Jan Hagemann1, Torsten Zuberbier2,3, Giorgio Walter Canonica4,5, Hubert Blain6, Jean Bousquet2,3,6, Ludger Klimek1,7. 1. Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Universitätsmedizin Mainz, Mainz, Germany. 2. Institute of Allergology, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Corporate Member of Freie Universität Berlin and Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Berlin, Germany. 3. Allergology and Immunology, Fraunhofer Institute for Translational Medicine and Pharmacology ITMP, Berlin, Germany. 4. Department of Biomedical Sciences, Humanitas University, Pieve Emanuele, Milan, Italy. 5. IRCCS Humanitas Research Hospital, Rozzano, Milan, Italy. 6. University Hospital Montpellier, Montpellier, France. 7. Center for Rhinology and Allergology, Wiesbaden, Germany.
In their correspondence,
the authors correctly point out that symptoms of COVID‐19 are changing constantly over time due to various influences, in particular variants of concern (VOC), environmental factors and vaccinations against the SARS‐CoV‐2. These evolutions happen globally and rapidly, and peer‐reviewed manuscripts can often not compete against newer app‐based reports of changing symptoms and VOC. The data collection for our paper took place at the end of 2020 when no vaccinations were available aside from clinical trials.
The study was intended to identify symptoms that might separate COVID‐19 from allergic rhinitis (AR) and common cold (CC), which are still seen as major concerns.We would like to emphasise the importance of regional differences as well, since in the first reports of COVID‐19, smell and taste dysfunctions were merely absent from China,
whereas they appeared to be of great importance in European countries.
,
However, symptom reports from ZOE and REACT are over‐representing the United Kingdom, compared with other regions, and should be considered with a careful analysis of its origin and transferability to other situations. The ARIA‐EAACI‐GA2LEN consensus did include different regions across the globe.The authors of the correspondence
are correct to point the possible importance of vaccination. However, vaccination may not be a major factor to consider since, as shown by the authors in their table, vaccination did not considerably change the symptoms of ZOE in nonvaccinated and vaccinated people aside from one item. ‘ZOE 2 vaccinations’ might comprise a time‐dependent bias as new VOC could have emerged in‐between vaccinations.It is of great interest to read Table 1 corresp. provided by the authors of the letter though it appears to be somewhat misleading.
(i) In our paper, specialists were asked to grade symptom levels and analyses that assessed the level of debate or agreement to those symptom levels in question. In our paper, we did not consider several items presented in the table concerning respiratory symptoms (e.g. headache, chills and fever), but we highlighted those clearly established when the study was done in table 3. Headache was not yet considered a major factor since most studies were carried out on severe Covid‐19.
(ii) We do not understand the list of items presented in the table since it is not in line with what we published. We proposed ‘no symptom’, ‘very rare symptoms’, ‘not uncommon symptoms’ and ‘possible symptoms’ (Table 1consensus), and then, we proposed a severity assessment. (iii) Moreover, there is a major issue in the table since in September 2021, several VOCs were found, yet not considered by the authors. In a new study using the same methods, we found significant differences in symptoms with wild‐type, delta and omicron variants (paper in preparation). (iv) The REACT paper referred to the table deals with long COVID.Overall, the correspondence points out important issues and limitations, but it might have been more precise concerning variants of interest in a rapidly changing field and geographical locations. We are grateful for these remarks that have to be translated into the improved presentation of data and an ongoing debate about symptoms that has to take VOC into consideration.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
JB and JH drafted the manuscript, which all authors then edited and revised critically.
Authors: Rupert Jones; Andrew Davis; Brooklyn Stanley; Steven Julious; Dermot Ryan; David J Jackson; David M G Halpin; Katherine Hickman; Hilary Pinnock; Jennifer K Quint; Kamlesh Khunti; Liam G Heaney; Phillip Oliver; Salman Siddiqui; Ian Pavord; David H M Jones; Michael Hyland; Lewis Ritchie; Pam Young; Tony Megaw; Steve Davis; Samantha Walker; Stephen Holgate; Sue Beecroft; Anu Kemppinen; Francis Appiagyei; Emma-Jane Roberts; Megan Preston; Antony Hardjojo; Victoria Carter; Marije van Melle; David Price Journal: Pragmat Obs Res Date: 2021-08-11
Authors: Jan Hagemann; Gabrielle L Onorato; Marek Jutel; Cezmi A Akdis; Ioana Agache; Torsten Zuberbier; Wienczyslawa Czarlewski; Joaquim Mullol; Anna Bedbrook; Claus Bachert; Kazi S Bennoor; Karl-Christian Bergmann; Fulvio Braido; Paulo Camargos; Luis Caraballo; Victoria Cardona; Thomas Casale; Lorenzo Cecchi; Tomas Chivato; Derek K Chu; Cemal Cingi; Jaime Correia-de-Sousa; Stefano Del Giacco; Dejan Dokic; Mark Dykewicz; Motohiro Ebisawa; Yehia El-Gamal; Regina Emuzyte; Jean-Luc Fauquert; Alessandro Fiocchi; Wytske J Fokkens; Joao A Fonseca; Bilun Gemicioglu; René-Maximiliano Gomez; Maia Gotua; Tari Haahtela; Eckard Hamelmann; Tomohisa Iinuma; Juan Carlos Ivancevich; Ewa Jassem; Omer Kalayci; Przemyslaw Kardas; Musa Khaitov; Piotr Kuna; Violeta Kvedariene; Desiree E Larenas-Linnemann; Brian Lipworth; Michael Makris; Jorge F Maspero; Neven Miculinic; Florin Mihaltan; Yousser Mohammad; Stephen Montefort; Mario Morais-Almeida; Ralph Mösges; Robert Naclerio; Hugo Neffen; Marek Niedoszytko; Robyn E O'Hehir; Ken Ohta; Yoshitaka Okamoto; Kimi Okubo; Petr Panzner; Nikolaos G Papadopoulos; Giovanni Passalacqua; Vincenzo Patella; Ana Pereira; Oliver Pfaar; Davor Plavec; Todor A Popov; Emmanuel P Prokopakis; Francesca Puggioni; Filip Raciborski; Jere Reijula; Frederico S Regateiro; Sietze Reitsma; Antonino Romano; Nelson Rosario; Menachem Rottem; Dermot Ryan; Boleslaw Samolinski; Joaquin Sastre; Dirceu Solé; Milan Sova; Cristiana Stellato; Charlotte Suppli-Ulrik; Ioanna Tsiligianni; Antonio Valero; Arunas Valiulis; Erkka Valovirta; Tuula Vasankari; Maria Teresa Ventura; Dana Wallace; De Yun Wang; Siân Williams; Arzu Yorgancioglu; Osman M Yusuf; Mario Zernotti; Jean Bousquet; Ludger Klimek Journal: Allergy Date: 2021-05-14 Impact factor: 14.710