| Literature DB >> 35672806 |
Ran Xu1, Elijah G Kiarie1, Alexandros Yiannikouris2, Lvhui Sun3, Niel A Karrow4.
Abstract
Mycotoxins are toxic secondary metabolites produced by filamentous fungi that are commonly detected as natural contaminants in agricultural commodities worldwide. Mycotoxin exposure can lead to mycotoxicosis in both animals and humans when found in animal feeds and food products, and at lower concentrations can affect animal performance by disrupting nutrient digestion, absorption, metabolism, and animal physiology. Thus, mycotoxin contamination of animal feeds represents a significant issue to the livestock industry and is a health threat to food animals. Since prevention of mycotoxin formation is difficult to undertake to avoid contamination, mitigation strategies are needed. This review explores how the mycotoxins aflatoxins, deoxynivalenol, zearalenone, fumonisins and ochratoxin A impose nutritional and metabolic effects on food animals and summarizes mitigation strategies to reduce the risk of mycotoxicity.Entities:
Keywords: Food animals; Mitigation strategies; Mycotoxins; Nutritional impact; Risk management; Susceptibility differences
Year: 2022 PMID: 35672806 PMCID: PMC9175326 DOI: 10.1186/s40104-022-00714-2
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Anim Sci Biotechnol ISSN: 1674-9782
Permitted/guidance levels of regulatory bodies for selected mycotoxins
| Mycotoxin | Commodity | European Commission permitted/guidance level, mg/kga | Food and Drug Administration permitted level/guidance level, mg/kgb | Canadian Food Inspection Agency permitted level/guidance level, mg/kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) | Maize | AFB1: 0.02 | Aflatoxins (AF): 1. Immature animals: 0.02 2. Dairy animals: 0.02 3. Breeding swine and mature poultry: 0.1 4. Finishing swine 100 pounds or greater in weight: 0.2 | AF: 0.02 |
| Maize silage | ||||
| Finished feed | AFB1: 1. Dairy cattle and calves, dairy goats, piglets, and young poultry animals: 0.005 2. Cattle (except dairy cattle and calves), pigs (except piglets) and poultry (except young animals): 0.020 | n/a | n/a | |
| Deoxynivalenol | Maize | 8 | 1. Swine (Grain and grain by-products not to exceed 20% of diet): 5 2. Chickens (Grain and grain by-products not to exceed 50% of diet): 10 3. Ruminating dairy cattle (> 4 months; 88% dry matter basis): 10 4. Other reviewed species (grain and grain by-products not to exceed 40% of diet): 5 | n/a |
| Maize Silage | ||||
| Finished feed | 1. Pigs: 0.9 2. Calves (< 4 months): 2 3. Other reviewed species: 5 | Ruminating dairy cattle (> 4 months): 5 | 1. Cattle and poultry: 5 2. Swine, young calves and lactating dairy animals: 1 | |
| Fumonisins (FUM) | Maize | 60 | 1. Swine (no more than 50% of diet dry weight basis): 20 2. Breeding poultry and breeding ruminants (including lactating dairy cattle) (no more than 50% of diet dry weight basis): 30 3. Poultry being raised for slaughter (no more than 50% of diet dry weight basis): 100 | n/a |
| Maize Silage | ||||
| Finished feed | 1. Pigs: 5 2. Poultry, calves (< 4 months): 20 3. Adult ruminants (> 4 months): 50 | n/a | n/a | |
| Zearalenone | Maize | 2 | n/a | n/a |
| Maize Silage | ||||
| Finished feed | 1. Piglets and gilts (young sows): 0.1 2. Sows and fattening pigs: 0.25 3. calves, dairy cattle and goats: 0.5 | n/a | 1. Gilt diets < 1–3 2. Cow diets 10 (1.5 if other toxins present) 3. Pigs: < 0.25-0.5 | |
| Ochratoxin A | Maize | 0.25 | n/a | n/a |
| Maize Silage | ||||
| Finished feed | 1. Pigs: 0.05 2. Poultry: 0.1 | n/a | 1. Swine diets (kidney damage): 0.2 2. Swine diets (reduced weight gain) 2 3. Poultry: 2 |
aFUM: Sum of fumonisin B1 and B2; bFUM: Sum of fumonisin B1, B2 and B3
Effects of selected major mycotoxins on feed intake
| Mycotoxin | Source of contamination | Animal model | LOAEL, mg/kg feeda | NOEL, mg/kg feedb | Feed intakec | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AFB1 | Artificial | Broilers | 0.04 | NA | D | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Broilers | NA | 0.5 | NS | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Broilers | NA | 1 | NS | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Broilers | 5 | NA | D | [ |
| AF | Natural | Laying hens | 0.123 | NA | D | [ |
| AF | Natural | Laying hens | 0.267 | NA | D | [ |
| AFB1 | Natural | Ducks | NA | Up to 0.1 | NS | [ |
| AFB1 | Natural | Ducks | 0.12002 | NA | D | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Ducks | 0.21 | NA | D | [ |
| AF | Artificial | Turkeys | 0.05 | NA | D | [ |
| AF | Artificial | Turkeys | 0.5 | NA | D | [ |
| AF | Artificial | Pigs | NA | 0.02 | NS | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Pigs | NA | 0.28 | NS | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Dairy goats | NA | 0.05 | NS | [ |
| DON | Artificial | Ducks | NA | 5 | NS | [ |
| DON | Artificial | Broilers | NA | 5 | NS | [ |
| DON | Natural | Broiler | NA | 5 | NS | [ |
| DON | Artificial | Turkey | NA | 5 | NS | [ |
| DON | Natural | Pigs | NA | 1 | NS | [ |
| DON | Natural | Pigs | 1.7 | NA | D | [ |
| DON | Natural | Pigs | 2.86 | NA | D | [ |
| DON | Natural | Pigs | 3.02 | NA | D | [ |
| DON | Artificial | Pigs | 3.8 | NA | D | [ |
| DON | Natural | Pigs | 4 | NA | D | [ |
| DON | Not specified | Pigs | 5 | NA | D | [ |
| FUM | Natural | Broilers | NA | Up to 5.5 | NS | [ |
| FUM | Artificial | Broilers | NA | 20 | NS | [ |
| FUM | Artificial | Ducks | NA | 20 | NS | [ |
| FUM | Artificial | Turkey | NA | 20 | NS | [ |
| FUM | Natural | Pigs | 30 | NA | D | [ |
| FUM | Natural | Pigs | 60 | NA | D | [ |
| OTA | Natural | Broilers | NA | 0.172 | NS | [ |
| OTA | Artificial | Broilers | NA | 2 | NS | [ |
| OTA | Not specified | Pigs | 0.4 | NA | D | [ |
| ZEN | Artificial | Ducks | NA | 0.5 | NS | [ |
| ZEN | Artificial | Turkey | NA | 0.5 | NS | [ |
| ZEN | Artificial | Laying hens | NA | 0.26 | NS | [ |
| ZEN | Artificial | Broilers | 0.5 | NA | D | [ |
| ZEN | Natural | Pigs | NA | 1 | NS | [ |
| ZEN | Purified powder | Pigs | NA | 1 | NS | [ |
| ZEN | Purified powder | Pigs | NA | 1.04 | NS | [ |
| ZEN | Purified powder | Pigs | NA | 1.22 | NS | [ |
| AFB1 + OTA | Artificial | Broilers | 0.025+ 0.1 | NA | D | [ |
| AFB1 + OTA | Purified | Dairy goats | NA | 0.05 + 0.1 | NS | [ |
| AF + ZEN | Natural | Laying hens | 0.123 + 0.260 | NA | D | [ |
| AFB1+ ZEN | Purified | Dairy goats | NA | 0.05 + 0.5 | NS | [ |
| DON+FUM | Artificial | Dairy cattle | NA | 0.733 + 0.994 | NS | [ |
| DON + ZEN | Natural | Pigs | 0.2654 + 1 | NA | D | [ |
| DON + ZEN | Natural | Dairy cattle | NA | 1.966 + 0.366 | NS | [ |
| DON + ZEN | Natural | Dairy cattle | NA | 5.24 + 0.66 | NS | [ |
| ZEN + FUM | Purified ZEN+ Natural FUM | Broilers | NA | 1+3.15 | NS | [ |
| ZEN + FUM | Purified ZEN+ Natural FUM | Broilers | NA | 1+5.5 | NS | [ |
| DON + FUM + ZEN | Artificial | Ducks | NA | 5 + 20 + 0.5 | NS | [ |
| DON + FUM + ZEN | Artificial | Turkey | NA | 5 + 20 + 0.5 | NS | [ |
| DON + FUM + ZEN | Artificial | Broilers | 5 + 20 + 0.5 | NA | D | [ |
| DON + FUM + ZEN | Artificial | Pigs | 0.9 + 5 + 0.1 | NA | D | [ |
| AFB1 + OTA + ZEN | Purified | Dairy goats | 0.05 + 0.1 + 0.5 | NA | D | [ |
aLOAEL Lowest-observed-effect-level, NA not applicable, bNOEL No-observed-effect level, NA Not applicable, cD decreased feed intake, NS Not significantly affected
Effects of selected major mycotoxins on nutrient digestibility
| Mycotoxin | Source of contamination | Animal model | LOAEL, mg/kg feed | Digestibility | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AFB1 | Natural | Ducks | 0.12002 | DM, CP, GE | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Broilers | 0.04 | DM, CP, GE | [ |
| AF | Artificial | Broilers | 0.5 | Net protein utilization; | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Broilers | 1.5 | ADE, N and amino acids | [ |
| AF | Artificial | Broilers | 2 | Protein efficiency, net protein utilization | [ |
| AF | Artificial | Laying hens | 0.6 | ADE and AME | [ |
| AFB1 | Artificial | Pigs | 0.28 | DM, GE, ether extract | [ |
| DON | Natural | Pigs | 2.86 | DM, GE, CP | [ |
| DON | Natural | Pigs | 4 | DM, fat, Energy | [ |
| DON | Artificial | Broilers | 5 | Tyrosine | [ |
| DON | Artificial | Pigs | 11.2 | Tryptophan | [ |
| FUM | Artificial | Broilers | 20 | DM | [ |
| FUM | Artificial | Pigs | 15 | CF, DE | [ |
| FUM | Artificial | Pigs | 30 | CF | [ |
| OTA | Artificial | Broilers | 2 | Protein efficiency, netprotein utilisation | [ |
| ZEN | Artificial | Pigs | 11.6 | Tryptophan | [ |
| ZEN + FUM | Purified ZEN+ Natural FUM | Broilers | 1 + 3.15 | DM, OM, CP, GE | [ |
| ZEN + FUM | Purified ZEN+ Natural FUM | Broilers | 1 + 5.5 | DM, OM, CP, GE | [ |
| DON + FUM | Artificial | Broilers | 1.5 + 20 | DM | [ |
| DON + FUM | Artificial | Broilers | 5 + 20 | DM, ADE | [ |
| DON + FUM | Artificial | Dairy cattle | 0.733 + 0.994 | DM and neutral detergent fiber | [ |
aLOAEL Lowest-observed-effect-level, bDM Dry matter, CP Crude protein, GE Gross energy, DE Digestible energy, OM Organic matter, ADE Apparent digestible energy
Factors contributing to viability of results in the literature
| Factor | Example | References | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diet-related factors | Mycotoxin | Aflatoxins, deoxynivalenol, fumonisins | [ |
| Source of contamination | Naturally contaminated | [ | |
| Artificially contaminated | [ | ||
| Purified powder | [ | ||
| Substrate of contamination | Corn | [ | |
| Wheat | [ | ||
| Barely | [ | ||
| Level of mycotoxin concentration | A wide range of mycotoxin concentrations | [ | |
| Individual or combined contamination | Synergistic effects of deoxynivalenol and fumonisins | [ | |
| Animal-related factors | Species | Poultry, pigs, dairy cattle, dairy goats | [ |
| Breed | Pigs: Yorkshire × Chester White × Duroc, Landrace × Yorkshire, Camborough Plus × C337 | [ | |
| Broilers: Arbor Acres, Ross-308 | [ | ||
| Ducks: Cherry Valley ducks, Pekin | [ | ||
| Laying hens: Hy-Line Brown laying hens, ISA Brown laying hens | [ | ||
| Sex | Pigs: all males, mixed sex and all females | [ | |
| Age | 21-d-old and 42-d-old female pigs | [ | |
| Production stage | Early-lactation vs. mid-lactation cows | [ | |
| Diet composition | Forage types in dairy total mixed ration | [ | |
| Other factors | Exposure duration | Pigs: 21-d, 35-d test period | [ |
Fig. 1Schematic diagram depicting physiological impact of mycotoxins on different organs affecting nutrient utilization