Adjunctive chemotherapy to radical radiation therapy in the treatment of advanced nasopharyngeal carcinoma.

Sixty-eight consecutive patients with previously untreated nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) with advanced cervical lymph nodal metastases were studied retrospectively for the effectiveness of combining chemotherapy with radical radiation therapy (RT). In 1981 and 1982, 36 patients were treated with radical radiation therapy alone (arm 1). In 1983, 13 patients were given 2 courses of VBMF prior to RT (arm 2). In 1984, 19 patients were given radical RT sandwiched between 2 courses of PVBMF before and 2 after (arm 3). The three arms were comparable in patient characteristics with similar stages of the disease, sex, age distribution, and rates of completion of the prescribed treatments. There was no significant difference in actuarial or disease-free survival between arm 1 and 3 or arm 2 and 3, but arm 1 compared favorably with arm 2 in actuarial survival (X2 = 9.533, p = 0.002). The distant relapses in arms 2 and 3 occurred at significantly shorter times after diagnosis than those in arm 1 (t = 4.1083, p = 0.0001). Postponement of radiation therapy by chemotherapy might have accounted for the earlier distant relapses in arm 2 and 3. Radiation therapy alone given in radical dose had been demonstrated to achieve significantly more complete responses in cervical nodal metastases than either forms of chemotherapy (VBMF or PVBMF) given just two courses prior to radiation therapy (p less than 0.00003). More controlled clinical trials must be completed before acceptance of chemotherapy as part of a standard radical treatment for advanced nasopharyngeal carcinoma with advanced cervical lymph nodal metastases. In all future trials, closer integration in time sequence between the two treatment modalities is indicated. Meanwhile cervical nodal status (CR vs, PR plus NR) at the end of any treatment was shown to be of paramount prognostic significance.