Xiaoyu Chen1, Xuan Feng2, Yibing Xie2, Langlang Wang2, Lu Chen3, Xueqian Wang2, Yixing Ma2, Ping Ning2, Yu Pu2. 1. Zhejiang Nanhua Anti-corrosion Equipment Co., LTD., Hangzhou 311255, China. 2. Faculty of Environmental Science and Engineering, Kunming University of Science and Technology, No. 727, Jingming South Road, Chenggong New District, Kunming 650500, China. 3. Faculty of Business Management, Yunnan Communications Vocational and Technical College, Kunming 650500, China.
Abstract
Traditional adsorbents undershot the expectations for arsine (AsH3) removal under low-temperature operation conditions in the industry. In this study, the copper (Cu) precursor was used to modify activated carbon and yield novel adsorbents by low-temperature roasting for high-efficiency removal of AsH3. The best conditions were determined as impregnation with 2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2 adsorbent and roasting at 180 °C. At a reaction temperature of 40 °C and an oxygen content of 1%, the AsH3 removal efficiency reached over 90% and lasted for 40 h and the best capacity of 369.6 mg/g was obtained with the Cu/Ac adsorbent. The characterization results showed the decomposition of Cu(NO3)2 during the low-temperature roasting process to form surface functional groups. The formation of the important intermediate Cu2(NO3)(OH)3 in the decomposition of Cu(NO3)2 into CuO plays a role in the good regeneration performance of the Cu/Ac adsorbent using water washing and the gas regeneration method. The results of in situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy combined with X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy demonstrated that the interaction of trace oxygen with Lewis (L) acid sites increased chemisorbed oxygen by 17.34%, significantly promoting the spontaneity of AsH3 oxidation reaction. These results provide a friendly economic method with industrial processes practical for AsH3 removal.
Traditional adsorbents undershot the expectations for arsine (AsH3) removal under low-temperature operation conditions in the industry. In this study, the copper (Cu) precursor was used to modify activated carbon and yield novel adsorbents by low-temperature roasting for high-efficiency removal of AsH3. The best conditions were determined as impregnation with 2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2 adsorbent and roasting at 180 °C. At a reaction temperature of 40 °C and an oxygen content of 1%, the AsH3 removal efficiency reached over 90% and lasted for 40 h and the best capacity of 369.6 mg/g was obtained with the Cu/Ac adsorbent. The characterization results showed the decomposition of Cu(NO3)2 during the low-temperature roasting process to form surface functional groups. The formation of the important intermediate Cu2(NO3)(OH)3 in the decomposition of Cu(NO3)2 into CuO plays a role in the good regeneration performance of the Cu/Ac adsorbent using water washing and the gas regeneration method. The results of in situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy combined with X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy demonstrated that the interaction of trace oxygen with Lewis (L) acid sites increased chemisorbed oxygen by 17.34%, significantly promoting the spontaneity of AsH3 oxidation reaction. These results provide a friendly economic method with industrial processes practical for AsH3 removal.
The industrial sources
of AsH3 mainly originate from
phosphorous, coal, non-ferrous metal smelting, petroleum processing,
and refining industries.[1] AsH3 is a severe hemolytic poison that leads to the accumulation of hydrogen
peroxide and destruction of the cell membrane. Acute AsH3 poisoning is characterized by acute intravascular hemolysis and
renal damage. This may also involve and damage many important organs,
including the heart, liver, and lungs.[2] Meanwhile, AsH3 is a pollutant that causes adsorbent
poisoning during carbonyl transformation and the synthesis of adsorbents.[3] During the combustion process of arsenic in the
yellow phosphorus ore, AsH3 can easily be produced by side
reactions with newly formed H2. However, the low-temperature
catalytic processes of such adsorbents could significantly lower the
operating energy costs and reduce CO2 production for thermal
oxidation. After high-pressure water washing, the exhaust gas temperature
would drop to 30–50 °C. Hence, removing AsH3 without reheating may reduce heating energy consumption. Therefore,
it is of practical significance and economic value to study adsorbents
with high removal efficiencies of AsH3 under low-temperature
conditions.Activated carbon through modification has long been
studied as
an adsorbent carrier due to its low cost, widely available sources,
resistance to acids and alkalis, excellent adsorption performances,
large specific surface area, and non-toxicity. To this end, various
modification methods have been attempted. For instance, Xu et al.[4] carried out a redox pretreatment in Cu-modified
activated carbon to increase the dispersion of Cu for CO removal.
Islam et al.[5] successfully prepared activated
carbon from coconut shells and recorded a specific surface area of
1640 m2/g with a pore volume of 1.032 cm3/g.
Khuong et al.[6] prepared activated carbon
adsorbents by K2CO3 activation for CO2 capture at room temperature. However, the activated carbon parameters
can be modified by physical and chemical treatments to adjust and
adapt the adsorbents to a wider range of applications, such as the
removal of AsH3. Besides, activated carbon from commercial
coal-based activated carbon possesses a very high affinity to arsenic
and thereby may suit removal of AsH3 issued from industrial
waste gas.Several modification routes of activated carbon currently
exist.
Cu is the most suitable component for the removal of AsH3 by activated carbon due to its low heat release during the redox
process coupled with a good removal effect on AsH3. As
a result, numerous materials based on Cu have been used as adsorbents
for the effective removal of AsH3. However, high operating
temperatures are typically required in these processes.[7] For instance, Lin et al.[8] determined the optimal parameters of AsH3 removal by
CuZnAl hydrotalcite-like adsorbents with calcination at 500 °C
and a hydrothermal temperature at 105 °C. Uffalussy et al.[9] performed adsorption of AsH3 by the
Cu–Pd alloy using a high-throughput composition spread alloy
film sample library. Jiang et al.[10] noticed
that a reaction temperature of 60 °C and an oxygen content of
4% allowed Co/Cu/Ac to effectively adsorb AsH3 after calcination
at 400 °C with the adsorption capacity of AsH3 reaching
35.7 mg/g. Wang et al.[11] reported adsorbents
with 0.2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2 after calcination at
400 °C to possess superior activity towards the removal of AsH3. Besides, a high capacity of 43.7 mg/g adsorbent at 60 °C
and 1.0% oxygen were obtained with Cu/Hβ. Previous studies by
Huang[12] showed a reduction in reaction
temperature but still required higher calcination temperatures with
stringent requirements on adsorbent preparation conditions. Alternatively,
roasting is easier than calcination and suitable for practical applications.In this study, a series of copper-modified activated carbon synthesized
by roasting at low temperatures (80–180 °C) were investigated
to gain a better understanding on the mechanism of CuO action for
AsH3 removal. To this end, adsorbents with different precursors
(Cu(NO3)2, CuCl2, Cu(C2H4O2)2, CuSO4) were prepared
and AsH3 removal was tested under the actual low temperature
in the industry. The preparation conditions related to loading precursor,
loading concentration, roasting temperature, and preparation conditions
linked to reaction temperature and oxygen content were all studied
to determine the optimal conditions. The physico-chemical properties,
phase compositions, and surface properties of the as-obtained adsorbents
were studied by Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET), X-ray
diffraction (XRD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), Fourier
transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), and in situ diffuse reflectance
infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (in situ-DRIFTS) to reveal
the reaction mechanisms.
Experimental Section
Preparation of Adsorbents
Four different
Cu precursors, Cu(NO3)2, CuCl2, Cu(C2H4O2)2, and CuSO4, were used for the modification of activated carbon. All adsorbents
were prepared by the low-temperature roasting method. Cu(NO3)2-modified Ac was taken as an example; first, activated
carbon was ground, followed by washing with deionized water and drying
at 80 °C for 4 h. After sieving the particles through 40–60
mesh, 2.0 g of activated carbon was impregnated with 2.0 mol/L Cu(NO3)2 solution of 10 mL. Next, the mixtures were left
to stand for 24 h after stirring at room temperature, followed by
roasting in an oven at low temperatures for 5 h (80, 120, 150, and
180 °C). Afterward, the samples were cooled down to ambient temperature
and sieved through 40–60 mesh. The Cu content was varied from
1 to 3 mol/L, where wt % means the mass percentage. After cooling,
the CuO-modified activated carbon adsorbents were obtained. Samples
prepared from different precursors are defined as Cu(NO3)2/Ac, Cu(C2H4O2)2/Ac, CuCl2/Ac, and CuSO4/Ac, respectively.
AsH3 Breakthrough Dynamic Testing
A scheme of the experimental setup is provided in Figure . The gas stream was introduced
into a mixer at a gas flow rate of 200 mL/min. The gas was composed
of AsH3 (200 ppm; Dalian Special Gas Corporation, China)
diluted in O2 (0–1.2%). The premixed gas then entered
the fixed bed filled with a 0.2 g adsorbent adsorption column. Two
sample ports were set: one for the imported gas and the other for
the residual tail gas after the treatment at the outlet. The waste
gas was treated by acid KMnO4. In this study, the AsH3 removal efficiency and adsorption capacity were used to evaluate
the arsenic capture capacity of the adsorbent. All experiments were
repeated three times, and the standard deviation and average value
were calculated. The reaction conditions are summarized in Table .
Figure 1
Schematic diagram of
the experimental setup: (1) cylinder with
AsH3 (200 ppm AsH3), (2) cylinder with O2, (3) mass flowmeter, (4) three-way valve, (5) mixer, (6)
three-way valve, (7) heating furnace, (8) adsorbents, (9) temperature
controller, (10) inlet measuring point, (11) KMnO4 solution
for AsH3 tail gas adsorption, and (12) outlet measuring
solution.
Table 1
Experimental Reaction
Conditions
sample
experiment
roasting temperature
active
component
carrier
reaction temperature (°C)
flue gas component
set I
180
2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2, CuCl2, Cu(C2H4O2)2, CuSO4
Ac
40
N2 + 1% O2 + 200 ppm AsH3
set II
80–180
2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2
Ac
40
N2 + 1% O2 + 200 ppm AsH3
set III
180
0–3.0 mol/L Cu(NO3)2
Ac
40
N2 + 1% O2 + 200 ppm AsH3
set IV
180
2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2
Ac
40
N2 + O2(0.5–1.2%) + 200 ppm AsH3
set V
180
2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2
Ac
25–60
N2 + 1% O2 + 200 ppm AsH3
Schematic diagram of
the experimental setup: (1) cylinder with
AsH3 (200 ppm AsH3), (2) cylinder with O2, (3) mass flowmeter, (4) three-way valve, (5) mixer, (6)
three-way valve, (7) heating furnace, (8) adsorbents, (9) temperature
controller, (10) inlet measuring point, (11) KMnO4 solution
for AsH3 tail gas adsorption, and (12) outlet measuring
solution.The concentration of AsH3 was measured
by the silver
diethyldithiocarbamate spectrophotometry method. The concentration
of AsH3 was calculated by eq under various conditionsThe
adsorption capacity of AsH3 was calculated using eq where X is the adsorption
capacity, mg/g; Q denotes the gas flow rate, m3/min; t represents the adsorption time, min; C0 and C represent the inlet
and outlet mass concentrations of AsH3, respectively, mg/m3; C represents the outlet mass concentration
of AsH3 in mg/m3; and m is
the weight of the adsorbent, g.
Adsorbent
Characterization
The surface
areas of the sorbents were determined by the BET method, while the
pore volume and the average pore size were extracted from the desorption
branch of the isotherm and calculated by the Barrett–Joyner–Halenda
method. The XRD patterns of the sorbents were recorded using a D8
Rigaku9000 X-ray powder diffractometer equipped with Ni-filtered Cu
Kα radiation (λ = 0.15406 nm). The surface states of the
adsorbents were analyzed by XPS (Thermo ESCALAB 250XI, Massachusetts,
Waltham, USA). The Cu 2p, O 1s, and As 3d binding energies (BEs) were
calibrated using C 1s (BE = 284.8 eV) as a standard. A Nicolet Impact
400 FT-IR spectrometer with a TGS detector was used for FT-IR studies.
In situ-DRIFTS was carried out on a Thermo Scientific Nicolet iS50
spectrometer equipped with a mercury–cadmium–telluride
detector cooled by liquid N2. Adsorbents were first purged
at 300 °C for 2 h under N2 gas (a total flow rate
of 100 mL/min) to dislodge water interference, and subsequently, spectra
of samples at the desired temperatures were recorded.
Results and Discussion
Effect of Preparation Conditions
on AsH3 Adsorption
The breakthrough curves of
AsH3 obtained with different Cu precursors (Cu(NO3)2, Cu(C2H4O2)2, CuCl2, and CuSO4) are depicted in Figure a. The breakthrough
time declined in the
following order: Cu(NO3)2/Ac > Cu(C2H4O2)2/Ac > CuCl2/Ac
> CuSO4/Ac > Ac. The adsorbent prepared with CuSO4 as the precursor displayed the worst effect. After roasting
at 180
°C, the removal efficiency of AsH3 decreased to less
than 90% only 7 h. This result was slightly better than that of the
blank activated carbon. The reason for this may have to do with the
difficult decomposition of SO42– during
low-temperature roasting, which prevented the formation of active
components. The adsorbent prepared with CuCl2 and Cu(C2H4O2)2 precursors looked
better than those obtained with CuSO4. However, the removal
efficiencies of AsH3 were lower than 90% after 12 and 23
h. Also, the adsorbent prepared with the Cu(NO3)2 precursor was able to remove AsH3 for nearly 40 h. The
reason for this had to do with Cu(NO3)2 precursors.
Xu et al.[13] reported the clustering tendency
of Cu(NO3)2 during the impregnation process,
allowing the adsorbent to retain a larger surface area and pore volume.
Therefore, Cu(NO3)2 was selected as an optimal
precursor in subsequent experiments for Cu modification of activated
carbon. The adsorbent prepared with different active component concentrations
(1.5, 2, 2.5, and 3 mol/L) is shown in Figure b. The adsorbent prepared with 1.5 mol/L
Cu(NO3)2 illustrated poor performances toward
the catalytic oxidation of AsH3, while that obtained with
2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2 displayed the best catalytic
effect. However, the increment in loading content to 2.5 mol/L and
3 mol/L led to a decline in performance. Thus, excess Cu(NO3)2 loading not only piled up on the adsorbent surface
but also blocked the pore size of the activated carbon, thereby reducing
the surface active sites of the adsorbent. In turn, the performance
of the adsorbent toward the catalytic removal of AsH3 diminished.
Thus, the use of 2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2 showed the
best catalytic activity. The roasting temperature would significantly
impact the pore size, pore volume, and precursor oxidation products
of the activated carbon adsorbent. Harsh calcination conditions used
in the industrial process combined with a flue gas temperature below
200 °C are not convenient for the preparation of traditional
adsorbents. As a result, adsorbents prepared without calcination would
have broad prospects. The AsH3 reaction curves for adsorbents
loaded by 2 mol/L Cu(NO3)2 and roasted at temperatures
of 80, 120, 150, and 180 °C are presented in Figure c. The results obtained at
180 °C looked significantly improved when compared to 80, 120,
and 150 °C. When roasted at 180 °C, the adsorbent displayed
the best removal efficiency toward AsH3. This can be related
to the decomposition temperature of Cu(NO3)2 (170 °C). The influences of four different roasting temperatures
on materials performances will be discussed in the BET results section.
Figure 2
Effect
of the (a) different Cu precursors, (b) Cu(NO3)2 impregnation concentration, and (c) roasting temperature
on AsH3 removal efficiencies; Reaction conditions: reaction
temperature = 40 °C, [AsH3] = 200 ppm, and [O2] = 1.0 vol %.
Effect
of the (a) different Cu precursors, (b) Cu(NO3)2 impregnation concentration, and (c) roasting temperature
on AsH3 removal efficiencies; Reaction conditions: reaction
temperature = 40 °C, [AsH3] = 200 ppm, and [O2] = 1.0 vol %.
Characterization
of the Cu/Ac Adsorbent
The pore property of the adsorbent
is the key factor to determine
the adsorption performance. As shown in Figure , the N2 adsorption capacity of
blank activated carbon was stronger than those of Cu/Ac-180 °C
and Cu/Ac-180 °C after the reaction (denoted as Cu/Ac-180 °C-E).
This can be explained by the partially covered Cu/Ac-180 °C and
Cu/Ac-180 °C-E by active components as well as a decline in surface
area. Moreover, the hysteresis loop shifted in the relative pressure
range of 0.4–1.0, a typical characteristic of mesoporous structures.
The physical properties of adsorbents prepared with 2% Cu(NO3)2 at different roasting temperatures of 80, 120, 150,
and 180 °C are gathered in Table . This included BET surface area, total pore volume,
DFT pore size, and average pore size. The BET surface area of blank
activated carbon decreased after loading, while the surface area reached
the maximum 1004.98 m2/g at 180 °C roasting. These
data were consistent with those of the removal effect, confirming
that the best roasting temperature is 180 °C. It was speculated
that copper nitrate was not completely decomposed at the other roasting
temperatures, so this did not form the copper oxide crystal phase,
that is, not enough active sites. Therefore, the following experiments
could be carried out on samples roasting at 180 °C (denoted as
Cu/Ac). In addition, it was observed that the specific surface area
sharply decreased to 427.78 m2/g after AsH3 adsorption,
accompanied by a reduction to 0.22 cm3/g in pore volume,
which may be due to deposition of adsorption products on the surface
of the Cu/Ac adsorbent.
Figure 3
Nitrogen adsorption/desorption isotherms were
obtained for blank
Ac, Ac loaded with 2% copper adsorbents at different roasting temperatures,
and the sample roasting at 180 °C after AsH3 adsorption.
Table 2
Specific Surface Area, Total Pore
Volume, DFT Pore Size and Average Pore Size of Blank Ac, Ac Loaded
with 2% Copper Adsorbents at Different Roasting Temperatures, and
the Sample Roasting at 180 °C after AsH3 Adsorption
sample
BET surface area (m2/g)
total
pore volume (cm3/g)
DFT pore size (D/nm)
average pore size (D/nm)
Ac-180 °C
1094.35
0.54
0.56
1.96
Cu/Ac-80 °C
937.87
0.50
1.13
2.14
Cu/Ac-120 °C
886.80
0.47
1.13
2.10
Cu/C-150 °C
963.21
0.51
1.03
2.12
Cu/C-180 °C
1004.98
0.53
0.56
2.12
Cu/C-180 °C-E
427.78
0.22
0.88
2.04
Nitrogen adsorption/desorption isotherms were
obtained for blank
Ac, Ac loaded with 2% copper adsorbents at different roasting temperatures,
and the sample roasting at 180 °C after AsH3 adsorption.XRD and FTIR characterization were used to further determine the
deposition products on the adsorbent and the changes of the surface
phase after reaction. Figure a shows the XRD patterns of the prepared sample with 2% copper
content. For the Cu/Ac sample, characteristic peaks of CuO were present
at 35.6°, 38.8°, and 61.8°. CuO was successfully deposited
on the adsorbent surface as an active component. In addition, the
Cu/Ac sample exhibited some diffraction peaks at 12.8°,[14,15] corresponding to cupric nitrate (Cu2(NO3)(OH)3). Therefore, the first consisted of transforming into Cu2(NO3)(OH)3, and the second consisted
of transforming into copper oxide. The weak interaction between copper
atoms and activated carbon led to the facile reduction of copper ions
to Cu+, thereby promoting the reaction. Cu(NO3)2 clusters occurred during impregnation so that the adsorbent
retained a larger surface area and pore volume, which is consistent
with the BET analysis. In addition, diffraction peaks of As2O3 were detected at 28.0°, 32.2°, 35.5°,
42.6°, 46.4°, 55.0°, and 59.6° in the Cu/Ac-E
sample.[16] Meanwhile, the peak attributed
to trace copper may be overlaid by that of As2O3. However, the relevant diffraction peak of As2O5 was absent in the XRD spectrum of related adsorbents obtained after
the reaction. This may be caused by the low content of As2O5 present on the adsorbent surface. Note that the existence
of As2O5 was confirmed by subsequent characterizations.
Moreover, the background spectrum of the activated carbon remained
almost unchanged after reaction, indicating the presentation of the
carrier structure of the modified activated carbon as well as the
low effect of the arsenic oxide product on the pore structure of the
carrier. The IR spectra of Cu/Ac and Cu/Ac-E are shown in Figure b. Two new peaks
appeared at 497.3 and 576.8 cm–1 of Cu/Ac-E, which
were related to the presence of O–As–O.[17] Another two new peaks at 832.2 and 988.7 cm–1 were associated with the formation of As–O after the reaction.[18] During the adsorption process, some reactions
of active sites took place. After the adsorption of AsH3 on the CuO surface, the bands at 629.7 cm–1 weakened
due to the bond cleavage reactions of Cu–O.[19] The exposure to AsH3 resulted in the deposition
of a significant quantity of arsenic on the surface as well as an
increased percentage of oxygen for the CuO series.[17] These results further testified that CuO was the active
center for AsH3 removal.
Figure 4
XRD patterns (a) and FTIR results (b)
of Cu/Ac and Cu/Ac-E.
XRD patterns (a) and FTIR results (b)
of Cu/Ac and Cu/Ac-E.To investigate the surface
species and chemical states of O 1s,
Cu 2p, and As 3d in the as-prepared adsorbents, XPS was employed for
further characterization of the samples, and the data are summarized
in Figure . The corresponding
XPS data before and after the reaction are displayed in Table . The BEs in the Cu 2p spectra
are depicted in Figure a. The Cu 2p peaks centered at 934.68–934.79 eV were assigned
to the Cu2+ in the Cu/Ac and Cu/Ac-E samples.[12,20] The Cu2+ content of the adsorbent decreased from 100.00
to 75.35% after the reaction, with the appearance of a peak of Cu+ at 932.8 eV. Considering the conversion cycle of Cu2+ and Cu+ contributing to oxygen utilization, the involvement
of Cu species on the surface of Cu/Ac plays an important role in enhancement
of AsH3 removal.[21] Three peaks
of O 1s are observed in Figure b. The peaks at about 531.3–532.3 eV could be attributed
to chemisorbed oxygen (denoted as Oβ). By comparison,
those at 530.01–530.30 eV belonged to lattice oxygen (donated
as Oα), and those at 534.00–534.50 eV belonged
to hydroxyl oxygen or adsorbed molecular water (denoted as Oγ).[22−24] The Oα decreased after the reaction,
while the Oβ increased by 17.34%. During the catalytic
reaction, the conversion cycle of Cu2+ and Cu+ can consume Oα, and oxygen in the air was absorbed
on the surface of the adsorbent to supplement Oβ.
However, after the interaction of Oβ with ions on
the surface, it was converted into Oα to obtain electrons,
thus achieving dynamic equilibrium. When oxygen supply was insufficient
during the reaction, Oα in the active component CuO
will be converted to Oα to participate in the reaction
of AsH3. This is consistent with the reduction of Cu2+ after the reaction in the previous analysis. In Figure c, the As 3d spectra
of reaction samples were divided into two peaks. The one located at
46.63 eV was attributed to As2O3 (81.77%), while
the other located at 45.05 eV was ascribed to As2O5 (18.23%). In other words, As2O3 was
the dominant oxidation product in the reaction.[21]
Figure 5
XPS spectra of Cu 2p (a), O 1s (b), and As 3d (c) for the Cu/Ac
and Cu/Ac-E adsorbents.
Table 3
Relative
Contents of Surface Species
of Cu/Ac and Cu/Ac-Ea
atomic
concentration (at. %)
sample
Cu+
Cu2+
Oα
Oβ
Oγ
As3+
As5+
Cu/Ac
—
100
54.83
40.80
4.37
—
—
Cu/Ac-E
24.65
75.35
6.79
58.14
35.06
81.77
18.23
Annotation: the
symbol “—”
represents a value of 0.
XPS spectra of Cu 2p (a), O 1s (b), and As 3d (c) for the Cu/Ac
and Cu/Ac-E adsorbents.Annotation: the
symbol “—”
represents a value of 0.
Effect of Reaction Conditions on AsH3 Adsorption
over Cu/Ac
The adsorption performance of Cu/Ac
under actual industrial conditions of micro-oxygen and low temperature
was tested. As shown in Figure a, the removal efficiency of AsH3 increased with
oxygen content (0.5, 0.8, 1, and 1.2%). The removal efficiencies registered
at oxygen contents of 0.5 and 0.8% were lower than that recorded at
90% after 8 h. By comparison, a significant increase was obtained
with a 1% oxygen content. However, a further rise in oxygen content
to 1.2% declined the performance since the presence of too much oxygen
would compete with AsH3 for active sites. Therefore, 1.0%
oxygen content was selected as optimal and used in further reaction.
The low-temperature adsorption performance of Cu/Ac was verified at
25, 40, 50, and 60 °C, and the results are illustrated in Figure b. At 25 °C,
the initial removal efficiency of AsH3 was low but improved
at 40 °C. This could be due to the activation temperature of
the adsorbent. However, a further rise in temperature to 50 and 60
°C led to a decline in removal efficiency to yield values about
the same as those obtained at 25 °C. Therefore, 40 °C was
selected as the optimal reaction temperature to yield suitable adsorbents.
The adsorption capacity reached 369 mg/g under these conditions, which
was 10 times that of the other copper-containing adsorbent. The above
result proved that Cu/AC had excellent arsenic removal capacity under
industrial micro-oxygen and low-temperature conditions.
Figure 6
Effect of the
oxygen content (a) and reaction temperature (b) on
AsH3 removal efficiency. Reaction conditions: Cu(NO3)2 content = 2 mol/L, roasting temperature = 180
°C, [AsH3] = 200 ppm.
Effect of the
oxygen content (a) and reaction temperature (b) on
AsH3 removal efficiency. Reaction conditions: Cu(NO3)2 content = 2 mol/L, roasting temperature = 180
°C, [AsH3] = 200 ppm.Cu/Ac was further characterized by in situ DRIFTS at different
reaction temperatures to investigate its excellent properties at low
temperature. The reaction curves were taken every 10 min after passing
AsH3 at 25, 40, 50, and 60 °C and are displayed in Figure a within the range
of 650–4000 cm–1. The comprehensive spectra
of after passing AsH3 for 30 min are provided in Figure b. All the curves
showed the AsH3 characteristic peak at 2123.2 cm–1,[25] and the intensity changes were different
at different temperatures. The intensity was the highest at 25 °C,
while it was the lowest at 40 °C. Based on an obvious abatement
of the AsH3 characteristic peak along with the time increasing
in Figure a, it can
be inferred that the Cu/Ac sample has a good purification capacity
on AsH3 at 40 °C, which was consistent with the experimental
phenomenon. By further comparing the curves, it was only when the
reaction temperature was 60 °C that new peaks appeared at 1346.7
cm–1 and could be inferred to NO3– that originates from (Cu(NO3)2) used in the adsorbent preparation process,[26−28] which was the
B acid site of the Cu/Ac adsorbent itself.[29,30] Besides, the stretching vibration absorption peaks of the symmetrical
H–O–H group appeared at 3440.1 cm–1,[31] indicating that there may be catalytic
reaction of AsH3 at the B acid site on the sample surface.[32] However, the negative peak of 3572 cm–1 attributed to the OH stretching vibration of the Si–(OH)–Al
bridge was observed due to toxic effects of arsenic species on B acid
sites. In other words, it is precisely the toxic effect of arsenic
species on strong acid sites that leads to the unsatisfactory removal
efficiency when the catalytic activation temperature is reached.[33]
Figure 7
(a) Reaction curve obtained every 10 min after passing
AsH3 in 25, 40, 50, and 60 °C. (b) In situ DRIFTS
obtained
after 30 min AsH3 adsorption.
(a) Reaction curve obtained every 10 min after passing
AsH3 in 25, 40, 50, and 60 °C. (b) In situ DRIFTS
obtained
after 30 min AsH3 adsorption.The reaction curves obtained every 10 min after passing O2 are displayed in Figure a, and the comprehensive spectra after passing oxygen for
30 min are illustrated in Figure b. When the reaction temperature was 50 and 60 °C,
there was a strong peak at 1346.7 cm–1, along with
the band at 3440.1 cm–1 assigned to the H–O–H
group. Moreover, the negative peak of the OH stretching vibration
of the Si–(OH)–Al bridge at 3572.1 cm–1[34] proved again that the B acid site was
involved in the catalytic reaction. Compared to the results obtained
without O2 in Figure , the intensity of these peaks enhanced. The catalytic
reaction took place between AsH3 and O2 at 50
and 60 °C. Two new peaks appeared at 940.5 and 1116.3 cm–1 at 25 and 40 °C; the former was assigned to
the presence of As–O from the arsenic oxide product,[35] and the latter was assigned to the bonds of
the Lewis (L) acid sites.[36] O2 may participate in the chemical adsorption of hydrogen arsenide
by adsorbing at L acid sites on the surface of Cu/Ac to convert to
Oβ.[33] This indicated that
a chemical adsorption process mainly occurred on the Cu/AC surface
when the reaction temperature was 25 and 40 °C. Finally, the
weak peak vibration of the L acid site was also observed in the reaction
curve at 50 °C, concluding that chemical adsorption and catalytic
oxidation processes happened at the same time. The above results showed
that when the reaction temperature falls short of the catalytic activation
temperature, there is mainly a chemical adsorption process on the
Cu/Ac surface; however, when it is reached, catalytic oxidation is
dominant. The different changes of these surface functional groups
were consistent with the AsH3 removal efficiency at four
reaction temperatures.
Figure 8
(a) Reaction curves obtained every 10 min after passing
O2 in 25, 40, 50, and 60 °C. (b) In situ DRIFTS after
30 min adsorption
of O2.
(a) Reaction curves obtained every 10 min after passing
O2 in 25, 40, 50, and 60 °C. (b) In situ DRIFTS after
30 min adsorption
of O2.
Regeneration
of the Cu/Ac Adsorbent
The Cu/Ac adsorbent was regenerated
by water washing and the purging
gas method. To this end, the Cu/Ac-E sample was first activated by
hot air at 100 °C for 3 h. Then, it was soaked and cleaned with
deionized water four to five times and placed in an electric blast
roasting oven to dry at 110–120 °C. Afterward, the sample
was placed in a tubular furnace under a nitrogen atmosphere, and the
temperature was increased using a temperature-programmed controller.
Considering the material obtained by roasting at 180 °C, the
temperature was first set at 20–180 °C. Afterward, the
heating was stopped, and the sample was cooled down to room temperature.
The sample was taken out, the nitrogen flow was stopped, and the regenerated
material was tested. As shown in Figure a, the regeneration efficiency of R (R is the ratio of the breakthrough time
of the regenerated adsorbent and fresh adsorbent) after one regeneration
cycle was 65%. After the second regeneration cycle, the sample recovered
an efficiency R reaching 60%, confirming reasonable
regeneration capability of the Cu/Ac adsorbent toward the removal
of AsH3. To determine the change of the surface phase after
regeneration of the Cu/AC adsorbent, Cu/Ac-R1 and Cu/Ac-R1-E were
analyzed by XRD. As shown in Figure b, after regeneration, it was evident that the intensity
of the diffraction peak of CuO at 35.6°, 38.8°, and 61.8°
in Cu/Ac-R1 increased, but no peak of Cu2(NO3) (OH)3 was found. This indicated that some CuO species
recovered in the regeneration process may be transformed by intermediate
Cu2(NO3)(OH)3. In addition, the crystallization
peak of As2O3 at 28.0°, 32.2°, 35.5°,
42.6°, 46.4°, 55.0°, and 59.6° was significantly
weakened in the Cu/Ac-R1 sample. It was speculated that transformation
of the intermediate Cu2(NO3)(OH)3 to the adsorption active center CuO and separation of crystalline
As2O3 may be the reasons for the good regeneration
performance of the Cu/Ac adsorbent. The results of XPS further confirmed
this point. The XPS results of Cu/Ac-R1 and Cu/Ac-R1-E further confirmed
this point. In Figure a, the Cu 2p diffraction peak at 934.61 and 935.01 eV belonged to
Cu2+ species, while the diffraction peak at 932.45 and
932.47 eV was ascribed to Cu+ species. These Cu2+ and Cu+ species appear in the form of CuO and Cu2O, respectively. From Table , after the reaction of Cu/Ac-R1, the content of Cu+ increased from 4.57 to 8.74% along with a decrease in Cu2+, indicating that recovered active center CuO participated
in a new round of AsH3 adsorption. The XPS spectrum of
As 3d of Cu/Ac-R1 and the Cu/Ac-R1-E sample was divided into two kind
of peaks, as shown in Figure b. One was the characteristic peak of As3+ at 44.91
and 45.15 eV, and the other was of As5+ centered in 46.60
and 46.76 eV. It can be seen that the peak area of arsenic oxide products
in the Cu/Ac-R1 sample was greatly reduced, especially a decrease
in area of about 7 times of As3+. However, the content
of As3+ increased from 56.27 to 87.8% in Cu/Ac-R1-E. Due
to more toxicity than As2O5, As2O3 can be considered as the main reason for the deactivation
of the Cu/Ac adsorbent.
Figure 9
(a) Regeneration performance of Cu/Ac (reaction
conditions: reaction
temperature = 40 °C, [AsH3] = 200 ppm, and [O2] = 1.0 vol %); (b) XRD patterns of Cu/Ac, Cu/Ac-E, Cu/Ac-R1,
and Cu/Ac-R1-E.
Figure 10
XPS spectra of Cu 2p (a) and As 3d (b)
for Cu/Ac-R1 and Cu/Ac-R1-E.
Table 4
Relative Contents of Surface Species
of Cu/Ac-R1 and Cu/Ac-R1-E
atomic
concentration (at. %)
sample
Cu+
Cu2+
As3+
As5+
Cu/Ac-R1
4.57
95.43
56.27
43.73
Cu/Ac-R1-E
8.74
91.26
87.80
12.20
(a) Regeneration performance of Cu/Ac (reaction
conditions: reaction
temperature = 40 °C, [AsH3] = 200 ppm, and [O2] = 1.0 vol %); (b) XRD patterns of Cu/Ac, Cu/Ac-E, Cu/Ac-R1,
and Cu/Ac-R1-E.XPS spectra of Cu 2p (a) and As 3d (b)
for Cu/Ac-R1 and Cu/Ac-R1-E.
Identification
of the AsH3 Adsorption
Mechanism
According to the experimental results and subsequent
product analysis, the mechanism of AsH3 chemisorption under
low temperature over Cu/Ac was identified. Addition of Cu(NO3)2 to the activated carbon can form the highly active
phase of CuO upon roasting at 180 °C. Since AsH3 was
adsorbed on the metal component, the As–H bond weakened, making
it easy to break at a lower temperature, and the Cu2+ and
Cu+ conversion cycle of the Cu/Ac adsorbent played an important
role in this process. Released Oα oxidized AsH3 to As3+, while Cu2+ was restored to
Cu+ and then oxidized to Cu2+ after contacting
with the oxygen of the air. Meanwhile, under a 40 °C reaction
temperature, L acid sites could greatly improve the surface chemical
adsorption of O2 of the Cu/Ac adsorbent, resulting in the
supplement of Oβ to contribute to the circulation
of Cu. The main arsenic oxide products were mainly As2O3 and a small amount of As2O5. In general,
the Cu/Ac adsorbent realized the efficient capture and purification
of AsH3 through the synergic effect of the circulation
of Cu species and activated L acid site.
Conclusions
The Cu/Ac adsorbent synthesized by the low-temperature roasting
method was proved to have a high efficiency in capturing AsH3. The released Oα through the cycle of Cu2+ to Cu+ in the active component CuO played an essential
role in the oxidation process of AsH3. Moreover, the L
acid site of the Cu/Ac adsorbent could quickly improve the chemisorption
of O2, thus supplementing Oβ to assist
with the cycle of Cu species. AsH3 was first oxidized to
As2O3 and then to As2O5, leading to the formation of deposits on the adsorbent surface.
As for the regeneration efficiency of 60% after several generations,
the intermediate Cu2(NO3)(OH) in Cu/Ac could
be partially converted into the active center CuO during the regeneration
process. The results of one-time water washing and purging gas regeneration
showed that Cu2+ was restored by 20%, while the main poison
As2O3 was reduced approximately 7 times. Compared
with traditional copper adsorbents, Cu(NO3)2-modified Ac roasting at low temperature reduced the reaction operating
temperature by 80 °C. In terms of industrial actual conditions
and low operating temperatures, Cu/AC synthesized by the low-temperature
roasting method is a promising adsorbent for industrial low-temperature
AsH3 removal.
Authors: Rubina Khanam; Anjani Kumar; A K Nayak; Md Shahid; Rahul Tripathi; S Vijayakumar; Debarati Bhaduri; Upendra Kumar; Sangita Mohanty; P Panneerselvam; Dibyendu Chatterjee; B S Satapathy; H Pathak Journal: Sci Total Environ Date: 2019-09-07 Impact factor: 7.963