Endovascular Repair of an Iliac Arteriovenous Fistula in a 30-Year-Old Female Patient with Suspected Severe Cardiac Insufficiency: A Case Report.

A 30-year-old female was initially diagnosed with cardiac insufficiency and severe claudication. Additional imaging revealed a large iliac arteriovenous fistula, which was treated with an endovascular technique. A custom-made, self-expanding, polytetrafluorethylene-covered stent was implanted to restore the physiologic hemodynamic environment. The patient was asymptomatic at the 12-month clinical follow-up.

Key Summary Points

Case Presentation

When the patient was 20 years old and in the third trimester of her pregnancy, she suffered a traumatic injury (stab wound) of the abdominal cavity. The patient had emergency surgery, which required laparotomy. The procedure was successful and saved both the patient and the fetus. She became pregnant again when she was 27 years old and, after giving birth to a second, healthy child, a rapidly progressing heart insufficiency was diagnosed. When she was 30 years old, the patient presented herself to her nearby hospital. She was not able to climb one flight of stairs, and her walking distance on a flat surface, prior to exhaustion, was only 10–20 m. The physical examination revealed, even without the use of a stethoscope, a murmur originating from the abdominal cavity. The murmur was audible from a distance. Angiographic tomography revealed a large arteriovenous fistula (AVF) with oval dimensions of 1.5 cm by 2.0 cm (Fig. 1), which communicated between the left internal iliac artery (IIA) and the internal iliac vein (IIV). Furthermore, an enlarged inferior vena cava (IVC), common iliac vein (CIV), and IIV were detected on the left side. The CIV and the proximal part of the IIA were also dilated (Figs. 2, 3). Chest X-ray imaging revealed cardiomegaly with enlarged ventricles and atria. There was no left ventricular hypertrophy.

Fig. 1

Angiographic computed tomography (CT) of a 30-year-old female presenting with cardiac insufficiency and severe claudication. The patient was diagnosed with a large arteriovenous fistula. CT (GE Healthcare Revolution™ angio CT and 100 ml of Omnipaque 350) reveals a large, oval-shaped fistula approximately 1.5 cm × 2 cm in size between the left internal iliac artery (IIA) and the left internal iliac vein (IIV)

Fig. 2

Angiographic CT reconstruction revealing an enlarged inferior vena cava (IVC) and common iliac vein (CIV). The proximal internal iliac artery (IIA) and the proximal part of the internal iliac vein (IIV) are also dilated. The size of the oval-shaped fistula orifice was 2.0 cm × 1.0 cm

Fig. 3

Angiographic CT in the transverse plane, revealing an enlarged inferior vena cava (IVC) approximately 8 cm in diameter

Due to adhesions after a previous laparotomy, an endovascular approach was chosen. Because of the limited availability of closure devices for routine interventions in the Polish health care system, a 2-cm incision was made in the right groin so that the right common femoral artery (CFA) was exposed. To better control bleeding, a slightly longer incision was necessary for vessel closure with a prepared suture line once the introducer had been removed. The vessel was punctured and a 7-French endovascular sheath was inserted to cross the bifurcation with a guidewire (Radifocus® Guidewire M Stiff type, Terumo Europe, Leuven, Belgium). A contralateral pelvic conventional angiogram confirmed the presence of the AVF. After reverting to a Meier stiff wire, the distal part of the IIA was cannulated. After the left CFA had been punctured, a 4-French introducer and a pigtail catheter were inserted. A custom-manufactured, polytetrafluorethylene (PTFE)-covered, tapered, self-expandable nitinol stent 9 mm × 14 mm × 60 mm in size (Balton Medical, Warsaw, Poland) was implanted (Fig. 4). Post-implantation control angiography (Fig. 5) confirmed a physiologic arterial flow pattern. Moreover, post-procedural computed tomography (CT) did not show any flow between the venous and arterial vessels (Fig. 6). Shortly after the intervention, the patient was able to walk and climb stairs 2 h after the procedure, and she was discharged after 2 days. At the 12-month follow-up, the patient was asymptomatic, and no procedure-related complications were observed. The patient gave her written permission to release her data for publication. The ethics committee at the Medical University of Warsaw was consulted and waived any approval process in light of the signed patient consent.

Fig. 4

PTFE-covered, tapered, self-expandable nitinol stent 9 mm × 14 mm × 60 mm in size (Balton Medical, Warsaw, Poland)

Fig. 5

Control angiography after implantation of a PTFE-covered stent confirms a normalized hemodynamic flow pattern in the common iliac artery (CIA) and internal iliac artery (IIA) without any leak flow to the internal iliac vein. Left panel: flow patterns in the external iliac artery (EIA) are also normalized. Right panel: due to the high flow rate in the EIA, a separate still angiographic image was taken (imaged with a Siemens Artis zee; angiogram of the left common iliac artery; contrast injection in the left iliac trunk using 50 ml of Omnipaque 350, GE Healthcare)

Fig. 6

Post-procedural CT with normalized hemodynamic flow patterns in the left common iliac artery (CIA), internal iliac artery (IIA), and external iliac artery (EIA). There is no leakage from the left internal iliac artery (IIA) into the internal iliac vein. Post-endovascular repair of the AVF did not reduce the size of the left CIA (imaged with a GE Healthcare Revolution™ and 100 ml of Omnipaque 350)

Discussion

We present a case that documents a minimally invasive endovascular repair of a very rare iatrogenic AVF between the internal iliac artery and the internal iliac vein.

Etiology and Demographics

Despite the low incidence rates of iliac AVF, the etiology of this vascular pathology (Table 1) may have several cardinal causes, which may be categorized as spontaneous and traumatic. Brewster et al. [1] investigated aortocaval and iliac AVF over a 30-year observation period. Their report of 20 abdominal AVFs revealed that the primary etiology was aneurysm erosion (70%), followed by iatrogenic causes (20%) and gunshot wounds (10%). Lumbar disk surgery was reported to be the most prominent iatrogenic cause of iliac AVF [2, 3]. However, Wang and coworkers [2] also pointed out that besides aneurysm formation (mycotic, syphilitic), neoplastic erosion affecting surrounding vasculatures and connective tissue pathologies (e.g., Marfan syndrome) may also be clinically significant causes of iliac AVF. Trauma may not always be related to penetrating injuries (gunshot and stab wounds); it may also occur after seat-belt trauma [4] and laparoscopic appendectomy [5].

Table 1

Summary table for iliac arteriovenous fistulas

Definition	Iliac arteriovenous fistulas are abnormal connections between the iliac arteries and the corresponding iliac veins (common, internal, external)
Etiology	Strongly associated with trauma (shot and stab wounds) or iatrogenic interventions (lumbar disk surgery), they may also be related to aneurysm formation (mycotic, syphilitic), neoplastic erosion affecting surrounding vasculatures, or connective tissue pathologies (e.g., Marfan syndrome)
Incidence	Occur in less than 1% of all common iliac artery aneurysm cases and in (most likely) < 1% of all lumbar disk surgeries; strongly related to lower quadrant “piercing” traumatic injuries with other concomitant symptoms (signs of congestive heart failure, dyspnea, back pain, lower extremity edema, abdominal bruit)
Gender ratio	Not gender specific
Age predilection	Not related to age
Risk factors	Preceding lumbar disk surgery and, in particular, repeat lower back surgeries and traumatic injuries to the lower left and right quadrants
Treatment	Vascular reconstruction (open surgery) and percutaneous interventions (covered self-expanding stents)
Prognosis	Early detection: expected mortality < 10% and alleviation of symptoms; in the case of preceding ruptured aneurysm: mortality > 60%
Findings on imaging	Contrast-enhanced MR: easily discernible CT and US: clearly communicating flow across the fistula

Clinical and Imaging Findings

Depending on the etiology, the size, and the anatomic location of the iliac AVF, symptoms may be quite nonspecific, consisting of back pain [1], dyspnea commonly observed as pulmonary edema [2], or unilateral leg edema [1, 5, 6]. Due to the dramatically compromised hemodynamic environment, specific cardiovascular abnormalities may aid the decision regarding additional imaging diagnostics. The presence of a pulsatile abdominal mass with concomitant vascular bruit and thrill [6] has frequently been reported. Furthermore, intermittent claudication [2, 7], congestive heart failure [8, 9], pulmonary hypertension [3], T-wave abnormalities and renal failure [3, 10], and left ventricular hypertrophy [11] are described in the literature. Imaging findings based on exploratory ultrasound (US) are able to detect iliac AVFs with sufficient arterial leak flow rates into the venous system.

The cross-sectional area of the AVF in this case report was estimated at 2.2 cm2 (Aoval = ¼π × daxial × dlongitudinal = ¼π × 1.9 cm × 1.5 cm). Unfortunately, there is a paucity of data on actual cross-sectional areas of AVFs. However, Cronin et al. [12] reported a diameter of the left IIA of 24 mm, which corresponds well to the pathoanatomy in our case. They used a thoracic endograft that was longer (10 vs. 6 cm) and had a larger diameter (28 mm vs. 9/14 mm). We were able to use a shorter stent graft, since the iliac trunk was quite short in our patient. Ramacciotti and coworkers [13] conducted flow experiments in a canine AVF model and found that the flow through the fistula increases by a factor of 5 if the diameter of the AVF is 50% larger than the arterial diameter. This scenario from preclinical work appears to be similar to our case, without having measured actual flow rates.

Differential Diagnoses

All imaging modalities (Table 2) will show the focal widening caused by either a pseudoaneurysm or an aneurysm. These can be clearly differentiated from an AVF, which communicates between an artery and a vein. With duplex ultrasound, a pseudoaneurysm can have a characteristic yin–yang sign, which indicates the presence of bidirectional flow due to swirling of the blood within the lumen of the lesion. This swirling flow can also be seen in conventional angiograms. In contrast-enhanced CT angiography and MR angiography, this swirling flow can be detected from differences in the degree and shape of opacification of the contrast media within the lesion and/or in the vessels adjacent to the lesion. On duplex ultrasound, a true aneurysm of fusiform shape may show turbulent, disorganized flow, whereas a saccular aneurysm may show the yin–yang sign of swirling flow.

Table 2

Differential diagnosis table for iliac arteriovenous fistulas

Diagnosis	Ultrasound (US) findings	CT findings	MRI findings	Angiography/DSA findings
Iliac arteriovenous fistula	Detectable arteriovenous flow patterns Arterialized venous flow is visible; pulsatile flow	Dilated inferior vena cava and/or iliac arteries originating from the aneurysmal fistulous tract (detectable even for a small-sized AVF)	Findings similar to CT, especially in gadolinium-enhanced MR: dilated inferior vena cava and/or iliac arteries originating from the aneurysmal fistulous tract	Findings similar to CT, even with small leak flows of << 0.5 l/min
Pseudoaneurysm	No arteriovenous communication, but large fluid accumulation that can have a characteristic yin–yang sign, which indicates the presence of bidirectional flow due to swirling of the blood within the lumen of the lesion	Contrast-enhanced CT scan with axial images reveal large contrast-filled spaces around the iliac artery	Jet of bleeding from the pseudoaneurysm; outpouching of the vessel wall; focal widening edema; gas (without signs of infection)	Irregular lumen Focal widening No communication with the vein; the pseudoaneurysm may have irregular jagged margins; the angles between the pseudoaneurysm and the vessel lumen may be more acute; a neck connecting the pseudoaneurysm to the vessel wall may be seen
Aneurysm	Opacification of the extended vessel and a fusiform shape may show turbulent, disorganized flow, whereas a saccular aneurysm may show the yin-yang sign of swirling flow	Outpouching of the lumen of the vessel, usually no venous opacification	Focal widening; time-resolved flow; surrounding tissue does not have bleeding; gas w/o infection	Regular focal widening; no communication with the vein; may have smoother margins; the angles between the aneurysm and the vessel lumen are more obtuse; usually there is no neck connecting the aneurysm to the vessel wall

DSA Digital Subtraction Angiography

For the sake of discussion (Table 2), it can be stated that in CT or MRI, it may be difficult to differentiate a pseudoaneurysm from a true aneurysm. In a true aneurysm, there are usually no edema, blood products, and/or air in the tissues surrounding the aneurysm, unless the aneurysm has ruptured or is infected. If the pseudoaneurysm is chronic, the edema, blood products, and/or air in the tissues surrounding the pseudoaneurysm have usually dissolved. Consequently, exploratory ultrasound imaging is able to detect an iliac AVF with a sufficient arterial leak flow into the venous system [6], which may be in the range of 3 l/min [5]. Gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance (MR), computed tomography (CT), and angiography [7] are all suitable to detect even small-sized iliac AVFs with certainty. As concluded by Iijima et al. [6], any combination of imaging diagnostics are useful for detecting iliac AVF and deciding on the treatment modality.

Treatment and Prognosis

Surgical repair in these scenarios is associated with high morbidity and mortality due to the complex anatomy and the unfavorable access site [6]. Taking into consideration post-laparotomy abdominal adhesions, surgical access to the pelvis would be very demanding, and is associated with a high procedural risk. Large incisions and significant blood loss would most likely be inevitable. Furthermore, vessel wall adhesion between the IIA and IIV could have led to vessel wall rupture or wall dissection during surgical repair, which is associated with fatal bleeding.

There is also a significant risk while obtaining vascular access. Perforation of the intestine or bladder could have occurred, which inevitably would have resulted in peritonitis. Such a situation would have made it impossible to use a surgical repair with vascular patches. The endovascular approach, however, requires only a puncture on the left side and a small incision on the right side exposing the right CIA. Since we were not routinely using closure systems, we used a slightly longer incision to create a vessel loop so that bleeding could be better controlled. We are also convinced that a decreased introducer diameter may have facilitated the puncture and may have even avoided an incision. The endovascular approach, however, became a valuable alternative when dealing with patients with an iliac AVF [11].

The in-hospital outcome of this endovascular approach with a short recovery time is noteworthy. The patient could walk 2 h after the procedure and was discharged after 2 days. A similar immediate improvement using surgical repair was also reported by Machado-Atías [3]. Thus, despite the potential higher cost of stenting in comparison to open surgery, the very short hospitalization made the procedure cost effective.

It is also of paramount importance to note the fact that the patient is in her procreative years. Surgical access to the pelvis might have led to complications in future pregnancies.

The alternative implantation of the covered stent in the corresponding vein in conjunction with coil implantation at the arterial lesion site was also reported in the literature [14]. However, we believe that it cannot be recommended due to difficult-to-detect microbleeding. The higher arterial pressure may exert enough forces on the stent and the vessel wall to provoke leakage at the lesion site.

Due to the low incidence rates of iliac AVF (less than 1% [6]) and the associated pathoanatomy, the manufacture of standard PTFE-covered stents is most likely not attractive for device manufacturers, despite their efficacy in this niche indication. In our case, we implanted a custom-made device whose dimensions were based on precise CT measurements obtained prior to our intervention. Another interesting solution, described by Cronin and coworkers, is the use of preexisting thoracic stents [12]. Nevertheless, despite the advantages of endovascular techniques, Kuehnle and coworkers [5] cautioned about the use of alloplastic material in patients who are not fully grown: even in very young patients, the open surgical repair option may still be associated with a higher benefit/risk ratio than endovascular repair with covered stents. Another potential risk factor for iliac AVF formation is the occurrence of thrombotic occlusions in the common iliac vein, as reported by Weyrich and Beck [15]. This rare complication may also necessitate an open surgical approach.

An important step, and the most technically demanding one, turned out to be the cannulation of the distal IIA. Despite the contralateral approach, the small size of the distal portion of the IIA and the significant blood flow through the fistula made it very cumbersome to cross the lesion with the guidewire and over-the-wire catheter. The other challenge for the operator was to cross the aortic bifurcation with the introducer. Significant device stiffness, the young age of the patient, and the fixation of the aorta due to the adhesions made the vessel much less movable. This increased the risk of potential dissections and/or wall perforations. The puncture of the left CFA, through which we introduced the pigtail catheter, greatly facilitated angiographic imaging. Furthermore, if the stent graft had migrated, the outlet of the external iliac artery would have been blocked. However, with the second guidewire in place, it would have enabled us to implant another “kissing” stent. Finally, both guidewires crossed each other, marking the beginning of the IIA.

It would have been preferable to use MRI imaging modalities to reduce radiation exposure to the patient. However, in our clinical setting, mandatory pregnancy tests permitted angiographic CT images, which were the design inputs for the custom-made device.

Conclusion

Despite the procedurally challenging implantation of a PTFE-covered, tapered, customized stent, the physiologic hemodynamic environment in a patient with a large iliac arteriovenous fistula was restored. In particular, women of childbearing age may benefit from endovascular techniques as compared to open surgical repair.

The etiology of iliac arteriovenous fistulas (AVF) may be categorized as spontaneous and traumatic.

AVF formation may be related to penetrating injuries (gunshot and stab wounds) but may also occur after seat-belt trauma and laparoscopic appendectomy.

Cardiac insufficiency may be caused by an undetected iliac AVF.

Surgical repair is associated with high morbidity and mortality due to the complex anatomy and the unfavorable access site.

Women of child-bearing age may benefit the most from endovascular repair using tapered, polytetrafluorethylene-covered stent grafts.