Arif Ali1, Mohd Muslim1, Ishita Neogi2, Mohd Afzal3, Abdullah Alarifi3, Musheer Ahmad1. 1. Department of Applied Chemistry, ZHCET, Faculty of Engineering and Technology, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh 202002, India. 2. Chemical Sciences and Technology Division, CSIR-National Institute for Interdisciplinary Science and Technology (NIIST), Industrial Estate PO, Thiruvananthapuram 695019, India. 3. Department of Chemistry, College of Science, King Saud University, Riyadh 11451, Saudi Arabia.
Abstract
In this work, a new bimetallic Na(I)-Zn(II) metal-organic framework (MOF), formulated as [Na2Zn3(btc)2(μ-HCOO)2(μ-H2O)8] n (1) (H3btc = benzene tricarboxylic acid), and its composite (ZnO@1) have been successfully synthesized using solvothermal and mechanochemical solid grinding methods. 1 and ZnO@1 were characterized by diffraction [single-crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD) and powder XRD], spectroscopic (ultraviolet-visible diffuse reflectance spectroscopy and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy), microscopic (transmission electron microscopy), and thermal (thermogravimetric analysis) methods. The surface area and porosity of 1 were determined using a Brunauer-Emmett-Teller analyzer. Single-crystal diffraction of 1 confirms that Na1 and Zn2 have octahedral coordination environments, whereas Zn1 has a tetrahedral coordination geometry. Topological simplification of 1 shows a 3,6-connected kgd net. Na(I)-Zn(II) MOF (1) is crystallized with slight porosity and exhibits good tendency toward the encapsulation of zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO NPs). The photocatalytic behaviors of 1 and its composite (ZnO@1) were investigated over MB dye under sunlight illumination with promising degradation efficiencies of 93.69% for 1 and 97.53% for ZnO@1 in 80 min.
In this work, a new bimetallic Na(I)-Zn(II) metal-organic framework (MOF), formulated as [Na2Zn3(btc)2(μ-HCOO)2(μ-H2O)8] n (1) (H3btc = benzene tricarboxylic acid), and its composite (ZnO@1) have been successfully synthesized using solvothermal and mechanochemical solid grinding methods. 1 and ZnO@1 were characterized by diffraction [single-crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD) and powder XRD], spectroscopic (ultraviolet-visible diffuse reflectance spectroscopy and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy), microscopic (transmission electron microscopy), and thermal (thermogravimetric analysis) methods. The surface area and porosity of 1 were determined using a Brunauer-Emmett-Teller analyzer. Single-crystal diffraction of 1 confirms that Na1 and Zn2 have octahedral coordination environments, whereas Zn1 has a tetrahedral coordination geometry. Topological simplification of 1 shows a 3,6-connected kgd net. Na(I)-Zn(II) MOF (1) is crystallized with slight porosity and exhibits good tendency toward the encapsulation of zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO NPs). The photocatalytic behaviors of 1 and its composite (ZnO@1) were investigated over MB dye under sunlight illumination with promising degradation efficiencies of 93.69% for 1 and 97.53% for ZnO@1 in 80 min.
In the past years, the demand of commercialized dyes and their
products has increased rapidly. The bulk production of a variety of
dyes was mainly aimed at to fulfill the demand of huge population,
but less attention was paid to their discharges and implications on
water bodies.[1−3] Near about thousands of natural and organic synthetic
dyes and dyestuff are being used in textile, paper, and leather industries
for coloring the products and are discharged into water sources. Based
on the World Bank reports, ∼17–20% contribution of water
pollution is due to the textile and dyeing industries.[4−6] According to recent reports, it has been concluded that the total
annual production of azo dyes (−N=N−) accounts
for about 7 × 105 tons and ∼13–15% of
this value is discarded into the water bodies.[7,8] These
waste dyestuff materials are potentially toxic not only to human health
but also to environments and aquatic life.[1,9,10] Slow degradation of such dyestuff by sunlight
in the water system and further complexation with several essential
metal ions may be hazardous for living systems.[11]Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are a new
class of crystalline
hybrid materials, also famous as brilliant porous coordination materials
that are composed of the organic linker and inorganic secondary building
units (metal ions/metal nodes).[12−16] MOFs have witnessed fast development in inorganic as well as material
chemistry due to their attractive properties, intriguing topologies,
and structural features coupled with high surface area, thermal stability,
and porosity. Moreover, the conventional semiconductor nature of MOFs
is solely dependent on the photoactive organic ligands, which can
be tuned by incorporating active metal ions.[17,18] MOFs have been exploited potentially in a wide range of research
areas such as photocatalysis,[19−21] adsorption,[8,22−26] gas sorption,[26−30] sensing,[31−33] magnetism,[34−38] and so on. The dimensionality and topology of MOFs are also dependent
on their mode of coordination assembly.[39,40] Zhang and
co-workers synthesized a new MOF material (NENU-505) that has shown
adsorption of cationic dye, and the adsorption capacity of NENU-505
was 33.5 mg/g at room temperature for methylene blue (MB).[41] Li and co-workers have also constructed a new
Cu-MOF for the removal of MB dye with a 45.045 mg/g or 96% removal
rate.[42a] Abedi and co-workers have also
shown the photocatalytic activity of the Ni(II)/K-based heterometallic
MOF toward the degradation of bromocresol green (BCG) dye under visible
light, which led to 94% degradation.[42b]MOFs play the most promising role in host–guest chemistry.
MOFs that are well-designed and have suitable porosity are capable
of hosting the nanoparticles (NPs). NPs are nanosized materials with
a high surface area and good semiconductor properties. Some pioneering
researchers have developed a variety of MOF-based NPs (NP@MOFs) via
the solid grinding method.[43a−43d] They successfully established that the NPs
can be encapsulated inside the pores of MOFs via the host–guest
mechanism, exploiting various non-covalent interactions.[44] Encapsulation of MOFs with NPs could result
in decreasing the band gap due to fast (e–/h+) recombination between MOF architectures and metal NPs.[45−47] The above observation inspired us to design and synthesize a new
ZnO@1 composite via the solid grinding method, and it
shows promising MB dye degradation efficiency over the MOF (1).
Results and Discussion
Structural
Description and Topological Study
of MOF 1
The crystal structure of [Na2Zn3(btc)2(μ-HCOO)2(μ-H2O)8] (1) was confirmed by single-crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD), and it
was crystallized in the monoclinic system with the C2/c space group. The asymmetric unit of 1 consists of one benzenetricarboxylate ion (organic linker), four
water molecules (three coordinated and one μ-H2O),
two independent zinc metal ions, and one sodium ion (Figure a). The fully deprotonated
(btc3–) ligand adopts both the mono and bidentate
fashion to connect Zn(II) and Na(I) ions. However, the formate (HCOO–) adopts the bridging monodentate fashion with Zn(II)
and Na(I) ions. Na1 and Zn2 have octahedral coordination polyhedra
(CN = 6), and Zn1 has a tetrahedral coordination polyhedron (Figure b). As depicted in Figure c, MOF 1 shows the following bond lengths: Zn1–O2 = 1.9481 Å,
Zn1–O8 = 1.9682 Å, Zn2–O5 = 2.0469 Å, Zn2–O12
= 2.1307 Å, Na1–O1 = 2.3579 Å, Na1–O5 = 2.4019
Å, Na1–O8 = 2.3280 Å, Na1–O12 = 2.4530 and
Zn1–Na1 = 3.504 Å, and Zn2–Na1 = 3.413 Å,
which are within the reported range. The linear chain of Zn(II) and
Na(I) is further extended by carboxylates of btc3– ligands to generate a three-dimensional heterobimetallic architecture
(Figure d).
Figure 1
(a) View of
the molecular structure of 1, (b) polyhedral
view of metal ions, (c) linear heterometallic chain of Zn(II) and
Na(I) ions, and (d) 3D architecture.
(a) View of
the molecular structure of 1, (b) polyhedral
view of metal ions, (c) linear heterometallic chain of Zn(II) and
Na(I) ions, and (d) 3D architecture.The topological study of 1 shows the coordination
formula to be A5K52M26M14,[48] where
A is a metal [(Zn)3 and (Na)2], K5 is C9H3O6, M2 is CHO2, and M1 corresponds to water. The standard representation
of valence-bonded 1 in the 3,4,5,5-c nodal net of the
new topological type with the point symbol for the net is represented
as follows: {3.6.7}2{32.4.52.6.82.92}2{32.4.52.62.72.8}2{32.82.92}(Figure S1). To understand the
extended generation of different subnets from the underlying net that
contains the edges of weight no less than a specified value and having
applied the multilevel analysis following the order of subnets, we
describe the packing of the structure on different levels of solid
angle (Supporting Information, Table S1). At a higher solid angle, the coordination of 1 is
zero-dimensional (0D). On decreasing the solid angle, we have found
extended dimension packing of the structure connected. Formation of
a 3,4,5,5-c net depends on the value of the solid angle (Ω), as shown in Figure a. The topology
in a 3,6-connected net with the point symbol for net {43}2{46.66.83} is presented
in Figure b,c.
Figure 2
(a) Order of
the subnets that describe the packing of the structure
on different levels of the solid angle, (b) topological type after rod–net representation of structure 1, and (c) structural fragments in the (100) direction.
(a) Order of
the subnets that describe the packing of the structure
on different levels of the solid angle, (b) topological type after rod–net representation of structure 1, and (c) structural fragments in the (100) direction.
FTIR, PXRD, TGA, and UV-DRS
Analysis
The vibrational bands show the binding of carboxylate,
formate (μ-HCOO–), and water (μ-H2O) with sodium and
zinc metal ions. Herein, the vibration stretching frequency of ν(O–H)
of the bridging water molecules is observed at 3360 cm–1. The medium absorption bands ∼2800–3127 cm–1 could be due to the hydrogen-bonded −OH network inside the
MOF. The absorption frequencies at ∼2750 and 1340 cm–1 may be attributed to the stretching and bending vibrations of bridging
formate (HCOO–) ions.[8,49] The symmetric
and asymmetric vibrational bands at 1412 cm–1 [νs(COO–)] and 1595 cm–1[νas(COO–)] could be assigned to the carboxylate
groups.[50−52] The absorption bands ν(Na–O) and ν(Zn–O)
appeared at 561 and 466 cm–1, respectively. Similarly,
ZnO@1 shows shifting in the characteristic absorption
bands. The absorption band at 3450 cm–1 could be
attributed to ν(O–H), and the disappearance of the band
at 3127 cm–1 indicates that zinc oxide NPs (ZnO-NPs)
are encapsulated inside the pores via hydrogen bonding and other weak
interactions.[53] The vibrational absorption
band at 475 cm–1 could be due to ZnO NPs[54] (Figure S2).Powder XRD (PXRD) patterns were recorded to check the bulk phase
purity or structural integrity of 1 and ZnO@1. Simulated and experimental patterns match well, which confirm the
bulk purity of the synthesized MOF. ZnO@1 shows new patterns
from 25 to 40°, which could be an indication of the embedding
of zinc oxide NPs inside the pores of 1. The structural
integrity and crystalline nature of the architecture were maintained
during the experiments (Figure S3). Thermogravimetric
analysis (TGA) was performed to confirm the thermal stabilities of 1 and its composite (ZnO@1). The decomposition
of the framework of 1 started at ∼115 °C
due to the elimination of coordinated water molecules. MOFs 1 and ZnO@1 are thermally stable upto ∼290
°C and ∼315 °C, respectively (Figure S4).Ultraviolet–visible diffuse reflectance
spectroscopy (UV-DRS)
spectra of 1 and its composite were recorded between
250 and 800 nm to identify their optical behaviors. The energy band
gap of 1 and its composite were estimated from the Tauc
plot. The plot of (αhν)2 versus
the energy (hν) gives the band gap as the x-axis intercept of an extrapolated tangential line.[9] The band gaps of 1 and its composite
were estimated to be 3.27 and 3.15 eV (Figure a,b), respectively. Moreover, zinc oxide
NPs show a band gap energy of 2.83 eV (Figure c).
Figure 3
Optical band gaps as estimated from the Tauc
plot using UV-DRS
spectra (a) 1, (b) ZnO@1, and (c) ZnO NPs.
Optical band gaps as estimated from the Tauc
plot using UV-DRS
spectra (a) 1, (b) ZnO@1, and (c) ZnO NPs.
BET and TEM Analyses
The specific
surface area and porosity of 1 were determined using
Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) adsorption isotherms for
N2 gas at 77 K and pore size distribution evaluated from
the non-local density functional theory (NLDFT) equilibrium model.[55] Degassed MOF 1 exhibited slight
porosity with variable pore volume distributions (Figure S5).MOF 1 and ZnO@1 have different particle sizes and morphologies that were confirmed
by the transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis (JEOL JEM-2100F). Figure a depicts particles
of 1 to be in a fractured cage-like architecture, which
get encapsulated with ZnO NPs.[43b,43c,56] To give better insights into ZnO@1, both low-magnification
(Figure b) and high-magnification
(Figure c) images
were recorded.
Figure 4
TEM images of (a)MOF 1, (b) ZnO@1 at
low magnification, and (c) ZnO@1 at high magnification.
TEM images of (a)MOF 1, (b) ZnO@1 at
low magnification, and (c) ZnO@1 at high magnification.
Dye Adsorption Studies
For this purpose,
crystals of 1 were soaked in the aqueous solution of
MB and methyl orange (MO) dyes of 15 ppm concentration at room temperature
for 12 h.[57a] The changes in concentrations
of the MB and MO dyes in the solution were measured using a UV–visible
(UV–vis) spectrophotometer. The color visual and UV–vis
absorption spectra of MB and MO dye solution revealed that MO dye
showed a negligible change in absorption intensity with its maximum
absorption wavelength (464 nm) (Figure S6). Interestingly, the selective adsorptive binding of cationic MB
dye molecules on the framework of 1 could be directed
by the formate ions and carboxylate oxygen atoms of btc3– ligands through electrostatic, π–π, and hydrogen
bonding interactions (Figure S7 and Supporting
Information, Table S2).[8,57b,58] Therefore, the adsorption experiment proceeded
on the selected MB dye only.To understand the adsorption phenomenon
of 1, batch adsorption experiments were performed, which
give the important insights into the adsorption efficiency, kinetics,
and adsorption mechanism.[59,60a]Figure a depicts the UV–vis spectra of 1 before and after adsorption of the MB dye. MB was adsorbed
to the maximum extent of 1 with an adsorption efficiency
of 78% within 10 mins of the adsorption experiment. However, an equilibrium
condition could be attained after achieving 85.2% adsorption efficiency;
afterward, MOF 1 showed saturation due to the limitation
of adsorption sites on it.[60b]
Figure 5
(a) UV–vis
absorption spectra of 1 for MB dye
uptake, (b) removal efficiency at variable pH values, (c) effect of
temperature, and (d) effect of contact time.
(a) UV–vis
absorption spectra of 1 for MB dye
uptake, (b) removal efficiency at variable pH values, (c) effect of
temperature, and (d) effect of contact time.To investigate how the MB dye is being adsorbed, we took photographs
of cuvettes containing the dye solution after isolating MOF 1 from
it. Additionally, the scavenging effect of the MB dye adsorption on 1 was confirmed by UV–vis characteristic peaks at 664
nm with a decreasing trend of absorption intensity at the same wavelength.[60c] To confirm the structural integrity of 1, we recorded PXRD data before and after adsorption of MB
dye on it (Figure S3). There is no significant
variation observed in diffraction patterns with a slight change in
the peak intensity. Therefore, it is confirmed that 1 facilitates dye adsorption without losing its crystallinity after
adsorption.[61a,61b]
Adsorption
Kinetics
To analyze the
adsorption kinetics, the experimental data were fitted with adsorption
kinetic models, such as pseudo-first-order, pseudo-second-order, and
intraparticle diffusion kinetic models.[61c] Several batches of experiments were carried out to investigate the
rates of adsorption, which depend upon the mobility of the dye molecules
onto the surface of 1.[61d] By
using the models, the values of kinetic parameters and the correlation
coefficient can be calculated with the help of the following equations, eqs –3, respectively.[61d]Here, the adsorption capacity
of 1 is described by qe and q (mg/g) at the equilibrium
and time.
Rate constants are different for different orders of the reaction
such as k1 for the pseudo-first-order
model (min–1), k2 for
the pseudo-second-order model (g mg–1 min–1), and k3 for the intraparticle diffusion
model (mg g–1 min–1).[62,63]The fitting results such as the adsorption capacities, rate
constant, and correlation coefficient are shown in Table . The correlation coefficient
(R2) values of 1 at different
initial concentrations were all <0.998 through the pseudo-second-order
model.[64a,64b] The good linear fitting relationship supported
that the pseudo-second-order kinetic model was the fitting model for
calculating the amount of MB in a short period (Figure ). The highest adsorption amount of MB could
reach up to 290.7 mg/g, which was comparable to those of the reported
MOF architecture (Table ).[64c]
Table 1
Kinetic
Parameters of MB Dye Adsorption
for 1
model
pseudo-first-order kinetics
pseudo-second-order kinetics
intraparticle
diffusion
parameter
k1 (min–1)
qe (cal) (mg/g)
qe (exp) (mg/g)
R2
k2 (g mg–1 min–1)
qe (cal) (mg/g)
qe (exp) (mg/g)
R2
k3 (mg/g min–1/2)
R2
MB
0.36
140.30
120.28
0.895
0.065
280.50
290.7
0.998
34.6
0.860
Figure 6
Adsorption kinetic plots for MB dye adsorption
on 1: (a) pseudo-first-order, (b) pseudo-second-order,
and (c) intraparticle
diffusion models.
Table 3
Adsorption and Photocatalytic Degradation
of MB Dye over 1
adsorption
photocatalytic degradation
MOFs
qe (mg/g)
kinetics order
mechanism
references
catalyst
(MOF)
degradation efficiency (%)
source
time (min)
references
UiO-66
69.8
pseudo-second-order
π–π stacking
interaction
(59)
3D Cu based
50
sunlight
210
(60)
MIL-53(Al)–NH2
45.2
pseudo-second-order
π–π stacking
interaction, H-bonding
(77)
3D Zn based
89
UV light
80
(84)
MIL-53(Al)
3.6
pseudo-second-order
π–π stacking
interaction, H-bonding
(77)
3D Zn based
63
visible
50
(93)
SCNU-Z2
455.6
pseudo-second-order
cation-exchange process
(90)
3D Zn based
79
visible
90
(94)
3D Na(I)–Zn(II) MOF (1)
290.7
pseudo-second-order
π–π stacking
interaction, H-bonding
this work
3D Na(I)–Zn(II) MOF (1)/ZnO@1
93.69/97.53
sunlight
80
this work
Adsorption kinetic plots for MB dye adsorption
on 1: (a) pseudo-first-order, (b) pseudo-second-order,
and (c) intraparticle
diffusion models.
Effect of pH
pH is an important parameter
influencing the adsorption process by changing the surface charge
distribution of the adsorbent.[65−68,69a] To gain deep insights
into the influence of pH on the adsorption process, we prepared a
series of solution of 1 with pH values in the range ∼3.0–14.0.
The pH values were adjusted using 0.1 N NaOH and 0.1 N HCl solution
in an aqueous medium under ambient conditions.[69b] It is evident from Figure b that as we increase the pH from 3 to 7, the adsorption
capacity of 1 increases significantly. At a low pH of
3, 1 achieved ∼20% adsorption efficiency due to
the interaction of the H+ ions with the positive part of
MB dye.[62] However, 85.2% adsorption efficiency
is reached at pH = 7. Conversely, as we increase the pH range from
neutral to alkaline, pH = 11, it can be seen that the adsorption capacity
(∼42%) decreases significantly due to the negative part of
MB interacting with the base forming NaCl.[63,69c,70,71a] The effect
of pH on the uptake capacity has been shown with 1 being
a better adsorbent at a pH of 7 with 85.2% removal efficiency of MB
dye.To identify the surface charge of the 1 adsorbent,
the point of zero charge (PZC) (pHpzc) method was utilized.[71b] The PZC (pHpzc) value can be estimated
from the plot between initial pH and ΔpH (initial pH –
final pH), which is ∼6.7 in the case of MOF 1 (Figure ). It is observed[71c,71d] that the negative charge on the surface of the adsorbent gets accumulated
with the increase in the pH, resulting in the adsorption of cationic
dyes on its surface being favored.
Figure 7
PZC (pHPZC) plot for 1.
PZC (pHPZC) plot for 1.
Effect
of Temperature
The temperature
of the solution phase is considered to be a significant parameter
because it changes the adsorption capacity of the adsorbent.[72a,72b,73] The effect of temperature on
the adsorption efficiency of 1 was recorded at different
temperatures ranging from 20 to 60 °C (Figure c). The maximum adsorption efficiency (82%)
of 1 was observed at room temperature (20 °C), and
it started to decline with further increase in the temperature from
20 to 55 °C, which indicates an exothermic process.[74a,74b,75]
Effect
of Contact Time
The contact
time is also an important factor that influences the adsorption capacity
of the adsorbents.[76a] At the start of the
reaction time, t = 0 min, 1 shows a
negligible amount of MB dye adsorption. However, ∼45% MB dye
adsorption was achieved during the first 10 min of contact time. A
rapid adsorption process was recorded during the first 60 min of adsorption.
After this period, the equilibrium is reached with 82.5% adsorption
efficiency, and beyond it, saturation is observed (Figure d).[76b,76c,77,78]
Photocatalytic Activity
Furthermore,
for the complete remediation of unabsorbed MB dye from wastewater,
the photocatalytic process has been proved to be an efficient method
to degrade or mineralize the organic pollutants from wastewater under
sunlight.[79,80] Therefore, we performed photocatalytic degradation
of MB dye over 1 and ZnO@1 by using batch
experiments that have shown a characteristic change in UV–vis
absorbance upon sunlight illumination. UV–vis experiments have
shown a gradual change in the intensity of the dye solution under
photoirradiation, which indicates the successful photocatalytic degradation
of dye molecules (Figure a,d). Photocatalytic degradation of MB was estimated from
the absorption intensity versus irradiation time plot at λmax = ∼664 nm (Figure b,e). Dye degradation efficiencies over 1 and ZnO@1 were calculated using the following relation
(eq ).[81]
Figure 8
(a,d) UV–vis spectra of the change in MB dye concentrations
over 1 and ZnO@1, (b,e) photocatalytic degradation
of MB dye with time in an aqueous solution under sunlight irradiation,
and (c,f) kinetics of MB dye degradation, plot of −ln(C0/C) vs time (min).
(a,d) UV–vis spectra of the change in MB dye concentrations
over 1 and ZnO@1, (b,e) photocatalytic degradation
of MB dye with time in an aqueous solution under sunlight irradiation,
and (c,f) kinetics of MB dye degradation, plot of −ln(C0/C) vs time (min).Photocatalytic degradation efficiency (%)where
the initial concentration is represented
by C0 and the final concentration is represented
by C at time t.Overall degradation
values of MB dye over 1 and ZnO@1 were observed
to be 93.69 and 97.53%, respectively.For 1, degradation
values of MB over 10, 15, and 20
mg were obtained to be 27.83, 46.66, and 58.81% for the initial 10
min, respectively, and the overall percentage were 91.53, 93.26, and
93.69% within 80 min, respectively. Similarly, ZnO@1 has
shown degradation of 81.60, 79.68, and 89.75% within the first 10
min and 95.92, 97.30, and 97.53% within 80 min, respectively.Moreover, the degradation kinetics of MB dye was evaluated by using
the Langmuir–Hinshelwood mechanism. Photocatalytic degradation
of MB dye followed pseudo-first-order kineticswhere the initial dye concentration is C0 (mg/L) at time t = 0, the
final dye concentration is C (mg/L) at time t = t (min), and k is
the dye degradation rate for the catalyst of pseudo-first order, and
on simplifying eq ,where, the rate of degradation –ln(C/C0) versus irradiation time
shows linear fitting for MB dye as per eq . The apparent rate of the reaction was obtained
using eq , which shows
the degradation rate of the reaction for dye[82,83]where C0 is the
initial dye concentration, kapp is the
apparent adsorption constant for MB dye on the surface of the photocatalyst
(L/mg), the maximum photocatalytic degradation rate (mg/L min) is
represented by kr, and t1/2 is the half-life time of the reaction rate, which
is calculated by using the following equation, eq (Table )[82]
Table 2
Apparent Rate Constant (kapp), Half-Life Time of the Reaction Rate (t1/2), and the Corresponding Correlation Factor (R2) for Degradation of MB Dye over the Catalyst
(1 and ZnO@1), with Values Obtained from
the Langmuir–Hinshelwood Rate Equation
parameters
1
ZnO@1
catalyst dose
kapp (min–1)
t1/2 (min–1)
R2
kapp (min–1)
t1/2 (min–1)
R2
10 mg
0.0187
37.48
0.9843
0.0262
26.46
0.9347
15 mg
0.0241
28.79
0.9903
0.0371
18.67
0.9788
20 mg
0.0280
24.75
0.9178
0.0433
16.02
0.9329
Linear fitting of the plot between −ln(C/C0) versus time gives a straight
line
with a slope parameter value which is equal to the apparent rate constant
of pseudo-first-order reaction (kapp)
(Figure c,f). The
calculated values of kapp for 1 and ZnO@1 show that the reaction rate increase with
the increasing catalyst dose for MB dye. The half-life time (t1/2) of reactions decreased with the increasing
catalyst dose, which may be attributed to faster degradation of dye
molecules at a 20 mg dose of 1 and ZnO@1. Moreover, to understand the better correlation between the catalyst
dose and reaction rate, the correlation coefficient (R2) was considered. The R2 value
of the 15 mg catalyst dose (0.9903 for 1 and 0.9787 for
ZnO@1) proved its higher efficiency for degradation of
MB dye. Therefore, the amount of the catalyst and concentration of
dye play a pivotal role in the good heterogeneous recombination for
photocatalytic degradation of dye molecules. It is observed that the
formation of the electron–hole (e–/h+) heterojunction is closely related to the degree of availability
of catalyst active sites, which results in successful photocatalysis
under sunlight exposure. The tabulated MOFs have displayed good photocatalytic
activity for degradation of MB dye under light sources (Table ).
Photocatalytic Mechanism
for Dye Degradation
MOFs as a semiconducting catalyst can
absorb photons and generate
electron–hole pairs in conduction and valance bands.[83−85] Upon irradiation of sunlight, the organic linkers act as an electron-releasing
agent via a conjugation system to metal ions.[86] The hopping of electrons from one place to another
place triggers the redox mechanism. Herein, we assume that under the
illumination of sunlight, the excited electrons from the ligand system
could react with molecular oxygen, forming reactive oxygen species
(ROS). Similarly, water molecules and their hydroxyl ions react with
the holes and form reactive hydroxyl radicals (OH•).[85−87] Therefore, ROS and OH· radicals play
a central role in the degradation of MB dye molecules (Figure ). According to some recent
reports,[88−90] presumably, the lower band gap energy of ZnO@1 could facilitate the electron excitation at a lower energy
and hence fast production of ROS and OH• radicals,
which results in an enhanced rate of photodegradation of MB dye molecules.[91,92]
Figure 9
Plausible
mechanism of photocatalytic degradation of MB dye over 1 and ZnO@1 catalysts. Hydrogen atoms are omitted
for structural clarity of 1.
Plausible
mechanism of photocatalytic degradation of MB dye over 1 and ZnO@1 catalysts. Hydrogen atoms are omitted
for structural clarity of 1.
Conclusions
Here, we have summarized the
synthesis of Na(I) and Zn(II)-based
bimetallic MOF and its composite (ZnO@1) under solvothermal
and mechanochemical solid grinding methods. Both the MOF 1 and its composite are thoroughly characterized by various spectroscopic,
thermal, and microscopic techniques. MOF 1 proved to
be a potential adsorbent toward selective removal of cationic MB dyes.
The formate ions and carboxylate oxygen atoms of btc3– ligands are key components for the selective adsorptive binding
of cationic MB dye molecules on the framework of 1 through
several electrostatic and noncovalent interactions. 1 and its composite have exhibited promising photocatalytic degradation
activity of MB dye under sunlight illumination.
Experimental
Section
Materials
Benzenetricarboxylic acid
(H3btc), zinc nitrate [Zn(NO3)·6H2O], sodium formate (HCOONa), and potassium nitrate were procured
from Sigma-Aldrich. Sodium hydroxide, MB dye, and solvents were purchased
from Fisher Scientific and used as received.
Instrumentation
A CE-440 elemental
analyzer (Exeter Analytical Inc.) was used for elemental analysis
of MOF 1. Photocatalytic degradation and adsorption studies
were performed on a Thermo Scientific Evolution 201 UV–vis
spectrophotometer with a standard path length (1 cm) of cuvettes at
ambient temperature. Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectra of 1 and ZnO@1 were obtained using a Thermo Scientific
NICOLET model (iS50). UV-DRS spectra were recorded on a PerkinElmer,
Lambda 35 spectrophotometer instrument to estimate the optical assets
of (1 and ZnO@1) photocatalysts. TGA curves
of 1 and its composite were recorded on a Shimadzu TGA-50H
instrument. For phase purity of 1 and ZnO@1, a Miniflexll X-ray diffractometer was used to record the PXRD pattern.
To investigate the particle heterostructure and intimate contact morphology
of 1 and its composite, a transmission electron microscopy
(TEM) JEOL JEM-2100F instrument was utilized. A Quanta chrome Quadrasorb
SI analyzer was used for BET analysis.
Single-Crystal
Diffraction Details
The diffraction data of 1 were obtained on a Bruker
SMART APEX CCD diffractometer and collected using monochromatic Mo
Kα radiation (λ = 0.71073 Å) at 100(2) K. The linear
absorption coefficients and the anomalous dispersion corrections were
obtained from the International Tables for X-ray crystallography.[95] Using Olex2,[96] the
structure was solved using the olex2. Solve[97] structure solution program using Charge Flipping and refined using
the olex2. Refine[97] refinement package
using Gauss–Newton minimization. All hydrogen atoms were located
in different Fourier maps in the structures and refined isotropically.
All non-H atoms were refined anisotropically. The crystal structural
refinement data, details of the bond lengths, and bond angles of 1 are provided in Supporting Information, Tables S3–S5.
Synthesis of Complex 1
A mixture of 20 mg of benzenetricarboxylic acid
(H3btc),
10 mg of sodium formate (HCOONa), and 100 mg of zinc nitrate [Zn(NO3)2·6H2O] was dissolved in 5 mL
of the solvent mixture (2 mL of ethanol and 3 mL of H2O)
and transferred into a Teflon autoclave. 0.5 mL of sodium hydroxide
solution (1 mmol) was added into it and sealed tightly. The autoclave
was placed in the hydrothermal oven for 72 h at 120 °C. After
this period, we obtained a pale yellow colored solution, and it was
filtered. The solution was left to allow slow evaporation. After 2–3
weeks, we observed light pale yellow cubic-like crystals (Scheme ). Melting point:
245 °C; elemental analysis (%): calcd for C20H24Na2O24Zn3 (890.57): C, 26.97%;
H, 2.72%; found: C, 27.01%; H, 2.79%. IR (cm–1):
3359 (w), 3127 (w), 2800 (m), 2460 (w), 1586 (s), 1456 (s), 1379 (s),
1113 (w), 1017 (s), 880 (w), 820 (w), 768 (m), 716 (m), 561 (m), 466
(w).
Scheme 1
Schematic Representation of Synthesis of 1
Synthesis of ZnO@1
Zinc oxide NPs (ZnO NPs) and ZnO@1 were synthesized
using earlier reported procedures with slight modification.[43,47,98] We took 100 mg of MOF 1 and 10% (w/w) of zinc oxide NPs in an agate mortar and pestle and
performed mechanochemical solid grinding for 2 h at ambient temperature.
Following this, a few drops of ethanol in ground powder were added
and subjected to drying under vacuum for 30 min. The obtained ZnO@1, as shown in Scheme , is thoroughly characterized. IR (cm–1):
3450 (s), 2850 (w), 2460(w), 1620 (s), 1477(s), 1376 (m), 1343 (m),
1190 (w), 1119 (s), 1017 (s), 840 (w), 768 (w), 725 (w), 622 (w).
Scheme 2
Schematic Representation of Encapsulation of NPs inside the Pores
of the MOF
Batch
Adsorption Process
We prepared
a standard stock solution of 15 ppm [15 mg of the dye in 1 L of demineralized
water (DMW)] MB dye. The crystalline sample of 1 was
immersed in 30 mL of dye solution in a 100 mL conical flask and kept
for 90 min at room temperature. Following this, we recorded UV–vis
spectra between 450 and 750 nm wavelengths at a regular time interval
(after each 10 min). The maximum absorption of the dye solution appears
at a wavelength of λmax = 665 nm. Moreover, decreasing
patterns were observed in the absorbance peak with time. Using eqs and 10,[82] the percentage removal efficiency
and the adsorption capacity, respectively, of 1 can be
estimatedwhere C0 (mg/L)
and C (mg/L) represent
the initial and at time t (min) equilibrium concentrations
of the dye solution, respectively. Here, the sample volume is V (in mL) and “m” stands
for the dose or mass (mg) of the adsorbent. We also explored the significance
of parameters such as time, temperature, and pH on the adsorption
process.
Photocatalytic Degradation of Dye
To check the photocatalytic activity, we took 10, 15, and 20 mg amounts
of 1 and ZnO@1 dispersed in 30 mL of MB
dye stock aqueous solution (15 ppm) in 50 mL separate beakers, and
before using sunlight irradiation, the solution was magnetically stirred
for 1 h to confirm the establishment of the equilibrium between adsorption
and desorption processes after the suspended solution was formed.
Following this, the solution was exposed to sunlight for photocatalytic
degradation of MB dye molecules over 1 and ZnO@1, and their UV–vis spectra were continually recorded
to confirm absorption behaviors. A continuous decrease in the intensity
of the absorption edge confirmed the photocatalytic degradation of
MB dye. The overall reaction was shown to follow pseudo-first-order
kinetics for photocatalytic dye degradation and the rate constant
of the reaction was calculated using eq .[98]where k is calculated from
the plot of −ln(C/C0) versus time interval and C0 and C denote the concentrations of dye at time t = 0 and t = t (min), respectively.
PZC Study
To determine the surface
charge of adsorbent 1 for the dye adsorption process,
the pHPZC estimations were performed in both acidic and
basic aqueous phases at different pH values. A series of 30 mL of
(0.1 M) KNO3 aqueous solution were taken into 100 mL conical
flasks, and their pH values were adjusted to values between 2 and
10 (2, 4, 6, 8, and 10) by adding 0.1 M HCl and 0.1 M NaOH. Afterward,
15 mg of adsorbent 1 was added in each conical flask
for 24 h. Now, after the completion of this time period, the solutions
were centrifuged, and their pH (final pH) values were measured.[91,92]
Authors: Viktor N Serezhkin; Anna V Vologzhanina; Larisa B Serezhkina; Ekaterina S Smirnova; Elena V Grachova; Polina V Ostrova; Mikhail Yu Antipin Journal: Acta Crystallogr B Date: 2009-01-15