| Literature DB >> 35958887 |
Tracy J Sims1, Kristina S Boye1, Susan Robinson2, Tessa Kennedy-Martin2.
Abstract
Purpose: Understanding the treatment-related attributes influencing medication-taking behaviors in people with type 2 diabetes (T2D) is important for delivery of patient-centered care. This review aimed to identify and summarize studies in which people with T2D (PwD) directly indicated the treatment-related attributes associated with medication-taking behaviors or intentions. Materials andEntities:
Keywords: adherence; discontinuation; medication attributes; type 2 diabetes
Year: 2022 PMID: 35958887 PMCID: PMC9359496 DOI: 10.2147/PPA.S367046
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Patient Prefer Adherence ISSN: 1177-889X Impact factor: 2.314
Figure 1Study selection.
Characteristics of Included Studies
| Author (Year)/ Country | T2D Treatment | Study Type | Methods and Analysis | Medication-Taking Indicator | Hypothetical (H) or Actual (A) Behavior | Attributes Studieda | Study Populationb |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barba et al, 2017 | Oral and/or injectable | Cross-sectional survey | Electronic self-administered questionnaire; PwD rate importance of a list of factors considered important for adherence (5-point Likert scale) | Adherence (assessed by MMAS-4) | H | Complexity | N=963 |
| Chen et al, 2020 | Insulin or GLP-1 RA | Cross-sectional survey | Interviewer-administered questionnaire; single- and multiple-choice questions providing a list of possible concerns that PwD had at treatment initiation | Initiation | A | Weight changec | N=500 |
| de Climens et al, 2020 | OAD and/or injectables | Cross-sectional survey | Self-administered online questionnaire; comprised 1 closed- and 3 open-ended questions determining reasons for discontinuation | Discontinuation | A | Glycemic efficacy | N=161 |
| Dehdari and Dehdari, 2019 | T2D medications (not specified) | Qualitative study | Face-to-face interviews consisting of open-ended questions on experiences of adherence and its influencing factors | Adherence | A | Dose frequency | N=22 |
| Farmer et al, 2006 | OAD | Cross-sectional survey | Self-completed postal questionnaire; PwD rate agreement with list of beliefs about medication taking (5-point Likert scale) and state if factor affected their intention to take medication regularly | MARS-5 (Adherent=25; non-adherent <25) | H | Glycemic efficacy | N=121 |
| Flory et al, 2019 | Metformin | Qualitative study | Facilitator-led, semi-structured interviews and focus groups consisting of open-ended questions and probes on motivations and barriers to metformin | Adherence | A | Glycemic efficacy | N=20 |
| Gater et al, 2020 | Dual GLP-1/GCG RA | Phase 2, double-blind, RCT (exploratory endpoint) | Self-administered electronic questionnaire (PQAT) consisting of 3 open-ended questions focused on benefits and disadvantages of treatments and reasons for willingness to/not to continue treatment | Adherence | H | Glycemic efficacy | N=57 |
| Hauber et al, 2009 | OAD (hypothetical) | Cross-sectional DCE | Web-based survey; PwD rate (5-point Likert scale) likely adherence to hypothetical medication profiles (based on 6 attributes) presented in a series of choice tasks | Self-reported likelihood of missing or skipping doses | H | Glycemic efficacy | N=407 |
| Hauber et al, 2013 | OAD (hypothetical) | Cross-sectional DCE | Web-based survey; PwD rate (5-point Likert scale) their likely adherence to the hypothetical medication profiles (based on 5 attributes) presented in a series of choice tasks | Self-reported likelihood of missing or skipping doses | H | Dose frequency | N=1114 |
| Huang et al, 2020 | OAD and/or injectable | Qualitative study | Qualitative face-to-face semi-structured interviews consisting of open-ended questions on factors associated with adherence | Adherence to Refills and Medications Scale for Diabetes Score (adherence: high =28; low <28) | A | Glycemic efficacy | N=23 |
| Jarab et al, 2018 | OAD and/or injectable | Qualitative study | Facilitator-led focus groups comprising interviews using a schedule of open-ended questions including barriers to adherence | Adherence | A | Dose frequency | N=36 |
| Kubo et al, 2019 | OAD | Cross-sectional survey | Self-reported online questionnaire; PwD choose from list of motivations and influencers for initiation or adherence | Initiation | A | Glycemic efficacy | N=560 |
| Polonsky et al, 2011 | QW injectable | Cross-sectional survey | Online questionnaire; PwD asked how a list of 6 treatment characteristics would influence willingness to take a new QW medication (5-point Likert scale) | Initiation | H | Glycemic efficacy | N=1355 |
| Sajith et al, 2014 | T2D medications | Cross-sectional prospective, observational study | Interview using questionnaire (no details provided but appears PwD presented with list of factors affecting adherence) | Adherence | A | Hypoglycemiac | N=105 |
| Sikirica et al, 2017 | GLP-1 RA | Multinational, cross-sectional survey | Self-completed questionnaire consisting of series of open-ended questions about reasons for discontinuation | Discontinuation | A | Glycemic efficacy | N=2173 |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Insulin or GLP-1 RA | Cross-sectional survey | Online questionnaire; PwD selected factors from a list that were barriers to adherence or reasons for discontinuation | Adherence | A | Weight changec | N=2000 |
Notes: aOnly those attributes and reasons of relevance to the current review are listed. Attributes were referred to in various ways across studies, but terms have been standardized for reporting purposes; bData are mean (SD) unless otherwise stated; cDenotes an attribute evaluated under a broader “umbrella” term. For the purposes of the review, the attribute must itself have been specifically noted by the study authors as being included under that umbrella either listed or provided as an example.
Abbreviations: AE, adverse event; DCE, discrete-choice experiment; GCG, glucagon; GI, gastrointestinal; GLP-1, glucagon-like peptide-1; IQR, interquartile range; MARS, Medication Adherence Report Scale; MMAS, Morisky Medication Adherence Scale; OAD, oral antidiabetes drug; PQAT, Patient’s Qualitative Assessment of Treatment; PwD, people/person with diabetes; QW, once weekly; RA, receptor agonist; RCT, randomized controlled trial; T2D, type 2 diabetes.
Overview of Main Findings from Studies That Evaluated Glycemic Efficacy as a Treatment-Related Attribute
| Indicator Influenced | Study (Author, Year) | Treatment Studied | Main Finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initiation | Polonsky et al, 2011 | QW injectable | 44% very/extremely likely to be willing to take medication if it “could help to reduce your blood sugar spikes”; current injectable users more likely to be willing vs current OAD users (65.1% vs 31.3%) |
| Kubo et al, 2019 | OAD | 63.2% of drug-naïve PwD cited “reduces blood sugar effectively” as important when considering an OAD | |
| Adherence | Farmer et al, 2006 | OAD | 91.5% agree/strongly agree with the belief that taking OADs regularly “would keep my blood sugar under control” and 87.8% that it “would keep my diabetes under control” (87.8%); both significantly correlated with intention to take medication (Spearman’s |
| Flory et al, 2019 | Metformin | Under theme of “motivation”: benefits of glucose lowering (“My A1c has been fabulous”) | |
| Hauber et al, 2009 | OAD | Glucose control had no effect on medication adherence | |
| Huang et al, 2020 | Oral/injectable | Under theme “motivation for medication adherence” and subtheme “facilitators”: belief in the effectiveness of treatment, including perception that glucose control is a direct benefit of medication when taken according to HCP instructions (“If I didn’t take metformin, I’m sure my blood sugar level would go up very quickly. I think that’s dangerous … ”) | |
| Kubo et al, 2019 | OAD | 43% of current users cited “reduces blood sugar effectively” as a motivation for continuing to take treatment | |
| Gater et al, 2021 | GLP-1/GCG RA | 32% reported improved glucose levels/control as reason reported for willingness to continue treatment | |
| Discontinuation | de Climens et al, 2020 | OAD/injectable | 26% reported drug efficacy issues (of which 36% and 24% was no perceived positive benefit or decision of medical team, respectively) as a reason for discontinuation |
| Sikirica et al, 2017 | GLP-1 RA | 34.5% reported inadequate blood glucose control as a reason for discontinuation |
Abbreviations: GLP-1 RA, glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonist; GLP-1/GCG RA, dual glucagon-like peptide-1/glucagon receptor agonist; HCP, healthcare professional; OAD, oral antidiabetes drug; PwD, person/people with diabetes; QW, once weekly.
Overview of Main Findings from Studies That Evaluated Adverse Events of T2D Medications as a Treatment-Related Attribute
| Indicator Influenced | Study (Author, Year) | Treatment Studied | Main Finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initiation | Chen et al, 2020 | Injectable | 37.4% cited being “worried about AEs of injection therapy, such as hypoglycemia and |
| Polonsky et al, 2011 | QW injectable | 55.1% very/extremely likely to be willing to take medication if it “could help you lose weight” (current oral vs injectable users: 44.0% vs 74.1%) and 51.5% if it “could help you to avoid weight gain” (39.3% vs 72.5%) | |
| Adherence | Farmer et al, 2006 | OAD | 13.9% agree/strongly agree with the belief that taking OADs regularly “would lead to my gaining weight”, the only belief evaluated that was significantly correlated with reduced adherence (Spearman’s |
| Flory et al, 2019 | Metformin | Under theme of “motivation”: “other benefits” including weight loss (“When I first started taking metformin, I lost about 50 pounds”) | |
| Gater et al, 2021 | GLP-1/GCG RA | 16% cited weight loss as a reason for willingness to continue treatment | |
| Hauber et al, 2009 | OAD | Medication-related weight gain 1 of only 2 attributes (including heart attack risk) significantly associated with an increased likelihood of missing/skipping doses; a weight gain of 9.0 kg decreased the rate of likely adherence by 30% (95% CI 29.6, 32.3) | |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Injectable | 24% cited AEs (including weight gain) and 19% cited medication concerns (including weight worry) as barriers to adherence | |
| Discontinuation | de Climens et al, 2020 | OAD/injectable | 18% who discontinued treatment due to side effects did so because of weight gaina |
| Sikirica et al, 2017 | GLP-1 RA | 25% discontinued because treatment “did not help weight loss” and 8% because they “caused weight gain” | |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Injectable | 20%/28% cited AEs (including weight gain) and 4%/11% cited medication concerns (including weight worry) as main/contributory reason for discontinuation | |
| Adherence | Farmer et al, 2006 | OAD | 32.8% agree/strongly agree with the belief that taking OADs regularly “would cause me unpleasant side effects such as feeling sick or bloated”; belief not significantly correlated with intention to take medication (Spearman’s |
| Flory et al, 2019 | Metformin | Under theme of “barriers to metformin use”: GI AEs (“The one side effect it gives me which is the runs”) | |
| Hauber et al, 2009 | OAD | Mild stomach upset had no effect on medication adherence | |
| Huang et al, 2020 | Oral/injectable | Under theme “motivation for medication adherence” and subtheme “barriers”: concerns about medication safety including side effects such as GI upset | |
| Spain et al, 2016 | GLP-1 RA | 6–8% cited GI AEs as a barrier to current therapy | |
| Discontinuation | de Climens et al, 2020 | Oral/injectable | 18% of PwD discontinuing treatment because of side effects did so because of GI disorders |
| Gater et al, 2021 | GLP-1/GCG RA | 29% reported vomiting and 21% nausea as reasons for being unwilling to continue therapy | |
| Sikirica et al, 2017 | GLP-1 RA | 64% discontinued because treatment “made me feel sick” and 45% because they “made me throw up” | |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Injectable | AEs most common reason for discontinuation of liraglutide (32%) and exenatide (23%), with nausea and vomiting the main reasons in liraglutide discontinuers (18%) | |
| Initiation | Chen et al, 2020 | Injectable | 37.4% cited being “worried about AEs of injection therapy, such as |
| Polonsky et al, 2011 | QW injectable | 38.5% very/extremely likely to be willing to take medication if “you could have a lower risk of having hypoglycemia” | |
| Adherence | Hauber et al, 2009 | OAD | Mild-to-moderate hypoglycemia negatively impacted medication adherence if it occurred >2 times per month |
| Huang et al, 2020 | Oral/injectable | Under theme of “motivations for adherence” and subtheme “barriers”: concerns about medication side effects such as hypoglycemia impeded adherence | |
| Sajith et al, 2014 | Unspecified | 13.3% cited “other factors” including hypoglycemia as affecting medication adherence | |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Injectable | 24% cited AEs (including hypoglycemia) as a barrier experienced while on therapy | |
| Discontinuation | de Climens et al, 2020 | Oral/injectable | 16% of those discontinuing medications because of side effects did so due to hypoglycemiab |
| Sikirica et al, 2017 | GLP-1 RA | 10% discontinued due to “symptoms of low blood sugar” | |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Injectable | 20%/28% cited AEs (including hypoglycemia) as the main/contributory reason for discontinuation | |
Notes: a6.2% in whole study population; b5.6% in whole study population.
Abbreviations: AE, adverse event; CI, confidence interval; GI, gastrointestinal; GLP-1 RA, glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonist; GLP-1/GCG RA, dual glucagon-like peptide-1/glucagon receptor agonist; OAD, oral antidiabetes drug; PwD, person/people with diabetes; QW, once weekly; T2D, type 2 diabetes.
Overview of Main Findings from Studies That Evaluated Dosing Characteristics (Frequency, Complexity, and Route) of T2D Medications as a Treatment-Related Attribute
| Indicator Influenced | Study (Author, Year) | Treatment Studied | Main Finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initiation | Chen et al, 2020 | Injectable | 58% reported inconvenience of daily injections as a concern regarding initiation |
| Polonsky et al, 2011 | QW injectable | 36.5% agreed/strongly agreed that “QW medication could help me stick to my blood glucose-lowering medications better” | |
| Kubo et al, 2019 | OAD | Important factors when considering an OAD in drug-naïve PwD: “has a weekly dosing schedule” (5.2%); “don’t have to take it every day” (10.4%); “has a daily dosing schedule” (12.1%); “less frequent dosing schedule” (32.9%) | |
| Adherence | Dehdari and Dehdari, 2019 | Unspecified | Under theme “perceived barriers to adherence” and subtheme “treatment characteristics”: PwD indicated that taking medications several times a day may affect adherence |
| Hauber et al, 2013 | OAD | Higher likelihood of non-adherence with less convenient dosing (fewer pills and lower frequency) | |
| Jarab et al, 2018 | Oral/injectable | Under theme “barriers to adherence”: many PwD related non-adherence to frequency of administration (“If it could be made that you can take all your medicines in one go that would be better than having different periods”) | |
| Kubo et al, 2019 | OAD | Important factors when considering an OAD in current users: “has a weekly dosing schedule” (4.3%); “don’t have to take it every day” (4.0%); “has a daily dosing schedule” (37.3%); “less frequent dosing schedule” (28.4%) | |
| Sajith et al, 2014 | Unspecified | 18.1% reported “frequency of dosing/increasing number of dosing times” as a factor affecting adherence | |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Injectable | 30% cited “burden/inconvenience” (including dose frequency) as a barrier experienced on therapy | |
| Discontinuation | Sikirica et al, 2017 | GLP-1 RA | 20.1% discontinued because “regular injections were too inconvenient” |
| Spain et al, 2016 | Injectable | 4%/11% cited “burden/inconvenience” (including dose frequency) as a main/contributory reason for discontinuation | |
| Initiation | Polonsky et al, 2011 | QW injectable | 61.3% agreed/strongly agreed that “QW medication could make taking that specific blood glucose-lowering medication more convenient”; 38.3% very/extremely likely to be willing to initiate medication “if it reduced number of daily OADs” |
| Kubo et al, 2019 | OAD | 31.2% of drug-naïve PwD cited treatment being “easy to take or administer” an important factor when considering an OAD; 4.3% cited “drug is more convenient to take” and 8.7% “I wouldn’t have to take as many medications” as motivations for initiation | |
| Adherence | Barba et al, 2017 | Oral/injectable | 81.6% reported “complexity of administration” and 57.2% “complexity of medication container” as important factors associated with adherence |
| Hauber et al, 2013 | OAD | Higher likelihood of non-adherence with less convenient dosing (fewer pills and lower frequency) | |
| Huang et al, 2020 | Oral/injectable | Under theme of “other barriers” and subtheme of “barriers”: complexity of regimen (comprising type, frequency, quantity, and size) suggested as an impediment to adherence | |
| Kubo et al, 2019 | OAD | 39.6% of current users cited treatment being “easy to take or administer” an important factor when considering an OAD; 21.5% cited “drug is more convenient to take” and 6.3% “I wouldn’t have to take as many medications” as motivations for continuing treatment | |
| Sajith et al, 2014 | Unspecified | 19.1% cited “complexity of medication regimen” and 25.7% “number of medications/too much medication” as factors affecting medication adherence | |
| Adherence | Dehdari and Dehdari, 2019 | Unspecified | Under theme of “medication beliefs” and subtheme “prioritizing use of pills instead of insulin injection”: preference for pills was identified as a variable influencing adherence (“Pills are [less] bothering than seeing the injection”) |
| Jarab et al, 2018 | Oral/injectable | Under theme “barriers to adherence”, many PwD related non-adherence to route of administration, preferring any other route than injectable (“I would prefer it if it wasn’t for the needle. If there was another way of taking it”) | |
| Discontinuation | Sikirica et al, 2017 | GLP-1 RA | 39.7% stated that preferring oral medication over injections was a reason for discontinuation |
Abbreviations: GLP-1 RA, glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonist; OAD, oral antidiabetes drug; PwD, person/people with diabetes; QW, once weekly; T2D, type 2 diabetes.