Two-dimensional MXenes have shown great promise for many different applications, but in order to fully utilize their potential, control of their termination groups is essential. Here we demonstrate hydrolyzation with a continuous gas flow as a method to remove F-terminations from multilayered V2CT x particles, in order to prepare nearly F-free and partly bare vanadium carbide MXene. Density functional theory calculations demonstrate that the substitution of F-terminations is thermodynamically feasible and presents partly nonterminated V2CO as the dominating hydrolyzation product. Hydrolyzation at elevated temperatures reduced the F content but only subtly changed the O content, as inferred from spectroscopic data. The ideal hydrolyzation temperature was found to be 300 °C, as a degradation of the V2CT x phase and a transition to vanadium oxycarbides and V2O3 were observed at higher temperature. When tested as electrodes in Li-ion batteries, the hydrolyzed MXene demonstrated a reduced polarization compared with the pristine MXene, but no change in intercalation voltage was observed. Annealing in dry Ar did not result in the same F reduction, and the importance of water vapor was concluded, demonstrating hydrolyzation as a new and efficient method to control the surface terminations of multilayered V2CT x post etching. These results also provide new insights on the thermal stability of V2CT x MXene in hydrated atmospheres.
Two-dimensional MXenes have shown great promise for many different applications, but in order to fully utilize their potential, control of their termination groups is essential. Here we demonstrate hydrolyzation with a continuous gas flow as a method to remove F-terminations from multilayered V2CT x particles, in order to prepare nearly F-free and partly bare vanadium carbide MXene. Density functional theory calculations demonstrate that the substitution of F-terminations is thermodynamically feasible and presents partly nonterminated V2CO as the dominating hydrolyzation product. Hydrolyzation at elevated temperatures reduced the F content but only subtly changed the O content, as inferred from spectroscopic data. The ideal hydrolyzation temperature was found to be 300 °C, as a degradation of the V2CT x phase and a transition to vanadium oxycarbides and V2O3 were observed at higher temperature. When tested as electrodes in Li-ion batteries, the hydrolyzed MXene demonstrated a reduced polarization compared with the pristine MXene, but no change in intercalation voltage was observed. Annealing in dry Ar did not result in the same F reduction, and the importance of water vapor was concluded, demonstrating hydrolyzation as a new and efficient method to control the surface terminations of multilayered V2CT x post etching. These results also provide new insights on the thermal stability of V2CT x MXene in hydrated atmospheres.
Since the first report
of MXenes 11 years ago,[1] the research interest
for this family of two-dimensional
materials has grown exponentially. MXenes are transition metal carbides,
nitrides and carbonitrides, where the transition metal “M”
and the carbon or nitrogen “X” atoms are stacked in
odd numbered layers (e.g., Ti3C2, V2C, and Nb2C).[2] Because of their
unique combination of tunable properties, such as metallic conduction,
hydrophilic surfaces, adjustable interlayer spacings and rich surface
chemistries, MXenes have been reported for a range of applications,
from water purification and biomedicine to hydrogen evolution and
energy storage.[2−6] Not only can the combination of M and X elements, or the number
of layers, change the properties of the MXene, but with the formation
of surface terminal groups upon synthesis, such as -O, -OH, -F, and
-Cl, the tuning possibilities of these materials are significant.
However, although there have been reported dozens of different MX
compositions, there are few methods to fully control the surface terminations
on a limited number of MXenes.[6,7] As the surface terminations
determine the local environment in between the MXene layers, and properties
such as electronic conduction and ion-intercalation, controlling them
is of critical importance for full utilization of MXenes’ potential.[8−11]Using the most common etching methods for MXene consisting
of HF
solutions or a solution of HCl and F-salts, a mixture of the above-mentioned
termination groups are formed.[12−14] Although there have been reports
on vacuum annealing, oxygen annealing, and treatment in alkalic solutions,
where the aim was to change the termination groups post etching, they
usually only report on partly termination substitution and often in
nonscalable methods such as on thin films.[9,11,15−18] To prove useful for practical
applications such as battery electrodes, the termination groups within
the bulk of multilayered MXene particles must be reliably controlled.
To the authors’ knowledge, it remains to be demonstrated a
method to homogeneously control terminations in MXenes after the etching
in F-containing solutions.An example of a MXene where surface
control is important is the
V2CT phase,
which is one of the best compositions for electrode materials in supercapacitors
and batteries because of its predicted potential.[19−21] Even though
V2CT already
has demonstrated some of the highest capacities of MXenes in Li-ion
batteries (LiBs) and supercapacitors,[22,23] there is still
predicted higher capacity, higher voltage, and lower migration barriers
in V2CO2 compared with OH- and F-terminated
V2CT.[19,24−27] However, synthesizing V2CO2 without decomposing
the MXene structure is challenging, because vanadium oxides can form
at elevated temperatures by hydrothermal treatment,[28,29] as well as by annealing in inert, reducing and oxidative atmospheres.[30,31] Hence, changing the termination groups of V2CT without formation of secondary
phases remains a challenge.In this work, we demonstrate the
use of gas hydrolysis to change
the surface terminations of V2CT MXene. Three different hydrolyzation reactions are
proposed, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations support
that a shift from F termination to OH/O termination is thermodynamically
feasible, given a continuous flow of humidified Ar gas. Therefore,
V2CT particles
synthesized by regular HF-etching of V2AlC were exposed
to a controlled water vapor pressure at various temperatures. X-ray
photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy
(EDS) were used to verify the chemical change upon hydrolyzation at
elevated temperature, indicating a significant reduction of F content
upon hydrolyzation at elevated temperatures. X-ray diffraction (XRD),
scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and Raman spectroscopy were used
to describe the structural changes, showing how the MXene phase remains
stable up to 300 °C. These hydrolyzation results are also compared
to annealing in dry Ar gas by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), demonstrating
that the water vapor is essential for the resulting change in termination.
In the end, galvanostatic cycling of V2CT electrodes in Li-ion batteries is presented
to indicate the change in electrochemical properties of V2CT upon modifying the
MXene surface.
Results and Discussion
Thermodynamics
With the intention of substituting F-terminations
with O-containing terminations, the following three hydrolyzation
reactions are suggested:The variation in standard free energy
with temperature for the three hydrolyzation reactions is given in Figure a. While reaction remains positive
for all temperatures, reaction has a negative ΔG° at T > RT and reaction at T > 400 K, indicating spontaneous
reactions
at elevated temperatures. However, these results only illustrate the
situation at standard conditions, and Figure S11 demonstrates how the ΔG of reaction also becomes spontaneous
with a sufficiently high ratio between the vapor pressure of H2O and HF. In general, having a high vapor pressure of water
and continuous removal of HF gas is beneficial for all the presented
hydrolyzation reactions. With a given water vapor pressure of 4.738
× 104 Pa, originating from the saturated water gas
at 80 °C,[32]Figure b presents the calculated equilibrium partial
pressures of HF gas for the three reactions and demonstrates that
significant amounts of HF gas will be produced at elevated temperatures.
It also shows that the dominating reaction would be substitution of
two F terminations in favor of a single O-termination, leaving parts
of the surface unterminated (V2CO). In total, these results
give a strong indication that the removal of F-terminations from V2CT by hydrolyzation
is possible, as all the proposed reactions show spontaneous reactions
at achievable experimental conditions.
Figure 1
Thermodynamic properties
from DFT calculations of three reactions
for removal of F-termination from V2CT. (a) shows ΔG° as a function of temperature, while (b) shows the equilibrium
partial pressure of HF gas for the three reactions, considering a
saturated water vapor pressure of 4.738 × 104 Pa.
Thermodynamic properties
from DFT calculations of three reactions
for removal of F-termination from V2CT. (a) shows ΔG° as a function of temperature, while (b) shows the equilibrium
partial pressure of HF gas for the three reactions, considering a
saturated water vapor pressure of 4.738 × 104 Pa.
Structure and Morphology
The structural
change of the
V2CT phase
upon hydrolyzation is illustrated in Figure . It shows that the intensity of the MXene
related reflections remain relatively stable up to a hydrolyzation
temperature of 300 °C, before they are significantly reduced
at 400 °C and virtually absent at 500 °C. The most likely
explanation for the degradation at 400 °C can be described by
the broad reflections emerging at around 36.6°, 43.5°, and
64.2° which most likely comes from a mixture of vanadium oxycarbides
(denoted “VCO”), as both VC and VO crystallize in the same rock salt
structure (space group Fm3̅m)[33] and show XRD reflections in those
three areas (PDF 01-074-1220 and PDF 04-004-9038). However, these
reflections disappear upon increasing the temperature to 500 °C,
where the only detectable reflections remaining are related to Al2O3 from the MAX phase synthesis and V2O3. This indicates that the V2CT first decomposes to VCO followed by the formation
of V2O3 at temperatures above 400 °C. The
transition to V2O3 after hydrolyzation at 500
°C is also demonstrated by Raman measurements (Figure S5), where the MXene related vibration bands disappear
in favor of V2O3 bands around 210 cm–1, and the D and G bands are attributed to amorphous carbonaceous
species that remain. For an
oxygen terminated MXene phase (V2CO2), the degradation
can be described by the following reaction:
Figure 2
X-ray diffractograms
of V2CT hydrolyzed
at different temperatures (a), where
(b) shows a close-up of the (002) V2CT reflections located inside the black
rectangle in (a). In (a), there is also a dashed line indicating the
position of the (110) MXene reflection at 63.8°.
X-ray diffractograms
of V2CT hydrolyzed
at different temperatures (a), where
(b) shows a close-up of the (002) V2CT reflections located inside the black
rectangle in (a). In (a), there is also a dashed line indicating the
position of the (110) MXene reflection at 63.8°.However, apart from the degradation at 400 °C significant
changes to the MXene phase after hydrolyzation at lower temperatures
are observed. First, it should be noted that already in the pristine
MXene, the (002) double reflection indicates that two different interlayer
spacings are present in the MXene (9.574 and 7.735 Å, Figure b). This reflection
splitting may be due to intercalation of water molecules in parts
of the particles. Xie et al. calculated that the interlayer spacing
of V2CT lies
around 7.5 Å with no intercalated water and around 9.5 Å
with 2 layers of water molecules, in fair agreement with our experimental
results.[34] Since previous articles often
report on an interlayer spacing around 9.5 Å or higher, it is
reasonable to assume that parts of our particles have been dried prior
to the characterization.[31,35,36] Interestingly, the split remains after hydrolyzation, although we
see a shift in intensity toward the reflection at higher 2θ,
indicating a reduction of interlayer spacing and less water between
the layers. Additionally, we see an uneven shift of the two reflections
toward larger 2θ upon increasing the hydrolyzation temperature.
After hydrolyzation at 300 °C, the reduction of the interlayer
spacing was 0.320 Å for the reflection at lower 2θ and
0.475 Å for the reflection at higher 2θ (Figure b). This change is ascribed
to changes in the surface terminations of the MXene, as well as small
changes in intercalated water.Another interesting aspect with
the XRD results is that no reflections
related to the MAX phase remain after the etching, indicating complete
Al removal from the MAX phase (Figure S2). This is usually not reported for HF-etched V2AlC and
demonstrates that reducing the particle size prior to etching can
help improve the etching yield of this phase.[22,31] With an average size of 5.91 μm (Figure S3), it is shown that 72 h of etching in 48 wt % HF is enough
for complete conversion to MXene at ∼22 °C.The
change in morphology with hydrolysis and temperature is given
in Figure . Although
the macroscopic disc-like morphology remains similar even after the
phase transition to V2O3 (a–c), the high-magnification
images (d–f) reveal a formation of nanoparticles at the edges
of the particles after hydrolyzation at 500 °C, which most likely
represent V2O3. A similar growth of oxide nanoparticles
has been reported after hydrothermal treatment of V2CT, although they report on
higher oxidation states of V, corresponding to VO2 and
V2O5.[28,29] In Ti-based MXenes
the formation of TiO2 nanoparticles at the edges of Ti3C2T and Ti2CT is also commonly observed upon exposure to water and air at elevated
temperatures.[37−40] The average particle size of the MXenes is a few microns, indicating
that the particle size is maintained upon etching, as it matches well
with the V2AlC MAX phase (Figures S3 and S4). Figure also shows that the particles have a lot of cracks and uneven surfaces.
This might originate from introduction of strain in the particles
during milling of the MAX phase as it can also be seen in the MAX
phase particles before etching (Figure S4).
Figure 3
SEM images with low (a–c) and high (d–e) magnification:
pristine V2CT (a,d) and V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C (b,e) and 500 °C (c,f). The
high-magnification areas represent the red rectangle in the low-magnification
images.
SEM images with low (a–c) and high (d–e) magnification:
pristine V2CT (a,d) and V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C (b,e) and 500 °C (c,f). The
high-magnification areas represent the red rectangle in the low-magnification
images.
Chemical Composition
The change in chemical environment
upon hydrolyzation is described in Figure , where XPS is used to probe the outer surface
of the MXene particles and EDS is used for bulk characterization. Figure a presents the deconvolution
of the XPS regions of V 2p and O 1s from V2CT before and after hydrolyzation at 300
°C. Based on the fitting parameters of previous work, the different
V 2p3/2 peaks were assigned to V2+ (513.1 eV),
V3+ (515.3 eV) and V4+ (516.3 eV).[31,41,42] The paramagnetic splitting of
V 2p is set to 7.2 eV with a split ratio of 0.5, which gives rise
to the V 2p1/2 peaks at higher binding energies.[43] The distribution of oxidation states in the
pristine V2CT is in accordance with previous reports.[31,44,45] Upon hydrolyzation, oxidation of the surface
V atoms from 2+ to 4+ is evident, indicating possible oxide formation
and/or change in the surface terminations. No contributions from V5+ (517.1 eV) in any of the spectra were detected, indicating
that the hydrolyzation conditions are less oxidative than air.[30,31] The deconvolution of the O 1s region is ascribed to vanadium oxides
O–V (529.7 eV), O-terminated MXene as C–V–O (531.1
eV), and a combination of OH-terminated V2CT and adsorbed water as C–V–OH/H2Oads (532.1 eV).[22,31,42,46,47] The changes upon hydrolyzation indicate partial increase of surface
oxides, with a reduction in the amount of OH-terminations and adsorbed
water. This corresponds well with the changes in the V 2p region,
and the XRD results presented in Figure , as well as with previous reports on the
effect of V2CT annealing.[31]
Figure 4
XPS spectra of the V
2p and O 1s region (a) and the F 1s region
(b) for V2CT and V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C, where the intensity of (a) is normalized
to the V peaks. (c) The lower energy region of EDS spectra obtained
from mapping of V2CT and V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C and 500 °C, where the intensities
are normalized to the V LL peak at 0.446 eV, to show the relative
shift of the O and F content.
XPS spectra of the V
2p and O 1s region (a) and the F 1s region
(b) for V2CT and V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C, where the intensity of (a) is normalized
to the V peaks. (c) The lower energy region of EDS spectra obtained
from mapping of V2CT and V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C and 500 °C, where the intensities
are normalized to the V LL peak at 0.446 eV, to show the relative
shift of the O and F content.In Table , the
quantification of the chemical compositions of V2AlC, V2CT, and V2CT after hydrolyzation
at elevated temperatures is given. The EDS results are based on average
values of several point scans and show a clear trend in reducing the
concentration of F upon increasing the hydrolyzation temperature.
The trend is supported by the EDS spectra from mapping presented in Figure c, demonstrating
a significant reduction in the F Kα peak at 0.68 keV upon increasing
the hydrolyzation temperature. The EDS results indicate a F reduction
of around 2/3 in the bulk of V2CT particles hydrolyzed at 300 °C compared
to pristine V2CT. From Figure b, the reduction in F is even more significant at the outer surface
of the particles as the F 1s peak is virtually absent after the hydrolyzation
at 300 °C.
Table 1
EDS Data Averaged from Several Point
Scans of V2AlC, Pristine V2CT, and V2CT Hydrolyzed at Different Temperaturesa
sample
V
Al
O
F
O (XPS)
F (XPS)
V2AlC
2
0.93
0.07
-
V2CTx
2
0.03
0.27
1.00
1.31
0.54
Hyd100C
2
0.03
0.38
0.74
Hyd200C
2
0.05
0.28
0.49
Hyd300C
2
0.02
0.27
0.31
1.18
0.04
Hyd400C
2
0.09
0.35
0.15
Hyd500C
2
0.03
1.06
0.03
The last two columns indicate
the quantification obtained from the XPS fitting. All values are presented
relative to one formula unit of V2CT (or a V amount of 2).
The last two columns indicate
the quantification obtained from the XPS fitting. All values are presented
relative to one formula unit of V2CT (or a V amount of 2).However, only minute changes in
O-terminations are observed upon
hydrolyzation. From Table , the EDS results indicate insignificant changes in the amount
of O upon increasing the hydrolyzation temperature, where the O content
remains stable at around 0.3 per unit formula of V2CT. It should be noted that
the quantification of V and O content by EDS is uncertain due to overlapping
peaks, which is shown in Figure c. Nonetheless, the XPS results of the O 1s region
also demonstrate a similar trend, where no obvious increase in the
O-content can be seen after the hydrolyzation at 300 °C. From
these results, it is therefore difficult to conclude whether the hydrolyzation
has resulted in an increase of O-terminations or if F-terminations
are simply removed, resulting in the formation of nonterminated V2C. Although formation of V2C does not match well
with the increased oxidation state of V, removal of terminations matches
well with the 2θ shift in the XRD results (Figure b), as V2C would
have a smaller interlayer spacing than terminated V2CT. Additionally, it should
be noted that from the theoretically calculated ΔG°(T) curves presented in Figure b, the formation of single terminated V2CO is the most favorable reaction, indicating that formation of a
partly nonterminated phase (V2CO) is more favorable than
forming two O-terminations (V2CO2). With that
in mind, even though characterization of the surface terminations
is challenging with respect to MXenes, a more thorough study would
be needed to confirm the nature of the termination groups on hydrolyzation,
and to better quantify the amount of O-terminations.
Thermal Stability
Figure shows the
TG curve of V2CT in Ar atmosphere and the
resulting X-ray diffractograms after various annealing temperatures.
From the TG curve in Figure a, it is seen that the V2CT shows a continuous mass loss but with three
significant mass loss regions at ∼80–280 °C, ∼320–500
°C and above ∼650 °C, matching well with previous
reports.[12,30] The initial mass loss is ascribed to desorption
of physiosorbed water, which is supported by the 2θ-shift of
the (002) V2CT reflections after annealing at 300 °C (Figure b). At higher temperatures (∼320–480
°C), the removal of chemisorbed water due to OH-terminations
is suggested.[30,35] However, the XRD data show that
this temperature also results in a degradation of the MXene structure,
as the (002) reflections of V2CT are significantly reduced after annealing up to
600 °C. Similar to hydrolyzation at 400 °C (Figure ), the formation of broad reflections
from oxycarbide (VCO) appear at this temperature. It is therefore suggested that
the chemisorbed water may be required for the stability of the V2CT phase. At
the third mass loss region (>650 °C), the MXene phase is fully
degraded. According to Wu et al. only V2O3 and
V8C7 phases were left after annealing up to
1000 °C.[30] However, Figure b shows the presence of a VF2 phase after 1 h at 800 °C, indicating that some of the
F content remained at this temperature. There is a chance that the
discrepancies between these results might come from the initial O:F
ratio obtained after etching, where Wu et al. showed a much higher
O content than what is presented here (0.98:0.30 vs 0.27:1.00). This
might have led to V2O3 being formed instead
of VF2. Since Matthews et al. showed a significant mass
loss between 800 and 1000 °C, it might also be that F is removed
above 800 °C, resulting in the formation of only oxides and carbides.[35]
Figure 5
(a) TG curve of V2CT heated in Ar atmosphere up to 800 °C followed
by 60 min
dwelling. The inset shows differential mass loss during the heating
step. (b) The resulting X-ray diffractograms after heating up to 300
°C, 600 °C and 800 °C, shown in (a). The dwelling times
at the different temperatures were 60 min, and the dashed line in
(b) indicates the position of the (110) MXene reflection at 63.8°.
(a) TG curve of V2CT heated in Ar atmosphere up to 800 °C followed
by 60 min
dwelling. The inset shows differential mass loss during the heating
step. (b) The resulting X-ray diffractograms after heating up to 300
°C, 600 °C and 800 °C, shown in (a). The dwelling times
at the different temperatures were 60 min, and the dashed line in
(b) indicates the position of the (110) MXene reflection at 63.8°.Comparing the results after annealing in pure Ar
with the results
from the hydrolyzation experiments (Figure ), some differences with respect to the inclusion
of water is observed. First, the remaining F phase after annealing
at 800 °C in Ar (Figure b) indicates that the water vapor is essential for the removal
of F during hydrolyzation, seeing that the F content was reduced to
∼0 after hydrolyzation at 500 °C (Table ). Additionally, the splitting of the (002)
reflections remains even after annealing in dry Ar, indicating that
the chemisorbed water reacts similarly in wet and dry Ar. Moreover,
the decomposition of V2CT starts at lower temperatures in the presence of
water vapor, considering that the diffractogram after hydrolyzation
at 400 °C resembles the one after annealing at 600 °C in
Ar. However, even after annealing at 800 °C in dry Ar, the layered
morphology of the particles remains (Figure S13), which is similar to what has been reported previously.[30,31]
Electrochemical Properties
The cycling results of V2CT electrodes
in LiB half cells are presented in Figure . It shows voltage profiles from two cycles
at two different current densities (10 and 100 mA/g) and demonstrates
similar profiles for the pristine V2CT and the V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C. Both materials
display generally sloped curves indicative of the pseudocapacitive
storage mechanism of MXenes.[48,49] With sloped plateaus
at around 1.5–3 V, these voltage profiles are also similar
to previously reported profiles for V2CT, showing higher average voltages for
V2CT MXene
compared with other MXene compositions.[22,45,50] Another interesting similarity with previous reports
is the irreversible plateau observed at ∼1.6 V on the first
discharge (Figure S16). As SEI formation
is not expected to take place at such high voltages, it is possible
that this plateau represents trapping of some Li-ions in V2CT on the first cycle.[51] Nevertheless, these cycling results verify the
presence of V2CT both before and after the hydrolyzation.
Figure 6
Voltage plots of two
different cycles at two different current
densities from V2CT electrodes before and after hydrolyzation at 300 °C.
Voltage plots of two
different cycles at two different current
densities from V2CT electrodes before and after hydrolyzation at 300 °C.After comparing the electrochemical performance
before and after
hydrolyzation, only subtle differences are observed (Figure ). This contrasts with some
of the predicted changes from DFT calculations for changing termination
groups. First, the average voltage was not increased after the removal
of both F- and OH-terminations from hydrolyzation. This could be another
indication of the hydrolyzation not resulting in any increase in the
O-terminations, as the voltage then would have been expected to increase.[19,52] Instead, this could also suggest the formation of nonterminated
MXene. However, it might also be that the pseudocapacitive nature
of the energy storage mechanism blurs out the effects of the intercalation
voltages. Wang et al. presented similar voltages for V2CT etched in milder
F-conditions (HCl and F-salts), resulting in fewer F-terminations
than what is obtained by HF-etching.[45] Although
they demonstrated significantly higher capacities than by HF-etching,
most of the capacity was obtained between 0.5 and 0.01 V. Above 0.5
V, their capacities were similar to the capacities obtained here.The rate capability on the other hand was significantly improved
after hydrolyzation of the MXene (Figure ). Some of these changes can be related to
the difference in loading (4.31 mg/cm2 for V2CT and 1.62 mg/cm2 for Hyd300C), but they cannot explain all the changes. Upon
increasing the current density from 10 mA/g to 100 mA/g, the overpotential
of the pristine V2CT increases more than for the hydrolyzed one. This change in
polarization has previously been demonstrated for F-free Ti3C2T MXene[53] and matches better with calculated results,
as both bare and O-terminated V2CT have been shown to have lower migration
barriers for Li-ions compared with OH- and F-terminated V2CT.[24−27] Notably, the reported F-free
Ti3C2T also did not result in any significant change in intercalation
voltage.Comparing the first cycles of both cells, the irreversible
plateau
at ∼1.6 V is longer for the pristine V2CT than for the V2CT hydrolyzed at 300
°C (Figure S16). A possible explanation
for this can be the reduction of the intercalated water between the
MXene layers, where the pristine V2CT has the highest amount of intercalated water.
Similar water reduction has previously been reported at comparable
voltages in LiPF6 electrolytes with water impurities, where
H2O is reduced into OH– and H2 gas.[54,55] However, if water reduction is the explanation
of the irreversible plateau, it does not seem to have affected the
long-term cycling performance of these electrodes significantly. Nonetheless,
seeing that intercalated water remains in V2CT even after annealing in dry Ar at 300
°C, further research should be directed toward understanding
the effect of intercalated water in MXenes when cycling in nonaqueous
electrolytes.
Discussion
Among the possible post
etch treatments of MXenes, the present
investigation has demonstrated that hydrolyzation of V2CT at elevated temperatures
in a continuous flow of humidified Ar(g) can reduce the concentration
of F-terminations. Although there have been several reports on hydrolysis
of the Ti3C2T MXene phase, most of them have been performed under closed
conditions, building up significant partial pressures of the product
gases resulting from the hydrolyzation reaction and thus limiting
further reaction. To the authors’ knowledge, there has only
been reported one attempt on hydrolyzation of MXene in a continuous
flow of humidified inert gas; however, this was performed on Ti3C2T, at moderate hydrolyzation conditions (1 h at 400 °C, with
25 °C water bath and 100 mL/min gas flow).[48] Based on the results presented here, the application of
hydrolysis using a continuous flow of Ar(g) with a high partial pressure
of H2O(g) opens up for new possibilities for post etching
treatments of MXenes beyond only V2CT.[35,56]Another way of
circumventing F-terminations would be to synthesize
the MXene in a F-free environment. For the Ti3C2T phase, there has
been reported several F-free etching methods, such as hydrothermal
etching in NaOH solutions, in anhydrous halogen solutions and by molten
salt reactions in both halogens and Lewis acids.[7,53,57−59] Although the latter
method was used to replace Al by Zn from V2AlC in the formation
of V2ZnC, they were unable to further separate V2CCl2 sheets because of the high bond strength of V–Zn.[58] Homogeneously terminated MXenes can be prepared
by the molten salt method, where successful formation of pure Br-,
Cl-, I-, Te-, Se-, NH2-, S-, and O-terminations of both
Ti3C2T and Nb2CT MXenes has been demonstrated.[7] However,
to the authors’ knowledge, there has not yet been reported
any successful etching of V2CT using any of these methods. Until other etching
methods are successfully implemented for V2CT, post etching methods will still remain
essential in order to control the surface chemistry of this MXene.
Conclusions
In summary, we have demonstrated gas hydrolyzation as a new and
efficient method to significantly reduce the number of F-terminations
from multilayered V2CT MXene. DFT calculations demonstrated that several hydrolyzation
reactions are possible and that a continuous gas flow during the hydrolyzation
would be ideal in order to maintain a high enough ratio between water
vapor and the gas products. The V2CT was dehydrated upon annealing in both dry
and wet Ar gas, leading to the removal of intercalated water and OH-terminations
up to ∼300 °C. Additionally, hydrolyzation at 300 °C
resulted in a removal of F content by almost 70% from the bulk of
V2CT particles,
thus demonstrating gas hydrolyzation as the most efficient post etching
method for bulk F removal to date. However, at hydrolyzation temperatures
above 300 °C, the MXene phase started to decompose, and a hydrolyzation
temperature of 500 °C resulted in a complete transformation into
V2O3 and C. In dry Ar, the decomposition started
at slightly higher temperatures and only rock salt vanadium oxycarbides
and VF2 remained after annealing at 800 °C.Although hydrolyzation resulted in a reduction of F-terminations,
it did not result in any corresponding increase in O content of the
MXene. Instead, formation of nonterminated V2C is proposed,
which is supported by the electrochemical performance of the hydrolyzed
V2CT. In
LiB half cells, a reduced polarization was observed after hydrolyzation
at 300 °C, matching well with the predicted lower migration barriers
of bare and O-terminated V2CT. All in all, our results present a new method for
post etch removal of F-terminations from MXenes and introduces new
insights on the thermal stability of V2CT in a hydrated atmosphere.
Methods
Synthesis of
MAX Phase
The V2AlC MAX phase
was synthesized by a solid-state reaction of V (Sigma-Aldrich, 99.5%),
Al (Alfa Aesar, 99.5%), and graphite (Timcal Timrex, 99.5%) powders
in a molar ratio of 2:1.3:1. The powders were mixed by wet ball (YSZ)
milling in isopropanol overnight, dried in a rotavapor (Büchi
R210) and subsequently pressed into 1 g cylindrical pellets at 25
MPa. The pellets were annealed in flowing Ar atmosphere at 1500 °C
with a heating rate of 5 °C/min and a dwelling time of 4 h in
a tube furnace (Entech ETF 17). To prevent oxidation, the tube was
flushed with Ar for 4 h before the heat treatment. The synthesized
MAX phase powder was mortared manually in a steel mortar followed
by planetary milling at 300 rpm for 10 h in isopropanol with WC milling
balls and milling jar, to reduce the particle size and obtain a narrow
particle size distribution prior to etching (Figure S3).
Synthesis of MXene
The multilayered
V2CT MXene
particles were synthesized
by slowly adding 2 g of the synthesized V2AlC MAX phase
powder in a polypropylene beaker with 40 mL of a 48 wt % HF solution
over the time of 15 min. Thereafter, the beaker was partly covered
with parafilm and etched at room temperature for 72 h under constant
stirring. After the etching, the remaining powder dispersion was washed
several times by centrifugation in DI-water dispersions, until reaching
a pH > 5. In the end, the remaining dispersion was vacuum filtered
through a 0.22 μm pore sized PVDF filter paper, before the powder
was vacuum-dried at 120 °C for 12 h.
Hydrolyzation
The hydrolyzation of V2CT was performed by spreading
out 0.1 g of the MXene powder over 1–2 cm2 in an
alumina crucible boat before introducing it to a quartz tube furnace
(Figure S1). The furnace was sealed and
after a 2 h flushing step with a flow rate of Ar gas (99.999%) at
200 mL/min, the furnace was heated to a given temperature at a rate
of 200 °C/h and dwelled for 15 h with the same gas flow. To saturate
the annealing atmosphere with H2O after the flushing step,
Ar gas was bubbled through a DI water container at 80 °C prior
to entering the tube. With a saturated vapor pressure of 4.738 ×
104 Pa,[32] the water content
in the Ar/H2O mixture was 47%. The exhaust gas was bubbled
through a solution of 1 M Ca(NO3)2 in order
to prevent air leakage into the furnace and to capture HF formed during
the hydrolyzation.
Characterization Techniques
The
phase purity and crystalline
structure of the products were characterized by X-ray powder diffraction
(XRD, Bruker D8 Focus Diffractometer) using a Cu Kα radiation
source (λ = 0.15418 nm) and a 0.2 mm slit size. The XRD data
were collected in a 2θ-range from 5 to 75° with a step
size of 0.0143° and a 0.68 s step time. The Al2O3 residue obtained from the MAX phase synthesis was used as
a reference for the measurements, adjusting and scaling the spectra
relative to its (012) reflection located at 25.57°. Thermal stability
(TGA) of the MXene was measured with a NETZSCH STA 449 F3 Jupiter
analyzer by placing ∼15 mg of the powder in α-Al2O3 containers with lid, heating it up under an
Ar flow of 30 mL/min and a heating rate of 5 °C/min from RT to
300, 600, and 800 °C, with a dwelling time of 1 h. The particle
size of the MAX phase was determined by laser diffraction (PSD, Horiba
Partica LA-960) dispersing the powder in isopropanol to prevent agglomeration.
The surface morphology and microstructure were investigated by a field-emission
scanning electron microscope (FESEM, Carl Zeiss Ag – ULTRA
55) using an acceleration voltage of 5–10 kV. Energy dispersive
X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) was used to assess chemical composition using
an XFlash 4010 X-ray detector and an acceleration voltage of 10–15
kV. To obtain quantitative results, the average values from five or
more point scans were chosen and analyzed using the Bruker Esprit
1.9 software (Figure S10). X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy (XPS) was used for further information on chemical composition
of the powder. The XPS samples were made by gluing the MXene powder
to a Si wafer substrate using silver glue, and the measurements were
performed under ultrahigh vacuum using a SPECS XR-50 X-ray source
with a Mg anode and a VG ESCA MKIV with a CLAM4 analyzer. The satellite
peaks stemming from the Mg Kα3 and Kα4 were removed from the spectra before further data analysis were
completed (Figure S14). To compensate for
the static charge of the sample, the Si2p peak from the
substrate (99.3 eV) was used as an internal reference.[43] The fitting of the curves was completed in the
Igor Pro 7 software, using a Shirley background, and the quantification
was performed using known photoionization cross-section values.[60] The vibrational properties were investigated
by a WITec Alpha 300r Confocal Raman Microscope, using a 100×
objective, a 532 nm Ar laser and a laser power below 0.8 mW to prevent
oxidation of the material (Figure S6).
Electrochemical Measurements
To assess the electrochemical
performance of the materials, LiB half cells were prepared with the
MXene as the working electrode. These electrodes were processed by
mixing N-ethyl-2-pyrrolidone (NEP)-slurries with 10 wt.% PVDF binder,
10 wt.% carbon black as conductive additive and 80 wt.% of the active
material (V2CT and V2CT hydrolyzed at 300 °C). First, the carbon black and active material
were mixed for 10 min at 25 Hz in a shaker mill. Next, a premade PVDF-NEP
solution was added before the slurry was further diluted with additional
NEP to obtain a solid to liquid ratio of 1:6. The slurries were then
mixed by continuous shaking at 15 Hz for 30 min with a shaker ball
and drop cast onto precut circular Al current collectors. The electrodes
were dried at room temperature in a fume hood overnight before being
dried in vacuum at 60 °C for at least 4 h. This resulted in active
material loadings of 1.6–4.3 mg/cm2. The electrodes
were assembled into 2016-type coin cells in an argon-filled glovebox
(O2 ≤ 0.1 ppm, H2O ≤ 0.1 ppm)
using Li-foil as the counter electrode, glass microfiber (Whatman)
as the separator, and 110 μL 1 M LiPF6 in ethylene
carbonate and ethyl methyl carbonate with a volume ratio of 1:1 (EC/EMC
1:1) as the electrolyte. The assembled cells were galvanostatically
cycled at various specific currents (10 mA/g-100 mA/g) in a voltage
range of 0.5 to 3.5 V using a BioLogic BCS-805 cycler at a controlled
temperature of 20 °C.
Theoretical Calculations
Density
functional theory
calculations were done with VASP[61−64] using the PBEsol functional[65−67] and a plane-wave energy cutoff of 650 eV. Gamma-centered k-point
meshes with ∼0.2 Å–1 spacings were used
for solid structures. Geometries were relaxed until the forces on
the ions were below 10–4 eV/Å to obtain ground
state energies (E0(T = 0 K)). Vibrational properties of the solid
were calculated with Phonopy,[68] and those
for gaseous species were calculated by standard statistical mechanics.[69,70] Corresponding zero-point energies (ZPE) were calculated for the
solids and taken from the NIST-CCCBDB database for gaseous species.[71] The thermodynamic properties of chemical reactions
were evaluated following ref (72). Pseudopotentials, ΔG curves for
more reactions, and a full description of the computational workflow
are given in the Supporting Information.
Authors: Youbing Li; Hui Shao; Zifeng Lin; Jun Lu; Liyuan Liu; Benjamin Duployer; Per O Å Persson; Per Eklund; Lars Hultman; Mian Li; Ke Chen; Xian-Hu Zha; Shiyu Du; Patrick Rozier; Zhifang Chai; Encarnacion Raymundo-Piñero; Pierre-Louis Taberna; Patrice Simon; Qing Huang Journal: Nat Mater Date: 2020-04-13 Impact factor: 43.841
Authors: Yu Xie; Michael Naguib; Vadym N Mochalin; Michel W Barsoum; Yury Gogotsi; Xiqian Yu; Kyung-Wan Nam; Xiao-Qing Yang; Alexander I Kolesnikov; Paul R C Kent Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2014-04-21 Impact factor: 15.419