| Literature DB >> 35750345 |
S M Moazzem Hossain1, Sara Al-Dahir2,3, Riyadh-Al Hilfi4, Yasir Majeed5, Alaa Rahi6, Vickneswaran Sabaratnam7, Taha Al-Mulla8, Omar Hossain9, Adam Aldahir10, Ryan Norton11, Faris Lami12.
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to evaluate Iraq's health facility preparedness for the surge of hospitalised cases associated with the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. In this article, we review pandemic preparedness at both general and tertiary hospitals throughout all districts of Iraq. COVID-19 pandemic preparedness, for the purpose of this review, is defined as: (1) staff to patient ratio, (2) personal protective equipment (PPE) to staff ratio, (3) infection control measures training and compliance and (4) laboratory and surveillance capacity. Despite the designation of facilities as COVID-19 referral hospitals, we did not find any increased preparedness with regard to staffing and PPE allocation. COVID-19 designated hospital reported an increased mean number of respiratory therapists as well as sufficient intensive care unit staff, but this did not reach significant levels. Non-COVID-19 facilities tended to have higher mean numbers of registered nurses, cleaning staff and laboratory staff, whereas the COVID-19 facilities were allocated additional N-95 masks (554.54 vs 147.76), gowns (226.72 vs 104.14) and boot coverings (170.48 vs 86.8) per 10 staff, but none of these differences were statistically significant. Though COVID-19 facilities were able to make increased requisitions for PPE supplies, all facility types reported unfulfilled requisitions, which is more likely a reflection of global storage rather than Iraq's preparedness for the pandemic. Incorporating future pandemic preparedness into health system strengthening efforts across facilities, including supplies, staffing and training acquisition, retention and training, are critical to Iraq's future success in mitigating the ongoing impact of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2022. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; Health systems evaluation
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35750345 PMCID: PMC9226466 DOI: 10.1136/bmjgh-2022-008715
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Glob Health ISSN: 2059-7908
Health facility sampling
| Health system level | Facility type | Sampled facilities |
| COVID-designated hospitals | General hospitals | 19 (61%) |
| Tertiary hospitals | 12 (39%) | |
| Total | 31 | |
| Non-COVID hospitals | General hospitals | 32 (68%) |
| Tertiary hospitals | 15 (32%) | |
| Total | 47 |
number (%)
Hospital readiness based on staffing per 100 patient beds and supplies per 10 hospital staff
| Staff per 100 patients | COVID-19 hospitals (n=31) | Non-COVID-19 hospitals (n=47) |
| Mean (95% CI) | Mean (95% CI) | |
| Physicians | 23.86 (16.47 to 31.24) | 22.76 (18.48 to 27.04) |
| Physician assistants | 18.05 (12.14 to 23.96) | 18.93 (11.95 to 25.9) |
| Registered nurses/nurse assistants/paramedics | 53.17 (34.72 to 71.61) | 63.85 (45.48 to 82.21) |
| Pharmacists and technicians | 15.13 (9.67 to 20.59) | 18.14 (14.31 to 21.98) |
| Radiology staff | 3.63 (2.46 to 4.81) | 5.99 (3.93 to 8.05) |
| Respiratory therapists | 0.97 (0 to 1.98) | 0.08 (0 to 0.17) |
| Cleaning staff | 16.45 (10.41 to 22.5) | 21.41 (15.54 to 27.28) |
| Laboratory staff | 19.95 (11.33 to 28.57) | 24.05 (18.73 to 29.37) |
|
| ||
| Gloves | 478.76 (213.42 to 744.1) | 468.03 (202.57 to 733.5) |
| N-95 masks | 554.54 (0 to 1347.52) | 147.76 (90.96 to 204.55) |
| Face shields | 25.9 (12.38 to 39.41) | 17 (7.5 to 26.51) |
| Gowns | 226.72 (45.22 to 408.21) | 104.14 (54.22 to 154.05) |
| Aprons | 14.93 (0 to 37.39) | 10.36 (3.81 to 16.91) |
| Boot coverings | 170.48 (36.78 to 304.18) | 86.8 (35.8 to 137.81) |
Total PPE forecasted and supplied per 100 staff members assigned to facility
| COVID-19 hospitals | Non-COVID-19 hospitals | |||||
| Forecasted | Supplied | Portion fulfilled (%) | Forecasted | Supplied mean (SD) | Portion fulfilled (%) | |
| Face masks | 6569 (1793) | 2488 (761) | 38 | 2890 (769) | 606 (152) | 21 |
| N-95 masks | 660 (201) | 332 (164) | 50 | 343 (166) | 41 (10) | 12 |
| Face shields | 444 (200) | 222 (164) | 50 | 126 (36) | 46 (26) | 37 |
| Gloves | 8815 (2457) | 6271 (2468) | 71 | 7082 (1566) | 1570 (421) | 22 |
| Water apron | 531 (291) | 113 (60) | 21 | 616 (214) | 69 (34) | 11 |
| Disposable gown | 1561 (319) | 1586 (358) | 101 | 969 (219) | 526 (138) | 54 |
| Boot/shoe covers | 3820 (1279) | 1798 (662) | 47 | 1457 (416) | 428 (118) | 29 |
PPE, personal protective equipment.
COVID-19 facility level assessment on adherence to infection prevention and control standard operating procedure recommendations
| COVID-19 hospitals (n=31) | Non-COVID-19 hospitals (n=47) | |||
| n (%) | 95% CI | n (%) | 95% CI | |
|
| ||||
| Facility has SOP and protection measures | 26 (83.87) | 68.2% to 93.57% | 40 (85.11) | 72.97% to 93.08% |
| Facility is fenced with restricted access | 30 (96.77) | 85.9% to 99.65% | 43 (91.49) | 81.02% to 97.06% |
| The entrance and exit of the facility are clearly identified with personnel stationed to control flow of patients | 30 (96.77) | 85.9% to 99.65% | 46 (97.87) | 90.48% to 99.77% |
| The patient flow is clearly signed | 22 (70.97) | 53.66% to 84.56% | 35 (74.47) | 60.81% to 85.22% |
| Access to caregivers’ rooms is restricted to one caregiver per patient | 18 (58.06) | 40.62% to 74.08% | 25 (53.19) | 39.09% to 66.91% |
| Minimum of 1-metre distance between all patients in the waiting area | 8 (25.81) | 13.03% to 42.87% | 13 (27.66) | 16.48% to 41.5% |
| Presence of a triage area to screen visitors | 19 (61.29) | 43.77% to 76.81% | 23 (48.94) | 35.07% to 62.93% |
|
| ||||
| Sufficient water available at all times | 26 (83.8) | 68.2% to 93.5% | 35 (74.4) | 60.8% to 85.2% |
| Hand sanitiser is available for staff use at all times | 26 (83.8) | 68.2% to 93.5% | 35 (74.4) | 60.8% to 85.2% |
| Appropriate PPE is available for all staff | 24 (77.4) | 60.7% to 89.2% | 26 (55.3) | 41.1% to 68.8% |
| Appropriate PPE for all staff involved in direct patient care | 23 (74.1) | 57.1% to 86.9% | 38 (80.8) | 67.9% to 90% |
| Appropriate (PPE) for cleaning and disinfection staff | 19 (61.2) | 43.7% to 76.8% | 28 (59.5) | 45.3% to 72.6% |
| Appropriate (PPE) for all waste management staff | 19 (61.2) | 43.7% to 76.8% | 28 (59.5) | 45.3% to 72.6% |
SOP, standard operating procedures.