Muhammad B Wazir1,2, Muhammad Daud2, Soma Safeer2, Faisal Almarzooqi1, Ahsanulhaq Qurashi3. 1. Department of Chemical Engineering, Khalifa University of Science and Technology, Main Campus, 127788 Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. 2. Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Engineering and Technology, 25120 Peshawar, Pakistan. 3. Department of Chemistry, Khalifa University of Science and Technology, Main Campus, 127788 Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates.
Abstract
Hydrogen (H2) is a green and economical substitute to traditional fossil fuels due to zero carbon emissions. Water splitting technology is developing at a rapid speed to sustainably generate H2 through electro- and photolysis of water without the harmful emissions associated with steam methane reforming. Development of efficient catalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is pertinent for economical green H2 generation. In this regard, 2D transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs) are considered to be excellent alternatives to noble metal catalysts. Among other TMDCs, 2D MoSe2 is preferred due to the low Gibbs free energy for hydrogen adsorption, good electrical conductivity, and more metallic nature. Moreover, the physicochemical and electronic properties of MoSe2 can be easily tailored to suit HER application by simple synthetic strategies. Herein, we comprehensively review the application of 2D MoSe2 in the electrocatalytic HER, focusing on recent advancements in the modulation of the MoSe2 properties through nanostructure design, phase transformation, defect engineering, doping, and formation of heterostructures. We also discuss the role of 2D MoSe2 as a cocatalyst in the photocatalytic HER. The article concludes with a synopsis of current progress and prospective future trends.
Hydrogen (H2) is a green and economical substitute to traditional fossil fuels due to zero carbon emissions. Water splitting technology is developing at a rapid speed to sustainably generate H2 through electro- and photolysis of water without the harmful emissions associated with steam methane reforming. Development of efficient catalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is pertinent for economical green H2 generation. In this regard, 2D transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs) are considered to be excellent alternatives to noble metal catalysts. Among other TMDCs, 2D MoSe2 is preferred due to the low Gibbs free energy for hydrogen adsorption, good electrical conductivity, and more metallic nature. Moreover, the physicochemical and electronic properties of MoSe2 can be easily tailored to suit HER application by simple synthetic strategies. Herein, we comprehensively review the application of 2D MoSe2 in the electrocatalytic HER, focusing on recent advancements in the modulation of the MoSe2 properties through nanostructure design, phase transformation, defect engineering, doping, and formation of heterostructures. We also discuss the role of 2D MoSe2 as a cocatalyst in the photocatalytic HER. The article concludes with a synopsis of current progress and prospective future trends.
The
excessive reliance on conventional fossil fuels and the exponentially
increasing demand for energy is leading to a rapid depletion of these
resources with increased carbon emissions proving detrimental for
the environment. The current scenario poses an imperious need for
alternate (green and economical) energy technologies to best fulfill
these demands. Green hydrogen is a reliable substitute for traditional
fossil fuels owing to its characteristics of zero carbon emissions,
recyclability, high conversion efficiency, and high energy density.
Hydrogen is predicted to be supplying 11% of the total energy demands
of the globe by 2025 and 34% by 2050.[1]Currently, hydrogen is produced on the industrial level by steam
methane reforming of natural gas, resulting in carbon dioxide emissions.
However, electro- and photocatalytic water splitting are preferred,
as renewable energy sources are used in the production of hydrogen.[2] Precious noble metals such as ruthenium (Ru),
iridium (Ir), palladium (Pd), platinum (Pt), and their alloys are
the most efficient catalysts for electrocatalytic and photocatalytic
water splitting owing to their optimum absorption and binding energies
for hydrogen and protons. However, natural scarcity and consequently
the high cost of such metals limit their application.[3] Recently, transition metal-based materials have gained
the attention as efficient HER catalysts.[4] Among these, two-dimensional (2D) earth-abundant transition metal
dichalcogenides (TMDCs) are preferred due to their tunable characteristics.[5−7]MoS2 has been extensively investigated as an effective
HER catalyst. However, experimental studies have shown MoSe2 to be more favorable due to its more metallic nature, lower Gibbs
free energy, and narrower band gap.[8−10] The catalytic activity
of MoSe2 greatly depends on the edge sites and its morphology.[8] In addition, the small band gap and ability to
act as an electron exporter in bicatalytic systems make MoSe2 a reliable cocatalyst for photolysis of water.[8,11] Nevertheless,
drawbacks like poor conductivity relative to noble metal catalysts
and aggregation of MoSe2 during fabrication are pushing
researchers to introduce novel techniques to further improve the HER
performance of MoSe2.[3]A few review articles are available on closely related topics.
For instance, Xia et al.[3] reviewed the
progress of transition metal selenides for HER electrolysis. Recently,
Nithya studied the recent progress in CoSe2-based electrocatalysts
for H2 generation.[12] Another
review article presented the role of various active sites and ways
to increase active sites in metal sulfides.[13] The design, synthesis, property modulation, and mechanisms of 2D
transition metal dichalcogenide-based electrocatalysts have also been
reviewed.[10] However, there is no review
article hitherto which comprehensively focuses on the application
of 2D MoSe2 nanocatalysts for hydrogen generation. Herein,
we will provide an up to date review of the current literature on
strategies to enhance the HER activity of MoSe2-based materials.
We will elucidate the rationale and effects of modulating the catalytic
and physicochemical properties of MoSe2 through nanostructure
design, phase transformation, heteroatom doping, defect engineering,
and heterostructure formation as depicted in Scheme .
Scheme 1
Conceptual Illustration of Tuning the MoSe2 Properties
for the HER
Structure
and Properties of MoSe2
MoSe2 has a
two-dimensional (2D) lattice structure like
MoS2 in which a single-layered nanostructure is comprised
of a layer of Mo atoms sandwiched between two layers of Se atoms.
A few-layered structure is formed by the weak van der Waals interlayer
interaction among several monolayers.[14] MoSe2 may exist as semiconductive 2H phase with trigonal
prismatic geometry or a metallic 1T phase with octahedral geometry.[15] A small band gap makes MoSe2 relevant
for photoelectrochemical applications.[3] The low Gibbs free energy of MoSe2 for hydrogen adsorption
makes it a promising catalyst for the HER. MoSe2 also exhibits
higher electrical conductivity than MoS2 owing to the more
metallic nature of Se (1 × 10–3 S m–1) than S (5 × 10–28 S m–1).[5] In addition, the 1T phase exhibits
higher electrical conductivity than the 2H phase. However, the metastable
metallic 1T phase is thermodynamically unstable and can readily be
converted into the 2H phase.[15,16] In the following sections
we will elucidate the recent approaches to tailor the properties of
MoSe2 for enhanced HER performance beyond intrinsic levels.
Modulating the Electrocatalytic and Physicochemical
Properties of Pristine MoSe2 for Enhanced Hydrogen Generation
Nanostructure Design
The fabrication
of nanostructures is an excellent way of improving the electrocatalytic
performance of 2D MoSe2 as it exposes abundant active sites.
However, 2D architectures of MoSe2 (e.g., nanosheets and
nanoflakes) often need a substrate support to be employed as an electrode
in the electrocatalytic HER. The perpendicular stacking of 2D MoSe2 nanosheets on a conductive support is a favorable nanoarchitecture,
which can promote the HER by giving access to abundant active sites
and improving the charge transport. Dai et al.[14] used the rGO platform to disperse defect-rich oxygen-incorporated
MoSe2 nanosheets with an interlayer spacing of 0.71 nm
by the PVP-assisted hydrothermal method as illustrated in Figure a and 1b. The rGO helped to improve the charge transport due to good
electrical conductivity and acted as a platform to disperse MoSe2 nanosheets to maximize exposed sites. Therefore, the resultant
2D nanosheets supported on interconnected conducting network exhibited
improved HER performance.
Figure 1
Nanostructure design of 2D MoSe2.
(a) Pristine MoSe2. (b) Interlayer expansion of MoSe2 by oxygen incorporation.
Reprinted with permission from ref (14). Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society. (c)
Schematic illustration of MoSe2 nanoarchitecture synthesis
with the help of PTAS as a seed promoter. SEM images of PTAS-assisted
grown 3D MoSe2: (d and e) top and (f) side views at different
magnifications. Reprinted with permission from ref (17). Copyright 2017 IOP Publishing.
Nanostructure design of 2D MoSe2.
(a) Pristine MoSe2. (b) Interlayer expansion of MoSe2 by oxygen incorporation.
Reprinted with permission from ref (14). Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society. (c)
Schematic illustration of MoSe2 nanoarchitecture synthesis
with the help of PTAS as a seed promoter. SEM images of PTAS-assisted
grown 3D MoSe2: (d and e) top and (f) side views at different
magnifications. Reprinted with permission from ref (17). Copyright 2017 IOP Publishing.Efforts to improve the HER activity by designing
a 2D nanoarchitecture
in the form of nanosheets and nanoflakes and modulating their electronic
and catalytic properties have surely produced promising results. However,
to further improve the electrocatalytic performance, these 2D structures
are extended in three-dimensional space. An increased packing density
of active sites can be obtained by merging the active-site-rich 2D
nanosheets in a 3D space. It not only provides access to more active
sites but also improves the electronic conductivity through interconnected
networks. A highly crystalline 3D hierarchical nanoarchitecture composed
of few-layered perpendicular MoSe2 nanosheets anchored
onto the 2D MoSe2 horizontal layer was constructed through
the chemical vapor deposition method by employing perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic
acid tetrapotassium salt (PTAS) as a seeding agent as illustrated
in Figure c. The corrugated
ultrathin nanosheets with an average width and height of 1.69 and
2.74 μm, respectively, were grown vertically onto the horizontal
2D nanosheet (Figure d–f). The as-obtained 3D architecture exhibited less charge
transfer resistance (only 2%) and more electrochemically active surface
area (∼12 times) than the 2D MoSe2 layer. The Tafel
slope of 3D MoSe2 was reduced from 123.8 to 47.3 mV dec–1.[17] The 3D flower-like
nanoarchitectures constructed by superposition of 2D nanosheets are
also preferred due to the plethora of exposed edge sites, higher surface
areas, and improved electrical conductivity. Tran et al.[18] prepared porous MoSe2 nanoflowers
with enhanced morphology by selective etching of copper (Cu) from
MoSe2@Cu2Se. The stacked 2D-MoSe2 nanosheets, emulating the shape of petals, with a more open structure
not only led to the proliferation of active sites but also boosted
the conductivity, greatly enhancing the HER activity of porous rose-like
MoSe2 nanostructures.[18]However, to fully exploit the HER potential of MoSe2 nanostructure
design is usually coupled with other physicochemical
property modulation techniques including phase transformation, doping,
defect engineering, and heterostructure formation. Table compares the performance of
MoSe2 before and after modification to highlight the extent
and mechanism of the modulation effect.
Table 1
Performance
Comparison of MoSe2-Based Catalysts for HER and Underlying
Mechanisms
HER
catalyst
current density (mA/cm2)
overpotential (mV)
Tafel slope (mV/dec)
underlying mechanism for performance
enhancement
ref
interlayer-expanded 1T-MoSe2
10
179
78
2H → 1T phase transformation
and layer expansion resulting in a lower Gibbs free energy for H adsorption/desorption and anincreased number of active
sites
(19)
2H-MoSe2
10
558
141
plasma
10
148
51.6
more optimized active
sites owing to Se vacancies and holes
created through etching
(20)
etched MoSe2 (at 20 W)
1T-MoSe2 MoSe2-4-180 (MoSe2-x-T, x = NaBH4: Na2MoO4·2H2O, T = temperature °C)
10
152
52
2H → 1T phase transformation
coupled with defect formation leading to increased intrinsic activity
and more unsaturated Se active sites, respectively
(15)
MoSe2-1-180
10
355
146
MoSe2-4-140
10
211
72
MoSe2-4-160
10
197
54
MoSe2-4-200
10
163
55
Pt
30
defect-rich exfoliated MoSe2
10
350
90
structural defects, multiple Se vacancies,
MoSe antisite
point defect, etc.
(21)
bulk MoSe2
150
Ni-doped MoSe2
10
184
83
Ni–dopant-induced active
sites and lower charge transfer resistance
(22)
MoSe2 nanosheets
10
335
118
MoSe2/N-doped carbon
10
142
62
optimized
adsorption and desorption of H* due to N-doped carbon confinement
(23)
MoSe2
10
468
164
N-doped carbon
10
859
286
Pt/C
10
33
34
MoSe2–NiSe epitaxial growth strategy
10
210
56
synergistic
interaction between MoSe2 and NiSe and
enhanced conductivity
(7)
1
160
TOF: 5.6 s–1 at 250 mV
pure MoSe2
10
278
95
MoSe2 + NiSe mixture
10
299
74
MoSe2/MoO2/Mo
10
142
48.9
synergistic effect of combining abundant active sites of MoSe2 and improved conductivity across MoSe2/MoO2/Mo
(24)
MoSe2/Mo
10
267
65.2
MoSe2/WS2
10
75
60
rapid interface charge transport and increased
edge active
sites
(25)
MoSe2
10
112
136
WS2
10
158
114
Phase Transformation
Phase transformation
of 2D MoSe2 from a typical p-type semiconducting 2H phase
with a trigonal prismatic lattice to a metallic 1T phase with a trigonal
octahedral lattice (Figure a) promotes electrical conductivity and activates basal planes
to improve the HER performance.[16] Ambrosi
et al.[26] chemically exfoliated MoSe2, MoS2, WSe2, and WS2 using
the Li intercalation method. A more efficient and effective 2H →
1T phase transformation was achieved in MoSe2 and WS2 as compared to other counterparts. Noticeably, the 2D MoSe2 showed a 300 mV shift in overpotential and the best overall
HER performance with the lowest Tafel slope after exfoliation.
Figure 2
2H →
1T phase transformation of 2D MoSe2. (a)
Schematic illustration of the crystal structure of 2H- and 1T-phase
MoSe2. Reprinted with permission from ref (16). Copyright 2018 Wiley.
(b) Schematic description of disorder and phase and engineering in
2D MoSe2 through hydrothermal synthesis by regulating the
reaction temperature (T) and ratio of NaBH4 to Na2MoO4·2H2O (x). Reprinted with permission from ref (15). Copyright 2017 Wiley. (c) Graphical depiction
of the HER activity of interlayer-expanded 1T MoSe2. Reprinted
with permission from ref (19). Copyright 2016 Royal Society of Chemistry. (d) Schematic
illustration of in situ 2H → 1T phase transition in MoSe2 through spontaneous electron transfer from Co to Mo. Reprinted
with permission from ref (27). Copyright 2019 Nature.
2H →
1T phase transformation of 2D MoSe2. (a)
Schematic illustration of the crystal structure of 2H- and 1T-phase
MoSe2. Reprinted with permission from ref (16). Copyright 2018 Wiley.
(b) Schematic description of disorder and phase and engineering in
2D MoSe2 through hydrothermal synthesis by regulating the
reaction temperature (T) and ratio of NaBH4 to Na2MoO4·2H2O (x). Reprinted with permission from ref (15). Copyright 2017 Wiley. (c) Graphical depiction
of the HER activity of interlayer-expanded 1T MoSe2. Reprinted
with permission from ref (19). Copyright 2016 Royal Society of Chemistry. (d) Schematic
illustration of in situ 2H → 1T phase transition in MoSe2 through spontaneous electron transfer from Co to Mo. Reprinted
with permission from ref (27). Copyright 2019 Nature.The metastable metallic 1T phase of MoSe2 can readily
be converted into 2H phase, indicating lower stability.[28] The integration of metastable 1T phase with
2H phase is often utilized to prepare stable mixed 1T/2H phase 2D
MoSe2 for improved HER activity.[19] For instance, Xiao et al.[29] prepared
stable multiphase 1T/2H-MoSe2 by tuning the amount of NaBH4 reductant. The severe reduction process at excess NaBH4 concentration can lead to electronic structure change, conducive
to 2H → 1T rearrangement, in the MoSe2 framework.[15] The synergistic combination of phase transformation
with nanostructure formation and doping have also resulted in improved
performance for the electrocatalytic HER.[16] For instance, Yin et al.[15] synergistically
coupled the disorder engineering with phase transition by regulating
the temperature and the amount of NaBH4 in hydrothermal
synthesis (Figure b). Jiang et al.[19] integrated the phase
transition with interlayer spacing (Figure c) to benefit from additional sites provided
by defect-rich mixed 1T and 2H phases, increased density of exposed
sites, optimized hydrogen adsorption free energy, and enhanced electronic
conductivity of metallic 1T phase. Recently, Oh et al.[27] reported an in situ 2H → 1T phase transition
in MoSe2 during the formation of the heterostructure with
perovskite oxide La0.5Sr0.5CoO3−δ (LSC) induced by spontaneous electron transfer from Co to Mo as
illustrated in Figure d. The phase transition was induced by alteration of the electronic
configuration of the Mo 4d orbital from occupied 4d to incompletely filled d, d, and d due to additional electrons.[27]
Defect Engineering
In pristine 2D
MoSe2, only the edge sites are active for catalytic H2 evolution. The enlargement of the MoSe2 edge thorough
pore engineering enhances the HER performance to some extent. However,
to fully utilize the large proportion of stable basal planes of 2D
TMDCs, defect engineering is often employed to activate these passive
basal planes for H2 evolution.[30] The defects, including chalcogen vacancy, metal vacancy, line, and
antisite, etc., result in alteration of the electronic structure and
modify the intrinsic characteristics of 2D MoSe2 in favor
of electrocatalytic H2 generation.[6,20,21] For instance, vacancy creation induces the
catalytic activity in the inert basal plane and edges of 2D MoSe2 and enhances the electronic conductivity.[6,20] Gao
et al.[6] produced dual Mo and Se vacancies
in 2H MoSe2 through chemical vapor deposition. These vacancies
induced active catalytic sites in the basal plane and on the edges
by reducing the energy barrier of MoSe2 for H+ adsorption. These vacancies also facilitated the electron transport
by boosting the number of electrons and gap states near the Fermi
level for efficient electrocatalytic HER. The alterations in charge
densities of potential active sites created by Se and Mo vacancies
can be observed in Figure a–c. Furthermore, Figure d and 3e illustrates
the low Gibbs free energy of H+ adsorption at Mo and Se
vacancy sites on the edge and basal plane, indicting activation of
the inert basal plane by dual vacancies.[6] Similarly, Truong et al.[21] prepared exfoliated
MoSe2 sheets with multiple defects, favoring catalytic
H2 evolution, including Se vacancy, Se2 vacancy,
MoSe antisite, and adatoms through a supercritical fluid process.
A recent study accompanied by finite element and first-principles
density functional theory calculations also confirmed that vacancies
create additional active sites by reducing ΔGH* and improve the electrical conductivity by decreasing
the band gap.[20]Table S1 presents the Gibbs free energy at Mo and Se sites for various
vacancies. In conclusion, engineered structural defects tailor the
physicochemical properties of 2D MoSe2 for HER activity
beyond intrinsic levels.
Figure 3
Vacancy-induced activation of the basal plane
of 2D MoSe2. Partial charge densities of 2D MoSe2: (a) pristine,
(b) 3.12 atom % Se vacancy, and (c) 6.12 atom % Mo vacancy. Gibbs
free energy for hydrogen adsorption at the Mo site and Se site for
(d) basal plane Se vacancy, (e) basal plane Mo vacancy, (f) Se edge
with Se vacancy, and (g) Mo edge with Mo vacancy. Reprinted with permission
from ref (6). Copyright
2018 Wiley.
Vacancy-induced activation of the basal plane
of 2D MoSe2. Partial charge densities of 2D MoSe2: (a) pristine,
(b) 3.12 atom % Se vacancy, and (c) 6.12 atom % Mo vacancy. Gibbs
free energy for hydrogen adsorption at the Mo site and Se site for
(d) basal plane Se vacancy, (e) basal plane Mo vacancy, (f) Se edge
with Se vacancy, and (g) Mo edge with Mo vacancy. Reprinted with permission
from ref (6). Copyright
2018 Wiley.
Heteroatom
Doping
Heteroatom doping
is another way to activate the inactive basal planes of MoSe2. Doping of metal and nonmetal heteroatoms in 2D MoSe2 alters the electronic structure and modulates the density of states
at the Fermi level. This, in turn, activates the basal planes and
inactive edges of 2D MoSe2 for electrocatalytic HER. Gao
et al.[31] activated the basal planes and
Se edge of 2D MoSe2 by B doping. The first-principles calculations
suggested an improvement in the catalytic activity of MoSe2 for H2 evolution upon substitution of Se by B. This was
experimentally confirmed, as B-doped MoSe2 exhibited a
lower overpotential, reduced Tafel slope, and five times higher TOF
than pristine MoSe2. Although Se sites at the basal plane
of B-doped MoSe2 were found to be inactive for the HER
with ΔGH* ≈ 1 eV, the B sites
were active for the HER with ΔGH* values of −0.15 and 0.05 for one and two B-atom doping, respectively.
In addition, B doping activated the Se sites at both the Mo and the
Se edges by lowering the ΔGH* to
near zero.Metal doping in 2D MoSe2 has a similar
effect to nonmetal doping in terms of increasing the active sites
and improving the electrical conductivity. Qian et al.[32] plotted the Gibbs free energy of H+ adsorption on metal dopant sites and adjacent Se sites in a volcano
plot to identify potential dopants (Figure a). Notably, Zn showed potential for both
acting as an active site and activating adjacent Se sites. Zhao et
al.[33] successfully utilized the transition
metal (Ni, Co)-doped MoSe2 for enhanced electrocatalytic
HER in both acidic and alkaline media as illustrated in Figure b and 4c. Similarly, Yang et al.[22] reported Ni–MoSe2 for hydrogen evolution in alkaline medium with improved stability
owing to the formation of Ni–Se bonds, keeping Ni dopants intact
after a long-term cycling process.
Figure 4
Doped MoSe2 for electrocatalytic
HER. (a) Calculated
volcano plot of MoSe2 doped with different transition metals.
Reprinted with permission from ref (32). Copyright 2019 Elsevier. Electrocatalytic HER
performance of Ni- and Co-doped MoSe2 in (b) alkaline and
(c) acidic media. Reproduced with permission from ref (33). Copyright 2019 Wiley.
Doped MoSe2 for electrocatalytic
HER. (a) Calculated
volcano plot of MoSe2 doped with different transition metals.
Reprinted with permission from ref (32). Copyright 2019 Elsevier. Electrocatalytic HER
performance of Ni- and Co-doped MoSe2 in (b) alkaline and
(c) acidic media. Reproduced with permission from ref (33). Copyright 2019 Wiley.
Carbon Support
The conductive support
is essentially important to fully exploit the superior HER potential
of 2D MoSe2. Carbon supports provide a platform for electrocatalyst
dispersion, electrical conductivity, better electrocatalytic properties,
high stability, energetic transfer of an electron at the catalyst–support
interface, and abundant redox reaction sites. Highly conductive carbon-based
materials provide excellent support for the growth of MoSe2 nanostructures. Fabricating MoSe2 nanoarchitectures on
carbon substrates enhances charge transport, and the hybrid inherits
the intrinsic stability and conductivity of the substrate. For instance,
the HER performance of the MoSe2 electrocatalyst was significantly
enhanced by the flexibility and strength provided by a carbon cloth.[34] Similarly, a hybrid with an enhanced morphological
structure was obtained by combining MoSe2 with graphene
oxide, which aided the electrocatalytic kinetics at the interface
and also lowered the electron transfer resistance.[35] The core–shell C@MoSe2 hybrid with a
conductive carbon core prevented agglomeration and restacking of MoSe2 nanosheets and reduced the charge transfer resistance by
providing electrical contact between the MoSe2 shells.[36] Even though these support materials might not
actively take part in the electrolysis, conductive supports greatly
amend the HER performance of MoSe2 by ameliorating the
surface morphology, nanosheet distribution, agglomeration, and electrical
conductivity.To take the role of carbon-based supports in enhancing
the HER activity of carbon-supported MoSe2 a step further,
carbon-based materials can also be activated through heteroatom doping.[23,37] Nitrogen-doped carbonaceous materials show superior HER activity
as N doping lowers the Gibbs free energy for H+ adsorption
in carbon materials like carbon shells.[23]
Heterostructure Formation
Heterostructures
of MoSe2 are formed with other electrocatalytically active
materials to benefit from synergistic combination of the physicochemical,
electronic, and morphological properties.[25] Heterostructure formation with other metallic materials greatly
enhances the electrical conductivity of the MoSe2 hybrid
by providing additional channels for charge transportation. In addition,
the hybrid material benefits from the synergistic combination of physicochemical
properties of all of the constituents. Yang et al.[38] integrated MoSe2 with Bi2Se3 to obtain a hybrid with enhanced charge transfer properties and
a lower Tafel slope approaching that of noble metals. Moreover, integrating
MoSe2 with catalysts exhibiting a similar crystallographic
structure and lower lattice mismatch results in formation of well-defined
heterointerfaces with efficient charge transport.[7,39] For
instance, MoS2 and hexagonal NiSe exhibit a lower lattice
mismatch of 3% and 10.17%, respectively. Combining MoSe2 with MoS2[39] and NiSe[7] resulted in epitaxial growth of nanocrystallites
with active heterojunctions exhibiting a larger surface area and improved
charge transport. Likewise, core@shell heterostructures also improve
the interfacial charge transfer resulting in enhanced HER performance.[40] Defect formation at the heterointerface contributes
to formation of additional active sites and activates the basal planes
of MoSe2. Intercalation of 2D MoSe2 nanosheets
with porous CoP sheets not only resulted in an increased surface area
but also increased the active site density due to the formation of
interfacial defects.[41]In the previous
sections, we summarized common strategies employed to exploit the
HER potential of 2D MoSe2. Various experimental studies
tested these concepts and reported performance enhancements. Table S2 summarizes the performance parameters
and figures of merits for selected MoSe2-based electrocatalysts
for the HER.
MoSe2 in Photocatalytic
Hydrogen
Generation
Although the conduction band minimum of MoSe2 is well
above the water reduction potential, making it favorable for the HER,
the small band gap of MoSe2 is not suitable for generation
and separation of enough electron–hole pairs.[42] In addition, inherent photocorrosion associated with 2D
TMDCs also greatly limits the application of MoSe2 in photocatalytic
H2 generation.[43] Therefore,
rather than developing MoSe2 as a standalone alternative
to popular catalysts (e.g., TiO2) for photolysis, more
focus was allocated to utilize MoSe2 in combination with
other electron-generating materials as it provides active sites for
H2 generation and acts as an efficient electron sink. Gupta
et al.[42] reported the photocatalytic HER
activity of 1T-MoSe2 sensitized by Eosin Y dye. MoSe2 helps in the separation of the electron–hole pair
as it acts as an electron sink and provides thermodynamically favorable
active sites for hydrogen adsorption and evolution. Moreover, 1T-MoSe2 was reported to enhance the photocatalytic HER activity of
g-C3N4 by 90 times by acting as a conduction
band cocatalyst in 1T-MoSe2/g-C3N4.[44] Similarly, MoSe2 acted
as an electron sink and provided catalytic sites for H2 generation in hierarchical ZnIn2S4/MoSe2 nanoarchitectures to enhance the photocatalytic HER performance.[45] Zeng et al.[46] constructed
a heterostructure of flower-like and network-like 2H MoSe2 with porous g-C3N4 to elucidate the dominant
role of the active sites provided by MoSe2. The network-like
MoSe2 exhibited superior HER performance owing to the synergistic
effect of the sheet-on-sheet heterointerface, which effectively assists
in charge separation and migration. Similar effects were also observed
in layered nanocomposites of 2D MoSe2 with borocarbonitride
and polymer-functionalized rGO (Figure a).[11] Therefore, we believe
that more efforts directed toward addressing poor charge separation
and photocorrosion of MoSe2 could produce promising results.
Figure 5
MoSe2 as cocatalyst for photocatalytic HER. (a) Dye-sensitized
photocatalytic HER on a layered nanostructure of MoSe2.
Reprinted with permission from ref (11). Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society. Time-dependent
population of photogenerated (b) holes and (c) electrons in the CB
and VB of MoSe2 and Ti2CO2. Reprinted
with permission from ref (43). Copyright 2021 Royal Society of Chemistry. (d) Volcano-like
correlation between the overpotential and the Gibbs free energy for
hydrogen adsorption at different sites. Reprinted with permission
from ref (47). Copyright
2020 Elsevier.
MoSe2 as cocatalyst for photocatalytic HER. (a) Dye-sensitized
photocatalytic HER on a layered nanostructure of MoSe2.
Reprinted with permission from ref (11). Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society. Time-dependent
population of photogenerated (b) holes and (c) electrons in the CB
and VB of MoSe2 and Ti2CO2. Reprinted
with permission from ref (43). Copyright 2021 Royal Society of Chemistry. (d) Volcano-like
correlation between the overpotential and the Gibbs free energy for
hydrogen adsorption at different sites. Reprinted with permission
from ref (47). Copyright
2020 Elsevier.Carefully aligning the band gap
of MoSe2 with other
semiconductors to construct a Z-scheme heterojunction is a promising
strategy for ameliorating the detrimental electron–hole pair
recombination. In addition, a Z-scheme catalyst can also extend the
application of MoSe2 to total water splitting in a bicatalytic
system by providing holes for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER).
Moreover, fast transfer of photogenerated holes across the heterojunction
can help remediate the inherent photocorrosion of MoSe2 and significantly enhance the stability of the catalytic system.
Fu et al.[43] proposed a 2D van der Waals
(vdW) MoSe2/Ti2CO2 heterojunction
for overall water splitting where Ti2CO2 and
MoSe2 act as O2 and H2 evolution
photocatalysts, respectively. The first-principles calculations revealed
that the MoSe2/Ti2CO2 heterojunction
resists photocorrosion and electron–hole recombination. Nonadiabatic
molecular dynamics (NAMD) simulations predicted the ultrafast transfer
of charge carriers across the heterojunction (Figure b and 5c). Notably,
both the instant transfer of 65% holes from the VB of MoSe2 to the CB of Ti2CO2 and the antiphotocorrosion
property of Ti2CO2 aided to the photostability
of the heterojunction. Moreover, the unique band alignment of the
heterojunction leads to a 12% theoretical solar-to-hydrogen (STH)
energy conversion efficiency, making the Z-scheme MoSe2/Ti2CO2 photocatalyst promising for commercial
application.Mechanistically, a heterogeneous photocatalytic
HER on the surface
of a catalyst is like electrocatalytic H2 generation with
an added complexity of electron–hole pair generation through
light irradiation, their separation, and propagation to reaction sites.
Therefore, strategies employed to enhance the electrocatalytic HER
performance of MoSe2 can be improvised to assist in photocatalytic
H2 generation. In addition, activating the basal planes
and inactive edges and optimizing the H+ adsorption sites
will improve the ability of MoSe2 to effectively receive
and export the electron to H2 evolution sites. In that
regard, multiphase MoSe2 was successfully incorporated
in heterostructures with improved ability to receive electrons, higher
HER activity, and improved stability.[47] The comparison of H2 evolution activity at different
active sites is illustrated in a volcano-like plot in Figure d. Moreover, the photoelectrochemical
HER is another avenue to explore and can benefit from the synergy
of the electro- and photocatalytic HER in a single catalyst. For instance,
rhenium-doped MoSe2 exhibited enhanced photocurrent response.[48]Table S3 presents
the performance evaluation of MoSe2-based photocatalysts
for H2 generation.
Conclusions and Future Perspectives
MoSe2 is an excellent electrocatalyst for the HER owing
to its low Gibbs free energy for hydrogen adsorption, narrow band
gap, and more metallic nature. Nevertheless, the relatively low electrical
conductivity, inactive basal planes, and aggregation of nanosheets
during synthesis limit the application of pristine MoSe2. Fortunately, the physicochemical and electronic properties of MoSe2 can easily be tailored to suit the HER by simple techniques.
Researchers have successfully realized desirable effects such as an
increased number of active sites, improved electrical conductivity,
stability, and enhanced morphology sufficiently exposing active sites
in 2D MoSe2. Simple strategies including phase transition,
defect engineering, heteroatom doping, and heterostructure formation
are effective in enhancing the HER performance. For instance, the
2H → 1T phase transition of 2D MoSe2 enhances the
electrical conductivity and activates the basal planes to improve
the HER performance. Moreover, defect engineering and heteroatom doping
can activate the basal planes and improve the conductivity without
compromising the stability. We believe that combining multiple strategies
in a single catalyst can result in maximized performance.Nanostructure
design is also an important tool to fully utilize
the superior HER potential of 2D MoSe2. The formation of
nanosheets and nanoflakes with enhanced morphology and exposed active
sites boosts the overall performance. In that regard, sufficiently
open nanoarchitectures, closely packing enough active sites, with
interconnected electrical networks are desirable. This is often achieved
using an interconnected network of highly conductive supports as the
substrate for MoSe2 growth. Carbon-based materials are
better suited as support materials owing to the good conductivity
and ability to form interconnected networks. In addition, carbonaceous
materials may also be activated for the HER by N doping. However,
synthesis of a grid-like structure of MoSe2 is still challenging,
which can provide superior conductivity and enhanced pathways for
electrolyte and H2 diffusion. Moreover, the green synthesis
of MoSe2-based catalysts should be pursued to make the
H2 generation wholly green.Combining MoSe2 with other active materials is another
noteworthy technique to enhance the catalytic activity. The formation
of a heterostructure results in an increased number of active sites,
improved morphology, and amplified conductivity to synergistically
enhance the electrocatalytic H2 generation. Moreover, optimized
integration of multiple modification techniques in a single catalyst
should be explored to further enhance the HER performance. However,
identification of the best suited candidates is still dependent on
human intuition, heuristics, and trial and error methods, which consume
a lot of time and precious resources. Data-driven studies employing
machine-learning models guided by ab initio calculations can accelerate
the discovery of the best HER catalysts. The physicochemical properties
of different combinations of materials and modulations can be predicted
through theoretical calculations as well as data-driven approaches.
Machine learning can further be helpful in screening suitable candidates
from an array of potential materials. Finally, results can be verified
through experimental studies. More information on the utilization
of machine learning for material discovery can be found in recent
reviews.[49,50]MoSe2 also acts as good
cocatalyst in the photocatalytic
and photoelectrocatalytic HER by providing active sites and ameliorating
electron–hole recombination by acting as an electron sink.
The activity of MoSe2 as an electron exporter in photocatalytic
H2 generation can be further enhanced through phase transition,
defect engineering, doping, and other techniques employed for the
electrocatalytic HER. Moreover, construction and experimental investigation
of a direct Z-scheme photocatalyst of MoSe2 is a novel
avenue to explore and might produce promising results for overall
water splitting.The application of 2D MoSe2 for
other relevant applications
such as the electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) to produce
ammonia (NH3) should also be investigated. Similar to other
TMDCs, 2D MoSe2 might also exhibit an enhanced ammonia
yield rate as the spontaneous adsorption of N2 on the 1T
phase of MoSe2 has already been established.[51] Recently, Chen et al.[52] effectively reduced N2 to NH3 with a high
Faradaic efficiency of 37.82% by isolating single Au atoms onto MoSe2. We believe that the application of the above-mentioned strategies
can also be effectively extended to enhance the performance of MoSe2-based catalysts for green NH3 production.
Authors: Tian-Long Zhai; Cuijuan Xuan; Jincheng Xu; Li Ban; Zhiming Cheng; Shaolei Wang; Deli Wang; Bien Tan; Chun Zhang Journal: Chem Asian J Date: 2018-08-01
Authors: Dezhi Xiao; Qingdong Ruan; De-Liang Bao; Yang Luo; Chao Huang; Siying Tang; Jie Shen; Cheng Cheng; Paul K Chu Journal: Small Date: 2020-05-28 Impact factor: 13.281