| Literature DB >> 35947543 |
Long H Nguyen1,2,3, Adjoa Anyane-Yeboa1,2, Kerstin Klaser4, Jordi Merino5,6,7, David A Drew1,2, Wenjie Ma1,3, Raaj S Mehta1,2,3, Daniel Y Kim1, Erica T Warner1,8, Amit D Joshi1, Mark S Graham4, Carole H Sudre4, Ellen J Thompson9, Anna May10, Christina Hu10, Solveig Jørgensen10, Somesh Selvachandran10, Sarah E Berry11, Sean P David12, Maria Elena Martinez13,14, Jane C Figueiredo15, Anne M Murray16,17, Alan R Sanders18,19, Karestan C Koenen20, Jonathan Wolf10, Sebastien Ourselin4, Tim D Spector8, Claire J Steves8, Andrew T Chan1,2,21,22.
Abstract
Racial/ethnic minorities have been disproportionately impacted by COVID-19. The effects of COVID-19 on the long-term mental health of minorities remains unclear. To evaluate differences in odds of screening positive for depression and anxiety among various racial and ethnic groups during the latter phase of the COVID-19 pandemic, we performed a cross-sectional analysis of 691,473 participants nested within the prospective smartphone-based COVID Symptom Study in the United States (U.S.) and United Kingdom (U.K). from February 23, 2021 to June 9, 2021. In the U.S. (n=57,187), compared to White participants, the multivariable odds ratios (ORs) for screening positive for depression were 1·16 (95% CI: 1·02 to 1·31) for Black, 1·23 (1·11 to 1·36) for Hispanic, and 1·15 (1·02 to 1·30) for Asian participants, and 1·34 (1·13 to 1·59) for participants reporting more than one race/other even after accounting for personal factors such as prior history of a mental health disorder, COVID-19 infection status, and surrounding lockdown stringency. Rates of screening positive for anxiety were comparable. In the U.K. (n=643,286), racial/ethnic minorities had similarly elevated rates of positive screening for depression and anxiety. These disparities were not fully explained by changes in leisure time activities. Racial/ethnic minorities bore a disproportionate mental health burden during the COVID-19 pandemic. These differences will need to be considered as health care systems transition from prioritizing infection control to mitigating long-term consequences.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35947543 PMCID: PMC9365178 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0271661
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.752
Baseline characteristics of study participants by race and ethnicity according to country of enrollment.
| United States | United Kingdom | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| White | Black | Hispanic | Asian | Other | White | Black | South Asian | Middle East/East Asian | Other | |
|
| 50410 | 1664 | 2239 | 2157 | 717 | 614902 | 3669 | 6231 | 2885 | 6599 |
|
| 61·7 (13·7) | 60·5 (13·9) | 52·4 (17·0) | 58·3 (19·1) | 59·0 (15·3) | 56·6 (13·2) | 50·5 (13·2) | 50·8 (13·8) | 50·7 (14·3) | 50·2 (13·8) |
| <25 | 654 (1·3) | 45 (2·7) | 138 (6·2) | 163 (7·6) | 18 (2·5) | 7451 (1·2) | 117 (3·2) | 166 (2·7) | 72 (2·5) | 198 (3·0) |
| 25-34 | 2164 (4·3) | 59 (3·5) | 269 (12·0) | 186 (8·6) | 41 (5·7) | 35342 (5·7) | 399 (10·9) | 643 (10·3) | 358 (12·4) | 761 (11·5) |
| 35-44 | 4095 (8·1) | 115 (6·9) | 332 (14·8) | 219 (10·2) | 83 (11·6) | 74032 (12·0) | 600 (16·4) | 1311 (21·0) | 600 (20·8) | 1358 (20·6) |
| 45-54 | 5723 (11·4) | 234 (14·1) | 402 (18·0) | 252 (11·7) | 98 (13·7) | 126942 (20·6) | 975 (26·6) | 1652 (26·5) | 683 (23·7) | 1591 (24·1) |
| 55-64 | 11223 (22·3) | 469 (28·2) | 454 (20·3) | 268 (12·4) | 155 (21·6) | 180790 (29·4) | 1110 (30·3) | 1340 (21·5) | 601 (20·8) | 1618 (24·5) |
| 65-74 | 19583 (38·8) | 535 (32·2) | 448 (20·0) | 518 (24·0) | 230 (32·1) | 152242 (24·8) | 380 (10·4) | 887 (14·2) | 464 (16·1) | 895 (13·6) |
| ≥75 | 6968 (13·8) | 207 (12·4) | 196 (8·8) | 551 (25·5) | 92 (12·8) | 38103 (6·2) | 88 (2·4) | 232 (3·7) | 107 (3·7) | 178 (2·7) |
|
| 37566 (74·5) | 1394 (83·8) | 1551 (69·3) | 1382 (64·1) | 514 (71·7) | 410263 (66·7) | 2499 (68·1) | 3737 (60·0) | 1833 (63·5) | 4545 (68·9) |
|
| 27·1 (6·3) | 30·0 (7·1) | 28·0 (6·6) | 25·2 (5·3) | 28·4 (689) | 26·8 (6·3) | 28·5 (7·8) | 25·7 (6·1) | 25·4 (6·3) | 26·6 (7·2) |
| <18.5 | 892 (1·8) | 18 (1·1) | 52 (2·3) | 74 (3·4) | 14 (2·0) | 12203 (2·0) | 80 (2·2) | 259 (4·2) | 104 (3·6) | 181 (2·7) |
| 18·5-24·9 | 20940 (41·5) | 392 (23·6) | 774 (34·6) | 1147 (53·2) | 224 (31·2) | 263631 (42·9) | 1252 (34·1) | 3058 (49·1) | 1545 (53·6) | 3109 (47·1) |
| 25-29·9 | 16272 (32·3) | 541 (32·5) | 728 (32·5) | 638 (29·6) | 260 (36·3) | 206401 (33·6) | 1208 (32·9) | 1920 (30·8) | 823 (28·5) | 1971 (29·9) |
| ≥30 | 12306 (24·4) | 713 (42·8) | 685 (30·6) | 298 (13·8) | 219 (30·5) | 132667 (21·6) | 1129 (30·8) | 994 (16·0) | 413 (14·3) | 1338 (20·3) |
|
| ||||||||||
| Diabetes | 2376 (4·7) | 189 (11·4) | 132 (5·9) | 177 (8·2) | 48 (6·7) | 20470 (3·3) | 182 (5·0) | 449 (7·2) | 100 (3·5) | 235 (3·6) |
| Heart Disease | 3560 (7·1) | 110 (6·6) | 122 (5·4) | 166 (7·7) | 58 (8·1) | 22433 (3·6) | 99 (2·7) | 288 (4·6) | 100 (3·5) | 202 (3·1) |
| Lung Disease | 1414 (2·8) | 47 (2·8) | 35 (1·6) | 40 (1·9) | 29 (4·1) | 12627 (2·1) | 64 (1·7) | 111 (1·8) | 54 (1·9) | 111 (1·7) |
| Kidney Disease | 901 (1·8) | 41 (2·5) | 39 (1·7) | 48 (2·2) | 20 (2·8) | 5524 (0·9) | 47 (1·3) | 71 (1·1) | 27 (0·9) | 49 (0·7) |
| Cancer | 1389 (2·8) | 43 (2·6) | 46 (2·1) | 48 (2·2) | 17 (2·4) | 7218 (2·0) | 45 (2·2) | 55 (1·7) | 20 (1·4) | 52 (1·6) |
|
| 45·9 (18·4) | 35·9 (17·6) | 40·1 (19·0) | 46·7 (17·6) | 43·9 (19·0) | 7·2 (2·5) | 6·6 (2·6) | 7·38 (2·45) | 7·63 (2·32) | 7·41 (2·40) |
|
| 812881 (314746) | 67947 (286326) | 761936 (312160) | 89695 (31792) | 777624 (290122) | 7·0 (2·5) | 5·64 (2·70) | 6·5 (2·6) | 6·6 (2·6) | 6·5 (2·6) |
|
| 59·0 (7·5) | 57·9 (6·5) | 58·6 (7·0) | 64·6 (9·1) | 59·6 (8·0) | 86·4 (3·0) | 86·3 (3·2) | 86·4 (3·1) | 86·5 (3·0) | 86·3 (3·2) |
|
| 14520 (28·8) | 474 (28·5) | 577 (25·8) | 548 (25·4) | 247 (34·4) | 125141 (20·4) | 773 (21·1) | 841 (13·5) | 493 (17·1) | 1314 (19·9) |
|
| 3957 (7·8) | 137 (8·2) | 195 (8·7) | 152 (7·0) | 56 (7·8) | 24837 (4·0) | 209 (5·7) | 440 (7·1) | 152 (5·3) | 254 (3·8) |
|
| 2684 (5·3) | 119 (7·2) | 255 (11·4) | 89 (4·1) | 41 (5·7) | 33727 (5·5) | 343 (9·3) | 537 (8·6) | 210 (7·3) | 489 (7·4) |
|
| 14457 (28·7) | 379 (22·8) | 637 (28·5) | 375 (17·4) | 259 (36·2) | 132514 (21·6) | 875 (23·9) | 930 (14·9) | 432 (15·0) | 1591 (24·1) |
In the U.S., all racial categories were defined as each respective race not of Hispanic or Latino ancestry, and census-level data on education assessed the proportion of the general population above age 25 years with a Bachelor’s degree and income using median annual household income (U.S. dollars/year). In the U.K., census-level data on education used the education and income scores for the Index of Multiple Deprivation, respectively. Lockdown stringency was assessed using the Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker’s index for overall government response at the time of mental health questionnaire completion. N (percentages) presented for categorical variables. Values are means (SD) for continuous variables. Values of polytomous variables may not sum to 100% due to rounding. Abbreviations: BMI (body mass index), m (meter), kg (kilogram).
PHQ and GAD scores by race and ethnicity according to country of enrollment.
|
| ||||||
|
|
|
|
|
| ||
|
| 6325/50410 (13%) | 263/1664 (16%) | 443/2239 (20%) | 292/2157 (14%) | 146/717 (20%) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·21 (1·07 to 1·37) | 1·23 (1·12 to 1·36) | 0·92 (0·82 to 1·04) | 1·55 (1·32 to 1·83) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·16 (1·02 to 1·31) | 1·23 (1·11 to 1·36) | 1·15 (1·02 to 1·30) | 1·34 (1·13 to 1·59) | |
|
| 7338/50410 (15%) | 259/1664 (16%) | 544/2239 (24%) | 289/2157 (13%) | 142/717 (20%) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·01 (0·89 to 1·15) | 1·17 (1·07 to 1·28) | 0·73 (0·64 to 0·82) | 1·23 (1·04 to 1·45) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·01 (0·89 to 1·14) | 1·23 (1·12 to 1·35) | 0·91 (0·81 to 1·03) | 1·12 (0·94 to 1·32) | |
|
| ||||||
|
|
|
|
|
| ||
|
| 115277/614902 (19%) | 890/3669 (24%) | 1529/6231 (25%) | 665/2885 (23%) | 1477/6599 (22%) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·18 (1·11 to 1·26) | 1·20 (1·14 to 1·26) | 1·11 (1·03 to 1·20) | 1·07 (1·02 to 1·13) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·09 (1·01 to 1·17) | 1·36 (1·29 to 1·44) | 1·30 (1·20 to 1·41) | 1·11 (1·05 to 1·17) | |
|
| 107468/614902 (17%) | 848/3669 (23%) | 1402/6231 (23%) | 585/2885 (20%) | 1501/6599 (23%) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·13 (1·06 to 1·21) | 1·10 (1·04 to 1·15) | 0·97 (0·89 to 1·05) | 1·10 (1·04 to 1·15) | |
|
| 1·0 [ref.] | 1·07 (1·00 to 1·15) | 1·26 (1·19 to 1·33) | 1·11 (1·02 to 1·21) | 1·11 (1·05 to 1·17) | |
1Conditioned upon age and date of mental health questionnaire completion.
2Additional conditioning upon sex and adjustment for personal history of mental health diagnosis, diabetes, heart disease, lung disease, kidney disease, current smoking status, body mass index, prior reported history of COVID-19 infection, and HCW status, as well as education, income, and lockdown stringency at the community level.
Abbreviations: CI (confidence interval), OR (odds ratio), PHQ-2 (Patient Health Questionnaire-2), GAD-2 (Generalized Anxiety Disorder 2-item).