| Literature DB >> 35573987 |
Jarvis C Noronha1,2, Jeffrey I Mechanick3.
Abstract
Nutrition therapy plays an integral role in the prevention and management of patients with type 2 diabetes (T2D). A potential strategy is the utilization of diabetes-specific nutrition formulas (DSNFs) as meal replacements. In this article, we distinguish DSNFs from standard nutrition formulas, review the clinical data examining the effectiveness of DSNFs, and propose an evidence-based algorithm for incorporating DSNFs as part of nutrition therapy in T2D. DSNFs contain slowly-digestible carbohydrates, healthy fats (e.g., monounsaturated fatty acids), and specific micronutrients, which provide added benefits over standard nutrition formulas. In short- and long-term clinical trials, DSNFs demonstrate improvements in postprandial glycemic responses translating into sustainable benefits in long-term glycemic control (e.g., hemoglobin A1c and glycemic variability) and various cardiometabolic outcomes. To facilitate the delivery of DSNFs in a clinical setting, the transcultural diabetes nutrition algorithm can be utilized based on body weight (underweight, normal weight, or overweight) and level of glycemic control (controlled or uncontrolled).Entities:
Keywords: clinical practice; diabetes; glycemic control; glycemic response; meal replacement
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35573987 PMCID: PMC9099205 DOI: 10.3389/fendo.2022.874968
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Endocrinol (Lausanne) ISSN: 1664-2392 Impact factor: 6.055
Effect of Diabetes-Specific Nutrition Formulas on Glycemic and Cardiometabolic Endpoints in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes.
| Study [reference] | Design, Population | Intervention | Control | Main Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lansink et al. ( | Parallel, RCT, 44 T2D patients | 2x200mL of DSNF (Diasip®) for 4 weeks (n=22; 9M, 13F) | 2x200mL isocaloric standard formula for 4 weeks (n=22; 16M, 6F) | ↓PPGR in DSNF group at visit 1 (Day 1) and after 4 weeks use vs. control group |
| Laksir et al. ( | Crossover, RCT, 19 T2D patients who were malnourished or at risk of malnourishment | 1x200mL DSNF (Fortimel DiaCare) | 1x200mL standard formula (Fortimel Extra) | ↓PPGR and iCmax of glucose after DSNF consumption (1x200mL) vs. standard formula (1x200mL) |
| Angarita Dávila et al. ( | Crossover, RCT, 16 T2D patients | DSNF with resistant maltodextrin and sucromalt (GS; Glucerna SR®) | Non-DSNF (ET; Ensure®) | ↓PGR, PPIR and GIP response in GS and DI group vs. ET |
| Gulati et al. ( | Crossover, RCT, 40 T2D patients | DSNF (Nutren® Diabetes) | Isocaloric meal (Cornflakes and milk) | ↓PPGR and PPIR in DSNF group vs. isocaloric meal group |
| Mottalib et al. ( | Crossover, RCT, 22 OW/OB patients with T2D | DSNF (Glucerna; GL) | Isocaloric meal (Oatmeal; OM) | ↓PPGR and ↑ GLP-1 response after GL and UGC vs. OM |
| Mustad et al. ( | Parallel, RCT, 81 T2D patients on oral anti-diabetes medications | Participants consumed DSNF (Glucerna Hunger Smart) at breakfast and as a mid-afternoon snack (DNSF Bkfst/AS; n=24) | Participants consumed no study product (SSD; n=32) | ↓Positive AUC and ↓ adjusted peak value for glucose in DNSF Bkfst/AS group compared to SSD group |
| Chee et al. ( | Parallel, RCT, 230 OW/OB patients with T2D | tDNA plan incorporating DSNFs with motivational interviewing for 6 months (tDNA-MI) | Usual care (UC) for 6 months | ↓Body weight, HbA1c, and SBP in tDNA-MI and tDNA-CC groups vs. UC group at 6 months |
| Look AHEAD Group 2013 ( | 5145 OW/OB patients with T2D | Intensive lifestyle intervention (ILI) incorporating various MRs including DSNFs | Diabetes support and education (DSE) control group | ↓Body weight and ↓ HbA1c in ILI group compared with control group throughout study period (median follow-up, 9.6 years) |
| Elia et al. ( | SRMA, 23 studies, n=784 patients with T2D | DSNFs (oral or tube feeds) | Standard formulas | ↓Postprandial rise in blood glucose, peak blood glucose, and glucose AUC; reduced requirement for insulin |
| Ojo et al. ( | SRMA, 5 studies, n=270 patients with T2D | DSNFs (oral or tube feeds) | Standard formulas | ↓FBG and HbA1c, and |
| Sanz-Paris et al. ( | SRMA, 18 studies, n=845 patients with T1D/T2D | DSNFs high in MUFAs (oral or tube feeds) | Standard formulas | ↓Postprandial glucose peak, incremental glucose response, glucose variability, HbA1c change from baseline, mean administered insulin dose, mean blood triglycerides and ↑ mean blood HDL |
AUC, area under the curve; DSNF, diabetes-specific nutrition formula; FBG, fasting blood glucose; FPG, fasting plasma glucose; F, female; GIP, gastric inhibitory peptide; GLP-1, glucagon-like peptide-1; HbA1c, hemoglobin A1c; HDL, high-density lipoprotein; iCmax, incremental maximum concentration; M, male; OW/OB, overweight/obese; PPGR, postprandial glucose response; PPIR, postprandial insulin response; SBP, systolic blood pressure; tDNA, trans-cultural diabetes nutrition algorithm; T1D, type 1 diabetes; T2D, type 2 diabetes.
“down arrow” = reduced/lower.
“up arrow” = increased/higher.
Evidence-Based Algorithm for the use of Diabetes-Specific Nutrition Formulas in Prediabetes, Type 1 Diabetes and Type 2 Diabetes.
| Overweight/obese individuals | Use 2 to 3 diabetes-specific nutrition formulas <250lb = 1200 to 1500 calories >250lb = 1500 to 1800 calories | |
| Normal weight individuals | Uncontrolled diabetes HbA1c>7% | 1 to 2 diabetes-specific nutrition formulas per day to be incorporated into a meal plan, as a calorie replacement for meal, partial meal, or snack (grade D; LOE 4) |
| Controlled diabetes HbA1c<7% | Use of diabetes-specific nutrition formulas should be based on clinical judgement and individual assessment | |
| Underweight individuals | Use of diabetes-specific nutrition supplements | |
Adapted from (27).
LOE 1: data defined as conclusive results from prospective, randomized controlled trials that have large subject populations representative of the target population and results that are easily generalized to the target population. Data also include results from meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials, results from multicenter trials, and “all or none” evidence; LOE 2: data include conclusive results from individual randomized controlled trials that have limited subject numbers or target population representation; LOE 3: data include all other conclusive clinical findings from nonrandomized studies, studies without controls, and nonexperimental or observational studies. These data may require interpretation and, by themselves, are not compelling; LOE 4: data are defined as information based solely on experience or expert opinion and are not necessarily substantiated by any conclusive scientific data. Frequently, only LOE 4 data are available.
Diabetes-specific nutrition formulas are nutritional products used as replacement for meals, partial meals, or snacks to replace calories in the diet.
Individuals who may have muscle mass and/or function loss and/or micronutrient deficiency may benefit from diabetes-specific nutrition supplements. Individuals who need support with weight maintenance and/or a healthy meal plan could benefit from diabetes-specific nutrition formulas.
Diabetes-specific nutrition supplements are complete and balanced nutritional products used in addition to a typical meal plan, to help promote increased nutritional intake.