| Literature DB >> 35884023 |
Peivand Bastani1, Nithin Manchery1, Mahnaz Samadbeik2, Diep Hong Ha1, Loc Giang Do1.
Abstract
Digital health technologies can widely increase access to oral health solutions and can make them easier to use and more accessible at all primary, secondary, and tertiary levels. This study aims to present a bibliometric analysis of published literature to identify the content, trends, and context of digital health technology use in children's oral and dental health. After finalising the research question, the Scopus database was used to search systematically for related keywords from 1997 to 2022. The PRISMA methodology applied for systematic reviews was adopted to refine search results. VOS viewer software was applied to illustrate the topics and trends of digital health technology involved in children's oral and dental health. An increase in use of the digital technologies was appeared in the index keywords after 2005. Computer-assisted therapy/surgery, computer simulation, computer program, image processing, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) imaging, and audio-visual equipment were more used index keywords in children's dental care re-search from 2005-2015. Telemedicine, mobile application, virtual reality, and medical information were reported with the index keywords of dental caries, dental procedures, and dental anxiety after 2015. The study also identified a gap in the published literature in applying newer digital technologies, such as the Internet of Things (IoT) and gamification, in oral and dental health research and practice. There is a growing tendency to use digital technologies in children's oral and dental health in recent years. Although the types and categorisations of the technology are typically diverse during the timeframe and by the area of dental services and oral health, identifying and categorizing these technologies based on oral health services could familiarise oral health policymakers with the application of the technology and help them design technology-based interventions to improve children's oral health.Entities:
Keywords: bibliometric analysis; children; dental care; digital; oral health
Year: 2022 PMID: 35884023 PMCID: PMC9321641 DOI: 10.3390/children9071039
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Children (Basel) ISSN: 2227-9067
Search strategy.
| NO. | Construct | Search Field/Limits |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | “Oral health” OR (Oral AND Health) OR (Diagnosis AND Oral) OR | In: Topic (Title, Abstract, Keywords) |
| #2 | “digital technology” OR “digital tool” OR “digital health” OR telemedicine OR “mobile health” OR mHealth OR eHealth OR “artificial intelligence” OR app OR smartphone OR software OR “information technology” OR electronics OR computer or internet OR online OR “Information and Communication Technology” OR Computers OR tablet OR phone OR iPad OR “mobile technology” OR “Cellular phone” OR “cellular phones” OR telecommunications OR “mobile applications” OR web-based OR “mobile apps” OR “text message” OR SMS OR “short message Service” OR “portable game” OR handheld OR PDA OR “personal digital assistant” OR “social media” OR “online social networking” OR “virtual reality” OR avatars OR “online gaming” OR “video games” | In: Topic (Title, Abstract, Keywords) |
| #3 | paediatric OR child OR children OR Childhood OR infant OR toddler OR newborn OR preschool * OR pre-school * OR newborn OR “school age” | In: Topic (Title, Abstract, Keywords) |
| #4 | #1 AND #2 AND #3 | Language: English |
* represents any group of characters. * behind the root word and the search will look for all variations of the root word.
Figure 1PRISMA flow charts of procedures used in the identification of final article for the bibliometric review.
Distribution of the articles according to the number of contributions of the countries.
| Country | Number of Publications |
|---|---|
| United Kingdom | 12 |
| United States | 10 |
| India | 8 |
| Brazil | 6 |
| Germany | 6 |
| Others | 36 (80 total) |
Figure 2Trend of publication during the timeframe (Scopus source).
Figure 3Network visualization map of the author keywords (keyword threshold = 2; displays 32 out of 211 keywords). Each colour represents different patterns of co-occurrences based on multiple keywords retrieved from the dataset.
Figure 4Overlay visualization map of the author keywords (keyword threshold = 2; displays 32 out of 211 keywords). Circles in dark and light blue and green represent those oral and dental related topics and digital technologies with an older average publication year. Circles in yellow, orange, and red demonstrate the terminologies with newer and more recent average publication year.
Figure 5Overlay visualization map of the index keywords (keyword threshold = 2; displays 174 out of 559 keywords). Circles in dark and light blue and green represent those oral and dental related topics and digital technologies with an older average publication year. Circles in yellow, orange, and red demonstrate the terminologies with newer and more recent average publication year.
Figure 6Network visualization map of the index keywords (keyword threshold = 2; display 174 out of 559 keywords). Each colour represents different patterns of co-occurrences based on multiple keywords retrieved from the dataset.
Clusters of index keywords related to digital health in children’s oral and dental health.
| Cluster | Colour | Number of Keywords | Digital Technology Keywords | Selected Keywords |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 37 | Computer communication, | Interpersonal communication, dental restorations, tooth eruption, deciduous tooth, pulpectomy, tooth radiography, rural population, enamel hypoplasia clinical competence, distance education, insurance, reimbursement. | |
| 2 | 28 | Audio visual equipment, | Treatment planning, treatment outcome, surgery, cephalometry, esthetics dentistry, instrumentation, malocclusion, maxillofacial surgery, orthodontics, patient satisfaction, psychology, mothers, self-concepts | |
| 3 | 28 | Social media, | Cohort studies, comparative studies, controlled clinical trial, cross-sectional studies, epidemiological method, health survey, cariostatic agent, cleft lip, cleft palate, dental caries, dmft index, fluorides, incisor, sugar intake, toothpaste, child parent relation, dietary source, dietary supplement | |
| 4 | 27 | Diagnostic image, | factual, medical photography | |
| 5 | 24 | Computer assisted therapy, | Devices, adolescent, anxiety, autism, dental anaesthesia, dental anxiety, dental care, dental procedure, equipment design, pain management, preventive health service, school child, therapy, tooth extraction | |
| 6 | 19 | Software, | Teaching, oral hygiene, mouth hygiene, health promotion, health care quality, general practice, dental health | |
| 7 | 11 | Cell phone, | Tooth brushing, tooth plaque, child behaviour, procedure, dental plaque index |