Flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are capable of changing their crystal structure as a function of external stimuli such as pressure, temperature, and type of adsorbed guest species. DUT-49 is the first MOF exhibiting structural transitions accompanied by the counterintuitive phenomenon of negative gas adsorption. Here, we present high-pressure in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopic studies of a novel isoreticular MOF family based on DUT-49. These porous materials differ only in the length of their organic linkers causing changes in pore size and elasticity. The series encompasses both, purely microporous materials as well as materials with both micropores and small mesopores. The chemical shift of the adsorbed xenon depends on xenon-wall interactions and thus on the pore size of the material. The xenon adsorption behavior of different MOFs can be observed over the whole range of relative pressure. Chemical shift adsorption/desorption isotherms closely resembling the conventional, uptake-measurement-based isotherms were obtained at 237 K where all materials are rigid. The comparable chemical environment of the adsorbed xenon in these isoreticular MOFs allows to establish a correlation between the chemical shift at a relative pressure of p/p 0 = 1.0 and the mean pore diameter. Furthermore, the xenon adsorption behavior of MOFs is studied also at 200 K. Here, structural flexibility is found for DUT-50, a material with an even longer linker than that of the previously known DUT-49. Its structural transitions are monitored by 129Xe NMR spectroscopy. This compound is the second known MOF showing the phenomenon of negative gas adsorption. Further increase in the linker length results in DUT-151, a material with an interpenetrated network topology. In situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopy proves that this material exhibits another type of flexibility compared to DUT-49 and DUT-50. Further surprising observations are made for DUT-46. Volumetric xenon adsorption measurements show that this nonflexible microporous material does not exhibit any hysteresis. In contrast, the in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopically detected xenon chemical shift isotherms exhibit a hysteresis even after longer equilibration times than in the volumetric experiments. This indicates kinetically hindered redistribution processes and long-lived metastable states of adsorbed xenon within the MOF persisting at the time scale of hours or longer.
Flexible metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are capable of changing their crystal structure as a function of external stimuli such as pressure, temperature, and type of adsorbed guest species. DUT-49 is the first MOF exhibiting structural transitions accompanied by the counterintuitive phenomenon of negative gas adsorption. Here, we present high-pressure in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopic studies of a novel isoreticular MOF family based on DUT-49. These porous materials differ only in the length of their organic linkers causing changes in pore size and elasticity. The series encompasses both, purely microporous materials as well as materials with both micropores and small mesopores. The chemical shift of the adsorbed xenon depends on xenon-wall interactions and thus on the pore size of the material. The xenon adsorption behavior of different MOFs can be observed over the whole range of relative pressure. Chemical shift adsorption/desorption isotherms closely resembling the conventional, uptake-measurement-based isotherms were obtained at 237 K where all materials are rigid. The comparable chemical environment of the adsorbed xenon in these isoreticular MOFs allows to establish a correlation between the chemical shift at a relative pressure of p/p 0 = 1.0 and the mean pore diameter. Furthermore, the xenon adsorption behavior of MOFs is studied also at 200 K. Here, structural flexibility is found for DUT-50, a material with an even longer linker than that of the previously known DUT-49. Its structural transitions are monitored by 129Xe NMR spectroscopy. This compound is the second known MOF showing the phenomenon of negative gas adsorption. Further increase in the linker length results in DUT-151, a material with an interpenetrated network topology. In situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopy proves that this material exhibits another type of flexibility compared to DUT-49 and DUT-50. Further surprising observations are made for DUT-46. Volumetric xenon adsorption measurements show that this nonflexible microporous material does not exhibit any hysteresis. In contrast, the in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopically detected xenon chemical shift isotherms exhibit a hysteresis even after longer equilibration times than in the volumetric experiments. This indicates kinetically hindered redistribution processes and long-lived metastable states of adsorbed xenon within the MOF persisting at the time scale of hours or longer.
Metal–organic
frameworks (MOFs) are highly porous hybrid
materials based on inorganic secondary building units (SBUs) that
are connected by organic linkers.[1,2] Their properties
can be tuned by varying the length and functionalization of the organic
linkers.[3,4] Thus, MOFs have become a research field
of increasing interest.[1] Low densities
(down to 0.124 g/cm3)[5] and high
surface areas (up to 7839 m2/g)[6] render the materials suitable for various applications. They are
explored with respect to gas and energy storage, gas separation, catalysis,
sensing, and as drug delivery systems in biomedicine.[1,2,4,7−9] Before applying MOFs in gas storage and separation,
it is especially important to characterize the adsorption processes
inside the pore system. Flexible MOFs are a peculiar subgroup of MOFs
with unique properties. They undergo structural transitions induced
by external stimuli such as temperature, pressure, and presence of
guest molecules. Famous examples are MIL-53, SNU-9, DUT-8, and many
others.[10−12]The recently discovered material DUT-49 (Dresden
University of
Technology No. 49) is the first flexible MOF showing the surprising
phenomenon of a negative gas adsorption (NGA).[13] Adsorbed gases such as methane or xenon are partly released
from the structure at increasing pressure during the structural transition
from an open-pore (op) to a contracted-pore (cp) state. Inspired by
this observation, an isoreticular series was synthesized, which differs
from DUT-49 only in the length of the linker molecule (cf. Figure ). The xenon adsorption
behavior of this isoreticular series is investigated within the present
work using a high-pressure in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopy.
Figure 1
Structure
of the investigated metal–organic frameworks and
their corresponding organic linkers (a, e) DUT-48, (b, f) DUT-46,
(c, g) DUT-49, and (d, h) DUT-50. Color code: Cu—turquoise,
O—red, C—gray, N—blue, H—white, cuboctahedral
pore—green, tetrahedral pore—blue, octahedral pore—orange.
Structure
of the investigated metal–organic frameworks and
their corresponding organic linkers (a, e) DUT-48, (b, f) DUT-46,
(c, g) DUT-49, and (d, h) DUT-50. Color code: Cu—turquoise,
O—red, C—gray, N—blue, H—white, cuboctahedral
pore—green, tetrahedral pore—blue, octahedral pore—orange.NMR spectroscopy offers two general approaches
to study porous
materials like MOFs. On the one hand, it is possible to investigate
the structure and dynamics of the material itself by observing the
NMR-active nuclei in the corresponding compound, such as 13C or 1H.[14−16] On the other hand, it is possible to load the materials
with NMR-active probe molecules or atoms, thus exploiting host–guest
interactions. Gases like CO2 or Xe are often applied as
probe.[17−25]Due to its large electron cloud, the NMR chemical shift of
xenon
exhibits a high sensitivity. Therefore, 129Xe (I = 1/2) with a natural abundance of 26.4% is a well-suited
probe to study surfaces.[26−29] The chemical shift of the adsorbed xenon in porous
materials like zeolites[28−30] or MOFs[31] can be written asThe
first term, δs, reflects
all contributions due to interactions between xenon atoms and different
surface sites of the pore system. The second term, δXe–Xe, describes the interactions between the adsorbed xenon atoms and
depends on the density of xenon ρXe and the temperature.[26−28]Since the adsorbed xenon is mobile and can undergo rapid exchange
and diffusion processes inside the pore system, two fundamentally
different cases must be distinguished: (i) Compounds with pores large
enough to adsorb xenon but rather small interconnecting windows/channels
between these pores prevent fast exchange processes between neighboring
pores. Note that the diameter of xenon is ca. 4.4 Å. (ii) Compounds
with pores interconnected by sufficiently large windows/channels allow
a rapid xenon diffusion between different pores. A striking example
for case (i) is the zeolites Na-A and Ag-A.[32−35] Xenon clusters of different sizes
are then formed inside different pores—without a fast exchange
between neighboring pores. This results in an ensemble of lines of
different chemical shifts caused by the influence of Xe–Xe
interactions, which depend on the cluster size (cf. eq ). Recently, this behavior was also
observed for a special MOF denoted as MFU-4 with a remarkably small
pore aperture of only 2.4 Å diameter.[36] Quite often, however, case (ii) is observed. A rapid diffusion of
xenon atoms through the pore system then results in a single line
with a chemical shift representing the weighted average along the
trajectory of xenon. Note that the shape of this line is not necessarily
symmetric. For materials with anisotropic pore systems, the line shape
of the adsorbed xenon can be anisotropic as demonstrated previously.[37−42] Note that the line shape not only depends on intracrystalline exchange
and diffusion but also on intercrystalline exchange processes.[41] Thus, 129Xe NMR spectroscopy provides
information about adsorption processes as well as xenon dynamics in
various porous materials.[26−51]Here, high-pressure in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopy
is
used to investigate host–guest interactions under controlled
thermodynamic conditions. The home-built high-pressure apparatus[51] allows in situ experiments at variable pressures
up to saturation and at temperatures down to 195 K. In addition to
the previously studied DUT-49, a novel series of MOFs including the
materials DUT-48, DUT-46, and DUT-50 was studied. These MOFs are built
from copper paddle-wheels and carbazole-3,6-dicarboxylate forming
metal–organic polyhedrons (MOPs). These MOPs constitute small
cuboctahedral pores. Connecting the MOPs with tetratopic, organic
linkers result in a framework consisting of three different types
of pores. In addition to the cuboctahedral pores, tetrahedral and
octahedral cavities are formed (cf. Figure a–d).[52] The length of the organic linkers is varied within the MOF family
(Figure e–h),
resulting in MOFs of different pore sizes and inner surface areas
(Table ). The functionalization
of the organic linkers as well as the MOP structure remains unchanged.
DUT-49 shows an extremely high methane storage capacity.[52] Comparative investigation of the new isoreticular
series thus allows to study differences in the adsorption behavior
that are purely introduced by different linkers. Furthermore, it is
speculated that the pore size may correlate with the chemical shift
of the adsorbed xenon due to similarity in the surface chemistry provided
by this special MOF series.
Table 1
Calculated Pore Sizes
of DUT-48, DUT-46,
DUT-49, and DUT-50
octahedralpore
(Å)
tetrahedral
pore (Å)
cuboctahedral
pore (Å)
DUT-48
18.7
14.8
10.7
DUT-46
21.8
15.0
10.7
DUT-49
24.8
17.6
10.5
DUT-50
30.7
21.0
10.7
Experimental Section
The dried
MOFs were stored under an inert, dry atmosphere. For
the experiments, the samples were transferred into a single-crystal
sapphire tube and activated overnight (100 °C, 10–5 mbar). The high-pressure in situ experiments were carried out using
a home-built apparatus.[51] A defined xenon
pressure can be adjusted. All experiments were carried out on an Avance
300 NMR spectrometer (Bruker, Germany) equipped with an HR probe.
The NMR spectra were recorded at a resonance frequency of 83.04 MHz
for 129Xe using a pulse length of 11 μs and relaxation
delays of 15 s. A BIOSPIN SA BCU-Xtreme unit (Bruker, Germany) was
used for sample cooling. Measurements were carried out at two different
temperatures of 237 and 200 K. To obtain adsorption/desorption isotherms,
the chemical shift of the adsorbed xenon was observed over the whole
range of pressure up to a relative pressure of p/p0 = 1. Equilibration times of 15 min after pressure
changes and 30 min after temperature changes were used. The temperature
calibration was carried out using the 1H signal of methanol.[53,54] As a second method of temperature calibration, the condensation
pressure of xenon was used to determine the corresponding temperature
from the phase diagram. The chemical shift is referenced relative
to xenon gas extrapolated to zero pressure.
Results and Discussion
The flexibility of DUT-49, i.e., its phase transformations, does
not only depend on the type of adsorbed gas but also on the temperature.
In the case of xenon adsorption, it behaves like a rigid MOF at 237
K but is flexible at 200 K. Therefore, isothermal in situ 129Xe NMR experiments were performed at these two temperatures for the
isoreticular series studied here as well.
Experiments at 237 K
129Xe NMR spectra were
recorded at various pressures covering the entire relative pressure
range at constant temperature. Such measurements result in chemical
shift adsorption/desorption isotherms. Figure compares the chemical shift isotherms for
the purely microporous material DUT-48, as well as DUT-46 and DUT-50,
which exhibit micropores and small mesopores (cf. Table ). This comparison reveals striking
differences for the three chemical shift isotherms. First, the shape
of the chemical shift isotherm of DUT-48 resembles a reversible type
I(b) isotherm.[55] This observation can be
explained by the fact that the 129Xe NMR chemical shift
is correlated with the amount of xenon adsorbed in the pores as predicted
by the second term of eq . This correlation is the reason for the similarity between conventional
adsorption/desorption isotherms obtained by uptake measurements (in
mass or volume units) and the chemical shift isotherms presented here.
Similar correlations were already observed by our group[56] for the microporous MOFs UiO-66 and UiO-67 (Universitetet
i Oslo).[57] After a steep, almost linear
increase at a low relative pressure, the isotherm starts to level
off for p/p0 > 0.4.
The
initial regime with its linear behavior is well-known for other microporous
materials such as zeolites.[28,55] In contrast to DUT-48,
the isotherm of DUT-50 exhibits the characteristic S-shape (type IV)
expected for mesoporous materials.[55] At
lower relative pressures, the present micropores are preferentially
filled and only a monolayer of xenon atoms is adsorbed in the mesopores.
With increasing relative pressure, multilayer adsorption occurs inside
the mesopores, which finally results in capillary condensation. Therefore,
a plateau is finally observed, indicating that the maximum possible
density is reached, as also observed for the microporous DUT-48. However,
xenon desorption during pressure release shows a hysteresis compared
to the adsorption branch for the mesoporous DUT-50, a characteristic
behavior for capillary condensation inside mesopores. The isotherm
of DUT-46 is located between those of the two cases described above.
The chemical shift isotherm shows a type I(b) shape. However, the
chemical shift increase is slower than that for DUT-48 and the plateau
is finally reached at a higher relative pressure. This is due to the
larger pores of the material. Nevertheless, the obtained isotherm
is reversible.
Figure 2
129Xe NMR adsorption and desorption isotherms
of DUT-48,
DUT-46, and DUT-50 at 237 K.
129Xe NMR adsorption and desorption isotherms
of DUT-48,
DUT-46, and DUT-50 at 237 K.It is, furthermore, interesting to note that the chemical shift
of the adsorbed xenon exceeds the chemical shift of liquid xenon at
a given temperature and high relative pressure. The chemical shift
of 129Xe at p/p0 = 1 can be determined very precisely by the extrapolation of the
chemical shift since the slope of the isotherm decreases and is almost
zero at relative pressures close to one. It can be concluded from
this observation in combination with eq that the xenon density inside the pores only slightly
changes at sufficiently high relative pressures, i.e., that the pore
system is filled at p/p0 close to 1. A chemical shift difference Δδ is observed
between the chemical shift δ̅ resulting from the extrapolation
of δ to p/p0 = 1 and the chemical shift δB of bulk liquid xenon
of ca. 197 ppm at the given measurement
temperature.
This difference arises due
to the fact that a certain fraction of xenon atoms is in direct contact
with the MOF surface, whereas others in the middle of a sufficiently
large pore only interact with other xenon atoms as in the bulk liquid.
Due to the presence of exchange processes, an averaged chemical shift
results. The inset of Figure illustrates this idea. Under the simplifying assumption that
the surface is chemically homogeneous and the chemical shift of xenon
in the surface contact is given by δS, one can then
writeHere, pS and pB are the probabilities of a xenon atom to be
in surface contact or in the bulk liquid, respectively. Thus, Δδ
depends on the probability pS that xenon
interacts with the surface. It can be written asNS and NB are the number of xenon atoms in contact with
the surface and in the bulk liquid, respectively.
Figure 3
Correlation of the mean
pore diameter, d, and
the chemical shift difference, Δδ, of the adsorbed xenon
at 237 K for DUT-48, DUT-46, DUT-49, and DUT-50. The inset shows the
model of a xenon-filled pore.
Correlation of the mean
pore diameter, d, and
the chemical shift difference, Δδ, of the adsorbed xenon
at 237 K for DUT-48, DUT-46, DUT-49, and DUT-50. The inset shows the
model of a xenon-filled pore.The probability for a xenon atom to be in surface contact, however,
will depend on the average pore size of the material. To test the
validity of this consideration, the correlation between Δδ
and the average pore diameter of the studied samples (cf. Table ) is shown in Figure . For the materials
of the considered isoreticular series, Δδ obviously follows
the expected trend: An increasing average pore size leads to a decreasing
Δδ since the probability of a surface contact decreases
in larger pores. Assuming spherical pores, one would expect a 1/d dependence for pS. The data
do not exactly follow this dependence but show a similar trend. The
deviation is not unexpected because the MOFs exhibit not only mesopores
but also micropores and the above-mentioned assumptions are certainly
an oversimplification. In any case, our observations show that Δδ
can be used as an easily measurable estimate for the average pore
size in MOFs of comparable surface chemistry.
Table 2
Average
Pore Diameter d (for Detailed Information about the
Calculation, see Table S2) and Chemical
Shift Difference Δδ
of the Adsorbed Xenon Relative to the Bulk Liquid Xenon at 237 K for
DUT-48, DUT-46, DUT-49, and DUT-50
d (Å)
Δδ
(ppm)
DUT-48
15.66
32.0
DUT-46
17.59
24.2
DUT-49
20.80
21.3
DUT-50
26.98
19.2
Experiments at 200 K
As mentioned above, DUT-49 is
rigid at 237 K but becomes flexible at 200 K.[13] The other members of the described isoreticular series were found
to be rigid at 237 K as well. To characterize the influence of decreasing
temperature, their behavior at 200 K was also studied here. Since
the 129Xe chemical shift is very sensitive to structural
changes, differences between chemical shift isotherms and the conventional
xenon uptake measurements must now be taken into account.For
DUT-48, an almost reversible type I(b) isotherm is also observed at
200 K (Figure ). Only
a minor hysteresis occurs within the experimental error. This means
that the microporous DUT-48 is rigid at both measurement temperatures
applied here.
Figure 4
129Xe NMR adsorption and desorption isotherms
of DUT-48
(top) and DUT-46 (bottom) at 200 K.
129Xe NMR adsorption and desorption isotherms
of DUT-48
(top) and DUT-46 (bottom) at 200 K.DUT-46 contains both micropores and small mesopores (see Table ) and exhibits a type
IV adsorption/desorption isotherm. However, the volumetric uptake-derived
isotherm does not exhibit a detectable hysteresis. This can be explained
by the rather small mesopores (21.8 Å diameter) where capillary
condensation not yet plays a major role. However, the NMR-derived 129Xe chemical shift adsorption/desorption isotherm exhibits
a considerable hysteresis. It should be noted that the uptake-derived
isotherm was measured at an even shorter equilibration time of about
400 s for each data point than the NMR-derived chemical shift isotherm
measured with 15 min equilibration for each data point. The data in
the hysteresis range at relative pressures between 0.1 and 0.3 were
even measured after 75 min equilibration because the equilibrium is
not reached after 15 min. This follows from the observation that line
width and position still change after 15 min (cf. Figure S2). The characteristic difference between the two
isotherms, i.e., the absence of a hysteresis in the volumetric uptake-derived
data, can thus not be explained by insufficient equilibration time
for the NMR experiment. Our explanation for this behavior is a diffusion-limited
redistribution of the adsorbed xenon in the pore system. Typically,
the small pores fill first at low pressures. However, the windows
of the smallest pores are only about 4 Å in size and the van
der Waals diameter of xenon amounts to 4.4 Å. At low pressures,
xenon is thus probably not (or only to a limited extent) adsorbed
in these small cuboctahedral pores. However, a redistribution of the
adsorbed xenon in the pore system can occur at a higher pressure,
i.e., the small pores are increasingly filled. During desorption,
the cuboctahedral pores are still filled and the desorption takes
place at a lower relative pressure. Thus, the hysteresis in the NMR-derived
isotherm could be explained. It is already known for another MOF that
xenon is able to pass even smaller pore apertures and is trapped inside
afterward.[36] However, this behavior can
be observed at lower temperatures and pressures for DUT-46. In agreement
with this idea, the integral intensity of the signal for adsorbed
xenon remains almost constant during the whole time of the equilibration
experiment of 75 min (cf. Figure S3). Only
minor changes occur after the first few minutes of equilibration.
Thus, the significant change in chemical shift and line shape occurs
most likely due to the rearrangement of the already adsorbed xenon
atoms. Further work is in progress to clarify this observation. In
any case, it can be stated that DUT-46 and DUT-48 do not show the
counterintuitive low-temperature NGA behavior of DUT-49. The reason
for this is most likely the linker structure. NGA is a spontaneous
desorption of gas during pressure increase.[13] Adsorbed xenon is released because the mesopores are contracted.
This is accompanied by a pronounced deformation (bending) of the linkers.
The energy needed for this bending is overcompensated by the higher
adsorption enthalpies for guests like methane or xenon.[58] Obviously, the organic linkers used in DUT-48
and DUT-46 are too short and rigid to allow adsorption-driven bending
in contrast to DUT-49. However, DUT-50 exhibits an even longer linker
than DUT-49 in contrast to DUT-48 and DUT-46. The 129Xe
NMR spectra recorded at 200 K are shown in Figure for the adsorption experiment, i.e., steadily
increasing pressure along with the volumetric uptake-derived adsorption
isotherm. The chemical shift of the adsorbed xenon steadily increases
from 120 to 150 ppm with a relative
pressure of up to 0.28. At a relative pressure of about 0.3, a sudden
shift jump of nearly 100 ppm occurs. This jump is caused by the structural
transition from an open-pore (op) state to a closed-pore (cp) state.
The resulting higher probability pS for
xenon to be in contact with the surface in the contracted pores causes
a sudden increase in chemical shift similar to that in DUT-49.[31]
Figure 5
129Xe NMR adsorption spectra (top) and 129Xe NMR and volumetric uptake-derived xenon adsorption isotherms
(bottom)
of DUT-50 at 200 K.
129Xe NMR adsorption spectra (top) and 129Xe NMR and volumetric uptake-derived xenon adsorption isotherms
(bottom)
of DUT-50 at 200 K.Further pressure increase
results in a moderate increase for the
chemical shift of xenon in the cp state. However, a second signal
at a lower chemical shift occurs at relative pressures beyond 0.45.
This can be assigned to the xenon adsorbed in DUT-50op. The transformation
of DUT-50 from the cp state back to the op state takes place over
a relatively wide relative pressure range. At p/p0 = 1, only one signal for xenon remains, indicating
the complete transformation of DUT-50 into the op state.The
coexistence of the cp and op states over a relatively wide
relative pressure range between 0.46 and 0.92 could be explained by
two models: (i) The structural transformation is a collective phenomenon
of entire crystallites and the sample contains crystallites that exhibit
different transition pressures. (ii) The pore opening starts locally
at a certain pressure and does then steadily proceed into other regions
of the crystallite at increasing pressure (for example, from the surface
into the bulk). It is anticipated that the exchange rate of xenon
between the op and cp states would be slower for the intercrystalline
exchange described in (i) than for the intracrystalline exchange in
(ii). Therefore, we measured the exchange rate by 2D EXSY spectroscopy
(Figure ). The exchange
rate can be calculated from the dependence of the intensity ratio
between cross peaks and diagonal peaks on the mixing time τm. For a two-site exchange, the ratio between the intensities
of the cross peaks, Icross, and diagonal
peaks, Idiagonal, is described by the
function[59]Figure demonstrates that
the data indeed follow this function. An
exchange rate kex of 95 Hz could be measured
corresponding to a characteristic exchange time constant of 11 ms. This is a typical value for
intercrystalline
exchange processes in microcrystalline materials.[51,60] It is thus anticipated that the op–cp structural transition
in DUT-50 is a collective switching of entire crystallites in an ensemble
of crystallites with a slightly varying switching pressure and not
a local phenomenon continuously spreading out within one crystallite.
During the desorption experiment (see Figure ), the structural change from DUT-50op to
DUT-50cp occurs at p/p0 = 0.3. The material stays in this state even at a very low pressure
down to 0.01. This means that the described structural transitions
are not reversible.
Figure 6
EXSY spectra of xenon adsorbed on DUT-50 at p =
2.0 bar and 200 K (top) and correlation between the mixing time and
the intensity ratio of cross peaks and diagonal peaks measured as
a function of the mixing time. The red line was determined by fitting
the data to eq .
Figure 7
129Xe NMR desorption spectra (top) and 129Xe NMR and volumetric uptake-derived xenon desorption isotherms
(bottom)
of DUT-50 at 200 K.
EXSY spectra of xenon adsorbed on DUT-50 at p =
2.0 bar and 200 K (top) and correlation between the mixing time and
the intensity ratio of cross peaks and diagonal peaks measured as
a function of the mixing time. The red line was determined by fitting
the data to eq .129Xe NMR desorption spectra (top) and 129Xe NMR and volumetric uptake-derived xenon desorption isotherms
(bottom)
of DUT-50 at 200 K.The adsorption/desorption
isotherm obtained from the 129Xe NMR spectra can be compared
with the volumetric xenon isotherms
(cf. Figures and 7, bottom). During adsorption, the jump in the chemical
shift takes place, coinciding with the NGA transition. The appearance
of a second signal for the adsorbed xenon shows a gradual transformation
of the cp state back to the op state. During desorption, the structural
change of DUT-50 is only observable within the 129Xe NMR
isotherm, rendering 129Xe NMR spectroscopy highly useful
to better understand the structural transformation. It can thus be
stated that DUT-50 is the second known material showing a negative
gas adsorption phenomenon.Finally, another MOF denoted as DUT-151
(cf. Figure S4) with an even longer linker
than that of DUT-50
(four 1,4-substituted phenylene units in the ligand backbone) was
also investigated with respect to its xenon adsorption behavior. Due
to its interpenetrated network structure, the MOF was not included
into the pore size estimation experiments.Nevertheless, the
adsorption experiments at 200 K were performed
for DUT-151 as well. The material shows structural transformations
during adsorption at this temperature, which, however, differ from
the behavior of DUT-50. After the activation (DUT-151act) and start
of the adsorption experiment at low pressure, the material is found
in the closed-pore state (DUT-151cp). At low pressure, the signal
of the adsorbed xenon is observed in the range between 118 and 158
ppm (Figure ). This
signal can be assigned to xenon adsorbed on the closed pores at low
pressures. Beyond a relative pressure of 0.2, a second signal for
the adsorbed xenon occurs at a higher chemical shift of 202 ppm. Thus,
two signals can be observed simultaneously in this pressure range.
However, the signal intensity of the first signal at a lower chemical
shift decreases with increasing pressure and the signal finally disappears.
Figure 8
129Xe NMR adsorption spectra (top) and 129Xe NMR adsorption
and desorption isotherms (bottom) of DUT-151 at
200 K.
129Xe NMR adsorption spectra (top) and 129Xe NMR adsorption
and desorption isotherms (bottom) of DUT-151 at
200 K.We assume that the interpenetrated
networks shift relative to each
other beginning from a relative pressure of 0.2, i.e., the network
seems to transform from a closed-pore structure to an open-pore structure
(DUT-151op). The chemical shift jump and the appearance of the second
signal is clearly visible within the adsorption isotherm of DUT-151
at 200 K (Figure ,
bottom). This pore opening allows more xenon adsorption as seen from
the increasing total signal intensity. The tendency of the lattice
to close, which must be overcome by adsorbed xenon, as well as Xe–Xe
interactions may cause a higher chemical shift of the second signal.
During desorption, only one signal of the adsorbed xenon is recorded
and a hysteresis is observed. The chemical shift jump is observable
during desorption at a lower relative pressure of 0.15. The starting
value of the chemical shift of the adsorbed xenon is reached again
after desorption of gas, thus the adsorption-induced structural transition
seems to be reversible. The reason for the difference in adsorption
and switching behavior compared with those of DUT-49 and DUT-50 (see
above) is the lattice interpenetration present in DUT-151. This was
found to prevent large-scale structural contraction and NGA due to
a reduced void. However, sufficient void space in the pores is required
for such a structural transition.
Conclusions
High-pressure
in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopy is well-suited
to investigate host–guest interactions and adsorption processes
in porous materials such as MOFs. The following conclusions are drawn
from our studies:Chemical shift measurement of the
adsorbed xenon as a function of pressure yields chemical shift adsorption/desorption
isotherms, which compare well with the conventional, uptake-measurement-based
isotherms for rigid MOFs. This is because the chemical shift and the
density of the adsorbed xenon are correlated.The difference Δδ between
the chemical shift of the adsorbed xenon extrapolated to a relative
pressure of one and the chemical shift of bulk liquid xenon correlates
with the average pore diameter for MOFs of comparable chemical composition,
i.e., surface chemistry. This correlation between Δδ and
the mean pore diameter is demonstrated for the series of isoreticular
MOFs studied here (DUT-48, DUT-46, DUT-49, and DUT-50). The chemical
shift difference of the adsorbed xenon decreases with increasing mean
pore diameter. The quantity Δδ is easily and accurately
measurable by high-pressure in situ 129Xe NMR spectroscopy
and allows an estimation of the mean pore size.Characterization of the adsorption
processes at lower temperature (200 K) shows interesting adsorption
phenomena. Similar to DUT-49, the novel compound DUT-50 also shows
structural changes of the pore system during adsorption, causing a
negative gas adsorption (NGA) as can be visualized by 129Xe NMR spectroscopy. 2D EXSY experiments allow to measure the exchange
between the coexisting open and contracted pores. The measured exchange
rate suggests that structural transitions in DUT-50 are a rather collective
phenomenon of entire crystallites.The interpenetrated compound DUT-151
shows a different switching behavior compared with DUT-49 and DUT-50.
The transition is not a structural contraction but a xenon-adsorption-induced
mutual shift of the two interpenetrating networks from a closed-pore
to an open-pore state of the MOF.The nonflexible compound DUT-46 exhibits
a hysteresis in the 129Xe NMR isotherm due to diffusion-limited
adsorption/redistribution processes at low temperature.
Authors: Igor Moudrakovski; Dmitriy V Soldatov; John A Ripmeester; Devin N Sears; Cynthia J Jameson Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2004-12-13 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Nicole Klein; Christin Herzog; Michal Sabo; Irena Senkovska; Jürgen Getzschmann; Silvia Paasch; Martin R Lohe; Eike Brunner; Stefan Kaskel Journal: Phys Chem Chem Phys Date: 2010-08-09 Impact factor: 3.676
Authors: Ivo Stassen; Nicholas Burtch; Alec Talin; Paolo Falcaro; Mark Allendorf; Rob Ameloot Journal: Chem Soc Rev Date: 2017-06-06 Impact factor: 54.564
Authors: Francesco Walenszus; Jack D Evans; Volodymyr Bon; Friedrich Schwotzer; Irena Senkovska; Stefan Kaskel Journal: Chem Mater Date: 2021-10-06 Impact factor: 10.508
Authors: Daniil M Polyukhov; Simon Krause; Volodymyr Bon; Artem S Poryvaev; Stefan Kaskel; Matvey V Fedin Journal: J Phys Chem Lett Date: 2020-07-10 Impact factor: 6.888