Lutz Adam1,2, Eva Müller3, Kai Ludwig4, Simon Klenk1,2, Daniel Lauster5, Susanne Liese6,7, Andreas Herrmann5, Christian P R Hackenberger1,2. 1. Leibniz-Forschungsinstitut für Molekulare Pharmakologie (FMP), Robert-Rössle-Straße 10, 13125 Berlin, Germany. 2. Institut für Chemie, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Brook-Taylor-Street 2, 12489 Berlin, Germany. 3. Institut für translationale HIV Forschung, Universitätsklinikum Essen, Virchowstree 171, 45147 Essen, Germany. 4. Forschungszentrum für Elektronenmikroskopie und Gerätezentrum BioSupraMol, Institut für Chemie und Biochemie, Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin 14195, Germany. 5. Institut für Chemie und Biochemie, Freie Universität Berlin, Arnimallee 22, 14195 Berlin, Germany. 6. Max-Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems, Nöthnitzer Street 38, Dresden 01187, Germany. 7. Institut für Physik, Universität Augsburg, Augsburg 86159, Germany.
Abstract
Multiple conjugation of virus-binding ligands to multivalent carriers is a prominent strategy to construct highly affine virus binders for the inhibition of viral entry into host cells. In a previous study, we introduced rationally designed sialic acid conjugates of bacteriophages (Qβ) that match the triangular binding site geometry on hemagglutinin spike proteins of influenza A virions, resulting in effective infection inhibition in vitro and in vivo. In this work, we demonstrate that even partially sialylated Qβ conjugates retain the inhibitory effect despite reduced activity. These observations not only support the importance of trivalent binding events in preserving high affinity, as supported by computational modeling, but also allow us to construct heterobifunctional modalities. Capsids carrying two different sialic acid ligand-linker structures showed higher viral inhibition than their monofunctional counterparts. Furthermore, capsids carrying a fluorescent dye in addition to sialic acid ligands were used to track their interaction with cells. These findings support exploring broader applications as multivalent inhibitors in the future.
Multiple conjugation of virus-binding ligands to multivalent carriers is a prominent strategy to construct highly affine virus binders for the inhibition of viral entry into host cells. In a previous study, we introduced rationally designed sialic acid conjugates of bacteriophages (Qβ) that match the triangular binding site geometry on hemagglutinin spike proteins of influenza A virions, resulting in effective infection inhibition in vitro and in vivo. In this work, we demonstrate that even partially sialylated Qβ conjugates retain the inhibitory effect despite reduced activity. These observations not only support the importance of trivalent binding events in preserving high affinity, as supported by computational modeling, but also allow us to construct heterobifunctional modalities. Capsids carrying two different sialic acid ligand-linker structures showed higher viral inhibition than their monofunctional counterparts. Furthermore, capsids carrying a fluorescent dye in addition to sialic acid ligands were used to track their interaction with cells. These findings support exploring broader applications as multivalent inhibitors in the future.
Hemagglutinin
(HA), the most abundant spike protein of influenza
A and B viruses, is a promising target for antivirals to complement
currently licensed therapeutics and reduce the risk of emerging drug-resistant
strains.[1] Specific binding of an inhibitor
to HA can be achieved by mimicking its natural host cell receptor, i.e., terminal sialic acid (SA) residues of the glycocalyx,
through the multivalent presentation of N-acetylneuraminic
acid (Neu5Ac) derivatives or sialyl oligosaccharides. Alternatively,
peptides[2] or aptamers[3] have been used to furnish multivalent conjugates with antiviral
activity in vitro and in vivo. Among
SA-based HA-binding inhibitors, different concepts regarding special
prearrangement of carbohydrates have been explored. While some approaches
rely on rather flexible scaffolds, e.g., linear polymers[4−9] or mostly arbitrary structures, such as hyperbranched or dendritic
polymers,[4,10] gold nanoparticles,[11] proteins,[12−14] nanogels,[15] virus-like
particles,[16] carbon nanostructures,[17,18] phospholipid micelles,[19,20] or lipid bilayers,[21] others employ a rational design to tailor SA
positions to match the triangular HA receptor binding site (RBS) geometry.
For instance, the architecture of a tripodal inhibitor with a peptide
scaffold by Waldmann et al. was inspired by detailed in silico analysis of the HA head domain topology.[22] Other systems achieve accurate spacing of carbohydrate ligands using
cyclic peptides[23] or PNA–DNA oligomers[24] as structural elements.Recently, our
laboratory has contributed to the rational engineering
of influenza inhibitors by introducing structurally defined Qβ-sialoside
conjugates as SA-based HA inhibitors.[25] We used an engineered version of the highly symmetrical Qβ-bacteriophage-carrying
homopropargylglycine (Hpg) at specific positions in the capsid protein
(Qβ[Hpg] (1), see Scheme ) to immobilize azide-containing Neu5Ac derivatives via variable ethylene glycol (EG) linkers (Sia1 (2), Sia3 (3), Sia8 (4) for n = 1, 3, 8 according to Scheme , respectively) using Cu-catalyzed alkyne–azide
cycloaddition (CuAAC). Thereby, we precisely matched the triple-symmetric
geometrical arrangement of the HA RBS and were able to demonstrate
potent neutralization of various influenza strains in vitro and in vivo by preventing binding to host cells.
In our previous study, conjugates with shorter linkers generally showed
higher inhibitory potency than those with longer linkers, which can
likely be attributed to their lower flexibility and therefore higher
fidelity to the prearranged configuration. Data obtained by cryogenic
transmission electron microscopy (cryoTEM) and microscale thermophoresis-based
affinity studies with HA suggested that individual functionalized
capsids tend to interact with single HA trimers, thus supporting the
notion of a trivalent binding mode. However, multivalent interactions
must be conceived as dynamic complexes composed of individually associating
and dissociating receptor–ligand pairs. Consequently, the maximum
possible valency is not always equal to the functional valency, which
is the valency in the most probable binding state.[26] So far, we had no comprehensive experimental evidence to
evaluate the contribution of mono- and bivalent interactions to the
overall affinity of Qβ sialosides. The same report applied a
statistical mechanics model, which quantitatively predicted a parameter
of HA affinity, the equilibrium binding constant KD, for various Qβ sialosides assuming exclusively
trivalent interactions between the capsids and HA. These values showed
a strong correlation (nearly identical values) with the binding inhibitory
constant K (sometimes
referred to as the hemagglutination inhibition titer), which is a
common measure for the potency of influenza inhibitors and is obtained
experimentally by the hemagglutination inhibition (HAI) test (for
further information see refs (27−29)).
Scheme 1
Reaction
Scheme for the Preparation of (A) Fully and (B) Partially
Monofunctionalized Qβ Sialosides by CuAAC. (C) One-Pot CuAAC
Synthesis of Bifunctional Qβ Sialosides with Different EG-Linker
Lengths
THPTA: Tris(3-hydroxypropyltriazolylmethyl)amine.
Protein structure of Qβ-bacteriophage capsid (protein data bank
(PDB) #1QBE) published in ref (26).[26]
Reaction
Scheme for the Preparation of (A) Fully and (B) Partially
Monofunctionalized Qβ Sialosides by CuAAC. (C) One-Pot CuAAC
Synthesis of Bifunctional Qβ Sialosides with Different EG-Linker
Lengths
THPTA: Tris(3-hydroxypropyltriazolylmethyl)amine.
Protein structure of Qβ-bacteriophage capsid (protein data bank
(PDB) #1QBE) published in ref (26).[26]In
the current study, we first set out to examine whether the quality
of prediction holds up in scenarios where trivalent binding is limited
to gain more insight into the binding pattern. To this end, we prepared
a library of partially functionalized Qβ sialosides using decreasing
amounts of sialic acid azide linkers in CuAAC reactions, which resulted
in unoccupied positions in the triangular prearrangement of the SA
ligands. Afterward, we compared their inhibitory potencies to the
theoretical values. In doing so, we ensured that the probability of
mono- and bivalent binding motives increases with decreasing degree
of functionalization (DF). This would not be the case for mixtures
of fully and nonsialylated capsids with the same overall DF, for instance
a 1:1 mixture of capsids with DF = 100 and 0% to achieve an overall
50% of occupied conjugation sites.Building on insights we gained
during this study, we furthermore
constructed several heterobifunctional influenza inhibitors with different
SA linkers or fluorescent labels attached. We used these modalities
to study the fate of Qβ sialosides in a cellular environment,
which we could not address in the previous publication. Of particular
interest was to unravel whether capsids would be taken up by cells via nonspecific interactions with the cell surface or in
complex with influenza viruses.
Results and Discussion
Partially functionalized Qβ sialosides were prepared from
Qβ[Hpg] (1) following a modified version of the
CuAAC protocol published previously.[25] Here,
we controlled the DF by the amount of SA azide added to the reaction
(Scheme B and Table ) (see Materials and Methods). Capsids with linker lengths n = 1, 3, and 8 and DF values ranging from ca. 20 to 100%
were subsequently examined for HA binding of influenza A virus (IAV)
H3N2 strain X31 (A/X31) in an HAI test (see Materials
and Methods). The determined inhibition constant K reflects the lowest inhibitor concentration
to achieve 100% hemagglutination inhibition.[27−29] In all cases,
an exponential increase of K was observed with decreasing DF. Remarkably, we found considerable
inhibitory potency even at a DF of only 20% for all functionalized
capsid variants independent of their EG-linker lengths. However, the
increase was less steeper for longer linker variants (Figure ). It can be hypothesized that
this results from the ability of longer linkers to form alternative
triangular configurations to compensate for unoccupied sugar positions.
Further repeated measurements using capsid variants with linker lengths n = 3 and 8 from the same stock solution lead to equal K values from which no standard
deviation could be determined (see Supporting Information). This is not uncommon as replicate K values from the HAI assay typically
only differ by a factor of 2, which becomes more prominent for lower
affine compounds (e.g., Sia8 with 20% DF).[29] We surmise, as illustrated in Figure , that short and inflexible
linkers allow trivalent interactions between capsids and HA only at
faces where each conjugation site is occupied by SA. Instead, longer
linkers could make it possible to rescue trivalent binding by substituting
a vacant SA position with SA from a neighboring face.
Table 1
Obtained DF in Qβ-Sialoside
Bioconjugations in Relation to Input Azide per Hpg
SA azide
equivalents/Hpg
obtained DF [%]
product number
Sia1 (2)
15
100
5a
1
85
5b
0.75
67
5c
0.5
45
5d
0.25
19
5e
Sia3 (3)
15
100
6a
5
93
6b
3.3
83
6c
1.7
53
6d
1.3
35
6e
0.7
21
6f
Sia8 (4)
25
100
7a
5
92
7b
3.3
69
7c
1.7
34
7d
1.3
27
7e
1
23
7f
0.7
15
7g
Sia1 (2)/Sia3 (3)
7.5/7.5
39/61
8
Sia1 (2)/Sia8 (4)
7.5/7.5
49/51
9
Sia1 (2)/TAMRA-N3 (8)
15/0.075
97/3 (±2%)
11a
15/0.15
90/7 (3% residual Hpg)
11b
Figure 1
(A–C)
Comparison of experimental K values of HAI test against influenza A virus
(IAV) strain A/X31 (markers) and their theoretically predicted progressions
for Qβ sialosides of different linker lengths in relation to
DF. n represents the number of EG units in the SA
linker. Dashed lines represent theoretical K progressions for quadratic (red) and cubic
(green) proportionalities between K and DF. For n = 1, the slope of the experimental
values is in good agreement with a cubic relation between K and DF, whereas for n = 3 and 8, the decline is more in line with a quadratic
dependency. Data points represent mean values from either two (n = 3 and 8, green and blue) or three (n = 1, black) replicate experiments. Numerical values for experimentally
obtained K are given
in the Supporting Information. (D, E) Effective
number of matching SA triplets (D) and SA doublets (E) in relation
to DF. All values are given relative to the fully functionalized capsid.
The ratio of triplet motives available for virus binding declines
in an approximately cubic relation to DF for n =
1 and quadratically for n = 8, while n = 3 shows an intermediate behavior. In contrast, the ratio of available
doublet motives scales in a quadratic relation to DF for all linker
lengths.
Figure 2
Triangular arrangements of SA azides on the
capsid surface. Blue
spheres indicate Hpg side chain positions. Red triangles indicate
HA RBS geometry. Left: arrangement with minimal distance to Hpg side
chains, requiring no linker flexibility. Right: alternative triangular
arrangement for a more flexible linker, which substitutes one SA from
the minimal distance arrangement with that of a neighboring position.
A 1.5 nm (light blue circles) approximately is the most probable end-to-end
distance of an EG(8) linker.[25] Protein
structure of Qβ-bacteriophage capsid (PDB #1QBE) published in
ref (31).[31]
(A–C)
Comparison of experimental K values of HAI test against influenza A virus
(IAV) strain A/X31 (markers) and their theoretically predicted progressions
for Qβ sialosides of different linker lengths in relation to
DF. n represents the number of EG units in the SA
linker. Dashed lines represent theoretical K progressions for quadratic (red) and cubic
(green) proportionalities between K and DF. For n = 1, the slope of the experimental
values is in good agreement with a cubic relation between K and DF, whereas for n = 3 and 8, the decline is more in line with a quadratic
dependency. Data points represent mean values from either two (n = 3 and 8, green and blue) or three (n = 1, black) replicate experiments. Numerical values for experimentally
obtained K are given
in the Supporting Information. (D, E) Effective
number of matching SA triplets (D) and SA doublets (E) in relation
to DF. All values are given relative to the fully functionalized capsid.
The ratio of triplet motives available for virus binding declines
in an approximately cubic relation to DF for n =
1 and quadratically for n = 8, while n = 3 shows an intermediate behavior. In contrast, the ratio of available
doublet motives scales in a quadratic relation to DF for all linker
lengths.Triangular arrangements of SA azides on the
capsid surface. Blue
spheres indicate Hpg side chain positions. Red triangles indicate
HA RBS geometry. Left: arrangement with minimal distance to Hpg side
chains, requiring no linker flexibility. Right: alternative triangular
arrangement for a more flexible linker, which substitutes one SA from
the minimal distance arrangement with that of a neighboring position.
A 1.5 nm (light blue circles) approximately is the most probable end-to-end
distance of an EG(8) linker.[25] Protein
structure of Qβ-bacteriophage capsid (PDB #1QBE) published in
ref (31).[31]To follow up on this
assumption of binding behavior as a function
of linker length, we aimed to obtain the relation between the inhibitory
constant K and the degree
of functionalization theoretically and to compare them with the experimental
data to gain insight into the phage binding mode. We noted that, for
a fixed linker length, the probability to bind to a SA triplet scales
aswhile the probability to bind to two neighboring
SA scales aswith d and d̅ being the distance that has to be bridged by the
linker in the trivalent
and divalent binding modes, respectively, n being
the polymerization index of the EG linker, and r0 = 5 Å.[30] Based on these binding
probabilities, we define the effective number of matching SA triplets
and SA doublets aswhere we sum over all possible
SA triplets
and SA doublets of a capsid, weighted with the appropriate binding
probability. To determine Ntri,eff and Ndi,eff numerically, we generated random configurations
of partially functionalized capsids and averaged over 500 configurations.
In Figure D,E, Ntri,eff and Ndi,eff are shown relative to the fully functionalized capsid in dependence
of DF. Figure D shows
a scaling of Ntri,eff ∼ DF3 for short linkers with n = 1, while longer
linkers transition to Ntri,eff ∼
DF2. In qualitative terms, the number of possibilities
for trivalent binding decreases more strongly for short linkers (n = 1) compared to longer linkers (n =
3 or 8). This behavior is consistent with the possibility of longer
linkers to make use of irregular triangular configurations. For the
divalent case, we find Ndi,eff ∼
DF2 independent of the linker length (Figure E). For short linkers (n = 1), tri- and divalent binding show a clearly distinct
scaling behavior. In contrast, the number of effective binding possibilities
for longer linkers (n = 3 and 8) is approximately
proportional to DF2 for both tri- and divalent binding.To relate these findings to the inhibitory constants K shown in Figure A–C, we note that K in trivalent and divalent binding modes
is inversely proportional to Ntri,eff and Ndi,eff, respectively. Hence, if the binding
mode of capsids with a short linker (n = 1) is dominated
by trivalent binding, the inhibitory constant should scale as K ∼ DF–3, which is confirmed by Figure A. The scaling behavior here clearly shows that divalent
bonds contribute only negligibly. The interpretation of the scaling
behavior for longer linkers (n = 3 and 8) is more
complex, since the slopes found in Figure B,C scale roughly with K ∼ DF–2, which
is in agreement with both divalent and trivalent binding. We therefore
restate a result from our previous study, finding that trivalent binding
is the dominant binding mode in fully functionalized capsids.[25] Now, the scaling behavior in Figure D,E shows that the ratio between
tri- and divalent binding for long linkers Ntri,eff/Ndi,eff ≈ DF2/DF2 ≈ 1 can be approximated as independent
of DF. The dominance of trivalent binding is therefore preserved even
for lower DF.Since all tested variants of sialylated capsids,
by interpolation
of the obtained data, retained K values in the range of 1–10 nM down to 50% sialylation,
we hypothesized that it should be possible to employ a portion of
the Hpg conjugation sites for the attachment of alternative ligands
or fluorescent labels without drastically compromising the inhibitory
activity. In our previous study, we found that the inhibition potential
of phages toward human pathogenic IAV strains with different HA types
depends not only on the SA receptor (SA vs 2,3-sialyllactose vs 2,6-sialyllactose) but also on the linker length. We
concluded that the distance of the SA RBS is slightly different among
different HA types.[25] Therefore, we were
interested in combining different SA-based ligands on the same capsid
to engineer broad-spectrum IAV inhibitors.In a convenient one-pot
protocol, we simply combined two distinct
SA azides at equal ratios in our CuAAC conjugations to aim for DF
of ∼50% for each ligand. Mixed conjugates of the previously
shown Sia[n] derivatives (Qβ[Sia1&3] (8) and Qβ[Sia1&8] (9)) were prepared
in this fashion (Scheme C) and analyzed by mass spectrometry to determine the relative loadings
of individual sugars (see the Supporting Information). Inhibition of influenza strain A/X31 by these mixed conjugates
was again demonstrated in a HAI test (Figure ). Interestingly, Qβ[Sia1&3] (8) showed a higher inhibitory potency (K = 0.16 nM) than either of the monofunctional
capsids (K = 0.25 nM
for Qβ[Sia1(100%)] and K = 1.5 nM for Qβ[Sia3(100%)]), hinting at a possible
cooperative effect between these ligands. The K value of Qβ[Sia1&8] (9) (K = 1.4 nM) is in
between those of its monofunctional analogues (K = 0.25 nM for Qβ[Sia1(100%)] and K = 4.4 nM for Qβ[Sia8(100%)]).
These first inhibition studies can be regarded as a proof of concept
for the feasibility and activity of mixed Qβ sialosides. As
a future perspective, it would be of interest to investigate the inhibitory
range of mixed capsids against a wider panel of influenza strains
and introduce other ligands such as sialyllactose oligosaccharides
or ligands for other influenza surface proteins, which is currently
ongoing in our laboratories.
Figure 3
HAI test of mixed linker length Qβ sialosides
against influenza
A/X31. K values for
DF = 50% were interpolated from a regression function of the experimental
values shown in Figure (see Materials and Methods). Other data
points represent mean values of two (Qβ[Sia3(100%)], Qβ[Sia8(100%)],
and mixed capsids) or three (Qβ[Sia1(100%)]) replicate experiments.
Numerical values for experimentally obtained K are given in the Supporting Information.
HAI test of mixed linker length Qβ sialosides
against influenza
A/X31. K values for
DF = 50% were interpolated from a regression function of the experimental
values shown in Figure (see Materials and Methods). Other data
points represent mean values of two (Qβ[Sia3(100%)], Qβ[Sia8(100%)],
and mixed capsids) or three (Qβ[Sia1(100%)]) replicate experiments.
Numerical values for experimentally obtained K are given in the Supporting Information.Having established a
one-pot protocol to obtain Qβ capsids
with two different labels, we next aimed to synthesize fluorescent
Qβ sialosides to monitor their interactions with viruses and
living cells. The fluorescent glycoconjugates were obtained by formally
replacing a small amount of the SA in a given Qβ sialoside with
tetramethylrhodamine (TAMRA) as a fluorescent dye. We envisioned that
this approach is favorable over unspecific fluorescent labeling reagents,
such as succinimide esters targeting other reactive amino acids on
the capsid surface, which would yield less well-defined and less reproducible
products.Consequently, we conjugated Sia1 (2)
and CuAAC-compatible
TAMRA azide (10) (for synthesis, see the Supporting Information) concomitantly to Qβ[Hpg]
(1) by combining them at different ratios in one-pot
CuAAC reactions (Scheme ). A ratio of Sia1 (2)/TAMRA azide (10)
= 199:1 reproducibly afforded conjugates with 3% (±2%) of Hpg
side chains modified with the dye and full conversion of the remaining
positions with SA (Table , entry 1). Higher dye loadings led to incomplete conversion
of alkyne functionalities and increasingly hydrophobic products, which
aggregated over time and could no longer be analyzed by LC-MS to determine
the DF of the sugar and dye (Table , entries 2 and 3).
Scheme 2
Reaction Scheme for One-Pot CuAAC Synthesis of Bifunctional
Qβ
Sialosides with TAMRA Fluorescent Label
For product DF in relation
to
reagent ratio, see Table .
Table 2
SA and Dye Loadings of Bifunctional
Qβ Sialosides as a Result of Different Reagent Ratios in CuAAC
entry
ratio Sia1:TAMRA-N3
product number
DF (Sia1)
DF (TAMRA)
DF (Hpg)
1
199:1
11a
97% (±2%)
3% (±2%)
0%
2
99:1
11b
90%
7%
3%
3
49:1 and lower
incomplete conversion:
Product
too hydrophobic for LC-MS analysis.
Reaction Scheme for One-Pot CuAAC Synthesis of Bifunctional
Qβ
Sialosides with TAMRA Fluorescent Label
For product DF in relation
to
reagent ratio, see Table .To assess the aggregation propensity
of fluorescently labeled capsids,
a Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)] (11a) sample was analyzed
using dynamic light scattering (DLS). Freshly prepared, fully sialylated
Qβ[Sia1(100%)] (5a) and a visibly aggregated, TAMRA-labeled
Qβ sialoside obtained with a Sia1:TAMRA-N3 ratio
of 4:1 were used as reference samples. Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) showed a uniform population of separate particles
directly after preparation and 4% aggregation after 1 month of storage
at 4 °C (Figure A,B). Virus binding of fresh Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)] (11a) was furthermore verified by cryoTEM upon incubation with
influenza strain A/X31 (Figure C).
Figure 4
DLS spectra of Qβ sialosides. (A) Light scattering intensity
distribution of reference samples. Freshly prepared Qβ[Sia1(100%)]
(5a) (green curve) shows a uniform population of particles
with a diameter of 30 nm, which corresponds in size to the wild-type
Qβ bacteriophage.[32] Visibly aggregated
Qβ sialosides with high TAMRA loading (red curve) show a second
population of aggregates of ca. 1 μm diameter. (B) Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) showed 4% aggregation after 1 month of storage
at 4 °C. (C) CryoTEM micrograph of Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) densely decorating influenza A virions (A/X31).
DLS spectra of Qβ sialosides. (A) Light scattering intensity
distribution of reference samples. Freshly prepared Qβ[Sia1(100%)]
(5a) (green curve) shows a uniform population of particles
with a diameter of 30 nm, which corresponds in size to the wild-type
Qβ bacteriophage.[32] Visibly aggregated
Qβ sialosides with high TAMRA loading (red curve) show a second
population of aggregates of ca. 1 μm diameter. (B) Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) showed 4% aggregation after 1 month of storage
at 4 °C. (C) CryoTEM micrograph of Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) densely decorating influenza A virions (A/X31).Next, we examined Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) for interaction with A549 cells by fluorescence
microscopy (Figure ). The capsids showed
no uptake or apparent interaction, both with healthy and influenza-infected
cells. When the virus was preincubated with the inhibitor, we observed
the formation of virus–phage aggregates, which also did not
interact with cells. For this experiment, we used a more recent seasonal
IAV H3N2 strain A/Panama/2007/99 (A/Panama). We have shown recently
that Qβ[Sia1] efficiently binds and inhibits host cell entry
of this strain comparable to that of A/X31.[25] In future experiments, we plan to use fluorescent Qβ sialosides
to study their interactions with other biological environments, such
as the respiratory mucus layer. Since mucus can act as a barrier for
drug delivery, such studies may yield valuable insights into the ability
of Qβ sialosides to penetrate the mucus layer and furthermore
provide valuable tool compounds to probe mucus transport in general.
Figure 5
Interaction
study of Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)] (green) with
A549 cells. Left: the capsids distribute evenly around healthy cells.
No cellular uptake could be observed after incubation of capsids with
cells for 20 min at 37 °C. Middle: the capsids show no attachment
to A549 cells with bound DiD-labeled viruses A/Panama (red). Cells
were preincubated with viruses at 4 °C before addition of capsids.
Upon supply of capsids, the cells were incubated for 20 min at 37
°C. Black arrows indicate DiD-labeled influenza virions that
have not been internalized into cells. The virus loses its label upon
membrane fusion during infection. Right: Virions (A/Panama) and Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) form aggregates (yellow) upon preincubation that
do not interact with A549 cells.
Interaction
study of Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)] (green) with
A549 cells. Left: the capsids distribute evenly around healthy cells.
No cellular uptake could be observed after incubation of capsids with
cells for 20 min at 37 °C. Middle: the capsids show no attachment
to A549 cells with bound DiD-labeled viruses A/Panama (red). Cells
were preincubated with viruses at 4 °C before addition of capsids.
Upon supply of capsids, the cells were incubated for 20 min at 37
°C. Black arrows indicate DiD-labeled influenza virions that
have not been internalized into cells. The virus loses its label upon
membrane fusion during infection. Right: Virions (A/Panama) and Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(11a) form aggregates (yellow) upon preincubation that
do not interact with A549 cells.
Conclusions
In this study, we have shown that a partial reduction of the Sia-DF
of Qβ phages keeps the inhibitory effect of influenza virus
binding to cells although at a reduced level. The good coincidence
of our experimental data with those of a detailed computational modeling
strongly suggests that at least a trivalent interaction between functionalized
phages and viruses is necessary for binding. Thus, both the DF as
well as the linker length are the limiting factors of phage association
with the viral spike proteins.Nevertheless, retention of the
inhibitory effect even at reduced
DF offers the opportunity to further advance our previously introduced
monofunctionalized inhibitors[25] and generate
heterofunctional Qβ phages. We took advantage of this by covalently
labeling Sia-functionalized phages with a fluorescent dye at very
low DF and track interaction of those phages with viruses and host
cells. The absence of cellular uptake of phages further strengthens
their applicability as extracellularly active antivirals. Even more
important, we generated phages carrying two SA with different linker
lengths and observed an even higher inhibition potential with respect
to monofunctional phages, indicating a cooperative effect by binding
to various SA receptors on the phage surface. Thus, these heterofunctional
multivalent structures have strong potential for preventing the interaction
with host cells for a broader range of viruses. These studies are
fundamental for further development not only of the phages used here,
but also, in general, for the application of multivalent inhibitors.
To prevent rapid emergence of resistance, the use of heterofunctional
multivalent inhibitors, i.e., scaffold occupation
with ligands that inhibit different targets of the pathogen simultaneously,
is an alternative. For example, HA and neuraminidase (NA) can be inhibited
simultaneously on the surface of IAV.[16,33]
Materials and
Methods
Chemicals and Solvents
Chemicals and solvents were
obtained from various chemical vendors in reagent grade. All materials
were used without further purification unless specified otherwise.
SA azides and Qβ[Hpg] (1) were obtained as described
in the literature.[25]
Virus Strains
Virus strains used were influenza A/X31
(H3N2), which is a laboratory strain reassorted from A/Aichi/2/68
(H3N2) and A/Puerto Rico/8/1934 (H1N1) (in short A/X31), and A/Panama/2007/99
(H3N2) (in short A/Panama).
Analytical LC-MS
LC-MS analysis
of Qβ sialosides
to determine DF was conducted using an ACQUITY H-class instrument
(Waters Corporation) equipped with an ACQUITY UPLC-Protein BEH C4,
300 Å, 1.7 μm, 2.1 mm × 50 mm column (Waters Corporation)
and a XEVO G2-XS QTof mass analyzer (Waters Corporation). The liquid
phase consisted of mixtures of acetonitrile and water as described
above, containing, instead of TFA, 0.01% formic acid (FA) (≥99.0%,
Optima LC/MS Grade, Fisher Chemical). The obtained data were processed
using the software MassLynx (version 4.1, Waters Corporation) and
protein spectra were deconvoluted by the included MaxEnt1 algorithm.The protein (10 μg) was incubated at 95 °C for 5–10
min and subsequently mixed with an equal volume of 100 mM triethylammonium
bicarbonate (TEAB) buffer, pH 8.5, containing 12 M urea. Dithiothreitol
(DTT) was added from a 100 mM aqueous stock solution to a final concentration
of 5 mM and the mixture incubated at 37 °C for 1 h. Then, iodoacetamide
(or acrylamide) was added from a ca. 500 mM dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO)
stock solution to reach 50 mM and incubation at 37 °C was continued
for another 30 min. Finally, the mixture was diluted 1:10 with 20%
acetonitrile and 0.4% FA in water (to a DMSO concentration of 1%)
and washed 6× with the same solvent in a 10 kDa cutoff centrifugal
spin filter (Amicon Ultra Ultracel regenerated cellulose, Merck Millipore
Ltd., Cork, Ireland), concentrated to ca. 100 μL, filtered through
a 0.2 μm syringe filter (Minisart RC 4, Sartorius Stedim Lab
Ltd., Stonehouse, UK), and injected by passing the LC into the QToF
mass analyzer.The viability of the method for quantitative
determination of DF
was demonstrated by analyzing a reference sample, consisting equal
parts of Qβ[Hpg] (1) and Qβ[Sia1(100%)] (5a) as obtained by literature protocols.[25] The spectrum showed signals of equal intensity for both
monomers (Figure S2).
Protein Concentration
Determination
Concentrations
of protein solutions were determined using a Pierce BCA Protein Assay
Kit (ThermoFisher Scientific) according to the manufacturer’s
instructions. Absorption at 562 nm was measured on a Tecan Infinite
M-Plex plate reader (Tecan Group Ltd., Männedorf, Switzerland)
and results evaluated using the software Prism (version 5.04, GraphPad
Software, Inc., San Diego, CA).
HAI Test
The hemagglutination
assay was performed according
to a standardized protocol.[4] EDTA-stabilized
human donor blood (German Red Cross) was diluted with Dulbecco’s
phosphate-buffered saline (DPBS) and erythrocytes were pelleted at
1500 rcf, 10 min, 4 °C repeatedly until the supernatant remained
clear. Erythrocytes were diluted with DPBS to obtain a suspension
of a hematocrit of 1%, which was stored on ice. Concentrated virus
stocks from −80 °C storage were thawed on ice. To determine
viral activity, serial 1:2 dilutions in DPBS were prepared in a 96-well
round bottom plate at a total volume of 25 μL after which 50
μL of 1% erythrocyte suspension was added to each well and the
mixtures incubated for 1 h at r.t. Based on these results, a 4 HAU/5
μL virus suspension was prepared in DPBS. Accurate virus titer
of this suspension was verified by another hemagglutination test starting
from 4 HAU with 25 μL total volume in the first well.For the HAI test, inhibitors were serially diluted in a 96-well round
bottom plate at 20 μL total volume. Five microliters (4 HAU)
of virus suspension was added and the mixtures incubated for 30 min
at r.t. Ensuingly, 50 μL of 1% erythrocyte suspension was added
to each well and the results documented following another hour of
incubation. The endpoint of the inhibitor dilution series was the
highest dilution to still cause complete inhibition of hemagglutination,
which reflects the inhibitory constant K.[27−29]K values for Qβ[Sia1]
conjugates
(5a–e) were measured in triplicates, K values for Qβ[Sia3] conjugates (6a–f), Qβ[Sia8] conjugates (7a–g), and those
for conjugates with mixed linker lengths (8 and 9) were measured in duplicates, each during the course of
one individual experiment (Table S1). The
values depicted in Figures and 3 are the arithmetic means of
these replicates.The values for DF = 50% shown in Figure were obtained by
interpolating the experimental
data using a regression function of the typewhere a is the slope
of the
graph and b is the ordinate intercept.
Cryoelectron
Microscopy
To control the binding of the
Qβ phage capsids to influenza virus by cryoTEM, Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(9a) (concentration 200 nmol/L) was incubated with 15
μL of IAV X31 (1.2 mg/mL total protein) with gentle agitation
for 30 min at room temperature. A perforated (1 μm hole diameter)
carbon film-covered microscopical 200 mesh grid (R1/4 batch of Quantifoil,
MicroTools GmbH, Jena, Germany) was cleaned with chloroform and hydrophilized
by 60 s glow discharging before a 5 μL aliquot of the sample
solution was applied to the grid. The sample was vitrified by automatic
blotting and plunge freezing with a FEI Vitrobot Mark IV (ThermoFisher
Scientific Inc., Waltham, MA) using liquid ethane as the cryogen.
The vitrified specimen was transferred to the autoloader of a FEI
TALOS ARCTICA electron microscope (ThermoFisher Scientific Inc.) operated
at an acceleration voltage of 200 kV. Micrographs were acquired on
a FEI Falcon 3 direct electron detector (ThermoFisher Scientific Inc.)
using a 100 μm objective aperture and a nominal magnification
of 28,000× corresponding to a calibrated pixel size of 3.69 Å/pixel.
Dynamic Light Scattering
DLS was performed using a
Zetasizer Nano-ZS instrument (Malvern Instruments, Malvern, UK).
Qβ-Sialoside Bioconjugation
For bioconjugation,
Qβ[Hpg] (1) was transferred from the NaN3-containing storage buffer (100 mM potassium phosphate (KPi) + 0.02%
NaN3) to regular KPi using PD MidiTrap G-25 protein desalting
columns (Cytivia, Marlborough, MA). Stock solutions of 100 mM Na ascorbate
and 100 mM aminoguanidine·HCl in KPi buffer were prepared. Catalyst
mix was prepared by mixing equal parts of 200 mM Cu(OAc)2 and 1 M THPTA in water. In a snap cap reaction vial, 0.5–2
nmol Qβ[Hpg] (1) was mixed with 36,000 equiv aminoguanidine,
1800 equiv Cu(OAc)2/9000 equiv THPTA from catalyst mix,
and the indicated amounts of azide (see Table ). If necessary, KPi was added to fill up
the reaction vial. Finally, 36,000 equiv of Na-ascorbate was added
and the capped vial incubated at 37 °C overnight.Purification
of the products was performed by 1–2 rounds of dialysis against
KPi + 5 mM EDTA and one round of dialysis against KPi, followed by
SEC. Products were stored at 4 °C in KPi + 0.02% NaN3.
Theoretical Model for the Inhibitory Constant K
For an irregular arrangement
of SA on the capsid, the distances d1, d2, and d3 between
the HA-binding pocket and the three closest SA groups differ from
each other. We therefore determine the quadratic mean . We furthermore note
that molecular dynamics
simulation found for the end-to-end distance of short PEG
oligomers with r0 = 5 Å and n being the polymerization index of the EG linker.[34] We use these results to calculate the weight
when summing over all SA triplets and doublets.To determine
the effective number of matching SA triplets numerically, we consider
a partially functionalized capsid, where the functionalized residues
are chosen randomly. For each SA group, we determine two neighboring
SA groups, such that the resulting SA triangle is closest to the triangular
arrangement of the HA-binding pockets. Subsequently, the distances d1, d2, and d3 are determined and the quadratic mean is calculated.
To determine Ntri,eff of the entire capsid,
we sum over all SA triangles. Subsequently, the K of the capsid is averaged over 500
different random SA configurations for each DF. Ndi,eff is calculated in an analogous way.
A549 Infection
with A/Panama
The evening before the
infection, 8.000 cells/well are seeded into an Ibidi angioslide. The
viruses are diluted in DMEM containing 1% penicillin/streptomycin
(v/v), 1% l-glutamine (v/v), 0.2% BSA (w/v), and 2 μg/mL
TPCK-trypsin to achieve an multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 11.
The virus solution is incubated on ice for 30 min followed by 30 min
of incubation at 37 °C.
Interaction of A/Panama
with A549 Cells
A549 cells
are incubated with Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)] (9a)
for 10 min on ice and washed off carefully. For the experiment in
which A/Panama viruses are to be bound to the cell surface, cells
are incubated with DID-labeled IAV (multiplicity of infection (MOI)
11) for 30 min on ice before 200 nM Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(9a) is added to the cells and incubated on ice for 10
min, then washed off carefully. DID-labeled IAV and Qβ[Sia1(98%),TAMRA(2%)]
(9a) are mixed in a 1:1 (v:v) ratio and incubated for
30 min at room temperature. The mixture is provided to the A459 cells
and incubated on ice for 10 min. Unbound complexes are carefully washed
off. Live cell imaging was performed at 37 °C using a spinning
disc confocal microscope.
Nucleoprotein (NP) Staining
For
anti-NP AB staining,
infected cells are fixed and permeabilized using 10% formalin with
0.2% Triton-X100 in PBS. Cells are blocked with PBS containing 2%
BSA for 1 h at room temperature. The primary antibody is diluted 1:500
in BB and incubated for 1 h at 37 °C. After washing three times
with PBS++, the secondary antibody is stained the same way.
Authors: Susanne Liese; Manuel Gensler; Stefanie Krysiak; Richard Schwarzl; Andreas Achazi; Beate Paulus; Thorsten Hugel; Jürgen P Rabe; Roland R Netz Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2016-12-21 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Daniel Lauster; Simon Klenk; Kai Ludwig; Saba Nojoumi; Sandra Behren; Lutz Adam; Marlena Stadtmüller; Sandra Saenger; Stephanie Zimmler; Katja Hönzke; Ling Yao; Ute Hoffmann; Markus Bardua; Alf Hamann; Martin Witzenrath; Leif E Sander; Thorsten Wolff; Andreas C Hocke; Stefan Hippenstiel; Sacha De Carlo; Jens Neudecker; Klaus Osterrieder; Nediljko Budisa; Roland R Netz; Christoph Böttcher; Susanne Liese; Andreas Herrmann; Christian P R Hackenberger Journal: Nat Nanotechnol Date: 2020-03-30 Impact factor: 39.213
Authors: Lukas Kaufmann; Mohammedyaseen Syedbasha; Dominik Vogt; Yvonne Hollenstein; Julia Hartmann; Janina E Linnik; Adrian Egli Journal: J Vis Exp Date: 2017-12-01 Impact factor: 1.355
Authors: Jayanta Haldar; Luis Alvarez de Cienfuegos; Terrence M Tumpey; Larisa V Gubareva; Jianzhu Chen; Alexander M Klibanov Journal: Pharm Res Date: 2009-12-15 Impact factor: 4.200
Authors: Sumati Bhatia; Malte Hilsch; Jose Luis Cuellar-Camacho; Kai Ludwig; Chuanxiong Nie; Badri Parshad; Matthias Wallert; Stephan Block; Daniel Lauster; Christoph Böttcher; Andreas Herrmann; Rainer Haag Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2020-06-30 Impact factor: 15.336