Spacing calculated using
HR-TEM
images of CNC (a′), CaO (b′), CNC-doped CaO (c′),
and Ce/CNC-doped CaO (d′). HR-TEM scale bar is 100 nm.Energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectroscopy was
carried out to analyze
the sample’s elemental composition, as expressed in Figure a–d. The obtained
images show strong peaks of Ca, O, and C, which confirmed the formation
of codoped CaO nanorods. Atomic ratios (1:1) of Ca and O elements
were quantified by EDX data, which are approximately near stoichiometric
analysis of CaO. From the test results of doped samples, dopants (CNC
and Ce) manifested in all samples as per concentrations of dopants.
Figure 7
EDS analysis
of CNC (a), CaO (b), CNC-doped CaO (c), and Ce/CNC-doped
CaO (d).
EDS analysis
of CNC (a), CaO (b), CNC-doped CaO (c), and Ce/CNC-doped
CaO (d).Photocatalysis was enhanced by the defect addition
because of dopants,
leading to narrowing of Eg by structural
changes. By the decomposition of dye (MBCF), the photocatalytic activity
of CNC, CaO, CNC-doped CaO, and Ce/CNC-doped CaO was examined after
desorption or adsorption under irradiation attained in the dark for
10 min. The sample has been exposed to visible light irradiation,
and a 3 mL volume of dye was syringed out at certain intervals of
time for UV–Vis analysis. When the dye concentration was reduced,
it was discovered that the absorbance maxima at 665 nm were reduced
as a result. The graph between MBCF concentrations (C/Co) as a function of irradiation time
evaluated the photo-decolorization activity, as presented in Figure a. Furthermore, kinetics
of photodegradation were analyzed using pseudo-first-order, and rate
constants were calculated for CNC, CaO, CNC-doped CaO, and Ce/CNC-doped
CaO as 0.00332, 0.00236, 0.00292, and 0.00258 min–1, respectively (Figure b). The recombination rate of electron–hole pairs reduces
by intermediate energy levels because of the addition of Ce/CNC dopants,
so rate constants and dye photodegradation values of codoped CaO were
evaluated to be better than dopant-free CaO. Degradation largely depends
on surface area, size, shape, and absorption behavior on different
surfaces of the nanocatalysts. The larger the surface area of the
particles, the higher the number of active sites for atoms, which
in turn leads to an increase in redox reaction, which in turn causes
the dye to degrade. Experiment stability is a critical factor to be
considered while utilizing as a photocatalyst for wastewater treatment.
CNC and all samples of CaO (pristine and doped) degraded MBCF within
120 min, while pure CaO showed the lowest degradation efficiency,
as depicted in Figure c. CNC showed 3% degradation after 35 min of light irradiation. Pristine
CaO degraded 10% of MBCF in 60 min. Increased photocatalytic activity
was observed after doping CNC with CaO, with the maximal degradation
rate of 18% achieved in 25–30 min. The extremely high % degradation
was observed in a Ce/CNC-doped CaO specimen, indicating that the codoped
nanomaterial was the most effective irradiation photocatalyst. The
increase in photocatalytic activity of CaO, CNC, and Ce can be ascribed
to a lower recombination rate of photo-induced charge carriers as
a result of their doping. Electrons of VB excited to CB of induced
Ce giving electron–hole pairs when codoped CaO was irradiated.
Oxygen molecules (O2) have been reduced by migrated charges
into active oxygen radicals (O*2), while hydroxyl radicals
were produced when holes in the VB of Ce reacted with water molecules.[60] Finally, produced O*2 and OH* radicals
descended MBCF to generate degraded products. The degradation mechanism
(redox reactions) is illustrated in eqs –6.
Figure 8
(a) C/C0 vs time plot,
(b) ln(C0/C) vs time
plot, (c) degradation % graph, (d) stability of codoped CaO samples,
and (e) photoactivity mechanism of products.
(a) C/C0 vs time plot,
(b) ln(C0/C) vs time
plot, (c) degradation % graph, (d) stability of codoped CaO samples,
and (e) photoactivity mechanism of products.In the above equations, the MBCF dye was degraded,
and byproducts
were produced. Usually, photocatalyst stability was examined by leaving
completed activities uninterrupted for 3 days and obtaining an absorption
spectrum from each sample every 24 h to record any variations in dye
degradation. It has been determined that the dye has degraded every
24 h by spectrophotometry, and the findings are shown in Figure d. The CNC/Ce-doped
CaO photocatalyst proved to be a promising performer and demonstrated
outstanding stability. Table S1 compares
the degradation of several dyes using various catalyst amounts and
times. Metal oxide nanocomposites’ photocatalytic activity
was assessed by the reduction of MBCF under mercury lamp for a certain
interval of time. The created holes in CNC (VB) and electrons transfer
from the VB to CB of nanocomposites when illuminated under light.
Subsequently, electrons transfer toward CB of CaO and holes move toward
higher potential of CNC (VB), as shown in Figure e. Photogenerated electrons and holes play
an important part in redox reactions when these interact with surrounding
molecules in aqueous solution (Figure e).In vitro microbicidal efficacy of pure and
doped samples for pathogenic
bacteria was studied by calculating inhibition zones through well
diffusion assay are demonstrated in Table S2. The mechanism and obtained data of all samples showed antimicrobial
activity against bacterial strains in Figures and 10. A synergistic
effect between the prepared samples and inhibition zones was depicted
by results (Figure S1). In the case of
CNC, significant bactericidal regions (p < 0.05)
against Escherichia coli (3.30 and
4.45 mm) and Staphylococcus aureus (0.95
and 1.65 mm) were obtained at the minimum and maximum concentrations,
correspondingly. Furthermore, pristine and codoped CaO inhibition
areas against Escherichia coli ranged
1.90–7.15 mm and 3.30–7.15 mm while 1.90–7.80
mm and 2.25–7.80 mm for Staphylococcus aureus were recorded at minimum and maximum concentrations, respectively.
These results were compared with those obtained with ciprofloxacin
and DI water as 7.80 and 0 mm, correspondingly. Pristine and codoped
CaO showed tremendous antimicrobial efficacy for Gram-positive in
comparison with Gram-negative bacteria while CNC manifested intensified
response vice versa. Codoped CaO efficiently highlighted bacteria-killing
activity, as depicted in Table S2.
Figure 9
Schematic presentation
of specimen’s bactericidal mechanism.
Figure 10
In vitro bactericidal efficacy of CNC (a), CaO, CNC-doped
CaO,
Ce/CNC-doped CaO (b,c) for E. coli and
CNC (a′), CaO, CNC-doped CaO, Ce/CNC-doped CaO (b′,c′)
for S. aureus.
Schematic presentation
of specimen’s bactericidal mechanism.In vitro bactericidal efficacy of CNC (a), CaO, CNC-doped
CaO,
Ce/CNC-doped CaO (b,c) for E. coli and
CNC (a′), CaO, CNC-doped CaO, Ce/CNC-doped CaO (b′,c′)
for S. aureus.The effectiveness of antibacterial nanostructures
is reliant on
their size and concentration; therefore, oxidative stress of nanomaterials
is also dependent on these parameters. Bacteria die as a result of
the expulsion and bulging of cytoplasmic contents caused by reactive
oxygen species (ROS), encasing their exterior membranes.[61] When cations substantially interact with the
negative components of microbial cells, micro-microbes collapse as
a result.[62,63] When cations interfere with bacterial ribosome
activity and enzyme breakdown, micro-pathogens are unable to proliferate
and sustain.[64]In addition to their
capacity to interact with bacterial cells
and impair cell membrane permeability, metal-doped nanorods also have
the potential to disrupt essential metabolic processes.[65] Nanorod toxicity to microbes is therefore studied
in more detail. Antibiotics may be able to combat bacterial infections
by inhibiting enzymes that play a critical role in bacterial survival,
which is the primary virulence factor implicated in the infection.[66] Molecular docking experiments were carried out
on DNA gyrase and FabI enzymes of E. coli as prospective targets based on the excellent bactericidal activity
(in vitro) of CNC-doped CaO and Ce/CNC-doped CaO against E. coli.The best docked conformation for CNC-doped
CaO against DNA gyrase
revealed H-bonding interaction with Gly77 (3.3 Å), Asn46 (1.3
Å), Asp73 (3.1 Å), and Thr165 (2.6 Å) having a binding
score of −8.672 kcal/mol (Figure a). Similarly, the Ce/CNC-doped CaO nanocomposite
showed a binding score of −9.174 kcal/mol having H-bonding
interactions with Gly77 (3.1 Å), Asp73 (2.2 and 2.9 Å),
and Thr165 (2.5 Å) alongside metal contact interactions with
Arg76, as illustrated in Figure b.
Figure 11
Binding interaction pattern of (a) CNC-doped CaO and (b)
Ce/CNC-doped
CaO nanocomposites with active site residues of DNA gyrase from E. coli.
Binding interaction pattern of (a) CNC-doped CaO and (b)
Ce/CNC-doped
CaO nanocomposites with active site residues of DNA gyrase from E. coli.In the case of FabI, the top-ranked docked complex
for CNC-doped
CaO revealed H-bonding interactions with Ser91 (2.7 Å), Gly13
(2.9 Å), Ser19 (2.9 Å), Thr194 (1.1 and 2.7 Å), and
Ala196 (3.0 Å) having a binding score of −7.936 kcal/mol.
On the other hand, Ce/CNC-doped CaO showed a binding score of −8.691
kcal/mol having H-bonding interactions with Ser91 (3.0 Å), Gly13
(1.5 Å), Ser19 (3.1 Å), Thr194 (1.0 and 2.7 Å), and
Ala196 (1.9 Å) as shown in Figure a, b.
Figure 12
Binding interaction pattern of (a) CNC-doped
CaO and (b) Ce/CNC-doped
CaO nanocomposites with active site residues of FabI from E. coli.
Binding interaction pattern of (a) CNC-doped
CaO and (b) Ce/CNC-doped
CaO nanocomposites with active site residues of FabI from E. coli.
Conclusions
Pristine and codoped CaO
nanomaterial with Ce and CNC dopants were
favorably synthesized via the sol–gel process. In the cubic
structure of CaO, no obvious peak and dopant’s crystal phase
was observed in XRD spectra, which indicated that low concentrations
of dopants in CaO are homogenously distributed. FTIR recorded all
functional groups present in the sample. The presence of a typical
absorption band around 874 cm–1 in the fingerprint
region has been assigned to vibration modes of Ca–O–Ca
bonding adsorption edge shifted toward higher wavelengths by the decrease
in Eg from 4.17 to 3.41 eV upon Ce/CNC
doping, which corresponds to the electronic characteristics of dopants.
The PL spectra demonstrated the capabilities of nanoparticles by demonstrating
better separation of charges and a reduction in the rate of e––h+ recombination. Chemical composition was calculated with EDX, which
confirmed the presence of constituent elements (e.g., Ca, O, and Na).
A high degree of agglomeration and formation of nanorods of CaO upon
doping could be observed using HR-TEM profiles while the d-spacing
of pristine and doped CaO has been calculated as 0.326 and 0.250 nm,
respectively. Upon the CNC/Ce incorporation, the degradation of the
MBCF dye by CaO was enhanced under light irradiation. The highest
photodegradation was recorded for codoped CaO, which showed synergistic
effects under the visible source. CNC and Ce doping contents reduced
the Eg width and decreased the charge
carrier’s recombination, which promoted the photoactivity.
Pristine and codoped CaO showed tremendous antimicrobial efficacy
against Gram-positive as compared to Gram-negative bacteria while
CNC manifested intensified response vice versa. In silico MDS predicted
the inhibition of DNA gyrase and FabI as the possible mechanism behind
the biocidal activity of nanorods against bacterial strains.
Authors: S Altaf; A Haider; S Naz; A Ul-Hamid; J Haider; M Imran; A Shahzadi; M Naz; H Ajaz; M Ikram Journal: Nanoscale Res Lett Date: 2020-07-08 Impact factor: 4.703