| Literature DB >> 35726205 |
Nityanand Jain1, Sakshi Prasad2, Zsófia Csenge Czárth3, Swarali Yatin Chodnekar4, Srinithi Mohan5, Elena Savchenko6, Deepkanwar Singh Panag1, Andrei Tanasov7, Marta Maria Betka8, Emilia Platos9, Dorota Świątek8, Aleksandra Małgorzata Krygowska9, Sofia Rozani10, Mahek Srivastava5, Kyriacos Evangelou10, Kitija Lucija Gristina1, Alina Bordeniuc11, Amir Reza Akbari12, Shivani Jain13, Andrejs Kostiks14, Aigars Reinis1.
Abstract
War refugees and veterans have been known to frequently develop neuropsychiatric conditions including depression, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and anxiety disorders that tend to leave a long-lasting scar and impact their emotional response system. The shear stress, trauma, and mental breakdown from overnight displacement, family separation, and killing of friends and families cannot be described enough. Victims often require years of mental health support as they struggle with sleep difficulties, recurring memories, anxiety, grief, and anger. Everyone develops their coping mechanism which can involve dependence and long-term addiction to alcohol, drugs, violence, or gambling. The high prevalence of mental health disorders during and after the war indicates an undeniable necessity for screening those in need of treatment. For medical health professionals, it is crucial to identify such vulnerable groups who are prone to developing neuropsychiatric morbidities and associated risk factors. It is pivotal to develop and deploy effective and affordable multi-sectoral collaborative care models and therapy, which primarily depends upon family and primary care physicians in the conflict zones. Herein, we provide a brief overview regarding the identification and management of vulnerable populations, alongside discussing the challenges and possible solutions to the same.Entities:
Keywords: PTSD; conflict; depression; neuropsychiatric effects; refugees; stigma; treatment
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35726205 PMCID: PMC9218442 DOI: 10.1177/21501319221106625
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Prim Care Community Health ISSN: 2150-1319
Risk Factors in Association of Developing Depression, PTSD, and Anxiety Disorders in War-Refugees and Veterans.
| Category | Risk factor | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Demographic risk factors (3) | Age | Older age increases the risk |
| Gender | Females are more prone to most mental disorders except PTSD | |
| For PTSD both genders are equally vulnerable | ||
| Education | A lower educational level increases the risk | |
| War-related risk factors (2) | Number of war traumatic events | Higher the number, the higher the risk |
| Conflict experience | No previous combat and prison experience increases the risk | |
| Post-migration risk factors (7) | Duration of migration | Longer duration in exile/displaced state has been poorly but positively correlated with psychiatric disorders |
| Post-migration stress | Increased stress is associated with a higher risk | |
| Employment | Unemployment increases risk | |
| Income | Lower income and savings increase the risk | |
| Language proficiency | Inability to comprehend the language of the host country can increase the risk | |
| Social support | Lack of social support increases the risk | |
| Marital status | Unmarried people are more susceptible to depression | |
| No such correlation has been established with PTSD or anxiety disorders | ||
| Other risk factors (2) | Previous neuropsychiatric disorder | Past significant medical history elevates the risk |
| Child of the affected mother | Children of mothers with first-hand experience of war-related events are more vulnerable |
Commonly Employed Structured Questionnaires for Assessing Mental Disorders Amongst Refugees and War-Veterans.
| Questionnaire | Description | Scoring/evaluation | Diagnostic purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Hopkins Symptom Checklist-25 (HSCL-25) | Consists of 2 subscales—HSCL-A for anxiety (10 items) and HSCL-D for depression (15 items). Each item is scored from 1 to 4. | 1. High total 25 item average correlates with the severe emotional distress of unspecified diagnosis | Assessing the existence and severity of anxiety and depression symptoms |
| 2. High 15-item depression average correlates with major depression (DSM-IV)
| |||
| 3. Probable psychiatric case if HSCL-25 ≥1.55 whilst treatment is required if the score is ≥1.75 | |||
| Harvard Trauma Questionnaire (HTQ) | Six unique versions for different conflict refugees (Vietnamese, Cambodian, Laotian, Japanese, Croatian, and Bosnian) | In the Cambodian version, a score >2.5 is considered symptomatic of PTSD | Assessing the existence and severity of PTSD |
| PCL (PTSD Checklist) | The newer version comprises 20 items checklist corresponding to the DSM-V version and doesn’t have military or civilian versions. Each question is answered from 0 to 4. | In PCL-5, a provisional PTSD diagnosis can be made by treating each item rated ≥2 as symptomatic, and then following the diagnostic rule which requires at least: 1B item (questions 1-5), 1C item (questions 6-7), 2D items (questions 8-14), 2E items (questions 15-20) | A Provisional diagnosis of PTSD. The gold standard for diagnosis of PTSD is the clinically administered PTSD Scale (CAPS-5). |
| A score of 31 to 33 (out of 80) is indicative of probable PTSD | |||
| Comprehensive Trauma Inventory (CTI-104) | 104 event items divided into 12 event-type scales. Each item has a check box for whether the patient experienced the event or not, followed by a 0 to 4 scale for assessing the severity of the threat/fear of that event. | Scoring can be done either by calculating the number of events experienced or the sum of the scores of the events experienced | Accessing whether the patient has experienced a traumatic event or not and if yes, evaluate the impact of the event in terms of fear and/or threat |
| Post Migration Living Difficulties (PMLD) Scale | 23 Items scale with each item scored on a 4-point scale | Uses DSM-V scheme for diagnosis of PTSD | Assessment of current stressors amongst asylum seekers |
| Refugee Health Screener-15 (RHS-15) | The first 13 questions of the RHS-15 are known as the RHS-13 and relate to symptoms of depression, anxiety, and PTSD | For the RHS-13, a total score ≥11 is interpreted as a positive screening | Screening and predicting distress, anxiety, PTSD, and depression in refugees |
| Post-traumatic Diagnostic Scale (PDS) | 12-item scale is usually administered along with HTQ. Divided into 4 parts—Part 1 for assessing exposure to a traumatic event and Parts 2 to 4 for symptoms of PTSD. | Uses DSM-V scheme for diagnosis of PTSD | Assessment of PTSD |
DSM-IV and V, diagnostic and statistical manual of the American Psychiatric Association, versions IV and V, respectively.
Overview of the Teaching Recovery Techniques (TRT) Sessions.
| Audience—session no. | Aim of the session | Description of the session |
|---|---|---|
| Child—First | Introduction | Getting to know each other and identification of the major issues |
| Child—Second | Intrusion | Discussion about war events, news, and normalization of reactions to traumatic events. Introduction of “Safe place” visualization. |
| Child—Third | Intrusion | Thought discussion, use of imagery techniques, dual attention tasks, dreamwork, and distraction |
| Child—Fourth | Arousal | The practice of relaxation, breath control, and positive self-coping exercises. Understanding “fear thermometer” activity scheduling, and sleep hygiene. |
| Child—Fifth | Exposure | War event flashbacks are discussed, the concept of grading and personalized fear hierarchy is revisited, and real-life graded exposure preparation is done |
| Child—Sixth | Exposure | Learning about how to expose themselves to traumatic events via drawing, talking, and writing and implementation of techniques learned in the fourth session (arousal), the importance of doing enjoyable things |
| Child—Seventh | Follow-up | Looking into the future without discussing further the content of the intervention |
| Caregiver—first | Introduction | Occurs before the start of the children’s session and involves psychoeducation about traumas and how they impact children and adults |
| Caregiver—second | Briefing | Occurs between children’s sessions second and fourth. Caregivers are acquainted with the information that children are receiving and how caregivers can help youth to cope with past and ongoing traumas. |
Figure 1.The multi-pillar collaborative approach for reducing the mental health treatment gap.