Maximilien S Baas-Thomas1, Sebastian B Oehm1, Nili Ostrov1, George M Church1,2. 1. Department of Genetics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, United States. 2. Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, United States.
Abstract
Bacterial selection is an indispensable tool for E. coli genetic engineering. Marker genes allow for mutant isolation even at low editing efficiencies. TolC is an especially useful E. coli marker: its presence can be selected for with sodium dodecyl sulfate, while its absence can be selected for with the bactericidal protein ColE1. However, utilization of this selection system is greatly limited by the lack of commercially available ColE1 protein. Here, we provide a simple, plate-based, ColE1 negative-selection protocol that does not require purification of ColE1. Using agar plates containing a nonpurified lysate from a ColE1-production strain, we achieved a stringent negative selection with an escape rate of 10-7. Using this powerful negative-selection assay, we then performed the scarless deletion of multiple, large genomic loci (>10 kb), screening only 12 colonies each. We hope this accessible protocol for ColE1 production will lower the barrier of entry for any lab that wishes to harness tolC's dual selection for genetic engineering.
Bacterial selection is an indispensable tool for E. coli genetic engineering. Marker genes allow for mutant isolation even at low editing efficiencies. TolC is an especially useful E. coli marker: its presence can be selected for with sodium dodecyl sulfate, while its absence can be selected for with the bactericidal protein ColE1. However, utilization of this selection system is greatly limited by the lack of commercially available ColE1 protein. Here, we provide a simple, plate-based, ColE1 negative-selection protocol that does not require purification of ColE1. Using agar plates containing a nonpurified lysate from a ColE1-production strain, we achieved a stringent negative selection with an escape rate of 10-7. Using this powerful negative-selection assay, we then performed the scarless deletion of multiple, large genomic loci (>10 kb), screening only 12 colonies each. We hope this accessible protocol for ColE1 production will lower the barrier of entry for any lab that wishes to harness tolC's dual selection for genetic engineering.
Selective
markers are a key
tool in genetic engineering and synthetic biology. They are commonly
used in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells to maintain plasmids and
facilitate deletions and insertions into the genome. Most common marker
genes are used for positive selection, for example, introducing antibiotic
resistance genes such as ampicillin. Negative-selection markers, also
known as counter-selection markers, have a toxic effect that is useful
for ensuring the absence or removal of a gene, for example, for curing
the cell of plasmids and to remove selection markers so they can be
reused.[1] Single genes that enable both
positive and negative selection, or “dual-selection markers”,
are highly desirable since they can be easily and repeatedly inserted
and removed for “scarless” manipulation of multiple
loci in the same cell. Currently, only a few examples of dual-selection
markers are available in bacteria. Beyond recombineering, such dual-selection
cassettes have also been used in a range of applications, including
the evolution of genetic circuits[2] or the
engineering of allosteric transcription factors.[3]Various types of negative-selection genes for recombineering
are
currently available.[2,4−12] A critical parameter for negative selections is the rate at which
incorrect cells escape selection and form colonies (escapee cells).
Among the published systems tested in common E. coli lab strains: the inducible toxin systems, the TetA-SacB cassette, and the tolC marker stand out as the
most stringent markers used in E. coli recombineering, with selection escape rates as low as 1 × 10–8, 6 × 10–7, and 4 × 10–11, respectively.[5,6,13] However, the TetA-SacB cassette requires specialized
counter-selection conditions that inhibit cell growth significantly,[6] and inducible toxin systems often require minimal
media for counter selection. PheS and rpsL/Strep are alternatives for negative selection in
rich media but require the addition of a positive marker to allow
for dual selection. These issues limit the use of these selections
in growth-deficient cells.The tolC gene enables
highly stringent dual selections
in rich LB media. It encodes an outer membrane efflux protein involved
in the expulsion of a diverse range of molecules from the cell.[14] ColE1 is a bactericidal colicin protein that
allows its bacterial host to kill vulnerable cells and gain a growth
advantage. Cells producing ColE1 harbor an immunity gene, also expressed
from the same colicin plasmid, to protect itself from the toxic effect.[15,16] Because ColE1 requires TolC to enter and lyse the target cell, cells
are safe from ColE1 if they lack TolC. These properties
enable tolC’s use in a simple dual-selection
scheme. In the presence of ColE1 toxin, tolC cells die and tolC cells remain viable (negative selection).
In the presence of the surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), tolC cells are protected, while tolC die by membrane
disruption (positive selection) [Figure A].
Figure 1
Optimization of ColE1 production. (A) ColE1
lysate and SDS enable
a dual-selection scheme for cells containing (tolC) or lacking (tolC) the tolC gene.
(B) Overview of ColE1 production protocol steps. (C) Two representative
spot assays of different ColE1 preparations dropped onto tolC+ covered plates were then incubated. Top: 2 h expression
at OD600 = 1.5. Bottom: 16 h expression at OD600 = 0.2. Spots of inhibited growth are circled. Δ indicates
the maximum inhibitory dilution. (D) ColE1 expression was induced
at three different OD600 values and harvested postinduction.
Dark circles represent 2 h induction. Open circles represent 16 h
induction. Gray circles represent no-induction negative control. Maximum
inhibitory dilutions were assessed using the spot assay. Data were
log10-transformed and all replicates, means, and standard
deviations are represented.
Optimization of ColE1 production. (A) ColE1
lysate and SDS enable
a dual-selection scheme for cells containing (tolC) or lacking (tolC) the tolC gene.
(B) Overview of ColE1 production protocol steps. (C) Two representative
spot assays of different ColE1 preparations dropped onto tolC+ covered plates were then incubated. Top: 2 h expression
at OD600 = 1.5. Bottom: 16 h expression at OD600 = 0.2. Spots of inhibited growth are circled. Δ indicates
the maximum inhibitory dilution. (D) ColE1 expression was induced
at three different OD600 values and harvested postinduction.
Dark circles represent 2 h induction. Open circles represent 16 h
induction. Gray circles represent no-induction negative control. Maximum
inhibitory dilutions were assessed using the spot assay. Data were
log10-transformed and all replicates, means, and standard
deviations are represented.While tolC has been utilized in several studies,[1,13,17−19] the system
has so far not been widely adopted due to the difficulty in procuring
the ColE1 protein. While methods to obtain pure ColE1 in small amounts
for protein analysis are well documented, a protocol for its bulk
production as a selective reagent is not well characterized. We are
currently unaware of any commercially available sources. Published
purification methods[20,21] employ fractionation and multiple
chromatography steps for protein purification. In addition, the tolC system has been primarily used in liquid selections,
complicating the isolation of single colonies. Gregg et al.[13] described a plate-based tolC selection scheme using cell lysate for isolation of single colonies
from specific recombineering strains. Recently, Tamer et al.[21] described an alternate purification method employing
a customized expression vector and both size-exclusion and cation
chromatography.Here, we expand upon, simplify, and improve
the reported ColE1
production protocol[13] for a plate-based
selection using cell lysate from the ColE1-producing E. coli strain JC411.[20] Unlike previous protocols, this assay only requires basic microbial
culturing and plate preparation techniques [Figure B]. We characterize the effect of ColE1 induction
conditions on selection stringency and dynamic range. We demonstrate
the repeatable nature of tolC dual selection by scarlessly
deleting multiple loci across the E. coli genome. We believe this work helps reduce the expertise barrier
and promotes adoption of tolC as a dual-selection
marker for microbial genome engineering.
Results and Discussion
The major bottleneck for using tolC dual selection
is the ColE1 preparation. Without commercially available ColE1 protein,
one would have to purify ColE1 to make selective media, rendering
the process laborious and expensive. To address this bottleneck and
develop a cheaper, more accessible assay, we decided to characterize
and optimize ColE1 selections that utilize unpurified cell lysate
rather than purified protein.The use of the ColE1-producing E. coli strain JC411 has been previously reported.[20] The ColE1 gene (cea) is encoded
on the ColE1 plasmid.
Under normal conditions, its promoter is inhibited by LexA. Upon exposure
to mitomycin-C, the cellular SOS response initiates autocatalytic
cleavage of LexA resulting in ColE1 production. It was previously
shown that the majority of colicin molecules are kept in a cell’s
cytosol and on a cell’s membrane than are released freely into
the media.[22−24] We thus chose to proceed with lysing the cell pellet,
rather than harvest the media [Figure B]. Briefly, cells are lysed using sonication, the
lysate is centrifuged, and the resulting supernatant containing ColE1
is sterile-filtered and incorporated into LB-agar plates. Our optimized
protocol provides a robust ColE1 negative selection for tolC.We adopted a simple spot assay to assess the potency of each
lysate
preparation and compare between batches, since it is difficult to
precisely measure the amount of ColE1 in crude cell lysate. In this
assay, the crude ColE1-containing lysate is spotted on top of wild
type E. coli (tolC) spread on an LBM plate
without selection. After the cells are incubated, the toxic presence
of ColE1 in the lysate results in clear spots in the lawn. We used
“maximum inhibitory dilution”—the lowest dilution
of lysate causing cell death—as a relative indicator for the
amount of ColE1 in the lysate [Figure C, Methods]. When we tested
the media of the JC411 culture (instead of the lysed pellet) with
the spot assay, we found very little to no selective action (data
not shown). We used this assay to compare the strength of lysates
prepared with different protocols.We investigated the effect
of two induction parameters on ColE1
production: the OD600 at induction, and the duration of
ColE1 expression [Figure D]. We found cell density at the time of induction had no
statistically significant effect on lysate potency (OD600 of 0.2, 1.5, or 3). Surprisingly, we did not find significant change
in lysate potency using short (2 h) or long (16 h) inductions with
mitomycin-C either. We thus chose a short 2 h induction protocol at
OD600 = 1.5 for subsequent experiments. Using this protocol,
200 mL of JC411 culture routinely produces a hundred negative-selection
plates.We then tested the stringency of ColE1 negative selection
by quantifying
the number of escape colonies on plates containing different ColE1
amounts. It was previously shown that combining ColE1 with vancomycin[25] yielded a mixture with a lower escape rate compared
to using ColE1 alone.[13] We therefore included
vancomycin in our characterization of ColE1 selective plates.First, we performed control experiments confirming that cells lacking tolC (tolC) are not affected by ColE1 toxicity, as expected, by forming
lawns on all lysate-containing plates, noting the plates vary in coloration
[Figure A]. Alternatively,
only individual escapee colonies were detected when plating wild type
cells carrying the tolC gene (tolC) on lysate-containing plates.
Figure 2
Selection stringency
as a function of ColE1 and vancomycin. (A)
Stationary-phase tolC or tolC cultures
incubated at 37 °C for 16 h on the indicated plates containing
ColE1 and/or vancomycin. (B–D) Escape rate of strains (● tolC, ○ tolC) on plates containing ColE1
lysate. (B) Plates containing ColE1 lysate only. ColE1 lysate dilution
of 1× refers to 14 μL/mL of cell lysate (see Methods). (C) Plates containing vancomycin only. (D) Plates
containing both ColE1 lysate and vancomycin. A constant amount of
128 μg/mL vancomycin was added to varying dilutions of ColE1
cell lysate. Data were log10-transformed and all replicates,
means, and standard deviations are represented. (E) Mock selection.
Stationary-phase tolC and tolC cell
cultures were mixed at the indicated ratios, plated on ColE1 lysate
+ vancomycin, and grown overnight. Each dot represents one experiment
in which 96 colonies were screened; means and standard deviations
are represented.
Selection stringency
as a function of ColE1 and vancomycin. (A)
Stationary-phase tolC or tolC cultures
incubated at 37 °C for 16 h on the indicated plates containing
ColE1 and/or vancomycin. (B–D) Escape rate of strains (● tolC, ○ tolC) on plates containing ColE1
lysate. (B) Plates containing ColE1 lysate only. ColE1 lysate dilution
of 1× refers to 14 μL/mL of cell lysate (see Methods). (C) Plates containing vancomycin only. (D) Plates
containing both ColE1 lysate and vancomycin. A constant amount of
128 μg/mL vancomycin was added to varying dilutions of ColE1
cell lysate. Data were log10-transformed and all replicates,
means, and standard deviations are represented. (E) Mock selection.
Stationary-phase tolC and tolC cell
cultures were mixed at the indicated ratios, plated on ColE1 lysate
+ vancomycin, and grown overnight. Each dot represents one experiment
in which 96 colonies were screened; means and standard deviations
are represented.To measure escape rate,
we prepared plates containing undiluted
lysate or 10-fold dilutions of the lysate. We then calculated the
ratios of CFU/mL between nonselective and selective plates to find
the “escape rate” in each case. We used 14 μL
of lysate per 1 mL of LB-agar (used previously by Gregg et al.[13]) as the definition of 1× concentration.
We found that plates made with this amount of lysate provided a stringent
selection with a mean escape rate of 2.15 × 10–6 (without vancomycin) [Figure B]. Selective stringency was maintained even when diluting
the lysate in the plates by 10- or 100-fold (5.67 × 10–6 and 2.35 × 10–5, respectively). Selection
was completely lost when the lysate was diluted 1000-fold. These results
indicate ColE1-containing lysate alone reproducibly provides a robust tolC negative selection.Vancomycin alone had little
to no significant inhibitory effect
on either tolC or tolC cells at concentrations
below 128 μg/mL. At 128 μg/mL, vancomycin showed a moderate
inhibitory effect on both tolC and tolC (4.00 × 10–1 and 8.31 × 10–1, respectively) [Figure C]. When vancomycin was combined with ColE1 lysate, we observed
an increase in tolC selection stringency, reaching
mean escape rates of 5.91 × 10–7 (undiluted)
and 7.2 × 10–7 (10-fold diluted lysate). When
using very diluted lysate with vancomycin, mean escape rates showed
a slight improvement (from 5.67 × 10–6 to 3.10
× 10–6 using 100-fold lysate dilution, and
from 1.49 × 100 to 1.87 × 10–2 using 1000-fold diluted lysate) [Figure D].Additionally, we challenged our
lysate-containing selective plates
by isolating a small number of tolC resistant cells from a large background of tolC cells. In a mock selection experiment,
cells were mixed at tolC:tolC ratios
ranging from 10:1 to 107:1, and the mixture was plated
on ColE1 lysate with vancomycin. Ninety-six colonies of each plate
were PCR-tested to determine the presence of the tolC gene, expecting only tolC cells to grow under ColE1 selective conditions [Figure E]. The total numbers of cells
plated on each plate were from 102 to 103tolC cells, and from
104 to 109tolC cells. We found the expected tolC cell compositions when using
up to a 105:1 (tolC:tolC)
ratio. At the ratio of 107:1 (109:102 plated), we observed that only 4% of screened cells were tolC. This computes
to a tolC escape rate
of ∼2.4 × 10–6 as 109 ×
2.4 × 10–6 = 2400 tolC escapees, compared to the 100 tolC expected cells found ≈4% tolC. It is possible
the reduction in selection stringency was due to the large number
of cells on the plate, diluting or shielding tolC cells from ColE1 protein. Overall,
this demonstrates that a simple ColE1 lysate + vancomycin plate can
be used for negative selection to find one successful recombinant
cell out of a background of 107 with a single 96-well screen.Finally, we demonstrated the utility of negative selection on ColE1
lysate plates in a tolC recombineering assay: targeting
the deletion of three different genomic regions in E. coli [Figure ]. We designed several cassettes [Supporting Figure S3, S7], all containing the tolC gene, for removing these loci [Figure A]. Cassettes were transformed into tolCE. coli following expression of λ-Red
recombinase [Methods]. First, we selected
for the integration of tolC cassettes into the genome
by a positive selection for the presence of tolC using
SDS-containing plates. PCR screening was performed at each step to
identify recombinants, followed by Sanger sequencing [Figure C, Supporting Figure S6]. Next, to remove tolC from the
genome, we performed recombineering of a short deletion oligo (90
bp), which targets homologous recombination at both ends of the inserted tolC cassette. The final colonies that carry a scarless
deletion of the desired region were isolated by negative selection
on ColE1 lysate + vancomycin plates.
Figure 3
Scarless deletion of three loci with a
dual-selectable tolC cassette. (A) Two-step scarless
recombineering. tolC cassette diagramed in the Deletion
step: Boxes represent
the 100 bp homology regions, upright perpendiculars represent terminators,
bent arrows represent a promoter, and ⇀ represent binding sites
for deletion-screening primers. Insertion of the cassette (tolC) was positively selected
with SDS, then removal of the cassette (tolC) was negatively selected with ColE1
lysate + vancomycin. Carbenicillin maintained the λ-Red recombineering
plasmid. (B) Three genomic loci (11.5–22.0 kb) were targeted
for scarless deletion: the Flg operon, and the Qin/Kim
and CP4–57 cryptic prophages. (C) Electrophoresis gel showing
all steps of PCR deletion screening. No band is expected before deletion,
a larger band postdeletion (due to cassette insertion), and a smaller
band at the scarless stage.
Scarless deletion of three loci with a
dual-selectable tolC cassette. (A) Two-step scarless
recombineering. tolC cassette diagramed in the Deletion
step: Boxes represent
the 100 bp homology regions, upright perpendiculars represent terminators,
bent arrows represent a promoter, and ⇀ represent binding sites
for deletion-screening primers. Insertion of the cassette (tolC) was positively selected
with SDS, then removal of the cassette (tolC) was negatively selected with ColE1
lysate + vancomycin. Carbenicillin maintained the λ-Red recombineering
plasmid. (B) Three genomic loci (11.5–22.0 kb) were targeted
for scarless deletion: the Flg operon, and the Qin/Kim
and CP4–57 cryptic prophages. (C) Electrophoresis gel showing
all steps of PCR deletion screening. No band is expected before deletion,
a larger band postdeletion (due to cassette insertion), and a smaller
band at the scarless stage.The genomic regions targeted for deletion were the Qin/Kim (Q)
and CP4–57 (C) cryptic prophages, and the Flg operon (F), ranging in size from 11.5 kb to 22.0 kb [Figure B]. By repeatedly inserting
and then removing the tolC cassette, we were able
to sequentially perform scarless deletion of all three loci in the
same E. coli strain. We further
showed these deletions can be performed in multiple orders with similar
efficiency [Supporting Figure S4]. Overall,
this shows that tolC dual selection can be efficiently
used multiple times in a row with the ease of plating directly for
colonies at every step [Supporting Figure S5].Overall, we present an efficient method to prepare ColE1-based,
negative-selection plates at laboratory scale using cell lysate. Our
one-day lysate preparation protocol is shorter than previously reported,[13] reaching negative-selection stringency of 10–6 using lysate alone, and up to 10–7 in the presence of vancomycin, all in the absence of enhancing genotypes.
We show that the stringency of selection is maintained even when the
lysate is diluted 10-fold from its originally reported concentration,[13] producing over a hundred plates per batch (see Methods). We also show that ColE1 lysate can be
conveniently kept at 4 °C for 6 weeks [Supporting Figure S1], suggesting that tolC negative-selection
plates can be made in large batches and stored. Further characterization
is required to assess frozen lysate stability.It was previously
shown that other genetic modifications, such
as duplication of the tolQRA locus,[13] can further enhance the stringency of tolC negative selection. In this work, we show that the tolC gene alone provides a robust negative selection suitable for most
routine applications in wild type E. coli, including insertion and deletion of large genomic regions. Further
work is required to quantify the contribution of such modifications
to recombineering.Our work provides a streamlined, thorough,
and accessible method
to utilize the full potential of tolC negative selection
with minimal specialized equipment or protocols. Being relatively
short (1.5 kb), the tolC gene can be easily cloned
and expressed to enable efficient plasmid curing and multistep, scarless
recombineering. As the scale and complexity of genome editing projects
continues to increase, the mining and characterization of additional
dual-selection markers will greatly accelerate microbial engineering
and synthetic biology applications.
Methods
Strains and
Culture Methods
ColE1 was expressed from
strain JC411: Escherichia coli (Migula)
Castellani and Chalmers (ATCC #27138) (Escherichia
coliF–, leuB6(Am), fhuA2::IS2, lacY1, gln
X44(AS), gal-6, λ–, hisG1, rfbC1, galP63, argG6, rpsL104, malT1(λR), xyl-7, mtlA2, metB1).[20] All strains were grown in liquid
culture using the Miller formulation of lysogeny broth (LBM). TOP10 (“tolC”) cells from Invitrogen and TOP10·tolC (“tolC”) were used for testing.
TOP10·tolC was created from TOP10 using λ-Red recombineering and a 200
bp nonselectable Ultramer (from IDT) to scarlessly delete the endogenous tolC gene. It was directly selected for on LB-agar plates
containing 14 μL/mL of ColE1 lysate. It is important to mention
that tolC is part of the major efflux system for
many commonly used antibiotics. The minimum inhibitory concentrations
(MIC) of antibiotics may be altered when tolC is
deleted. We found that chloramphenicol was lethal to tolC cells regardless of the presence
of a resistance marker or concentration used.
Preparation of ColE1 Lysate
and LBM Plates Containing
Lysate + Vancomycin
JC411 was grown from a frozen glycerol
stock overnight (∼16 h) in 3 mL of LBM at 37 °C.
A 200 mL LBM production culture in a glass 1 L baffled
flask was inoculated with 400 μL of the overnight culture and
grown in a 37 °C shaking incubator (Innova 42) at 250 rpm. At
OD600 = 1.5, ColE1 production was induced by the addition
of mitomycin-C to a final concentration of 0.5 μg/mL. The flask
incubated further for 2 h. (Other expression parameters were compared
[Figure ].) The culture
was then aliquoted into four 50 mL Falcon tubes and the cells were
harvested by centrifugation at 5250 rcf for 40 min at 4 °C (Beckman
Coulter model Allegra X-15R). The cell pellets were frozen overnight
at −20 °C, if necessary. The pellets were pooled and washed
in 5 mL total of 50 mM K2HPO4 buffer (previously
titrated to pH = 7.6 with HCl). The cells were then centrifuged at
4500 rcf for 15 min at 4 °C and resuspended in 3 mL of buffer.
Sonication (QSonica model Q125, set at 50% power) was then performed
on ice in a 15 mL Falcon tube with a 2 mm diameter probe, outputting
7 W, in 10 s on/20 s off cycles for 5 min of sonication (15 min total
time). The resulting cell lysate was aliquoted into 1.5 mL microcentrifuge
tubes and clarified by centrifugation at 21 130 rcf for 30
min at 4 °C to remove cell debris (Eppendorf model 5424 R). Finally,
this lysate’s supernatant (containing ColE1) was filter-sterilized
through a 0.22 μm sterile filter (Corning cat. 431219) to remove
any surviving JC411 cells. This lysate was stored directly at 4 °C.
ColE1 agar plates (each 25 mL) were prepared by adding lysate (1.4
μL/mL) and vancomycin (128 μg/mL) directly to molten,
autoclaved LB-agar (LBM 25 g/L, agar 15 g/L) once the bottle
had cooled to approximately 60 °C, so as to not denature the
ColE1. Premixing vancomycin and lysate could cause precipitation and
uneven mixing. Control experiments using E. coli lacking ColE1 production (made from TOP10) did not inhibit growth
in the spot assay (data not shown). Protocol is formatted for convenience
in Supporting Figure S2.
ColE1 Spot
Assay
100 μL of a confluent TOP10
(tolC) culture at OD600 = 3 were spread per prewarmed 37 °C LB-agar plate.
After 30 min at room temperature, a 10-fold serial dilution of lysate
(each dilution made with a clean pipet tip) was made in 50 mM K2HPO4 buffer (previously titrated to pH = 7.6 with
HCl) and spotted (1 μL per spot) on the plate, left at room
temperature for 30 min upright until the spots were dry, and then
incubated upside-down at 37 °C for 16 h. The number of spots
showing clearly inhibited growth (a truly empty, not hazy region)
was recorded, and the maximum inhibitory dilution was thereby inferred.
The spot assay was used to compare the potency of ColE1 lysate which
had been produced from JC411 cells induced at either OD600 = 0.2, 1.5, or 3.0, for either 2 or 16 h [Figure D].
Escape Rate Assay
The selection
stringencies of lysate-only,
vancomycin-only, and lysate + vancomycin LB-agar plates at different
concentrations were tested. For lysate-only: the maximum concentration
of lysate (1×) was defined as 14 μL/mL and 10-fold dilutions
down to 10–3 were tested. Vancomycin-only: plates
were tested at 128 μg/mL and in 2-fold dilutions down to 16
μg/mL. Lysate + vancomycin: The same range of dilutions of lysate
was used as in the lysate-only experiment, while 128 μg/mL vancomycin
was maintained throughout. The number of tolC cells which escaped negative-selection and
formed colonies was determined by incubating dilutions of confluent
cell culture on these series of plates for 16 h at 37 °C. Plating
dilutions on LB-agar without selection allowed for redetermination
of the total CFU/mL for each biological replicate. To calculate an
escape rate, the total number of escapees/mL was divided by the total
number of CFU/mL without selection.
Mock Selection
In order to quantitatively model a recombinogenic
screen, tolC and tolC cultures were grown
overnight in LBM at 37 °C and their OD600 was measured to determine the number of cells. The cultures were
diluted and mixed to create cell ratios (tolC:tolC) of 101:1, 103:1, 105:1,
and 107:1. These mixtures were plated in triplicate on
LB-agar plates containing 14 μL of ColE1 lysate and 128 μg
vancomycin per 1 mL of LB-agar, and grown overnight at 37 °C.
From each plate, 96 colonies were PCR screened to infer what percentage
of them were the expected tolC cells. PCR primers targeted the endogenous tolC locus and the size of the amplified band determined if the cell
was tolC or tolC [Supporting Figure S3].
Scarless Deletion Demonstration
Three loci were chosen
for scarless deletion in the TOP10·tolC genome: the Flg operon
and the Qin/Kim and CP4–57 cryptic prophages [Figure B]. The tolC cassette without homology regions was ordered from Genewiz as a
clonal gene (TurboGENE). Extension primers (from IDT) were used to
PCR amplify each tolC cassette and add 100 bp of
genomic homology on each side [Supporting Figure S3, S7]. Amplified cassettes were DpnI restriction digested
(NEB #R0176) and their sizes were confirmed with gel electrophoresis
(Invitrogen E-gel EX 1%). Three 90 bp Ultramers (from IDT) were ordered,
each consisting of 45 bp from both outer ends of the homology regions
joined together [Figure A, Supporting Figure S3]. The TOP10·tolC strain was transformed
with pORTMAGE-2 (CarbR) plasmid (AddGene #72677). A single
colony was grown overnight in 3 mL of LBM + carbenicillin
(30 μg/mL) on a roller drum (New Brunswick model TC-7) at 60
rpm, 32 °C. 500 μL of this culture was passaged into 50
mL of LBM + carbenicillin (30 μg/mL) in a 250 mL
baffled flask and grown in a 32 °C shaking incubator (Innova
44) at 250 rpm until visibly turbid (OD600 < 0.6). Expression
of λ-Red recombinase from the pORTMAGE-2 plasmid was induced
by heat-shock in a shaking 42 °C water bath (Thermo Scientific
model MaxQ 7000) at 180 rpm for 14 min, then the culture was pelleted
at 5250 rcf for 14 min at 4 °C (Beckman Coulter model Allegra
X-15R). The supernatant was discarded, and the pellet was resuspended
in 1 mL of 4 °C ddH2O. The culture was spun down at
6500 rcf for 2 min 30 s at 4 °C (Eppendorf model 5424 R), then
washed identically three more times. Finally, the pellet was resuspended
in 150 μL of 4 °C ddH2O, and 40 μL of
those cells were mixed with 2 μL (1–2 ng) of tolC cassette. The culture was then electroporated in a
1 mm gap cuvette (Bio-Rad cat. 1652089) with an exponential decay
protocol of 1.8 kV, 200 Ω, and 25 μF (Bio-Rad GenePulser
Xcell). The culture was immediately resuspended with 1 mL of prewarmed
37 °C SOB medium (a.k.a. Hanahan’s Broth). The culture
was incubated overnight at 32 °C. The following day, 10% dilutions
(100 μL of culture), 10–3 dilutions (1 μL
culture + 99 μL LBM) and 10–5 dilutions
(100 μL from a mix of 1 μL culture + 10 mL LBM) of the culture were plated on LB-agar plates containing 50 μg/mL
sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and 30 μg/mL carbenicillin. After
two nights of incubation at 32 °C, 12 colonies were directly
PCR screened for the deletion of the target locus. A successful colony
was chosen for overnight growth at 32 °C in 3 mL LBM + SDS + carbenicillin (same concentrations). The induction and transformation
processes were repeated but starting with a 250 mL LBM +
SDS + carbenicillin culture and using 2 μL of Ultramer stock
solution (6 ng). After recovery in SOB, they were plated in dilutions
(as above) on LB-agar plates containing (per mL of LB-agar): 1.4 μL/mL
ColE1 lysate, 128 μg/mL vancomycin, and 30 μg/mL carbenicillin
and grown for two nights at 32 °C. Twelve colonies were PCR screened
for removal of the tolC cassette. This process was
iterated thrice in the same strain to scarlessly delete all three
targeted loci [Supporting Figure S4]. Geneious
Prime 2022.0.1 (https://www.geneious.com) was used for Sanger sequencing alignment and analysis [Supporting Figure S6].
Authors: Noah D Taylor; Alexander S Garruss; Rocco Moretti; Sum Chan; Mark A Arbing; Duilio Cascio; Jameson K Rogers; Farren J Isaacs; Sriram Kosuri; David Baker; Stanley Fields; George M Church; Srivatsan Raman Journal: Nat Methods Date: 2015-12-21 Impact factor: 28.547
Authors: Eric Cascales; Susan K Buchanan; Denis Duché; Colin Kleanthous; Roland Lloubès; Kathleen Postle; Margaret Riley; Stephen Slatin; Danièle Cavard Journal: Microbiol Mol Biol Rev Date: 2007-03 Impact factor: 11.056