| Literature DB >> 35759493 |
Pauline O'Reilly1,2,3, Pauline Meskell1,2, Barbara Whelan1,2, Catriona Kennedy1,4, Bart Ramsay5,6, Alice Coffey1,2,3, Donal G Fortune2,7, Sarah Walsh8, Saskia Ingen-Housz-Oro9,10,11, Christopher B Bunker12, Donna M Wilson1,13, Isabelle Delaunois14, Liz Dore15, Siobhan Howard2,7, Sheila Ryan1,5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The existing evidence demonstrates that survivors of SJS/TEN have reported long-lasting psychological effects of their condition. Burns patients experience similar psychological effects. It is important to look at ways to help allay the psychological complications of SJS/TEN. As there is an absence of evidence on SJS/TEN psychotherapeutic interventions, it was judged to be beneficial to determine the evidence underpinning psychotherapeutic interventions used with burns patients. AIMS ANDEntities:
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35759493 PMCID: PMC9236256 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0270424
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.752
PICO review question and search terms.
|
| Adults (persons aged 18 and over) AND Burn patient or Burns or Burn injur* or Burn patient* or burns AND |
|
| Adults (persons aged 18 and over) diagnosed with Stevens-Johnson Syndrome or Epidermal Necrolysis or toxic or Stevens Johnson syndrome or Toxic Epidermal Necrolyses or Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis or TEN or Lyell’s Syndrome or Lyell Syndrome or Lyell’s Syndromes or Lyell’s disease |
|
| Psychotherapy or Psycholo* AND (care or intervention* or strateg* or manag* or technique* or approach or approaches or support or nursing or accompaniment or accompagnement or treatment or treating) or Psychotherap* AND (care or intervention* or strateg* or manag* or technique* or approach or approaches or support or nursing or accompaniment or accompagnement or treatment or treating) or counselling or counsellor or Patient centered nursing or Patient centred nursing or Patient centred care or Patient centered care or Holistic nursing or affirmative therapy or cognitive therapy or anxiety AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or emotion focused therapy or PTSD AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or Post traumatic stress disorder AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or Emotional support or Self-esteem AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or Body image AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or Panic AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or Stress And (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or Hypnosis or Distraction techniques or Meditation or Mindfulness or Diary writing or Fear AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) or Premorbid psychopathology AND (manag* or intervention* or support or technique*) |
|
| Intensive care unit or Critical care or Critical care nursing or Burn units or Acute phase or Short term or A&E or Critical care or Intensive care or ICU or ICUs or ITU or ITUs or Intensive Care Unit or Intensive Therapy Unit or Intensive Therapy Units or High dependency unit or HDU or Burn Center or Burn Centers or Burn Centre or Burn Centres or Burns Unit or Burns Units or Inpatient* |
|
| PTSD or post-traumatic stress symptoms or anxiety or depression or self-esteem or body image or pain or quality of life |
Fig 1PRISMA flow diagram for burns evidence (Population 1) [31].
Fig 2PRISMA flow diagram for SJS/TEN evidence (Population 2) [31].
Characteristics of the included quantitative studies.
| Author/Country | Aim/Purpose | Study Design | Study Participants | Outcome Measures | Method of Analyses | Key Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Delfani et al. [ | Compare the effects of muscle relaxation and mental imagery techniques on pain intensity in in patients with second degree burns | Quasi-experimental study | n = 135 (all male). Age range 20–45 years | VAS | One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), Chi-square test and one sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test | Both interventions viz. muscle relaxation and mental imagery significantly reduced pain intensity (p = 0.02; p < 0.01) in patients with a second-degree burn wound. |
| Fauerbach et al. [ | Evaluate the feasibility of conducting an RCT of the SMART (Safety, Meaning, Activation, and Resilience Training) intervention vs nondirective supportive psychotherapy (NDSP) in a sample of acutely hospitalized adult survivors of burn injury. | A proof-of-concept, parallel group RCT | n = 50 but due to drop out and missing data final sample size was n = 40. Age range 18–62 years | DTS | Descriptive statistics (range, median, SE) | The findings suggest that (1) it is feasible to conduct an RCT of brief CBT (i.e., SMART) vs NDSP in an acutely injured, hospitalized sample of survivors of burn injury and (2) brief CBT has the potential to yield clinically significant outcomes in this population. |
| Jafarizadeh et al. [ | Compare the effectiveness of hypnosis and ‘neutral hypnosis’ (as a placebo in the control group) in decreasing background burn pain | Quantitative—blinded, randomised, placebo-controlled study. | n = 60 (all male). Mean age 30.5±9.11 years | VAS | Descriptive statistics (mean ± standard deviation and frequency (%)), Kolmogorov-Smirnov test to identify the normal distribution of data, independent t-test, Chi-square test and Fisher’s exact test, Repeated measures ANOVA | No significant difference between groups in reduction in background pain intensity. Significant reduction in background pain quality and pain anxiety in the intervention group during the four hypnosis sessions (p<0.0005). |
| Berger et al. [ | Measure the influence of a new pain management including hypnosis in a critical care setting on pain intensity and the patients’ anticipation of pain before treatment. | Intervention study with matched controls | n = 23 + n = 23 historical controls. Age 36±14 years old. | VAS | Data provided as mean ±S.D., median and range. Comparison of baseline continuous variables between groups with one-way ANOVA, and non-parametric variables with x2 tests, or Wilcoxon test. Two-way ANOVA used to analyse evolution of opioid dose delivery over time. | The pain protocol using hypnosis resulted in the early delivery of higher opioid doses/24 h (p<0.0001) followed by a later reduction with lower pain scores (p<0.0001), less procedural related anxiety, less procedures under anaesthesia, reduced total grafting requirements (p = 0.014), and lower hospital costs per patient. |
| Najafi Ghezeljeh et al. [ | Evaluate the effects of massage and music on pain intensity, anxiety intensity and relaxation level in burn patients. | Randomized controlled clinical trial with factorial design | n = 240 divided into 4 following groups (i) control group (n = 60), (ii) massage group (n = 60), (iii) music group (n = 60) and (iv) music-plus-massage group (n = 60). Mean [standard deviation (SD)] age of the participants was 32.23 (8.43) years. | VAS | One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), Scheffe ad hoc test and Chi-square test were applied. Mean scores of changes in variables before and after intervention were considered to compare groups. Within group comparison (before and after intervention), paired t-test and Chi-square test were used. | There was a significant difference in the mean change scores of pain intensity between the control group and music group (p < .001), massage group (p < .001) and the music plus massage group (p < .001). |
| Mohammedi Fakhar et al. [ | Determine the effect of jaw relaxation on pain anxiety related to dressing changes in burn injuries. | A randomised clinical trial with a control group. | N = 100 (72 male, 28 female) | BSPAS | Descriptive statistics, chi-square test, dependent and independent t-test and Fisher’s exact test | Following jaw relaxation intervention (before dressing) there was a significant difference in the experimental group (p<0.05). Post-dressing pain anxiety of the experimental group was less than the control group (p<0.05). However, there was no significant difference between before and after dressing pain anxiety (after intervention) in the experimental group (p = 0.303). |
| Ozdemir & Sarritas [ | Determine the effect of yoga on self-esteem and body image of burn patients. | A quasi-experimental pre-test post-test with a control groups clinical trial. | N = 110 (52 male, 58 female) Age range 18–85 years. | The Body Image Scale | Chi-square test for comparison of percentage, mean, standard deviation, and control variables. Independent sample | After yoga practice, there was a statistically significant increase and improvement in the self-esteem (p < 0.05) and body image of the experimental group (p < 0.05). A statistically significant decline in the score average of pre-test and post-test of body image of the patients in the control group was observed (p<0.05). |
| Li et al. [ | Observe the effect of a rehabilitation intervention on the comprehensive | Randomized controlled design | n = 60 (n = 30 intervention group + n = 30 control group) (47 male, 13 female) Mean age±SD for control group 38.33±14.10 and intervention group 35.5±12.59. | BSHS-B | Descriptive statistical analysis used to determine means, ranges, and standard deviations of the variables, Student’s t-test used to compare comprehensive health levels and four sub-domains at the baseline between groups, and analysis of variance (ANOVA) was also used to determine whether there was an effect of intervention on comprehensive health level. | The rehabilitation intervention group had significantly better scores than the control group for comprehensive health (p<0.001), physical function(p<0.001), psychological function (p<0.001), social function (p<0.001) and general health (p<0.001). |
| Morris et al. [ | Ascertain the feasibility and potential effect of a Virtual Reality system used in conjunction with analgesia, on reducing pain and anxiety in adult burn patients undergoing physiotherapy treatment, compared to analgesia alone. | A randomized (condition only), single-blind (assessor blinded only), single-subject, pre–post experimental case series (within-subject) design | n = 11 (3 female, 8 male) Median age 33 | NPRS | Box-and-whisker plot method, Chi-square tests as well as the Student’s paired t-test were used to analyse data. | A marginal (p = 0.06) to insignificant (p = 0.13) difference between the two sessions (analgesia with VR and analgesia without VR) in reducing pain was found. No significant difference (p = 0.58) was found between the two sessions (analgesia with VR and analgesia without VR) for anxiety. |
| Park et al. [ | Evaluate the effects of Relaxation Breathing on procedural pain and anxiety during burn dressing changes. | A quasi-experimental, pre-test-post-test comparison group design without random assignment to groups. | N = 60 (n = 30 experimental group and n = 30 control group) (29 male, 31 female) | VAS | Descriptive statistics, including mean, median, and standard deviation (SD), were obtained to describe the sociodemographic and burn-specific variables. The homogeneity test was used to detect any significant group differences in the demographic data and pre-test measures. | The pain scores significantly differed between the 2 groups after intervention (RB group vs. control group, P = .01) and over time (pretest vs. posttest, P = .001). The anxiety scores significantly differed between the 2 groups (P = .01) and over time (P = .02). |
| Fauerbach et al. [ | Determine if contradictory coping messages would lead to an approach–avoidance coping conflict and to determine if experiment-induced coping conflict is also associated with higher distress. | Randomised, within-subject crossover design | n = 59 (45 male, 14 female) | IES | Analyses were conducted to test for pre-test differences using analysis of variance (ANOVA), Pearson’s w2 statistic, or Fisher’s exact test, as appropriate | Participants in the process-then-suppress condition, relative to the suppress-then-process condition, were significantly more likely to exhibit approach–avoidance coping conflict. Approach–avoidance coping conflict was associated with greater re-experiencing symptoms. The order of coping skill training can influence treatment outcome, success of coping methods, and overall levels of distress. |
| Wiechman et al. [ | Determine the effects of hypnosis on postburn itch and pain relief. | A andomized control trial with a control group. | N = 27 (62% Caucasian & 60% male) | NPRS | Not outlined | There were no significant differences between the groups on any outcome measure and both groups demonstrated improved pain and itch over time. There was a large effect size for Itch as measured by the NRS (intensity) and the 5D Itch Scale from baseline to 1 month. |
| Seyedoshohadaee et al. [ | Determine the effect of a short-term training course by nurses on body image in patients with burn injuries. | A semi-experimental single-group survey | n = 130 (65 | SWAP | Descriptive statistical analysis used to determine means, paired sample t-test, used to outline the difference between the mean scores of body image before and after educational interventions | The mean scores of the body image of patients before and after the intervention were 49.44±11.39 and 41.63±11.89, respectively. There was a significant difference between the mean scores of body image before and after educational interventions (T = 6.013, P≤0.001). |
| Mamashli et al. [ | Determine the effect of implementing interventions based on mental empowerment through multimedia education in burn patients | A randomized clinical trial with a control group | n = 50 control group; n = 50 intervention group (44% female and 56% male) | BSHS-B | Descriptive and inferential statistics (Chi-square and independent and paired t tests for the distribution of normal variables), Fisher’s exact test, nonparametric tests e.g., Mann-Whitney, Wilcoxon and Friedman test and Dunn test, with Bonferroni’s correction, Spearman correlation coefficient | Before interventions, the mean of mental dimension in intervention and control groups were 2.08±0.59 and 1.64±0.47, respectively (p<0.001). Three and six months after the Intervention, they were 3.37±0.93 and 2.24±0.4, 4.11±0.74 and 2.75±0.58, respectively (p<0.001). |
| Pruskowski et al. [ | Determine the impact of a therapy dog programme | Cross sectional study | n = 14 patients and n = 23 staff | None used | Not outlined | Most patients reported improved pain and anxiety after working with the therapy dogs. |
Characteristics of the included qualitative studies.
| Author/Country | Aim/Purpose | Study Design | Study Participants | Method of Analyses | Key Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Badger and Royse [ | Explore burns survivors’ descriptions of compassionate health care to explicate and better understand this concept within the context of burn care | Qualitative focus group interviews | n = 31 (18 female, 13 male). Age range 23–70 years | Qualitative thematic data analysis | Three primary themes identified with subthemes. 1) respect the person (subthemes: establishing an empathic connection, restoring control through choice, providing individualized care, and going above and beyond), 2) communication (subthemes: interpersonal and informational), and 3) provision of competent care. |
| Kornhaber et al. [ | Explore burn survivors’ experiences of providing and receiving inpatient peer support to develop an in-depth understanding of the influence during the rehabilitation journey. | A descriptive phenomenological methodology. | n = 21 (20 male, 1 female). Average age 44 years ranging from 21–65 years. | Transcripts analysed using Colaizzi’s seven steps method of data analysis. | Inpatient peer support had both a positive and negative impact on the rehabilitation journey. Findings demonstrated that peer support assisted with fostering reassurance, hope and motivation in burn rehabilitation. Inappropriate matching of peer supporters and bad timing in providing the support could impact negatively on participants. |
Theme 1 empirically supported psychotherapeutic treatments.
| Theme 1 | Empirically supported psychotherapeutic treatments | ||
|---|---|---|---|
|
| 1. Relaxation Therapy | 2. Hypnosis | 3. Cognitive behavioural therapy; Virtual reality |
|
| These techniques reduce burn patients’ pain. Mental imagery had more reducing effect on pain intensity. | Hypnosis for reduction of background pain and pain anxiety in patients with burns | CBT—Safety, Meaning, Activation, and Resilience Training (SMART) protocol |
|
| A significant difference in the mean score of pain intensity after dressing on the second day of burn between the control and the relaxation groups and mental imagery groups. | Hypnosis is generally effective for the treatment of pain and pain anxiety, which is consistent with many studies confirming the effect not only on burns but also on many other types of acute or chronic diseases | CBT can target maladaptive ruminations, a core cognitive component of depression. |
|
| [ | [ | [ |
Theme 2 alternative psychotherapeutic treatments.
|
| Alternative psychotherapeutic treatments | |
| Category | 1. Training programmes | 2. Therapeutic Relationships |
| Sub-category | Music & Massage | Compassionate care |
|
| Improvement in pain and anxiety intensity with increased levels of relaxation | 1. Empathic connection—attentive listeners, seeking to understand the survivors’ experiences and concerns, seeing someone as a human being and try and understand what their experience could |
| Reference | [ | [ |