| Literature DB >> 35924607 |
Ben Sebothoma1, Katijah Khoza-Shangase.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic is the latest public health emergency that has presented challenges globally. Limited evidence exists on the association between COVID-19 and middle ear pathologies, regardless of the respiratory nature of some of the core symptoms.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; middle ear function; pathology; scoping review; symptoms
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35924607 PMCID: PMC9350185 DOI: 10.4102/sajcd.v69i2.910
Source DB: PubMed Journal: S Afr J Commun Disord ISSN: 0379-8046
Details of study characteristics of each study included.
| Author | Study title | Aim of study | Study design | Country | Signs and symptoms | Conclusion | Recommendations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bhatta et al. ( | Study of Hearing Status in COVID-19 Patients: | To evaluate the hearing status of COVID-19 patients and compare with control group (pure tone audiogram and impedance audiometry of COVID-19 patients performed initially and at 3 months follow-up) | A Multicentred review. | Nepal and India | Aural symptoms were: aural fullness in 1.4%, hearing loss in 3.9%, and earache in 1.8% were present initially, resolved at 3 months follow-up. Impedance audiometry: type B and type C tympanograms in 5.1% and 1.15% ears, and out of these 64.7% and 40% improved at 3 months follow up, respectively. 3.2% with mild CHL, but no significant difference observed between the average air conduction and bone conduction of the COVID-19 patients and control group. | The COVID-19 infection may present with aural symptoms; however, it was concluded that there was no significant difference in the hearing status of the COVID-19 positive patients in comparison with the control group. The presence of some changes in the normal functioning of the eustachian tube and middle ear in the COVID-19 infection was also highlighted. | - |
| Boroujeni et al. ( | Acute otitis media and COVID-19 symptoms: a case report | To present a 39-year-old case of a female patient complaining of earache and hearing loss with no other COVID-19 symptoms. | Case report | Isfahan, Iran | Complained of sense of fullness, hearing loss in the left ear. Redness and bulging of TM noted. Type B tymp, absent reflexes and mild to mod-severe CHL | Acute otitis media can be the only symptom in the absence of common COVID-19 symptoms. Because COVID-19 has been identified as a known cause of upper respiratory infection, otitis media could be expected. Prolongation of patients’ nasopharyngeal and eustachian tube tissues’ oedema caused by possible COVID-19 induced disorders in the mucociliary and immune system performance leads to negative pressure, thus causing the middle ear to become susceptible to secondary viral and bacterial infections. | COVID-19 should also be suspected where the only observed symptom is earache with hearing loss. |
| Dharmarajan et al. ( | Hearing loss – a Camouflaged manifestation of COVID-19 infection | To assess the audiological profile among 100 mild to moderately affected COVID-19 individuals, so as to make a contribution to the emerging literature on otologic manifestations in COVID-19. | Case series | India | Otoscopic examination showed normal external auditory canal and tympanic membrane in 95 patients, 4 patients had retracted TM, and 2 had dull TM. 6 patients had CHL. 18 had a referred OAE | Early identification and intervention if required help to give a better quality of life to the patient | - |
| Enrique, Margarita, Ángel, Saturnino and Jesús ( | COVID-19 and severe ENT infections in paediatric patients. IS there a relationship? | To determine whether there is a relationship between COVID-19 and severe infections in the ear, nose, throat and deep cervical area (ENT) in paediatric populations | Retrospective observation study | Spain | Found a significant outbreak in the incidence of complicated mastoiditis and deep cervical infections with complications in the year 2020 (13 patients) linked to the COVID-19 pandemic. | The limitations in primary care due to a shortage of human resources in dealing with the pandemic’s initial onslaught and changes in help-seeking behaviour could explain increased complicated infections. | - |
| Fidan ( | New type of COVID-19 induced acute otitis media in adult. | To present an adult case with COVID-19 with otitis media, without any classical COVID-19 symptoms | Case report | Turkey | Presented with otalgia and tinnitus, Hyperaemia and bulging TM. Type B tymp and CHL in the right ear | COVID-19 can manifest itself with different findings, without the classic symptoms, and complete body examination is most important in the evaluation of patients | - |
| Maharaj, Bello Alvarez, Mungul, and Hari ( | Otologic dysfunction in patients with COVID-19: | To describe otologic dysfunction in patients with the novel SARS-CoV-2. | Systematic review | N/A | There were 28 patients in total identified with the largest study comprising 20 patients. All patients presented with hearing loss | SARS-CoV-2 is a probable cause of middle ear infections and sensorineural hearing loss, secondary to spread of the novel virus into the middle ear and related neural structures. Currently, there is no evidence supporting the presence of SARS-CoV-2 in the middle ear, but findings of this review implicate the virus as a potential source of otologic disorders. Mechanism of hearing loss in this case was a middle ear effusion secondary to an ascending nasopharyngeal infection | - |
| Raad, Ghorbani, Mikaniki, Haseli and Karimi-Galougahi ( | Otitis media in coronavirus disease 2019: A case series | To assess the presence of otitis media in a series of patients with confirmed COVID-19 and ENT symptoms | Case series | Iran | The present case series includes eight patients who presented over a 2-month COVID-19 pandemic period. Six of the eight patients had otalgia, and seven had HL. Middle ear effusion was evident in six patients on otoscopic examination. Three patients had typical signs of acute otitis media, one had acute otitis media with TM perforation. Most patients had CHL | Otitis media should be considered a manifestation or associated symptom of COVID-19 during the current pandemic | Otitis media was the first manifestation of COVID-19 in some patients in this case series. Thus, it is recommended that during the current pandemic, the presence of otitis media should alert clinicians to the possibility of Covid-19 |
| Wanna et al. (2021) | COVID-19 sampling from the middle ear and mastoid: A case report | To report the case of a recently hospitalised COVID-19 positive patient with a previous history of canal-wall down mastoidectomy for cholesteatoma who required mastoid cavity debridement | - | - | Patient present with aural fullness, and purulent otorrhea | More investigation is needed prior to making definitive recommendations on middle ear or mastoid manipulation in the COVID-19 positive patient | - |
COVID-19, coronavirus disease 2019; CHL, conductive hearing loss; OAE, Otoacoustic emissions; ENT, Ear, Nose and Throat; SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2; HL, hearing loss.
Details of the study test procedure for determining middle ear pathologies (MEP).
| Author | Test procedure |
|---|---|
| Bhatta et al. ( | Case history, pure tones and impedance audiometry |
| Boroujeni et al. ( | Otorhinolaryngological examination, tympanometry and pure tone audiometry |
| Dharmarajan et al. ( | Clinical examination, pure tone audiometry and transient evoked otoacoustic emission |
| Enrique et al. ( | Retrospective analysis of the clinical history |
| Fidan ( | Otorhinolaryngological examination, tympanometry and pure tone audiometry |
| Maharaj et al. ( | Description of various studies’ results |
| Raad et al. ( | Otorhinolaryngological examination and case history |
| Wanna et al. ( | Otorhinolaryngological examination and case history |
FIGURE 1The PRISMA flow diagram describing the process of study selection.