In this study, biobased gel polymer electrolyte (GPE) membranes were developed via the esterification reaction of a cardanol-based epoxy resin with glutaric anhydride, succinic anhydride, and hexahydro-4-methylphthalic anhydride. Nonisothermal differential scanning calorimetry was used to assess the optimal curing time and temperature of the formulations, evidencing a process activation energy of ∼65-70 kJ mol-1. A rubbery plateau modulus of 0.65-0.78 MPa and a crosslinking density of 2 × 10-4 mol cm-3 were found through dynamic mechanical analysis. Based on these characteristics, such biobased membranes were tested for applicability as GPEs for potassium-ion batteries (KIBs), showing an excellent electrochemical stability toward potassium metal in the -0.2-5 V voltage range and suitable ionic conductivity (10-3 S cm-1) at room temperature. This study demonstrates the practical viability of these biobased materials as efficient GPEs for the fabrication of KIBs, paving the path to increased sustainability in the field of next-generation battery technologies.
In this study, biobased gel polymer electrolyte (GPE) membranes were developed via the esterification reaction of a cardanol-based epoxy resin with glutaric anhydride, succinic anhydride, and hexahydro-4-methylphthalic anhydride. Nonisothermal differential scanning calorimetry was used to assess the optimal curing time and temperature of the formulations, evidencing a process activation energy of ∼65-70 kJ mol-1. A rubbery plateau modulus of 0.65-0.78 MPa and a crosslinking density of 2 × 10-4 mol cm-3 were found through dynamic mechanical analysis. Based on these characteristics, such biobased membranes were tested for applicability as GPEs for potassium-ion batteries (KIBs), showing an excellent electrochemical stability toward potassium metal in the -0.2-5 V voltage range and suitable ionic conductivity (10-3 S cm-1) at room temperature. This study demonstrates the practical viability of these biobased materials as efficient GPEs for the fabrication of KIBs, paving the path to increased sustainability in the field of next-generation battery technologies.
In the context of high-performance
polymers, epoxy resins represent
one of the most widely employed families of thermosetting systems
for demanding applications, given their outstanding thermal, chemical,
and mechanical resistance, which enables them to be used successfully
in a large variety of industrial fields.[1] However, epoxy resins also exhibit critical issues, mainly associated
with the toxicity of some of their precursors, which are typically
derived from fossil resources.[2,3] Within this context,
vegetable oils have been considered as a cheap source of potentially
useful functional monomers and oligomers to be explored as promising
candidates for replacing fossil-based epoxy resins.[4−14] In particular, cardanol, a highly abundant, nonedible and renewable
byproduct extracted from the shell of the cashew nuts, has also been
investigated for the production of biobased epoxy resins.[15−17] On the other hand, in order to obtain fully biobased systems, research
efforts in the direction of increased materials sustainability have
focused on the development of alternative systems to replace the most
commonly used oil-based curing agents, namely amines, amides, hydroxyls,
acid anhydrides, phenols, and polyphenols.[18,19] In this field, particular attention has been given to modified plant
oils, biobased acids and anhydrides, biobased amines, biobased phenols,
rosin acids, terpenes, and lignin.[20−22]In view of the
main principles and goals of sustainable development,
the design and synthesis of such advanced, fully biobased polymers
is a prerequisite for their application in technological areas where
both high performance and enhanced sustainability set the requirements.
In this respect, growing interest is nowadays devoted to the world
of rechargeable batteries,[23,24] whose market penetration
is experiencing a significant acceleration not only in portable electronics
and sustainable mobility but also in the field of large-scale electricity
storage in power plants connected with photovoltaic or wind power
stations. In these sectors, safety is a crucial and still an unsolved
aspect, as the vast majority of commercial (lithium-based) batteries
still work with electrolytes obtained using flammable and, in some
conditions, even explosive organic solvents mixed with salts.[25,26] This has forced the scientific community to investigate the use
of polymer matrices for the preparation of quasi-solid electrolytes
(where the electrolyte solution is trapped in a cross-linked polymeric
matrix)[27−30] and fully solid ones (in which the mobility of lithium ions is exclusively
guaranteed by the segmental movement of polymer chains in the amorphous
phase).[31−33] Most of these polymeric systems are based on poly(ethylene
oxide) (PEO) of petrochemical derivation due to its favorable electrochemical
stability, ability to reversibly complex metal cations (starting from
lithium ions), and its processability aimed at obtaining quasi-solid
and solid electrolytes.[34−36]While lithium-based batteries
research rapidly proceeds, the limited
lithium reserves (0.0017 wt % in Earth’s crust) and its uneven
geographical availability overall lead to inevitable increases in
raw material costs, which can typically be sustained in the case of
high-tech devices (where commercial costs are already high) or if
a suitable recycling chain is implemented to recover and reuse lithium.[37,38] In parallel, postlithium batteries are also being considered worldwide,
especially for those applications where the battery size is large,
and the cost must be kept very low, for example, in the case of electrochemical
energy storage units to be integrated into buildings or into renewable
energy-based power stations. Our group has recently started working
on potassium-ion batteries (KIBs), given the cheap and abundant raw
material (2.09 wt % in Earth’s crust), its favorable geographical
distribution, and its intriguing electrochemical properties (K+/K has a potential of −2.93 V vs standard hydrogen
electrode, a value close to that of Li+/Li, −3.04
V).[39−41] Also, potassium ions show a weaker Lewis acidity
than that of lithium-based counterparts, accompanied by a much smaller
Stokes’ radius (i.e., 3.6 vs 4.8 Å) in propylene carbonate,
thus guaranteeing a higher ionic conductivity in the liquid electrolyte.[42−44] Overall, potassium ions can be successfully used as charge carriers
between the anode and cathode in KIBs, following the same “rocking-chair”
mechanism that has brought lithium-ion battery to the current worldwide
success. In view of their potential market penetration, KIBs must
target the same safety conditions as the lithium-based counterpart;
thus, some very preliminary literature articles are appearing with
polymer electrolytes replacing liquid ones.[45−47] Also, preliminary
studies are often carried out in half-cells using potassium metal
as the anode (that could as well represent a good choice at the market
level considering its low cost). However, its high reactivity further
requires an electrolyte system able to keep the device stable with
time. One of the major challenges for KIB’s applicability is,
in fact, the occurrence of severe side reactions between the electrolyte
and electrodes, which result in an unstable solid–electrolyte
interphase, and thus a low coulombic efficiency. Additionally, the
poor solubility of potassium salt in the traditional ester electrolyte
has led to the use of ether solvents.[48] Hence, designing suitable electrolytes is necessary for the development
of efficient and competitive KIBs.[49,50] To address
these issues, in this article, we propose gel polymer electrolyte
(GPE) matrices obtained from biobased epoxy resins derived from cardanol
and crosslinked with cyclic anhydrides as curing agents, able to be
activated by an electrolyte based on potassium salts and showing promising
electrochemical
performance in view of KIB’s applications. In particular, an
electrochemical stability toward potassium metal and a suitable ionic
conductivity at room temperature could be achieved as key milestones
for future investigations aimed at integrating the proposed bioderived
GPE in lab-scale potassium-based secondary battery prototypes.
Experimental Section
Materials
Cardanol-derived
epoxy novolac resin NC547
was purchased from Cardolite (see Figure S1 in the Supporting Information for the chemical structure), whereas
hexahydro-4-methylphthalic anhydride (PAn), glutaric anhydride (GAn),
and succinic anhydride (SAn) were bought from Sigma-Aldrich. Triazabicyclodecene
(TBD), potassium (cubes in mineral oil, 99.5% trace metal basis),
and KPF6 (99.5% trace metal basis) were purchased from
Merck. Battery grade ethylene carbonate (EC) and diethyl carbonate
(DEC) were bought from Solvionic.
Characterization
Nonisothermal differential scanning
calorimetry (DSC) analyses were performed with a DSC 823e Mettler-Toledo
instrument under nitrogen atmosphere. The uncured samples (∼5–10
mg) were subjected to a thermal cycle from 25 to 300 °C with
different heating rates (β = 5, 10, 15, and 20 °C min−1) to determine the curing temperature of the biobased
epoxy system, the latter being related to the exothermic peak temperature
of the crosslinking reaction (Tp).Ozawa and Kissinger–Akahira–Sunose (KAS) methods were
used to calculate the apparent kinetic activation energy of the curing
process (Ea) according to eqs and 2, respectively.where A′
and A are the preindex factors of the Ozawa and KAS
methods,
respectively, and R is the universal gas constant.Additionally, DSC analyses on samples treated at the selected curing
temperature for different curing times (0–120 min) were performed
with a thermal cycle from 25 to 300 °C at 10 °C min–1 to evaluate the curing kinetics.Fourier-transformed
infrared (FTIR) spectra were recorded using
a Thermo Nicolet Nexus 670 instrument. Measurements were performed
in transmission mode on solid films deposited on KBr discs, recording
64 accumulated scans at a resolution of 4 cm–1.Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed with a TA Instruments
Q500 under air atmosphere. The cured samples (∼15–20
mg) were subjected to a thermal cycle from 25 to 800 °C at a
heating rate of 20 °C min−1 to assess the thermo-oxidative
stability of the biobased epoxy systems.To evaluate the extent
of crosslinking after curing, gel content
measurements were performed by soaking the samples in tetrahydrofuran
(i.e., a good solvent for both biobased epoxy resin and anhydrides),
subsequently allowing them to dry in vacuum and finally measuring
the mass of the dried undissolved material. This procedure was repeated
at increasing soaking times. After 24 h, the mass of the dried undissolved
materials was found to be constant. Accordingly, the gel fraction
(GEL %) was calculated based on eq where m24h and m0 represent the weight
of the recovered gel after 24 h soaking and of the pristine samples,
respectively.Dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) in shear mode
was performed with
a Mettler-Toledo DMA/SDTA 861e on sample disks with a diameter of
6 mm and a thickness of 2 mm to determine the linear viscoelastic
region (LVR) and the thermal transitions of the obtained materials.
In the former case, DMA measurements were performed in a strain sweep
configuration (1 Hz, strain between 0.1 and 200 μm) at 25 °C.
In the latter case, temperature sweep tests (from −50 to 140
°C with a heating rate of 3 °C min–1)
were conducted at 1 Hz and a deformation amplitude within the LVR
(1 μm). From DMA analysis in the temperature sweep configuration,
the crosslinking density ν (moles of crosslinking sites per
unit volume, mol cm–3) was calculated through eq where TC is the
characteristic temperature, and GR′ is the shear storage modulus
in the rubbery plateau at TC. TC was set at 100 °C (373 K) for all the
samples, well above their respective glass transition temperature.The electrolyte uptake ratio (EUR) was measured for each biobased
epoxy membrane at room temperature and under dry atmosphere by swelling
each membrane with a standard KIB liquid electrolyte, namely KPF6 0.8 M in EC/DEC 1:1. Each sample was weighted at different
time intervals, and EUR values were determined for each measurement
through eq where m and m represent
the weight of the dry membrane and of the membrane swelled for time t, respectively.The rheological properties of the
cardanol-based membranes both
in the dry and swollen (with a EC/DEC 1:1 v/v solution) state were
measured using a Discovery DHR2 stress-controlled rheometer (TA Instruments)
equipped with a 20 mm diameter stainless steel plate and a Peltier
plate temperature controller (parallel-plate geometry). In particular,
the LVR was measured by varying the shear stress amplitude from 1
to 104 Pa at a constant frequency of 10 Hz. All experiments
were carried out at a constant temperature of 25 °C and applying
an active normal force on the specimen (10 N for both dry and swollen
samples) for the entire duration of the measurements. Linear sweep
voltammetry (LSV) was carried out at room temperature using two ECC-Std
electrochemical cells by EL-Cell GmbH, able to apply a mechanical
load (up to 50 N) on the 18 mm-diameter plunger, ensuring an adjustable,
reproducible, and homogeneous pressure on the electrodes. One cell
was used to detect the cathodic branch of the LSV measurement; thus,
the swollen membrane was sandwiched between potassium and copper foils
to be tested from its open-circuit voltage (OCV) down to −0.2
V. Instead, the other cell was assembled according to the following
architecture: potassium|swollen membrane|stainless steel. The potential
scan for the latter was set from OCV to 5 V to record the anodic branch
of the LSV curve. Both measurements were conducted at a scanning rate
of 0.1 mV s–1. The electrochemical workstation used
was the VSP-3e model by BioLogic Sciences Instruments.The ionic
conductivity (σ) values of the swollen GPE membranes
were measured by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS), assembling
ECC-Std electrochemical cells, where the swollen membrane was sandwiched
between two stainless steel plates. The cell was kept into a digitally
controlled climatic chamber (model MK53 × 102.1 by
BINDER GmbH), where the temperature was decreased from 50 to 10 °C
by 10 °C steps. At each step, the temperature was kept constant
for 1 h and then the EIS measurement was performed, allowing to record
the value of electrolyte resistance (Rb), at the high-frequency intercept, at that temperature. σ
values were calculated through eq where L is the sample thickness,
and S is its area.
Preparation of Biobased
Epoxy Membranes
Biobased membranes
were prepared using a cardanol-derived epoxy resin (from now on referred
to as NC547) and three different cyclic anhydride curing agents: GAn,
SAn, and PAn, the latter used as a reference system given its wide
application in conventional oil-based epoxy systems.[51−54] A given amount of NC547 was weighed in a beaker and preheated to
100 °C using a hot plate in order to reduce its viscosity and
make the mixing process easier. Then, the selected anhydride was added
to the NC547 resin and magnetically stirred until a homogeneous mixture
was obtained. The composition was fixed at an anhydride/epoxy group
molar ratio equal to 1. Finally, the catalyst (TBD) was added to the
mixture in an amount equal to 5 wt % with respect to the moles of
epoxy functionalities, and magnetic stirring was continued until a
complete dissolution in the blend was achieved. The obtained viscous
liquid was deposited by blade coating (K control coater by RK Printcoat
Instruments) on a Teflon sheet and transferred into an oven for the
curing step (45–90 min, depending on the system) at 160 °C
(this temperature was selected based on DSC analyses of the curing
process, as detailed in the following).
Results and Discussion
Crosslinking
of Cardanol-Derived Epoxy Resins with Cyclic Anhydrides
To
obtain the solid biobased GPE membranes, the cardanol-derived
epoxy resin NC547 was crosslinked with three different cyclic anhydrides
(GAn, SAn, and PAn) via a ring–opening reaction (Scheme ).
Scheme 1
Reaction Mechanism
of the Epoxy Ring Opening in NC547 with the Different
Anhydrides: (A) GAn, (B) SAn, and (C) PAn
Photographic
Images of Representative
Membranes are Also Reported
Reaction Mechanism
of the Epoxy Ring Opening in NC547 with the Different
Anhydrides: (A) GAn, (B) SAn, and (C) PAn
Photographic
Images of Representative
Membranes are Also ReportedA preliminary
study on the curing process was conducted by means
of DSC analyses to assess the optimal curing temperature and time
for each biobased epoxy/anhydride blend. Measurements were performed
at different heating rates (β = 5, 10, 15, and 20 °C min–1) to determine the Tp of
each system, this parameter being related to the exothermic peak of
the crosslinking reaction. From DSC analyses, the Ea of the curing process (Table ) was calculated according to the Ozawa (eq ) and the KAS (eq ) methods; in Figure , the corresponding
linear regression curves are reported, while the DSC thermograms are
reported in Figure S2 in the Supporting Information.
Table 1
Values of Ea of the Crosslinking Reaction for the Different
Cardanol-Derived
Epoxy/Anhydride Systems According to the Ozawa and the KAS Methods
composition
Ea-Ozawa [kJ mol–1]
Ea-KAS [kJ mol–1]
NC547-GAn
70.4
66.1
NC547-SAn
69.5
65.6
NC547-PAn
68.5
64.6
Figure 1
Linear regression curves based on the Ozawa and the KAS methods
of (A,A′) GAn-, (B,B′) SAn-, and (C,C′) PAn-based
epoxy systems.
Linear regression curves based on the Ozawa and the KAS methods
of (A,A′) GAn-, (B,B′) SAn-, and (C,C′) PAn-based
epoxy systems.These two methods are based on the assumption that
the maximum
rate of the curing reaction occurs at the peak temperature of the
exothermic signal recorded by DSC measurements.[55,56] As shown in Table , the Ea values for all biobased epoxy
systems are relatively comparable with each other irrespective of
the curing agent used, indicating that the nature of the cyclic anhydride
does not influence significantly the kinetics of the crosslinking
reaction. In addition, the relatively low values of Ea suggest that all systems react rapidly to lead to the
formation of the cured network.[57,58]As expected,
the Tp of each system
is closely related to the heating rate β used during the DSC
scan (Figure S2). Indeed, as β increases,
the onset temperature of the curing process and the associated peak
temperature Tp move toward higher values
as a result of the reduced time allowed for the system to react. Finally,
the higher the heating rate, the larger the dH/dt ratio of the systems as a consequence of the increase
in the thermal inertia and the associated inhibition of the curing
reaction.[59] Based on these considerations,
for all biobased epoxy systems an optimal curing temperature of 160
°C was selected.Additionally, the kinetics of the curing
process was studied via
DSC by monitoring the evolution of the exothermic peak in the thermograms
associated with the curing reaction during increasing curing times
at the curing temperature selected (i.e., 160 °C). The conversion
curves of the curing process versus curing time for the three biobased
GPE membrane materials are reported in Figure .
Figure 2
Conversion (%) of the curing reaction of NC547/GAn,
NC547/SAn,
and NC547/PAn blends at increasing curing time (0–120 min).
Conversion (%) of the curing reaction of NC547/GAn,
NC547/SAn,
and NC547/PAn blends at increasing curing time (0–120 min).For all systems, the curing process was found to
be fully completed
within 90 min of heat treatment at 160 °C, independently of the
curing agent. Interestingly, GAn-based membranes were characterized
by slower curing kinetics, likely due to the lower reactivity of GAn
with respect to SAn and PAn.[60,61] On the contrary, SAn-based
membranes exhibited the fastest conversion rate, yielding complete
curing already after ∼45 min of heating. The evolution of the
crosslinking reaction was also monitored by means of FTIR spectroscopy,
comparing the spectra of the uncured biobased epoxy/anhydride systems
with cured ones (Figure ). In all systems, the disappearance of the peak at 915 cm–1 associated with the bending of the oxirane CH2–O–CH
ring suggests a complete reaction of the epoxy groups in NC547 with
the anhydride crosslinker, leading to the formation of ester linkages
(as corroborated by the appearance of the carbonyl signal centered
at 1732 cm–1). In addition, the absence in all cured
materials of the signals associated to the stretching of the C=O
carbonyl groups of anhydrides centered at 1857 and 1780 cm–1 further confirms the full conversion of the epoxy/anhydride reaction,
irrespective of the curing agent.
Figure 3
FTIR spectra of uncured and cured GAn-,
SAn-, and PAn-based epoxy
systems; spectra were normalized with respect to the signal peaked
at 1260 cm–1, corresponding to the C–O stretching
of the benzene ring of NC547.
FTIR spectra of uncured and cured GAn-,
SAn-, and PAn-based epoxy
systems; spectra were normalized with respect to the signal peaked
at 1260 cm–1, corresponding to the C–O stretching
of the benzene ring of NC547.The thermal stability of the cardanol-based epoxy systems was studied
by means of TGA analysis in air (Figure ), considering the degradation temperatures
at 5% (T5%) and 50% (T50%) of weight loss and at the maximum of the derivative
(DTGA) curve (see Table S1 in the Supporting Information). All the cardanol-based membranes show high thermal stability up
to 400 °C, independently of the curing agent, with major weight
losses only observed in the range between 400 and 600 °C, likely
ascribable to the complete disruption of the macromolecular network.
Furthermore, at 800 °C, the materials are fully degraded, with
char yields of nearly 0%.[62,63]
Figure 4
TGA and DTGA curves for
the three different NC547-based membranes.
TGA and DTGA curves for
the three different NC547-based membranes.
Cardanol-Based Epoxy/Anhydride Crosslinked Systems
The extent
of crosslinking for the different cardanol-based epoxy/anhydride
systems after curing was evaluated by means of gel content experiments,
which yielded high values of GEL % (>90%) in all cases (see Table
S2 in Supporting Information). This evidence
indicates a high degree of conversion of the epoxy/anhydride reaction
and a high network connectivity independently of the chemical nature
of the anhydride curing agent used.The mechanical response
of all cardanol-based epoxy/anhydride cured membranes was investigated
by means of DMA measurements through temperature sweep tests.As shown in Figure and reported in Table , all systems exhibited comparable values of GR′ (∼0.7
MPa) in the rubbery plateau, which resulted to be in line with those
reported in the literature for polymer-based electrolytes for battery
applications,[29,45,64] thus suggesting the practical viability of these biobased membrane
materials as GPEs (see the Supporting Information for additional mechanical characterization). DMA measurements were
also employed to determine their glass transition temperature [Tg, as the temperature of the tan(δ) peak].
Slightly higher values of Tg were found
for PAn-based systems (38 °C) as compared with GAn- and SAn-based
ones (20 °C in both cases). As similar ν values were estimated
for the different epoxy/anhydride membranes (∼2 × 10–4 mol cm–3, with a slightly lower
value observed in SAn-based systems), this trend could be associated
with the characteristic chemical structures of the anhydride crosslinkers
employed, with PAn leading to the incorporation of a six-membered
ring in the polymer backbone upon reaction with the biobased epoxy
resin, thus yielding an increased rigidity of the three-dimensional
crosslinked network and, in turn, a slightly higher Tg value (Table ).
Figure 5
Shear storage modulus (G′) and tan(δ)
as a function of temperature obtained from DMA in temperature sweep
configuration of (A) NC547-GAn, (B) NC547-SAn, and (C) NC547-PAn systems.
Table 2
Values of GR′ and ν
Estimated from the Molecular Theory of Rubber Elasticity and Tg of the Cardanol-Based Crosslinked Epoxy Systems
composition
GR′ [MPa]
ν [mol cm–3]
Tg [°C]
NC547-GAn
0.642
2.09 × 10–4
20
NC547-SAn
0.647
2.07 × 10–4
20
NC547-PAn
0.777
2.51 × 10–4
38
Shear storage modulus (G′) and tan(δ)
as a function of temperature obtained from DMA in temperature sweep
configuration of (A) NC547-GAn, (B) NC547-SAn, and (C) NC547-PAn systems.When designing GPEs for battery applications, one of the preliminary
requirements to be met is the ability of the polymer network to entrap
a liquid electrolyte solution in suitable amounts (≥30% with
respect to the polymer weight) without compromising its mechanical
stability.[65,66] The three different cardanol-derived
epoxy/anhydride cured membranes demonstrated a remarkable swelling
ability when immersed in the electrolyte solution commonly used for
KIBs, consisting of KPF6 0.80 M in EC/DEC 1:1. As shown
in Figure , where
the swelling profiles of all membrane materials are reported, a swelling
plateau is reached in all systems after ∼45 min of immersion
in the electrolyte solution. In particular, in this time interval,
PAn-based and GAn-based systems reach a plateau at a maximum EUR value
of ∼45%, with no notable differences in the uptake process.
Instead, significantly higher mass increase values (80%) are observed
in SAn-based membranes.
Figure 6
EUR over time with error bands for the three
different NC547-based
membranes immersed in a standard KIB electrolyte, KPF6 0.80
M in EC/DEC 1:1 (error bars represent standard deviation out of three
measurements).
EUR over time with error bands for the three
different NC547-based
membranes immersed in a standard KIB electrolyte, KPF6 0.80
M in EC/DEC 1:1 (error bars represent standard deviation out of three
measurements).This trend could be ascribed to
the slightly lower crosslinking
density of this latter system, which entails intrinsically higher
macromolecular chain mobility, ultimately associated with a less compact
network and a higher free volume.[67] On
the contrary, the presence of a rigid six-membered ring in the three-dimensional
structure of PAn-based materials associated with their slightly higher
crosslinking density limits their electrolyte uptake ability, ultimately
resulting in lower membrane swelling.The structural stability
and the viscoelastic response of the cardanol-based
GPEs were investigated through dynamic rheological tests at 25 °C.
In particular, the dependence of the shear storage modulus G′ and the shear loss modulus G″
on the shear stress (τ) was investigated by means of LVR tests.
Measurements were carried out on both dried and swollen samples (swelling
was performed using the EC/DEC 1:1 v/v solution, based on the outcomes
of EUR tests—Figure ). The results for all the three membrane systems are reported
in Figure .
Figure 7
Rheological
shear stress sweep tests on (A) GAn-, (B) SAn-, and
(C) PAn-based membranes. For all compositions, full symbols indicate G′, and hollow symbols indicate G″.
Rheological
shear stress sweep tests on (A) GAn-, (B) SAn-, and
(C) PAn-based membranes. For all compositions, full symbols indicate G′, and hollow symbols indicate G″.Comparing LVR test results of
the dry membranes with their unswollen
counterpart, it was found that for all three compositions, swelling
due to electrolyte uptake led to a decrease of both G′ and G″ as a consequence of the increased
end-to-end distance of the macromolecular chains and the expansion
of the porous structure due to solvent intercalation, coupled with
its plasticizing action to the polymer chains.[68,69] As the applied shear stress increased (>1000 Pa), some deviations
from linearity of both G′ and G″ were recorded, leading to a slightly reduced LVR and an
earlier onset of irreversible plastic deformation (viz., lower threshold
stress values). Notwithstanding these observations, the wide LVR found
on all biobased membranes, irrespective of the composition, and their
high stress resistance (up to 1000 Pa), appear to be favorable in
view of their potential applicability as GPEs for KIBs. Indeed, their
excellent mechanical stability could be exploited for device fabrication
as no sign of yielding is present in any of the membranes, irrespectively
of composition and physical state.[70] In
addition, all the systems show a predominantly solid-like behavior,
confirming their full and effective crosslinked nature, which is essential
for these GPEs to be used for KIB devices fabrication.[71]
Electrochemical Characterization of Cardanol-Based
Epoxy/Anhydride
GPEs
Metallic potassium is extremely reactive, and the identification
of polymeric matrices able to stabilize this electrode (inhibiting
both the growth of metal dendrites and the reactivity of K towards
the electrolyte components) is one of the main challenges faced nowadays
by the scientific community working in the field of KIBs. In this
context, the evaluation of the electrochemical stability window (ESW)
represents a fundamental experiment to quantitatively gauge the applicability
of a polymeric membrane as GPE and its compatibility with the associated
metallic electrode. Accordingly, the ESW of the SAn-based system activated
by swelling it in the KPF6 electrolyte solution was tested
through LSV both in the anodic and the cathodic regime. The resulting
current–voltage profile is shown in Figure A. Interestingly, the proposed biobased GPE
showed a notably wide ESW, with near nil current signal for the whole
potential range explored (from −0.2 to 5 V, viz., the one of
interest for KIB applications), thus indicating its excellent compatibility
with potassium metal. No side reactions were found to occur at any
voltage value, being the negative peak revealed at −0.2 V related
to the potassium reduction reaction.[65]
Figure 8
(A) LSV
trace for the SAn-based epoxy membrane (activated by swelling
in KPF6 0.80 M in EC/DEC 1:1), sandwiched between a potassium
and copper foil for the cathodic branch and potassium and stainless
steel for the anodic one; cells were tested in the potential range
from the OCV to −0.2 V and from the OCV to 5 V, respectively.
A zoom of the oxidative stability region is provided. (B) Ionic conductivity
data for the SAn-based epoxy membrane (activated by swelling in KPF6 0.80 M in EC/DEC 1:1), measured from 10 to 50 °C and
presented as an Arrhenius plot.
(A) LSV
trace for the SAn-based epoxy membrane (activated by swelling
in KPF6 0.80 M in EC/DEC 1:1), sandwiched between a potassium
and copper foil for the cathodic branch and potassium and stainless
steel for the anodic one; cells were tested in the potential range
from the OCV to −0.2 V and from the OCV to 5 V, respectively.
A zoom of the oxidative stability region is provided. (B) Ionic conductivity
data for the SAn-based epoxy membrane (activated by swelling in KPF6 0.80 M in EC/DEC 1:1), measured from 10 to 50 °C and
presented as an Arrhenius plot.Together with the assessment of the electrochemical stability of
the GPE in the voltage range of interest for the selected application,
another important figure of merit to be considered for gauging its
possible use in KIBs is represented by the ionic conductivity of the
swollen membrane in a relevant temperature window. In a quasi-solid
system such as the one studied in this study, the conduction of ions
(K+, PF6–) occurs both in
the liquid solution trapped in the membrane and via ion motion along
the polymer chains. The latter is more relevant if the polymer matrix
is amorphous.[72] DSC traces of cured SAn-based
membranes did not reveal the presence of any melting/crystallization
peak and highlighted one single glass transition, thus confirming
the completely amorphous nature of the polymer matrix and the excellent
thermodynamic compatibility between SAn and the biobased NC547 epoxy
resin (see Figure S5 in the Supporting Information). Based on these considerations, ionic conductivity measurements
between 10 and 50 °C were performed, considering this as a plausible
temperature range for KIB applications in large-scale energy storage
plants.[73,74] As shown in Figure B, the activated GPEs possessed an appreciable
ionic conductivity with values ranging between 10–3 and 10–2 S cm–1 when passing
from lower (10 °C) to higher temperatures (50 °C), respectively.
Interestingly, lower ionic conductivities were found for GAn- and
PAn-based membranes over the same temperature interval, in line with
their less favorable EUR response as compared with SAn-based systems
(see Figure S6 in the Supporting Information). Overall, the ionic conductivity of the SAn sample compares well
with those typically found in the literature for GPEs used in KIBs
and appears to be amongst the highest encountered in the field for
biobased quasi-solid polymer electrolytes.[49] Indeed, the cardanol-based electrolyte ionic conductivity at room
temperature (10–3 S cm–1) exceeds
by one order of magnitude the values usually obtained for relevant
quasi solid-state electrolytes previously published in the literature.
This is valid also for the well-established PEO-based matrices. As
a matter of fact, Fei et al. formulated a PEO/KFSI solid-state polymer
electrolyte,[75] while Jeedi et al. designed
a PEO/PVdF/KNO3 system;[76] both
of these systems led to ionic conductivity values lower than those
reported in this study (1.14 × 10–5 and 8.79
× 10–5 S cm–1 at room temperature,
respectively). Indeed, room temperature ionic conductivities in the
10–3 S cm–1 range are typically
sufficient to fabricate working devices, thus confirming the potential
viability of these cardanol-derived systems as alternative biobased
GPEs for KIBs.[77,78]
Conclusions
In
summary, GPE membranes based on a cardanol-derived epoxy resin
crosslinked with three different anhydrides (glutaric, succinic, and
hexahydro-4-methylphthalic) were proposed in this study for potential
application as biobased quasi-solid polymer electrolytes in KIBs.
The optimal curing time and temperature were evaluated by nonisothermal
DSC analysis at different heating rates, and the activation energy
of the curing process was estimated through the Ozawa and the KAS
methods and found to be in the order of 65–70 kJ mol–1 for all the three compositions. FTIR spectroscopy confirmed the
effective occurrence of the curing reaction via epoxy ring opening,
leading to a crosslinked system of high network connectivity, as also
supported by gravimetric gel content measurements. DMA measurements
evidenced a rubbery-plateau modulus in the 0.65–0.78 MPa range
for all systems, with a crosslinking density in the order of 2 ×
10–4 mol cm–3. Swelling tests
conducted on these biobased membrane materials evidenced that the
highest electrolyte uptake was recorded when using SAn as anhydride
curing agent, which yielded a plateau value of an 80% mass increase
after ∼45 min of immersion in a typical KPF6 electrolyte
solution. The same systems showed an excellent electrochemical stability
toward potassium metal in the range between −0.2 and 5 V and
a suitable ionic conductivity (10–3 S cm–1) at room temperature. This study provides the first demonstration
of cardanol-based epoxy/anhydride systems as quasi-solid polymer electrolyte
membranes for potassium metal electrochemical cells and demonstrates
their potential viability as efficient biobased GPEs for the fabrication
of KIBs, paving the path to increased sustainability in the field
of next-generation battery technologies.