Literature DB >> 35530938

Comparison between trabectedin and doxorubicin in soft-tissue sarcomas-reply letter.

Jing-Yi Dang1, Jun Fu1, Zhao Zhang1, Dong Liu1, Debing Cheng1, Hongbin Fan1.   

Abstract

Entities:  

Year:  2022        PMID: 35530938      PMCID: PMC9073790          DOI: 10.21037/atm-2022-1

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Ann Transl Med        ISSN: 2305-5839


× No keyword cloud information.
We thank for the comments from Wu et al. (1) on our research (2), comparison between trabectedin and doxorubicin in soft-tissue sarcomas. Reviewer Wu et al. said that in , we reported that 80 patients were included, which was inconsistent with the original study (3). In addition, Figure 6 showed the wrong data that the disease control rate of 54 of 75 patients in the experimental group and 41 of 39 patients in the control group lead to the inability to estimate the odds ratio (OR). We appreciate the suggestions. In , we listed the Hartmann’s study (3) and we corrected the samples in from (2). We now correct the Figure 6 of our research (2) since the mistake in typing the number ().
Table 1

Characteristics of included trials (2)

StudyYearType of studyCountryInterventionnMean age (years)
Cesne2021RCTFranceTrabectedin5266.5
Best supportive care5163.7
Chawla2015RCTUSATrabectedin8354
Doxorubicin4054
Demetri2016RCTUSATrabectedin34557
Dacarbazine17356
Hartmann2020RCTGermanyTrofosfamide7570
Doxorubicin3970.5
Hensley2015RCTUKGemcitabine-docetaxel + trabectedin5354.8
Gemcitabine-docetaxel + placebo5456.2
Jones2019RCTUKTrabectedin + G/D13955
Placebo + G/D7054
Martin-Broto2016RCTSpainTrabectedin + doxorubicin5453
Doxorubicin5952
Schöffski 2021RCTBelgiumTrabectedin4059.5
Dacarbazine4056
Seddon2017RCTUKTrabectedin12956
Dacarbazine12855
Tian2020RCTChinaTrabectedin2438.58±14.01
Doxorubicin standard-dose14643.30±12.10
Figure 1

Forest plot of relative risks (RRs) with corresponding 95% confidential intervals (CIs) in disease control rate (DCR) (2).

Forest plot of relative risks (RRs) with corresponding 95% confidential intervals (CIs) in disease control rate (DCR) (2). They also said that the authors conducted the sensitivity analysis only by omitting Schöffski et al.’s study (4) and did not further exclude the other included studies. Since the sensitivity was conducted by removing each study in term and selecting the most obvious change one, we only reported the result omitting Schöffski et al.’s study, which is the most obvious change article. Other included researches had smaller influence on the I2 value than Schöffski et al.’s study. The article’s supplementary files as
  4 in total

1.  Randomised phase 2 study comparing the efficacy and safety of the oral tyrosine kinase inhibitor nintedanib with single agent ifosfamide in patients with advanced, inoperable, metastatic soft tissue sarcoma after failure of first-line chemotherapy: EORTC-1506-STBSG "ANITA".

Authors:  Patrick Schöffski; Maud Toulmonde; Anna Estival; Gloria Marquina; Monika Dudzisz-Śledź; Mehdi Brahmi; Neeltje Steeghs; Vasilios Karavasilis; Jacco de Haan; Agnieszka Wozniak; Sophie Cousin; Marta Domènech; Judith V M G Bovée; Céline Charon-Barra; Sandrine Marreaud; Saskia Litière; Laura De Meulemeester; Christine Olungu; Hans Gelderblom
Journal:  Eur J Cancer       Date:  2021-05-29       Impact factor: 9.162

2.  Randomised phase II trial of trofosfamide vs. doxorubicin in elderly patients with untreated metastatic soft-tissue sarcoma.

Authors:  Joerg T Hartmann; Hans-G Kopp; Viktor Gruenwald; Sophie Piperno-Neumann; Annegret Kunitz; Ralf Hofheinz; Lothar Mueller; Michael Geissler; Marius Horger; Peter Fix; Jens M Chemnitz; Michael Neise; Thomas Wehler; Ingo Zander; Robert Eckert; Claus Hann von Weyhern; Sebastian Bauer; Frank Mayer
Journal:  Eur J Cancer       Date:  2019-11-28       Impact factor: 9.162

3.  Comparison between trabectedin and doxorubicin in soft-tissue sarcomas: a systematic review and meta-analysis.

Authors:  Jingyi Dang; Jun Fu; Zhao Zhang; Dong Liu; Debin Cheng; Hongbin Fan
Journal:  Ann Transl Med       Date:  2021-12

4.  Do patients with soft-tissue sarcomas treated with trabectedin have better clinical effects and a longer survival time than those treated with doxorubicin?

Authors:  Jiangfeng Wu; Maoliang Zhang; Chunting Chen; Anli Zhao; Yinghong Guo
Journal:  Ann Transl Med       Date:  2022-04
  4 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.