Wenhao Zheng1, Nicolas F Zorn2, Mischa Bonn1, Jana Zaumseil2, Hai I Wang1. 1. Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research, D-55128 Mainz, Germany. 2. Institute for Physical Chemistry and Centre for Advanced Materials, Universität Heidelberg, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany.
Abstract
The controlled introduction of covalent sp3 defects into semiconducting single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) gives rise to exciton localization and red-shifted near-infrared luminescence. The single-photon emission characteristics of these functionalized SWCNTs make them interesting candidates for electrically driven quantum light sources. However, the impact of sp3 defects on the carrier dynamics and charge transport in carbon nanotubes remains an open question. Here, we use ultrafast, time-resolved optical-pump terahertz-probe spectroscopy as a direct and quantitative technique to investigate the microscopic and temperature-dependent charge transport properties of pristine and functionalized (6,5) SWCNTs in dispersions and thin films. We find that sp3 functionalization increases charge carrier scattering, thus reducing the intra-nanotube carrier mobility. In combination with electrical measurements of SWCNT network field-effect transistors, these data enable us to distinguish between contributions of intra-nanotube band transport, sp3 defect scattering and inter-nanotube carrier hopping to the overall charge transport properties of nanotube networks.
The controlled introduction of covalent sp3 defects into semiconducting single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) gives rise to exciton localization and red-shifted near-infrared luminescence. The single-photon emission characteristics of these functionalized SWCNTs make them interesting candidates for electrically driven quantum light sources. However, the impact of sp3 defects on the carrier dynamics and charge transport in carbon nanotubes remains an open question. Here, we use ultrafast, time-resolved optical-pump terahertz-probe spectroscopy as a direct and quantitative technique to investigate the microscopic and temperature-dependent charge transport properties of pristine and functionalized (6,5) SWCNTs in dispersions and thin films. We find that sp3 functionalization increases charge carrier scattering, thus reducing the intra-nanotube carrier mobility. In combination with electrical measurements of SWCNT network field-effect transistors, these data enable us to distinguish between contributions of intra-nanotube band transport, sp3 defect scattering and inter-nanotube carrier hopping to the overall charge transport properties of nanotube networks.
Highly purified
semiconducting
single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) are a promising material for
electronic circuits and optoelectronic devices owing to their high
charge carrier mobilities and narrowband near-infrared (nIR) emission.[1−3] Recently, the controlled functionalization of SWCNTs with covalently
attached aryl or alkyl groups has emerged as a versatile approach
to enhance their optical properties.[4−7] These local sp3-hybridized lattice defects, also referred to as quantum defects
or organic color centers, form new electronic states that efficiently
trap excitons, leading to red-shifted (by ∼100–300 meV)
nIR photoluminescence (PL) with increased quantum yields.[8−12] Furthermore, such functionalization enables high-purity single-photon
emission in SWCNTs at room temperature.[13,14] These sp3 defects also influence the intrinsic charge
transport along the nanotubes (i.e., intrananotube band transport[15]) as indicated by the reduced conductivities
that were found for individual functionalized SWCNTs (both metallic
and semiconducting).[16,17] In contrast to single nanotubes,
charge transport in SWCNT networks is commonly believed to be limited
by thermally activated carrier hopping across the nanotube–nanotube
junctions,[18] which leads to their substantially
lower field-effect mobilities of only 5–50 cm2 V–1 s–1 compared to around 1000 cm2 V–1 s–1 for a single
nanotube depending on its diameter.[19] Nevertheless,
recent studies have shown that the introduction of sp3 defects also lowers the overall charge carrier mobility
in dense nanotube networks.[20] The apparent
convolution of intra- and internanotube transport in a network (see Figure a) further complicates
the interpretation of the impact of sp3 defects. Consequently, experimental techniques are required that
can determine local charge transport and carrier mobilities within
individual SWCNTs or SWCNT segments. For example, flash-photolysis
time-resolved microwave conductivity on nanotube dispersions[21] and dark microwave conductivity measurements
on chemically doped nanotube networks[22] have provided some initial insights for pristine SWCNTs but were
not applied to functionalized nanotubes.
Figure 1
(a) Schematic of a polymer-wrapped, sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNT with the molecular
structure of the wrapping
polymer PFO-BPy. Charge transport through a network of such SWCNTs
involves carrier hopping across nanotube–nanotube junctions
(inter-nanotube transport) as well as intra-nanotube transport along
the individual SWCNTs. (b) Normalized absorption spectra of pristine
and sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNT dispersions.
Labels indicate the main excitonic E11 transition with its phonon sideband (PSB) and the E11* defect-state absorption feature. Inset: zoom-in on
the E11* absorption band. (c) Normalized
PL spectra of pristine and sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNT dispersions after E22 excitation at 575 nm.
(d) Raman spectra of pristine and sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNT films normalized to the G+ mode. Inset: zoom-in
on the defect-related D mode, which increases with sp3 defect density.
(a) Schematic of a polymer-wrapped, sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNT with the molecular
structure of the wrapping
polymer PFO-BPy. Charge transport through a network of such SWCNTs
involves carrier hopping across nanotube–nanotube junctions
(inter-nanotube transport) as well as intra-nanotube transport along
the individual SWCNTs. (b) Normalized absorption spectra of pristine
and sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNT dispersions.
Labels indicate the main excitonic E11 transition with its phonon sideband (PSB) and the E11* defect-state absorption feature. Inset: zoom-in on
the E11* absorption band. (c) Normalized
PL spectra of pristine and sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNT dispersions after E22 excitation at 575 nm.
(d) Raman spectra of pristine and sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNT films normalized to the G+ mode. Inset: zoom-in
on the defect-related D mode, which increases with sp3 defect density.Ultrafast optical-pump terahertz (THz)-probe (OPTP) spectroscopy
is another contact-free, all-optical method that has been shown to
enable a quantitative description of intrinsic charge transport properties
(e.g., charge scattering time) of various nanomaterials in dispersions
and films, including pristine carbon nanotubes.[23−27] Due to the transient nature of the THz probe with
an oscillating electrical field with ∼1 ps duration, charge
carriers are locally driven over a distance of 10s of nm, rendering
THz spectroscopy a highly suitable technique to probe charge transport
on a microscopic level.[23,28] Previous THz studies
revealed significantly longer charge scattering times for (6,5) SWCNTs
compared to graphene nanoribbons,[24] as
well as very similar carrier dynamics for semiconducting and metallic
SWCNT films.[29]Here, we investigate
the intrinsic charge transport properties
of sp3-functionalized, polymer-sorted
(6,5) SWCNTs as a model system by combining (temperature-dependent)
OPTP spectroscopy of dispersions and thin films with electrical measurements
of nanotube network field-effect transistors. The observed decrease
in magnitude and lifetime of the transient photoconductivity with
the degree of functionalization corroborates the impact of sp3 defects on intra-nanotube carrier mobilities
and provides a clearer picture of the contributions of intra-nanotube
and inter-nanotube charge transport in pristine and functionalized
SWCNT networks.
Results and Discussion
Monochiral,
semiconducting (6,5) SWCNTs (diameter ∼0.76
nm, average length ∼1.4 μm) were obtained by highly selective
dispersion of CoMoCAT nanotubes with a fluorene-bipyridine copolymer
(PFO-BPy) in toluene.[30] These polymer-wrapped
(6,5) SWCNTs were covalently functionalized with 4-nitrobenzenediazonium
tetrafluoroborate[31] to create different
densities of sp3 defects (see Figure a) on the nanotubes
(for further details, see Methods). The degree
of functionalization was quantified with various spectroscopic metrics.
The introduction of sp3 defects gives
rise to a small E11* defect absorption band at ∼1160
nm (see Figure b and Supporting Information (SI) Figure S1) and a
significant E11* PL emission feature at
∼1172 nm (Figure c). Both increase relative to the native E11 excitonic
transition with increasing defect concentration. Furthermore, resonant
Raman spectroscopy (Figure d) showed an increasing but still relatively low signal of
the defect-related D mode in relation to the G+ mode, which
is associated with the sp2 carbon lattice.[31] As shown in SI Figure 2, a linear correlation between the Raman D/G+ area ratio
and the integrated E11*/E11 area ratios in absorption
and emission was found. While all three quantities may serve as metrics
for the defect concentration of sp3-functionalized
carbon nanotubes,[20,31] here we will use only the Raman
D/G+ ratio to reflect the degree of functionalization in
our samples. The estimated sp3 defect
densities (based on the differential Raman D/G+ area ratio)[32] range between 5 and 20 defects per μm,
corresponding to an average distance of about 200 to 50 nm between
two adjacent defects. Note that samples with different defect densities
still possess the same length distribution, as determined by atomic
force microscopy (see SI Figure S3).To investigate the impact of sp3 functionalization
on the photoconductivity dynamics and transport properties of individual
polymer-wrapped SWCNTs in dispersion, we employed ultrafast optical-pump
terahertz (THz)-probe (OPTP) spectroscopy as schematically shown in Figure a. In OPTP measurements,
interband photoexcitation (∼1.25 eV optical pump pulses, close
to the E11 transition peak at ∼1000
nm) generates a small population of free charge carriers that are
subsequently probed by a single-cycle THz pulse with ∼2 THz
bandwidth. The field of the incident THz pulse accelerates the free
charge carriers, whereby some of the energy in the THz field is dissipated.
The degree of dissipation is a direct measure of charge carrier mobility.
The transmitted THz field E is characterized directly
in the time domain, so that both its amplitude and phase can be determined,
thus providing direct access to the complex-valued photoconductivity
Δσ. By monitoring the photoinduced THz absorption (ΔE = Epump – E) at different pump–probe delays, the time-dependent photoconductivity
(Δσ ∝ – ΔE/E) dynamics can be traced (see the SI for a detailed description).[23]
Figure 2
(a) Schematic
illustration of optical-pump THz-probe (OPTP) spectroscopy
on nanotube dispersions. (b) Photoconductivity dynamics of pristine
and sp3-functionalized (low and high defect
density) SWCNT dispersions in toluene following optical excitation
at 1.25 eV at room temperature (absorbed photon density, ∼
3 × 1018 m–2) and (c) data normalized
to the maximum photoconductivity (logarithmic scale). (d) Complex
photoconductivity spectra of pristine and sp3-functionalized (high defect density) SWCNT dispersions measured
∼1.5 ps after photoexcitation (blue circles, real conductivity;
gray triangles, imaginary conductivity). The solid lines represent
fits to the data with the Drude-Smith model. (e) Maximum photoconductivity
(red triangles) extracted from a) and photogenerated carrier mobility
in the DC limit (blue circles) determined from fit in d) depending
on the sp3 defect density (Raman D/G+ area ratio).
(a) Schematic
illustration of optical-pump THz-probe (OPTP) spectroscopy
on nanotube dispersions. (b) Photoconductivity dynamics of pristine
and sp3-functionalized (low and high defect
density) SWCNT dispersions in toluene following optical excitation
at 1.25 eV at room temperature (absorbed photon density, ∼
3 × 1018 m–2) and (c) data normalized
to the maximum photoconductivity (logarithmic scale). (d) Complex
photoconductivity spectra of pristine and sp3-functionalized (high defect density) SWCNT dispersions measured
∼1.5 ps after photoexcitation (blue circles, real conductivity;
gray triangles, imaginary conductivity). The solid lines represent
fits to the data with the Drude-Smith model. (e) Maximum photoconductivity
(red triangles) extracted from a) and photogenerated carrier mobility
in the DC limit (blue circles) determined from fit in d) depending
on the sp3 defect density (Raman D/G+ area ratio).Figure b compares
the magnitude of the real component of the photoconductivity of three
representative nanotube dispersions (pristine, low and high degree
of sp3 functionalization; for complete
data sets, see SI Figure S4). In all samples,
the optical generation of free carriers is manifested by a steep rise
in photoconductivity. We note that the generation of free carriers
following excitation to the lowest excitonic states was reported previously
for polymer-wrapped SWCNTs,[21] yet the detailed
mechanism remains elusive. One of the plausible explanations involves
the thermodynamic equilibrium between free carriers and excitons (e.g.,
following Saha equation).[33−35] Further investigation is required
for a better understanding of free carrier generation under these
conditions, which is beyond the focus of the current study.As shown in Figure b, sp3 functionalization results in a
pronounced decrease in the peak photoconductivity amplitude for a
given absorbed photon density Nabs and
thus approximately the same photogenerated charge carrier density
as for the pristine nanotubes (the photon-to-free-charge conversion
quantum yield is expected to be similar in all samples). The nanotube
dispersion with the highest sp3 defect
concentration exhibits a reduction of ∼30% in Δσ compared to pristine SWCNTs. In dispersion, OPTP probes individual
nanotubes, and thus inter-nanotube electronic coupling can be excluded.
This assumption is supported by the nearly identical photoconductivity
(both amplitude and dynamics after normalization to the absorbed photon
density) of dispersions with different nanotube concentrations (see SI Figure S5). As such, our observation corroborates
the direct impact of sp3 functionalization
on intra-nanotube charge transport. We assign the reduction of photoconductivity
to charge scattering at the sp3 defects.
The scattering probability increases with increasing defect density,
thus accounting for the decreased photoconductivity. For the highest
defect density investigated here (∼20 defects per μm),
the majority of photogenerated carriers interacts with a defect site
during their lifetime (see estimation of carrier diffusion length
of about 30–50 nm, SI Figure S6).After reaching a maximum, the photoconductivity decays rapidly,
followed by a slow decay component (see Figure b). The fast decay can be directly related
to the formation of bound electron–hole pairs (i.e., excitons),[24,33] which do not contribute to the conductance. Exciton localization
may occur at sp3 defects. Recent transient
absorption studies reported exciton trapping at defects on sub-10
ps time scales for very high defect densities.[36] Here, the impact of sp3 defects
on the photoconductivity dynamics, in particular on carrier localization,
is shown in the normalized transients in Figure c and SI Figure S7. Increasing the sp3 defect density leads
to a significant reduction in the photoconductivity lifetimes. The
exciton localization probability is enhanced as manifested by the
increased weight of the fast decay in the photoconductivity with increasing
defect density.To further clarify the impact of sp3 functionalization on the THz photoconductivity in SWCNTs
and the
nature of charge carriers following optical excitations, we conducted
THz time-domain spectroscopy (THz-TDS; for experimental details and
data analysis, see Methods and SI), from which the frequency-resolved photoconductivity
can be obtained. Figure d illustrates the complex photoconductivity spectra measured at a
delay of ∼1.5 ps after photoexcitation (see SI Figure S8 for spectra at different delays up to 6 ps).
The large real conductivity (along with a small imaginary conductivity)
indicates the dominant role of free carriers in the photoconductivity
response at early times after optical excitation. We find that the
Drude-Smith (DS) model, which was previously applied to describe charge
transport in carbon nanotubes,[24,29] provides a good description
of the data. This model describes the transport of free carriers in
a medium where charges experience preferential backscattering, for
example, due to nanoscale confinement. The DS model equation reads[37,38]where
τ, ω, ε0, e, and m* are the effective carrier
momentum scattering time, plasma frequency,
vacuum permittivity, elementary charge, and charge effective mass,
respectively. The parameter C characterizes the probability
of backscattering at, for example, defects or/and grain boundaries.
Values for C can range from 0 (isotropic scattering)
to −1 (complete backscattering). From the DS parameters, we
infer the mobility in the DC limit, which is shown as a function
of the Raman D/G+ area ratio (i.e., sp3 defect density) in Figure e together with the extracted photoconductivity
amplitudes. Both exhibit a very similar trend, and the ∼25%
reduction of carrier mobility for the sample with the highest defect
concentration is quantitatively consistent with the decrease in photoconductivity
amplitude. These values suggest that the impact of sp3 defects on intra-nanotube carrier mobility, rather than
on photogenerated carrier density, governs the reduction of photoconductivity
upon sp3 functionalization (see Figure b). Similarly, we
observe an increase in the charge carrier scattering rate of ∼20%
induced by the sp3 defects for the highest
Raman D/G+ area ratio (see SI Figure S9). These values correlate well with a conductivity decrease
of ∼20% associated with the introduction of single defects
in individual nanotubes.[16,17] Although the extracted
mobilities of several hundred cm2V–1s–1 are in good agreement with the reported diameter-dependent
mobilities for single-nanotube transistors,[19] it should be noted that the carrier mobilities extracted here represent
local values (on the length scales of 10s of nm) and are measured
at low carrier densities (approximately 1 charge carrier per μm
of SWCNT). In addition, the extracted mobility values may depend on
the applied fitting model (e.g., the Drude-Smith model here). However,
the relative trend of carrier mobilities is robust and does not depend
on the fitting.To compare the impact of sp3 defects
on the local carrier mobilities in individual nanotubes to macroscopic
charge transport in networks, we also fabricated field-effect transistors
(FETs) with dense, spin-coated films (see SI Figure S10) of pristine and sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNTs and interdigitated source-drain electrodes with channel
length and width of 20 μm and 10 mm, respectively. Figure a shows a schematic
cross-section of an FET with a representative AFM image of a functionalized
nanotube network. Due to the required amount of material, different
series of SWCNT dispersions were prepared for OPTP spectroscopy and
FET fabrication. However, as indicated by the very similar E11*/E11 absorption
area ratios and Raman D/G+ area ratios (see SI Figure S11), the degree of sp3 functionalization was similar in both cases and thus
should not affect the comparison. The full spectroscopic characterization
of the SWCNT dispersions used for FET fabrication is shown in SI Figure S12.
Figure 3
(a) Schematic illustration of a bottom-contact,
top-gate SWCNT
network FET (layer thicknesses not to scale) together with a representative
atomic force micrograph of a sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNT network (scale bar, 500 nm). (b) Ambipolar transfer characteristics
(source-drain voltage Vds = −0.1
V) of FETs based on networks of pristine and sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNTs with different defect densities
(solid lines, drain currents Id; gray
dotted lines, gate leakage currents Ig). (c) Linear charge carrier mobilities (blue circles, hole mobilities;
red triangles, electron mobilities) of SWCNT network FETs normalized
to the pristine network reference transistors versus Raman D/G+ area ratio. Error bars are standard deviations for at least
16 transistors measured for each SWCNT network.
(a) Schematic illustration of a bottom-contact,
top-gate SWCNT
network FET (layer thicknesses not to scale) together with a representative
atomic force micrograph of a sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNT network (scale bar, 500 nm). (b) Ambipolar transfer characteristics
(source-drain voltage Vds = −0.1
V) of FETs based on networks of pristine and sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNTs with different defect densities
(solid lines, drain currents Id; gray
dotted lines, gate leakage currents Ig). (c) Linear charge carrier mobilities (blue circles, hole mobilities;
red triangles, electron mobilities) of SWCNT network FETs normalized
to the pristine network reference transistors versus Raman D/G+ area ratio. Error bars are standard deviations for at least
16 transistors measured for each SWCNT network.All devices exhibited balanced ambipolar charge transport characteristics
(i.e., electron and hole conduction) with low gate leakage currents
as shown in the current–voltage (transfer) characteristics
(linear regime, source-drain voltage Vds = −0.1 V) in Figure b. Despite decreasing electron and hole currents with increasing sp3 defect density, even devices with the highest
degree of functionalization remained fully functional and showed good
switching behavior. Note that the current hysteresis resulted from
incomplete removal of oxygen and water, which act as charge traps,[39] due to the relatively low annealing temperatures
that were required to avoid defect cleavage.[20]The increasing number of sp3 defects
causes a decrease in charge carrier mobility for both holes and electrons. Figure c shows the carrier
mobilities normalized to the values for the pristine SWCNT network
transistors versus the Raman D/G+ area ratio. We find a
decrease of ∼50–70% for the highest density of sp3 defects compared to the reference transistors.
Absolute linear mobilities range between 1.18 ± 0.05 cm2 V–1 s–1 (pristine) to 0.35 ±
0.01 cm2 V–1 s–1 (highest
defect density) for electrons, whereas hole mobilities decrease from
4.78 ± 0.20 cm2 V–1 s–1 to 2.26 ± 0.06 cm2 V–1 s–1 upon sp3 functionalization (see also SI Figure S13 and Table S1). These values are
in excellent agreement with previous results for functionalized SWCNT
network FETs with bromoaryl instead of nitroaryl defects.[20]The electrical measurements of SWCNT FETs
(channel length of 20
μm) represent the macroscopic charge transport in nanotube networks
involving both intra-nanotube transport and carrier hopping across
nanotube–nanotube junctions. As such, the observed decrease
in mobility by ∼50–70% for the highest degree of functionalization
reflects the interaction of charge carriers with multiple sp3 defects. Note also that FETs operate at high
charge carrier densities (1011–1013 cm–2, corresponding to a few 10s to hundreds of charge
carriers per μm of SWCNT), and mobilities in SWCNTs increase
with carrier concentration before reaching a maximum.[19,40] Furthermore, the interaction of nanotubes with the substrate (phonon
scattering)[41] and with each other affect
the overall carrier mobility. All this is in clear contrast to OPTP
measurements of individual SWCNTs in dispersion, where a low density
of photogenerated carriers is locally driven over a few 10s of nm
and may scatter at one or only a few defect sites. Taking these differences
into account, the ∼25% reduction in carrier mobility (∼30%
reduction in photoconductivity) upon sp3 functionalization obtained from OPTP measurements indicates a comparable
impact of luminescent defects on the microscopic and macroscopic carrier
mobilities in functionalized individual SWCNTs and their networks,
respectively. Since THz spectroscopy of SWCNT dispersions unambiguously
probes only the intrinsic nanotube charge transport, we can assume
that the intra-nanotube resistance (increased by the sp3 defects) in (6,5) SWCNT networks–in contrast
to common belief–is not negligible compared to the junction
resistance (inter-nanotube hopping).[42]To further corroborate the impact of sp3 defects on charge transport in individual SWCNTs within networks,
we performed temperature-dependent OPTP spectroscopy on dense (6,5)
SWCNT films. As shown in SI Figure S14a, for pristine nanotubes at 288 K, the THz photoconductivity of thin
films was twice as high as that of SWCNTs in dispersion. This is not
surprising, given that the enhanced electronic coupling of nanotubes
in networks should facilitate exciton dissociation onto different
nanotubes.[43] Inter-nanotube exciton dissociation
leads to an increased photon-to-free-charge conversion quantum yield
in films compared to dispersions. We further find that the (rescaled)
frequency-resolved photoconductivities for film and dispersion show
identical spectra (see SI Figure S14b)
and thus the same momentum scattering time for a given pump–probe
delay. Figure a shows
the photoconductivity dynamics of thin films of pristine and highly sp3-functionalized SWCNTs at room temperature.
Similar to the dispersions (see Figure ), the peak photoconductivity normalized by the absorbed
photon density was ∼30% lower for the functionalized films
compared to the pristine reference. The similarity of the photoconductivity
changes for nanotube dispersions and films indicates that OPTP primarily
probes the intra-nanotube transport even in dense networks. We note
that the observed trends of photoconductivity changes upon functionalization
also persist for higher absorbed photon densities and consequently
higher charge carrier densities. These higher carrier densities come
close to the low-voltage range in FET measurements (see above) and
corroborate the comparability of both techniques.
Figure 4
(a) Temperature-dependent
photoconductivity (proportional to −ΔE/E) dynamics of pristine and sp3-functionalized SWCNT thin films at room temperature
(288 K, dashed lines) and 78 K (solid lines). The optical excitation
energy was 1.25 eV and the absorbed photon density was ∼2 ×
1018 m–2. (b) Temperature-dependent maximum
photoconductivity normalized to the values at 288 K for pristine (blue
circles) and sp3-functionalized (orange
triangles) SWCNT films, respectively. (c) Complex photoconductivity
spectra for the pristine SWCNT thin film at 288 K and 78 K measured
∼1.5 ps after photoexcitation (blue circles, real conductivity;
gray triangles, imaginary conductivity). The solid lines represent
fits to the data with the DS model. (d) Carrier mobilities in the
DC limit extracted from the fits in (c) as a function of inverse temperature
(blue circles, pristine SWCNT film; orange triangles, sp3-functionalized SWCNT film). Solid lines are linear fits
to the data.
(a) Temperature-dependent
photoconductivity (proportional to −ΔE/E) dynamics of pristine and sp3-functionalized SWCNT thin films at room temperature
(288 K, dashed lines) and 78 K (solid lines). The optical excitation
energy was 1.25 eV and the absorbed photon density was ∼2 ×
1018 m–2. (b) Temperature-dependent maximum
photoconductivity normalized to the values at 288 K for pristine (blue
circles) and sp3-functionalized (orange
triangles) SWCNT films, respectively. (c) Complex photoconductivity
spectra for the pristine SWCNT thin film at 288 K and 78 K measured
∼1.5 ps after photoexcitation (blue circles, real conductivity;
gray triangles, imaginary conductivity). The solid lines represent
fits to the data with the DS model. (d) Carrier mobilities in the
DC limit extracted from the fits in (c) as a function of inverse temperature
(blue circles, pristine SWCNT film; orange triangles, sp3-functionalized SWCNT film). Solid lines are linear fits
to the data.Measurements at low temperatures
(at 78 K in Figure a, for other temperatures, see SI Figure S15) showed a significant increase
of the photoconductivity amplitude for the pristine SWCNT film, whereas sp3-functionalized SWCNTs exhibited an almost
negligible increase (Figure b). We employed temperature-dependent THz-TDS measurements
to record complex conductivity spectra (see Figure c and SI Figure S16 and analyzed the frequency-resolved spectra by the DS model to extract
the carrier mobility as a function of temperature. The observed inverse
temperature dependence of the mobility (μ ∝ 1/T, see Figure d) is in agreement with single-nanotube FET measurements and suggests
that for pristine SWCNT films charge transport within individual nanotubes
is mainly limited by phonon scattering.[15,19] In contrast
to that, charge transport through macroscopic SWCNT networks (e.g.,
in FETs) is always thermally activated due to carrier hopping across
nanotube–nanotube junctions.[40]As shown in Figure d, the increase in mobility with decreasing temperatures was more
pronounced for pristine SWCNTs than for the sp3-functionalized networks, which is in agreement with the temperature-dependent
photoconductivity amplitudes (Figure b). For both samples, phonon scattering, which is the
cause of this temperature dependence,[15,19] should be
reduced to a similar degree at lower temperatures. However, the additional
charge scattering at sp3 defects significantly
reduces the inverse temperature dependence of the intra-nanotube mobility
for functionalized SWCNTs as well as the absolute values.Differences
in the temperature dependence of carrier mobilities
were observed previously for FETs with pristine and sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNT networks: At higher temperatures,
the impact of the defects was small, whereas at low temperatures,
the presence of sp3 defects significantly
increased the temperature dependence of the mobility (i.e., the mobilities
decreased much more with decreasing temperature compared to a pristine
network).[20] This observation can now be
rationalized by the insights into the temperature-dependent intra-nanotube
mobilities in sp3-functionalized nanotubes
obtained by time-resolved THz spectroscopy. At higher temperatures,
thermally activated inter-nanotube carrier hopping dominates the temperature
dependence of network mobilities, and the changes in intra-nanotube
transport upon sp3 functionalization do
not have a significant impact. At low temperatures, however, inter-nanotube
hopping is slowed down, and the differences in intra-nanotube transport
become more apparent. For the pristine SWCNT network, the intra-nanotube
mobility increases with decreasing temperature due to reduced phonon
scattering (band transport), thus counteracting the decrease in network
mobilities due to the reduced carrier hopping. However, for the functionalized
SWCNTs, the temperature dependence of intra-nanotube transport is
significantly diminished (it barely increases with decreasing temperature,
see Figure d). Therefore,
it cannot counteract the decrease in inter-nanotube carrier mobility
at lower temperatures, and thus, the overall network mobilities decrease
even further at lower temperatures compared to the pristine SWCNT
networks. Consequently, the field-effect mobilities of sp3-functionalized SWCNT networks exhibit a stronger temperature
dependence than those of pristine (6,5) SWCNT network FETs. Overall,
only a convolution of inter-nanotube hopping and intra-nanotube band
transport (affected by the sp3 defects)
can explain the observed temperature dependence of the network mobilities
in FETs with functionalized nanotubes. These results provide further
evidence that junction resistances are not the only limiting factor
for charge transport through random SWCNT networks.
Conclusion
We have investigated the impact of luminescent sp3 defects on charge transport in polymer-wrapped (6,5)
carbon nanotubes on a microscopic and macroscopic level by combining
(temperature-dependent) OPTP and THz time-domain spectroscopy of dispersions
and thin films with electrical measurements of network FETs. The complementary
nature of these methods allows us to evaluate the contributions of
intra-nanotube transport and nanotube–nanotube junctions in
SWCNT networks. We find that the introduction of luminescent sp3 defects leads to increased charge scattering
along SWCNT segments and reduced carrier mobility, photoconductivity,
and lifetime. It also diminishes the intrinsic increase of intra-nanotube
carrier mobilities with decreasing temperature. Since the reduction
of the field-effect mobilities in functionalized nanotube networks
is on the same order of magnitude as that of the photoconductivity,
we propose that the apparent carrier mobilities (holes and electrons)
in (6,5) SWCNT networks are not only limited by the junctions but
result from a superposition of intra- and inter-nanotube contributions.
Methods
Selective Dispersion of
(6,5) SWCNTs
(6,5) SWCNTs were
selectively extracted from CoMoCAT raw material (Sigma-Aldrich, batch
no. MKCJ7287, 0.4 g L–1) via polymer-wrapping with
poly[(9,9-dioctylfluorenyl-2,7-diyl)-alt-(6,6′-(2,2′-bipyridine))]
(PFO-BPy, American Dye Source, MW = 40
kg mol–1, 0.5 g L–1) in toluene
under shear force mixing (Silverson L2/Air mixer, 10230 rpm, 72 h)
as described previously.[30] To remove residual
aggregates and impurities, two consecutive centrifugation steps (60 000g, 45 min each) and subsequent filtration through a polytetrafluoroethylene
(PTFE) syringe filter (pore size 5 μm) were employed. The obtained
dispersion was either directly used for sp3 functionalization of (6,5) SWCNTs, or filtered through a PTFE membrane
(Merck Millipore JVWP, pore size 0.1 μm) and washed with toluene
(10 mL) for the fabrication of reference samples as detailed below.
sp3 Functionalization of (6,5) SWCNTs
As described previously,[31] PFO-BPy-wrapped
(6,5) SWCNTs were covalently functionalized with 4-nitrobenzenediazonium
tetrafluoroborate in a solvent mixture of toluene and acetonitrile
(80:20 vol %). Reactions were performed at a (6,5) SWCNT concentration
of 0.54 mg L–1, corresponding to an optical density
of 0.3 cm–1 at the E11 absorption peak. An appropriate amount of 18-crown-6 (concentration
in the final reaction mixture, 2 mg mL–1) was dissolved
in toluene and then added to the nanotube dispersion. Subsequently,
a solution of the diazonium salt in acetonitrile was added to achieve
a concentration in the final reaction mixture between 50 μg
mL–1 and 750 μg mL–1. After
thorough mixing, the reaction was allowed to proceed at room temperature
in the dark for ∼16 h. Then, the reaction mixture was filtered
through a PTFE membrane filter (Merck Millipore JVWP, pore size 0.1
μm) and the collected SWCNTs were washed with acetonitrile and
toluene in order to remove unreacted diazonium salt as well as excess
polymer.
Preparation of SWCNT Dispersions for FET Fabrication and THz
Measurements
For the fabrication of SWCNT network field-effect
transistors (FETs), filter cakes of pristine and sp3-functionalized (6,5) SWCNTs were redispersed in 1 mL
of fresh toluene via bath sonication (30 min) to obtain concentrated
dispersions (optical density of 8–10 cm–1 at the E11 transition) that were immediately
used for spin-coating (see below). For THz measurements of SWCNT dispersions,
filter cakes were redispersed in 1 mL of a PFO-BPy solution in toluene
(0.1 g L–1) to increase the stability of the dispersions.
Fabrication of (6,5) SWCNT Network FETs
On low-sodium
glass substrates (Schott AG, AF32eco, 300 μm thickness), interdigitated
bottom-contact electrodes (L = 20 μm, W = 10 mm) were patterned by photolithography (LOR5B/S1813
resist, microresist technology GmbH) and electron beam evaporation
of chromium (3 nm) and gold (30 nm), followed by lift-off in N-methyl pyrrolidone. SWCNT networks were deposited from
concentrated dispersions via spin-coating (3 × 80 μL, 2000
rpm, 30 s) onto the electrodes with intermediate annealing steps at
120 °C. To remove residual polymer, substrates were subsequently
rinsed with tetrahydrofuran and 2-propanol. All SWCNTs outside the
channel area were removed by oxygen plasma treatment. After an annealing
step at 150 °C for 30 min in dry nitrogen atmosphere, a double-layer
dielectric was applied, i.e., ∼11 nm of poly(methyl methacrylate)
(PMMA, syndiotactic, Polymer Source, MW = 315 kg mol–1) were spin-coated from n-butylacetate followed by atomic layer deposition of ∼61
nm of hafnium oxide (Ultratech Inc., Savannah S100) at 100 °C
using a tetrakis(dimethylamino)hafnium precursor (Strem Chemicals
Inc.) and water as the oxidizing agent. Thermal evaporation of 30
nm silver top-gate electrodes through a shadow mask completed the
devices.
Preparation of (6,5) SWCNT Thin Films for THz Measurements
Filter cakes of pristine and sp3-functionalized
(6,5) SWCNTs were redispersed in 1 mL of fresh toluene via bath sonication
and diluted to an optical density of ∼0.1 cm–1 at the E11 absorption transition. Of
each dispersion, 10 mL were filtered over respective mixed cellulose
ester membranes (Merck Millipore VSWP, pore size 0.025 μm).
Cleaned fused silicon dioxide substrates (from PI-KEM Ltd.) were subjected
to UV/ozone treatment. Filter membranes with SWCNT films were cut
to the desired size and placed onto the substrates with the SWCNT
film facing down. The filter cake was wetted with 2-propanol, pressed
against the substrate, and the sample was immediately put into an
acetone bath (7 × 15 min) to dissolve the filter membrane, leaving
only the SWCNT film on the substrate. Samples were rinsed with acetone
and 2-propanol and then blow-dried with nitrogen.
Characterization
Baseline-corrected absorption spectra
of SWCNT dispersions were acquired with a Cary 6000i UV–vis-nIR
spectrometer (Varian Inc.). Raman spectra (excitation wavelength 532
nm) were measured on drop-cast SWCNT films using a Renishaw inVia
confocal Raman microscope with a 50× long working distance objective
(Olympus, N.A. 0.5). PL spectra were measured on a home-built laser
setup under E22 excitation (575 nm) with
the wavelength-filtered output of a picosecond-pulsed supercontinuum
laser (Fianium WhiteLase SC400, 20 MHz repetition rate). The laser
was focused onto the samples with a nIR-optimized 50× objective
(Olympus, N.A. 0.65). Scattered laser light was blocked by appropriate
long-pass filters, and emission spectra were recorded with a grating
spectrometer (Acton SpectraPro SP2358, 150 lines mm–1) equipped with a liquid nitrogen-cooled InGaAs line camera (Princeton
Instruments OMA V:1024–1.7 LN). Atomic force micrographs were
acquired with a Bruker Dimension Icon under ambient conditions. Current–voltage
characteristics of SWCNT network FETs were measured in inert atmosphere
with an Agilent 4156C semiconductor parameter analyzer.
THz Spectroscopy
THz spectroscopy was performed with
a commercial, regenerative amplified, mode-locked Ti:sapphire femtosecond
laser system from Spectra Physics Spitfire Ace. The laser system provides
characteristic 1 kHz pulses of approximately 50 fs duration and a
central wavelength of 800 nm. THz waves were generated by optical
rectification on a zinc telluride (ZnTe) crystal (along the ⟨110⟩
orientation). The transmitted THz wave was sampled by a second 800
nm pulse via the electro-optic effect by a second ZnTe detection crystal.
To track the dynamics of the real photoconductivity in optical-pump
THz-probe (OPTP) measurements, the pump-induced THz absorption was
measured by fixing the sampling beam to the peak of the THz field.
By varying the time delay between the pump and sampling beam with
an optical delay stage, the time-dependent photoconductivity was recorded.
The pump path contained an optical parametric amplifier and mixing
stages (Light Conversion, TOPAS) to convert the incident 800 nm light
to ∼1000 nm wavelength light. During the measurements, the
entire THz setup was kept under dry nitrogen atmosphere to avoid THz
absorption. Samples were either purged with dry nitrogen or placed
under vacuum conditions (<2 × 10–4 mbar).
Authors: Maximilian Brohmann; Felix J Berger; Maik Matthiesen; Stefan P Schießl; Severin Schneider; Jana Zaumseil Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2019-06-11 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Yue Luo; Xiaowei He; Younghee Kim; Jeffrey L Blackburn; Stephen K Doorn; Han Htoon; Stefan Strauf Journal: Nano Lett Date: 2019-11-08 Impact factor: 11.189
Authors: Nicolai F Hartmann; Kirill A Velizhanin; Erik H Haroz; Mijin Kim; Xuedan Ma; YuHuang Wang; Han Htoon; Stephen K Doorn Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2016-08-19 Impact factor: 15.881