| Literature DB >> 35706953 |
Silvana Parisi1, Sara Lillo1, Alberto Cacciola1, Gianluca Ferini2, Vito Valenti2, Anna Viola2, Anna Santacaterina3, Angelo Platania3, Anna Brogna4, Consuelo Tamburella1, Stefano Pergolizzi1.
Abstract
Old or very old oncological patients represent a heterogeneous and frail population due to concomitant comorbidities. Whether radiotherapy alone or in combination with novel cancer drugs may provide a clear benefit in this setting of patients is still a matter of debate. The aim of our review is to analyze the evaluation process and the different therapeutic possibilities in older cancer patients, focusing on the different and most disparate applications of radiotherapy. We reviewed the most recent literature on radiotherapy in older patients providing clinical evidence of treatment related toxicity, tolerance and outcomes using standard fractionated and/or hypofractionated irradiation alone or in combination with chemotherapy, targeted and immunotherapy. In older cancer patients unfit for systemic therapy or surgery, radiotherapy represents a valid therapeutic approach, both with curative and palliative intents, ensuring excellent patient compliance in terms of local toxicity and adherence to therapy.Entities:
Keywords: Frailty; Geriatrics; Radiation oncology
Year: 2022 PMID: 35706953 PMCID: PMC9189877 DOI: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e09593
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Heliyon ISSN: 2405-8440
Summary of the main studies on conventionally fractionated and hypofractionated RT in older patients. Survival outcomes and complications are reported. Abbreviations: P prospective, R retrospective, NSCLC non-small cell lung cancer, MIBC muscle invasive bladder cancer, BCC basal cell carcinoma, CFRT conventional fractionated radiotherapy, HFRT hypofractionated radiation therapy, FU follow-up, OS overall survival, RFS recurrence-free survival, LC local control, BCF biochemical or clinical failure, GI gastrointestinal, GU genitourinary.
| Authors | Year | Type of study | N. | Median age (range) | Histology | Type of RT | Dose range Gy/fxs | Median FU (months) | Outcomes | Acute toxicities (%) | Late toxicities (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pergolizzi et al. [ | 2002 | P | 40 | 77 (75–83) | NSCLC | CFRT | 54-64/27-32 | 54 | Median OS 19 months | G1/2 esophagitis (70) | Radiation pneumonia (5) |
| Santacaterina et al. [ | 2002 | R | 45 | 75 (70–85) | MIBC | CFRT | 56-64/28-32 | 63 | Median OS 21.5 months | G1/2 GI and/or GU toxicity (100) | - |
| Santacaterina et al. [ | 2015 | R | 27 | 84.5 (81–91) | MIBC | CFRT | 60-64/30-32 | 17.5 | Mean OS 23.5 months | G1/2 GI and/or GU toxicity (55.5) | G1/2 GI and/or GU toxicity (11) |
| Wujanto et al. [ | 2019 | R | 45 | 77 (65–95) | MIBC | CFRT | 50–69.8/30-40 | 31 | Median OS 56 months | G1/2 GI and/or GU toxicity (89) | G3 cystitis (2.2) |
| Soyfer et al. [ | 2013 | R | 21 | 80 | Soft-tissue sarcoma | HFRT | 39-48/13-16 | 26 | - | G2/3 toxicity (3.75) | G2/3 toxicity (3.75) |
| Kouloulias et al. [ | 2014 | R | 38 | 78 (64–91) | BCC | HFRT | 30/5 once weekly | 48 | Local RFS 92.1% | G1/2 skin toxicity (92.2) | - |
| Marriappan et al. [ | 2014 | R | 25 | 89 (83–103) | BCC | HFRT | 42/7 once weekly | 15 | LC 95% | - | - |
| Pelissero et al. [ | 2015 | R | 117 | 82 (75–103) | BCC | HFRT | 25-30/5–6 once weekly | 61 | 3-year RFS 96.4%; | G1/2 skin toxicity (30.7) | - |
| Russi et al. [ | 2015 | R | 134 | 82.5 (75–103) | BCC | HFRT | 25-30/5–6 once weekly | 64.5 | 3-year RFS 97.3%; | G1/2 skin toxicity (30.6) | - |
| Dirix et al. [ | 2016 | R | 44 | 72 | MIBC | HFRT | 34.5/6 | 10 | Mean OS 10.5 months; mean hematuria-free survival 13 months | G3 GU toxicity (9) | G3 GU toxicity (19) |
| Sanz et al. [ | 2018 | R | 486 | 79 | Breast cancer | HFRT | 30–37.5/6 | 51 | 5-year OS 74.2%; local RFS 96.5% | G1 dermatitis (52) | G1 fibrosis (68) |
| Wilson et al. [ | 2018 | P | 491 | 75 | Prostate cancer | HFRT | 57-60/19-20 | 60 | 5-year BCF-free rates 87.7–91% | G3 GI and/or GU toxicity (10) | G2 GI toxicity (12.5) and GU toxicity (9.2) |
| Hammer et al. [ | 2019 | R | 17 | 87 (81–95) | MIBC | HFRT | 45/15 | 65.3 | 1-year OS 47%; | G3 GI toxicity (6) and GU toxicity (24) | G3 GU toxicity (5.8) |
Summary of the main studies on RT + chemotherapy (CRT) and RT + targeted therapy (TT)/immunotherapy (IT) in older patients. Survival outcomes and complications are reported. Abbreviations: R retrospective, NSCLC non-small cell lung cancer, HNC head and neck cancer, FU follow-up, OS overall survival, GI gastrointestinal, GU genitourinary.
| Authors | Year | Type of study | N. | Median age (range) | Histology | Type of therapy | Dose range Gy/fxs | Median FU (months) | Outcomes | Acute toxicities (%) | Late toxicities (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cai et al. [ | 2013 | R | 126 | 75 (70–92) | Rectal cancer | CRT | 52.2 | 19 | 3-year OS 48.1% | - | - |
| Servagi-Vernat et al. [ | 2015 | Phase 2 study | 30 | 85.2 (79.4–92) | Esophageal cancer | CRT | 50/25 | 36 | 3-year OS 22.2% | G > 4 toxicity (38) | - |
| Nosaka et al. [ | 2016 | R | 49 | 75.4 (70–89) | Cervical cancer | CRT | 50.4/28 | 25.5 | Median OS 66.9 vs 60.1 months (CRT vs RT group) | G3/4 acute toxicities: hyponatremia (35), neutropenia (15), diarrhea (10) | - |
| Perry et al. [ | 2017 | Trial | 562 | 73 (65–90) | Glioblastoma | CRT | 40/15 | 17 | Median OS 9.3 vs 7.6 months (CRT vs RT group) | G3/4 hematological toxicity (46.6) | - |
| Atagi et al. [ | 2018 | Phase 3 trial | 200 | 77 | NSCLC | CRT | 60/30 | 19.4 | Median OS 22.4 vs 16.9 months (CRT vs RT group) | G4 hematological toxicity (26.4) | G3/4 lung toxicity (6.5) |
| Miller et al. [ | 2018 | R | 23229 | 77.6 | NSCLC | CRT | 64.8/33 | 15.5 | Median OS 18.1 vs 12.2 (CRT vs RT group) | G > 3 hematological toxicity (89.9) | - |
| Lazzari et al. [ | 2018 | Case report | 1 | 80 | NSCLC | RT + IT | 66/33 | 36 | - | G2 anemia and G3 febrile neutropenia | - |
| Müller von der Grün et al. [ | 2018 | R | 158 | 65 | HNC | CRT | 70.6 | 29 | 3-year OS 50% | G > 3 hematological toxicity (18) | - |
| Lai et al. [ | 2018 | R | 70 | 75 | HNC | CRT | 60-74/30-37 | - | Median OS 10.8 vs 11.4 months (CRT vs RT group) | G3/4 hematological toxicities: neutropenia (13.2), | - |
| Wang et al. [ | 2019 | R | 1061 | 74 (70–88) | Cervical cancer | CRT | 50.4/28 | 28.9 | 3-year OS 71.9% | G3/4 hematological toxicity (58.1) | G3/4 GI toxicity (8.6) |
| Jingu et al. [ | 2020 | R | 358 | 80 | Esophageal cancer | CRT | 50–60 | - | 3-year OS 22% | - | - |
| Lu et al. [ | 2021 | R | 272 | 72 (65–88) | HNC | CRT | - | - | 5-year OS 61.8 vs 51.7 (CRT vs RT group) | - | - |