Elyse Kimpiab1, Kashala Fabrice Kapiamba2, Leo Folifac1, Oluwaseun Oyekola1, Leslie Petrik3. 1. Department of Chemical Engineering, Cape Peninsula University of Technology, Symphony way, P.O. Box 1906, Bellville, Cape Town 7535, South Africa. 2. Department of Civil, Architectural and Environmental Engineering, Missouri University of Science and Technology, Rolla, Missouri 65401, United States. 3. Environmental and Nanoscience, Chemistry Department, Faculty of Natural Science, University of the Western Cape, Cape Town 8000, South Africa.
Abstract
Intensive mining activities generate toxic acid mine drainage (AMD) effluents containing a high concentration of metals, including iron. The chemical synthesis of iron nanoparticles from this waste could lead to further environmental concerns. Therefore, the green synthesis of nanoparticles using plants has gained significant interest because of several benefits, including being eco-friendly. The current study reports a novel approach involving the synthesis of stabilized iron nanoparticles from AMD using rooibos tea extract. An aqueous solution of rooibos tea was prepared and titrated with AMD to reduce Fe2+/Fe3+. The samples synthesized under optimum conditions were characterized by TEM, XRD, FTIR, UV-Vis, and EDS. The results revealed that the nanoparticles had an average particle size of 36 nm with a spherical shape. These particles showed promising application as a Fenton-like catalyst for the degradation of textile dye (orange II sodium salt) with a removal efficiency of 94% within 30 min. Thus, the stabilized iron nanoparticles synthesized here performed in higher ranges than the currently reported Fenton-like catalysts regarding dye removal efficiency and reaction time.
Intensive mining activities generate toxic acid mine drainage (AMD) effluents containing a high concentration of metals, including iron. The chemical synthesis of iron nanoparticles from this waste could lead to further environmental concerns. Therefore, the green synthesis of nanoparticles using plants has gained significant interest because of several benefits, including being eco-friendly. The current study reports a novel approach involving the synthesis of stabilized iron nanoparticles from AMD using rooibos tea extract. An aqueous solution of rooibos tea was prepared and titrated with AMD to reduce Fe2+/Fe3+. The samples synthesized under optimum conditions were characterized by TEM, XRD, FTIR, UV-Vis, and EDS. The results revealed that the nanoparticles had an average particle size of 36 nm with a spherical shape. These particles showed promising application as a Fenton-like catalyst for the degradation of textile dye (orange II sodium salt) with a removal efficiency of 94% within 30 min. Thus, the stabilized iron nanoparticles synthesized here performed in higher ranges than the currently reported Fenton-like catalysts regarding dye removal efficiency and reaction time.
Mining industries are
significant contributors to many countries’
national gross domestic products.[1,2] Consequently,
the huge amount of waste from mining activities adversely affects
ecosystems, including human health.[3,4] Minerals are
extracted from both open-pit and underground mine configurations across
the life of the mine, inevitably leading to the generation of acid
mine drainage (AMD), a toxic waste effluent. AMD is generated by the
spontaneous oxidation of FeS2 when exposed to air and water.
On one hand, AMD can cause deleterious effects on the environment
when discharged into water systems. Notably, AMD results in river
pollution, depletion of aquatic life, and contamination of the food
chain by toxic metals. The impacts of AMD, including the contamination
of surface water, its threat to the quality of freshwater resources,
and its impact upon the well-being of humans and the environment at
large, are well documented.[5,6] Meanwhile, AMD has been
chemically treated to precipitate metals, including iron, using reducing
reagents. AMD remediation and prevention, treatment technique options,
and resource recovery have been reviewed.[7,8] On
the other hand, the textile industry, which employs large amounts
of colorants including dyes and dye-protecting agents, generates a
huge amount of dye wastewater that is toxic to the environment.[9,10] This toxicity may range from soil contamination to pollution of
an entire river, potentially causing severe harm to aquatic life.
In many countries, the law recommends treating dye wastewater before
its discharge into the environment and emphasizing decoloration. Adsorption
techniques for purifying wastewater have become more prevalent in
recent years owing to their efficiency in removing pollutants that
are difficult to treat using biological methods. Adsorption can produce
high-quality water and is an economically feasible process. Possible
approaches to textile wastewater, including advanced oxidative and
biological processes, have been critically reviewed.[11−13] Meanwhile, most currently employed approaches suffer from waste
management and environmental protection setbacks, considering the
life cycle of chemicals used, high cost, and technological immaturity
for biological processes. Nevertheless, in recent years, environmental
research has paid particular attention to zero-valent iron (ZVI) owing
to its inherent reactivity to textile effluents such as dyes and site
remediation applications.[14,15] For instance, orange
II sodium salt is an azo dye produced by the azo coupling of β-naphthol
and the diazonium derivative of sulfanilic acid. This dye is often
used to dye wool in the textile industry. Furthermore, orange II sodium
salt in wastewater is of specific environmental concern because it
generates an unpleasant color to the water in addition to the hazards
of dangerous by-products generated through oxidation, hydrolysis,
or other chemical reactions occurring in the waste phase. Fenton-like
reactions are responsible for the degradation of pollutants. Several
studies have reported the mechanisms underlying these reactions. However,
the activity of most heterogeneous catalysts decreases under macroneutral
conditions due to strong dependence on the pH of the solution.[16] However, Yan et al.[17] recently provided a cocatalytic heterogeneous Fenton (CoFe2O4/MoS2) system independent of the surrounding
pH, thus enhancing the remediation of organic pollutants. Furthermore,
Ji et al.[18] developed self-producing reactive
oxygen species systems (made of a mixture of a cobalt-based catalyst
Fe2+ species) and maintained the continuous and effective
degradation of organic pollutants. Another type of catalyst that has
shown immense success for pollutant degradation in water is ZVI nanoparticles
(nZVI). These nanoparticles are predominantly 10–60 nm in size
with exceptional characteristics and a maximum wavelength of 400 nm.[19−21] Shahwan et al.[22] reported that the higher
surface reactivity of nZVI is due to its small size, large surface
area, and oxidation state. The chemical synthesis of nZVI has been
successfullyachieved by several groups; the synthesis methods, applications,
and performance assessment of these nanoparticles have been well documented.[23−25] The major setback and the challenge in producing high volumes of
iron nanoparticles using chemical methods relies on the need for NaBH4
as a reducing agent, which is very expensive and has strict environmental
restriction policies. Hence, alternative “green” ways
with the use of plant extracts or cheaper reducing agents have gained
popularity in the past decade. Plant extracts have been proven to
be impeccable reducing agents, and iron nanoparticles, including nZVI,
were successfully synthesized.[26,27] The latest studies
worth mentioning include the Ricinus communis aqueous seed extract used to synthesize nZVI to treat methylene
blue-polluted water.[27] The other plant
extracts explored as reductants comprise (list is nonexhaustive) onion
peel extract, pomegranate peel extract, and Cleistocalyx
operculatus leaf extract.[28−30]The iron
nanoparticles synthesis demonstrated in the abovementioned
publications required manufactured chemicals (iron salts) as the source
of iron. However, green reducing agents have been employed, thus only
partially solving an eventual environmental concern. Considering that
AMD contains a high concentration of iron which can be valorized,
investment in effective technologies to recycle/reuse iron in AMD
would promote sustainable economies. Thus, the recovery of iron from
AMD could promote a circular economy. Because of the limitations of
chemical precipitation methods as well as potential environmental
concerns, this research focused on synthesizing iron nanoparticles
from AMD using rooibos tea extract (Aspalathus linearis or red tea) as a reducing reagent. This study avoids the chemical
removal of iron, potentially resulting in secondary pollution. Here,
an environmentally friendly alternative was employed to synthesize
polyphenol-stabilized iron nanoparticles from AMD waste effluent using
rooibos tea extract (RBE), a readily available resource. Furthermore,
the effectiveness of the synthesized iron nanoparticles as a Fenton
catalyst to remove orange II sodium salt from textile wastewater was
assessed.
Methodology
Synthesis
of Iron Nanoparticles
Fresh
dry rooibos tea leaves (200 g) were added to 200 mL of a 20% ethanol
solution (50% grade, Sigma-Aldrich) and then stirred for 1 h. Next,
the liquid was separated from the tea leaves using a sieve, frozen,
and dried for 72 h in a freeze dryer (−55 °C and 0.2 bar,
FreeZone 2.5 L, Labconco). The dry powdered rooibos tea extract (about
15 g) obtained by freezing was mixed with 100 mL of distilled water
to prepare solutions with a water concentration range of 5–20
g/L. The pH of the solution was measured before titration and varied
in the range of 4 to 7 by adding drops of sodium hydroxide (NaOH)
at room temperature. Finally, the pH-adjusted aqueous tea solution
was poured into a burette for titration with 100 mL of AMD (from a
coal mine in Mpumalanga, South Africa) using a magnetic stirring plate
in the absence of oxygen (in a nitrogen-filled glove box). The raw
AMD used in this study contained 100.30 mg/L of dissolved iron; the
concentrations of other elements are presented in Figure .[31]
Figure 1
Elemental
composition of AMD.
Elemental
composition of AMD.Reaction times of 0 to
24 h were evaluated to synthesize iron nanoparticles
using rooibos tea extract as a vital parameter for optimization. The
suspensions formed were centrifuged for 30 min to recover black pellets,
which were washed with diluted ethanol and centrifuged for an additional
30 min. Finally, the washed black pellets were placed in a freeze-dryer
for 72 h and characterized thereafter. The samples at various parameters
were synthesized using a non-formal model as summarized in Table .
Table 1
Summary of Prepared Samples
sample code
concentration
of RBE (g/L)
time (h)
pH
fixed parameters
EK 1
1
5
24
7
temperature
(ambient), time, pH
2
10
3
15
4
20
EK 2
1
5
0
7
RBE concentration,
pH, temperature (ambient)
2
6
3
12
4
24
EK 3
1
5
6
4
RBE concentration,
time, temperature (ambient)
2
4.5
3
5
4
5.5
5
6
6
7
Ferric Reducing/Antioxidant
Power Assay
Ferric reducing/antioxidant power (FRAP) activity
was measured
according to the method developed by Benzie and Strain[32] with some modifications. Briefly, an acetate
buffer (300 mM, pH 3.6) was mixed with a solution of 10 Mm TPTZ (2,4,6-tripyridyl-s-triazine) in 0.1 M HCl and FeCl3·6H2O (20 mM) in a ratio of 10:1:1 to obtain the working FRAP
reagent. Then, 2 mg/ L each of ascorbic acid (standard) and plant
extract were carefully prepared and subjected to agitation for 5 min
with a vortex mixer (Dragon LAB MX-S) followed by centrifugation (Eppendorf
centrifuge 5810R) at 1000 rpm for another 5 min to allow the formation
of clear solutions of the test samples. Next, 100 mL of tea leaf extracts
were mixed separately with 300 mL of the prepared FRAP reagent. The
sample absorbance was measured at 593 nm with the Multiskan spectrum
(Thermo Electro Corporation, MA, USA). Finally, methanol solutions
of FeSO4·7H2O ranging from 100 to 2000
μM were prepared and used for creating the calibration curve
of known Fe2+ concentration. The parameter equivalent concentration
is defined as the antioxidant concentration having a Ferric-TPTZ reducing
ability equivalent to 1 Mm FeSO4·7H2O.
Characterization
The prepared iron
nanoparticles were characterized using a Hach Instruments DR6000 UV–Vis
spectrometer (Hach Lange GmbH, Düsseldorf, Germany) in the
wavelength range of 350–800 nm with a resolution of 1 nm. In
addition, RBE and iron nanoparticles, prepared under optimum conditions
(RBE = 5 g/L synthesized at room temperature, pH = 6, for 6 h of reaction
time, sample EK35), were further characterized by Fourier transform
infrared spectroscopy (FTIR, PerkinElmer PE1600). For FTIR analysis,
samples were prepared by mixing 1% EK35 specimen with 100 mg of KBr
powder and then compressing the mixture into a disc. A resolution
of 2 cm–1 was employed, and an average of 32 scans
were collected.The morphology and dispersion of the prepared
iron nanoparticles were characterized using transmission electron
microscopy (TEM, Tecnai TF20 HRTEM). The images of the samples were
recorded in bright-field mode operating at 5 kV. The size of the nanoparticles
prepared at different pH values was measured using ImageJ software
(National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA) on TEM images.
In addition, the localized elemental composition of the iron nanoparticles
was determined in duplicate by electron dispersive spectroscopy (EDS,
Oxford Instruments Aztec Energy EDS Analysis System) in conjunction
with TEM.X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of the iron nanoparticles
were
obtained using a D8 Advance XRD instrument (Bruker AXS, Germany) with
a high-power Cu Kα radiation source (λ = 0.154
nm) at a voltage and current of 40 kV and 40 mA, respectively. All
samples were scanned in steps from 10 to 80° 2θ at a scanning
rate of 3° 2θ per minute.
Application
of the Synthesized Iron Nanoparticles
Using Orange II Sodium Salt
The synthesized nanoparticles
were applied as a Fenton-like catalyst to treat simulated dye wastewater.
Batches were prepared by adding 40 mL of 50 ppm orange II sodium salt
(85% dye content, Sigma-Aldrich) with 5 mL of hydrogen peroxide (50%
solution, Sigma-Aldrich). A series of dosages of iron nanoparticles
was added to the solution, and the mixtures were stirred for 30 min.
The removal efficiency was measured using ultraviolet and visible
spectrophotometry (UV–Vis) and compared to the removal efficiency
of dye wastewater treated with hydrogen peroxide alone, a run treated
as the control parameter. These experiments were performed in triplicate.
The removal efficiency was calculated using the following equation:where Co and Cf are initial and final dye concentrations,
respectively.
Results and Discussion
Antioxidant Activity of Some Selected Reductants
The
FRAP values of plant extracts often used for iron nanoparticles
are shown in Table on a dry weight basis of the sample.
Table 2
FRAP Values
of Common Plant Extracts
Used for the Synthesis of Iron Nanoparticles
plant and
chemical reductants
FRAP per
dry weight of the sample (μmol FeII/g)
COV
(%) for
triplicate measurement
green tea extract
888
1.89
green rooibos tea extract
805
2.41
rooibos tea extract
756
2.39
sodium borohydride
6014
2.72
From Table , it
could be noticed that the FRAP values of the aqueous–ethanolic
extracts of green tea, green rooibos tea, rooibos tea, and sodium
borohydride were 805, 888, 756, and 6014 μmol/g, respectively.
The sodium borohydride FRAP test value was compared with the tea extracts’
antioxidant strength. Even though sodium borohydride had the highest
FRAP value, the antioxidant values of the tea reductants were comparable.
The aqueous–ethanolic polyphenolic tea extracts did not show
significant discrepancies in their FRAP values. Therefore, all the
tea extracts had a similar reducing capability of iron. It was further
noticed that green tea had the highest FRAP value among the tea extract
reductants. This was an indication that green tea had a greater capacity
to reduce iron from a higher oxidation state to a lower oxidation
state. The FRAP test findings suggest that tea extracts contain high
amounts of polyphenolic compounds with the potential to act as a reducing
agent. It was expected that compounds that donate electrons to reduce
Fe3+ to Fe2+ could also quench free radicals.
In this line of investigation, the radical scavenging activity of
the tea extracts was determined against the stable free radical DPPH
(2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl) antioxidant activities.
Optimum Conditions for the Synthesis of Iron
Nanoparticles
In this study, by visual inspection, we observed
a change in the solution color from light (AMD) to dark brown over
time during treatment with rooibos tea extract. After 6 h, the reaction
mixture turned from dark brown to black, and the nanoparticles appeared.
The reaction was allowed to continue for up to 24 h, but only imperceptible
color variation could be detected (see Figure ). This observation was similar to that reported
by Kuang et al.[33] who reported that 6 h
is generally sufficient to reduce iron from the AMD; thus, 6 h was
deemed the optimum reaction time for the synthesis of all samples.
Figure 2
Color
variation during AMD titration with Rooibos tea extract.
Color
variation during AMD titration with Rooibos tea extract.Experimental results showed that the size of the iron nanoparticles
was significantly dependent on the pH at which the synthesis was conducted.
For example, Figure shows that iron nanoparticles synthesized in series EK3 were larger
when formed at a pH range of 4 to 5 and relatively smaller at pH 6
(the optimum condition). The particle size was measured using ImageJ
software on TEM images.
Figure 3
Effects of pH on particle size (prepared at
room temperature and
6 h reaction time; EK3 series).
Effects of pH on particle size (prepared at
room temperature and
6 h reaction time; EK3 series).The lowest RBE concentration (5 g/L) corresponds to the literature
as the optimum dosage for generating spherical particles.[34]
Characterization of Prepared
Iron Nanoparticles
The iron nanoparticles synthesized under
optimum conditions (pH
= 6; dosage of Rooibos tea = 5 g/L; reaction time = 6 h) were characterized
by TEM, XRD, FTIR, UV–Vis, and EDS. Nanoparticles prepared
under the above conditions had smaller average particle sizes (36.33
nm), providing a higher surface area for reaction and required a lower
RBE concentration and minimum preparation time. UV–Vis spectra
(Figure ) were used
to ascertain the existence of iron nanoparticles with an absorption
peak maximum in the range of 400–800 nm. Iron nanoparticles
(Figure c) showed
absorption at higher wavelengths. AMD (Figure a) showed no sharp absorption between 550
and 800 nm, while the rooibos tea itself (Figure b) showed a peak at 500 nm.[22] The differences in spectra between raw materials (RBE and
AMD) and prepared nanoparticles illustrate the successful synthesis
of nanoiron. Further details on the structure and composition are
provided in the following characterizations.
Figure 4
UV spectra of AMD (a),
RBE (b), and iron nanoparticles (c); sample
EK35.
UV spectra of AMD (a),
RBE (b), and iron nanoparticles (c); sample
EK35.The FTIR spectrum of rooibos tea
(Figure a) displayed
stretching vibrations at 3360
cm–1 for O–H and 1610 cm–1 for C=C. Absorption bands at 2900 and 1350 cm–1 for C–H and C–N groups, respectively.
Figure 5
FTIR spectra of RBE (a)
and synthesized iron nanoparticles (b),
sample EK35.
FTIR spectra of RBE (a)
and synthesized iron nanoparticles (b),
sample EK35.In comparison with RBE, the FTIR
spectrum of iron nanoparticles
(Figure b) showed
a stretch of the O–H group at 3400 cm–1,
C–H at 2900 cm–1, C=C at 1630 cm–1, and respectively, C–O–C and C–N
at 1020 and 1375 cm–1, which fitted well to the
spectrum of RBE, showing that RBE stabilized the iron and suggesting
that the surface of the synthesized nanoiron is primarily iron at
higher oxidation states.[35,36] The O–H band
is ascribed to the formation of lepidrocte (γ-FeOOH) on the
surface of the presumed zero-valent core as confirmed by XRD. The
functional group bands obtained in the FTIR spectrum of iron nanoparticles
were similar to those reported in the literature for nZVI. The bonding
of the oxidized polyphenols from RBE on the surface of iron nanoparticles
was thus confirmed, and the results were in agreement with Hoag et
al.,[34] such that the polyphenols present
in rooibos tea, as in most plant extracts, could function as a powerful
stabilizing and reducing agent responsible for the partial reduction
of Fe2+/Fe3+ to Fe0. The morphology
and size of the EK35 sample appeared to show the formation of spherical
particles enveloped in the polyphenol chain structures and a greater
degree of dispersion. A reduction in the surface magnetism was observed
when a magnet was used to separate iron nanoparticles in the slurry;
it was only somewhat effective. Filtration was therefore used to assist
magnetic separation.Figure shows the
TEM image and XRD pattern of the iron nanoparticle sample prepared
under optimum conditions (sample EK35). Using ImageJ (from TEM images),
the average particle size was found to be 36 nm, and TEM revealed
the existence of polyphenols in tea, partially coating the surface
of the nanoiron. In terms of magnetism and dispersion, the results
differed from those of Kuang et al.,[33] and
the source of iron might be the reason for the discrepancy; Kuang
et al. used iron salts’ FeCl3, while AMD was used
as the source of iron in the current study. The nature and structure
of the dissolved iron in AMD is worth further investigation. An inspection
of the XRD spectrum of sample NK35 reveals peaks at 43.1 and 58 °,
likely indicating the presence of Feo in its crystalline
form.[36,37] It also displayed a peak at approximately
17.6°, identified as polyphenols found in the RBE. Similar observations
have been reported in studies on the synthesis of iron nanoparticles
using aqueous sorghum bran extracts and three tea extracts (green
tea, black tea, and oolong tea).[33,38] The peak at
approximately 24.5° was attributed to iron hydroxides (FeOOH),
whereas the maghemite (γ-Fe2O3) peak was
observed at approximately 35.5°.[39,40] It is important
to note the higher peak intensities for iron oxides and from the XRD
patterns, which can be attributed to the fact that the iron nanoparticles
synthesized by RBE were not all fully reduced metals as they existed
as core/shell particles.
Figure 6
TEM (a) and XRD patterns (b) of as-prepared
EK35.
TEM (a) and XRD patterns (b) of as-prepared
EK35.The elemental composition of sample
EK35 displayed a pattern in
the form of peaks of C, S, and K in addition to Fe and O. Carbon originated
predominantly from the polyphenols found in rooibos tea, whereas Fe
and S originated from AMD. Moreover, potassium (K) was attributed
to Rooibos tea as it is vital to plant growth and exists in every
living plant cell. The lower iron content observed may be due to the
large mass percent of carbon from the polyphenol coating from RBE
as was noticeable in the TEM images.[41]Average atomic percentages obtained from EDS were 51.04 ±
0.49% for C, 23.15 ± 0.27% for O, 17.33 ± 0.17% for Fe,
6.10 ± 0.04% for K, and 2.39 ± 0.14% for S (Table ). The iron content of sample
EK35 synthesized using plant extract was probably lower than expected
from its AMD’s content (Figure ) and lower than that in iron nanoparticles synthesized
by a more conventional route owing to the slow exchange of valence
electrons between Fe and the polyphenolic constituents of plants (rooibos
tea extract in this study), resulting in the formation of a stable
iron complex.[36]
Table 3
EDS Elemental
Composition of Nanoiron
(Atomic Percentages), Sample EK35
elements
atomic %
C
51.04 ± 049
O
23.15 ± 0.27
Fe
17.33 ± 0.17
K
6.10 ± 0.04
S
2.39 ± 0.14
Application of Stabilized Iron Nanoparticles
for Decoloration of Orange II Sodium Salt
The effectiveness
of iron nanoparticles was evaluated as a Fenton catalyst for decolorizing
simulated wastewater containing orange II dye. We varied three parameters
in the quest to optimize the decolorization reaction. Figure shows the effects of H2O2 concentration (a), pH (b), and nanoiron dosage
(c). The latter was assessed at room temperature (25 ° C), with
an initial dye concentration of 50 mg/L, pH of 6, and an H2O2 concentration of 0.0894 mol/L. As depicted in Figure c, the increase in
nanoiron dosage from 0.0 to 0.6 g/L enhanced the oxidative degradation
of the dye, which was mainly due to the increase in the number of
active sites and improving H2O2 decomposition
for increased generation of more hydroxyl radicals. However, a further
increase from 0.6 to 1.0 g/L did not significantly affect the relative
degradation. The reason behind this slow increase at high concentrations
may be due to the aggregation of nanoiron particles and the scavenging
of hydroxyl radicals through an undesirable reaction. Thus, the nanoiron
dosage of 0.6 g/L was chosen as the optimum condition and kept constant
while varying H2O2 concentrations. Figure a reveals that when
the concentration of H2O2 was set at 0.0135
mol/L, the dye removal efficiency was low (65%) because there was
insufficient •OH radicals in aqueous solution. The
dye degradation was enhanced to 80% when H2O2 concentration further increased to 0.0447 mol/L, mainly due to a
higher concentration of •OH radicals. However, dye
removal efficiency declined to 60 and 62% at the H2O2 concentration of 0.0894 and 0.1354 mol/L, respectively. The
main reason behind the decline may be thought to be the scavenging
effect of hydroxyl radicals and the inhibition of iron corrosion on
the surface of nanoiron by hydrogen peroxide. Hence, 0.0447 mol/ L
was chosen as the optimal H2O2 concentration
for effective oxidative dye degradation. Finally, it has been reported
that acidic conditions favor the Fenton-like process with an optimum
pH of 3.5 for the degradation of methyl tertiary butyl ether[42] or between 2 and 4 for the degradation of orange
II sodium salts.[36] Therefore, it was not
unexpected to confirm those results in our experiments, as depicted
in Figure c, with
an optimum pH of 3.
Figure 7
Decoloration of orange II sodium salt dye with stabilized
nanoiron.
(a) Effect of nanoiron dosage. (b) Effect of H2O2 concentration. (c) Effect of pH. (d) Decoloration at optimum conditions
(0.0447 mol/L H2O2, pH = 3, and 0.6 g/L of EK35).
Decoloration of orange II sodium salt dye with stabilized
nanoiron.
(a) Effect of nanoiron dosage. (b) Effect of H2O2 concentration. (c) Effect of pH. (d) Decoloration at optimum conditions
(0.0447 mol/L H2O2, pH = 3, and 0.6 g/L of EK35).Employing all optimum parameters, we found that
the orange II sodium
salt removal was very low and did not exceed 6% when H2O2 was used in the absence of nanoiron, as shown in Figure d. On the other hand,
when nanoiron was added to the simulated dye wastewater solution,
the dye removal efficiency reached 95%, demonstrating the importance
of the stabilized iron nanoparticles in removing orange II sodium
salt regardless of the polyphenol coating and low iron content (∼17%).Furthermore, decoloration of the dye was achieved after 30 min.
Few studies have reported such high-efficiency color removal within
this short time for unsupported greener nanoparticles without integration
with other techniques.[43] This rapid performance
may be mainly ascribed to the strong oxidant •OH
radicals generated from the oxidation reaction of iron nanoparticle
surfaces by transferring two electrons to H2O2 (eq ) to yield Fe2+, which then reacts with H2O2 in the
Fenton process (eq ),
which is capable of oxidizing organic substrates.It has been reported that iron nanoparticles
synthesized using
plant extracts behave primarily as adsorbents rather than reductants.
However, the synthesized nanoparticles, which can act as reductants,
catalysts, and adsorbents, have been well documented.[44]The performance of our stabilized nanoiron catalysts
was higher
than most nZVI reported in the literature for similar tasks. For instance,
Bhatti et al.[45] chemically synthesized
nZVI using FeSO4·7H2O and NaBH4. These nanoparticles were then used to treat textile water effluents,
and a color removal efficiency of 86–90% under optimum conditions
(pH = 3, nZVI = 0.2 g/L, H2O2 = 8 mM, and reaction
time = 90 min at 40 °C) was achieved despite having a higher
iron content of 80.50%.[45] Sravanthi et
al.[46] employed a green approach to synthesize
nZVI from Calotropis gigantea flower
extract (both reducing and stabilizing agents) to treat contaminated
water. Meanwhile, their nanoparticles possessed average sizes (50–90
nm) that were slightly larger than those synthesized in the current
study. Furthermore, dye decoloration and aniline removal hardly exceeded
85% despite the use of sorbent materials in a batch reactor. Employing
an alternative synthesis route, Ravikumar et al.,[47] in an attempt to remove methyl orange from textile dye
water, obtained Bio-nZVI granules by anaerobic granular sludge under
anaerobic conditions. Their catalysts, under optimum conditions, showed
removal of up to 99%; it is worth noting that the reaction time was
240 min, 8 times longer than the time required for our catalyst. Lastly,
our results are higher than the maximum 90% dye removal reported by
several other groups.[41,48,49] The benefit of our study is the short time required to achieve higher
removal efficiency and the green synthesis of our catalyst from the
reuse of iron in AMD, which is considered both a waste and an environmental
hazard.
Conclusions
Iron-rich
AMD, a problematic waste effluent, was used as feedstock
to produce a value-added product, iron nanoparticles. Rooibos tea
was used to reduce Fe2+/Fe3+ to Fe0 from acid mine drainage, replacing the alkaline reagents used in
the chemical synthesis methods. To the best of our knowledge, no study
has combined waste AMD as a source of iron and rooibos tea extract
as a reducing agent and stabilizer instead of chemical synthesis techniques.
Thus, as in this study, employing greener methods is a remedial approach.
The optimum reaction conditions for synthesizing stabilized iron nanoparticles
from acid mine drainage using rooibos tea were ambient temperature
(∼ 25 °C), a pH of 6, and a dosage of 5 g/L of rooibos
tea for 6 h of reaction time. The synthesized iron nanoparticles were
applied as a Fenton-like catalyst for the decoloration of textile
dye (orange II sodium salt) and showed a removal efficiency of 94%
within 30 min. Compared to nZVI reported in the literature and synthesized
by different techniques, our Fenton-like catalyst was very effective
with a smaller size, higher removal efficiency, and faster reaction
time. Future investigations are necessary to validate the catalyst
performance observed in this study. More importantly, other parameters
that may further improve the catalyst activity, such as the effects
of the dosage of rooibos tea on both the size and the shape of iron
nanoparticles, may also be worth studying.
Authors: Eric C Njagi; Hui Huang; Lisa Stafford; Homer Genuino; Hugo M Galindo; John B Collins; George E Hoag; Steven L Suib Journal: Langmuir Date: 2010-12-06 Impact factor: 3.882