| Literature DB >> 35855436 |
Anna L Huguenard1, Yuping Derek Li1, Nima Sharifai2, Stephanie M Perkins3, Sonika Dahiya2, Michael R Chicoine1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Ewing sarcoma is a neoplasm within the family of small round blue cell tumors and most frequently arises from skeletal bone. Primary involvement of the central nervous system in these lesions is extremely rare, with an incidence of 1%. OBSERVATIONS: A case is presented of a 34-year-old man who presented with left facial numbness, multiple intracranial lesions, a lumbar intradural lesion, and diffuse spinal leptomeningeal involvement. A lumbar laminectomy and biopsy were performed, which revealed the diagnosis of extraskeletal Ewing sarcoma/primitive neuroectodermal tumor. The patient had a rapidly progressive clinical decline despite total neuroaxis radiation and multiple lines of chemotherapeutic treatments, eventually dying from his disease and its sequelae 6 months after diagnosis. LESSONS: The authors' review of 40 cases in the literature revealed only 2 patients with isolated intraaxial cranial lesions, 4 patients with cranial and spine involvement, and an additional 34 patients with spine lesions. The unique characteristics of this patient's case, including his presentation with diffuse disease and pathology that included a rare V600E BRAF mutation, are discussed in the context of the available literature.Entities:
Keywords: BRAF; CNS = central nervous system; CSF = cerebrospinal fluid; CT = computed tomography; ES = Ewing sarcoma; Ewing sarcoma; GFAP = glial fibrillary acidic protein; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging; cPNET = central primitive neuroectodermal tumor; intracranial; oncology; spine
Year: 2021 PMID: 35855436 PMCID: PMC9241201 DOI: 10.3171/CASE2042
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Neurosurg Case Lessons ISSN: 2694-1902
Reported cases in the literature for primary CNS extraskeletal ES
| Study | Age (yrs)/Gender | Location | Other Spread | Presentation | Hemorrhage | CD99/t(11:22) | Treatment | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VandenHeuvel et al., 2015[ | 2/F | Frontal lobe | None, CSF negative | Partial seizures | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, CYA, DXR; radiation: focal radiation | Alive at 6 yrs |
| VandenHeuvel et al., 2015[ | 61/M | Fronto-temporal lobe | None, CSF negative | Slurred speech, lt facial droop, lt hemiparesis | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; no adjuvant chemo or radiation | Lost to follow-up |
| Weil et al., 2001[ | 21/M | T10–11, L1–2, 2 parietal lesions | CSF negative | Thoracic back pain, lower extremity weakness/spasticity | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR cranial & spinal lesion; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, ETP, IFO; radiation: craniospinal radiation, boost to tumor bed | Alive at 30 mos |
| Mateen et al., 2011[ | 60/M | L2–3 | Delayed diffuse cranial & spine leptomeningeal spread | Back pain, bilat leg radiculopathy | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: IFO, ETP, DXR, TMZ; radiation: radiation to L1–4 | Dead at 48 mos |
| Tan et al., 2019[ | 34/F | C4–T3 | Diffuse leptomeningeal disease of spine, rapid intracranial spread | Upper extremity paresthesias, urinary retention | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: none; radiation: urgent radiotherapy to craniospinal axis | Dead at 11 mos |
| Izubuchi et al., 2020[ | 35/F | T12–L1, L4–5 | Diffuse meningeal spread, multiple intracranial lesions at 10 mos | Radiculopathy & bilat leg paresthesias | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, ETP; radiation: total spinal radiation, later WBRT due to mets | Dead at 16 mos |
| Hisaoka et al., 1997[ | 14/M | Cauda equina | None | Back pain & lt leg radiculopathy | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; no adjuvant chemo or radiation | Alive at 3 mos |
| Uesaka et al., 2003[ | 11/F | C7–T1 | None | Progressive paraparesis | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; no adjuvant chemo or radiation documented | Unknown |
| Harimaya et al., 2003[ | 30/F | C2–4 | None | Extremity paresthesias, urinary retention | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, DXR, IFO, ACD; radiation: focal radiotherapy | Dead at 14 mos |
| Harimaya et al., 2003[ | 14/M | Cauda equina (L1–2) | None | Low back pain & lower extremity radiculopathy | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, DXR, IFO, ACD, CBP, ETP; radiation: none | Alive at 67 mos |
| Woestenborghs et al., 2005[ | 11/M | C4–T2 | None | Progressive quadriparesis | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: VCR, IFO, ACD, ETP; radiation: none | Unknown |
| Mobley et al., 2006[ | 32/M | Cauda equina (L2–4) | None | Back pain, distal lower extremity weakness | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: ACD, VCR, DXR, CPM, ETP, IFO; radiation: regional radiation T12–S3 w/ boost to resection site | Dead at 12 mos |
| Haresh et al., 2008[ | 26/M | Cauda equina (T11–S2) | Delayed spread to T6–7 | Back pain, lower extremity weakness | No | +/? | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, CDDP, ETP; radiation: focal radiation | Alive at 6 mos |
| Kim & Shin, 2009[ | 32/F | C3–5 | None | Progressive upper extremity paresis | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: ETP, IFO; radiation: focal radiation | Alive at 12 mos |
| Klimo et al., 2009[ | 10/M | L4–5 | None | Rt leg pain & paresthesias | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, ETP, IFO; radiation: radiation to L3–5 | Alive at 12 mos |
| Theeler et al., 2009[ | 28/F | T5–8 | None | Lt arm pain, lower extremity paresthesias | No | +/+ | Surgery: none (CT-guided biopsy); chemo: VCR, CPM, DXR, IFO, ETP; radiation: palliative spinal radiation | Alive at 2 mos |
| Vincentelli et al., 2010[ | 40/F | Cauda equina (T11–L4) | None | Paraparesis & urinary retention | Yes | ?/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: DXR, IFO; radiation: conformational radiotherapy | Alive at 6 mos |
| Muzzafar et al., 2010[ | 38/M | Cauda equina (L2–S2) | None | Back pain, bilat leg radiculopathy | Yes | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: systemic therapy; radiation: none | Unknown |
| Karikari et al., 2011[ | 56/F | L1 | None, CSF negative | Back pain, leg radiculopathy | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, ETP; radiation: local radiation | Unknown |
| Yan et al., 2011[ | 10/M | C2–3 | None, CSF negative | Neck pain, rt hemiparesis | No | +/? | Surgery: GTR; dead prior to adjuvant therapy | Dead at 30 days |
| Duan et al., 2011[ | 8/M | L2–L4 | None | Unknown | No | +/? | Surgery: GTR; chemo: systemic therapy; radiation: local radiation | Unknown |
| Duan et al., 2011[ | 25/M | L2/3 | None | Unknown | No | +/? | Surgery: GTR; chemo: systemic therapy; radiation: focal radiation | Unknown |
| Mateen et al., 2011[ | 50/M | T10–L1 | None | Progressive lower extremity paresthesias | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, CPM, DXR, IFO, ETP; radiation: focal to thoracolumbar spine | Alive at 26 mos |
| Pancucci et al., 2013[ | 55/M | L4–S2 | None, bone marrow biopsy negative | Lower extremity weakness, urinary retention | Yes | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: DXR, IFO, ETP; radiation: fractionated external radiotherapy | Alive at 13 mos |
| Pancucci et al., 2013[ | 25/F | L2–3 | None, bone marrow biopsy negative | Lower extremity weakness, urinary urgency | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; no adjuvant therapy given patient’s poor performance status | Local relapse at 14 mos |
| Khalatbari et al., 2013[ | 28/F | L5–S1 | None | Back & rt leg pain, acute cauda equina | Yes | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, ETP; radiation: focal radiation | Alive at 72 mos |
| Bazzocchi et al., 2013[ | 44/F | T6–7, L1–2 | None | Sudden-onset paraplegia | No | +/? | Surgery: GTR of largest lesion; chemo: VCR, CPM, DXR, IFO, ETP; radiation: focal to lumbar spine | Unknown |
| Lozupone et al., 2014[ | 44/F | Cauda equina (L1–S3) | None | Low back pain & radiculopathy | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, EPIR, EDX; radiation: focal conformational radiotherapy | Alive at 6 mos |
| Zhao et al., 2014[ | 14/M | L4–5 | None | Rt leg pain & paresthesias | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: CPM, DXR, IFO; radiation: focal radiation | Alive at 12 mos |
| Mardekian et al., 2014[ | 26/M | T12–L1 | None | Back pain | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; no adjuvant therapies described | Unknown |
| Mardekian et al., 2014[ | 70/M | T12–L1 | None | Back pain | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; no adjuvant therapies described | Unknown |
| Gong et al., 2015[ | 39/F | C4–6 | Delayed development of L4–S1 mass | Progressive lt arm paresthesias & pain | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: CPM, VCR; radiation: local radiotherapy | Alive at 3 yrs |
| Bostelmann et al., 2016[ | 29/M | C6–T1 | Delayed development of additional spinal metastatic lesions | Rt C7 radiculopathy followed by hemiparesis | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR, re-resection 4 wks later for recurrence; chemo: VCR, IFO, DXR, ETP, TOPO, CPM; radiation: total spine & local boost | Alive at 18 mos |
| Kartal & Akatlı, 2016[ | 5/M | T4–7 | None | Low back pain & gait disturbance | No | +/? | Surgery: GTR; no adjuvant therapies described | Unknown |
| Chihak et al., 2016[ | 25/M | C4–7 | None | Rt hand numbness/tingling | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: IFO, ETP, VCR, DXR, CPM; radiation: urgent radiation to tumor bed, total craniospinal radiation, additional boost to tumor area | Alive at 20 mos |
| Chihak et al., 2016[ | 34/M | L4–5, S1–2, S4–5 | None | Cauda equina symptoms | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, ETP; radiation: craniospinal radiation w/ local boost | Alive at 3 mos |
| Paterakis et al., 2017[ | 31/M | L2–3, sacral lesion | Delayed bone metastasis | Progressive paraparesis | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR of lumbar lesion; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, ETP; radiation: none | Alive at 24 mos |
| Scantland et al., 2018[ | 14/F | Conus medullaris | None | Progressive back pain | Yes | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, ETP; radiation: proton beam radiotherapy | Alive at 2 yrs |
| Takami et al., 2018[ | 61/M | L1–3 | None | Lt leg paresthesias, urinary retention | No | +/+ | Surgery: GTR; chemo: VCR, DXR, CPM, IFO, ETP; radiation: focal to lumbar spine | Alive at 3 mos |
| Khwaja et al., 2019[ | 44/F | C7–T1 | Diffuse leptomeningeal disease of spine | Pain in lower extremities, paraplegia | No | +/+ | Surgery: STR; chemo: CDDP, CCNU, IFO, CBP, ETP; radiation: craniospinal irradiation, focal boost w/ CyberKnife | Alive at 8 yrs |
+ = mutation present; ? = presence of mutation unknown; ACD = actinomycin D; CBP = carboplatin, CCNU = lomustine; CDDP = cisplatin; chemo = chemotherapy; CPM = cyclophosphamide; CYA = cyclosporine; DXR = doxorubicin (Adriamycin); EDX = epidoxorubicin; EPIR = epirubicin; ETP = etoposide; GTR = gross total resection; IFO = ifosfamide; STR = subtotal resection; t(11:22) = translocation (11:22); TMZ = temozolomide; TOPO = topotecan; VCR = vincristine; WBRT = whole brain radiotherapy.
Includes cranial intraparenchymal lesions, spine lesions, and patients with brain and spine involvement. Note, none of these cases describe a BRAF mutation.
FIG. 1.Non-contrast CT scans of the brain showing a hyperdense intraaxial lesion in the right frontal medial orbital gyrus (A, arrow), and adjacent cerebral edema (B).
FIG. 2.T1 postcontrast MRI of the brain. A: Rim-enhancing right frontal lesion with an associated hemorrhagic component with mild mass effect, shown in coronal, sagittal, and axial planes. B: Enhancing lesion within the left Meckel’s cave (arrows), shown in coronal, sagittal, and axial planes.
FIG. 3.Sagittal slices from MRI of the lumbar spine, with sequences of T2 (A), T1 without contrast (B), and T1 with contrast (C). There is a contrast-enhancing soft tissue epidural mass filling the thecal sac and compressing the adjacent conus medullaris (arrows) and, below that, the nerve roots of the cauda equina.
FIG. 4.Histopathological characteristics of resected lumbar intradural tumor—extraskeletal ES/PNET. Original magnifications ×400. Hematoxylin and eosin–stained images (A and B) show a small blue cell tumor, with variably round to spindle-shaped nuclei, karyorrhexis, brisk mitotic activity, and a patchy neutrophilic infiltrate. Immunohistochemical stains were performed, and the tumor cells show membranous expression of CD99 (C) and nonreactivity for CAM5.2 (D), GFAP (E), and synaptophysin (SYN) (F). SYN highlights entrapped axons within the involved nerve root.