| Literature DB >> 35954640 |
Kara M Moran1, Pricila H Mullachery2, Stephen Lankenau3, Usama Bilal2,4.
Abstract
Opioid use disorders (OUDs) are increasingly common among minoritized populations, who have historically experienced limited access to healthcare, a situation that may have worsened during the COVID-19 pandemic. Using a structured keyword search in Pubmed, we reviewed the literature to synthesize the evidence on changes in racial/ethnic disparities in OUD-related outcomes in urban areas during the COVID-19 pandemic in the US. Nine articles were included in the final analysis. Six found increases in OUD-related outcomes during the pandemic, with four showing a widening of disparities. Results also point to the worsening of opioid outcomes among Black and Latinx individuals related to shelter-in-place or stay-at-home orders. Studies examining the use of telehealth and access to OUD treatment showed that minoritized groups have benefited from telehealth programs. The limited number of studies in a small number of jurisdictions indicate a gap in research examining the intersection between COVID-19 and OUD-related outcomes with a focus on disparities. More research is needed to understand the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and related policies on OUD outcomes among racial/ethnic minoritized groups, including examining the impact of service disruptions on vulnerable groups with OUD.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; health disparities; opioid use disorders; urban health
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35954640 PMCID: PMC9368442 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19159283
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 4.614
Figure 1Flowchart of study inclusion.
Overall characteristics and scope of the studies.
| Study | Scope | Period | Race/Ethnicity Groups | Outcomes | Study Setting/Data Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Friedman et al., 2021 [ | Overall impact of the pandemic. | Data from 2020 were compared to baseline values in 2018 and 2019. | Latinx, Black, White | Overdose-associated cardiac arrests | US population. Data were from the National Emergency Medical Services Information system. |
| Handberry et al., 2021 [ | Overall impact of the pandemic. | Data from 2020 were compared to baseline values in 2018 and 2019. | American Indian/Alaska Native, Asian, Black/African American, Hispanic/Latino, Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander, and White. | 911 calls/EMS activations related to opioid use | US population. Data were from the National Emergency Medical Services Information system. |
| Ochalek et al., 2020 [ | Overall impact of the pandemic. | Data from 1 March to 30 June 2020, were compared to the same period in 2019. | Black/African American, White, Hispanic, Asian, American Indian or Alaska Native, more than 1 race/ethnicity | Non-fatal opioid overdoses | Population served by an urban emergency department in Virginia. Data were from electronic medical records. |
| Appa et al., 2021 [ | Specific to mitigation policies (shelter-in-place order). | 2019–2020 (monthly data). Specifically, 8.5 calendar months before and after the shelter-in-place order on 17 March 2020. | Asian, Black, White/Latinx, Other, Unknown | Unintentional overdose deaths | San Francisco population. Data were from the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. |
| Glober et al., 2020 [ | Specific to mitigation policies (stay-at-home order). | 2019–July 2020 (daily data). Data were analyzed in two periods: 122-day period directly preceding the stay-at-home order on 25 March, 2020, and the 122-day period after the order. | Black, White, Other | Unintentional overdose deaths | Indianapolis population. Data was from EMS System. |
| Genberg et al., 2021 [ | Specific to mitigation policies (stay-at-home). | April–June 2020 | Black, Non-Black | Substance use rates | Current and former people who inject drugs in Baltimore. Data were from a phone survey. |
| Khatri et al., 2021 [ | Specific to mitigation policies (stay-at-home). | 2019–June 2020 (monthly data). Data were analyzed in three periods, before and after the stay-at-home in March 2020, and April to June 2019. | Non-Hispanic Black, Non-Hispanic White, Hispanic | Unintentional overdose deaths and nonfatal overdoses | Philadelphia population. Data on overdose deaths were from the Philadelphia Medical Examiner’s Office and non-fatal overdoses were from EMS. |
| Mehtani et al., 2021 [ | Specific to mitigation policies (Telehealth). | 10 April–25 May 2020. | Black and Non-Black | Untreated OUD in isolation and quarantine sites | San Francisco population. Data were from telehealth encounters from electronic medical record and data from the San Francisco Department of Public Health. |
| O’Gurek and David, 2021 [ | Specific to mitigation policies (Telehealth). | Data from 16 March–30 April 2020, were compared to data from 1 January–13 March 2020. | White, Hispanic non-white, African American | Medical center visits | Population served by an urban office-based opioid treatment program. Data were from patient chart review. |
Notes: EMS—emergency medical service.
Summary of study results.
| Study | Results Summary | Result (More Detail) |
|---|---|---|
| Ochalek et al., 2020 [ | The total number of nonfatal opioid overdose visits increased during the pandemic. Among patients who presented with a nonfatal opioid overdose in 2019 and 2020, 64 (63%) and 181 (80%) were Black, respectively, vs. 29 (28%) and 32 (14%) who were white. | |
| Handberry et al., 2021 [ | 911 opioid use/overdose EMS activations were higher starting on March 2020 compared to pre-pandemic levels. When examined by race/ethnicity, opioid-use-related activations increased more among Asian, Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander, and Alaskan Indian/American Native, and least among white and Black/African American. | |
| Khatri et al., 2021 [ | The stay-at-home order was associated with increases in opioid overdose among non-Hispanic Black individuals but decreases among non-Hispanic white individuals. This represents the first time in recent history in Philadelphia that the absolute number of overdose deaths was higher among non-Hispanic Black individuals than among non-Hispanic white individuals. | |
| Friedman et al., 2021 [ | Overdose-associated cardiac arrests increased by 42.1% nationally in 2020. The highest percentage increases were seen among Latinx and Black individuals. | |
| Appa et al., 2021 [ | The median number of weekly overdose deaths increased by 50% after the shelter-in-place order. While the proportion of Black decedents slightly decreased after the shelter-in-place order, the death rate was still disproportionately high for Black vs. white residents. | |
| Glober et al., 2020 [ | Overdose-related calls for EMS and EMS naloxone administration increased during and after the Indiana stay-at-home order. Overdose-related calls increased by 43% and naloxone administration increased by 61% after the stay-at-home order. Deaths from drug overdoses increased by 47%. | |
| O’Gurek and David, 2021 [ | No-show rate in the office-based opioid treatment program reduced from 26% to 8% after the implementation of a telemedicine protocol. No-show rates reduced for all race/ethnicity groups. | |
| Mehtani et al., 2021 [ | Telehealth was used on the management substance use disorders for 59 guests in isolation and quarantine sites. Twelve patients were identified with untreated opioid use disorder and newly prescribed buprenorphine. Of these, all were marginally housed, 67% were Black, and 58% had never previously been prescribed medications for OUD. | |
| Genberg et al., 2021 [ | Black individuals who inject drugs were more likely than non-Black individuals to socially distance (73% vs. 48%) and use when alone (68% vs.35%). |
Notes: EMS—emergency medical service; PWID—people who inject drugs.