| Literature DB >> 35509961 |
Justine Alderfer1, Jyoti Aggarwal2, Kim Gilchrist1, Jose Maria Jimenez Alvir3, Joseph Cook4, Sang Hee Park5, Jennifer M Stephens5.
Abstract
Background: Despite demonstration of bioequivalence of generics to brands and the potential for reduced costs, some patients switch back from a generic to the brand. A prior retrospective analysis suggested that this switchback rate may be lower among patients that had initially switched to authorized generics (AG), often both produced and marketed by the brand company, compared to those initially switched to another generic. Objective: Explore switching patterns of brands, AGs, and generics, switchback rates, and the potential impact of switchbacks on healthcare costs.Entities:
Keywords: Generic; authorized generic; costs; medication switching
Year: 2022 PMID: 35509961 PMCID: PMC9059206 DOI: 10.2147/CEOR.S319796
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clinicoecon Outcomes Res ISSN: 1178-6981
List of Products Evaluated in the Study
| Therapeutic Area | Generic Name |
|---|---|
| Latanoprost | |
| Amlodipine and atorvastatin | |
| Phenytoin | |
| Sildenafil | |
| Tolterodine | |
| Celecoxib | |
| Sirolimus |
Figure 1Patient dentification. *Defined as the earliest generic or AG claim identified in the data source.
Figure 2Study design.
Figure 3Proportion of people who switched to authorized generics versus non-authorized generics.
Proportion of Patients Who Switched from Brand to Non-AG or AG, Discontinued Drug or Stayed on Brand
| Switched to Non-AG | Switched to AG | Discontinued Drug | Stayed on Brand | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amlodipine and atorvastatin (N=12,097) | 8333 (68.9%) | 57 (0.5%) | 758 (6.3%) | 2949 (24.4%) |
| Celecoxib (N=80,054) | 39,798 (49.7%) | 10,770 (13.5%) | 2920 (3.6%) | 26,566 (33.2%) |
| Tolterodine (N=1812) | 122 (6.7%) | 857 (47.3%) | 70 (3.9%) | 763 (42.1%) |
| Tolterodine long-acting (N=12,732) | 3201 (25.1%) | 5043 (39.6%) | 753 (5.9%) | 3735 (29.3%) |
| Phenytoin (N=869) | 217 (25.0%) | 188 (21.6%) | 96 (11.0%) | 368 (42.3%) |
| Ziprasidone (N=6697) | 3435 (51.3%) | 1253 (18.7%) | 143 (2.1%) | 1866 (27.9%) |
| Atorvastatin (N=353,504) | 282,484 (79.9%) | 2122 (0.6%) | 24,880 (7.0%) | 44,018 (12.5%) |
| Desvenlafaxine (N=25,541) | 4267 (16.7%) | 880 (3.4%) | 4664 (18.3%) | 15,730 (61.6%) |
| Sirolimus (N=1224) | 224 (18.3%) | 437 (35.7%) | 180 (14.7%) | 383 (31.3%) |
| Eletriptan (N=12,944) | 5564 (43.0%) | 3038 (23.5%) | 1405 (10.9%) | 2937 (22.7%) |
| Sildenafil (PAH) (N=759) | 480 (63.2%) | 79 (10.4%) | 44 (5.8%) | 156 (20.6%) |
| Dofetilide (N=2531) | 1379 (54.5%) | 465 (18.4%) | 98 (3.9%) | 589 (23.3%) |
| Sildenafil (MH) (N=51,252) | 19,782 (38.6%) | 10,604 (20.7%) | 4281 (8.4%) | 16,585 (32.4%) |
| Latanoprost (N=51,359) | 29,269 (57.0%) | 13,826 (26.9%) | 2446 (4.8%) | 5818 (11.3%) |
Note: Discontinuation is defined as a gap of >90 days from the last observed fill plus days supplied.
Abbreviations: AG, authorized generics; MH, men’s health; non-AG, non-authorized generic; PAH, pulmonary arterial hypertension.
Total Healthcare Costs (US$) Among People Who Had a Switchback versus People Without Switchback
| Therapeutic Area | Treatment | Any Switchback | No Switchback | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N | Days in Switchback Period, Median | Total healthcare Costs (US$) During Switchback Period, Mean (SD) | N | Total Healthcare Cost (US$) in 1st Montha, Mean (SD) | ||
| Ophthalmology | Latanoprost | 682 | 39.0 | 1728.91 (5229.01) | 37,405 | 804.59 (3342.38) |
| Cardiovascular | Amlodipine and atorvastatin | 443 | 33.0 | 1608.49 (3748.54) | 7193 | 1173.16 (3791.34) |
| Atorvastatin | 5838 | 31.0 | 1549.56 (7668.14) | 239,230 | 1108.40 (4381.77) | |
| Dofetilide | 105 | 33.0 | 4868.58 (9951.85) | 1409 | 3259.13 (9123.75) | |
| Sildenafil (PAH) | 15 | 40.0 | 5482.09 (6005.59) | 473 | 8478.98 (23,158.88) | |
| Central Nervous System | Phenytoin | 35 | 29.0 | 2996.61 (6946.94) | 312 | 787.36 (3417.02) |
| Ziprasidone | 178 | 28.0 | 3106.94 (6786.14) | 4180 | 2012.04 (4415.41) | |
| Desvenlafaxine | 217 | 34.0 | 1979.63 (6494.25) | 3700 | 1401.34 (4063.10) | |
| Eletriptan | 188 | 30.0 | 2037.75 (4567.87) | 6776 | 1513.31 (3661.33) | |
| Men’s Health | Sildenafil | 221 | 30.0 | 1198.40 (2499.29) | 17,280 | 1200.46 (4065.98) |
| Urinary | Tolterodine | 28 | 28.0 | 4800.85 (17,651.00) | 850 | 1539.57 (2988.36) |
| Tolterodine long-acting | 245 | 66.0 | 3464.61 (6093.60) | 7018 | 1531.31 (3267.63) | |
| Pain | Celecoxib | 794 | 37.0 | 3120.01 (8074.48) | 44,111 | 1695.08 (5084.54) |
| Immunosuppression | Sirolimus | 38 | 26.5 | 4359.26 (6350.64) | 489 | 5066.84 (12,226.62) |
Note: a1st month refers to the first month since switching from branded to generics/authorized generics.
Abbreviation: PAH, pulmonary arterial hypertension.
Figure 4Difference in proportion of switchback from authorized generics and non-authorized generics to branded drug. Difference is calculated as (% of switchback from AG) – (% switchback from non-AG).
Medicala and Pharmacyb Costs (US$) Among People Who Had a Switchback versus People Without Switchback
| Therapeutic Area | Treatment | Any Switchback (US$) | No Switchback (US$) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medical costs During Switchback Period, Mean (SD) | Pharmacy Costs During Switchback Period, Mean (SD) | Medical Costs in 1st Montha, Mean (SD) | Pharmacy Costs in 1st Monthc, | ||
| Ophthalmology | Latanoprost | 802.75 (2736.77) | 926.15 (3780.64) | 474.14 (3233.51) | 330.45 (676.29) |
| Cardiovascular | Amlodipine and atorvastatin | 688.66 (2622.61) | 919.84 (1811.95) | 493.01 (3693.92) | 680.16 (730.65) |
| Atorvastatin | 867.56 (7127.85) | 682.11 (1956.15) | 560.50 (4261.40) | 547.89 (854.73) | |
| Dofetilide | 3305.93 (9419.52) | 1562.65 (1831.51) | 1761.13 (8863.30) | 1498.00 (1963.57) | |
| Sildenafil | 1842.61 (4629.04) | 3639.48 (3311.26) | 3263.56 (22,147.48) | 5215.42 (7181.01) | |
| Central Nervous System | Phenytoin | 1470.63 (3724.00) | 1525.98 (4743.04) | 452.80 (3304.89) | 334.57 (833.52) |
| Ziprasidone | 837.52 (2000.77) | 2269.43 (6306.75) | 764.11 (4127.38) | 1247.93 (1395.01) | |
| Desvenlafaxine | 1074.16 (6178.35) | 905.46 (1329.65) | 656.29 (3690.78) | 745.05 (1445.89) | |
| Eletriptan | 828.81 (3431.36) | 1208.94 (2973.18) | 744.26 (3299.84) | 769.05 (1406.37) | |
| Men’s Health | Sildenafil | 365.33 (1433.50) | 833.07 (1887.05) | 535.11 (3690.64) | 665.34 (1608.62) |
| Urinary | Tolterodine | 774.80 (1943.16) | 4026.05 (17,057.68) | 632.56 (2565.48) | 907.02 (1427.79) |
| Tolterodine long-acting | 1377.32 (4228.58) | 2087.28 (3851.73) | 612.47 (2872.05) | 918.85 (1503.38) | |
| Pain | Celecoxib | 1628.68 (5778.75) | 1491.33 (3666.35) | 926.42 (4684.51) | 768.67 (1774.61) |
| Immunosuppression | Sirolimus | 2568.05 (5922.33) | 1791.21 (1595.33) | 2504.83 (11,578.69) | 2562.01 (3667.77) |
Notes: aMedical costs included all physician office, outpatient hospital, emergency department, and inpatient visits. bPharmacy costs included all medication prescriptions filled by the patient. c1st month refers to the first month since switching from branded to generics/authorized generics.