Hongyan Xia1,2, Yuguo Ding2, Jingjing Gong2, Annamaria Lilienkampf2, Kang Xie1, Mark Bradley2. 1. State Key Laboratory of Precision Electronic Manufacturing Technology and Equipment, School of Electromechanical Engineering, Guangdong University of Technology, Guangzhou, Guangdong 510006, China. 2. EaStCHEM School of Chemistry, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH9 3FJ, United Kingdom.
Abstract
Photoresponsive fluorochromic materials are regarded as an effective means for information storage. Their reversible changes of color and fluorescence facilitate the storage process and increase the possible storage capacity. Here, we propose an optically reconfigurable Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) process to realize tunable emissions based on photochromic spiropyrans and common fluorophores. The kinetics of the photoisomerization of the spiropyran and the FRET process of the composite were systematically investigated. Through tuning the ratios of the acceptor spiropyran and donor fluorophore and external light stimuli, a programmable FRET process was developed to obtain tunable outputs. More importantly, flexible microarrays were fabricated from such fluorochromic mixtures by inkjet printing (230 ppi) and the dynamic FRET process could also be applied to generate tunable fluorescence in ready-made microstructures. The flexible patterns created using the microarrays could be used as novel optically readable media for information storage by altering the composition and optical performance of every feature within the microarray. A key aspect of information storage such is anti-counterfeiting, and these colorful displays can be fabricated and integrated in a simple and straightforward system. The reliable fabrication and programmable optical performances of these large-scale flexible polymer microarrays represent a substantial step toward high-density and high-security information storage platforms.
Photoresponsive fluorochromic materials are regarded as an effective means for information storage. Their reversible changes of color and fluorescence facilitate the storage process and increase the possible storage capacity. Here, we propose an optically reconfigurable Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) process to realize tunable emissions based on photochromic spiropyrans and common fluorophores. The kinetics of the photoisomerization of the spiropyran and the FRET process of the composite were systematically investigated. Through tuning the ratios of the acceptor spiropyran and donor fluorophore and external light stimuli, a programmable FRET process was developed to obtain tunable outputs. More importantly, flexible microarrays were fabricated from such fluorochromic mixtures by inkjet printing (230 ppi) and the dynamic FRET process could also be applied to generate tunable fluorescence in ready-made microstructures. The flexible patterns created using the microarrays could be used as novel optically readable media for information storage by altering the composition and optical performance of every feature within the microarray. A key aspect of information storage such is anti-counterfeiting, and these colorful displays can be fabricated and integrated in a simple and straightforward system. The reliable fabrication and programmable optical performances of these large-scale flexible polymer microarrays represent a substantial step toward high-density and high-security information storage platforms.
Entities:
Keywords:
Förster resonance energy transfer; fluorochromic; information storage; photoresponsive; polymer microarray
Society
is entering an era of information and data, but how to
store the vast amount of information efficiently has already become
a major challenge.[1] Compared with magnetic
and electronic information storage technologies based on semiconductor
materials, optical information storage exhibits the merits of low
cost, high storage density, fast speed, easy portability, and low
power consumption.[2,3] Photoresponsive fluorochromic
materials that can switch and modulate their fluorescence and color
reversibly upon external light stimuli are very promising in optical
information storage.[4−6] Different from previous optical information storage
such as digital versatile discs (DVDs), compact discs (CDs), and Blu-ray
discs that are already replaced by solid-state memory, photoresponsive
materials can well realize information recording and readout because
they can undergo a series of reversible changes in certain physical
and chemical properties in response to light stimulus.[7] Information (re)writing and erasing,[8] encryption and decryption,[9] anti-counterfeiting,[10] and displays[11] based
on photoresponsive fluorochromic materials can be ″read″
directly by their change of color and fluorescence, thus offering
great convenience for optical information storage.[12,13] Light makes photoresponsive fluorochromic materials easier to realize
and put into practice than many other approaches; indeed, the rapid,
accurate, and remote spatiotemporal resolution enabled by photomodulation
will ensure a smooth realization for information storage.[14] In addition, light can modulate the color and
emission of photoresponsive materials precisely, preventing optical
information recording and readout from being stolen or counterfeited.
Also, organic photoresponsive fluorochromic materials exhibit unique
advantages due to their high flexibility, light weight, broad spectral
coverage, and compatibility with large-area solution processing techniques
such as inkjet printing in comparison with their inorganic counterparts.[15] One of the most commonly used strategies to
obtain photoresponsive fluorochromic materials is through Förster
resonance energy transfer (FRET) between functional photochromic units
(energy acceptors) and fluorophores (energy donors).[16] The reversible isomerization of photochromic units leads
to light-based and dynamically tunable concentrations of the isomers,
which can be used to modulate the stoichiometric ratio of the donor
and acceptor, resulting in tunable FRET and output emissions of the
composite system.[17−19] Such a system offers the potential for high-level
security and broader information processing and storage applications
through the manipulation of the FRET process. Most of the FRET processes
in previous works were carried out in solutions, even if some were
in nanoparticles, these particles were still dispersed or dissolved
in solutions, which were used as inks and written or printed on papers
when applied for information storage. The capacity and modulation
accuracy of the information storage are limited. Thus, the development
of modulation for the FRET process in solid microscale, capable of
rapidly switching emissions of each microunit in microstructures,
is of great significance in the increasement of the modulation accuracy
and density of information storage.Limited and random outputs
and distributions of emissions cannot
meet the development of miniaturization and integration of optoelectronic
components and devices, and well-organized and precisely controlled
integration and assembly are urgently needed.[20] Optical microarrays, which can integrate multifunctional materials
together optically and regularly, will enhance the photonic properties
and satisfy future optical integrated applications, such as information
storage.[21,22] Also, the ordered optical microarray provides
an effective approach to boost writing/reading throughputs as it can
increase information storage capacity and modulation accuracy. As
such, it has been reported that the optical microarray has a potential
to change the current magnetization-based approach for big data storage
to the use of optical discs, with each microunit in the microarray
having the ability to record and read information to maximize throughput.[23] Inkjet printing is a mask-free patterning technique
that can be used for the precise fabrication of optical microarrays
in a controlled manner, with the advantages of rapid noncontact processing
at low cost and inherent scalability.[24−26] This method can utilize
a variety of ″ink solutions″ with many nozzle formats,
allowing direct deposition onto substrates according to predesigned
patterns accurately.[27] In addition, the
morphology, size, and spacing of the printed features on the microarrays
can be readily adjusted with precise alignment and position over a
very large area.[28] Inkjet printing thus
provides a facile technology to deposit a wide variety of materials
on various substrates in well-defined patterns.[29]Spiropyrans, the typical photochromic compounds,
have been extensively
introduced into various functional materials due to their reversible
photochemical interconversion between two isomers with distinct properties
upon ultraviolet light (UV) and visible light (vis) irradiation.[30−32] Herein, spiropyran 1 and two fluorophores (5(6)-carboxyfluorescein
(2) and disodium 2,2′-[biphenyl-4,4′-diyldiethene-2,1-diyl]dibenzenesulfonate
(3)) were integrated together to construct the photoresponsive
fluorochromic materials through dynamic and tunable FRET process.
Under 365 and 470 nm light irradiation, spiropyran 1 isomerizes
between the ring-opened form (merocyanine, 1b) that is
fluorescent and the ring-closed form (spiro, 1a) that
is nonfluorescent. When mixed with a fluorophore, FRET will only occur
between the fluorophore and the spiropyran isomer 1b (acceptor).
This FRET efficiency can be modulated by adjusting the ratio of the
two isomers of spiropyran through different levels of light irradiation,
resulting in different colors and fluorescence of the mixtures. What’s
more, flexible and large-scale microarrays of the above photoresponsive
fluorochromic materials with a controllable arrangement and specific
functionalities on polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) substrates by inkjet
printing were obtained, with a resolution of 230 ppi. FRET was carried
out in the solid, well-designed, microstructures, and the emissions
of each microunit in microstructures can be regulated. Information
writing and erasing, encryption and decryption, and display can be
realized using the dynamic and colorful flexible microarrays. Owing
to the versatility, compatibility, and convenient processing capability
of the programmable fluorochromic polymer microarray, they could be
applied in almost all aspects of information storage. This system
is easy to fabricate without complex and troublesome synthesis. Every
feature within the microarrays can be used as a pixel, while every
individual pixel can be designed and modulated. Such multiple dynamic
emission states can potentially carry high-levels of information.
This precise adjustment at the microscale will greatly improve the
modulation accuracy and information storage capacity in ultracompact
photonic components.
Results and Discussion
Dynamic FRET Processes Based on the Photochromic
Moiety
The structures and absorption, and fluorescence spectra
of the ring-opened form of spiropyran (1b), 5(6)-carboxyfluorescein
(2), and disodium 2,2′-[biphenyl-4,4′-diyldiethene-2,1-diyl]dibenzenesulfonate
(3) are displayed in Figure S1. When the spiropyran is in the ring-opened isomer 1b that emits red fluorescence, there are two obvious absorption bands
between 500 and 700 nm and below 500 nm, which overlap largely with
the emission spectra of fluorophores 2 and 3, respectively (Figure a). Effective FRET channels can be established when the physical
distance between the donor and the acceptor is appropriate (in this
case, between 1b and 2, and 1b and 3). When the spiropyran is in the non-fluorescent
ring-closed form (1a), there is no FRET possible between 2, 3, and the spiropyran (Figure b). FRET can be generated and dynamically
modulated by changing the ratio of 1a and 1b through external light stimuli. As shown in Figure S2, with increased time of visible (470 nm) irradiation,
the fluorescences of 2 (Figure S2c,d) and 3 (Figure S2a,b) almost
remain unchanged. But for 1b, increasing the time of
470 nm irradiation closes the spiropyran, and the fluorescence intensity
decreases due to the loss of fluorescent 1b (the change
in fluorescence intensity with irradiation time fits a first-order
process (Figure S2e,f,g)). Thus, in a FRET
process using these three materials, with photochromic 1 used as the switching/dynamic component and 2 and 3 used as the static counterparts, tunable photoresponsive
fluorochromic materials can be generated.
Figure 1
(a) The spectral overlap
between the fluorescence spectrum of 2 and 3 and the absorption spectrum of 1b. (b) Isomerization
of 1a and 1b under UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2) and vis (470 nm, 15 mW/cm2) irradiation and an
illustration of the dynamic FRET process.
(c) The fluorescence spectra of 2, 3, and 1b.
(a) The spectral overlap
between the fluorescence spectrum of 2 and 3 and the absorption spectrum of 1b. (b) Isomerization
of 1a and 1b under UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2) and vis (470 nm, 15 mW/cm2) irradiation and an
illustration of the dynamic FRET process.
(c) The fluorescence spectra of 2, 3, and 1b.Figure shows the
typical spectroscopic changes observed during the FRET process. Before
470 nm exposure, the energy transfers from donors (2 and 3) to the acceptor (1b) and the emissions from
the donors are limited. However, upon increasing the 470 nm exposure
time (increasing the concentration of the ring-closed form 1a), the emission peaks in the green and blue bands increase, but the
emission peaks in the red bands decrease (due to the decreasing concentration
of fluorescent 1b). The reason is that isomerization
from 1b to 1a decreases the FRET efficiency
that is tightly correlated to the acceptor concentration (1b), and accordingly, the donor emissions are slowly switched on and
the acceptor emissions are suppressed. Here the optimized FRET efficiency
(in the blue or green bands: based on the decreased FL intensity/the
initial FL intensity) was calculated.[9] From Figure and Figures S3 and S4, when the molar ratio of 1b to 2 was 1:8, 1:4, and 1:2, the FERT efficiency
reached 42, 57, and 70%, respectively, and when the molar ratio of 1b to 3 was 10:1, 20:1, and 40:1, the FERT efficiency
can reach 63, 67, and 70%, respectively, so the FRET efficiency can
be tuned by changing the spiropyran/fluorophore ratio.
Figure 2
(a) The fluorescence
spectra and (b) the fluorescence intensity
changes of the red (the maximum peak intensity of each spectrum from
panel a in the range of 651–659 nm) and the green (the maximum
peak intensity of each spectrum from panel a in the range of 495–521
nm) bands for the mixed solution of 1b and 2 with a ratio of 1:4 upon different times of 470 nm (15 mW/cm2) light irradiation. (c) The first-order kinetic fitting of
the fluorescence intensity changes of the red and green bands from
panel b. (d) The fluorescence spectra and (e) the fluorescence intensity
changes of the red (the maximum peak intensity of each spectrum from
panel d in the range of 658–667 nm) and blue (the maximum peak
intensity of each spectrum from panel d in the range of 429–432
nm) bands for the mixed solution of 1b and 3 with a ratio of 20:1 upon different times of 470 nm (15 mW/cm2) light irradiation. (f) The first-order kinetic fitting of
the fluorescence intensity changes of the red and blue bands from
panel e.
(a) The fluorescence
spectra and (b) the fluorescence intensity
changes of the red (the maximum peak intensity of each spectrum from
panel a in the range of 651–659 nm) and the green (the maximum
peak intensity of each spectrum from panel a in the range of 495–521
nm) bands for the mixed solution of 1b and 2 with a ratio of 1:4 upon different times of 470 nm (15 mW/cm2) light irradiation. (c) The first-order kinetic fitting of
the fluorescence intensity changes of the red and green bands from
panel b. (d) The fluorescence spectra and (e) the fluorescence intensity
changes of the red (the maximum peak intensity of each spectrum from
panel d in the range of 658–667 nm) and blue (the maximum peak
intensity of each spectrum from panel d in the range of 429–432
nm) bands for the mixed solution of 1b and 3 with a ratio of 20:1 upon different times of 470 nm (15 mW/cm2) light irradiation. (f) The first-order kinetic fitting of
the fluorescence intensity changes of the red and blue bands from
panel e.Figure c,f presents
the kinetic plots for the fluorescence intensity changes (in the blue,
green, and red bands) with different times of 470 nm light irradiation
according to the calculation method described and the given formula
(details are in the Supporting Information).[33−36] In the system of FRET between the spiropyran and fluorophores with
matched emission bands, the kinetics are related to four parameters:
the initial concentration of the spiropyran, the ratio between the
spiropyran and the fluorophores, the excitation light intensity, and
the UV/vis irradiation time. Here the initial concentration of spiropyran
and the excitation light intensity when energy transfer occurs are
fixed, and the ratio between the spiropyran and the fluorophores and
the UV/vis irradiation time are changed. The fluorescence changes
of both the energy donors and acceptor are fitted well by exponential
equations, and the linear relationships demonstrate that they are
first-order reactions as shown in previous works.[18,37,38] The fluorescence intensity and kinetic analysis
of mixtures composed of 1b and 2, and 1b and 3 in various ratios were evaluated with
differing 470 nm light irradiation times (Figures S3 and S4). According to the reaction order and kinetic rates
of different blending ratios (presented in Table S1), they are comparable to the pure spiropyran, thus the isomerization
between 1a and 1b is the determining step
in the dynamic FRET process. Also we noticed that compared with the
kinetic rate constant k1 (0.00739 s–1) for pure spiropyran, k1’s (0.00926, 0.00919, and 0.00979 s–1) for
the mixtures of 1b and 2 with different
ratios are slightly higher, while k1’s
(0.00316, 0.00427, and 0.00484 s–1) for the mixtures
of 1b and 3 with different ratios are slightly
lower (Table S1), which could be rationalized
by the change in polarity of the different mixtures. With the isomerization
of 1b to 1a, the polarity decreases because
the ring-opened form 1b is more polar than the ring-closed
form 1a. The polarity of 2 is lower than 3 (3 contains ionically charged groups), which
presumably facilitates the formation of 1a, so the k1 for the mixture of 1b and 2 increases and the k1 for the
mixture of 1b and 3 decreases.Upon
exposure to 365 or 470 nm light, the fluorescence peaks in
the spiropyran and fluorophore mixtures can be made to fluctuate reversibly,
with the fluorescence emissions of the donors and acceptors switched
on and off repeatedly by the ″forward and backward″
FRET process. As shown in Figure S5, after
20 cyclic irradiations, there are no apparent changes in the fluorescence
intensity of peak and valley values from the fluorescence spectra,
indicating the outstanding stability and reversibility of the constructed
photoresponsive fluorochromic materials.
Fabrication
of Flexible and Fluorochromic
Polymer Microarrays
Herein inkjet printing, that can selectively
print a solution at desired positions on substrates in accordance
with predesigned patterns, was used to fabricate polymer microarrays
on flexible PDMS films under ambient conditions. By mixing part A
and part B of SYLGARD 184 Silicone Elastomer in a mass ratio of 10:1
and heating, the PDMS film could be obtained after solidification
(Figure S6). Photographs show the high
transparency of the PDMS film, which is crucial for later optical
applications. Also, the flexibility of the PDMS is excellent; whether
the film is bent, folded, twisted or otherwise shaped, it can completely
return to its original state. This lays a solid foundation for subsequent
deformation applications on curved and irregular surfaces (Figure S7).To allow good spot morphology
and stable polymer features on the substrate, the film surface was
preprocessed as shown in Figure a. The surface was initially temporally masked with
sucrose (according to a predesigned pattern) and then coated with
1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorooctyldimethylchlorosilane (PFDS) to generate
a fluorous surface. The sucrose mask and unreacted PFDS were removed
by washing, and subsequently, the exposed ″demasked″
surface was functionalized with the acrylsilane. At each designed
position, after the monomer, cross-linker, initiator, and dyes/fluorophores
are printed and polymerization is initiated, the polymer matrix was
cross-linked. Since there will be some penetration into the substrate,
a 3D covalent network will be generated with the dyes/fluorophores
confined and trapped within (Figure S8).[39] This will provide a very stable environment
for functional molecules to withstand subsequent deformable applications.
Here the monomer was acrylamide, and the cross-linker was N,N′-methylenebis(acrylamide). The
functional dyes/fluorophores are entrapped into the polyacrylamide
3D gel networks after polymerization. The polyacrylamide is selected
as the polymer matrix for the construction of optical microstructures
because of its high compatibility and excellent printability. Polyacrylamide
also exhibits high optical transparency in the visible region, which
would avoid optical losses caused by energy transfer between doped
photochromic materials and the host matrix, permitting us to construct
photonic devices with high performance. Benefiting from the high versatility
of the inkjet printing, 1, 2, and 3 or other dyes and functional materials can be doped in the
polymer features together or separately according to different applications.
Finally, large-scale pixelated functional microarrays are precisely
integrated to form the predesigned pattern.
Figure 3
(a) Illustration of the
preprocessing of the PDMS substrate and
fabrication of the polymer microarray. (b–f) SEM images of
the prepared dye-doped polymer microarray: (b) top view (scale bar:
200 μm); (c) side view (scale bar:100 μm); (d) top view
of a magnified image of one polymer feature (scale bar:10 μm);
(e) top view of features printed with different sizes (scale bar:500
μm); and (f) side view of a magnified image of one polymer feature
(scale bar:10 μm). (g–i) Fluorescence microscopy images
of the polymer microarrays: (g) doped with 3, (h) doped
with 2, and (i) doped with 1b. All scale
bars are 100 μm.
(a) Illustration of the
preprocessing of the PDMS substrate and
fabrication of the polymer microarray. (b–f) SEM images of
the prepared dye-doped polymer microarray: (b) top view (scale bar:
200 μm); (c) side view (scale bar:100 μm); (d) top view
of a magnified image of one polymer feature (scale bar:10 μm);
(e) top view of features printed with different sizes (scale bar:500
μm); and (f) side view of a magnified image of one polymer feature
(scale bar:10 μm). (g–i) Fluorescence microscopy images
of the polymer microarrays: (g) doped with 3, (h) doped
with 2, and (i) doped with 1b. All scale
bars are 100 μm.The SEM images of the
features across the microarray showed that
they are arranged regularly. Each feature exhibits a hemispherical
morphology with a circular boundary, which will minimize undesired
optical scattering and effectively confine emission to inside the
feature (Figure b,c),
demonstrating that acrylamide is a good choice for the printing. There
are some slight folds on the surface, presumably caused by shrinkage
during polymerization (Figure d,f). When 2, 3, and photoresponsive 1b were incorporated into the features, clear and bright blue,
green, and red emissions can be observed from the fluorescence optical
microscope images (Figure g,h,i). The emissions are uniform across each feature, indicating
that the dyes are well dispersed. Since, in these flexible polymer
microarrays, the functional dyes and fluorophores are entrapped in
the 3D cross-linked polyacrylamide gel networks, they can migrate
into similar microcavities and domains in gels where the free volume
is large and maintain their inherent properties.To increase
the feature density and brightness of the dye-doped
polymer microarrays, the smaller the feature size and spacing are,
the better. The size and the spacing distance can be rationally modulated
over a wide range by varying the corresponding parameters in the software
(Figures S9 and S10); e.g., by adjusting
the number of drops, we can modulate the size, and by adjusting the
dot pitch, we can modulate the spacing. Here, the minimal size of
one feature was about 80 μm and the minimal spacing between
adjacent features was about 30 μm, giving a pattern resolution
of 230 pixels per inch (ppi) (Figure g) according to the formula ρ = L/(d1 + d2) (ρ: the density, L: unit length, d1: diameter, and d2: distance between adjacent dots), which is comparable
to the literature.[40,41] Thus, it was an ideal building
block for the production of desired and ordered pixel microarrays
with high packaging density due to the precise positioning of inkjet
printing. Also, different sizes of features can be integrated into
one substrate (Figure i). The printing process is controllable and reproducible, which
is conducive for constructing high-quality microstructures on a large
scale. What’s more, the microarray can be printed well on different
substrates, indicating that the printed microstructure has high compatibility
and universality of diverse substrates (Figure S11), so this process could unlock a wide application scope
for most dyes and functional material solutions on a variety of substrates.
Tunable Fluorescence from Individual Features
The photoresponsive fluorochromic materials were developed within
a polymer microarray format, and the donor and acceptor were entrapped
and located within the Förster distance within each feature
by virtue of their high concentrations.[42] Thus, 1, 2, and 3 were doped
into the features of the polymer microarray, and individual microarray
features were analyzed using a microfluorescence system (Figure S12), with each dye-doped feature excited
locally with a focused laser beam. The ratio between spiropyran and
fluorophores and the UV/vis irradiation time are changed to modulate
the emissions of features.For the pattern ″ABC″,
the mixture of 1b and 2 is doped in the
microarray (in a ratio of 1:3), and the letters ″A″,
″B″, and ″C″ are irradiated with 470 nm
light for 0, 30, and 600 s, respectively. Different fluorescence colors
and spectra are obtained as shown in Figure a. For the letter ″A″, with
no visibe light irradiation, the features emit red fluorescence, attributed
to the fluorescent form of the spiropyran (1b) giving
rise to the peak at 650 nm, because the ring-opened form of spiropyran
(1b) in the polymer matrix of the letter ″A″
can absorb the green fluorescence of the carboxyfluorescein (2) due to the efficient FRET. For the letter ″B″,
upon vis irradiation (470 nm, 30 s), the features emit a yellow light
with two key peaks centered at 520 nm and 650 nm. This is because
both 1a and 1b are present, resulting in
a partial FRET process and hence dual emissions. For the letter ″C″,
after 10 min of 470 nm light exposure, the photochromic reaction is
complete to the ring-closed form (1a), and hence, the
features in ″C″ emit green fluorescence (main peak at
520 nm) originating from the carboxyfluorescein and the suppression
of the FRET process (the red fluorescence emission is not possible).
With prolonged 470 nm light irradiation from ″A″ to
″C″, the fluorescence intensity from the ring-opened
form of spiropyran (1b) decreases gradually, while the
fluorescence intensity from the donor carboxyfluorescein (2) increases, because the FRET efficiency between 1b and 2 is controlled by the population of 1b related
to the external light exposure time. The optimized FRET efficiency
can reach 69% in this microarray.
Figure 4
Color generation of the microarrays following
different 470 nm
(15 mW/cm2) light irradiation times and the corresponding
fluorescence spectra from an individual feature. (a) Fluorescence
images of 2 and 1b doped microarrays printed
as letters ″A″, B″, and ″C″. (b).
Fluorescence images of 3 and 1b doped microarrays
printed as numbers ″0″, ″1″, and ″2″.
The insets in the spectra are the fluorescence images of the corresponding
single feature (scale bar: 50 μm).
Color generation of the microarrays following
different 470 nm
(15 mW/cm2) light irradiation times and the corresponding
fluorescence spectra from an individual feature. (a) Fluorescence
images of 2 and 1b doped microarrays printed
as letters ″A″, B″, and ″C″. (b).
Fluorescence images of 3 and 1b doped microarrays
printed as numbers ″0″, ″1″, and ″2″.
The insets in the spectra are the fluorescence images of the corresponding
single feature (scale bar: 50 μm).A microarray doped with the ring-opened form of spiropyran (1b) and disodium 2,2′-[biphenyl-4,4′-diyldiethene-2,1-diyl]dibenzenesulfonate
(3) (in a ratio of 8:1) was similarly fabricated, printing
the numbers 0, 1, and 2. Here, the three features (0, 1, and 2) are
470 nm light irradiated for 0, 30, and 600 s, respectively. This gives
different emissions (red, magenta, and blue) due to the different
FRET efficiencies caused by the different illumination times. For
″0″, the features emit red fluorescence from 1b, with the fluorescence from 3 well suppressed due to
efficient FRET. With 470 nm light exposure for 30 s for ″1″,
a stronger emission is obtained from donor 3, with decreasing
emission from the 1b due to isomerization to 1a. For ″2″, there is negligible FRET with the fluorescence
spectrum dominated by the emission of 3, leading to distinct
color variation across the three features; the optimized FRET efficiency
reached 64%.It is generally agreed that the isomerization of
spiropyran can
be described by first-order kinetics in solutions[35,36,43] and in the spiropyran doped gels[44−46] under UV and vis irradiation except for crystalline polymer matrixes.
The isomerization of spiropyran and kinetics in our gel are almost
unaffected from our experimental results. The prepared features in
the polymer microarrays exhibit switchable and multicolor emissions
and similar FRET efficiencies as solutions, indicating that the photoisomerization
and FRET process and their kinetics are well-maintained in the polyacrylamide
3D cross-linked gel networks because the free volume is large in the
microcavities and domains in the gel and the polymer matrix does not
influence the photochromic properties of the doped photoresponsive
fluorochromic materials. Thus, the dynamically programmable polymer
microarrays could provide an opportunity to construct colorful pixelated
panels for information storage as a single feature can function as
an individual pixel without the need to combine several dots as subpixels.
Due to the optically reconfigurable FERT process, the pixels can emit
different colored fluorescence upon defined light exposure.
Flexible Pixelated Panels for Information
Storage
The above flexible fluorochromic polymer microarrays
can be applied in almost all aspects of information storage, including
data (re)writing and erasing, encryption and decryption for anti-counterfeiting,
colorful display, and so on. To show the flexibility of the polymer
microarrays, photos were taken of the printed patterns on curves with
different curvatures (c = 1/ρ, ρ is the
bending radius of the curve; Figure S13) prepared by 3D printing.To illustrate the ability of the
above polymer microarrays for data storage, a QR code was printed
first, with the code divided into four regions, as follows: region
①: only 3 was doped; region ②: only 1b was doped; and regions ③ and ④: 3 and 1b are doped together but at different ratios (Figure ). The whole code
will be visible using UV illumination, but the fluorescence of region
② will disappear and the message will be erased by vis illumination
due to the isomerization of 1b to 1a. Conveniently,
the colorful QR code could be scanned on a mobile phone. The relatively
slow writing and erasing speed is attributed to the slow isomerization
rate of spiropyran (that is not caused by the polymer matrix as even
in the solution, the isomerization rate of spiropyran is also slow).[47] Actually, 60% is completed within 30 s after
the UV light is turned on; it takes a long time to reach the equilibrium
state later. It was reported that the introduction of electron-donating
and electron-withdrawing substituents at the position of 6′
and 8′ into the structure of spiropyran can help to improve
its isomerization speed.[48,49] Exploring the effects
of different substituents of spiropyran on its isomerization and energy
transfer rate is a follow-up research focus in the polymer matrix
gel of this system. It is necessary to find ways to improve the information
writing and erasure speed in the QR code. The fatigue resistance of
one feature in region ③ of the QR code pattern was examined
after 30 consecutive cycles upon UV and vis irradiation (Figure S14). The fluorescence intensity changes
in the red and blue bands; both showed good reversibility and negligible
decrease, demonstrating that the photoisomerization of spiropyran
was robust and the FRET process of the fluorochromic materials proceeded
smoothly in the gels. Although the information carried by the colorful
code is the same as that carried by the traditional black-and-white
code, it also increases interest and makes the visual experience better.
With the progress of technology, the information carried by the colorful
code will be more abundant and the QR code generated here can be optically
controlled with a ″write–read–erase″ operation
with a nondestructive readout capability.
Figure 5
A fluorescent switchable
QR code. Left: a black and white fluorescence
microscope image of the inkjet-printed QR code (http://www.combichem.co.uk/). Middle and right: images of the printed QR code under different
UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2, 3 min) and visible (470 nm, 15 mW/cm2, 8 min) irradiations.
A fluorescent switchable
QR code. Left: a black and white fluorescence
microscope image of the inkjet-printed QR code (http://www.combichem.co.uk/). Middle and right: images of the printed QR code under different
UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2, 3 min) and visible (470 nm, 15 mW/cm2, 8 min) irradiations.The demand for high-level information security is growing. Recently,
anti-counterfeiting systems based on fluorochromic materials have
been developed to increase safety and security.[50,51] In this study, a reversible anti-counterfeiting platform was constructed
based on the programmable fluorochromic polymer microarray. A pattern
of a ″rabbit″ with an insert of a heart shape in the
middle was printed (Figure ). The features for the ″rabbit″ were doped
with 2 alone, but the ″heart″ was doped
with 1b and 2 together (in the ratio of
1:3). The original and true document is a green fluorescent rabbit
with a red fluorescent heart that could be hidden through vis irradiation
(470 nm) (i.e., both the rabbit and the heart emitted green fluorescence,
and the real information is invisible (encryption)). Only upon UV
irradiation is the correct information unlocked and displayed (the
″heart″ showing a notable color and fluorescence change
(decryption)). The encryption and decryption processes demonstrated
here will also work with a variety of patterns and could be extended
to high-security media, such as banknotes and identity documents,
with potential in anti-counterfeiting and information security applications.
Figure 6
Images
of a reversible anti-counterfeiting system using the pattern
of a ″rabbit″ with a ″heart″ shape based
on the fluorochromic polymer microarrays under UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2, 2 min) and visible (470 nm, 15 mW/cm2, 6 min)
exposure. Scale bar: 5 mm.
Images
of a reversible anti-counterfeiting system using the pattern
of a ″rabbit″ with a ″heart″ shape based
on the fluorochromic polymer microarrays under UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2, 2 min) and visible (470 nm, 15 mW/cm2, 6 min)
exposure. Scale bar: 5 mm.The uniformity of the features in the microarrays was also evaluated.
The fluorescence intensity changes of the green bands for all the
40 features in the heart shape were tested upon UV and visible irradiation
to show the uniformity of the printed features. From Figure S15, we can see that the fluorescence change and photoswitching
efficiency of 40 features in the heart shape at green bands are similar
upon UV and visible irradiation, so the uniformity of the printed
features in the microarrays is fine, which will be conducive to the
subsequent information storage applications with low signal-to-noise
ratios.Another important application of information storage
is the display.
At present, the lack of flexible pixelated display panels with highly
organized emissive geometries impedes the flexible displays in the
application of portable and wearable devices.[52] Here, based on the programmable flexible polymer microarray with
dense packing, a vivid, colorful umbrella image is printed. The different
regions of the umbrella are printed with different compositions and
ratios so that they could change color under UV and vis irradiation
(Figure and Figure S16). The display stability under deformations
is a crucial issue in the design of flexible display. Thus, the umbrella
pattern was analyzed with different curvatures (Figure ). This shows that there is almost no obvious
display difference to the naked eye during cycles of bend and relaxation,
demonstrating that the flexible panels formed by pixelated emissive
microarrays under deformation maintain a stable imaging performance.
Since any image can be considered as a matrix of pixels, different
display patterns can be easily generated with each individual feature
acting as a pixel. This universal and practical technique allows the
fabrication of sophisticated patterns and ″pixelated emissive
microarrays″ that will generate colorful panels for outstanding
color imaging and flexible displays.
Figure 7
Images of the flexible colorful display
of an ″umbrella″
pattern. (a) Under UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2) and vis (470
nm, 15 mW/cm2) irradiation. (b) Side view and (c) corresponding
top view of the flexible ″umbrella″ displays under different
curvatures. Scale bar: 2 cm.
Images of the flexible colorful display
of an ″umbrella″
pattern. (a) Under UV (365 nm, 10 mW/cm2) and vis (470
nm, 15 mW/cm2) irradiation. (b) Side view and (c) corresponding
top view of the flexible ″umbrella″ displays under different
curvatures. Scale bar: 2 cm.Long-term stability is important for practical applications. Here,
using the QR code pattern as an example, the long-term stability of
the fluorochromic microarrays was evaluated. After the QR code was
stored for 6 months under ambient temperature in the dark, the information
can also be written by UV and erased by visible light. Fluorochromic
properties were maintained as well as shown in Figure S17. The reason was that the 3D cross-linked polymer
matrix was very stable. It can protect the wrapped fluorochromic materials
from the bleaching of oxygen, moisture, and oxygen free radicals in
the air and increase their stability. Also, the substrate made of
PDMS is very stable. The polymer and substrate are polymerized together
by cross-linking, which can enhance the stability between the substrate
and the microarray features as well. All these confirmed the high
robustness and long-term stability of the fluorescent microstructures,
which make the application of polymer microarrays in the work as information
storage media completely feasible.
Conclusions
In conclusion, optically programmable polymer microarrays were
successfully fabricated on a flexible PDMS substrate through inkjet
printing. Photochromic spiropyrans and fluorophores (as energy acceptors
and donors for FRET) were incorporated simultaneously into the printed
features, endowing the images with intriguing photoresponsive fluorochromic
capabilities and sophisticated functions. The photoisomerization process
between isomers of spiropyran upon external light stimuli was applied
to achieve a tunable acceptor concentration for tailoring the stoichiometric
ratio of the acceptor and donor dynamically. As such, every feature
can function as a pixel, and the fluorochromic performance can be
designed and modulated based on an optically reconfigurable FRET process.
The large-scale, flexible, and pixelated microarrays with a resolution
of 230 ppi can be used for many aspects of information storage. The
marriage of photochromic units with fluorophores into well-assembled
microstructures provides a universal strategy to optically manipulate
fluorescence behavior and performance at a molecular and microscopic
level. The scalable integrated flexible microarrays reported in this
work will pave a new avenue for the efficient construction of large-scale
colorful information storage devices, with the polymer itself providing
a powerful vehicle to protect and enhance the stability of the dyes.
Experimental Section
Materials
2-(3′,3′-Dimethyl-6-nitrospiro[chromene-2,2′-indolin]-1′-yl)ethanol
(spiropyran) (1) and tris(trimethylsiloxy)-3-methacryloxypropylsilane
were purchased from Fluorochem Ltd. Acrylamide (monomer), N,N′-methylenebis(acrylamide) (cross-linker),
2,2′-azobis(2-methylpropionitrile) (initiator), and 5(6)-carboxyfluorescein
(2) were all obtained from Sigma-Aldrich. Disodium 2,2′-[biphenyl-4,4′-diyldiethene-2,1-diyl]dibenzenesulfonate
(3) was purchased from Generon Ltd. (brand: Neo Biotech).
SYLGARD 184 was obtained from Merck Life Sciences. 1H,1H,2H,2H-Perfluorooctyldimethylchlorosilane
(PFDS) was obtained from Fisher Scientific Ltd. All reagents and solvents
were of analytical grade and used as received without any further
treatment.
Fabrication of the PDMS
Flexible Substrate
The SYLGARD 184 base elastomer and curing
agent (mass ratio of
10:1) were mixed together uniformly and gently. To remove air bubbles,
the mixture of elastomer and curing agent was placed into a vacuum
desiccator for 1 h. The mixture was poured onto a silanized glass
surface, evenly spread, and then placed into an oven at 100 °C.
After incubating for 3 h, the cross-linked and cured PDMS film was
easily peeled off the glass slide and was cut to the desired size
as needed for later experiments.
Surface
Masking of the PDMS Film
The PDMS film with a moderate size
was washed by ultrasonication
in water, ethanol, and acetone and dried under a stream of nitrogen.
Then the PDMS film was treated with an O2 plasma (Diener
Plasma system, 50 L/h O2, 5 min, 100 W), making the hydrophobic
surface hydrophilic. Features (pixels) across the modified PDMS film
were masked by inkjet printing five drops of an aqueous sucrose solution
(20% w/v; the inkjet ink was the aqueous sucrose solution in this
step) to give a predesigned microarray pattern (the equipment is described
in the next part). 1H,1H,2H,2H-Perfluorooctyldimethylchlorosilane
(PFDS, 20 μL) was placed around the periphery of the sucrose
printed pattern, and subsequently, the film was sealed in a small
box to allow functionalization via the generation of a fluorous surface.
After 1 day, the film was washed with water and acetone to remove
the sucrose mask and excess PFDS and dried with a stream of nitrogen.
Tris(trimethylsiloxy)-3-methacryloxypropylsilane (15 μL) was
spread across the top of the dried film and sealed, with the acrylsilane
observed to "pooling" into the ″masked″ features.
After
24 h, the film was washed with acetone five times, dried under a flow
of nitrogen, and kept in a refrigerator until used.
Fabrication of the Emission Polymer Microarrays
The
emission polymer microarrays were fabricated through precise
spotting on the flexible PDMS substrate using the noncontact sciFLEXARRAYER
S5 (Scienion, Germany) inkjet printing system equipped with a PDC
80 Piezo Dispense Capillary (Piezo Systems, Massachusetts, USA; 50
μm nozzle aperture). The printer contained a washing area, a
solution absorption area and a printing area, with an XYZ stage, a
camera, and a piezoelectric nozzle. It was programmed/run using the
software sciFLEXARRAYER (Scienion AG, version 2.19.008.9). The pattern
to be printed can be self-designed by highlighting the features in
the field setup submenu (one feature can be regarded as one pixel)
(Figure S9). In addition, the number of
drops printed (the volume of a single drop is 360–440 pL) can
be used to modulate the printed feature size.Here, 50 μL
of each reagent solution was transferred into a 384-well microtiter
plate and printed (see the Supporting Information). After clicking ″start″ on the software, the whole
printing process is automatic and continuous. The solvent will be
absorbed automatically to clean the whole machine and nozzle first,
and then the nozzle capillary will absorb the dispensing liquid in
the microtiter plate and move to the front of camera that is used
to visualize the drop volume, shape, stability, and trajectory. These
can be adjusted by changing the pulse width (40–60 μs),
frequency (450–550 Hz), and piezo voltages (90–120 V)
through the software for reliable droplet ejection and good drop morphology.
The inkjet ink in this step was the N-methylpyrrolidone
(NMP) solutions of acrylamide (monomer, 1 M), N,N′-methylenebisacrylamide (cross-linker, 0.015 M),
functional materials (0.001 M, 1b or 2 or 3 or the mixtures of 1b and 2 or
the mixtures of 1b and 3 with different
molar ratios), and 2,2′-azobis(2-methylpropionitrile) (initiator,
0.005 M). Subsequently, the nozzle moved to the target area and printed
the designed pattern driven by piezo. After finishing printing, the
nozzle will finally return to the home position. As a part of the
automatic printing process, the nozzle was washed with a solvent between
each printing cycle. Printing was carried out at 20 °C in an
air atmosphere with 50% humidity.
Characterization
UV–vis absorbance
spectra were measured using an UV/vis spectrophotometer (Agilent 8453).
The fluorescence spectra of the solutions were determined by a spectrofluorophotometer
(Shimadzu RF-6000) with a xenon lamp excitation light source with
a data interval of 1 nm and a scan speed of 6000 nm/min. All spectral
measurements were obtained in a quartz sample cell (with a 1 cm path
length) at room temperature. The fluorescence spectra of one feature
of the polymer microarray were recorded using an in-house far-field
microfluorescence system. The morphology of the polymer microarrays
was examined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Zeiss Crossbeam
550 FIB-SEM). Fluorescence microscopy images were taken on a Axiovert
200M inverted research microscope (Zeiss) with a 20× objective.