Pressure from environmental nongovernmental organizations and the public has accelerated research on the development of innovative and renewable polymers and additives. Recently, biobased "green" plasticizers that can be covalently attached to replace toxic and migratory phthalate-based plasticizers have gained a lot of attention from researchers. In this work, we prepared an azide-functionalized soybean oil derivative (AzSBO) and investigated whether it can be used as a plasticizer. We covalently attached AzSBO to an electron-deficient triple-bond-containing polyester via a metal-free azide-alkyne click reaction. The thermal, mechanical, and solvent absorption behaviors of different amounts of azidated oil-containing polyesters were determined. Moreover, the plasticization efficiency of AzSBO was compared with the commercial plasticizers bis(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate and epoxidized soybean oil. At relatively lower AzSBO ratios, the degree of cross-linking was higher and thus the plasticization was less pronounced but the solvent resistance was significantly improved. As the ratio of AzSBO was increased, the glass transition temperature of the pristine polymer decreased up to 31 °C from 57 °C. Furthermore, the incorporation of AzSBO also improved the thermal properties and 20% AzSBO addition led to a 60 °C increase in the maximum weight loss temperature.
Pressure from environmental nongovernmental organizations and the public has accelerated research on the development of innovative and renewable polymers and additives. Recently, biobased "green" plasticizers that can be covalently attached to replace toxic and migratory phthalate-based plasticizers have gained a lot of attention from researchers. In this work, we prepared an azide-functionalized soybean oil derivative (AzSBO) and investigated whether it can be used as a plasticizer. We covalently attached AzSBO to an electron-deficient triple-bond-containing polyester via a metal-free azide-alkyne click reaction. The thermal, mechanical, and solvent absorption behaviors of different amounts of azidated oil-containing polyesters were determined. Moreover, the plasticization efficiency of AzSBO was compared with the commercial plasticizers bis(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate and epoxidized soybean oil. At relatively lower AzSBO ratios, the degree of cross-linking was higher and thus the plasticization was less pronounced but the solvent resistance was significantly improved. As the ratio of AzSBO was increased, the glass transition temperature of the pristine polymer decreased up to 31 °C from 57 °C. Furthermore, the incorporation of AzSBO also improved the thermal properties and 20% AzSBO addition led to a 60 °C increase in the maximum weight loss temperature.
The
ever-increasing environmental pollution problems associated
with the use of petroleum-based resources for the manufacturing of
plastic materials and the depletion of fossil raw materials gave rise
to the concept of Green Chemistry at the end of the 1990s and have
prompted researchers to seek safe and sustainable alternatives.[1−4] Biobased renewable building blocks such as vegetable oils, starch,
cardanol, lignin, rosin, furan, terpenes, and so on are promising
candidates for the preparation of thermoplastic or thermoset polymers.
Among them, vegetable oils that are the triglycerides of fatty acids
with glycerol, are one of the most preferred and prominent feedstocks
because of their high abundance, low cost, and inherent biodegradable
nature and are suitable for modification by many different chemical
routes.[5−10] Although vegetable oils can be used for functionalization, derivatization,
and polymer preparation without disturbing the triglyceride structure;
glycerol, monoglyceride, diglyceride, or fatty acids can be used for
the same goal. Indeed, plant oil-based alkyd resins that are prepared
by using monoglycerides have been used as binders for paints and coatings
for about 100 years.[11]In recent
years, there has been a growing trend in the development
of vegetable oil-based precursors as alternative polymer materials.[12] In most cases, plant oils are first subjected
to various modifications.[13] For instance,
epoxidation of double bonds of vegetable oils has become a routine
modification route.[14] The epoxidized vegetable
oils are cured thermally with amines,[15] or directly via photoinitiated cationic photopolymerization to synthesize
biobased thermoset materials[16] or they
are reacted with acrylic acid and used in photocurable coating formulations.[17] Modern techniques such as thiol–ene addition
reactions,[18,19] azide–alkyne click protocols,[20] and acyclic diene metathesis[21] have also been applied to functionalize/polymerize vegetable
oils or their constituents.Aside from these direct uses of
vegetable oils for the preparation
of plastic materials, lately, derivatives of vegetable oil have been
used as additives or agents for a wide range of applications including
the modification of commercial polymers. Vegetable oils were used
as plasticizers, lubricants, stabilizers, processing aids, surfactants,
etc.[22−24] Especially, much effort has been devoted to the use
of vegetable oils as plasticizers, particularly for polyvinyl chloride
(PVC).[25−29] To prevent the migration of the plasticizers, vegetable oil-based
compounds were also covalently attached to PVC via azide–alkyne
click reactions.[30−32]Recently, our group has focused on the synthesis,
modifications,
and applications of electron-deficient triple bond-containing polyesters.[33−40] The activated alkyne bonds on the polyester backbone made it possible
to perform reactions such as aza-Michael, thiol-Michael, Diels–Alder,
azide–alkyne click reactions readily under mild conditions,
in the absence of metal catalysts, and high yields. Notably, the modification
of the triple bond-containing polyesters via the metal-free azide–alkyne
cycloaddition is an intriguing feature for the elimination of copper
catalysts and benign reaction conditions. Herein, we report the modification
of polyester bearing alkyne groups; namely, poly(1,4-cyclohexanedimethylene
acetylene dicarboxylate) (PCA), with azide-functionalized soybean
oil which we aimed to use as a renewable plasticizer (Scheme ). It is worth mentioning here
that PCA is a reactive triple bond-containing cycloaliphatic polyester
with good film forming properties and a unique platform to be modified
via various amines, thiols, azides, etc.[33,36,37,39] PCA and similar
electron-deficient triple bond-containing polyesters can be regarded
as a modern alternative to conventional unsaturated polyesters. So
far, we have utilized PCA for the preparation of polyhedral oligomeric
silsesquioxanes-containing hybrid networks,[36] hydrophobic electrospun surfaces,[37] and
silica nanoparticle-containing hybrid nanocomposites.[39]
Scheme 1
Schematic Representation of the Modification of PCA
with AzSBO
Experimental
Section
Materials
Raw soybean oil (SBO) was
obtained from a local company. Formic acid, hydrogen peroxide (30
wt %), sodium chloride, ethyl acetate, anhydrous sodium sulfate, sodium
bicarbonate, and chloroform were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich and
used as received. PCA (Mn = 24.9 kDa, Mw = 70.3 kDa, and Đ =
2.82) was synthesized according to our previous publications.[33,36] DOP (bis(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate) was obtained as a gift from Plastifay
(Turkey).
Characterization
FTIR spectra were
recorded on a Cary 630 FTIR (Agilent Technologies) instrument over
the range 4000–600 cm–1. 1H (500
MHz) was recorded using an Agilent VNMRS 500 instrument in CDCl3. Gel permeation chromatography (GPC) measurements were carried
out with an Agilent instrument (model 1100) with a pump, refractive
index, and UV detectors and four Waters Styragel columns (HR 5E, HR
4E, HR 3, HR 2; 4.6 mm internal diameter, 300 mm length, packed with
5 μm particles). The effective molecular weight ranges of columns
are 2000–4 000 000, 50–100 000,
500–30 000, and 500–20 000 g/mol, respectively.
THF was used as eluent at a flow rate of 0.3 mL/min at 30οC, and 2,6-ditert-butyl-4-methylphenol (BHT) was
used as an internal standard. The number-average molecular weights
(Mn) and dispersities (Đ) of the polymers were calculated based on linear polystyrene (PS)
standards (Polymer Laboratories). Elemental analyses were carried
out using a LECO CHN 932. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC)
experiments were performed under a nitrogen atmosphere on the PerkinElmer
Pyris Diamond DSC apparatus. Samples were kept at 30 °C for 2
min and then heated to 100 °C with a heating rate of 20 °C/min.
After holding 5 min at this temperature, samples were cooled to −10
°C with a cooling rate of 20 °C/min, followed by maintaining
at this temperature for 2 min. Finally, they were reheated to 100
°C with a heating rate of 20 °C/min. Data from the second
heating cycle were reported. Thermogravimetric analyses (TGA) of the
films were performed by using a PerkinElmer thermogravimetric analyzer
(Pyris 1 TGA model). Samples were run from 30 to 600 °C with
a heating rate of 10 °C/min under a nitrogen atmosphere. Dynamic
mechanical analysis (DMA) was performed on a PerkinElmer DMA 8000
analyzer in the tension mode. Samples (40× 10 × 0.1 mm)
were clamped, and strain was applied at a frequency of 1 Hz and a
heating of 3 °C/min from −20 to 100 °C. The water
contact angles (CA) of the polyesters were determined on a Kruss (Easy
Drop DSA-2) tensiometer. Measurements were made using 3–5 μL
drops of distilled water. For each sample, at least three measurements
were made, and the average was taken. Tensile tests were performed
at room temperature on a Materials Testing Machine Z010/TN2S, using
a crosshead speed of 10 mm/min on rectangular specimens. An average
of at least three measurements is reported. The epoxy equivalent weight
(EEW, mol/100 g) was determined by the hydrochloric acid (HCl)-acetone
method.[41,42]
Epoxidation of Soybean
Oil (ESBO)
Soybean oil was epoxidized according to the literature.[43−45] Briefly, 50 g of dry soybean oil was added to a two-neck round-bottom
flask equipped with a pressure-equalizing dropping funnel and a condenser.
Three grams of formic acid was added to the soybean oil and the mixture
was heated to 45 °C. Under stirring, hydrogen peroxide (10 g)
was then added drop by drop in 1 h. After the addition was completed,
the temperature was raised to 65 °C and the reaction was allowed
to proceed for 6 h at this temperature. Afterward, the reaction flask
was cooled to room temperature. 100 g of ethyl acetate was added to
the reaction mixture and then transferred to a separatory funnel.
The solution was first washed several times with water, followed by
washing with dilute sodium bicarbonate solution (5%). The organic
phase was separated, dried with anhydrous magnesium sulfate, and filtered,
and ethyl acetate was removed via a rotary evaporator.
Azidated Soybean Oil (AzSBO)
Azide-functionalized
soybean oil was prepared by the ring-opening of the epoxide groups
of the soybean oil with sodium azide.[46,47] Twenty grams
of epoxidized soybean oil was mixed with 6 g of sodium azide, 4 g
of ammonium chloride, water (20 mL), and ethanol (50 mL) in a round-bottom
flask. A condenser was attached to the flask and the mixture was refluxed
at 90 °C under constant stirring for 48 h. After cooling this
mixture to room temperature, 100 mL of water was added and azidated
soybean oil was extracted with dichloromethane (20 mL × 4). The
organic phase was dried over anhydrous magnesium sulfate. After filtration,
the organic phase was evaporated and AzSBO was obtained as a highly
viscous brown liquid. The nitrogen content of the AzSBO was determined
by elemental analysis. The synthesis of ESBO and AzSBO is illustrated
in Scheme .
Scheme 2
Synthetic
Route for the Preparation of ESBO and AzSBO
Metal-Free Modification of PCA by AzSBO
One gram of PCA was dissolved in 2 mL of CHCl3 and then
the required amount of AzSBO (20, 40, and 60% with respect to the
amount of PCA) was added. This mixture was stirred for 5 min and then
the mixture was poured on Teflon molds and gradually heated to 60
°C to evaporate CHCl3 and catalyze the azide–alkyne
click reaction. Neat PCA films were also prepared similarly without
using the AzSBO. The films were named PCAX, where X symbolizes the
percentage of the added AzSBO.For comparison, ESBO- or DOP-containing
PCA films were prepared similarly as described above. Two-tenths of
a gram of ESBO or DOP was added per gram of PCA.
Results and Discussion
Characterization of AzSBO
The AzSBO
was prepared from the reaction of NaN3 with ESBO. The AzSBO
was characterized structurally with FTIR and 1H NMR spectroscopy. Figure displays the FTIR
spectra of pristine soybean oil, ESBO, and AzSBO, respectively. The
FTIR spectrum of SBO exhibited the characteristic bands at 1740, 2850,
2920, and 3010 cm–1 which were ascribed to the carbonyl
groups, symmetric and asymmetric stretching of −CH–
bonds, and to the carbon–hydrogen stretching vibrations of
the alkene double bonds within the triglyceride structure, respectively.
After the epoxidation reaction, new bands appeared at 847 and 822
cm–1, which correspond to the epoxy groups, whereas
the intensity of the alkene double bonds at 3010 cm–1 slightly declined.[42,43,46] Finally, the ring-opening of the epoxide groups with NaN3 led to a substantial disappearance of the characteristic epoxide
bands at 847 and 822 cm–1 and the formation of new
hydroxyl bands at around 3500 cm–1 and azide bands
at 2100 cm–1, as can be seen from the FTIR spectrum
of AzSBO. All these FTIR findings are in good accordance with the
literature and confirm the structure of AzSBO.[46,48−50]
Figure 1
FTIR spectra of SBO, ESBO, and AzSBO.
FTIR spectra of SBO, ESBO, and AzSBO.The structures of SBO, ESBO, and AzSBO were also investigated by 1H NMR spectroscopy (Figure ). The characteristic methine (a) and methylene (b)
protons of SBO’s glycerol unit were observed at 5.2 and 4.3–4.1
ppm, respectively. These peaks did not change after epoxidation and
azidation reactions. The peak at around 5.4 ppm was attributed to
the internal alkene double-bond protons of SBO. Upon epoxidation,
the intensity of this peak was decreased, indicating that the reaction
took place. Furthermore, a new peak appeared at 3.0–2.8 ppm
that was attributed to the characteristic protons of the epoxide rings.[45,47,48] After the azidation reaction,
these epoxy proton peaks almost disappeared because of the ring-opening
reaction and shifted to 3.2 and 3.5 ppm.[47,51] The former peak stemmed from the protons adjacent to the azide groups
and the latter peak was due to the protons neighboring the −OH
groups. All these findings prove that the AzSBO was synthesized successfully.
Figure 2
1H NMR spectra of (a) SBO, (b) ESBO, and (c) AzSBO.
1H NMR spectra of (a) SBO, (b) ESBO, and (c) AzSBO.Here, we must note that we deliberately aimed for low epoxide
conversion
and thus a lower azide group content to minimize the probability of
cross-linking. We calculated the epoxidation value by titration and
found it as 0.2529 (EEW = 395). On the basis of 1H NMR[52] we calculated the degree of epoxidation as 25.75%.
A fully epoxidized SBO was reported to have an EEW of 231.[53] Therefore, it can be said that the extent of
epoxidation was low, as expected. Moreover, the nitrogen content of
the AzSBO was found to be as low as 3.3% according to elemental analysis.As noted previously, several alkyne-bearing plasticizers were synthesized
and used for the plastification of PVC. Among the studies where vegetable
oils were used as the building blocks for the synthesis of alkyne
groups-containing clickable plasticizers, harsh, multistep reactions
were conducted in the presence of copper catalysts.[30−32] It must be
noted that in some of these works phosphorylated plasticizers were
synthesized, but even when the phosphorylation step is ignored, at
least three or more steps are involved. Thus, the method suggested
in this work is relatively simple compared to several strategies proposed
in the literature. In addition, in most of the previous attempts,
rather than the vegetable oil itself, vegetable oil-derived fatty
acids or fatty acid esters were used, generating glycerol as waste.
Here, in some sense, the applied strategy also valorizes glycerol
by preserving the vegetable oil’s triglyceride structure.
Physical Appearance and the Structural Characterization
of the AzSBO-Modified PCA
In this study, we mixed AzSBO with
PCA at different weight ratios. Our preliminary trials with percentages
above 60% of AzSBO resulted in mushy, tacky, and pastelike materials.
Above this threshold value, the obtained materials displayed macroscopic
phase separation. Furthermore, we were only able to prepare relatively
thin films (>1 mm). A mushy appearance was also observed when we
tried
to prepare thicker samples. The synthesized AzSBO contains relatively
fewer azide units and is a large molecule with sterically hindered
azide functionalities; thus, rather than cross-linking of the PCA
chains, modification from different points of the polymers is anticipated.
Nevertheless, because AzSBO is multifunctional (contains many azide
groups per triglyceride) the cross-linking of the PCA chains is unavoidable.
One gram of PCA requires (Mru = 222 g/mol) 4.5 mmol of azide groups
(0.189 g of nitrogen) for full cross-linking. Because the N% of AzSBO
was found to be 3.3%, even at the highest AzSBO-containing formulation
(0.6 g/1 g of PCA), the nitrogen content (0.0198 g) is far below the
amount of nitrogen needed to consume all the triple bonds. This result
is in line with our goal to use AzSBO as a plasticizer rather than
a cross-linking agent.The photographs of the prepared films
are supplied in Figure . it can be seen from this figure, pristine PCA produces colorless
and transparent films. On the other hand, AzSBO-modified films were
brown, reflecting the color of the AzSBO.
Figure 3
Digital photographs of
PCA and AzSBO-modified films.
Digital photographs of
PCA and AzSBO-modified films.The FTIR spectra of the AzSBO-modified PCA films are given in Figure . It can be seen
from this figure that all films have similar spectra. The characteristic
ester carbonyl band of PCA was observed at 1735 cm–1 and this band did not undergo any change upon the addition of AzSBO.
The azide stretching vibrations can be seen as weak bands at around
2100 cm–1 in these spectra, indicating that not
all azide groups were reacted but confirming the reaction of the azide
groups of AzSBO with the triple bonds of PCA.
Figure 4
FTIR spectra of PCA and
AzSBO-modified films.
FTIR spectra of PCA and
AzSBO-modified films.
Wettability
of the Polyester Films
The effect of the azidated vegetable
oil on the surface wettability
of the polyesters was investigated by measuring their WCAs (Figure ). The WCA of PCA
was found to be 71°, which is close to the WCA of PET. The incorporation
of the AzSBO led to an increase in the WCA values of the modified
films, which can be ascribed to the water-repellent nature of plant
oils. For instance, 40% AzSBO addition increased the WCA to 81°
± 2. Thus, as expected, the AzSBO rendered PCA films hydrophobic.
It must be noted here that when the AzSBO ratio was increased to 60%,
it was observed that the WCA value did not change much. This can be
attributed to the increased number of polar −OH groups and
unreacted polar azide groups, which lead to a decline in the water
repellency of the plant-oil-modified PCA.
Figure 5
WCA values of the films.
WCA values of the films.
Solvent Absorption Percentages
of the Modified
Polyesters
We measured the swelling behavior of the polyester
films in different solvents (Figure ). The films were cut into small pieces, dried in a
vacuum oven at 40 °C for 24 h, and weighed. Dried pieces were
then immersed into containers containing 10 mL of different solvents
and kept for 24 h. At different time intervals, the appearance of
the films was visually controlled and the swollen films were weighed.
Figure 6
Swelling
percentages of the polyester films in different solvents
after 24 h. The swelling percentages in chloroform are reported for
3 h. The films were disintegrated in CHCl3 and slowly dissolved.
Swelling
percentages of the polyester films in different solvents
after 24 h. The swelling percentages in chloroform are reported for
3 h. The films were disintegrated in CHCl3 and slowly dissolved.Pristine PCA displayed a significant amount of
water absorption
(26%). When PCA was modified with 20% AzSBO, a dramatic decrease was
observed for its water absorption value. Further AzSBO addition also
improved the water absorptivity but the enhancement was found to be
lower when compared to PCA20 and also as the amount of AzSBO increased
to 60% from 40%, the solvent absorption percentage was increased (still
lower than neat PCA). The initial decrease in water absorption indicates
that at this AzSBO ratio films are relatively cross-linked, repelling
the diffusion of water. On the other hand, the latter increase in
water absorption can be explained by the decreased cross-linking density,
leading to the exposure of the polar azide and hydroxyl groups which
in turn contribute to the water absorption. For the organic solvents,
a similar situation was encountered. For acetone, hexane, and toluene,
solvents in which neat PCA is insoluble, first, the solvent absorption
was decreased because of the relatively higher cross-linking density,
and then the solvent absorption percentages were increased with an
increasing amount of AzSBO because of the lightly cross-linked nature
of PCA40 and PCA60 and due to the strong affinity of the vegetable
oil-based AzSBO toward these solvents. Among these three solvents,
films exhibited less affinity toward hexane and higher swelling in
relatively polar acetone.In the case of chloroform in which
PCA was soluble, the films exhibited
a rather peculiar behavior. The pristine PCA films (PCA0) were completely
dissolved in CHCl3 within 15 min. Contrary to PCA0, AzSBO-modified
films gained resistance to dissolution because of cross-linking and
swelled in CHCl3 for at least 3 h. At the end of this period,
swollen films started to break apart into small pieces and within
24 h completely dissolved. This finding is important since it reveals
that the films were lightly cross-linked. As opposed to the swelling
behaviors in other solvents, the swelling percentage of PCA20 was
found to be higher than that of PCA40 and PCA60 despite its relatively
higher cross-linking density. It is thought that this result stems
from the ease of dissolution of PCA40 and PCA60 in chloroform. The
relatively faster dissolution of PCA40 and PCA60 resulted in lower
swelling percentages in CHCl3 when compared to PCA20, which
was much more resistant and produced higher swelling ratios before
breaking apart.Finally, after 24 h, we must note that the swollen
films in acetone
were dried at 40 °C under vacuum and reweighed to determine whether
the unreacted AzSBO passes to the solvent. The acetone soluble fractions
of PCA20, PCA40 and PCA60 were found as 6.5%, 9.8% and 13.5%, respectively.
Even though a biobased plasticizer is used in this work, the nonmigratory
effect ensures long-term stability for the polymer. The bulky, sterically
hindered, and low amount of azide groups-bearing AzSBO resulted in
relatively fewer attachment points to the triple bonds of PCA which
in turn led to some unreacted AzSBO.
Thermal
Properties
The thermal stability
of the PCA0 and the modified polyesters were determined by TGA. The
TGA thermograms are presented in Figure along with the corresponding derivative
weight curves and the results are listed in Table .
Figure 7
(a) TGA thermograms and (b) the derivative weight
curves of PCA
and the modified polyesters
Table 1
Thermal and Mechanical Properties
of the Modified Polyesters
Tmaxa (°C)
char (%)
Tgb (°C)
Young’s
modulus (MPa)
tensile strength
(MPa)
elongation
at break (%)
E′(20 °C)c (MPa)
ρx (× 103 mol/cm–3)c
PCA0
350
5.56
57
531 ± 50
17.5 ± 2.4
8.8 ± 5.1
1.33
-
PCA20
410
7.7
48
153.2 ± 48
2.25 ± 0.25
12.6 ± 4.3
ND
ND
PCA40
410
8.1
40
113.5 ± 12
3.28 ± 0.16
76.4 ± 23
0.48
1.7
PCA60
350–410
5.139
31
75.58 ± 10
3.55 ± 0.59
22.46 ± 5.3
0.14
0.65
Tmax is the maximum weight
loss temperature, which was determined from
the maximum of the corresponding derivative curves.
Determined by DSC.
Determined by DMA.
(a) TGA thermograms and (b) the derivative weight
curves of PCA
and the modified polyestersTmax is the maximum weight
loss temperature, which was determined from
the maximum of the corresponding derivative curves.Determined by DSC.Determined by DMA.PCA0 displayed a single-step degradation profile.
The small amount
of weight loss that occurred under 150 °C was attributed to the
absorbed moisture, reflecting the hygroscopic nature of PCA. The main
degradation temperature (Tmax) for PCA
was found as 350 °C and the char yield at 600 °C was determined
to be 5.56%. After modification and cross-linking, the thermal properties
were improved. Tmax values shifted to
410 °C and the char yields increased to 7.7 and 8.1% for PCA20
and PCA40, respectively. The improved thermal stability can also be
ascribed to the formation of thermally stable, rigid triazole rings.
PCA60, which produced the highest amount of acetone-soluble fraction,
displayed a two-stage degradation profile and exhibited a relatively
lower char yield. This result supports our view that the cross-linking
density decreased with an increasing amount of AzSBO. The decreased
cross-linking density adversely affected the thermal properties.The Tg values of the polyesters were
determined by DSC and the DSC curves of the polyesters are presented
in Figure . The Tg values were determined as 57, 48, 40, and
31 for PCA0, PCA20, PCA40, and PCA60, respectively (Table ). These results clearly display
the plasticization of PCA chains with the aid of AzSBO despite slight
cross-linking. The covalently attached AzSBO molecules act as internal
plasticizers while the unreacted AzSBO behaves like a common external
plasticizer. AzSBO increases the distance between individual polymer
chains and as a result, the free volume, mobility, and flexibility
of the polyester chains increase. Najafi et al. prepared oleic acid-based
internal plasticizers that were covalently attached to PVC chains.[54] The Tg of the neat
PVC decreased to 42.8 °C from 84 °C. In another work, Jia
et al. prepared an amine-functional plasticizer from waste vegetable
cooking oil, attached it to PVC via displacement of chlorines, and
similarly, the Tg value was almost halved
compared to PVC without plasticizer.[55]
Figure 8
DSC curves
of the polyesters.
DSC curves
of the polyesters.We also prepared ESBO
or DOP-containing PCA films and compared
their plasticization performance with AzSBO. The DSC spectra of PCA/DOP
and PCA/ESBO films are presented in Figures S1 and S2, respectively. As it can be seen from these spectra,
both ESBO and DOP-containing PCA films displayed two endotherms; one
approximately at the Tg value of the neat
PCA (57 °C) and another Tg at a lower
temperature. The lower Tg value for the
PCA/DOP films was measured as 38 °C, whereas that for the PCA/ESBO
films was found to be 36.5 °C. The presence of two Tg values indicate that both DOP and ESBO are not compatible
with PCA. Although PCA20 encoded films that contain AzSBO as the plasticizer,
displayed a relatively higher Tg value
(48 °C) with respect to DOP and ESBO, they were found to be much
more compatible with PCA. The relatively lower plasticization performance
of AzSBO can be attributed to the introduced cross-linking sites.
Fu et al. investigated the effect of dioctyl terephthalate (DOTP)
and ESBO on PVC and found that they had similar plasticization efficiencies
and when the same amount was added, the Tg for PVC/DOTP was determined to be 35.2 °C, whereas that for
PVC/ESBO was 39.8 °C.[28] Furthermore,
when they used epoxidized castor oil (ECO) as plasticizer, the films
displayed two Tg values, reflecting the
incompatibility between ECO and PVC.To gain more insight into
the cross-linking and plasticizing effect,
we investigated the thermomechanical properties of the AzSBO-containing
PCA films. The storage modulus versus temperature plots of the polyester
films are given in Figure S3 and the results
are displayed in Table . Since we could not be able to prepare thick films, the DMA tan
delta and loss modulus plots were too noisy and therefore they are
not reported here. Furthermore, despite our several trials, we could
not be able to record full plots for PCA20 encoded films, all samples
broke during the tests. The cross-linking densities (ρx) of
the polyesters were calculated by using the following equation according
to the literature:[56]where E′
is the rubbery
storage modulus at Tg + 40 °C in
MPa, R is the gas constant (8.3145 J/mol K), T is the temperature in K, and γ is Poisson’s
ratio. γ was assumed to be 0.5.[56] The Tg values were borrowed from the
DSC results.The DMA results apparently display the plasticizing
effect of AzSBO.
As the amount of the added AzSBO was increased, the storage modulus
as well as the cross-linking densities of the polyester films decreased.
Thus, it can be concluded that there is a good correlation between
the observed decreasing trend in Tg values
and the decreasing cross-linking densities. These results support
our previous findings. As the cross-linking density of the polyester
films increased, the restricted mobility led to relatively higher Tg values. For instance, the Tg of PCA40 was found to be 9° higher than that of
PCA60 because of the more than 3-fold increase in the cross-linking
density with respect to PCA60.As it is known cross-linking
and plasticization are two antagonistic
effects. The greater the cross-linking density, the less the plasticization.
Both the DSC and DMA results in this work clearly reflect this principle.
Mechanical Properties
The tensile
modulus, tensile strength, and elongation at break values of the PCA-based
films were determined. The representative stress–strain curves
are presented in Figure and the results are collected in Table . Note that the data in Table are the average of at least
three different measurements. The Young’s modulus and the elongation
at break value of PCA0 were found to be 531 MPa and 8.8%, respectively.
The Young’s modulus of the PCA20 decreased dramatically to
153.2 MPa. The modulus decreased with a further increase in the amount
of AzSBO. This result clearly shows that the films were lightly cross-linked
and internally plasticized by AzSBO. It would be suitable to expect
that the modulus would be higher or similar to PCA if the cross-linking
density was much higher. Thus, based on these results we can conclude
that in our case, modification of the PCA chains was prominent rather
than cross-linking. Increased elongation at break values accompanied
the decreased modulus values as a result of plasticization. The film
specimens of PCA60 broke before they could get too long because of
their low modulus values. The tensile strength values also declined
when the modified vegetable oil was incorporated; however, the tensile
strength values increased as the amount of AzSBO was increased.
Figure 9
Representative
stress–strain curves of the polyester films.
Representative
stress–strain curves of the polyester films.
Conclusions
As a continuation of our
studies on triple-bond-containing polyesters,
here we modified them with azidated vegetable oil and investigated
the properties of the resulting polymers. AzSBO was attached to PCA
chains via a metal-free azide–alkyne click reaction. PCA was
modified with up to 60% AzSBO. After this threshold value, self-standing
and visually uniform films cannot be produced. It turned out that
the solvent absorption and the plasticization of the polyester chains
could be controlled with the addition of different amounts of AzSBO.
DSC and DMA results revealed that at lower ratios, AzSBO lead to cross-linking
and thus the obtained films were resistant to solvent absorption and
the plasticization was less pronounced compared to a relatively higher
amount of AzSBO-containing films. As the amount of AzSBO was increased,
the Tg values declined and the films became
much more flexible because of the increased free volume and chain
mobility. The addition of AzSBO also led to improvement in the thermal
degradation temperatures due to cross-linking.Here, the applied
method is fast, straightforward, and effective
compared to other methods in the literature on vegetable oil-based
plasticizers. In addition, providing solvent resistance is another
privilege. Yet, not all AzSBO reacted with PCA, thus the nonmigratory
behavior was not revealed. Therefore, for future studies, we aim to
develop new plasticizers by directing our work in a way that will
further reduce migration.
Authors: Atanu Biswas; Brajendra K Sharma; J L Willett; Atanu Advaryu; S Z Erhan; H N Cheng Journal: J Agric Food Chem Date: 2008-06-18 Impact factor: 5.279