Jia Zhang1, Achintya Kundu1, Thomas Elsaesser1, Piero Macchi2, Marcel Kalter3, Georg Eickerling3, Wolfgang Scherer3. 1. Max-Born-Institut für Nichtlineare Optik und Kurzzeitspektroskopie, 12489 Berlin, Germany. 2. Department of Chemistry, Materials and Chemical Engineering, Politecnico di Milano, 20131 Milano, Italy. 3. Institut für Physik, Universität Augsburg, 86135 Augsburg, Germany.
Abstract
The vibrational response of the activated C-D bond in the chloroform complex [Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N')·CDCl3, where btz = 2,2'-bi-5,6-dihydro-4H-1,3-thiazine] is studied by linear and nonlinear two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy. The change of the C-D stretching vibration of metal-coordinated CDCl3 relative to the free solvent molecule serves as a measure of the non-classical Pt···D-C interaction strength. The stretching absorption band of the activated C-D bond displays a red shift of 119 cm-1 relative to uncoordinated CDCl3, a strong broadening, and an 8-fold enhancement of spectrally integrated absorption. The infrared (IR) absorption and 2D-IR line shapes are governed by spectral diffusion on 200 fs and 2 ps time scales, induced by the fluctuating solvent CDCl3. The enhanced vibrational absorption and coupling to solvent forces are assigned to the enhanced electric polarizability of the activated C-D bond. Density functional theory calculations show a significant increase of C-D bond polarizability of CDCl3 upon coordination to the 16 valence electron Pt(II) complex.
The vibrational response of the activated C-D bond in the chloroform complex [Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N')·CDCl3, where btz = 2,2'-bi-5,6-dihydro-4H-1,3-thiazine] is studied by linear and nonlinear two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy. The change of the C-D stretching vibration of metal-coordinated CDCl3 relative to the free solvent molecule serves as a measure of the non-classical Pt···D-C interaction strength. The stretching absorption band of the activated C-D bond displays a red shift of 119 cm-1 relative to uncoordinated CDCl3, a strong broadening, and an 8-fold enhancement of spectrally integrated absorption. The infrared (IR) absorption and 2D-IR line shapes are governed by spectral diffusion on 200 fs and 2 ps time scales, induced by the fluctuating solvent CDCl3. The enhanced vibrational absorption and coupling to solvent forces are assigned to the enhanced electric polarizability of the activated C-D bond. Density functional theory calculations show a significant increase of C-D bond polarizability of CDCl3 upon coordination to the 16 valence electron Pt(II) complex.
The metal-induced activation
of covalent carbon–hydrogen (C–H) bonds plays a key
role in many catalytic processes of industrial relevance, such as
olefine polymerization. However, the chemical inert nature of C–H
bonds as a consequence of their low bond polarizability and large
bond dissociation energies renders their activation rather difficult.
It is therefore of fundamental interest to understand the electronic
origin and the microscopic control parameters of metal-induced C–H
bond activation processes in transition metal complexes.Since
the early 1960s, numerous examples of M···H–C
interactions have been identified and characterized by a large variety
of spectroscopic and structure determination techniques as well as
computational methods, e.g., in the case of agostic[1−4] or σ-alkane transition metal
complexes.[5,6] However, relatively little information is
available in the case of the activation of C–H bonds via metal
hydrogen bonding.[7] This is surprising because
the first M···H–X hydrogen bonds (X = N and
O) have already been observed in metallocenyl alcohols in 1960 by
the detection of subtle red shifts of the coordinating M···H–O
moieties (M = Fe and Ru) relative to the free hydroxyl stretching
modes.[8]M···H–C
hydrogen bonds are considered a predominantly
electrostatic three-center four-electron (3c4e) interaction between
the hydrogen atom and the metal atom (hydrogen-bond acceptor). As
a result of the rather unpolar character of the covalent bond between
the carbon atom (hydrogen-bond donor) and the hydrogen atom, 3c4e
M···H–C hydrogen bonds are considered to be
rather weak. However, as outlined recently, when the hydrogen-bond
acceptor represents an electron-deficient transition metal complex
with a valence electron count of ≤16, covalent M···H–C
bonding might become the predominant interaction,[9] which causes a significant C–H bond activation with
a bond enlargement in the range typically observed in agostic benchmark
systems (0.03–0.1 Å).[10,11] This is also
the case for our title compound Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (1), where btz = 2,2′-bi-5,6-dihydro-4H-1,3-thiazine, with 16 valence electrons and a square-planar
coordinated d8–Pt(II) complex center, which is characterized
by a significantly depopulated d2 orbital. The latter can establish a non-classical M···H–C
metal hydrogen bond between the metal ligand fragment and the C–H
bond of the chloroform ligand.[9]The
M···H–C interaction in compound 1 has been characterized by vibrational spectroscopy because
it is particularly sensitive to local molecular interactions, which
induce shifts of vibrational transition frequencies and changes of
vibrational line shapes. In a very recent study of compound 1, pressure-dependent infrared (IR) spectra have been measured
in the crystalline phase.[9] A broad vibrational
absorption band has been observed, which is red-shifted by 254 cm–1 relative to the C–H stretching band of neat
chloroform in the gas phase.[12] This band
has been assigned to the C–H stretching vibration of the coordinating
chloroform molecule forming a non-classical Pt···H–C
bond. We note that the red shift of a C–H band can be used
to characterize metal-induced bond activation as a result of agostic
or M···H–C hydrogen bonding in solution.[9,13,14]While the red shift of
the C–H stretching frequency can
be empirically correlated with a lengthening of the C–H bond,[15] the molecular mechanisms behind the red shift
and the strong spectral broadening observed for non-classical M···H–C
interactions are not understood. Linear IR spectra reflect the time-averaged
vibrational response of the C–H group and do not allow for
a clear separation of different broadening mechanisms. In contrast,
nonlinear two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) methods can grasp vibrational
frequency correlations on the intrinsic femtosecond time scale of
structural fluctuations in liquids and, thus, dynamically discern
different contributions to the overall line shape.[16] In this Letter, we report a 2D-IR study of C–D stretching
excitations of the chloroform–Pt(II) complex 1 (Figure a) in liquid
CDCl3. The C–D stretching vibration of the CDCl3 solvent serves as a direct benchmark for bringing out the
impact of complex formation on the vibrational properties. In addition
to a pronounced red shift and broadening of the C–D stretching
band of the complex, we demonstrate a strong enhancement of IR absorption
strength in the complex compared to neat CDCl3. The line
shapes of the linear and 2D-IR spectra are governed by spectral diffusion
on 200 fs and 2 ps time scales, set by fast structural fluctuations
of the solvent. The changes in vibrational line shapes and the strong
coupling to solvent fluctuations are assigned to the enhanced electric
polarizability of the activated C–D bond.
Figure 1
(a) Ball-and-stick representations
of the calculated structures
of compounds CDCl3, Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (1), and Pt(C6H5)Cl(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (2a and 2b), with salient bond distances given
in angstroms. Hydrogen atoms have been omitted for clarity. (b, c,
and d) Visualization of the atomic polarizability tensors. Panel d
depicts the entire molecules where, for sake of better visibility,
the polarizabilities are drawn like thermal ellipsoids using the software
Mercury,[17] and therefore, the sizes are
not correctly proportioned; however, the orientation is correct. Panel
c shows a zoom in the region of the CDCl3 coordination,
and panel b shows a further zoom on the D atoms. Here, the plots are
obtained with the software Polaber,[18] and
the tensors have the correct proportions, adopting the scale factor
of 0.40 Å–2 (b) and 0.20 Å–2 (c). Note how the polarizability tensor of D is modified upon passing
from uncoordinated to coordinated species. For the sake of clarity
in panel b, the principal axes of the D polarizabilities are shown,
to emphasize the rotation with respect to the C–D bond direction.
(a) Ball-and-stick representations
of the calculated structures
of compounds CDCl3, Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (1), and Pt(C6H5)Cl(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (2a and 2b), with salient bond distances given
in angstroms. Hydrogen atoms have been omitted for clarity. (b, c,
and d) Visualization of the atomic polarizability tensors. Panel d
depicts the entire molecules where, for sake of better visibility,
the polarizabilities are drawn like thermal ellipsoids using the software
Mercury,[17] and therefore, the sizes are
not correctly proportioned; however, the orientation is correct. Panel
c shows a zoom in the region of the CDCl3 coordination,
and panel b shows a further zoom on the D atoms. Here, the plots are
obtained with the software Polaber,[18] and
the tensors have the correct proportions, adopting the scale factor
of 0.40 Å–2 (b) and 0.20 Å–2 (c). Note how the polarizability tensor of D is modified upon passing
from uncoordinated to coordinated species. For the sake of clarity
in panel b, the principal axes of the D polarizabilities are shown,
to emphasize the rotation with respect to the C–D bond direction.The molecular structure based on density functional
theory (DFT)
calculations and a linear IR absorption spectrum of compound 1 are shown in Figures a and 2. In the isolated complex, the
C–D group of a CDCl3 molecule coordinates the Pt
atom in the axial direction, resulting in a calculated elongation
of the C–D bond by 0.024 Å and a respective red shift
of the ν(C–D) stretching mode at 2020 cm–1 relative to non-coordinated chloroform [ν(C–D) = 2272
cm–1]. This is mainly due to the predominant Pt(d2) → σ*(C–D)
back donation and a secondary Pt(RY) ← σ(C–H)
donation into unoccupied extravalent (“Rydberg”) d orbitals
at the metal as revealed by second-order perturbation theory natural
bond orbital (NBO) analysis.[9,19] The Pt(d2) → σ*(C–D) interaction
amounts to −26.3 kJ mol–1 and provides a
substantial contribution to the total bonding energy between the metal
ligand fragment and the chloroform ligand (−64.6 kJ mol–1) as derived by an energy decomposition analysis (EDA).[20]
Figure 2
(a) Linear IR absorption spectrum of the complex in CDCl3 (black line, concentration c = 0.24 M),
consisting
of (1) the stretching absorption band of the complexed C–D
groups, (2) a shoulder probably as a result of C–D groups in
hydrogen bonds with dissociated btz ligands, and (3) the stretching
absorption band of uncomplexed C–D groups. The red line gives
the spectrum of the neat solvent CDCl3. Both spectra were
normalized to the peak absorbance at 2252 cm–1.
(b) Normalized IR absorption in the range of the C–D stretching
mode of the complex (1, solid line) and numerical spectrum from the
fit of the 2D-IR spectrum (dotted line).
(a) Linear IR absorption spectrum of the complex in CDCl3 (black line, concentration c = 0.24 M),
consisting
of (1) the stretching absorption band of the complexed C–D
groups, (2) a shoulder probably as a result of C–D groups in
hydrogen bonds with dissociated btz ligands, and (3) the stretching
absorption band of uncomplexed C–D groups. The red line gives
the spectrum of the neat solvent CDCl3. Both spectra were
normalized to the peak absorbance at 2252 cm–1.
(b) Normalized IR absorption in the range of the C–D stretching
mode of the complex (1, solid line) and numerical spectrum from the
fit of the 2D-IR spectrum (dotted line).The linear IR absorption spectrum in liquid CDCl3 (black
line in Figure a)
exhibits two prominent components, a broad band centered at 2133 cm–1 with a spectral width of 65 cm–1 (fwhm) and the much narrower C–D stretching band of the CDCl3 solvent at 2252 cm–1 of a spectral width
of 12 cm–1 only. The assignment of the broad vibrational
absorption will be discussed below.Femtosecond pump–probe
measurements give insight in the
dynamics of vibrational excitations in the range of the broad IR band.
The pump spectrum (dashed line in Figure a) is kept below 2220 cm–1 to avoid excitation of the solvent via its C–D stretching
band at 2252 cm–1. In Figure a, we present a series of transient pump–probe
spectra recorded at different delay times between pump and probe pulses
(colored symbols). The absorption change ΔA = −log(T/T0)
in mOD (OD = optical density) is plotted as a function of probe frequency
(T and T0 = sample transmission
with and without excitation). The pronounced absorption decrease ΔA < 0 between 2090 and 2220 cm–1 is
accompanied by an absorption increase ΔA >
0 of similar amplitude at lower probe frequencies. The absorption
decrease in the range of the linear absorption band 1 (solid line)
originates from the pump-induced depopulation of the v = 0 vibrational ground state and stimulated emission on the v = 1 to 0 transition. The transient population of the v = 1 state gives rise to enhanced absorption on the v = 1 to 2 transition, which is anharmonically red-shifted
compared to the v = 0 to 1 transition. Figure b shows two time-resolved transients
for fixed probe frequencies of 2041 cm–1 (v = 1 to 2 transition) and 2128 cm–1 (v = 0 to 1 transition). Both traces show a quasi-instantaneous
rise around delay zero and a complete decay of the absorption changes
on a 20 ps time scale. The solid lines are numerical fits to the data
points, following a monoexponential decay with a time constant of
5.1 ± 0.3 ps.
Figure 3
Results from femtosecond pump–probe experiments
in the range
of the C–D stretching vibration of the Pt(II) complex. (a)
Transient pump–probe spectra for different delay times. The
absorption change ΔA = −log(T/T0) is plotted as a function
of probe frequency (symbols, where T and T0 = sample transmission with and without excitation).
The dashed line represents the spectrum of the pump pulses, and the
solid line represents the linear absorption spectrum of the complexes
[Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3]. (b) Time-resolved
pump–probe traces measured at probe frequencies of 2041 cm–1 (red symbols) and 2128 cm–1 (black
symbols). The absorption change ΔA is plotted
as a function of the pump–probe delay. The solid lines are
monoexponential fits to the data with a decay time of 5.1 ± 0.3
ps.
Results from femtosecond pump–probe experiments
in the range
of the C–D stretching vibration of the Pt(II) complex. (a)
Transient pump–probe spectra for different delay times. The
absorption change ΔA = −log(T/T0) is plotted as a function
of probe frequency (symbols, where T and T0 = sample transmission with and without excitation).
The dashed line represents the spectrum of the pump pulses, and the
solid line represents the linear absorption spectrum of the complexes
[Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3]. (b) Time-resolved
pump–probe traces measured at probe frequencies of 2041 cm–1 (red symbols) and 2128 cm–1 (black
symbols). The absorption change ΔA is plotted
as a function of the pump–probe delay. The solid lines are
monoexponential fits to the data with a decay time of 5.1 ± 0.3
ps.More specific insight in vibrational
line shapes and the underlying
molecular mechanisms is attained from 2D-IR spectra. Figure a displays an experimental
2D-IR spectrum, measured at a population time T =
300 fs in the range of the broad absorption band with a maximum at
2133 cm–1 (cf. Figure ). The absorptive 2D signal, i.e., the real
part of the sum of the rephasing and non-rephasing signal, is plotted
as a function of the excitation frequency ν1 (ordinate)
and the detection frequency ν3 (abscissa). The yellow
contour represents the 2D signal on the v = 0 to
1 transition, while the blue contour is due to the v = 1 to 2 transition. Following the standard convention of 2D-IR
spectroscopy, the yellow contour is given with a positive sign and
the blue contour is given with a negative sign, opposite to the sign
of the absorption change ΔA in the pump–probe
spectra of Figure a.
Figure 4
(a) 2D-IR spectrum of the C–D stretching vibration of the
Pt(II) complex Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3. The
absorptive 2D signal measured at a waiting time T = 300 fs is plotted as a function of excitation frequency ν1 and detection frequency ν3. Yellow–red
contours represent signals on the v = 0 to 1 transition
corresponding to an absorption decrease, while blue contours are due
to the v = 1 to 2 transition and represent an absorption
increase. The signal change between neighboring contour lines is 2%.
The dashed lines mark the directions along which the cuts in panels
c and (d were taken. (b) Simulated 2D-IR spectrum. (c) Cuts of the
2D-IR spectra along the direction A. The black line represents the
experimental data, and the blue line represents the simulation. (d)
Same as panel c for a cut along the direction B.
(a) 2D-IR spectrum of the C–D stretching vibration of the
Pt(II) complex Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3. The
absorptive 2D signal measured at a waiting time T = 300 fs is plotted as a function of excitation frequency ν1 and detection frequency ν3. Yellow–red
contours represent signals on the v = 0 to 1 transition
corresponding to an absorption decrease, while blue contours are due
to the v = 1 to 2 transition and represent an absorption
increase. The signal change between neighboring contour lines is 2%.
The dashed lines mark the directions along which the cuts in panels
c and (d were taken. (b) Simulated 2D-IR spectrum. (c) Cuts of the
2D-IR spectra along the direction A. The black line represents the
experimental data, and the blue line represents the simulation. (d)
Same as panel c for a cut along the direction B.The 2D-IR spectra allow for a clear separation of the signals due
to v = 0 to 1 (yellow) and v = 1
to 2 (blue) excitations. The latter are red-shifted along the detection
frequency axis ν3 as a consequence of the anharmonic
red shift of the v = 1 to 2 transition. Both components
of the 2D signal display elliptic envelopes with the long axis tilted
relative to the frequency diagonal ν1 = ν3 (black solid line). For an analysis of the 2D-IR envelopes,
cuts along the directions A (diagonal) and B (antidiagonal) are plotted
in panels c and d of Figure (black lines).The 2D-IR spectra were analyzed with
the help of a density matrix
approach for describing the third-order nonlinear response of the
sample.[16,21,22] A three-level
system including the v = 0 to 1 transition and the
red-shifted v = 1 to 2 transition was considered.
To account for the impact of solvent fluctuations on the 2D line shapes,
the frequency fluctuation correlation function (FFCF) was approximated
by a sum of two Kubo terms.Here, Δν1 and Δν2 are
frequency fluctuation amplitudes, and τ1 and τ2 with τ1 < τ2 are correlation
decay times. On top of the FFCF, the contribution
of the v = 1 population decay with a time constant
of 5.1 ps was included in the calculations. The calculated 2D-IR spectra
were convoluted with the electric field envelopes of the femtosecond
mid-IR pulses to facilitate a 1:1 comparison to the experimental data.
As a benchmark, the linear IR absorption spectrum of the C–D
stretching vibrations was calculated as well (dotted line in Figure b).The 2D-IR
spectrum calculated for a population time T = 300
fs is shown in Figure b, and the parameter values used in the calculations are summarized
in Table . The calculated
2D-IR and linear absorption spectra are in good agreement with their
experimental counterparts. The correlation decay times derived from
the calculation are τ1 = 180 fs and τ2 = 2 ps, with the fluctuation amplitudes Δν1 = 35 cm–1 and Δν2 = 21
cm–1. The fast correlation decay makes the predominant
contribution to the antidiagonal line width of the 2D spectral envelopes
(Figure d), while
the slow component induces a substantial broadening along the diagonal
(Figure c). The population
decay of the v = 1 state has a minor influence on
the observed line shapes. The diagonal anharmonicity of the oscillators,
i.e., the difference in frequency of the v = 0 to
1 transition and the v = 1 to 2 transition, has a
value of 85 cm–1. It should be noted that 2D-IR
spectra of C–D stretching excitations of uncoordinated CDCl3 molecules, i.e., in the range of the strong absorption band
at 2252 cm–1 (red line in Figure b), have been reported in ref (23). They exhibit spectral
envelopes oriented parallel to the excitation frequency axis, pointing
to ultrafast spectral diffusion and a line shape close to the homogeneous
limit. The diagonal anharmonicity derived from the 2D-IR spectra had
a value of 67 cm–1.
Table 1
Parameter
Values from the Numerical
Simulation of the 2D-IR Spectra
C–D stretching v = 0 to 1 transition
2133 cm–1
C–D stretching v = 1 to 2 transition
2048 cm–1
diagonal
anharmonicity
85 cm–1
vibrational lifetime
5.1 ps
frequency fluctuation correlation function (FFCF)
correlation decay times
τ1 = 180 fs
τ2 = 2 ps
fluctuation amplitudes
Δν1 = 35 cm–1
Δν2 = 21 cm–1
We now discuss the experimental
and theoretical results. The broad
IR absorption band with a maximum at 2133 cm–1 occurs
in a frequency range where the neat solvent CDCl3 is essentially
transparent and vibrational bands of Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)
are absent. We thus assign the broad IR absorption to the C–D
stretching mode of CDCl3 molecules being part of the Pt(II)
chloroform complex 1, in line with the assignment of
the corresponding C–D stretching band in ref (4). The red shift by 119 cm–1 of the broad C–D stretching band relative
to that of uncoordinated CDCl3 molecules at 2252 cm–1 is due to the attractive Pt···D–C
interaction within the complex, lowering the force constant of the
C–D stretching vibration. The extent of the red shift is much
larger than frequency shifts observed in hydrogen bonds of similar
length between a C–H or C–D group and a non-metallic
acceptor atom.[23,24] This fact supports the results
of an earlier DFT study suggesting that the red shift in the title
complex is mainly due to the pronounced Pt(d2) → σ*(C–H) back donation as
a signature of non-classical metal hydrogen bonding.[9]The strength of the red-shifted C–D stretching
absorption
is substantially enhanced in comparison to the C–D stretching
band of the solvent CDCl3. From the IR absorbance at 2133
cm–1, the complex concentration, and the sample
thickness, one calculates a peak molar extinction coefficient ε(2133
cm–1) ≈ 16 M–1 cm–1, whereas the solvent C–D stretching band displays a peak
extinction coefficient of ε(2252 cm–1) = 6.2
M–1 cm–1. Spectral integration
over the two bands gives a ratio of the complex to solvent absorption
strength per C–D bond of approximately 8.2. This drastic enhancement
is a consequence of the modified electronic structure of the C–D
groups interacting with the metal atom. We assign it to a strong increase
of electric polarizability.A theoretical study of the polarizability
of the activated C–D
bonds is in line with this suggestion. Analysis of the calculated
atomic polarizability tensor of the bridging deuterium atom of the
Pt···D–C moiety (α33 = 6.8
bohr3) in compound 1 (Figure and Table ) reveals a noticeable polarizability enhancement along
the Pt···D direction relative to that in uncoordinated
chloroform (α33 = 3.5 bohr3). This enhancement
is mainly due to the establishment of non-classical Pt···D
orbital interactions. Accordingly, the bond polarizabilities of the
Pt···D bond of compound 1 and Pt(C6H5)Cl(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (compound 2a in Figure ) are rather similar
(32.4 bohr3 in compound 1 and 32.3 bohr3 in compound 2a) in line with their comparable
Pt···D orbital interaction.[9] This is also evident in the α11 component of the
polarizability tensor of the Pt atom (cf. Table ), which is very large in compounds 1 and 2a but significantly smaller in compound 2b, where no Pt···D interaction takes
place.
Table 2
Calculated Polarizability α33 of the Deuterium Atom along the Direction of the Maximum
Polarizability (Almost Coinciding with the C–D Direction) and
Polarizability α11 of the Platinum Atom along the
Direction of the Lowest Polarizability (Almost Coinciding with the
Pt···D Direction for 1 and 2a) for CDCl3, Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (1), and Pt(C6H5)Cl(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (2a and 2b)
molecular
system
polarizability
of D, α33 (bohr3)
polarizability
of Pt, α11 (bohr3)
CDCl3
3.54
Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (1)
6.76
23.34
Pt(C6H5)Cl(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (2a)
7.01
23.78
Pt(C6H5)Cl(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (2b)
5.62
16.63
Also, the C–D bond polarizabilities
increase significantly
upon establishment of a non-classical Pt···D–C
interaction: 8.3 bohr3 in CDCl3, 14.4 bohr3 in compound 1, and 14.5 bohr3 in
compound 2a. We note that the C–D bond polarizability
also increases when CDCl3 is involved in classical hydrogen
bonding. However, the polarizability enhancement is smaller. Accordingly,
in Pt(C6H5)Cl(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 (2b in Figure ) characterized by
a classical Cl···D–C hydrogen bond,[25] the C–D bond polarizability of the bridging
C–D group is 12.2 bohr3. In this respect, compound 2b might serve as a benchmark of a classical hydrogen bond,
in keeping with the discussion presented by Dos Santos and Macchi.[26] The smaller C–D bond polarizability in
compound 2b versus compounds 1 and 2a is also reflected in the smaller atomic polarizability
αiso of the chloro ligand in compound 2b (20.6 bohr3) compared to those of the platinum atoms
in compounds 1 (38.8 bohr3) and 2a (36.5 bohr3). The bond activation itself, however, does
not impart a significant change of the bond polarizabilities because
small increases in the atom–atom distance affect the polarizability
solely in terms of a subtle secondary contribution.The red
shift and absorption enhancement of the C–D stretching
band in the complex are accompanied by a strong broadening to a spectral
width of 65 cm–1 compared to 12 cm–1 for the C–D stretching band of CDCl3. The femtosecond
pump–probe experiments give a lifetime of the red-shifted C–D
stretching vibration of 5.1 ± 0.3 ps, somewhat shorter than the
∼15.7 ps decay time of the C–D vibration at 2252 cm–1.[23] The corresponding lifetime
broadening leads to a respective spectral width of 1.04 and 0.35 cm–1, in both cases negligible compared to the total spectral
widths. The much stronger broadening is dominated by the impact of
fluctuating forces, which CDCl3 solvent molecules in thermal
motion exert on the anharmonic C–D stretching oscillators.[27] Such forces originate from short-range dispersion
interactions and longer range electric interactions among CDCl3 molecules and with the complex. In neat liquid CDCl3, the molecules display an electric dipole moment of approximately
1.1 D[28,29] and a calculated C–D bond polarizability
of 10.4 bohr3 (calculated using a polarizable continuum
model around the molecule of CDCl3; noteworthy, the polarizability
of the bond is 8.3 bohr3 when computed without the polarizable
model). Both electric multipole and polarization forces are relevant,
which have been approximated by a pairwise additive Coulomb potential
and a non-additive polarization energy.The impact of the fluctuating
force on the C–D stretching
excitations depends upon the anharmonicity of the C–D stretching
oscillator[27,30] and the coupling strength of
the C–D bond to the liquid environment. A non-zero diagonal
anharmonicity of the oscillator is essential because excursions of
the IR transition frequency require a different energy modulation
of the two optically coupled states, the v = 0 and v = 1 states for the fundamental transition. In the present
system, the anharmonicities of 67 cm–1 for the solvent
C–D stretching mode and 85 cm–1 for the C–D
stretching mode of the complexes are of similar magnitude. The spectral
width of the solvent C–D stretching band of 12 cm–1 is a measure for the broadening caused by the total fluctuating
intermolecular force acting on a non-activated C–D group in
the bulk of liquid CDCl3. In striking contrast to this
behavior, the spectral width of the C–D stretching band of
the complex is roughly 5 times larger. This most interesting and surprising
observation points to a substantially stronger coupling to the external
fluctuating force. The enhanced electric polarizability of the activated
C–D bond thus leads to a significant induced dipole moment
of the C–D group, which vice versa results in a stronger coupling
to the electric forces from the solvent. We consider this mechanism
the main origin of the observed strong broadening.In our analysis
of the linear IR spectrum and the 2D-IR spectrum,
the influence of the fluctuating force on the line shapes is described
by introducing a FFCF consisting of two Kubo terms (eq ). The resulting line width is determined
by both the frequency fluctuation amplitudes Δν1,2 and the correlation decay times τ1,2. The fluctuation
amplitudes are proportional to the coupling strength between the oscillators
and their liquid environment, while the correlation times are determined
by the dynamics of thermally activated motions of solvent molecules.
The analysis of the 2D-IR line shapes gives decay times of 180 fs
and 2 ps in the FFCF and amplitudes of Δν1 =
35 cm–1 and Δν2 = 21 cm–1 for the fast and slower correlation components. The
correlation decay times are close to literature values derived from
ultrafast Kerr and theoretical studies of chloroform.[28,29,31] The latter have been attributed
to orientational and, at short times, collision-induced dynamics.
The agreement between the correlation times from the present 2D-IR
analysis and literature underlines the prominent influence of fluctuating
solvent forces on the vibrational line shape of the C–D vibration
of the Pt(II) chloroform complexes. The large fluctuation amplitudes
are specific for the C–D stretching mode of a CDCl3 molecule in a complex and result in the substantial line width of
the linear IR absorption and 2D-IR spectra. The much smaller spectral
widths of IR absorption and 2D-IR spectra of neat CDCl3[23] suggest fluctuation amplitudes of ∼10
cm–1.In conclusion, a combination of linear
and nonlinear 2D-IR spectroscopy
gives direct insight in the molecular mechanisms that determine the
ultrafast vibrational dynamics and line shapes of stretching vibrations
of activated C–D bonds in chloroform–Pt(II) complexes.
A one-to-one comparison to the C–D stretching mode of the solvent
CDCl3 elucidates and benchmarks the strong enhancement
of absorption strength and the strong broadening of the linear and
nonlinear vibrational line shapes of the complex. The broadening is
dominated by fluctuating electric forces from the solvent CDCl3. The strongly enhanced electric polarizability of activated
C–D bonds plays a key role for such spectroscopic properties.
In this way, the changes of the electronic structure of the complex
induced by pronounced Pt(d2) → σ*(C–H) back donation manifest in vibrational
spectra, making them a sensitive probe for this activation mechanism.
A similar polarizability behavior is expected to occur also in the
case of agostic or σ-type alkane transition metal complexes
displaying activated C–H bonds.
Materials and Methods
Sample
Preparation
A solution was prepared in a glovebox
by dissolving Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′) crystallites in CDCl3 (deutero, 99.8%) with a saturated concentration (c ≈ 0.24 M). A neat CDCl3 sample was prepared for
reference measurements. The sample was held in a demountable liquid
cell (Harrick) in between two 1 mm thick CaF2 windows separated
by a Teflon spacer of 390 μm thickness. The linear IR absorption
spectrum of the Pt(II) complex in CDCl3 and the CDCl3 reference spectrum were recorded with a Fourier transform
infrared (FTIR) spectrometer (Bruker Vertex 80, spectral resolution
of 1 cm–1).
Femtosecond Mid-IR Pump–Probe
Measurements
The
two-color mid-IR pump–probe setup has been described in detail
in ref (32). The output
of an amplified Ti:sapphire laser system (Coherent Libra, center wavelength
of 800 nm, pulse duration of <50 fs, pulse energy of 3.5 mJ, and
repetition rate of 1 kHz) drives two independent home-built optical
parametric frequency converters to generate two tunable mid-IR pulses.
The pump and probe pulses were centered at 2061 and 2105 cm–1 without spectral overlap with the very strong C–D stretching
absorption peak of CDCl3 at 2252 cm–1. The spectral width of the pulses was 170 cm–1 [full width at half maximum (fwhm)], the energy of the pump pulses
up to 2 μJ. The intensity ratio of pump to probe pulse was approximately
100. The temporal cross-correlation between pump and probe pulses
had a width of 150 fs (fwhm).The pump and probe pulses are
focused onto the sample with a spot diameter of 100 μm. In parallel,
a reference probe pulse travels through an unexcited part of the sample
to correct for shot-to-shot intensity fluctuations. After interaction
with the sample, the probe and the reference pulse are spectrally
dispersed in a monochromator and detected with a dual 64-pixel mercury–cadmium–telluride
(MCT) double array detector (spectral resolution of 2 cm–1). Complementary pump–probe experiments with the neat solvent
CDCl3 were performed under the same experimental conditions.
The absorbance change of the neat solvent is subtracted from that
of the Pt(C6H5)2(btz-N,N′)·CDCl3 sample to derive
the response of the Pt(II) complexes.
2D-IR Spectroscopy
Heterodyne-detected three-pulse
photon echoes are recorded to derive 2D-IR spectra of the Pt(II) complexes.
Details of the 2D-IR setup have been presented elsewhere.[21] Femtosecond pulses tunable in the near-infrared
(NIR) are generated in a three-stage optical parametric amplifier,
employing β-barium borate crystals driven by a commercial Ti:sapphire
laser system (Coherent Legend Elite, 800 nm, 80 fs, 3.1 mJ, and 1
kHz). Difference frequency mixing of the near-IR signal and idler
pulses in a 0.75 mm thick GaSe crystal generate mid-IR pulses of a
150 fs duration with a center frequency of 2060 cm–1 [spectral width (fwhm) of 150 cm–1] and an energy
of some of 4.5 μJ.Two pairs of phase-locked mid-IR pulses
with wavevectors (k1 and k2) and (k3 and kLO) are generated by reflection from diffractive optics. The pulses
(k1, k2, and k3) of 0.3 μJ energy each are focused onto
the sample in a box-coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) geometry.
The third-order photon echo signal is emitted in the phase matching
direction (−k1 + k2 + k3 = ksig) and overlapped with the local oscillator pulse kLO transmitted through the sample for heterodyne detection.
The heterodyne signal is dispersed by a monochromator and detected
by a 64-pixel MCT detector array (spectral resolution of 2 cm–1), defining the detection frequency ν3. The recorded signal field depends upon the coherence time τ
between the first (k1) and second (k2) pulse and the waiting time T between
the second (k2) and third (k3) pulse. The excitation frequency ν1 is generated
by Fourier transforming the nonlinear signal along the coherence time
τ. For proper phasing of the Fourier transform, the nonlinear
signal integrated along the excitation frequency ν1 is fitted to pump–probe spectra measured in the same setup
under identical experimental conditions.
DFT Calculations and Atomic
Polarizabilities
DFT calculations
on the Pt(II) complexes 1, 2a, and 2b and the CHCl3 molecule were performed employing
the BP86 density functional in combination with a TZ2P basis set as
implemented in the ADF suite of programs.[33−36] Scalar relativistic effects were
included within the zeroth-order regular approximation (ZORA),[37−40] and dispersion interactions for compounds 1 and 2a were treated via the density-dependent dispersion correction.[41] The molecular geometries were relaxed and verified
to converge to a local minimum via subsequent frequency calculations.
For the calculation of the bond polarizability, field-dependent calculations
employing the Gaussian 09 code (BP86/def2TZVP/DKH2)[42−44] have been performed
applying an electric field of 0.005 V/Å in positive and negative x, y, and z directions,
respectively.[45] From the field-dependent
calculations, intrinsic atomic dipole moments have been extracted
via the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) analysis[46] of the resulting electron densities, performed
using AimAll.[47] Bond dipole moments have
been calculated for QTAIM recognized bonds, using the QTAIM charges,
following the scheme proposed by Bader and Keith[48] and modified by Krawczuk et al.[18] The atomic polarizability tensors were calculated via numerical
differentiations of the total atomic dipoles, using the software PolaBer.[18] The inherent asymmetry of the atomic polarizabilities
is overcome by the symmetrization scheme of Nye.[49] The bond polarizability is calculated as the projection
of the atomic polarizabilities along the according bond direction.
Authors: Clare F Macrae; Ioana Sovago; Simon J Cottrell; Peter T A Galek; Patrick McCabe; Elna Pidcock; Michael Platings; Greg P Shields; Joanna S Stevens; Matthew Towler; Peter A Wood Journal: J Appl Crystallogr Date: 2020-02-01 Impact factor: 3.304