Nicholas Nyaaba1, Nana Efua Andoh2, Gordon Amoh3, Dominic Selorm Yao Amuzu4, Mary Ansong5, José M Ordóñez-Mena6,7, Jennifer Hirst6,7. 1. Infectious Disease Centre, 37 Military Hospital, Cantonments, Accra, Ghana. 2. Noguchi Memorial Institute for Medical Research, University of Ghana, Accra, Ghana. 3. Korle-Bu Polyclinic/ Family Medicine Department, Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital, Korle-Bu, Accra, Ghana. 4. West African Centre for Cell Biology of Infectious Pathogens, Department of Biochemistry, Cell and Molecular Biology, University of Ghana, Legon, Accra, Ghana. 5. The International Sickle Cell Centre, Accra Central, Accra, Ghana. 6. Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom. 7. National Institute for Health Research (NIRH), Oxford Biomedical Research Centre, Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Oxford, United Kingdom.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The artemisinin derivatives are the preferred antimalaria drugs for treating severe Plasmodium falciparum malaria. However, their clinical effectiveness compared to each other is unknown. Our objective, therefore, was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of the artemisinin derivatives and quinine for treating severe P. falciparum malaria in children and adults using a network meta-analysis. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Review protocol was registered with PROSPERO, CRD42020218190. We updated the search strategies of three Cochrane systematic reviews which included published and unpublished randomised control trials (RCTs) that have compared specific artemisinin derivatives to quinine in treating severe malaria. Search included CENTRAL, MEDLINE, Embase, LILACS, ISI Web of Science and trial registries up to February 2021. We screened studies, extracted data, assessed risk of bias, and quality of evidence in duplicate. Separate network meta-analyses in the frequentist framework, using a random effects model, with quinine as reference, were conducted for adults and children, and rankings were produced using p-scores to assess mortality, parasite clearance, coma recovery, fever clearance, neurological sequela and adverse events. Searches identified 818 citations, 33 RCTs were eligible. We pooled 7795 children and 3182 adults. The networks involved artesunate, artemether, rectal artemisinin, arteether and quinine. Compared to quinine, artesunate reduced mortality in children (risk ratio (RR), 0.76; 95%CI [0.65 to 0.89], moderate quality), adults (RR, 0.55; 95%CI [0.40 to 0.75], moderate quality) and in cerebral malaria (RR, 0.72; 95%CI [0.55 to 0.94], moderate quality). Compared to rectal artemisinin and intramuscular arteether, the efficacy and safety of parenteral artesunate, and intramuscular artemether in treating severe malaria are not clear. Rankings showed that none of the artemisinin drugs were consistently superior in all the outcomes assessed. Indirect evidence produced were of very low ratings due to suspected publication bias and imprecision. CONCLUSIONS: Artesunate reduces mortality compared to quinine for both adults and children in Asia and Africa including cerebral malaria. The artemisinin derivatives remain the best treatment for severe malaria but their comparative clinical effectiveness is yet to be fully explored.
BACKGROUND: The artemisinin derivatives are the preferred antimalaria drugs for treating severe Plasmodium falciparum malaria. However, their clinical effectiveness compared to each other is unknown. Our objective, therefore, was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of the artemisinin derivatives and quinine for treating severe P. falciparum malaria in children and adults using a network meta-analysis. METHODS AND FINDINGS: Review protocol was registered with PROSPERO, CRD42020218190. We updated the search strategies of three Cochrane systematic reviews which included published and unpublished randomised control trials (RCTs) that have compared specific artemisinin derivatives to quinine in treating severe malaria. Search included CENTRAL, MEDLINE, Embase, LILACS, ISI Web of Science and trial registries up to February 2021. We screened studies, extracted data, assessed risk of bias, and quality of evidence in duplicate. Separate network meta-analyses in the frequentist framework, using a random effects model, with quinine as reference, were conducted for adults and children, and rankings were produced using p-scores to assess mortality, parasite clearance, coma recovery, fever clearance, neurological sequela and adverse events. Searches identified 818 citations, 33 RCTs were eligible. We pooled 7795 children and 3182 adults. The networks involved artesunate, artemether, rectal artemisinin, arteether and quinine. Compared to quinine, artesunate reduced mortality in children (risk ratio (RR), 0.76; 95%CI [0.65 to 0.89], moderate quality), adults (RR, 0.55; 95%CI [0.40 to 0.75], moderate quality) and in cerebral malaria (RR, 0.72; 95%CI [0.55 to 0.94], moderate quality). Compared to rectal artemisinin and intramuscular arteether, the efficacy and safety of parenteral artesunate, and intramuscular artemether in treating severe malaria are not clear. Rankings showed that none of the artemisinin drugs were consistently superior in all the outcomes assessed. Indirect evidence produced were of very low ratings due to suspected publication bias and imprecision. CONCLUSIONS: Artesunate reduces mortality compared to quinine for both adults and children in Asia and Africa including cerebral malaria. The artemisinin derivatives remain the best treatment for severe malaria but their comparative clinical effectiveness is yet to be fully explored.
Authors: Jonathan A C Sterne; Jelena Savović; Matthew J Page; Roy G Elbers; Natalie S Blencowe; Isabelle Boutron; Christopher J Cates; Hung-Yuan Cheng; Mark S Corbett; Sandra M Eldridge; Jonathan R Emberson; Miguel A Hernán; Sally Hopewell; Asbjørn Hróbjartsson; Daniela R Junqueira; Peter Jüni; Jamie J Kirkham; Toby Lasserson; Tianjing Li; Alexandra McAleenan; Barnaby C Reeves; Sasha Shepperd; Ian Shrier; Lesley A Stewart; Kate Tilling; Ian R White; Penny F Whiting; Julian P T Higgins Journal: BMJ Date: 2019-08-28
Authors: Lorenz von Seidlein; Thomas J Peto; Rupam Tripura; Christopher Pell; Shunmay Yeung; Jean Marie Kindermans; Arjen Dondorp; Richard Maude Journal: Trends Parasitol Date: 2019-05-07
Authors: S Murphy; M English; C Waruiru; I Mwangi; E Amukoye; J Crawley; C Newton; P Winstanley; N Peshu; K Marsh Journal: Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg Date: 1996 May-Jun Impact factor: 2.184
Authors: M B van Hensbroek; E Onyiorah; S Jaffar; G Schneider; A Palmer; J Frenkel; G Enwere; S Forck; A Nusmeijer; S Bennett; B Greenwood; D Kwiatkowski Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 1996-07-11 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Arjen M Dondorp; Caterina I Fanello; Ilse C E Hendriksen; Ermelinda Gomes; Amir Seni; Kajal D Chhaganlal; Kalifa Bojang; Rasaq Olaosebikan; Nkechinyere Anunobi; Kathryn Maitland; Esther Kivaya; Tsiri Agbenyega; Samuel Blay Nguah; Jennifer Evans; Samwel Gesase; Catherine Kahabuka; George Mtove; Behzad Nadjm; Jacqueline Deen; Juliet Mwanga-Amumpaire; Margaret Nansumba; Corine Karema; Noella Umulisa; Aline Uwimana; Olugbenga A Mokuolu; Olanrewaju T Adedoyin; Wahab B R Johnson; Antoinette K Tshefu; Marie A Onyamboko; Tharisara Sakulthaew; Wirichada Pan Ngum; Kamolrat Silamut; Kasia Stepniewska; Charles J Woodrow; Delia Bethell; Bridget Wills; Martina Oneko; Tim E Peto; Lorenz von Seidlein; Nicholas P J Day; Nicholas J White Journal: Lancet Date: 2010-11-07 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Gitte N Hartmeyer; Christen R Stensvold; Thilde Fabricius; Ea S Marmolin; Silje V Hoegh; Henrik V Nielsen; Michael Kemp; Lasse S Vestergaard Journal: Emerg Infect Dis Date: 2019-10 Impact factor: 6.883