| Literature DB >> 35538323 |
Hossam Hosny1, Shazly Mousa2, Wael Salama2.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Posterior hip dislocation is the commonest type of hip dislocation. It is associated with femoral head fracture in 7% of cases. Urgent and congruent hip reduction is mandatory to improve clinical outcomes and avoid irreversible complications. The purpose of this study is to assess the safety and functional and radiological outcomes of surgical hip dislocation by Ganz technique for treatment of femoral head fracture. PATIENTS AND METHODS: In this retrospective study, 18 cases of femoral head fracture were included. Six cases had Pipkin type I and 12 had Pipkin type II fracture. They were treated through surgical hip dislocation. All cases were followed up for at least 24 months. Matta's criteria were used for radiological evaluation (plain radiographs). Functional evaluation was done using Harris Hip Score and modified Merle d'Aubigne and Postel score at final follow-up.Entities:
Keywords: Femoral head fracture; Femoral head osteonecrosis; Ganz technique; Hip dislocation; Pipkin classification; Trochanteric flip osteotomy
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35538323 PMCID: PMC9091069 DOI: 10.1186/s10195-022-00643-w
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Orthop Traumatol ISSN: 1590-9921
Fig. 1Intraoperative photo showing head of femur with type 1 Pipkin fracture
Fig. 2Intraoperative photo showing fixation of head of femur with screws
Fig. 3Intraoperative photo showing positive drilling test (arrow)
Demographic data of our cases
| Case | Age | Sex | Mode of trauma | Affected side | Type of fracture | Type of fixation | Follow-up period (months) | Harris Hip Score | Modified Merle d’Aubigne and Postel Score | Complications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case 1 | 30 years | Male | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type II | Herbert screw | 48 | 95 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 2 | 20 years | Male | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 45 | 95 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 3 | 35 years | Female | Falling from height | Left side | Pipkin type I | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 46 | 100 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 4 | 42 years | Female | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 48 | 85 Good | Good | – |
| Case 5 | 30 years | Male | Motor car accident | Left side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 38 | 75 Fair | Fair | – |
| Case 6 | 35 years | Male | Motorcycle accident | Left side | Pipkin type I | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 40 | 100 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 7 | 26 years | Male | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type I | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 48 | 95 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 8 | 25 years | Male | Motorcycle accident | Left side | Pipkin type II | Herbert screw | 45 | 90 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 9 | 28 years | Male | Motorcycle accident | Left side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 48 | 100 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 10 | 25 years | Female | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type II | Herbert screw | 45 | 85 Good | Good | – |
| Case 11 | 50 years | Female | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type I | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 40 | 85 Good | Good | – |
| Case 12 | 28 years | Male | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 25 | 60 Poor | Poor | Osteonecrosis |
| Case 13 | 44 years | Female | Motor car accident | Left side | Pipkin type II | Herbert screw | 30 | 85 Good | Good | – |
| Case 14 | 26 years | Male | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type I | Herbert screw | 36 | 100 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 15 | 32 years | Male | Motor car accident | Left side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 48 | 85 Good | Good | – |
| Case 16 | 40 years | Female | Fall from height | Left side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 36 | 90 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 17 | 36 years | Male | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type II | Cannulated screw 4 mm | 24 | 100 Excellent | Excellent | – |
| Case 18 | 24 years | Male | Motor car accident | Right side | Pipkin type I | Herbert screw | 45 | 85 Good | Excellent | – |
Fig. 4Preoperative radiograph of a female 35-year-old patient with left hip dislocation and fracture of the femoral head (Pipkin type 1 fracture)
Fig. 5A Preoperative CT scan showing head femur fracture (axial view). B Preoperative CT scan showing head femur fracture (coronal view)
Fig. 6Immediate postoperative plain radiograph showing femoral head fixation
Fig. 7Follow-up radiograph at 1 month postoperatively
Fig. 8Follow-up radiograph 2 years postoperatively
Fig. 9A, B Preoperative radiograph of a male 28-year-old patient with right hip dislocation and fracture of the femoral head (Pipkin type 2 fracture)
Fig. 10Follow-up radiograph at 12 months showing femoral head osteonecrosis
Other studies concerned with surgical hip dislocation
| Authors | Year | No. of cases | Indication for dislocation | Score | Follow-up period (mean, months) | Complications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gardener et al. | 2005 | 2 cases | Pipkin type II (2 cases) | None | – | |
| Henle et al. | 2007 | 12 case | Pipkin type I (1 case) Pipkin type II (3 cases) Pipkin type IV (8 cases) | Merle d’Aubigne and Postel score Thompson and Epstein score | 31 | Osteonecrosis ( 2 cases) Heterotopic ossification (5 cases) Reduced range of motion (4 cases) |
| Solberg et al. | 2009 | 12 case | Pipkin type IV fractures | Merle d’Aubigne´and Postel score Thompson–Epstein scoring | 47 | Osteonecrosis (1 case) Heterotopic ossification (3 cases) |
| Kokubo et al. | 2012 | 12 cases (3 cases treated with trochanteric flip osteotomy all of them of Pipkin type IV) | Pipkin type I (5 cases) Pipkin type II (2 cases) Pipkin type III (2 cases) Pipkin IV (3 cases) | Thompson and Epstein’s score | 115 | Osteoarthritis in one case treated later on by THA Heterotopic ossification (1 case) |
| Masse et al. | 2014 | 13 case | Pipkin type I (5 cases) Pipkin type II (two cases) Pipkin type IV (6 cases) | Modified Harris hip score | 77 | Osteonecrosis (1 case) Heterotopic ossification (2 cases) Arthritis (1 case) |
| Moustafa et al. | 2014 | 23 cases (only 12 cases treated with trochanteric flip osteotomy) | Pipkin type I ( 5 cases) Pipkin type II (18 case) | Modified Merle d’Aubigne and Postel Thompson and Epstein scores | 31 | Osteonecrosis (1 case) Nonunion of the trochanteric osteotomy developed in one patient |
| Gavaskar et al. | 2015 | 26 case | Pipkin type I (22 case) Pipkin type II ( 4 case) | Modified Merle d’Aubigne score Oxford hip score | 36 | No osteonecrosis Heterotopic ossification (5 cases) Deep infection (1 case) Painful trochanteric bursitis (1 case) which relieved after screw removal |
| Stirma et al. | 2018 | 4 cases | Pipkin type I (2 cases), Pipkin type II (1 case) Pipkin type IV (1 case) | Harris Hip Score | 15 | 1 case progressed to deep surgical site infection. He underwent total hip arthroplasty after 1 year of follow-up later on 1 case evolved with heterotopic calcification No cases of femoral head necrosis were identified |
| Wang et al. | 2019 | 12 case | Pipkin type I (4 cases), Pipkin type II (3 case) Pipkin type IV (5 cases) | The modified Merle d’Aubigne scores | 35 | Osteonecrosis (one case) Heterotopic ossification (4 cases) |
| Rana et al. | 2020 | 6 cases | – | Harris Hip Score | 10.8 | Osteonecrosis (2 cases) |
| Khalifa et al. | 2020 | 27 cases | Pipkin type I (6 cases), Pipkin type II (13 case) Pipkin type IV (8 case) | Modified Harris hip Modified Merle d’Aubigne and Postel scores | 48 | Osteonecrosis (2 cases) Heterotopic ossification (5 cases) Hip arthritis (1 case) |
| Engel et al. | 2021 | 7 cases | Pipkin type IV (7 case) | None | 894.57 ± 496.16 days | Osteonecrosis (2 cases) Heterotopic ossification (1 case) Hip arthritis (6 cases (4 converted to THA)) Deep infection (one case) |
| Current study | 2022 | 18 case | Pipkin type I (6 cases), Pipkin type II (12 cases) | Modified Harris Hip and Modified Merle d’Aubigne and Postel scores | 40 | Osteonecrosis (1 case) |