Modestos Athanasiou1, Andreas Manoli1, Paris Papagiorgis1, Kyriacos Georgiou2, Yuliia Berezovska3, Andreas Othonos2, Maryna I Bodnarchuk3, Maksym V Kovalenko4,3, Grigorios Itskos1. 1. Experimental Condensed Matter Physics Laboratory, Department of Physics, University of Cyprus, Nicosia 1678, Cyprus. 2. Department of Physics, Laboratory of Ultrafast Science, University of Cyprus, Nicosia 1678, Cyprus. 3. Laboratory for Thin Films and Photovoltaics, Empa-Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Überlandstrasse 129, Dübendorf CH-8600, Switzerland. 4. Institute of Inorganic Chemistry, Department of Chemistry and Applied Biosciences, ETH Zürich, Zürich CH-8093, Switzerland.
Abstract
Lead halide perovskite nanocrystals (NCs) are highly suitable active media for solution-processed lasers in the visible spectrum, owing to the wide tunability of their emission from blue to red via facile ion-exchange reactions. Their outstanding optical gain properties and the suppressed nonradiative recombination losses stem from their defect-tolerant nature. In this work, we demonstrate flexible waveguides combining the transparent, bioplastic, polymer cellulose acetate with green CsPbBr3 or red-emitting CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs in simple solution-processed architectures based on polymer-NC multilayers deposited on polymer micro-slabs. Experiments and simulations indicate that the employment of the thin, free-standing membranes results in confined electrical fields, enhanced by 2 orders of magnitude compared to identical multilayer stacks deposited on conventional, rigid quartz substrates. As a result, the polymer structures exhibit improved amplified emission characteristics under nanosecond excitation, with amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) thresholds down to ∼95 μJ cm-2 and ∼70 μJ cm-2 and high net modal gain up to ∼450 and ∼630 cm-1 in the green and red parts of the spectrum, respectively. The optimized gain properties are accompanied by a notable improvement of the ASE operational stability due to the low thermal resistance of the substrate-less membranes and the intimate thermal contact between the polymer and the NCs. Their application potential is further highlighted by the membrane's ability to sustain dual-color ASE in the green and red parts of the spectrum through excitation by a single UV source, activate underwater stimulated emission, and operate as efficient white light downconverters of commercial blue LEDs, producing high-quality white light emission, 115% of the NTSC color gamut.
Lead halide perovskite nanocrystals (NCs) are highly suitable active media for solution-processed lasers in the visible spectrum, owing to the wide tunability of their emission from blue to red via facile ion-exchange reactions. Their outstanding optical gain properties and the suppressed nonradiative recombination losses stem from their defect-tolerant nature. In this work, we demonstrate flexible waveguides combining the transparent, bioplastic, polymer cellulose acetate with green CsPbBr3 or red-emitting CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs in simple solution-processed architectures based on polymer-NC multilayers deposited on polymer micro-slabs. Experiments and simulations indicate that the employment of the thin, free-standing membranes results in confined electrical fields, enhanced by 2 orders of magnitude compared to identical multilayer stacks deposited on conventional, rigid quartz substrates. As a result, the polymer structures exhibit improved amplified emission characteristics under nanosecond excitation, with amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) thresholds down to ∼95 μJ cm-2 and ∼70 μJ cm-2 and high net modal gain up to ∼450 and ∼630 cm-1 in the green and red parts of the spectrum, respectively. The optimized gain properties are accompanied by a notable improvement of the ASE operational stability due to the low thermal resistance of the substrate-less membranes and the intimate thermal contact between the polymer and the NCs. Their application potential is further highlighted by the membrane's ability to sustain dual-color ASE in the green and red parts of the spectrum through excitation by a single UV source, activate underwater stimulated emission, and operate as efficient white light downconverters of commercial blue LEDs, producing high-quality white light emission, 115% of the NTSC color gamut.
Inorganic and hybrid
lead halide perovskite nanocrystals (LHP NCs)
have emerged as versatile, tunable, and low-cost gain media for optically
pumped, solution-processed lasers in the visible spectral region.
Significant advances include the demonstration of low threshold and
air-stable amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) in thin films or simple
waveguide structures of perovskite NCs with ambient stability of several
hours and thresholds down to ∼1 μJ cm–2 in the femtosecond excitation regime.[1−5] Furthermore, efficient optically pumped, single- and multi-mode
LHP NC lasers have been realized based on various resonator geometries
that include vertical cavities,[6−10] distributed feedback,[11−14] and whispering gallery architectures.[15−17]Despite the significant progress, there are some key challenges
that need to be tackled toward the realization of practical and cost-effective
optically pumped amplifiers and lasers based on perovskite NCs. Improving
the stability and reliability of the lasing structures operating in
ambient conditions is one such pressing issue. Furthermore, the great
majority of the reported work employed femtosecond laser excitation
to force favorable competition of the stimulated emission process
against gain losses; however, such an approach is practically problematic
in terms of cost, scalability, weight, and size of the device. A more
viable, compact, and cost-effective path will be the implementation
of quasi-continuous wave (cw) pulsed or pure cw lasers to initiate
the lasing action from the NCs. Bulk and low dimensional perovskites
have been recently demonstrated to sustain ASE or lasing even under
cw-excitation in properly designed structures.[11,12,18−24] However, these results are typically obtained at cryogenic temperatures,
inaccessible by commercial Peltier-type cooling, or implement rigid
cavities fabricated by rather elaborate epitaxial and lithographic
techniques, that limit the practicality and compromise the cost-effectiveness
and mass-production promise of a solution-based fabrication methodology.
Finally, the great majority of the work involves the one specific
popular emitter—green-luminescent CsPbBr3 NCs—allowing
us to thoroughly study effective ligand and encapsulation strategies.
To extend the stimulated emission gamut through the visible spectrum,
further work is needed to improve the lasing performance and reliability
of blue and red LHP NC emitters.Herein, we introduce a facile,
fully solution-processed fabrication
methodology to produce flexible waveguide structures combining cellulose
acetate (CA) polymer membranes with active gain media based on multilayer
stacks of CA with green CsPbBr3 or red-emitting CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs. Upon structure optimization, nanosecond excitation of
such free-standing membranes results in air-stable ASE in the green
and red parts of the spectrum, with low thresholds down to ∼90
and ∼70 μJ cm–2 and high net modal
gain up to ∼450 and ∼630 cm–1, respectively.
Reference structures produced by deposition of the same multilayer
CA/NC stacks in rigid quartz substrates also exhibit ASE, but at the
expense of higher thresholds and poorer ambient stability. Angle-resolved
white-light reflectivity measurements combined with transfer matrix
method (TMM) simulations confirm that the improved ASE threshold and
net modal gain in the CA membranes are a result of better optical
mode confinement that improves photon–exciton coupling. On
the other hand, the absence of a bulky substrate and the less thermal
dissipative CA/NC interface yields efficient heat exchange with the
environment, significantly improving the operational ASE stability
with respect to the reference quartz structures. The versatility and
excellent gain properties of such structures allow us also to stack
membranes and simultaneously sustain dual-color ASE in the green and
red parts of the spectrum using a single nanosecond excitation source
and operate as efficient downconverters of commercial blue LEDs, producing
high-quality white light emission, 115% of the NTSC.
Results and Discussion
Design
and Fabrication of NC-Sensitized Polymer Membranes
The objective
of the study has been the demonstration of air-stable
and efficient optical amplification in the quasi-cw optical pumping
regime by combining robust perovskite NC gain media with a simple,
fully solution-processed, mechanically flexible cavity design. To
achieve such a target, we implemented mirrorless, polymeric micro-membranes
that can weakly confine an optical field due to the refractive index
contrast between the organic material and the surrounding air. Free-standing
membranes were fabricated by spin casting microns-thick slabs of CA
onto quartz,[25] followed by alternate deposition
of multiple layers of CsPbBr3 or CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs and CA with layer thickness around 50 and 80 nm for NCs and
CA, respectively. Optimization of the structural characteristics of
such multilayer stacks is discussed in the following manuscript section.
Upon deposition, the membranes were lifted-off from the quartz substrate
via a simple peel-off technique, as schematically illustrated in Figure a. The figure also
contains images of the NC-sensitized membranes under ambient and UV-light
conditions, demonstrating their good uniformity, optical quality,
and bright emission. Green emitting CsPbBr3 NCs with dimethyldioctadecylammonium
bromide (DDAB) ligands have been selected as the active gain media,
owing to their structural robustness and good photostability combined
with exceptionally high photoluminescence (PL) QY approaching in the
liquid phase 100% (larger than 90% in the solid state).[26] The NCs employed were cuboids with mean sizes
of ∼10 nm, as presented in the TEM images of Figure S1, centered at ∼2.40 eV with a full width half
maximum (fwhm) of ∼80 meV, as shown in Figure b. For the red-emitting active gain media,
CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs with variable bromine-iodine ratio were
obtained via a newly designed synthesis using hot-injection methodology
with oleic acid (OA) and two different branched ligands such as dioctylamine
(DOAm) and DDAB. Branched ligands with shorter chains are known to
have strong binding to the surface of NCs, thus they provide better
surface passivation and improvement in the optical properties of these
mixed halide NCs, with PL QY exceeding 80% in the liquid phase (larger
than 10% in the solid state). In addition, DDA+ cations
have a strong affinity to negative sites of cesium lead halide NCs,
and Br– anions from DDAB can substitute I– in the structure resulting in more stable mixed CsPb(BI1–)3 NCs with an easily tunable wavelength.
Figure 1
(a) Schematic of the
fabrication procedure of the free-standing
membranes with a multilayer of CA and NCs as the active gain media.
The photos display the flexible membranes under ambient and low-power
UV light irradiation. Optical absorption and PL spectra (b) CsPbBr3 DDAB NCs and (c) CsPb(Br,I)3 DDAB NC solutions.
(d) Quantum yield, absorbance, and ASE threshold deposited on quartz
substrate versus the overall bilayer thickness. ASE threshold data
points from the pristine film and 1 pair layers are not included,
as such active regions did not sustain ASE at room temperature.
(a) Schematic of the
fabrication procedure of the free-standing
membranes with a multilayer of CA and NCs as the active gain media.
The photos display the flexible membranes under ambient and low-power
UV light irradiation. Optical absorption and PL spectra (b) CsPbBr3 DDAB NCs and (c) CsPb(Br,I)3 DDAB NC solutions.
(d) Quantum yield, absorbance, and ASE threshold deposited on quartz
substrate versus the overall bilayer thickness. ASE threshold data
points from the pristine film and 1 pair layers are not included,
as such active regions did not sustain ASE at room temperature.The size and shape of CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs
were confirmed
by transmission electron microscopy Figure S2b, showing the presence of two populations of NCs with the average
sizes of 16.86 ± 2.08 and 26.8 ± 4.23 nm. Powder X-ray diffraction
(XRD) of purified CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs shows an orthorhombic
perovskite structure (Figure S2d). Bromide
and iodide atoms are well intermixed into a solid solution, giving
rise to a gradual shift of XRD reflections. Their PL was centered
at ∼1.92 eV with an fwhm of ∼100 neV as seen in Figure c.Structures
produced via single layer deposition of CsPbBr3 or CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs on quartz or CA membranes do not sustain
nanosecond-excited ASE at room temperature. Instead, a multilayer
approach was implemented using alternating spin-casted layers of NCs
and CA, exploiting the orthogonality of the solvents of the two materials.
The method enables the formation of sufficiently thick active gain
regions, exceeding the cut-off thickness for the propagation of one
optical mode,[27,28] while at the same time preserving
the optical quality of the layers and reducing the optical losses
which single, thick casted films are prone to.[29] Representative results of the optimization studies in such
multilayers are presented in Figure d, where the influence of the number of CsPbBr3 NC/CA pairs on the light absorption, emission yield, and
ASE threshold is demonstrated. The respected emission and absorption
data as a function of the number of layers are displayed in Figure S3a,b. Based on such work, activation
of nanosecond ASE is typically achieved for an active medium of 1.5
NC/CA layers (a sequence of ∼50 nm NC/∼80 nm spacer
CA/∼50 nm NC layers), while ASE threshold minimization is obtained
for a total multilayer thickness of ∼310 nm or equivalently
the number of 2.5 NC/CA bilayers (a total NC thickness of ∼150
nm). The pronounced reduction of the ASE threshold in the 1.5 to 2.5
layer range is assigned to a combined effect of increased light absorption
and more efficient confinement of the optical modes within the thicker
active region. The effect appears to dominate over the slight reduction
of the emission quantum yield observed across the same thickness range.
The addition of more pairs in the multilayer stack, allows the propagation
of higher-order cavity modes, effectively reducing the photon–exciton
coupling. Furthermore, processes such as re-absorption and light scattering
become more prominent, reducing the emission QY and suppressing the
overall Q-factor of the cavity. Figure S3c,d contains another parametric study, probing the
influence of the CA spacer layers thickness on the ASE threshold;
experiments as such yielded optimum thicknesses of around 50 and 80
nm for the NC and CA layers incorporated in the multilayer stack active
regions, respectively. The use of such thick CA spacer layers in the
optimized waveguide structures also ensures that their optical properties
are not affected by electronic interactions between the NC emitters
layers.
Room-Temperature-ASE under Nanosecond Excitation
The
stimulated emission properties of CsPbBr3 NC/CA multilayers
deposited on rigid quartz and flexible CA substrates were examined
under optical excitation with a 355 nm nanosecond pulsed laser, with
a pulse width of 6 ns and repetition rate of 10 Hz. Both samples exhibit
a distinct transition from spontaneous emission to ASE, marked by
the linear to superlinear change of slope and the simultaneous collapse
of the emission linewidth from ∼100 to ∼20 meV when
the pumping fluence surpasses the characteristic threshold, as seen
in Figure a,b. The
ASE thresholds were extracted via the allometric fitting of the excitation-dependent
integrated areas, resulting in the champion structures displayed in Figure , to values of Eth ∼ 150 μJ cm–2 and Eth ∼ 95 μJ cm–2 for multilayers deposited on quartz and CA membranes,
respectively. It is worth noting that ASE dominates the background
spontaneous emission in both types of samples. For the multilayers
on quartz, the ASE is red-shifted by ∼30 meV relative to the
spontaneous emission peak, which is characteristic of the bi-excitonic
optical gain mechanism.[30,31] On the other hand,
in the free-standing membrane, the ASE lies in the proximity of the
PL peak as the emission couples to the Fabry Perot resonances supported
by the micron-thick CA substrate. Such results are further elaborated
in Figure S4, containing emission spectra
from the two structures below and above the ASE threshold, as well
as a comparison of emission data with TMM simulated reflectivity spectra
from the CA membrane sample.
Figure 2
Evolution of the ASE spectra at different excitation
energies for
2.5 CsPbBr3 NC/CA multilayers on (a) quartz and (b) CA
membrane. Integrated emission and allometric fits of the data along
with the emission linewidth versus excitation energy density are presented
for: (c) quartz and (d) CA membrane. (e) The operational stability
of ASE versus the number of excitation laser pulses.
Evolution of the ASE spectra at different excitation
energies for
2.5 CsPbBr3 NC/CA multilayers on (a) quartz and (b) CA
membrane. Integrated emission and allometric fits of the data along
with the emission linewidth versus excitation energy density are presented
for: (c) quartz and (d) CA membrane. (e) The operational stability
of ASE versus the number of excitation laser pulses.On top of sustaining ASE at consistently lower excitation
fluences
compared to the same gain media deposited in quartz, the polymer membranes
also exhibit significantly higher stability during ASE operation.
ASE stability for both types of structures was recorded under continuous
nanosecond excitation at ambient conditions, at a fluence of 200 μJ
cm–2 for illumination of up to 110 × 103 laser pulses or an equivalent of 3 operational hours. Figure e contains the results
of such a study performed on the same champion devices, the ASE data
of which are presented in Figure a–d. For the CA membrane structure, the ASE
intensity exhibited an initial increase of 10% up at ∼25 ×
103 laser pulses, followed by a gradual emission quenching
down to 85% of the initial intensity, which is a loss of only 15%
after 3 h of operation. The initial increase of the ASE intensity
was observed also in photostability tests of other free-standing membrane
samples and it could be related to the self-healing and annealing
effects of the NCs, during the intense photo-excitation.[32,33] In contrast, the multilayers deposited on quartz exhibit a rapid
loss of the output intensity, with complete quenching of the ASE at
∼40 × 103 pulses or equivalently 1 h of operation.The improved ASE stability in the free-standing membranes is predominantly
ascribed to the more efficient heat transfer and the smaller thermal
interface resistance of NCs/CA compared to the respective heat conduction
and heat dissipation properties of the structures deposited on quartz.
Heat extraction through the substrate depends on the material thermal
conductivity and the thickness; even though the thermal conductivity
of CA (∼0.17 W m–1K–1)[34] is 1 order of magnitude smaller than quartz
(∼1.6 W m–1K–1),[35] the CA membranes are more than 300 times thinner
than the conventional 1.1 mm thick quartz substrates employed in our
studies, allowing a more efficient heat flow through the CA substrate.
Furthermore, the CA polymer is conformable and can displace more of
the air entrapped in the CA–NC interfaces than the rigid quartz-NC
interface, reducing the thermal interface resistance and, thus, the
heat accumulated in the material heterointerface. Further evidence
for such an explanation can be found in Figure S5, in which the ASE peak position is monitored as a function
of the number of excitation pulses. For the multilayers deposited
on quartz, an appreciable ∼20 meV blue shift of the ASE builds
up during the one-hour operation lifetime of the structure. The blue
shift can be predominantly attributed to NC heating arising from the
anomalous temperature-dependent variation of the energy gap in CsPbBr3 NCs.[36] In contrast, the ASE peak
position in the free-standing membrane is considerably more stable,
showing a much smaller ∼7 meV red-shift over the course of
the 3 h operation. Such a bathochromic shift may originate from the
thermal expansion of the CA substrate and/or a small degree of NC
sintering during the intense laser illumination.[37] Overall, in all membrane samples, the ASE peak position
exhibited a small red or blue shift of the order of 5 to 10 mV, being
always significantly smaller in magnitude compared to the 20 to 30
meV blue shift of the ASE peak in quartz samples, confirming the improved
thermal properties of the former structures.Following an identical
fabrication procedure, red-emitting CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA multilayers
were also produced on quartz and free-standing
membranes, examined under optical excitation with a 532 nm nanosecond
pulsed laser, with a pulse width of 6 ns and repetition rate of 10
Hz. Similar to the CsPbBr3 NC-based structures, the CsPb(Br,I)3 NC sensitized membranes exhibit consistently lower ASE threshold
and higher output stability compared to the respected samples on quartz.
The main differences relative to the green-emitting analogous structures
are that on the average: (i) the ASE threshold reduces even more in
the flexible structures, that is from ∼150 μJ cm–2 in quartz to ∼70 μJ cm–2 in CA for the champion structures data shown in Figure a–d; (ii) the improvement
in operational stability is substantial but smaller than that in the
green-emitting samples as observed in Figure e. It is worth noting that to the best of
our knowledge the aforementioned ASE threshold of ∼70 μJ
cm–2 constitutes a record low value for red-emitting
perovskite NC structures in the nanosecond excitation regime.[30,38,39]
Figure 3
Excitation-dependent emission spectra
at different excitation energies
for CsPb(Br,I)3/CA multilayers on (a) quartz and (b) CA
membrane. Integrated PL area with the allometric fits of the data
along with the emission linewidth versus excitation energy density
for (c) quartz and (d) CA membrane. (e) Operational stability of ASE
versus the number of excitation laser pulses.
Excitation-dependent emission spectra
at different excitation energies
for CsPb(Br,I)3/CA multilayers on (a) quartz and (b) CA
membrane. Integrated PL area with the allometric fits of the data
along with the emission linewidth versus excitation energy density
for (c) quartz and (d) CA membrane. (e) Operational stability of ASE
versus the number of excitation laser pulses.The improved ASE stability can again be attributed to the superior
heat transfer properties of the flexible membranes. This is evidenced
by experiments summarized in Figure S6 that
account for the local heating by monitoring the ASE position shift
and further confirmed by the temperature and thermal images of the
samples obtained by an IR camera shown in Figure S7. It can be observed that during the first 7 min of ASE operation,
the local temperature on the quartz deposited waveguides exhibits
a temperature rise of ∼1.35 °C, which is ∼3.5 times
higher than the respective temperature rise of the polymer membrane.
Furthermore, as presented in Figure S8,
the free-standing membranes can sustain ASE under UV (355 nm) nanosecond
excitation, albeit at increased threshold values compared to the respected
values using green (532 nm) excitation. Importantly though no ASE
was observed under 355 nm pumping from multilayer CsPb(Br,I)3 NC structures deposited on quartz, indicative of the better waveguiding
and photostability properties of the free-standing membranes, as elaborated
further by optical gain measurements and TMM simulations, discussed
below.
Optical Gain Measurements
The optical gain and waveguiding
properties of the green and red-emitting NC multilayers on quartz
and free-standing membranes were further investigated via variable
stripe length (VSL) experiments.[30,40−42] A line-shaped excitation beam was focused onto the sample surface
via a cylindrical lens. At the same time, the ASE emission was collected
from the edge of the sample as a function of stripe length, enabling
the estimation of the net modal gain G. The optical
loss, α, related to re-absorption and scattering losses within
the structure was evaluated using a fixed stripe length beam by varying
the distance of the light stripe from the edge of the sample. The
results of the aforementioned VSL experiments at an excitation of
∼1.1 Eth (ASE threshold) are presented
in Figure a–d
for red and green-emitting multilayer stacks deposited on quartz and
polymer substrates.
Figure 4
Integrated emission intensity versus light stripe length
obtained
using VSL experiments for multilayers of: (a) CsPbBr3 NC/CA
on quartz, (b) CsPbBr3 NC/CA on CA membrane, (c) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA on quartz, and (d) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA on
CA membrane. The inset figures display the results of the optical
loss as a function of the stripe distance from the edge of the sample,
fitted via Beer–Lambert law type of curves. Net modal gain
coefficients as a function of the excitation energy density for (e)
for CsPbBr3 multilayers and (f) CsPb(Br,I)3 multilayers
on CA slabs.
Integrated emission intensity versus light stripe length
obtained
using VSL experiments for multilayers of: (a) CsPbBr3 NC/CA
on quartz, (b) CsPbBr3 NC/CA on CA membrane, (c) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA on quartz, and (d) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA on
CA membrane. The inset figures display the results of the optical
loss as a function of the stripe distance from the edge of the sample,
fitted via Beer–Lambert law type of curves. Net modal gain
coefficients as a function of the excitation energy density for (e)
for CsPbBr3 multilayers and (f) CsPb(Br,I)3 multilayers
on CA slabs.The ASE onset is characterized
by the steep increase of the integrated
emission intensity when the stripe size reaches the required length
for the optical gain to surpass the propagation losses. To estimate
the net modal gain, the experimental data were fitted using eq , near the threshold region.[30,40]Where A(λ) = ηg(λ), η denotes the cross-sectional geometrical
factor, g is the optical gain of the material, and L is the excitation stripe length.[43] For
green-emitting CsPbBr3 NC-based active media, the net modal
gain G is estimated at ∼92 ± 4 and ∼121
± 2 cm–1, for quartz and free-standing membranes,
respectively. Lower net modal gain values of ∼37 ± 3 and
∼109 ± 2 cm–1 were obtained for mixed
halide CsPb(Br,I)3 NC-based structures on quartz and CA,
respectively.The correlation of optical gain, loss, and net
modal gain is given
by eq (30,40)The absorption loss α is extracted by the fitting of
the
integrated emission versus excitation strip distance from the edge
of the sample using the following Beer–Lambert law function[40]Where I0 is the
integrated emission for d = 0 and d corresponds to the distance of the excitation stripe from the sample
edge. The fitting results are presented in the inset graphs of each
sample in Figure a–d.
As can be seen, a substantial reduction of the absorption losses by
a factor of ∼2 and ∼5 for green and red-emitting structures
is observed when switching from quartz to free-standing membranes.
As re-absorption losses in the rigid and flexible slabs are expected
to be similar due to the identical characteristics of the multilayer
active region, the reduction of the optical losses can be attributed
to a suppression of scattering losses in the free-standing membrane
as the emission is more efficiently waveguided through the optical
modes supported by the CA slab. The effect of pump excitation energy
on the net modal gain G for the green and red-emitting
flexible waveguides, is presented in Figure e,f. For both structures, the net modal gain
grows with pump fluence to values as high as ∼430 cm–1 at 1.7 mJ cm–1 and ∼620 cm–1 at 1.2 mJ cm–1 for CsPbBr3 and CsPb(Br,I)3 NC-based emitters. The lower G values and
the smaller rate with which the net modal gain grows with fluence
in the green-emitting samples are attributed to the higher optical
losses, such as the Auger and photocharging processes, associated
with the UV (355 nm) photoexcitation compared to the green (532 nm)
excitation used of the mixed-halide NC-based structures. A summary
of the ASE and optical gain properties of the studied samples is listed
in Table .
Table 1
ASE Threshold and Optical Gain Properties
of the Studied Samplesa
sample
Eth (μJ cm–2) λexc. ∼ 355 nm
Eth (μJ cm–2) λexc. ∼ 532 nm
α (cm–1) @1.1 Eth
G (cm–1) @1.1 Eth
g (cm–1) @1.1 Eth
G (cm–1) @16 Eth
quartz
CsPbBr3 NC multilayers
150
30
92
122
CsPb(Br,I)3 NC multilayers
150
110
37
147
membranes
CsPbBr3 NC multilayers
95
15
121
137
430
CsPb(Br,I)3 NC multilayers
300
70
21
109
130
620
The missing data in the first two
table columns, refer to samples in which no ASE was observed under
the specified experimental conditions. The missing data in the last
column, refer to samples in which ASE was not sustained at such high
excitation.
The missing data in the first two
table columns, refer to samples in which no ASE was observed under
the specified experimental conditions. The missing data in the last
column, refer to samples in which ASE was not sustained at such high
excitation.
Waveguiding
Properties of the Membrane Structures
The
TMM model was used to calculate the cross-sectional electric field
distribution within the green- and red-emitting waveguide structures
deposited in CA and quartz. The data are presented in Figure a,b, along with the refractive
index modulation and the layer thicknesses. The striking observation
from the simulation data is that the electric field intensity is 2
orders of magnitude larger in the membrane slabs compared to the quartz
deposited structures. This is largely a result of the significantly
smaller CA slab thickness that effectively confines the optical field
within the structure. A more careful look into the model data indicates
that the emission of the CsPbBr3 and CsPb(Br,I)3 NC-based structures couples to the 20th and 15th cavity mode, respectively.
This confirms that the reduction of the ASE threshold and the simultaneous
increase of the net modal gain observed in the membrane samples can
be attributed to such efficient light waveguiding properties.
Figure 5
Cross-sectional
electric field distribution on quartz and free-standing
membranes for (a) CsPbBr3 and (b) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA multilayers. Angle-dependent white light reflectivity and
TMM simulation data of the polymer waveguides containing (c) CsPbBr3 and (d) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA multilayers. The white
dashed lines represent the dispersion of the optical modes, while
the continuous straight light separates experimental and model data.
Cross-sectional
electric field distribution on quartz and free-standing
membranes for (a) CsPbBr3 and (b) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA multilayers. Angle-dependent white light reflectivity and
TMM simulation data of the polymer waveguides containing (c) CsPbBr3 and (d) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC/CA multilayers. The white
dashed lines represent the dispersion of the optical modes, while
the continuous straight light separates experimental and model data.Angle-dependent white-light reflectivity performed
on the structures
further confirms the formation of dispersive resonances, corresponding
to different order cavity modes, as seen in Figure c,d. Experimental data show good agreement
with simulated data produced via a TMM model. Based on the reflectivity
results, quality factors (Q ∼ λ/Δλ)
of ∼28 and ∼31 were estimated for the green and red-emitting
cavities, respectively that are comparable with Q-factors obtained in dielectric slab microcavities formed electron-beam
evaporation of conventional inorganic dielectric materials.[44]
Dual-Color ASE and White Light Generation
Lasers that
can produce dual or multicolor emission toward white light lasing
can find niche applications in full-color laser lighting/imaging/displays,
spectroscopy, fluorescence sensing, and visible light communications.[45−51] Monolithic integration of RGB laser multilayers based on epitaxial
semiconductors is challenging though, due to the large lattice mismatch
involved. Fabrication of single-chip, multicolor lasers based on soft,
solution-processed semiconductor gain media such as polymers, nanowires,
or NCs can circumvent the lattice mismatch issue, yet further work
is needed toward improvements in the design, capabilities, and reliability
of such laser devices. Toward such an objective, a preliminary study
of dual ASE emission was performed by optical excitation of stacked
up green-emitting CsPbBr3 and red-emitting CsPb(BrI)3 NC-based membranes.Optical pumping of the stacked
membranes was performed via 355 nm nanosecond pulses, exciting first
the CsPb(BrI)3 NC-based structure, as shown in the schematic
of Figure a, to minimize
reabsorption losses of the green ASE peak by the red-emitting overlayer
membrane. The spectral evolution as a function of excitation fluence
is presented in Figure b, while the combined integrated ASE emission from the stacked membranes
and the fwhm of each of the two ASE peaks is plotted against excitation
energy density, as shown in Figure c. Red ASE is activated at ∼90 μJ cm–2 while green ASE is switched on at ∼220 μJ
cm–2 with the dual ASE peaks sustained to densities
larger than 1 mJ cm-2. The far-field mixing of the
multicolor ASE is displayed on a CIE color map, highlighting the ability
to tune the color chromaticity of the output emission from red to
green by adjusting the excitation intensity.
Figure 6
(a) Schematic illustration
of the geometry used to initiate dual
ASE from stacked red- and green-emitting free-standing membranes.
(b) Evolution of the emission spectra at different pump fluences for
stacks of CsPb(Br,I)3/CsPbBr3—CA multilayers
demonstrating their ability to sustain dual-color ASE. The inset CIE
diagram indicates the tunability of the ASE emission chromaticity
via the excitation fluence. (c) Integrated area of the combined emission
from the stacked membranes and fwhm of the emission of each of the
two membranes plotted against excitation energy density.
(a) Schematic illustration
of the geometry used to initiate dual
ASE from stacked red- and green-emitting free-standing membranes.
(b) Evolution of the emission spectra at different pump fluences for
stacks of CsPb(Br,I)3/CsPbBr3—CA multilayers
demonstrating their ability to sustain dual-color ASE. The inset CIE
diagram indicates the tunability of the ASE emission chromaticity
via the excitation fluence. (c) Integrated area of the combined emission
from the stacked membranes and fwhm of the emission of each of the
two membranes plotted against excitation energy density.The potential of the NC-sensitized free-standing membranes
for
other applications such as light downconverters for white light generation
and underwater light communication was also explored, with blue-green
lasers being considered ideal candidates, to satisfy the demand for
high-bandwidth, high-speed wireless communication due to the large
range data transfer with low propagation losses in aqueous environments.
For the former function, green and red-emitting membranes were individually
or jointly integrated with blue-emitting InGaN LEDs. As presented
in Figure a–c,
the blue electroluminescence can be partially converted to green or
red emission by respected combinations of the InGaN diodes with green
or red emissive NC/CA multilayers. Integration of the green and red
membranes to the nitride LEDs results in RGB emission. By exploiting
the fact that the emission chromaticity can be finely tuned via the
LED driving current, a pure white color of CIE coordinates 0.34, 0.35
at a color temperature of ∼5000 K, and an NTSC 115% wide color
gamut can be demonstrated, as shown in Figures d and S9. The
results indicate that such lightweight, thin, and bendable structures
are promising for applications in flexible lighting panels and displays.
Figure 7
Optical
spectrum of combined blue-emitting InGaN LEDs with (a)
CsPbBr3 NC, (b) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC, and (c) combination
of both membranes. The inset photos show the hybrid LEDs under operation.
(d) Color gamut of the hybrid white-light system according to CIE
1931 color space in comparison with the National television system
committee (NTSC) standard. (e) Evolution of ASE spectra of CsPbBr3 membranes immersed in deionized (DI) water. The inset photo
shows the membrane under operation. (f) Integrated emission and spectral
linewidth as a function of the excitation fluence.
Optical
spectrum of combined blue-emitting InGaN LEDs with (a)
CsPbBr3 NC, (b) CsPb(Br,I)3 NC, and (c) combination
of both membranes. The inset photos show the hybrid LEDs under operation.
(d) Color gamut of the hybrid white-light system according to CIE
1931 color space in comparison with the National television system
committee (NTSC) standard. (e) Evolution of ASE spectra of CsPbBr3 membranes immersed in deionized (DI) water. The inset photo
shows the membrane under operation. (f) Integrated emission and spectral
linewidth as a function of the excitation fluence.The small solubility of CA in DI water combined with encapsulation
of the flexible membranes by the Hyflon AD 60 fluoropolymer,[52] enabled the demonstration of nanosecond-excited
ASE in an aqueous environment, as presented in Figure e. Upon UV-excitation of CsPbBr3 NC-based structures, an increase of fluence results in the activation
of ASE at ∼2.33 eV with an ASE onset at Pth ∼ 320 μJ cm–2, as presented
in Figure f. The increase
of the threshold by a factor of ∼3, compared to the respective
samples investigated in ambient conditions, can be assigned to the
reduction of the refractive index contrast between the membrane (nCA ∼ 1.46) and the surrounding medium
(nDI water ∼ 1.33 vs nair ∼ 1) resulting in higher optical
losses of the resonator as well as the degradation of the water-soaked
structure.
Conclusions
In summary, we have
demonstrated the facile, fully solution-processed
fabrication of flexible, free-standing structures, combining CA polymer
membranes with active gain media based on multilayer stacks of CA
with green CsPbBr3 or red-emitting CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs. Such flexible membranes act as low Q waveguides
supporting optical modes that can effectively couple with the perovskite
gain media emission resulting in nanosecond-excited ASE with a lower
threshold, higher net modal gain, and suppressed optical losses compared
to identical multilayers deposited on rigid quartz substrates. Furthermore,
they exhibit higher ASE operational stability compared to the latter
samples as a result of the better heat outflow properties arising
from the absence of a supporting substrate and the smaller thermal
interface resistance between the two soft and comfortable CA and NC
media. The exceptional optical amplification properties of such membranes
are witnessed by their ability to stack up and sustain dual-color
ASE in the green and red parts of the spectrum, while their versatility
for other photonic applications is confirmed by demonstrations of
white light generation and underwater ASE. The presented results demonstrate
the high potential of simple, solution-processed waveguides based
on polymer resonators and LHP NC gain media for practical, scalable,
flexible, and low-cost spontaneous and stimulated emission applications.
Materials
and Methods
NC Synthesis
CsPbBr3 DDAB NCs
The
synthesis of CsPbBr3 DDAB NCs is similar to the method
described in ref (53).
CsPb(Br,I)3 DDAB NCs
Preparation of Cesium Oleate
Precursor Solution
(Cs-oleate,
0.4 M). Cs2CO3 (814 mg, 2.5 mmol) was mixed
with octadecene (10 mL) and OA (2 mL, 6.34 mmol) in a vial. The mixture
was stirred and heated to ca. 125 °C on a hot plate until it
became clear and then cooled to room temperature.
Synthesis
of CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs
PbI2 (200 mg, 0.434
mmol) and DDAB (92.5 mg, 0.2 mmol) were added to
10 mL mesitylene in a 100 mL 3-necked flask. The mixture was heated
to 110 °C under a nitrogen atmosphere and. After the reaction
mixture reached set temperature, OA (1 mL, 3.17 mmol) and DOAm (2
mL, 6.63 mmol) were injected simultaneously. Then the temperature
of the mixture was raised to 140 °C forming a clear yellowish
solution, and then, the Cs-oleate (0.3 mL, 0.12 mmol) precursor was
swiftly injected. After 10s the reaction mixture was cooled down to
RT with a water/ice bath.
Isolation and Purification
of CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs
The purification procedure
was performed in the nitrogen glove box
using anhydrous solvents. The crude solution was centrifuged at 5000
rpm (3438g) for 7 min. The supernatant was discarded,
and the precipitate was dispersed in 10 mL of anhydrous hexane and
then centrifuged at 3700 rpm (1883g) for 2 min. The
precipitate was discarded, and 7 mL of anhydrous methyl acetate was
added to the supernatant, followed by centrifugation at 10,000 rpm
(13751g) for 5 min. The resulting precipitate was
dispersed in 3 mL anhydrous cyclohexane, followed by centrifugation
at 3700 rpm (1883g) for 2 min. The precipitate was
discarded, and the obtained colloidal solution of CsPb(Br/I)3 NCs was filtered with a PTFE-syringe filter (pore size 0.2 μm)
and used for further studies.
Sample Preparation
Quartz substrates with dimensions
of 2 × 1.5 cm were used for the deposition of the NC/CA multilayers
and the CA slabs. Prior to the deposition process, the substrates
underwent sequential cleaning with n-butyl acetate,
acetone, and IPA. The substrates were then kept in nitric acid for
8 h allowing them to form a highly hydrophilic surface. The samples
were then washed with deionized water, followed by sequential cleaning
with n-butyl acetate, acetone, and IPA and dried
under compressed air.
Flexible Membranes
CA (CA, Mn =
30,000, ηca ∼ 1.46) dissolved in acetone at
120 mg/mL was prepared
for the formation of free-standing and spacer layers used in the samples.
For the formation of the free-standing membranes, cellulose acetate
was spin cast under static conditions on a quartz substrate at 4000
rpm for 30 s. The thickness of the free-standing membranes was determined
via the single-point ellipsometry method, measured by a ThetaMetrisis
ellipsometer (FR-PRO).
LHP NCs/CA Multilayers
Multilayers
were deposited either
directly on top of quartz substrates or to the CA flexible substrates
via spin casting. Initially, CsPbBr3 or CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs dispersed in toluene (∼30 mg/mL) was deposited
under static coating conditions, at 1000 rpm for 30 s, followed by
a drying step at 4000 rpm for 10 sec. CA diluted in acetone (13 mg/mL),
was used as the spacer layer deposited via dynamic deposition of CA
at 5000 rpm. The bilayer deposition was repeated as many times as
needed to produce multilayers. In the case of the membranes, subsequent
to multilayer deposition, they were peeled off from the substrate.
TMM Model
A TMM model was used to simulate the reflectivity
from the studied waveguides as well as produce the cross-sectional
distribution of the electric field within the structures. The TMM
model is described in detail in the book “Basics of Optics
of Multilayer Systems”.[54] The absorption
spectra of the CsPbBr3 and CsPb(Br,I)3 NCs were
used as the input of the TMM model, with the amplitude of the excitonic
absorption corresponding to the oscillator strength of the excitonic
species.
Optical Spectroscopy
Steady-State PL and Optical Absorbance
The absorbance
of films was acquired using a PerkinElmer Lamda 1050 spectrophotometer
with a spectra range of 200–3000 nm. Steady-state PL was excited
by a 405 nm diode laser and detected via a combination of a 0.75 m
Acton 750i Princeton spectrometer and a 1024 × 256 pixels PIXIS
charge-coupled device (CCD) camera.
White-Light Angle-Resolved
Reflectivity
A custom-made
goniometer was used, equipped with a fiber-coupled tungsten-halogen
white light source coupled to a 600 μm core multimode fiber.
The white light beam was focused onto the sample’s surface
using a collimating and a focusing lens mount on the excitation arm,
in a 2 mm spot diameter. A second rotating arm was then used to collect
the reflected light via a fiber-coupled Ocean-Optics CCD spectrometer,
with a spectral resolution of ∼1 nm.
Amplified Spontaneous Emission
Experiments
The optical
excitation of the films was performed via Quantel Brilliant Nd/YAG
laser either 355 or 532 nm wavelength, producing a 4 mm beam with
a pulse width of ∼6 ns and repetition rate of 10 Hz. The excitation
energy density was varied via neutral density optical filters. The
excitation was performed using a line-shaped beam, focused on the
sample via a cylindrical lens. The PL and ASE were collected from
the sample side using a Mitutoyo 10×, 0.28 NA long working distance
objective coupled to a 100 μm core multimode fiber. The collected
emission spectra were dispersed in a 0.75 m Acton 750i Princeton spectrometer
equipped with a 1024 × 256 pixels PIXIS CCD camera.
Optical Gain
Properties
For the estimation of the optical
gain properties of our samples, VSL experiments were used. The excitation
beam was focused via a cylindrical lens in a 5 × 1 mm spot. The
length of the strip was adjusted via a precision-adjustable slit with
a micrometer sensitivity of 5 μm. For the optical loss measurements,
the excitation beam was initially placed at the edge of the sample.
By keeping the excitation beam size, intensity, and position constant,
the sample was moved in 50 μm intervals away from the light
collection side.
Transmission Electron Microscopy
TEM images were collected
using a JEOL JEM2200FS microscope operating at 200 kV accelerating
voltage.
Authors: Yu Tong; Eva Bladt; Meltem F Aygüler; Aurora Manzi; Karolina Z Milowska; Verena A Hintermayr; Pablo Docampo; Sara Bals; Alexander S Urban; Lakshminarayana Polavarapu; Jochen Feldmann Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2016-09-30 Impact factor: 15.336