| Literature DB >> 35883995 |
Domenico M Romeo1,2, Ilaria Venezia2, Margherita De Biase2, Federica Ascione2, Maria Rosaria Lala2, Valentina Arcangeli3, Eugenio Mercuri1,2, Claudia Brogna1.
Abstract
Children with developmental coordination disorder (DCD) and joint hypermobility could present an overlap of symptoms and motor functional difficulties. The link between these two clinical conditions has not yet been clarified. Recent studies reported a high incidence (30-50%) of motor delay in children who are referred to hypermobility and of enhanced joint hypermobility in children with DCD. The aim of this study was to provide a critical review of the literature outlining the association between DCD or limited motor performance and joint hypermobility. Studies were eligible for inclusion if they were written in English and human-based. All the studies were first selected, looking for the presence of a clinical association between developmental coordination disorder or motor performance and hyperlaxity and reporting details of outcome. After a review of the full texts, 16 articles for a total of 1898 children met the inclusion criteria. In general, there was evidence of a higher incidence of motor delay or DCD in children who are referred to hypermobility and of enhanced joint hypermobility in children with DCD with similar range of functional difficulties. These results could influence the way to support children with rehabilitation and the type of intervention according to the prevalence of one of the two conditions.Entities:
Keywords: developmental coordination disorder; joint hypermobility; outcome
Year: 2022 PMID: 35883995 PMCID: PMC9317025 DOI: 10.3390/children9071011
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Children (Basel) ISSN: 2227-9067
Figure 1Flow chart for process of article inclusion [8,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33].
Study characteristics.
| Ref. | Author, | Type of Study | Sample N | Age of Assessment in Months (m) or Years (y) | Joint Hypermobility and Developmental Coordination Disorder | Assessment for DCD/Motor Performance | Assessment for Hypermobility | Others Instruments Used |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | Kirby, A. et al., | Case-Control | 54 | Control group: 5–18 years | Similar clinical features between JHS and DCD | M-ABC | Questionnaire | Questionnaire covering a range of symptoms consistent with a diagnosis of JHS and related autonomic nervous systemic symptoms |
| [ | Romeo et al., | Longitudinal | 132 | From 12 months to 4 years | Children with joint laxity had lower scores than those without joint laxity on both total scores and subscores of M-ABC-2. | M-ABC-2 | Beighton Score (>4) | Touwen Infant Neurological Examination |
| [ | Adib, N. et al., | Prospective and Retrospective | 125 | 3–17 years | Children with JHS present Joint pain and coordination problems in 36% | Clinical history | Beighton Score (≥4) | - |
| [ | Moore, N. et al., | Cross-sectional, case-control, observational | 73 | 6–12 years | No significant difference in the number of children with pDCD in those with and without GJH. | Self-reported questionnaires | Beighton Score (≥6) | - |
| [ | Wright, K.E. et al., | Cross-sectional observation | 60 | 6–12 years | Hypermobility failed to explain significant variance in motor competence beyond that explained by neuromuscular performance. | M-ABC-2 | Beighton score | Resistance Training Skills Battery for Children (RTSBc), 5-repetition maximum (5RM) leg press and Biodex dynamometry |
| [ | Jelsma et al., 2013 | Case-control | Case group: 36 | Case group 7–10 years | In the DCD group the prevalence of hypermobility was higher and there was a significant negative correlation between the m-ABC total score and the degree of hyperextension of the knees. | M-ABC | Beighton score | - |
| [ | Tirosh et al., | Longitudinal | 59 | 54–60 months | Both gross and fine motor performance were significantly delayed in the group of children with joint hypermobility and motor delay. | Gross motor performance. | Clinical evaluation of the mobility of joints | - |
| [ | De Boer et al., | Prospective | 249 | Mean 5.5 years | No significant association was found between GJH and total motor performance. | Bayley Scales of Infant Development, Second Edition | Beighton Score (≥4; ≥5; ≥6) | |
| [ | Kirby et al., | Cohort | 126 | 8–9 years | Children with BJHS present functional difficulties that impact on fine and gross motor function. | M-ABC | Questionnaire | Hypermobility Syndrome Association developmental coordination disorder questionnaire |
| [ | Juul-Kristensen, B. et al., | Cross-sectional | 349 | (8.40 ± 0.52) years | Static balance and speed reaction tests better in children with GJH | Clinical examination and motor competence tests | Questionnaire | Questionnaire with 75 items on health and physical activity |
| [ | Remvig, L. et al., | Cohort | 315 | 10 years | Increased pain or frequency of injures were not related to GJH. | Motor competence tests: | Beighton score | Questionnaire with 75 items on health and physical activity |
| [ | Schubert-Hjalmarsson et al., | Cross-sectional | Case group: 20 | 8–15 years (11.2 ± 1.9) | Balance is decreased in children with HMS compared with healthy controls. | Bruininks-Oseretsky test of motor proficiency (balance) | Del Mar scale | Frequency of Partic- ipation Questionnaire |
| [ | Easton, V. et al., | Interventional | 119 | 5–16 years | Among the children with BJHS assessed, 32.8% scored ≤15 percentile on the M-ABC ( | M-ABC-2 | Clinical evaluation | Childhood Health Assess- ment Questionnaire |
| [ | Morrison, S.C. et al., | Interventional | 14 (14/0) | 6–11 years | Children with DCD were at the top end of the scale for lower limb hypermobility. | Not specified | Lower Limb Assessment Score | 6-Minute Walk Test |
| [ | Celletti, C. et al., | Observational | 41 | Mean age 8 ± 3 years | Children with DCD and GJH showed a significant excess of frequent falls, easy bruising, motor impersistence. | M-ABC | Beighton score | Linguistic Comprehension Test, Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, Boston Naming Test, Bus Story Test, and Memoria-Training tests |
| [ | Engelbert et al., 2005 | observational | 56 | 4–12 years | No significant association between the presence of a delay in motor development and joint hypermobility | M-ABC | Bulbena criteria | - |
M-ABC-2—Movement assessment battery for children-second edition; JHS—joint hypermobility syndrome; DCD—Developmental Coordination Disorder; ADHD—Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder; HCTDs—hereditary connective tissue disorders; pDCD—probable developmental coordination disorder; GJH—generalized joint hypermobility; BJHS—benign joint hypermobility syndrome; PAL—Physical Activity Level; HMS—Hypermobility Syndrome.