| Literature DB >> 35653044 |
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Regardless of its form, financing health in isolation will never raise sufficient funds to lead to universal health coverage. Achieving this goal which is not a pure health policy, requires multisectoral collaboration to support financing mechanisms. Within this framework, the World Health Organization has created the Health Financing Progress Matrix to assess a country's progress in health financing. The World Health Organization calls for multisectoral support for health financing systems to achieve universal health coverage. This paper aims to explain how health diplomacy can be defined and implemented to influence and facilitate multisectoral participation in fighting against fragmentation and increase necessary budget to internalize the health financing progress matrix in Burundi. MAIN TEXT: Burundi's health financing system is characterized by multiple fragmentation of resources and services, which reinforces economic and health inequities, referred to as de-universalization of universal health coverage. The health financing system in Burundi is inadequate to meet the health needs of the population. Different people with different needs form different segments, and coverage may be inconsistent, duplicative, or incomplete. Health diplomacy can alleviate this situation by appointing health finance attachés in each of the 19 sectors that make up the life of the country. Health finance attachés may have three main tasks:1) promoting confidence building, 2) seeking consensus, and 3) building solidarity for universal health coverage. The practices of health finance attachés can help to improve budget for more coverage. Following the World Health Organization's progress matrix on health financing, internalization can be achieved in four ways: (i) raising the profile of health diplomats to be accredited in non-health sectors, (ii) establishing offices of health finance attachés in each sector, (iii) creating means by which sectors benefiting from internalization act, (iv) operationalizing proportionate universal health coverage.Entities:
Keywords: De-universalization; Health diplomacy; Health financing progress matrix; Health gap; Health gradient; Internalization; Multisectoral collaboration; Proportionate universalism; Universal health coverage
Year: 2022 PMID: 35653044 PMCID: PMC9161612 DOI: 10.1186/s13561-022-00376-w
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Health Econ Rev ISSN: 2191-1991
The WHO matrix description
The WHO matrix contains guiding principles expressed in the form of seven assessment areas and nineteen desirable attributes both summarized here in four main components: • Multisectoral collaboration in financing, • Improving predictable and stable budget through financial and non-financial support, • Ensuring coordination of funds to prevent, avoid or alleviate fragmentation, and • Providing timely financial data to inform priority services to be improved. | |
The purpose of this health financing assessment tool at country level, is to provide annual evidence-based feedback to policy makers about gaps and enhancements to be made to accelerate progress on UHC. The WHO matrix recommends country assessment findings to be stated in the form of four progress levels: | |
| Emerging | No clear policy that guides implementation or practices |
| Progressing | There is policy under development with some aspects being implemented |
| Established | There is approuved policy which is being implemented, assessed, and regularly adjusted to comply with the international standards |
| Advanced | There is approuved policy aligned with the international standards, disseminated in all sectors, effectivelly implemented nationally, and with systematic annual assessment to inform policy design improvements and implementation. |
| With this progress matrix, the WHO has launched a call for multisectoral participation, such as bringing all stakeholders to the table, assessing together, closing gaps together, and jointly creating a national progress matrix [ | |
Structural fragmentation of financial coverage
| Vertical fragment 1 | Vertical fragment 2 | Vertical fragment 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
*From taxes, prices, and donors; *For formal and informal people; *Covering institutional functioning and vertical diseases programs | *From payroll deductions and individual contributions; *For informal people, private sector formal workers, and geographical areas; *Covering specific and limited set of services. | * From payroll deductions; * For civil servants and security bodies; *Covering a specific and limited set of services. | |
| Medical Assistance Card | Medical assistance card | National Office for Pensions and Occupational Risks | |
| Performance-Based Financing and Free Healthcare | Community-based health insurances (more than 125 micro-insurance) | National Institute of Social Security | |
| Fee exemption for needy people | Private health insurances (more than 10) | Public Service Health Insurance | |
| Foreign aid | Out-of-pocket payments | ||
| Government’s share | |||
| Foreign aid | |||
Source: Adapted from [29, 32],
Menu of recommended ways for the WHO matrix internalization in each sector
| Receiving sectors | Recommended ways to internalize the WHO matrix nationwide | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Agriculture | Introduce mechanisms for taxing non-agricultural property based on the size of the non-agricultural property. For example, taxation of USD 0.005 per area per year should encourage people to use their landholdings, increase land revenue [ |
| 2 | Breeding | Increase taxes on the sale of domestic animals to keep enough domestic animals and get more organic fertilizer on the land. More organic fertilizer should increase farm income – this should improve individual economic status [ |
| 3 | Peach | Introduce an annual boat registration system to increase annual taxation on boats and watercraft – this should help increase tax revenue [ |
| 4 | Trade | Increasing purchase taxes on non-essential consumer goods such as jewelry, more expensive clothing, electronic devices, etc. is intended to reduce disposable personal income to encourage people to buy less of these non-essential goods. In this sense, only people with higher economic status will consume non-essential goods and give a job. The health gradient will remain at a certain level which will enable economic growth [ |
| 5 | Mining | Raising taxes on mining production, import, and export to an optimal level will ensure that the mining sector contributes significantly to the maximum reduction of the health gradient between citizens and society as a whole [ |
| 6 | Industry | Expansion of the progressive industrial tax system, where rich industries are taxed more than poor ones (because their ability to pay increases as their income increases). This progressive tax system aims to distribute income equitably [ |
| 7 | Energy | Introduce a tax on fuel at the pump - levy a tax on the amount of fuel purchased at the pump (e.g. 0.5 USD per liter consumed) to raise public revenue [ |
| 8 | Transport | The introduction of a tax on airline tickets for all flights out of the country is a consistent source of revenue for heath [ |
| 9 | Justice | Introduce a legalized and regulated model of sin and luxury taxes from six main areas: (i) tobacco use, (ii) alcohol and cannabis use, (iii) sugary drinks, (iv) gambling, (v) sex work [ |
| 10 | Security | Dividend for health – reducing defense spending and reallocating funds to health is intended to help create and maintain peace, the only indicator of economic growth [ |
| 11 | Infrastructure | Increase the share of property tax – an annual property tax should lead to a successful valuation of land and be the nation’s own predictable, efficient and equitable revenue source [ |
| 12 | Religion | Organize annual crowdfunding for health – a channel for fundraising to finance health through awareness-raising campaigns [ |
| 13 | Public administration | (i) Strengthen mechanisms for cost control, planning, pricing, and budgeting for health [ |
| 14 | Communication | Taxing mobile phone bills and internet – less than 5% tax on mobile phone bills should generate more tax revenue [ |
| 15 | Tourism | Develop tourism sites and infrastructure – one tourist room creates 2.5 jobs [ |
| 16 | Health | Improve multisectoral coordination of health financing and networking of health services, expanding services coverage of quality |
| 17 | Education | Introduce a system of contribution vouchers for health – proof of payment of a certain amount (e.g. 1% of school fees) by each student at the beginning of each school year (with an exemption for the have-nots). |
| 18 | Bank and insurances | Establish a national bank specializing in banking for health services. E.g. currency creation for health services purchase (interest income), tax incentives for returns, and the like. The government should grant the bank all power and legal authority to provide financial solutions for the health services and to regularly provide innovative financing for health. |
| 19 | International cooperation | To link external funds with national revenues as recommended in the Paris declaration [ |
Source: Created from the literature review