Mineto Uchiyama1, Daichi Watanabe1, Yuhei Tanaka1, Kotaro Satoh2, Masami Kamigaito1. 1. Department of Molecular and Macromolecular Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering, Nagoya University, Furo-cho, Chikusa-ku, Nagoya 464-8603, Japan. 2. Department of Chemical Science and Engineering, School of Materials and Chemical Technology, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 2-12-1-H120 Ookayama, Meguro-ku, Tokyo 152-8550, Japan.
Abstract
Benzofuran (BzF) is a prochiral, 1,2-disubstituted, unsymmetric cyclic olefin that can afford optically active polymers by asymmetric polymerization, unlike common acyclic vinyl monomers. Although asymmetric cationic polymerization of BzF was reported by Natta et al. in the 1960s, the polymer structure has not been clarified, and there are no reports on molecular weight control. Herein, we report dual control of the optical activity and molecular weight of poly(BzF) using thioether-based reversible chain-transfer agents for asymmetric cationic polymerization with β-amino acid derivatives as chiral additives and aluminum chloride as a catalyst. This asymmetric moderately living cationic polymerization leads to an increase in molecular weight and specific optical rotation with monomer conversion. In addition, asymmetric block polymers consisting of opposite absolute configurational segments were synthesized using both enantiomers sequentially as chiral additives. Finally, a comprehensive analysis of the polymerization products and the model reaction revealed that the optical activity of poly(BzF) originates from the threo-diisotactic structure, which occurs by regio-, trans-, and enantioselective propagation.
Benzofuran (BzF) is a prochiral, 1,2-disubstituted, unsymmetric cyclic olefin that can afford optically active polymers by asymmetric polymerization, unlike common acyclic vinyl monomers. Although asymmetric cationic polymerization of BzF was reported by Natta et al. in the 1960s, the polymer structure has not been clarified, and there are no reports on molecular weight control. Herein, we report dual control of the optical activity and molecular weight of poly(BzF) using thioether-based reversible chain-transfer agents for asymmetric cationic polymerization with β-amino acid derivatives as chiral additives and aluminum chloride as a catalyst. This asymmetric moderately living cationic polymerization leads to an increase in molecular weight and specific optical rotation with monomer conversion. In addition, asymmetric block polymers consisting of opposite absolute configurational segments were synthesized using both enantiomers sequentially as chiral additives. Finally, a comprehensive analysis of the polymerization products and the model reaction revealed that the optical activity of poly(BzF) originates from the threo-diisotactic structure, which occurs by regio-, trans-, and enantioselective propagation.
Optically active natural
macromolecules with highly controlled
structures, such as proteins, deoxyribonucleic acids, and polysaccharides,
possess unique and specialized functions that are indispensable for
maintaining our lives. This constantly motivates research on the controlled
synthesis of optically active polymers, which have unique structures
and functions that can improve our modern life.[1−3]Vinyl
polymers are one of the largest families of synthetic polymers
and are obtained by the chain-growth polymerization of a wide variety
of olefinic compounds.[4,5] They are generally synthesized
from prochiral vinyl (CH2=CHX) or vinylidene (CH2=CXY) monomers and can possess asymmetric carbons (∼CH2–C*HX∼ or ∼CH2–C*XY∼)
in the main chains.[6−9] However, these vinyl polymers rarely show optical activity, even
if their asymmetric carbons are structured to have high isotacticity
with only one type of chiral center consisting of consecutive R or S sequences.[1] This is because the whole polymer chain can be regarded as having
a mirror plane, where the chain end groups are ignored due to the
long polymer chains, i.e., the chiral center in the main chain is
pseudoasymmetric. However, when the side chain has a very bulky substituent,
the one-handed helical conformation of the main chain is conserved,
resulting in optically active vinyl polymers as a special case.[1−3]Benzofuran (BzF) is a prochiral, 1,2-disubstituted, and unsymmetric
cyclic olefin with both vinyl ether- and styrene-like structures (Scheme ). This monomer readily
undergoes cationic polymerization to form rigid polymers with high
glass-transition temperature (Tg) and
high transparency, which is applicable to transparent thermoplastics.[10−14] Recently, it attracted further attention as a biobased and chemically
recyclable monomer from a sustainable viewpoint.[13,14] In 1961, Natta et al. reported the synthesis of optically active
polymers by the cationic polymerization of BzF using aluminum catalysts
(AlCl3 or EtAlCl2) and asymmetric cocatalysts
(β-phenylalanine or 10-camphorsulfonic acid) in toluene at −75
°C.[15] The optical activity can be
ascribed to main chain configurational chirality because in principle,
an ideal structure of diisotactic poly(BzF) with both erythro- and
threo-structures does not have a mirror plane, unlike the common vinyl
polymers mentioned above.[16−18] Since then, but at the latest
in the 1960s, similar asymmetric (asymmetric synthesis, asymmetric
induction, or asymmetric chirogenic)[9] cationic
polymerizations predominantly forming one type of chiral center in
the main chain have been reported for BzF and related unsymmetrical
cyclic olefins.[19−21] However, it is still unknown whether threo- or erythro-structures
are constructed as well as whether vinyl ether- or styrene-type cations
form. Namely, cis- or trans-addition and 1,2- or 2,1-addition are
not clarified. In addition, dual control of the chirality and molecular
weight of poly(BzF) has not been attained. Later, in the 2010s, only
moderate molecular weight control was reported using an achiral initiating
system consisting of cumyl chloride and SnCl4 in CH2Cl2 at −78 °C.[22] Novel polymerization methods for controlling both the chirality
and molecular weight of poly(BzF) can not only clarify the asymmetric
polymerization mechanisms but also lead to unique optically active
polymer materials with highly controlled structures.
Scheme 1
Asymmetric
Living Cationic Polymerization of Benzofuran (BzF) Based
on Reversible Chain-Transfer Mechanism
Recently, we developed a novel method to control molecular weight
in the cationic polymerization of vinyl monomers using a reversible
or degenerative chain-transfer (DT) mechanism, where the propagating
cationic chain end dynamically interchanges with the dormant species
originating from reversible chain-transfer agents (CTAs).[23−29] The effective CTAs are thioesters and thioethers, which control
the molecular weight of the resulting polymers as in radical reversible
addition–fragmentation chain-transfer (RAFT) polymerization
and work for various cationically polymerizable monomers, such as
vinyl ethers and p-alkoxystyrenes. This cationic
RAFT or DT process is applicable even for stereospecific cationic
polymerization to enable simultaneous control of the molecular weight
and tacticity of vinyl polymers. Indeed, stereospecific cationic RAFT
and DT polymerizations have been achieved for vinyl ethers and α-methylstyrene
by the judicious choice of counteranions in terms of bulkiness and/or
chirality.[30−33] However, no asymmetric RAFT or DT polymerization and no dual control
of optical activity and molecular weight have been realized in cationic
polymerization.[28−36]Herein, we report the asymmetric living cationic polymerization
of BzF, where both molecular weight and optical activity are controlled
using thioether as CTA in conjunction with chiral N-substituted β-phenylalanines
and AlCl3 as chiral catalysts. In particular, bulky chiral
β-phenylalanine derivatives provide much higher specific optical
rotation than that reported with native β-phenylalanine, while
an appropriate thioether controls the polymer molecular weight up
to several tens of thousands. A detailed analysis of the products
obtained in the polymerization and its model reaction reveals that
the asymmetric cationic polymerization proceeds via the selective
trans-threo addition of vinyl ether-type cation and that the optical
activity is a consequence of triple selectivities: in terms of regio-,
trans-, and enantio- selectivity. Furthermore, an asymmetric block
polymer is prepared using a pair of β-phenylalanine-based enantiomers
sequentially as opposite chiral additives.
Results and Discussion
Asymmetric
Cationic Polymerization Using Chiral Amino Acid Derivatives
To reinvestigate and improve the asymmetric cationic polymerization
of BzF, various chiral α- and β-amino acids and their
derivatives were employed in conjunction with AlCl3 as
a Lewis acid catalyst in toluene at −78 °C. Here, AlCl3 and a chiral additive were premixed at a 2:1 ratio in toluene
at 20 °C for 24 h, according to a previous report.[15] Although each of them was mostly insoluble in
toluene, the mixed catalyst solution became homogeneous during aging,
indicating the formation of aluminum compounds complexed with chiral
amino acid derivatives. This solution was used as a mixed catalyst
for the cationic polymerization of BzF.With (S)- α-phenylalanine ((S)-1), an
α-amino acid, almost no polymerization occurred, most likely
due to the significant loss of the Lewis acidity of AlCl3 by its strong chelation (entry 1 in Table ). Although protection of the amino group
with tert-butoxycarbonyl (t-Boc)
enabled the polymerization, the optical activity of the resulting
polymer was very low ([α]D25 = −0.7) (entry 6). On the other hand,
with the β-amino acid, i.e., (S)-β-phenylalanine
((S)-2), which was used in a previous
report,[15] polymerization proceeded and
resulted in polymers with high molecular weight (Mn = 1.50 × 105) and low specific optical
rotation ([α]D25 = +8.6) (entry 2). The optical activity was lower than the
reported value ([α]D25 = +56.7),[15] while
the polymerization conditions were the same.
Table 1
Asymmetric
Cationic Polymerization
of BzF Using Various Chiral Additivesa
entry
chiral additive
time (h)
conv (%)b
Mnc
Mw/Mnc
[α]D25d
1
(S)-1
62
9
2
(S)-2
44
92
150 000
2.48
+8.6
3
(R)-2
50
97
164 000
2.34
–7.3
4
(R)-3
63
82
130 000
2.17
+15.9
5
(S)-4
100
91
146 000
2.61
+9.5
6
(S)-1a
4
99
183 000
2.65
–0.7
7
(S)-2a
42
99
98 000
2.35
+52.7
8
(S)-2b
6
99
227 000
3.86
+65.0
9
(S)-2c
19
95
280 000
2.61
+66.0
10
(S)-2d
2
93
516 000
2.29
+93.4
11
(S)-2e
0.5
99
344 000
2.41
+72.2
12
(S)-2f
6
94
306 000
2.48
+0.8
Condition: [BzF]0/[AlCl3]0/[chiral additive]0 = 200/40/20 mM
in toluene at −78 °C.
Determined by 1H NMR.
Determined by size-exclusion chromatography
(SEC).
Measured in tetrahydrofuran
(THF).
Condition: [BzF]0/[AlCl3]0/[chiral additive]0 = 200/40/20 mM
in toluene at −78 °C.Determined by 1H NMR.Determined by size-exclusion chromatography
(SEC).Measured in tetrahydrofuran
(THF).On the other hand,
its enantiomer, (R)-β-phenylalanine
((R)-2), afforded polymers with almost
the same molecular weight (Mn = 1.64 ×
105) and the opposite optical rotation with a similar absolute
value (−7.3) (entry 3), indicating that the optical rotation
of the polymers was determined by the chirality of the β-amino
acid. Furthermore, other β-amino acids with alkyl groups, (R)-aminobutyric acid ((R)-3) and (S)-β-homovaline ((S)-4), which have the same absolute configuration as
that of (S)-2, also gave optically active
polymers with similarly positive optical rotations, +15.9 and +9.5,
respectively (entries 4 and 5). Thus, β-amino acids were effective
chiral additives for the asymmetric cationic polymerization of BzF
in conjunction with AlCl3.To further improve the
optical activity, substituted β-phenylalanine
derivatives were synthesized and employed. When (S)-2a with a t-Boc-substituted amino
group was used, the specific optical rotation of the resulting polymer
dramatically increased (+52.7) (entry 7). On the other hand, the polymer
obtained with (S)-2f, in which the carboxy
group was esterified with a methyl group, showed almost no optical
activity (entry 12). The carboxylic acid group in β-phenylalanine
seemed essential for asymmetric induction into poly(BzF), and the
substituents on the amino groups could improve the enantioselectivity.Then, various (S)-β-phenylalanine derivatives
with acetyl ((S)-2b), benzoyl ((S)-2c), pivaloyl ((S)-2d), and isopropyl ((S)-2e)
substituents on the amino group were prepared. All of these N-substituted β-amino acids afforded high-molecular-weight
polymers with high specific optical rotations over +50 (entries 8–11).
In particular, (S)-2d with a bulky pivaloyl
group showed the highest value (+93.4), indicating that bulkiness
around the nitrogen atom improved the enantioselectivity during propagation.
Thus, N-substituted β-amino acid derivatives functioned efficiently
as chiral additives for the asymmetric cationic polymerization of
BzF in the presence of AlCl3. In particular, bulky substituted
groups on the amino group significantly improved the enantioselectivity.The feed ratio of AlCl3 and chiral additives was also
investigated (Table S1). The use of a higher
amount of (S)-2a (AlCl3/(S)-2a = 1:2 and 1:1) deactivated the polymerization.
In contrast, a very fast polymerization occurred at a smaller amount
of (S)-2a (AlCl3/(S)-2a = 1:0.25) to give polymers with almost
no optical activity. Although polymerization occurred at AlCl3/(S)-2a = 1:0.67, the optical
activity was low. In addition, without premixing the catalysts, the
optical activity became slightly lower. These results indicate that
premixed catalyst at a 1:0.50 ratio of AlCl3 of (S)-2a is most efficient for the asymmetric
cationic polymerization. Although the isolation and determination
of aluminum complexes with β-amino acid derivatives are still
under investigation, the enantioselectivity is governed by the chiral
counteranions generated in situ from the chiral additives and Lewis
acids.
Asymmetric Living Cationic Polymerization via Reversible Chain
Transfer to Thioether
To achieve dual control of the optical
activity and molecular weight of the resulting polymers, asymmetric
living cationic polymerization of BzF was investigated using reversible
CTAs in the presence of chiral catalysts. Here, an aromatic thioether
(CTA1), a thiophenol adduct of p-methoxystyrene,
was used as CTA since it has been reported that thioethers function
efficiently for both vinyl ether and styrene derivatives.[24,30] The chiral additives used herein were unsubstituted ((S)-2), t-Boc-substituted ((S)-2a), and pivaloyl-substituted ((S)-2d) (S)- β-phenylalanines,
among which the last was the most effective in asymmetric cationic
polymerization, as mentioned above.Even in the presence of CTA1, all polymerizations proceeded almost quantitatively
without a significant decrease in the catalytic activity in toluene
at −78 °C (Figure S1). Upon
the addition of CTA1, the molecular weight of the obtained
polymers drastically decreased from one hundred thousand to several
thousands and agreed well with theoretical values, assuming that one
polymer chain was generated from one CTA molecule (Figure and entries 1, 6, and 9 in Table S2). In addition, a linear increase in
the Mn values to the monomer conversion
as well as relatively narrow and unimodal molecular weight distribution
(MWD) curves (Mw/Mn = 1.3–1.5) was observed throughout the polymerizations,
indicating that CTA1 could efficiently function as a
reversible chain-transfer agent in the cationic polymerization of
BzF.
Figure 1
Mn and SEC curves of the polymers obtained
in asymmetric living cationic polymerization of BzF using CTA1: [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl3]0/[chiral additive]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in
toluene at −78 °C.
Mn and SEC curves of the polymers obtained
in asymmetric living cationic polymerization of BzF using CTA1: [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl3]0/[chiral additive]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in
toluene at −78 °C.The polymer obtained with CTA1 and (S)-2d was then analyzed by 1H NMR and MALDI-TOF-MS
(Figure ). The proton
signals ascribed to the repeating BzF units were relatively sharp,
suggesting high stereoregularity, which will be discussed later. In
addition, small but characteristic signals assignable to methoxy (d)
and methyl (a) protons at the α-end originating from CTA1 were observed at 3.7 and 1.0–1.3 ppm, respectively. The molecular
weight (Mn(NMR)) calculated using the
integral ratios of the repeating units to the α-end was close
to that obtained by SEC (Mn(SEC)). The
MALDI-TOF-MS spectra showed almost only one main series of peaks separated
by 118 Da, which corresponds to the molar mass of BzF. The absolute
molar masses of the individual peaks were nearly the same as those
of poly(BzF), with both α- and ω-chain ends derived from CTA1, indicating that almost all of the polymer chains were
generated from CTA1 and reversibly terminated by the
thiophenol moiety to possess high chain end fidelity, which can be
used as macro CTA later.
Figure 2
1H NMR (A) (CDCl3, 55
°C) and MALDI-TOF-MS
(B) spectra of poly(BzF) obtained in asymmetric living cationic polymerization
of BzF using CTA1 and (S)-2d.
1H NMR (A) (CDCl3, 55
°C) and MALDI-TOF-MS
(B) spectra of poly(BzF) obtained in asymmetric living cationic polymerization
of BzF using CTA1 and (S)-2d.To further investigate the controllability
of molecular weight,
the feed ratio of BzF to CTA1 was changed (Figure S2). The Mn of the obtained polymers increased in direct proportion to the product
of the feed ratio ([BzF]0/[CTA1]0) and conversion by at least 30 000, where all polymers possessed
relatively narrow MWDs. These results indicate that the moderately
living cationic polymerization of BzF is achievable using a thioether
as a reversible chain-transfer agent.Then, we considered the
optical activity of the polymers obtained
in the presence of CTA1 and β-phenylalanine derivatives.
All of the obtained polymers showed optical activity, and the absolute
values of specific optical rotation were higher than those obtained
in the absence of CTA (Figure ; entries 6 and 9 in Table S2 vs
entries 7 and 10 in Table , respectively), except for the case with (S)-2, in which opposite optical rotation was observed
(Figure ; entry 1
in Table S2 vs entry 3 in Table ). In particular, the polymer
obtained with (S)-2d in the presence
of CTA1 showed the highest optical rotation (+123.5).
In addition, the formation of chiral pol(BzF) was confirmed by circular
dichroism (CD) (Figure S3). Similar CD
spectra as well as positive specific optical rotations were also observed
for those obtained with (S)-2a and (S)-2b (Figure S3 and entries 6 and 8 in Table S2).Thus, dual control of the optical activity and molecular weight
of poly(BzF), i.e., asymmetric living cationic polymerization of BzF,
was achieved using thioether as a chain-transfer agent and β-amino
acid derivatives as chiral additives in the presence of Lewis acid
catalysts.
Asymmetric Block Polymerization
This success prompted
us to examine the synthesis of asymmetric block copolymers. Prior
to this, we used each enantiomer of 2a, i.e., (S)-2a and (R)-2a, for living cationic polymerization of BzF with CTA1 and AlCl3. The polymerizations proceeded at almost the
same rate (Figure A) and produced polymers with almost the same molecular weight, which
similarly increased with monomer conversions, maintaining a unimodal
and narrow distribution (Figure S4). As
in the polymers obtained without CTA, each polymer showed opposite
optical activity with similar absolute values (entries 6 and 7 in Table S2). More interestingly, in both cases,
the absolute values of the optical specific rotations increased with
increasing the molecular weights, and the plots were almost mirror
images (Figure B).
Moreover, the obtained polymers exhibited mirror-imaged CD spectra
(Figure C). In addition,
the lack of dependence of the CD spectra on the measured temperature
suggests that the optical activity results not from conformational
chirality but from configurational chirality in the main chains (Figure S5). Thus, (S)-2a and (R)-2a gave moderately
living polymers with opposite main chain configurational chirality
when used with CTA1 and AlCl3.
Figure 3
Time-conversion curves
for asymmetric living cationic polymerization
using enantiomer additives (S)-2a and
(R)-2a (A), Mn-specific rotation ([α]D25) (B), and CD spectra (C) of the obtained
polymers; [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl]3/[(S)-2a or (R)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene at −78
°C.
Time-conversion curves
for asymmetric living cationic polymerization
using enantiomer additives (S)-2a and
(R)-2a (A), Mn-specific rotation ([α]D25) (B), and CD spectra (C) of the obtained
polymers; [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl]3/[(S)-2a or (R)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene at −78
°C.The asymmetric block polymerization
was then examined using (S)-2a and (R)-2a sequentially as chiral additives in the
cationic DT polymerization
based on the dormant thioether terminal. Poly(BzF) with thioether
terminals could be isolated and used as a macro CTA because the thioether
group was stable, and its amount was maintained quantitatively, as
indicated by the 1H NMR and MALDI-TOF-MS (see above). The
asymmetric moderately living cationic polymerization was thus conducted
using (S)-2a in the presence of CTA1 and AlCl3 to obtain optically active polymers
with a positive specific optical rotation (+49.3) and controlled molecular
weight (Mn = 7100, Mw/Mn = 1.40) (Figure A).
Figure 4
SEC curves (A) and Mn and specific
rotation (B) of asymmetric stereoblock polymers obtained in asymmetric
living cationic polymerization using macro CTA and (R)-2a: [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl3]0/[(S)-2a]0 = [BzF]0/[macro CTA]0/[AlCl3]0/[(R)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene at −78 °C.
SEC curves (A) and Mn and specific
rotation (B) of asymmetric stereoblock polymers obtained in asymmetric
living cationic polymerization using macro CTA and (R)-2a: [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl3]0/[(S)-2a]0 = [BzF]0/[macro CTA]0/[AlCl3]0/[(R)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene at −78 °C.The obtained polymer, which was isolated by precipitation
in methanol,
was employed as a macro CTA for the next asymmetric cationic DT polymerization
of BzF with (R)-2a as the enantiomer
additive. The second polymerization also proceeded smoothly, leading
to a further shift of the unimodal SEC curve to a high molecular weight
(Figure A). The Mn values increased in direct proportion to monomer
conversion and agreed well with the theoretical values (filled red
circles in Figure B), indicating that block polymerization successfully proceeded using
the macro CTA. On the other hand, the optical activity decreased in
direct proportion to monomer conversion from +49.3 to +6.1 (open red
circles in Figure B). With this change, the intensity of the CD signals gradually decreased
and finally approached zero (Figure S6).
Thus, the synthesis of an asymmetric stereoblock polymer, which consists
of two segments with opposite absolute configurations of asymmetric
carbon in the main chain, was successfully achieved using each enantiomer
sequentially as chiral additives in the cationic DT polymerization.
Regio- and Stereospecificity in Asymmetric Cationic Polymerization
In this final part, regio- and stereospecificity in the asymmetric
cationic polymerization of BzF were analyzed comprehensively. There
are two possibilities: that the propagation of BzF occurs via a vinyl
ether- or styryl-type cation, i.e., 2,1- or 1,2-addition, although
the regioselectivity has not been clarified.[10−12] To reveal this,
we prepared two thioether regioisomers, CTA2 and CTA3, which are both thiophenol adducts of BzF and can generate
a vinyl ether- and styryl-type cation of BzF, respectively. We employed
them in the asymmetric cationic polymerization of BzF with (S)-2a and AlCl3 in toluene at −78
°C.With CTA2, which can generate vinyl ether-type
cations via chain transfer, the polymerization proceeded smoothly,
although it became slower at the later stage in comparison to that
with CTA1 (Figure A). The SEC curves shifted to high molecular weight, although
a slight shoulder was observed at high monomer conversion (Figure B). On the other
hand, polymerization did not occur using CTA3, suggesting
that CTA3 could not generate the styryl-type cation and
acted as an inhibitor rather than a chain-transfer agent by forming
a stable sulfonium intermediate due to a stronger C–S bond
of CTA3. These results indicate that CTA2, which can generate a more stable oxocarbenium cation, functions
efficiently as a CTA and that asymmetric cationic propagation occurs
by forming a vinyl ether-type cation via predominant 2,1-addition.
Furthermore, model cationic addition reactions between CH3CH(OiBu)Cl and BzF with SnCl4/nBu4NCl indicated that 2,1-addition predominantly
occurred in toluene at −78 °C (2.1-/1.2- = 79/21), although
the regioselectivity was opposite in CH2Cl2 (2.1-/1.2-
= 14/86) (see Figure S7).[37]
Figure 5
Time-conversion curves (A) and SEC curves (B) for asymmetric living
cationic polymerization using CTA2 or CTA3: [BzF]0/[CTA2 or CTA3]0/[AlCl3]0/[(S)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene at −78
°C.
Time-conversion curves (A) and SEC curves (B) for asymmetric living
cationic polymerization using CTA2 or CTA3: [BzF]0/[CTA2 or CTA3]0/[AlCl3]0/[(S)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene at −78
°C.To examine solvent effects on
the asymmetric moderately living
cationic polymerization, CH2Cl2 was used for
BzF in conjunction with CTA1, AlCl3, and (R)-2a at −78 °C. The polymerization
was faster in CH2Cl2 than in toluene due to
the higher polarity, which is generally true in cationic polymerizations
(Figure S8). Although the molecular weights
of the resulting polymers were close to the theoretical values at
low monomer conversion, they became gradually higher at high monomer
conversion, suggesting that Friedel–Crafts reactions between
polymer chains occurred due to more dissociated cationic propagation
species in CH2Cl2. Furthermore, the specific
optical rotation of the polymer obtained in CH2Cl2 was lost (+1.0), whereas that obtained in toluene was −77.3.
These results indicate that the choice of the solvent is important
and that toluene is suitable for attaining dual control of the molecular
weight and optical activity of the resulting polymers.The polymers
obtained in toluene and CH2Cl2 were analyzed
in more detail by 1H and 13C
NMR to clarify the stereostructures. The 1H NMR spectrum
of the polymers obtained in CH2Cl2 showed broader
peaks than those obtained in toluene (Figure A,B), indicating lower stereoregularity in
CH2Cl2. The stereoregularity was evaluated in
more detail by 13C NMR, in which the characteristic peak
of methine carbon (47–50 ppm) in the main chain attached to
the phenyl group was used (Figures C,D, and S9). In particular,
the polymers obtained in toluene showed a very sharp peak at 49 ppm
and a small distinctive peak at approximately 48 ppm. The peaks at
49 (X) and 48 ppm (Y) can be most probably ascribed to the trans-threo
and cis-erythro enchainments of the BzF unit, respectively, according
to the 13C NMR spectra of trans- and cis-2,3-dihydoro-2,3-dimethyl
benzofuran as model compounds and poly(2,3-dihydrofuran) as similar
cyclic vinyl ether polymers, where the peaks observed at a lower and
higher magnetic filed were assigned to the trans- and cis-carbons,
respectively.[38−41] The peak intensity ratio of X/Y was 95:5, indicating a high trans-threo
selectivity during cationic polymerization with AlCl3 and
(R)-2a in toluene at −78 °C.
This ratio was almost the same as that obtained without CTA1 (Figure S10). In contrast, in the 13C NMR spectrum of the polymers obtained in CH2Cl2, a peak assignable to the cis structure
became more visible, and additional peaks at 49–50 ppm became
larger, where the X/Y ratio was 89:11. Although the exact stereostructures
of poly(BzF) are difficult to determine due to possible concurrent
2,1- and 1,2-progation, which could affect the peak shapes, it can
be concluded that trans-threo addition is at least predominant in
toluene at −78 °C. Thermal properties of the obtained
polymers with different tacticities and different optical activities
were evaluated by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) (Figure S11). All polymers showed nearly the same
high Tgs (184–189 °C) and
no melting temperatures irrespective of their different stereostructures.
Figure 6
1H NMR (A, B) and 13C NMR (C, D) spectra
(CDCl3, 55 °C) of the polymers obtained in asymmetric
living cationic polymerization of BzF in toluene (A, C) and CH2Cl2 (B, D): [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl3]0/[(R)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene or CH2Cl2 at −78 °C.
1H NMR (A, B) and 13C NMR (C, D) spectra
(CDCl3, 55 °C) of the polymers obtained in asymmetric
living cationic polymerization of BzF in toluene (A, C) and CH2Cl2 (B, D): [BzF]0/[CTA1]0/[AlCl3]0/[(R)-2a]0 = 200/4.0/40/20 mM in toluene or CH2Cl2 at −78 °C.Based on these results, the stereostructures of the optically active
poly(BzF) can be elucidated. Since BzF is a 1,2-disubstituted cyclic
unsymmetric monomer, there are four possible tactic stereostructures
for poly(BzF), i.e., threo-diisotactic, threo-disyndiotactic, erythro-diisotactic,
and erythro-disyndiotactic (Figure ).[6,8,16−18] Although the four stereoregular structures are chiral
due to the absence of mirror planes in the polymer chains, only threo-diisotactic
and erythro-diisotactic structures can become optically active because
they are composed of enantiomeric trans-threo and cis-erythro sequences,
respectively. The threo-disyndiotactic and erythro-disyndiotactic
poly(BzF)s are also chiral, but their optical activities may be negligibly
small because they consist of racemic trans-threo and cis-erythro
sequences, respectively. Considering that optically active poly(BzF)
obtained in toluene consisted predominantly of trans-threo-structures,
the main structure of poly(BzF) obtained in the asymmetric cationic
polymerization is threo-diisotactic, which has been clarified since
the first discovery of optically active poly(BzF) by Natta in 1961.
Figure 7
Possible
tactic stereostructures of poly(BzF).
Possible
tactic stereostructures of poly(BzF).
Conclusions
Dual control of the optical activity and molecular
weight of poly(BzF)
was achieved using optically active β-amino acid derivatives
as chiral additives and thioethers as reversible chain-transfer agents
in the presence of AlCl3 as Lewis acid catalysts. The configurational
chirality of the main chains was achieved by enantioselective propagation
induced by the chiral catalysts, while the molecular weight was controlled
by reversible chain transfer between the growing cationic species
and dormant C–S terminals. The asymmetric living cationic polymerization
enabled the synthesis of an asymmetric block polymer consisting of
segments with opposite absolute configurations. Furthermore, a comprehensive
analysis of the resulting polymers and model reactions revealed that
the optical activity of poly(BzF) originates from a threo-diisotactic
structure, which is a consequence of triple selectivity (enantio-,
stereo-, and regioselectivity) during cationic propagation. Thus,
the high versatility and applicability of the cationic DT mechanism
for enabling molecular weight control is confirmed even in asymmetric
polymerization and widens the scope of precision polymer synthesis
for multiple-factor control of polymer structures.
Authors: Aaron J Teator; Travis P Varner; Phil C Knutson; Cole C Sorensen; Frank A Leibfarth Journal: ACS Macro Lett Date: 2020-10-28 Impact factor: 6.903
Authors: Phil C Knutson; Aaron J Teator; Travis P Varner; Caleb T Kozuszek; Paige E Jacky; Frank A Leibfarth Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2021-10-01 Impact factor: 15.419