Sitthipong Srisajjakul1, Patcharin Prapaisilp2, Sirikan Bangchokdee3. 1. Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine Siriraj Hospital, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand. tiam.mahidol@gmail.com. 2. Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine Siriraj Hospital, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand. 3. Department of Internal Medicine, Pratumthani Hospital, Bang Prok, Thailand.
Abstract
Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) is a chronic inflammatory skin disease involving apocrine-bearing sites. It is characterized by recurrent painful nodules and abscesses that potentially rupture, resulting in sinus tract formation, fistulas, and scarring. HS tends to be found in the intertriginous areas (i.e., the axillary, inguinal, and perianal areas of the body). HS may be uncommon for radiologists because its diagnosis is usually based on clinical assessment. However, diagnosis based solely on clinical manifestations can underestimate the severity of HS. Ultrasonography and MRI play a critical adjunct role in determining the severity and extent of the disease and greatly aid its management. Given that MRI is an effective imaging tool, its role in the analysis of severe and anogenital HS lesions merits considerable attention. Unfortunately, anoperineal HS imposes diagnostic dilemmas. It has multiple symptoms and presentations and often mimics other diseases in the intertriginous areas. Therefore, a thorough understanding of HS is essential to avoid delayed diagnoses. This review highlights the typical MRI imaging features and staging of HS, emphasizing on the anoperineal location. The review also differentiates the disease from mimics to facilitate the prompt delivery of appropriate treatment and improve patients' quality of life.
Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) is a chronic inflammatory skin disease involving apocrine-bearing sites. It is characterized by recurrent painful nodules and abscesses that potentially rupture, resulting in sinus tract formation, fistulas, and scarring. HS tends to be found in the intertriginous areas (i.e., the axillary, inguinal, and perianal areas of the body). HS may be uncommon for radiologists because its diagnosis is usually based on clinical assessment. However, diagnosis based solely on clinical manifestations can underestimate the severity of HS. Ultrasonography and MRI play a critical adjunct role in determining the severity and extent of the disease and greatly aid its management. Given that MRI is an effective imaging tool, its role in the analysis of severe and anogenital HS lesions merits considerable attention. Unfortunately, anoperineal HS imposes diagnostic dilemmas. It has multiple symptoms and presentations and often mimics other diseases in the intertriginous areas. Therefore, a thorough understanding of HS is essential to avoid delayed diagnoses. This review highlights the typical MRI imaging features and staging of HS, emphasizing on the anoperineal location. The review also differentiates the disease from mimics to facilitate the prompt delivery of appropriate treatment and improve patients' quality of life.
Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) is a complex disease difficult to treat. The exact origin of HS is unclear. It is considered a disease of follicular occlusion rather than an inflammatory or infectious process of the apocrine glands [1]. The plugging of hair follicles with keratin and subsequent expansion and rupture of the follicles lead to spillage of the keratin into the surrounding tissue. This spillage leads to an intense inflammatory response that manifests as painful recurrent nodules and abscesses and, subsequently, the formation of sinus tracts and scarring [12]. Common locations are the intertriginous areas, such as the axillary region (Fig. 1), groin, and perineal and perianal regions. Several sites may be involved simultaneously, and are usually symmetrical. HS is more common in female; however, anoperineal HS affects more male than female [3]. The hallmark of HS is chronicity, with recurrences occurring in and around the original sites. Among all skin diseases, patients with HS have the highest morbidity and the lowest quality of life [4].
Fig. 1
Bilateral axillary HS.
A, B. A 29-year-old female patient with bilateral axillary HS. Multiple erythematous papules (black arrows) and paired pits from inflamed hair follicles (white arrow) with dermal contractures and rope-like elevation of skin (white arrowhead) and bridging scar (black arrowheads) are shown at both axillae. Bilateral involvement is common in this disease. HS = hidradenitis suppurativa
The clinical features of anoperineal HS can overlap with Crohn’s disease (CD), which has been reported to coexist in 17% to 40% of patients [5]. Pelvic MRI has gained acceptance as the imaging modality of choice for assessing anoperineal diseases. This article aims to identify MRI findings that can be used as a roadmap to suggest HS when anoperineal diseases are encountered and help differentiate HS from mimics.
Clinical Criteria and Staging
HS typically develops after puberty, with peak onset in the early 20s. The prevalence is estimated at 1% of the general European population, increasing to 4% in young adult female. There is a male predominance of anogenital disease, although overall, the condition is twice more common in female [67].The substantial environmental risk factors for the development of HS are smoking, obesity, and a family history of HS. The clinical symptoms and signs of HS are initially characterized by painful subcutaneous nodules with pruritus and hyperhidrosis. The nodules rupture over approximately 7 days to 15 days, leading to deep dermal abscesses. After rupture, the lesions frequently extrude a foul-smelling, purulent discharge. Subsequently, they become draining sinus tracts, scars, or fibrosis (Fig. 2). Three criteria are used to establish a clinical diagnosis (Table 1).
Fig. 2
Step of progression in hidradenitis suppurativa.
Normal hair follicle with attached sebaceous gland (white arrowhead) is shown. Follicular occlusion causing widening of the hair follicle is observed (black arrow). Subsequently, there is a nodular or abscess formation (asterisk). Finally, there is interconnection of the abscesses (two asterisks) and then rupture. This can lead to the formation of a complex network of sinus tracts (black arrowheads). Skin thickening and induration (white arrows) develop during the course of the disease.
Typical chronicity and recurrences: 2 recurrences of the lesions during a period of 6 months
Several classification systems have been proposed to stage HS. The Hurley clinical staging system is the most straightforward and widely implemented. It is also the most relevant system to the European S1 guidelines (Table 2) [89]. Most patients have stage I (68%) or stage II disease (28%), with few having stage III disease (4%) [10]. The drawback of the Hurley staging system is that it describes the finding in a particular region rather than the total disease burden for the patient [9].
Table 2
Hurley Clinical Staging System for Hidradenitis Suppurativa
Stage
Nodules/Abscesses
Sinus Tracts and Scarring
Extension of Disease
I
Single or multiple
No
Isolated lesions
II
Single or multiple
Yes
Recurrent and widely separated lesions
III
Multiple
Yes
Diffuse involvement across regional area with interconnected lesions
In contrast, the modified Sartorius scoring system is a more dynamic and quantitative severity assessment tool. It considers the lesion count, number of anatomical regions involved, types of lesions, and distance between two relevant lesions. Nevertheless, it is rarely used in clinical practice as it is time-consuming and complex [11].
Imaging Role
The diagnosis of HS is usually made by clinical observation, and a biopsy is rarely needed. However, compared with diagnosis by imaging, relying solely on a physical examination and using only clinical criteria for diagnosis can lead to underestimations of the stage of the disease and its severity [12]. Visual observation and manual palpation appear to be spatially limited due to inflammation, potentially resulting in incorrect interpretations of fistulas as nodules. Such misdiagnoses lead to errors in stage assignment, severity assessment, and treatment planning. Histology is often of limited value when HS involvement is deep and widely multiregional [13]. In such instances, a radiological investigation may better determine the subclinical changes (e.g., dermal pseudocysts, widened hair follicles, and subdermal fluid collection), and the severity of the involvement. This information can guide surgical treatment [1213].Ultrasonography is most frequently employed as the first line of investigation in HS, and it is an excellent technique for studying skin layers (Fig. 3). Nevertheless, MRI is gaining in popularity. While MRI is mainly used for extensive HS and deep anoperineal lesions [14], some physicians employ it even for milder stages of the disease. It is vital to obtain high-resolution images to readily identify the sinus tracts and a dermal or subdermal abscess and assess its extent. The MRI sequences include T2-weighted acquisitions, even with the short tau inversion recovery (STIR) technique, to emphasize the signal of fluid components. Post gadolinium and diffusion-weighted images may also help detect active disease and aid in diagnosing complex cases that previously underwent surgery. The MRI protocol and imaging parameters for anoperineal HS are detailed in Table 3.
Fig. 3
Perineal hidradenitis suppurativa.
A 45-year-old male patient with tender and itching at perineum. Ultrasonography of the anterior perineum shows a few hypoechoic fluid pockets (asterisks). Widened dermal hair follicles connecting to fluid collection are seen (arrowheads). Several areas of hypodermal sinus tracts emanating from fluid collections are noted (arrows).
Table 3
Pelvic MRI Protocol for Hidradenitis Suppurativa Evaluation at Our Institute
Imaging Sequence and Orientation
FOV (mm)
TR/TE (ms)
Thickness (mm)
Gap (mm)
NSA
Matrix Size
S/N Ratio
T2W SSFSE coronal
350 × 330
1200/89
5
1
1
358 × 356
1
T2W SSFSE axial
350 × 285
2000/114
6
1.2
1
293 × 400
1
T2W STIR axial
350 × 295
2860/78
6
1.2
1
227 × 384
1
T2W STIR sagittal
170 × 180
7040/95
3
0
2
286 × 336
1
T2W STIR axial
170 × 170
9550 × 88
3
0
2
235 × 336
1
T2W STIR coronal
170 × 180
5890 × 96
3
0
2
269 × 236
1
DWI axial b value 50, 800, 1000 s/mm2
170 × 170
9200 × 67
3
0
b50 = 1
b800 = 7
b1000 = 10
110 × 110
1
T1W 3D axial FS without GD
350 × 306
3/1.19
3
0
1
231 × 352
1
T1W 3D axial FS with GD
350 × 306
3/1.19
3
0
1
231 × 352
1
T1W 3D coronal FS with GD
350 × 330
4/1.23
3
0
1
204 × 256
1
T1W 3D sagittal FS with GD
270 × 330
4/1.23
3
0
1
156 × 256
1
All parameters presented are taken from a protocol designed for a 1.5T MR scanner. It is very important to cover the whole buttock and perineum because the fistulous pathways extend and open at the skin surface. Do not place pillows under the legs because doing so risks lifting the bottom of the pelvis away from the coil. A 3T MR scanner can be used with a high S/N ratio and spatial resolution with theoretically high conspicuity to identify minor fistulous pathways. Drawbacks include increased susceptibility artifacts, magnetic field inhomogeneity, and specific absorption rates. DWI = diffusion-weighted image, FOV = field of view, FS = fat suppressed, GD = gadolinium, NSA = number of signal coverage, SSFSE = single shot fast spin echo, STIR = short tau inversion recovery, S/N = signal to noise, T = Tesla, TE = echo time, TR = repetition time, T1W = T1-weighted, T2W = T2 weighted, 3D = three-dimensional
MRI Findings According to Disease Stage
Hurley Stage 1
The disease at this initial stage is confined to the skin and subcutaneous layer. MRI findings include dermal thickening and subdermal induration, which show high signal intensity on T2-weighted images, restricted diffusion, and enhancement (Fig. 4). Solitary or multiple isolated abscess formation is evident (Fig. 5). However, no scarring or sinus tract is present.
Fig. 4
Stage I hidradenitis suppurativa.
A 35-year-old female patient with painful lumps at right axilla.
A. Coronal short tau inversion recovery image shows skin thickening or induration with evidence of subdermal high signal intensity (arrow).
B. Coronal T1-weighted post gadolinium image shows area of enhancement extending to dermal surface at right axilla (arrow). Body marker was seen in both images.
Fig. 5
Stage I hidradenitis suppurativa.
A 51-year-old male patient with painful left groin. Axial short tau inversion recovery image shows skin thickening with subcutaneous abscess formation at left anterior perineum (arrow). Enlarged enhanced reactive bilateral inguinal nodes are identified (arrowheads).
Hurley Stage 2
If the disease does not heal with mild scarring, recurrent involvement can develop, with multiple, raised, subdermal pockets of rim-enhancing pus forming. These pockets eventually rupture to form sinus tracts. MRI findings show a combination of the stage I findings and widely separated, high signal intensity, sinus or fistulous tracts on STIR or post gadolinium images (Figs. 6, 7).
Fig. 6
Stage II hidradenitis suppurativa.
A 35-year-old male patient with purulent discharge at perianal area.
A. Axial short tau inversion recovery shows abscess pocket at left scrotum (asterisk) and multiple subdermal sinus tracts along right and left sided intergluteal cleft (arrowheads). Thickening of dermal plane and subcutaneous tissue of right gluteal region with increased signal intensity (arrow). B. DWI accentuates depiction of more subdermal sinus tracts (arrowheads) than axial short tau inversion recovery in (A). Skin and subcutaneous induration at right gluteal region is more conspicuous on DWI (arrow). DWI = diffusion-weighted image
Fig. 7
Stage II HS.
A 31-year-old male patient with grade II HS. Axial short tau inversion recovery shows multiple abscesses along right and left side of intergluteal cleft (white arrowheads) and sinus tract between abscesses at left side of intergluteal cleft (black arrowhead). Another branching sinus tract is in the left groin region (black arrow) with skin thickening and subcutaneous edema in the bilateral gluteal regions (white arrows). HS = hidradenitis suppurativa
Hurley Stage 3
Stage 3 often includes refractory or intractable cases with extensive involvement across a regional area. MRI shows multiple interconnecting sinus tracts and fistulas draining through the skin. Chronicity can be observed as thick sinus tract walls with low signal intensity during STIR imaging due to scar formation (Fig. 8). Occasionally, the disease extends beyond the dermis and subcutaneous fat to involve the deeper fascia and muscle, causing local deformities [15].
Fig. 8
Stage III hidradenitis suppurativa.
A 37-year-old male patient with tender and foul discharge at perianal region.
A. Axial short tau inversion recovery shows multiple subdermal sinus tracts along either side of the intergluteal cleft (white arrowheads). There is some intercommunication (black arrowheads) and marked subcutaneous thickening (black arrow) and a deep scar (white arrow). B. Axial short tau inversion recovery lower than (A) shows marked skin thickening (arrows) with scars and retracted skin surface at upper inner thighs (arrowheads). Significant scarring is very common in severe disease.
Enlarged inguinal nodes may be observed at all stages. Fistula communication with the bladder, urethra, and rectum is extremely rare. MRI has been used preoperatively to evaluate the borders of lesions before wide surgical excisions of HS and aid assess treatment responses. Griffin et al. [14] found that a reduction in the number of sinus tracts and their signal intensity on follow-up STIR MRI signified decreased disease activity, and loss of high T2 signal preceded a lack of enhancement on MRI.
The Link between HS and CD
Currently, the pathogenesis of HS and CD remains controversial. Studies have illustrated that HS and CD share similar risk factors, immune dysregulation mechanisms, genetic loci, and biochemical changes. It is well recognized that smoking increases the risk of CD and HS. Smoking in HS has pathological effects on the development of epidermal hyperplasia and follicular plugging [16]. Some studies found that CD and HS had identical immune dysregulation mechanisms, such as significant increases in interleukin-1 (IL-1), IL-6, IL-17, IL-23, and tumor necrosis factor [1617]. Both CD and HS histopathologically feature lymphatic follicles and granulomas.
Differential Diagnosis
CD
Making a differential diagnosis between anoperineal HS and CD is challenging as they can present with the same tissue changes. In addition, it is common for both disorders to coexist (Fig. 9), with signs of one overlapping with those of the other [518]. T2-weighted acquisitions and the STIR technique are the key imaging sequences used to identify abscesses and fistulous pathways in both diseases. The site, distribution, and characteristics of the lesions and associated findings are clues facilitating a differential diagnosis on MRI.
Fig. 9
Crohn’s disease and HS.
A. A 36-year-old male patient with Crohn’s disease and HS. Axial short tau inversion recovery shows subcutaneous abscess (arrowhead), subcutaneous induration with edema (white arrow), and enlarged inguinal nodes (N) consistent with HS. There is evidence of a perianal fistula in Crohn’s disease (black arrow). B. A 31-year-old male patient with Crohn’s disease and HS. Axial short tau inversion recovery shows subcutaneous abscess (white arrow) and sinus tract at left groin (white arrowhead), subcutaneous and skin thickening at left gluteal region (black arrowheads) and enlarged inguinal nodes consistent with HS (N) and associated perianal Crohn’s disease (black arrow). HS = hidradenitis suppurativa
In HS, the lesions often affect the anterior inguinal area, intergluteal fold, and the posterior sacral or gluteal region. Most fistulas do not reach the dentate line of the anal canal due to the absence of apocrine glands at and above that point. It is common to observe diffuse subcutaneous edema and skin thickening with bilateral involvement and less sphincter involvement. Involvement of the axillary region or another HS-specific location is another valuable clue [1920].In CD, lesions are more prevalent in the perianal location. Fistulous tracts or abscesses usually involve the anal sphincter complex, extending to the ischiorectal fossa and supralevator space [1920]. Coexisting rectal wall thickening and concomitant gastrointestinal symptoms are more commonly observed with CD.In addition, inflammatory granulomas or abscesses are more frequently found in HS and tend to be small and coalescent. In contrast, fistulous tracts seem to be more frequent in patients with CD than those with HS.
Pilonidal Abscess
Classically, pilonidal sinuses and abscesses arise at the natal cleft (the primary opening) and chiefly affect young male. Their clinical presentations vary. They may present as a simple intergluteal skin pit with minimal symptoms. Alternatively, they may manifest as a complex infection arising in the subcutaneous tissue of the sacrococcygeal area, with multiple sinuses and secondary openings located off the midline (Fig. 10). In cases where the pilonidal sinus runs caudally, the secondary opening may resemble a perianal fistula. HS is frequently mistaken as recurrent pilonidal sinus and is strongly associated with and exacerbated by smoking and obesity. However, recurrent painful suppurative abscesses, subcutaneous nodules, sinus tracts, or fistulas with chronic scarring and opened pits serve as diagnostic clues [8].
Fig. 10
Pilonidal abscess.
A, B. A 37-year-old male patient with cutaneous discharge at mid upper buttock. Coronal short tau inversion recovery shows small focal high signal intensity at higher level of the intergluteal cleft (arrow) with elongated tract (arrowheads) in the left buttock and surrounding inflammatory change. There is no communication with the anal sphincteric area.
Actinomycosis
Pelvic actinomycosis may occur because of penetrating trauma, abdominal surgery, or long-standing use of intrauterine devices. It usually presents abscess formation, dense fibrosis, and draining sinuses (Fig. 11). The condition can spread across tissue planes. Its infiltrative nature might stem from the action of proteolytic enzymes released by the bacterium Actinomycosis israelii. Pelvic actinomycosis is frequently confused with malignant diseases [21].
Fig. 11
Perineal actinomycosis.
A 32-year-old male patient with a history of penetrating trauma by wooden stick at left buttock. Axial T1-weighted post gadolinium image shows tract of penetrating trauma at medial aspect of left buttock. There is scrotal wall thickening with a rim enhancing abscess at the perineum (arrow). Fluid analysis of this abscess found actinomycosis.
Carbuncles, Cellulitis, and Erysipelas
HS may not be differentiated from carbuncles, cellulitis, and erysipelas if there is no sinus tract or fistula formation. The typical locations and chronicity of HS are clues for differentiation.
Fournier’s Gangrene
Fournier’s gangrene is a urological emergency. It is defined as rapid and progressive infective necrotizing fasciitis of the perineal or anoperineal region caused by polymicrobial infection. The condition typically affects middle-aged male, and the most frequently associated factors are diabetes and chronic alcohol consumption [22]. Soft-tissue inflammation and edema cause a suppurative infection and obliterative endarteritis of the dermal and hypodermal arteries leading to necrosis. Crepitus can be discovered through physical examination due to soft-tissue gas. The rate of fascial necrosis has been reported to be as high as 2 to 3 cm per hours, and patients can succumb to severe sepsis. Early diagnosis is therefore essential for patient survival [23].CT is beneficial and outperforms plain radiography and ultrasonography. Computed tomography delineates fascial and skin thickening, fat stranding, and gas extension in soft tissue, and it can occasionally identify the starting point of Fournier’s gangrene (Fig. 12). MRI can readily detect soft-tissue edema and fascial thickening in fluid-sensitive sequences. However, it may sometimes prove challenging to differentiate soft-tissue gas from the signal void of vascular flow or phlebolith (Fig. 13) [24].
Fig. 12
Fournier’s gangrene.
A 49-year-old male patient presented at the emergency unit with fever and tenderness of the genitalia. Axial enhanced CT shows soft-tissue edema and fascial thickening at scrotum and medial aspect of both upper thighs (arrows) and multiple soft-tissue gas (arrowheads). CT is far better than MRI for detecting air bubbles.
Fig. 13
Fournier’s gangrene.
A 52-year-old male patient with sepsis and multiple organ failure with crepitus at scrotal region.
A. Axial fat-suppressed T2-weighted image shows skin thickening and subcutaneous edema at anterior perineal region (arrowheads). B. Axial fat-suppressed T2-weighted image shows marked scrotal wall thickening (arrows) and multiple tiny air bubbles at right scrotal sac (arrowheads).
Complications
Complications may be local, systemic, physical, or (in cases of long-term uncontrolled disease) psychological. Infection may follow, in turn causing septicemia. Fibrosis and scarring result in contractures and impaired joint mobility. Arthropathy associated with HS manifests with variable clinical findings, and its activity is related to the disease activity of the HS [25]. Rarely, squamous cell carcinoma may develop on top of the scars or chronic inflammation in long-standing HS cases [26].
Management
Topical and systemic antibiotics, retinoids, hormones, steroids, and anti-tumor necrosis factor therapy coupled with local cleansing and warm compression are usually used for every clinical stage (Hurley stages I–III) [27]. If the disease is recurrent or advanced (Hurley stages II–III), incisional drainage or radical excision of all apocrine glands in the affected areas may be needed [28]. Surgery is often required to treat the tunnels and scars associated with chronic HS [262829].
CONCLUSIONS
Although HS is mainly clinically diagnosed, imaging tools, especially MRI, are beneficial and improve staging and characterization of lesions. The imaging tools can also guide management and reduce recurrent disease.
Authors: Alexa B Kimball; Francisco Kerdel; David Adams; Ulrich Mrowietz; Joel M Gelfand; Robert Gniadecki; Errol P Prens; Joel Schlessinger; Christos C Zouboulis; Hessel H van der Zee; Marie Rosenfeld; Parvez Mulani; Yihua Gu; Susan Paulson; Martin Okun; Gregor B E Jemec Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2012-12-18 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Jean E Revuz; Florence Canoui-Poitrine; Pierre Wolkenstein; Cedric Viallette; Germaine Gabison; Florence Pouget; Florence Poli; Ousmane Faye; Jean Claude Roujeau; Genevieve Bonnelye; Jean Jacques Grob; Sylvie Bastuji-Garin Journal: J Am Acad Dermatol Date: 2008-10 Impact factor: 11.527