| Literature DB >> 35625062 |
Marianna Delussi1, Vittorio Sciruicchio2, Paolo Taurisano1, Francesca Morgante3,4, Elena Salvatore5, Isabella Pia Ferrara5, Livio Clemente1, Chiara Sorbera6, Marina de Tommaso1.
Abstract
Pain is a minor problem compared with other Huntington Disease (HD) symptoms. Nevertheless, in HD it is poorly recognized and underestimated. So far, no study evaluated the presence of chronic pain in HD. The aim of this pilot study was to evaluate the presence and features of chronic pain in a cohort of HD gene carriers. An observational cross-sectional study was conducted in a cohort of HD gene carriers compared to not gene carriers (n.134 HD subjects, n.74 not gene mutation carriers). A specific pain interview, alongside a neurological, cognitive and behavioural examination, was performed in order to classify the type of pain, subjective intensity. A significant prevalence of "no Pain" in HD was found, which tended to increase with HD progression and a reduced frequency of pain in the last 3 months. A clear difference was found between manifest and premanifest HD in terms of intensity of pain, which did not change significantly with HD progression; however, a tendency emerges to a progressive reduction. No significant group difference was present in analgesic use, type and the site of pain. These findings could support a lower prevalence of chronic pain in manifest HD. Prevalence and intensity of chronic pain seem directly influenced by the process of neurodegeneration rather than by an incorrect cognitive and emotional functioning.Entities:
Keywords: Huntington’s disease; basal ganglia; chronic pain; cognitive decline; family controls; manifest patients; motor impairment; pain features; pain interview; premanifest subjects
Year: 2022 PMID: 35625062 PMCID: PMC9139182 DOI: 10.3390/brainsci12050676
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Brain Sci ISSN: 2076-3425
Demography and Outcome of the entire study group.
| Overall | Non Mut. | Pre HD | M Tot | HD Early | HD Middle | HD Late | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| 208 | 74 | 18 | 116 | 23 | 59 | 27 |
| Age | 53.59/11.88 | 55.19/10.52 | 45.56/10.38 | 53.88/12.46 | 51.57/13.56 | 54.8/9.38 | 55.3/17.42 |
| Gender N | 110F/98M | 43F/31M | 7F/11M | 60F/56M | 13F/10M | 27F/32M | 16F/11M |
| % | 52.9/47.1 | 58.1/41.9 | 38.9/61.1 | 51.7/48.3 | 56.5/43.5 | 45.8/54.2 | 59.3/40.7 |
| CAG | - | - | 41.25/0.95 | 44.15/3.65 | 45.36/6.36 | 43.48/2.55 | 44/3.26 |
| Y. of Illness | - | - | - | 11.3/7.22 | 8.36/8.65 | 10.29/5.71 | 13.41//7.99 |
| UHDRS | - | - | - | 46.83/23.53 | 21.69/14.59 | 44.1/19.93 | 64.88/18.14 |
| TFC | 8.67/4.62 | 12.62/1.18 | 13/0 | 6.01/4.12 | 12.43/0.78 | 5.46/2.01 | 1.74/2.19 |
| MMSE | 24.34/6.43 | 28.81/2.02 | 29.14/0.86 | 20.61/6.47 | 27.3/2.51 | 19.96/4.63 | 13.76/6.25 |
| SDMT Corr. | 11.91/16.75 | 33.53/13.05 | 20.75/17.65 | 6.11/12.62 | 29.2/14.62 | 2.24/5.85 | 0.96/4.58 |
| SDMT Err. | 0.09/0.32 | 0 | 0.5/1 | 0.08/0.27 | 0.2/0.42 | 0.07/0.25 | 0.04/0.2 |
| SCN Corr. | 33.95/30.24 | 70.47/15.54 | 54.25/15.01 | 21.45/23.99 | 58.1/22.49 | 22.83/16.94 | 3.78/9.23 |
| SCN Err. | 0.08/0.35 | 0 | 0.25/0.5 | 0.1/0.39 | 0/0 | 0.17/0.53 | 0.04/0.2 |
| SCR Corr. | 40.92/35.6 | 83.21/13.1 | 70.5/27.5 | 26.05/28.61 | 69.8/25.58 | 27.62/19.74 | 5.04/13.09 |
| SCR Err. | 0.07/0.33 | 0 | 0 | 0.1/0.39 | 0/0 | 0.07/0.37 | 0.17/0.49 |
| SI. Corr. | 17.42/19.38 | 43.47/9.73 | 39.25/11.14 | 8.03/12.3 | 27.4/15.1 | 6.9/8.44 | 1.04/3.47 |
| SI. Err. | 0.6/1.38 | 0.11/0.31 | 0.5/0.57 | 0.76/1.57 | 0.6/0.84 | 1.41/2.06 | 0/0 |
| PBA-s Dep. | 4.11/3.47 | 1.5/2.43 | 2.5/2.38 | 4.97/3.4 | 1.7/2.16 | 5.07/3.52 | 6.26/2.8 |
| PBA-s Irr. | 2.7/3.72 | 1.11/2.34 | 3/3.83 | 3.15/3.95 | 1.2/2.44 | 4.03/4.75 | 2.87/3.06 |
| PBA-s Psyc. | 0.67/2.97 | 0 | 0 | 0.9/3.43 | 0/0 | 0.21/0.77 | 2.17/5.41 |
| PBA-sApat. | 1.68/3.18 | 0 | 0.5/1 | 2.24/3.53 | 0.1/0.3 | 1.86/2.56 | 3.65/4.68 |
| PBA-sEx.Fu. | 1.64/4.2 | 0 | 0 | 2.23/4.76 | 0.1/0.31 | 2.17/3.45 | 3.22/6.68 |
Pain Interview and BPI-s outcomes.
| Overall S | Non Mut. C. | Pre HD | M Tot | HD Early | HD Middle | HD Late | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Point A | |||||||
| YES % | 104/50 | 47/63.5 | 10/55.6 | 47/40.5 | 11/47.8 | 24/40.7 | 7/25.9 |
| No % | 104/50 | 27/36.5 | 8/44.4 | 69/59.5 | 12/52.2 | 35/59.3 | 20/74.1 |
| Point | |||||||
| ≤10 N/% | 40/19.2 | 17/23 | 7/38.9 | 16/13.8 | 1/4.3 | 8/13.6 | 5/18.5 |
| ≤20 N/% | 17/8.2 | 7/9.5 | 0/0 | 10/8.6 | 3/13 | 6/10.2 | 1/3.7 |
| ≤30 N/% | 18/8.7 | 11/14.9 | 2/11.1 | 5/4.3 | 0/0 | 3/5.1 | 1/3.7 |
| ≤45 N/% | 13/6.3 | 5/6.8 | 0/0 | 8/6.9 | 3/13 | 4/6.8 | 0/0 |
| ≤90 N/% | 16/7.7 | 8/10.8 | 1/5.6 | 7/6 | 2/8.7 | 3/5.1 | 0/0 |
| Point C | |||||||
| Ar.-Le. N/% | 40/19.2 | 14/18.9 | 1/5.6 | 25/21.6 | 6/26.1 | 11/18.6 | 5/18.5 |
| He. N/% | 38/18.3 | 20/27 | 6/33.3 | 12/10.3 | 3/13 | 7/11.9 | 0/0 |
| Ba.-Sh. N/% | 22/10.6 | 12/16.2 | 2/11.1 | 8/6.9 | 2/8.7 | 4/6.8 | 2/7.4 |
| Tr. N/% | 3/1.4 | 0 | 1/5.6 | 2/1.7 | 0/0 | 2/3.4 | 0/0 |
| Point D | |||||||
| ≤10 N/% | 70/33.7 | 24/32.4 | 9/50 | 37/31.9 | 7/30.4 | 20/33.9 | 7/25.9 |
| ≤20 N/% | 15/7.2 | 11/14.9 | 0/0 | 4/3.4 | 0/0 | 3/5.1 | 0/0 |
| ≤30 N/% | 8/3.8 | 7/9.5 | 1/5.6 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 |
| ≤45 N/% | 3/1.4 | 3/4.1 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 |
| ≤90 N/% | 6/2.9 | 2/2.7 | 0/0 | 4/3.4 | 2/8.7 | 1/1.7 | 0/0 |
| Point E | |||||||
| VAS | |||||||
| Mean/DS | 6.32/2.23 | 7.67/1.93 | 6.9/2.02 | 4.85/1.57 | 4.82/1.94 | 4.63/1.4 | 4.83/0.4 |
| BPI-s I | 5.87/2.68 | 7.09/2.73 | 7.71/0.48 | 4.3/1.87 | 4/2.14 | 4.43/1.91 | 4.43/0.78 |
| BPI-s F | 5.3/3.19 | 5.94/1.73 | 4.81/0.93 | 4.67/4.41 | 8.87/8.18 | 3.88/2.36 | 3.27/1.91 |
| Pain type | |||||||
| Neuropathic | |||||||
| N/% | 2/1 | 1/1.4 | 0/0 | 1/0.9 | 0/0 | 1/1.7 | 0/0 |
| Nociceptive | |||||||
| N/% | 31/14.9 | 17/23 | 0/0 | 14/12.1 | 2/8.7 | 5/8.5 | 5/18.5 |
| Nociplastic | |||||||
| N/% | 39/18.8 | 16/21.6 | 7/38.9 | 16/13.8 | 3/13 | 12/20.3 | 0/0 |
| Visceral | |||||||
| N/% | 1/0.5 | 1/1.4 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 | 0/0 |
| Mixed | |||||||
| N/% | 26/12.5 | 10/13.5 | 3/16.7 | 13/11.2 | 5/21.7 | 5/8.5 | 1/3.7 |
Figure 1(a): prevalence of no pain responses in HD groups. (b): prevalence of no pain responses in HD stages. “*” = statistically significant value.
Figure 2(a): prevalence of no pain responses among type of pain among FC, HD-M and HD-PM groups. (b): % of pain days during the last 3 months among FC, HD-M and HD-PM groups. (c): site of pain was similar among FC, HD-M and HD-PM groups: Blue: FC, Orange: HD-PM, Grey: HD-M. (d): use of symptomatic drugs among FC, HD-M and HD-PM groups: Blue: FC, Orange: FC, Grey: HD-M. “*” = statistically significant value.
Figure 3(a): Intensity of pain (VAS) among FC, HD-M and HD-PM groups. (b): Intensity of pain (Vas) among HD gene carriers groups. “*” = statistically significant value.
Figure 4(a): Intensity of pain (BPI) among FC, HD-M and HD-PM groups. (b): Intensity of pain (BPI) among HD gene carriers groups. “*” = statistically significant value.
Figure 5(a): Scatter plot CAG and VAS between HD gene carriers groups. (b): Scatter plot TFC and VAS between HD stages.