| Literature DB >> 35498263 |
Clayton S Semenzin1,2, Martin Mapley1,2, Eric Wu2,3, Jo P Pauls1,2, Benjamin Simpson4, Shaun D Gregory2,5, Geoff Tansley1,2.
Abstract
Design methods for large industrial pumps are well developed, but they cannot be relied upon when designing specialised miniature pumps, due to scaling issues. Therefore, the design and development phase of small pumps demand numerous experimental tests to ensure a viable prototype. Of initial interest is hydraulic design in the form of pump performance and efficiency curves. This project aimed to produce an automated test rig capable of generating both the performance (P-Q - pressure vs. flow rate) and efficiency curves that are reliable and repeatable. The apparatus is largely customizable and suitable for a range of smaller pump sizes. The pump impeller and volute were 3D printed, allowing for design flexibility and rapid prototyping and testing. The test loop was automated which allowed the flow rate to be incremented from 0 L/min to the maximum flow rate. At each step the pressure, flow rate, voltage and current were recorded to generate the P - Q and efficiency curves. Repeatability results showed low variations of ±3 mmHg (400 Pa) in pressure and ± 2% in hydraulic efficiency. The given setup can be used to compare and evaluate the hydraulic performance of various pump designs.Entities:
Keywords: Efficiency curves; Performance curves; Small pumps
Year: 2020 PMID: 35498263 PMCID: PMC9041202 DOI: 10.1016/j.ohx.2020.e00140
Source DB: PubMed Journal: HardwareX ISSN: 2468-0672
Fig. 1Test loop main components.
Fig. 2Test rig main components.
Fig. 3Cut-away showing adjustment of the axial clearance.
Fig. 4Pump assembly components.
Fig. 5Control box components.
Fig. 6Replacement of the original front plate with the bearing plate.
Fig. 7a) Exploded view showing the base plate assembly, b) underside of linear rail system with t-nuts and c) assembled base plate photo.
Fig. 8Exploded view showing assembly of the slotted plate.
Fig. 9Exploded view showing motor mount assembly and photo of assembled components.
Fig. 10a) Exploded view showing assembly of the motor mount to the linear rail system and b) photo of assembled motor mount and linear rail system.
Fig. 11Exploded view of bearing adapter assemblies and photo is assembled components.
Fig. 12a) Exploded view showing the shaft component assembly and b) photos showing the shaft components assembled on either side of the bearing plate.
Fig. 13a) Exploded view showing the pump base assembly and b) photo of the assembled pump base and impeller mount.
Fig. 14Control box socket configuration (left) and slot for Arduino access (right).
Fig. 15Control box electrical wiring diagram.
Fig. 16External wiring plug connections.
Fig. 17Photos of assembled reservoir showing the internal (top) and external (bottom) components.
Fig. 18Test loop circuit showing tubing lengths.
Fig. 19Exploded views showing the pinch valve stand assembly steps.
Fig. 20Pneumatic control assembly.
Fig. 21Transonic (TS410) flow meter.
Fig. 22Experimental run showing sufficient settling of pressure and flow rate at each flow increment.
Fig. 23Flow chart of operation process.
Fig. 24Measurement of the axial and radial variation using the dial gauge indicator.
Fig. 253D printed pump assembly.
Fig. 26a) Exploded view showing full pump assembly and b) photo showing assembled pump components.
Fig. 27Fully assembled test rig with set shaft position.
Fig. 28Control Desk interface with numbered steps to reach design point.
Fig. 29Control Desk interface with numbered steps to start the experiment and record data.
Fig. 30Control Desk interface with numbered steps to end the experiment.
Fig. 31Flow rate calibration data points with line-of-best-fit.
Calculated flow rate gain and offset.
| Gain | Offset | |
|---|---|---|
| Flow Calibration | 1.0347 | −0.1027 |
Fig. 32Voltage (left) and current (right) calibration data points with lines-of-best-fit.
Calculated gains and offsets for the voltage and current measurements.
| Gain | Offset | |
|---|---|---|
| Voltage Calibration | −29.4 | 23.42 |
| Current Calibration | 4.75 | −0.0026 |
Experimental tuning values used for the flow rate and pump speed PID controllers.
| Flow Rate (SimuLink) | Pump Speed (Arduino) | |
|---|---|---|
| KP | −0.36 | 0.09 |
| KI | −0.05 | 0.0001 |
| KD | −0.8 | 0.06 |
Fig. 33Experimental runs showing sufficient settling and stability of a) flow rate and b) motor speed PID gains.
Repeatability pump design parameters.
| Design Value | |
|---|---|
| Impeller Diameter | 50 mm |
| Eye Diameter | 10 mm |
| Outlet Angle | 22.5° |
| Inlet Angle | 35° |
| Inlet Height | 4.3 mm |
| Outlet Height | 1.5 mm |
| Number of Blades | 6 |
| Volute Design | Constant Mean Velocity |
| Axial Clearance | 0.4 mm |
Fig. 34Repeatability results for a) P-Q curves and b) efficiency curves from the initial repeatability tests (blue) and over time (red) with standard deviation error bars.
| Hardware name | |
|---|---|
| Subject area | Fluid Dynamics Mechanical Engineering General |
| Hardware type | Fluidic Handling Electrical engineering Mechanical engineering |
| Open Source License | CC by 4.0 |
| Cost of Hardware | |
| Source File Repository |
| Design file name | File type | Open source license | Location of the file |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base_Plate | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Bearing_Plate | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Motor_Mount | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Slotted_Plate | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Shaft | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Base_Stand | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Bracket_Stand | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Centre_Section | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Slide_Section | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Bearing_Adapter | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Pump_Base | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Pump_Top | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Impeller | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Volute | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Spacers | CAD | CC by 4.0 | |
| Wiring | Image | CC by 4.0 | |
| SimuLink | SimuLink | CC by 4.0 | |
| Arduino | Arduino | CC by 4.0 | |
| MatLab | MatLab script | CC by 4.0 |
| Computer | PC | 1 | Recycled | Other | ||
| Power Supply | Minleaf DC 60 V 5A Adjustable power supply | 1 | $99.99 | $99.99 | ebay.com.au | Other |
| dSPACE | DS1104 | 1 | Recycled | Other | ||
| Electrical Box | 240 × 160 × 90 mm Electrical Box (HB6134) | 1 | $39.95 | $39.95 | Jaycar | ABS |
| Arduino | Arduino Due (with headers) R3 MCU development board A000062 (769–7412) | 1 | $57.52 | $57.52 | RS online | Other |
| Touch Screen | 3.2″ TFT Touch screen LCD display + Mega Shield V2.2 | 1 | $26.80 | $26.80 | ebay.com.au | Other |
| Stepper Motor Driver | TB6560 Stepper motor driver | 1 | $19.95 | $19.95 | ebay.com.au | Other |
| 12 V Voltage Regulator | MC78T12 12 V 3A Voltage Regulator (ZV1634) | 1 | $4.95 | $4.95 | Jaycar | Composite |
| Regulator Heatsink | Regulator Heatsink | 1 | Recycled | Metal | ||
| MOSFET | Infineon IRL520NPBF MOSFET (541–1196) | 1 | $1.81 | $1.81 | RS online | Composite |
| MOSFET Heatsink | MOSFET Heatsink | 1 | Recycled | Metal | ||
| Op Amps | LM324 Quadruple Op Amp (ZL3324) | 1 | $2.35 | $2.35 | Jaycar | Composite |
| Diode | 1 N4004 Diode (ZR1004) | 1 | $0.98 (pack of 4) | $0.98 | Jaycar | Metal |
| 15 kΩ Resistor | 15kΩ ± 1% 0.5 W metal film resistor (RR0600) | 3 | $0.55 (pack of 8) | $0.55 | Jaycar | Composite |
| 27 kΩ Resistor | 27kΩ ± 1% 0.5 W metal film resistor (RR0606) | 4 | $0.55 (pack of 8) | $0.55 | Jaycar | Composite |
| 150 Ω Resistor | 150 Ω ± 1% 0.5 W metal film resistor (RR0552) | 1 | $0.85 (pack of 8) | $0.85 | Jaycar | Composite |
| 82 kΩ Resistor | 82kΩ ± 1% 0.5 W metal film resistor (RR0618) | 4 | $0.55 (pack of 8) | $0.55 | Jaycar | Composite |
| 3.9 kΩ Resistor | 3.9kΩ ± 1% 0.5 W metal film resistor (RR0586) | 2 | $0.55 (pack of 8) | $0.55 | Jaycar | Composite |
| Current Sense Resistor | Vishay wirewound 0.1 Ω ± 1% 3 W resistor LVR03 series (LVR03R1000FE70) | 1 | $3.51 | $3.51 | Element14 | Composite |
| Motor | Chihai 24 V 8000 rpm motor with quadrature hall effect sensor (CHR-RS3162) | 1 | $15.45 | $15.45 | DX.com | Metal |
| 5 Pin Socket | GX-16 5 Pin Female (PS2018) | 1 | $3.75 | $3.75 | Jaycar | Metal |
| 5 Pin Plug | GX-16 5 Pin Male (PP2017) | 1 | $3.50 | $3.50 | Jaycar | Metal |
| 4 Pin Socket | GX-16 4 Pin Female (PS2012) | 1 | $3.75 | $3.75 | Jaycar | Metal |
| 4 Pin Plug | GX-16 4 Pin Male (PP2010) | 1 | $3.50 | $3.50 | Jaycar | Metal |
| 2 Pin Socket | GX-16 2 Pin Female (PS2014) | 1 | $3.75 | $3.75 | Jaycar | Metal |
| 2 Pin Plug | GX-16 2 Pin Male (PP2013) | 1 | $3.50 | $3.50 | Jaycar | Metal |
| DC Power Plug | 2.5 mm DC Power Line Connector 10 mm Shaft (PP0511) | 1 | $2.25 | $2.25 | Jaycar | Metal |
| DC Power Socket | 2.5 mm Bulkhead Male DC Power Connector (PS0524) | 1 | $2.95 | $2.95 | Jaycar | Metal |
| BNC connector | RS Pro 75 Ω Panel Mount Bulkhead BNC Connector, Solder Termination (546–4904) | 2 | $3.98 | $7.96 | RS online | Metal |
| Banana Plug – Black | Black Right Angle Banana Plug (PP0395) | 1 | $2.50 | $2.50 | Jaycar | Composite |
| Banana Plug – Red | Red Right Angle Banana Plug (PP0394) | 1 | $2.50 | $2.50 | Jaycar | Composite |
| 2 Core Power Cable | 7.5A 2 core Tinned DC Power cable (WH3057) | 2 m | $1.60/m | $3.20 | Jaycar | Composite |
| 4 Core Cable | 4 Core Screened Microphone Cable (WB1540) | 2 m | $3.45/m | $6.90 | Jaycar | Composite |
| BNC Cable | 2.0 Lead, BNC PLG-PLG, 50R(779829–58-2.0) | 2 | $6.95 | $13.90 | Element 14 | Composite |
| Electrical Wiring | Hook-Up Wire Pack – 2 m, 8 colours (WH3025) | 5 m | $5.95 | $5.95 | Jaycar | Composite |
| Prototype Board | Small Breadboard Layout Prototyping Board (HP9570) | 1 | $4.95 | $4.95 | Jaycar | Other |
| Linear Rail System | CNC GGP Ball Screw 1204 200 mm Stroke Linear Motion Guide Rail + 23 NEMA Stepper Motor | 1 | $120.22 | $120.22 | aliexpress.com | Metal |
| 8 mm Bearing | 8 mm Deep Groove Ball Bearing 22 mm OD 608-2Z(137–1471) | 1 | $7.23 | $7.23 | RS online | Metal |
| Coupling Adapter | Coupling adapter | 1 | In-house | Objective 3D | VeroWhitePlusSup706 B | |
| Cup Joint | HPI Heavy Duty Cup Joint 5 × 10 × 16 mm | 1 | $14.99 | $14.99 | ebay.com.au | Metal |
| Roll Pin | 300 Grade Stainless Steel 2 mm × 16 mm Length Roll Pin(RP020-0160–4) | 1 | $2.68 | $2.68 | Small Parts and Bearings | Metal |
| Small Shaft Collar | RS Pro One Piece Screw Collar, 5 mm Bore, Stainless Steel (122–3448) | 1 | $5.23 (pack of 2) | $5.23 | RS online | Stainless steel |
| Large Shaft Collar | Ruland Shaft Collar One Piece Clamp Screw, 5 mm Bore, Aluminium ENCL20-5MM-A (174–6673) | 2 | $13.29 | $26.58 | RS online | Aluminium |
| Bearing Adapter | Bearing Adapters | 2 | In-house | Objective 3D | VeroWhitePlusSup706 B | |
| Self-Aligning Bearings | VXB 135 Self-Aligning Bearing 5 × 19 × 6 Miniature (12124) | 2 | $15.28 | $30.56 | ebay.com.au | Chrome Steel |
| Thrust Bearings | Align F5-10 M Axial Thrust Bearings (HN6125) | 2 | $12.20 | $24.40 | ebay.com.au | Stainless steel |
| Base Plate | Base Plate | 1 | $600 | Total cost for all parts | Griffith University | Aluminium |
| Bearing Plate | Bearing Plate | 1 | Griffith University | Aluminium | ||
| Slotted Plate | Slotted Plate | 1 | Griffith University | Aluminium | ||
| Motor Mount | Motor Mount | 1 | Griffith University | Aluminium | ||
| Shaft | Shaft | 1 | Griffith University | Stainless Steel | ||
| Anodising | Anodising | 1 | $50.00 | $50.00 | A Grade Anodising | Aluminium |
| M6 × 25 mm Bolts | M6 × 25 mm Socket Head Cap Screws Zinc-Plated (SHCSM625ZP) | 6 | $0.51 | $3.06 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Metal |
| M6 × 20 mm Bolts | M6 × 20 mm Socket Head Cap Screws Zinc-Plated (SHCSM620ZP) | 4 | $0.51 | $2.04 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Metal |
| M5 × 10 mm Bolts | M5 × 10 mm Socket Head Cap Screws Zinc-Plated (SHCSM510Z) | 4 | $0.37 | $1.48 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Metal |
| M3 × 10 mm Bolts | M3 × 10 mm Socket Head Cap Screws Zinc-Plated (SHCSM310Z) | 4 | $0.58 | $2.32 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Metal |
| Button M3 × 8 mm Bolts | M3 × 8 mm Button Head Cap Screws (BHCSM38) | 20 | $0.67 | $13.40 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Metal |
| M3 × 16 mm Bolts | M3 × 16 mm Socket Head Cap Screws Zinc-Plated (SHCSM316Z) | 4 | $0.54 | $2.16 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Metal |
| Button M3 × 6 mm Bolt | Button M3 × 6 mm Button Head Cap Screws Zinc Plated (BHCSM36Z) | 1 | $1.22 | $1.22 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Metal |
| M5 × 65 mm Bolts | Hobson Socket Head Cap Screw M5 × 65 mm Stainless Steel G304 | 4 | $9.00 (pack of 5) | $9.00 | ebay.com.au | Metal |
| M3 × 3 mm Grub Screw | M3 × 3 mm Steel Hex Head Cup Point Grub Screw | 1 | $3.69 (pack of 5) | $3.69 | ebay.com.au | Steel |
| M3 × 2 mm Grub Screw | M3 × 2 mm Steel Hex Head Cup Point Grub Screw | 1 | $3.69 (pack of 5) | $3.69 | ebay.com.au | Steel |
| M3 Nuts | M3 G316 Stainless Steel Std Hex Nuts (SSHN316M3) | 4 | $0.20 | $0.80 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Stainless Steel |
| M5 Nuts | M5 G316 Stainless Steel Std Hex Nuts (SSHN316M5) | 4 | $0.11 | $0.44 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Stainless Steel |
| M5 Washers | Zenith M5 316 Stainless Steel Flat Washer – 25 Pack(2330001) | 16 | $4.70 (pack of 25) | $4.70 | Bunnings | Stainless Steel |
| M3 Washers | Zenith M3 316 Stainless Steel Flat Washer – 35 Pack(2320123) | 4 | $4.60 (pack of 35) | $4.60 | Bunnings | Stainless Steel |
| 4 mm Nylon Washers | 4 mm Nylon Washer – Pk.25 (HP0166) | 4 | $5.00 (Pack of 25) | $5.00 | Jaycar | Nylon |
| M3 × 25 mm Standoffs | Wurth Elektronik Brass Hex Standoff 970250324, 25 mm, M3 (184–2757) | 10 | $1.78 | $17.80 | RS online | Brass |
| M5 × 25 mm Bolts | M5 × 25 mm Socket Head Cap Screws Zinc-Plated (SHCSM525ZP) | 4 | $0.49 | $1.96 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Stainless Steel |
| M5 Wing Nuts | M5 G316 Stainless Steel Wing Nuts (SSWN316M5) | 4 | $0.95 | $3.80 | Bolts and Industrial Supplies | Stainless Steel |
| Pump Base | Pump Base | 1 | In-house | Objective 3D | VeroWhitePlusSup706 B | |
| Volute | Volute | 1 | ||||
| Pump Top | Pump Top | 1 | ||||
| Impeller | Impeller | 1 | ||||
| Spacers | Spacers | 4 | ||||
| 52 × 2 mm O-rings | 52 × 2 mm O-Ring NBR 70 Duro(N70M-0520020) | 2 | $2.16 | $4.32 | Ludowici Sealing Solutions | Nitrile Rubber |
| 5 mm Rigid Flange Coupling | 5 mm Rigid Flange Coupling Motor Guide Shaft Coupler | 1 | $2.94 | $2.94 | ebay.com.au | Metal |
| Acrylic Plate | Acrylic Plate | 1 | $33.00 | $33.00 | Laser Cut Designs | Acrylic |
| 5 mm Shaft Seal | RS Pro Nitrile Rubber Seal, 5 mm Bore, 16 mm O.D (211–8715) | 1 | $17.08 (pack of 5) | $17.08 | RS online | Nitrile Rubber |
| ½” Vinyl Tubing | Pope 13 mm × 5 m Clear Vinyl Tubing (3130568) | 1 | $20.91/5 m length | $20.91 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| ½” Tygon Tubing | Tygon E3603 - ACF00036 ID: 1/2″ OD: 5/8″ Wall: 1/16″ Length: 15 m | 1 | $235.10/ 15 m length | $235.10 | Gallay Medical and Scientific | Plastic |
| Luer connector | ½”× ½” Single Luer Connector (27226) | 2 | $3.57 | $7.14 | Qosina | Plastic |
| 3-Way Taps | Stop Cock 3 Way Intravenous Tap (IV110001) | 2 | $2.10 | $4.20 | Solmed | Plastic |
| Pressure Transducers | Omega PX181B – 015C5VX346 Pressure Transducer | 2 | $369.00 | $738.00 | Omega Engineering | Other |
| PVC Pipe | Holman 100 mm × 1 m PVC DWV Pipe (4770090) | 1 | $15.00/(1 m length) | $15.00 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| PVC Cap | Holman 100 mm PVC DWV Push on Cap (0149127) | 1 | $1.08 | $1.08 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| PVC Glue | Protek 250 mL Type N Blue PVC Cement (4750115) | 1 | $5.00 | $5.00 | Bunnings | Other |
| PVC Priming Fluid | Protek 125 mL Red Priming Fluid (4750121) | 1 | $4.50 | $4.50 | Bunnings | Other |
| 20 mm Ball Valve | Holman 20 mm PVC Solvent Weld Ball Valve (5070624) | 2 | $9.85 | $19.70 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| ¾ ” Brass Flange Nut | ¾ ” BSP Wide Flange Brass Nut | 2 | $6.44 (5pk) | $6.44 | ebay.com.au | Metal |
| ¾” Tank Gasket | Philmac ¾” Tank Outlet (4814051) | 2 | $12.55 (for 1 outlet and 2 gaskets) | $12.55 | Bunnings | Rubber |
| ¾” Nipple | Garden Rain 0.75″ Poly Irrigation Nipple (3100150) | 2 | $2.08 | $4.16 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| 18 mm O-ring | Holman 18 mm Rubber O-ring, 5 pack (3110573) | 2 | $4.45 (5pk) | $4.45 | Bunnings | Rubber |
| 25–13 mm Threaded to Barbed End | Pope 13 mm Tail × 25 mm BSP Male Director (3128229) | 2 | $1.15 | $2.30 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| 20–13 mm Threaded to Barbed End | Pope 13 mm Tail × 20 mm BSP Male Director (3128211) | 2 | $1.15 | $2.30 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| Thread Tape | Kinetic 12 mm × 10 m Premium Thread Seal (4920187) | 1 | $3.40 | $3.40 | Bunnings | Other |
| Glycerol | Glycerol UNIVAR 2.5L GL(AJA242-2.5LGL) | 1 | $64.75/2.5 L | $64.75 | Bacto Laboratories Pty Ltd | Other |
| Pinch Valve Stand | Pinch Valve Stand | 2 | $29.60 | $59.20 | Global Acrylic | Acrylic |
| Reservoir Stand | Reservoir Stand | 1 | $34.00 | $34.00 | Laser Cut Designs | Acrylic |
| Lab Stand | Mini Lab Bracket Retort Stand Clip Clamp 30 cm High | 2 | $19.49 | $39.98 | ebay.com.au | Metal |
| Pinch Valve | AKO VMP025.04 K.71Pinch Valve | 1 | $352.00 | $352.00 | CONVAIR Engineering Pty Ltd | Other |
| Manual air Regulator | SMC Precision Modular Regulator (IR3000-04) | 1 | $208.89* | $208.89* | SMC | Other |
| Voltage air Regulator | SMC Electro-Pneumatic Regulator(ITV2030-312BS5) | 1 | $653.28* | $653.28* | SMC | Other |
| 3/8″ Soft Nylon Air Tube | SMC TIS Soft Nylon Tubing 3/8 OD, wht, 20 m (TISA11W-20) | 1 | $73.76* (20 m roll) | $73.76* | SMC | Plastic |
| PVC Air Hose | Kinetic 6 mm × 2 m Reinforced Pressure Hose (4920246) | 1 | $11.85/ (2 m length) | $11.85 | Bunnings | Plastic |
| Push in Air Tube Connectors | SMC One Touch UNIFIT Male Connector(KQ2 L 11 – U04A) | 2 | $100.06* (pack of 10) | $100.06* | SMC | Composite |
| Air Hose Quick Connect | Craftright 6 Piece Nitto Style Fittings Set (6330410) | 1 | $26.95 (6 piece set) | $26.95 | Bunnings | Metal |
| 600PF Quick Connect | 600PF Nitto Style Quick connect | 1 | $55.08 | $55.08 | ebay.com.au | Metal |
| ¾” Male – ¾” Male connector | Brass Hex Nipple Male Threaded BSP, 20 mm (¾”) | 1 | $9.35 | $9.35 | Valve Warehouse Australia | Metal |
| ¾” Male – ½” Male Connector | Brass Reducing Hex Nipple – Male × Male BSP, 25 × 15 mm (¾” × ½”) | 1 | $9.15 | $9.15 | Valve Warehouse Australia | Metal |
| ½” Female – ½” Male Connector | Brass BSP Threaded Adaptor – Male & Female, 15 mm (½”) | 1 | $4.68 | $4.68 | Valve Warehouse Australia | Metal |
| Hose Clamps | Kinetic 11–25 mm 304 Stainless Steel Hose Clamp (0110737) | 2 | $1.50 | $3.00 | Bunnings | Metal |